"We Don't Want to Be Like Josh" Josh Duggar's Brothers Want Nothing to Do with Him

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 18 сен 2024
  • #CountingOn
    Josh Duggar is becoming more present in events with the Duggars & his image is being more widely shared - but what do the brothers really think about him?
    Disclaimer:
    Without a Crystal Ball is a commentary channel. The views expressed by Katie Joy are her opinions and should not be considered fact. Katie Joy discusses trending topics, current events, reality tv & More. This channel is for your entertainment. Please make sure you conduct your own research on any topics to verify any information.
    Support the Channel By Becoming a Member:
    / @withoutacrystalball
    Follow Katie Joy on Social Media:
    Instagram: / withoutacrystalball
    Twitter:
    / woacbofficial
    / katiejoyyt
    Facebook:
    / withoutacrystalball
    Without a Crystal Ball is a commentary channel. The views expressed by Katie Joy are her opinions and should not be considered fact.
    All Clips Obtained through TLC RUclips & Used under Fair Use:
    All clips obtained through TLC RUclips and used under Fair Use:
    The Copyright Laws of the United States recognizes a “fair use” of copyrighted content. Section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Act states:
    “NOTWITHSTANDING THE PROVISIONS OF SECTIONS 106 AND 106A, THE FAIR USE OF A COPYRIGHTED WORK, INCLUDING SUCH USE BY REPRODUCTION IN COPIES OR PHONORECORDS OR BY ANY OTHER MEANS SPECIFIED BY THAT SECTION, FOR PURPOSES SUCH AS CRITICISM, COMMENT, NEWS REPORTING, TEACHING (INCLUDING MULTIPLE COPIES FOR CLASSROOM USE), SCHOLARSHIP, OR RESEARCH, IS NOT AN INFRINGEMENT OF COPYRIGHT.”
    THIS VIDEO AND OUR RUclips CHANNEL IN GENERAL MAY CONTAIN CERTAIN COPYRIGHTED WORKS THAT WERE NOT SPECIFICALLY AUTHORIZED TO BE USED BY THE COPYRIGHT HOLDER(S), BUT WHICH WE BELIEVE IN GOOD FAITH ARE PROTECTED BY FEDERAL LAW AND THE FAIR USE DOCTRINE FOR ONE OR MORE OF THE REASONS NOTED ABOVE.

Комментарии • 407

  • @rosilla802
    @rosilla802 3 года назад +539

    John David, the honorable Duggar. I think this man is his family's rock.

    • @kaybeyers5804
      @kaybeyers5804 3 года назад +84

      I remember when this aired I was really surprised he was so honest. I really admire him.

    • @susanjohnston8973
      @susanjohnston8973 3 года назад +72

      I’ve heard him criticize his dad for his greed also.

    • @kaybeyers5804
      @kaybeyers5804 3 года назад +30

      @@susanjohnston8973 It's cool that he doesn't pretend like so many of the others.

    • @chichimcgee7283
      @chichimcgee7283 3 года назад +6

      Absolutely.

    • @juustwait3918
      @juustwait3918 3 года назад +66

      Jana and him have been the glue that held them all together. They don't get the credit they deserve.

  • @homespunhomefragrance5659
    @homespunhomefragrance5659 3 года назад +185

    When John David got married to Abbie, he chose Joe to be his best man over Josh. To me, that speaks volumes.

    • @angiejones968
      @angiejones968 3 года назад +4

      True but the wedding was on the show so of course Josh couldn't be his best man

    • @homespunhomefragrance5659
      @homespunhomefragrance5659 3 года назад +16

      @@angiejones968 Yes. But I do also remember how John David said he didn’t want to be like Josh anymore after the scandal came out in 2015. To me, that shows how far apart they’ve drifted. And I’m sure even more so now with this new release of information.

    • @crystalgingerich7667
      @crystalgingerich7667 3 года назад +1

      Definitely

  • @erinmckinnon1294
    @erinmckinnon1294 3 года назад +300

    Jon David is the best Duggar boy. Abbie scored when it comes to Duggar boys. I'm sure he is utterly embarrassed by Josh

    • @1nebulochaotic312
      @1nebulochaotic312 3 года назад +12

      honestly abbie is very lucky. they’re a wonderful couple

    • @xoxohayaati
      @xoxohayaati 3 года назад +3

      He’s gay though. Sadly they sent him and Josiah and Jana for conversion therapy allegedly.

    • @biancacox8630
      @biancacox8630 3 года назад

      @@1nebulochaotic312 yep!!!!👍🥰

    • @gweng.9159
      @gweng.9159 3 года назад +6

      @@xoxohayaati What? Most ridiculous statement ever.

    • @xoxohayaati
      @xoxohayaati 3 года назад +2

      Gwen G. You must be living under a rock bc this has BEEN speculated

  • @abbywebb2822
    @abbywebb2822 3 года назад +239

    John David seems like a really stand up guy and protector. He seems to really care for everyone

    • @17lms17
      @17lms17 3 года назад +8

      And his wife wears pants!

    • @rosannecole4992
      @rosannecole4992 3 года назад +4

      Yes he seems grounded & respectful!

    • @MeganVictoriaKearns
      @MeganVictoriaKearns 3 года назад +2

      I have always liked John David. Of course I don't know him personally, so I can't be certain, but he seems like a wonderful guy. I read him as being a responsible, hardworking, caring brother to his 16 younger siblings and his 20+ nieces and nephews. He also appears not to care one single bit about his public image or getting screen time. He just works very hard and takes care of his family. Oh and he's a pilot. That's freakin' awesome!

    • @ansiejeanty8814
      @ansiejeanty8814 3 года назад

      Probably a wolf in sheep's clothing

  • @buffy32684
    @buffy32684 3 года назад +167

    I’ve always liked John David. He has always seemed like a very stand up guy. And his love for his wife seems so pure.

    • @lostinwonderland6873
      @lostinwonderland6873 3 года назад +5

      They are the only marriage I think are truly in love since they did get married when they where older than the others who are trying to leave their dad's control and be able to do the front hugging in the bed the way Katie say's it

    • @mariakeil349
      @mariakeil349 3 года назад +1

      @@lostinwonderland6873 I was thinking the same thing!

    • @annetraut8247
      @annetraut8247 3 года назад +1

      They're my favorite Duggar couple!

    • @mariakeil349
      @mariakeil349 3 года назад +1

      @@annetraut8247 I agree

    • @rosannecole4992
      @rosannecole4992 3 года назад

      Yes it appears his love for Abbie ' is genuine & and he will protect her ..Good character coming from John David..!

  • @FindMeOnABeach
    @FindMeOnABeach 3 года назад +91

    It's really appalling that Jill is not welcome in the Duggar's home, but Josh is - and lives on the property even. That tells you everything you need to know about Jim Bob and Michelle's values.🥴

    • @gingersutton8240
      @gingersutton8240 3 года назад +1

      The reason for them living on JBs property m koo hit be because all J & As holdings are in her name now. This building serves the purpose of home for them.
      It might be a protection for J & As money.
      Who really knows.
      As far as J D's being gay? It is really none of my business.
      He seems to be a delightful young man no matter what. That's all that matters!

    • @barrett7893
      @barrett7893 3 года назад

      Amen

    • @jessestewart169
      @jessestewart169 3 года назад

      Good point I never thought of that.

    • @bobbielawton9372
      @bobbielawton9372 3 года назад

      Shows how off base they are

    • @bigbadmay5012
      @bigbadmay5012 2 года назад +1

      It's effing disgusting

  • @cathrinefrydenlund3180
    @cathrinefrydenlund3180 3 года назад +117

    Josh has stained the family permanently. He'll never have his come back. JD and Joe seem to be the most level headed and kind brothers. I think they're the most genuine of the bunch and they seem to really care about the people around them.

  • @ruthgallant6047
    @ruthgallant6047 3 года назад +55

    Josh always needs to be watched. Never leave him alone with any girls, his daughters and nieces included.

    • @martaanna1264
      @martaanna1264 3 года назад +6

      I thinking the same

    • @lauren.g5382
      @lauren.g5382 3 года назад +10

      I’m scared for his daughters. Mackenzie just started puberty too!

    • @MrsMAS
      @MrsMAS 3 года назад +12

      You called that, sadly.

  • @brendaenglish2477
    @brendaenglish2477 3 года назад +57

    I get a feeling Josh is like the weird Uncle that many families have. He’s creepy, nobody really likes him, but they feel like he needs to be invited to everything because he is family.

    • @rosannecole4992
      @rosannecole4992 3 года назад +6

      Duggar parents are hiding secrets about Josh from way back..!

    • @annagarcia1527
      @annagarcia1527 3 года назад +4

      LOL RIGHT? the other kids prolly tell their own children " okay kids make sure you leave uncle josh alone cause he hasnt been well"

    • @kamirobey175
      @kamirobey175 3 года назад +1

      Thank you! What a wonderful way to put it. He's the creepy uncle that mothers tell their kids to never be caught alone with him and if they are to scream really loudly and run away

    • @relsba
      @relsba 3 года назад

      I won’t invite my brother or his girlfriend to family gatherings because of her past and my brother’s acceptance of it. I won’t have my children, grandchildren or greats exposed to them even if they are family. What a cop out!

  • @kadysquires7911
    @kadysquires7911 3 года назад +128

    Joe is so sensitive and I low key love it

    • @WithoutACrystalBall
      @WithoutACrystalBall  3 года назад +3

      Same

    • @lizmowrey9866
      @lizmowrey9866 3 года назад +3

      Me as well
      It's hard to come across that in their world

    • @kateslavin5728
      @kateslavin5728 3 года назад +2

      I wonder if they sent him to Alert because he’s “too soft”

    • @lovesanimalshatesrats6339
      @lovesanimalshatesrats6339 3 года назад +1

      I think he’s the cutest of all the boys.

    • @MrsMAS
      @MrsMAS 3 года назад +1

      I think Joe & John are probably great husbands.

  • @LaurenRussell12
    @LaurenRussell12 3 года назад +94

    Oh and John David KICKED out the cameras and his parents out of the delivery room when Abbie gave birth and didn’t SLEEP while Abbie was in labor like Josh

    • @cambilynn1172
      @cambilynn1172 3 года назад +23

      Oh wow!! Really?! Good for him!!! I never understood why Michelle & 2-3 of her kids were always in the delivery room with whomever was giving birth. And right FRONT & CENTER!! 🙈 Just gross. So bravo to John for kicking them out.

    • @LaurenRussell12
      @LaurenRussell12 3 года назад +20

      @@cambilynn1172 Yeah and Abbie had an epidural too like Jinger. Of course Michelle and Jana were judging her though. People can say what they want about Jeremy but I’m thankful he was supportive of Jinger getting the epidural and was so over Jinger’s family.

    • @karenpierson9841
      @karenpierson9841 3 года назад +4

      Of course she's pregnant and looks like twins! I say June or july.

    • @sueannnatter5295
      @sueannnatter5295 3 года назад +3

      Josh slept during Anna's labor? I hadn't heard that. I have one of those in my family.....and I was smitten mad when I found out! I thought we were the only ones....

    • @LaurenRussell12
      @LaurenRussell12 3 года назад +6

      @@sueannnatter5295 Yes he slept when Anna was pregnant with I think both Mackenzie and Michael. Anna was in labor and she looked on the verge of tears and she had told the camera that Josh was tired and he is sleeping. I would have been angry

  • @sharonbrown6595
    @sharonbrown6595 3 года назад +66

    I remember when josh got caught John David said I told josh I don’t want to be like him at all. Good for them I have a lot of respect for John David because he didn’t sugar coat the whole crap

    • @lauren.g5382
      @lauren.g5382 3 года назад +1

      I completely agree. He told it how it was

  • @Kalina1982
    @Kalina1982 3 года назад +79

    I cannot stand looking at Josh’s face. I really don’t know how Anna does it. She makes babies with him!!!! Gag!!

    • @Tina06019
      @Tina06019 3 года назад

      Maybe in the dark?

  • @brendac5786
    @brendac5786 3 года назад +100

    John David and Abbie are my favorite. I think they are the most normal. One child, she has a career and married later in life compared to the others.

    • @WithoutACrystalBall
      @WithoutACrystalBall  3 года назад +4

      Same!

    • @lizmowrey9866
      @lizmowrey9866 3 года назад +1

      I think they're my favorite as well

    • @AyakoTachi
      @AyakoTachi 3 года назад +14

      Yes! And JD was the first to have a legitimate, licensed career/job (pilot); not flipping houses/social media/questionable dealings as an inexperienced construction contractor, etc.

    • @HaveWhatBringsMeJoy
      @HaveWhatBringsMeJoy 3 года назад +10

      Not only does she have a career, but she has short hair. I don't have a problem with long hair, but I think it's interesting that she is the only one with shorter hair, and that they allowed their son to marry someone with shorter hair. Does she wear pants or dresses?

    • @brendac5786
      @brendac5786 3 года назад +10

      @@HaveWhatBringsMeJoy she wears pants!

  • @dannizinn6477
    @dannizinn6477 3 года назад +96

    I think John David tries to be the husband Josh isn't.

    • @lostinwonderland6873
      @lostinwonderland6873 3 года назад +5

      I agree with you 100% and I hope the rest of the boy's are too because the kind of older brother they have is garbage, and the parent's as well for not doing what they should had and hid it for so long

    • @mariakeil349
      @mariakeil349 3 года назад +1

      Yes!! John David is a stand up guy in my opinion

    • @lostinwonderland6873
      @lostinwonderland6873 3 года назад

      @@mariakeil349 I hope the other boys are as well, he seems to be so happy and in love with his wife and that has a lot to say because they got married older than his sisters,

  • @Crazy4Disney94
    @Crazy4Disney94 3 года назад +107

    In regards to the lost boys, you also have to remember that these boys were raised by their sisters who were abused by their big brother. So to them he basically attracted their mothers and I don’t believe that they can ever forgive Josh for what he did to them.

    • @DANNYTHEFROG123
      @DANNYTHEFROG123 3 года назад +11

      So true. And it's sad to think about. I'm glad the boys dont idolize him anymore.

    • @eliciaeldridge3452
      @eliciaeldridge3452 3 года назад +6

      They knew about that, as he said at 0:10 "It was a little more of a shock then the first stuff coming" He were referring to when Ashely Madison was hacked and it was found that Josh had an actively used account. Which I believe was in 2015 just a short time after the public found out about what Josh had done to his sisters which is why some people think the sibling's are only referring to that, I'm guessing. All though I am sure for some of the siblings it was a combination of the two.

    • @flowergirl5336
      @flowergirl5336 3 года назад +8

      Do you mean attacked instead of attracted

    • @ColorsofHopeCraftsASMR
      @ColorsofHopeCraftsASMR 3 года назад +1

      This sounds plausible.

    • @Crazy4Disney94
      @Crazy4Disney94 3 года назад +3

      Sorry I meant attacked

  • @kaykay2031
    @kaykay2031 3 года назад +27

    They say the reason why Janna was never a victim of Josh is because John David was very protective of her

    • @Emper0rH0rde
      @Emper0rH0rde Год назад

      @@LisaKoffler I heard on a podcast that one of his sisters hit him after he tried to touch her

  • @dawnbates3500
    @dawnbates3500 3 года назад +64

    Maybe the boys are also angry because the boys are allowed to be angry. They girls just have to keep sweet and not question anything.

    • @lostinwonderland6873
      @lostinwonderland6873 3 года назад +7

      That is why I think they get married to who ever as long as they can leave their parents house because they can not show any feelings towards anything, just like in a cult

    • @rosannecole4992
      @rosannecole4992 3 года назад +1

      Yes the girls cant Express their feelings only wear a smile thru tick and thin!

  • @robinhood3951
    @robinhood3951 3 года назад +69

    The older kids knew about the teenage scandal and had come to grips with it - all forgiven. But they were outraged to learn about Ashley-Madison. One reason is that Anna is beloved by the family, and she's the best wife a man could ask for. I really think all the kids were furious that Josh betrayed her. He also betrayed their Christian faith. He gave 'snarkers' ammunition to rail against the family as a whole. For the practical siblings, Josh really 'killed the golden goose." But John-David said it best - he just didn't want to be like him anymore. Josh lost the respect of all his siblings.

    • @larissatom6910
      @larissatom6910 3 года назад +9

      Yes, with the Ashley Madison scandal Josh was no longer a kid that made a mistake. He is now demonstrating a pattern of disrespect towards women and his family.

  • @TourettesMajestic
    @TourettesMajestic 3 года назад +29

    This video hits different now that Josh has been arrested :/
    “The general public isn’t ready for josh to be redeemed” - boy did we have a storm coming

  • @hopenorum6501
    @hopenorum6501 3 года назад +39

    They lost respect for Josh and rightly so... John and Joseph both said so... and that was in relation to Josh’s secret that no one knew until it was leaked to the media... honestly Josh made his choices and has to live with the consequences...

  • @donnakillewald9151
    @donnakillewald9151 3 года назад +26

    Jim Bob should have kicked Josh out of the family, and disowned him because of his behavior. And, Anna should be supported for her loyalty. And been given approval in divorcing Josh. She has to be the most miserable person on this planet. She’s a Saint.

    • @pattybronner6212
      @pattybronner6212 3 года назад +8

      I have such mixed feelings on poor Anna. She's damned if she continues to stay with Josh. She's damned if she leaves him. She's certainly a tragic figure.

    • @AB-mx1de
      @AB-mx1de 3 года назад +3

      @@pattybronner6212 very true. I wish she could move on and find a man who would absolutely love and be true to her.

    • @maryanncasciani3866
      @maryanncasciani3866 3 года назад

      I also feel for Anna. She’s such a good person and wife. Believe me when I say, no one would want to be in her situation right now. It’s more than shocking to the other spouse to learn of this. Exactly right, Anna should be able to get a divorce and still live in that house and be supported by the Duggar parents. She then should be allowed to court other men if that’s her choice. The last thing Anna should have to worry about is how she’s going to put a roof over her children’s head and food on the table. That’s the very least Jb and Michelle can do.

  • @kccfanpage1348
    @kccfanpage1348 3 года назад +12

    Josh's brothers are embarrassed by him.
    If you're a normal person, you don't want to be associated with someone who molested his sisters and cheated on his wife.
    They're distancing from him as if to say, "Hey, I'm not like that."

  • @DANNYTHEFROG123
    @DANNYTHEFROG123 3 года назад +41

    The boys are right to be mad. Hurting their sisters and Anna.

  • @sherip9854
    @sherip9854 3 года назад +43

    Josh is a stain on the Duggar brand. Anna by association hurts them to. It’s unfortunate because she seems like a lovely woman and mama. John David seems to be the most genuine that’s why we love him. 💕 it’s hard seeing josh pop up on the family social media. I roll my eyes and wanna skip their posts because of him. I support the girls not their immature brother. 🤷🏻‍♀️

    • @dayzdnconfuz3d
      @dayzdnconfuz3d 3 года назад +1

      Really? It’s not Anna’s fault at all- any of it. That’s messed up to say.

    • @sherip9854
      @sherip9854 3 года назад +1

      @@dayzdnconfuz3d no of course,it’s not her fault. From a business perspective she is “ that guys” wife. And every time she shows up on camera, people think of him and the things he did. It’s bad for ratings. It’s not a good move for the network.

    • @margyritchie2702
      @margyritchie2702 3 года назад

      They're all a stain on humanity!

  • @nicolenowicki5021
    @nicolenowicki5021 3 года назад +17

    Josh is an awful human. He was a teenager not a child and this happened because he wasn’t allowed to be a normal child/teen. This is 100% on josh and Michelle and Jim bob

    • @carrietremble
      @carrietremble 3 года назад +1

      @@patriciaceja6112 Someone 18 or 19 is a teen and IS NOT a child! They are legal adults!

    • @maryanncasciani3866
      @maryanncasciani3866 3 года назад

      I couldn’t say the reason that Josh is like this is because he wasn’t allowed to be a normal kid. My ex husband is just as sick as josh and he had a normal childhood, same with 2 of my uncles. Who knows the root cause?

  • @scottranger8909
    @scottranger8909 3 года назад +51

    I met John David a few years back and he's a very nice young man.

  • @emilyjohnson2189
    @emilyjohnson2189 3 года назад +33

    Can you imagine when Josh's daughters grow up & read about awful he is🤮

    • @deeking3683
      @deeking3683 3 года назад +6

      Unfortunately, they may already know.

    • @tuesdaypatience
      @tuesdaypatience 3 года назад +5

      Don’t worry...their mom and grandparents will make sure to spin it so they believe their dad has been forgiven and that he is the *real* victim 🙄. Anna needs to be investigated by DHS to see if she has protected her children from him.

  • @michelekelsey691
    @michelekelsey691 3 года назад +6

    I worry for Joshua's daughters. I have never heard of anyone who has voiced concerns about his past SA with his sister's and how this could play out with his daughters!!! If I was Anna I would NEVER leave any of my daughters alone for one minute with him.

  • @criscat8239
    @criscat8239 3 года назад +15

    Maybe that's why JB and Michelle publicly praise Josh. No one else cares about him.

    • @lostinwonderland6873
      @lostinwonderland6873 3 года назад +2

      They probably think that him coming back to the show will help to spread the word that their church helped him and healed him which we all know is b.s and Lucifer has a special place for Josh and others like him

  • @tricid2458
    @tricid2458 3 года назад +12

    I think the brothers are in a difficult position and doing the best they can. We don’t know everything that is going on.

  • @khdavis
    @khdavis 3 года назад +6

    In the group pics it looks as if Jill and Derick have been childless at the weddings. They seem to be protecting their children from the rest of the Duggar family by not bringing them - smart and good choice!

  • @sonyafox3271
    @sonyafox3271 3 года назад +16

    With that being said, Jim Bob and Michelle should take a note from John David’s note book. But, JB and, Michelle will never get it.

  • @annettecarolherbst
    @annettecarolherbst 3 года назад +30

    I love John David he seems the most normal (if you can call these people normal). Josh has always! given me the creeps even before we knew all his grossness. Have to say Katie your make up is gourgous today!

    • @annettecarolherbst
      @annettecarolherbst 3 года назад +1

      Also Jinger looks awful her face is so gaunt and colorless. I hope Michelle is keeping her eye on her. I feel scared for her looking at her

    • @brendac5786
      @brendac5786 3 года назад

      @@annettecarolherbst the last family picture with Jinger I thought she looked terrible.

  • @saraschneider6781
    @saraschneider6781 3 года назад +5

    That was the single most devastating line in the original post scandal documentary.

  • @christinahowley4690
    @christinahowley4690 3 года назад +9

    I believe that Josh disgraced his family. Especially his younger brothers who always looked up to him. He is very toxic.

  • @KAYELLEK
    @KAYELLEK 3 года назад +13

    Also josh married young and moved out when the boys were very young. John david really watched and helped them grow up

  • @rhodagarza5607
    @rhodagarza5607 3 года назад +6

    That tells a lot that John David don't want to be anything like his brother I wonder what Jim Bob thinks about that

  • @brendaenglish2477
    @brendaenglish2477 3 года назад +7

    John David really seems like a level headed, good man.

  • @kristinasullivan9436
    @kristinasullivan9436 3 года назад +12

    I don't think Josh, knowing what he did to his sisters, should ever be allowed around his children unsupervised and he should definitely not be holding the baby. Anna needs to protect her kids and his parents should have made sure that their son never ever had a chance to reoffend. I very hope there are alarms I'm the girls room if he were to ever step foot in there at night while Anna is sleeping.

  • @lissetg8121
    @lissetg8121 3 года назад +8

    Josh just stands out odd and awkward in the brothers group picture. Picture would of been better off without him.

  • @kymberlysteiger8125
    @kymberlysteiger8125 3 года назад +15

    I think, given the chance, Josh would do it again. You can’t pray that behavior out of a person. And the fact that it started so early, no therapy, barely a slap on the hand, he’s probably dying inside to repeat those behaviors! God only knows what he puts Anna through because you know she probably told him she’ll do whatever he wants to make him happy so he doesn’t feel the need to stray! It’s no wonder why she’s popping them out faster now, it’s been how long since he’s been able to hire someone to slap around for rough front hugging 🤗 or watch gross 🤮 inappropriate shows Lol 😝 Poor Anna, she deserves SO MUCH BETTER!

    • @CAMarg-zs1xq
      @CAMarg-zs1xq 3 года назад

      I knew something was up with their wedding special...two virgins should not have described their wedding night as amazing...I knew that Josh was getting experience somewhere

  • @lolanelson9634
    @lolanelson9634 3 года назад +2

    I mean, after he goes to prison, he will not be allowed to be around children. If he does, he’d be violating probation. I don’t think that the brothers will ever feel safe with him being around their kids. He needs to be taken out of their patriarchal line.

  • @amandawilder7353
    @amandawilder7353 3 года назад +5

    Its refreshing to atleast hear they are shocked, and ultimately hurt, as well feeling the deceptive nature that is their brother. Josh hurt more than he could care to know.

  • @murphysmommy
    @murphysmommy 3 года назад +7

    John David spoke for all of us when he talked about how horrified and disappointed he was to learn of Josh's actions. PS) Your dog is amazing. I wish that I could sleep as soundly as him/her!

  • @unicorn5798
    @unicorn5798 3 года назад +26

    Some people really do go to great lengths to hide their weight. I know it may seem silly but people can really hate the way they look after gaining weight and not want to be in pictures. I am bigger and absolutely hate taking pictures and looking at myself in pictures. So she very well could be feeling very sensitive about the way she looks.

    • @brendac5786
      @brendac5786 3 года назад +1

      Give her a break! She’s had six children.

    • @katglby
      @katglby 3 года назад

      I can't stand Josh, but IMO I don't think the photographer stuck him on the end on purpose. Could be just how they all gathered for the pic.

  • @lizmowrey9866
    @lizmowrey9866 3 года назад +8

    I applaud JD for realizing what his brother did is bad and deciding to step up

  • @funoldmomof2
    @funoldmomof2 3 года назад +16

    I feel that the lost boys were like preteens when all this came out about their oldest brother & maybe did not understand it all.. Now that they are older & understanding what it all means, they have different feelings towards him. I'm also wondering if maybe something has happened between the oldest brother that is getting ready to hit the fan that the family knows about, yet we don't & maybe that is why Anna could be ashamed to let the public know that she is going to have #7.. Interesting that Jill & Derek attended the Wedding. I Pray Jill & Derek keeps her guard up with her family and don't get pulled back in to the cult..

    • @becbecholley
      @becbecholley 3 года назад +4

      That’s exactly what I was saying, they are becoming grown men, husbands and dads and are realizing on a deeper level how dysfunctional JB&M are handling things. They will never give up on golden boy

  • @judyp4153
    @judyp4153 3 года назад +5

    If I had kid who did that to one of their siblings I would disown that kid.

  • @heatherbaird1894
    @heatherbaird1894 3 года назад +5

    My opinion is that John David is the role model now to the boys. I also think he might live a more relaxed life style. He seems like he really loves Abbey and she and Grace/future kids more freedom and choices then what we grew up with. I might be wrong, but I feel like doesn't want to live his adult life just like his childhood life.

  • @sillyaccount32
    @sillyaccount32 3 года назад +10

    Yes, he’s definitely a stain on the family name...he’s the family skid mark😂

    • @AmandaPaige71
      @AmandaPaige71 3 года назад

      THAT'S sooo funny!! Even better than the boil on the butt of the family which is what I was going to say!
      💀🤣💀🤣💀

  • @chibilee3037
    @chibilee3037 3 года назад +24

    When you mentioned Josh trying to make his way back onto the show, my heart dropped. It scares me to think of that, for the sake of the victims still healing from the past and the children in their family.

    • @lostinwonderland6873
      @lostinwonderland6873 3 года назад +6

      The parents do not care the mother is so brain washed by Jim Bob that she goes with whatever he says and he only cares about money and himself.

  • @jenniferl8967
    @jenniferl8967 3 года назад +13

    Your dog is the cutest in the background 🥺😍

  • @kaydawbs1835
    @kaydawbs1835 3 года назад +14

    Anna is having a girl. Josh likes the names Ashley and Madison. Anna is still undecided 😜

  • @zivagoldman2001
    @zivagoldman2001 3 года назад +2

    The 2 strikes against josh are what the public knows. How many other offenses has he gotten away with? I'm sure he was forced to ask for forgiveness and Mom and Pop forced the others to give their forgiveness. I think they just tolerate him because it's "good for the image". Yet they ban Jill and Derrick for their 'sins'. I will never understand their way of thinking!

  • @saulithyia
    @saulithyia 3 года назад +4

    Despite their upbringing being so sheltered and Josh not learning "boundaries" and whatnot, I still put the blame on him for all he did. I would think as indoctrinated into the Bible and scriptures, it would be pretty clear that touching your sister in inappropriate ways would be considered sinful to the utmost degree. He was a teenager, he knew what he was doing was wrong. If you have to hide, sneak, and fear "getting caught", then you know what you're doing is wrong. I've raised 3 of my own, they know what's right and wrong.

  • @pattybronner6212
    @pattybronner6212 3 года назад +13

    Perhaps if Josh had gotten proper counseling after the original situation with the girls, he would not have made subsequent"mistakes". After the original incident, the fault lies 100%with the parents.

    • @faith.tew92
      @faith.tew92 3 года назад

      I agree a bit part of the problem lies with the parents, however Josh was competent enough to know right from wrong. The blame is on him. He chose to do wrong.

    • @pattybronner6212
      @pattybronner6212 3 года назад

      @@faith.tew92 I am not disagreeing. Josh obviously knew he had done wrong when he went to his parents and confessed. But he was only 14 or 15( again, not excusing him). IF his parents had gotten him real professional help at that time, there is a possibility that he would not have wronged his wife, mistreated sex workers, and basically lied to everyone. Although I don't have much sympathy for him, his life and other lives that he touched might have been much improved if he had been given appropriate and timely therapy.

  • @erinpufunt
    @erinpufunt 2 года назад +1

    This was such a heart breaking episode.. I think every word everyone of those kids said was sincere. “I don’t want to be like you anymore” truly , my heart goes out to them

  • @histerp51
    @histerp51 3 года назад +2

    I am sooo concerned that Josh took pics of his own children....He needs to get some very deep help and get away from those children.....arggg

  • @bflogal18
    @bflogal18 3 года назад +13

    Wonder who took those photos? Maybe they brought a “buddy” along on the honeymoon? 😂

  • @sisboombah9595
    @sisboombah9595 3 года назад +10

    I want err on the side of caution with Anna and her "hiding something". Chances are, she is in fact pregnant. HOWEVER, I know that certain antidepressants and mood regulating medications can change your body very rapidly. What if she's taking care and ownership of her mental health and takes medication that causes weight gain? She seems to be carrying this weight very differently than she did with her pregnancies, her face looks so different than it has with pregnancies. I was put on medication where I was up to 168 lbs, when my average weight was around 124. At 5'0", it didn't have a lot of places to settle, so my appearance changed. I ALWAYS felt a need to "hide" in photos back then bc it was a lot to deal with and seemed to be happening very quickly. Since being off those meds, I am down to 130 lbs, and feel more recognizable when I look in the mirror.

    • @Sunset1705
      @Sunset1705 3 года назад +3

      That’s a good point and for any normal family that’d be a possibility but for these people, there’s no way she saw a real therapist who prescribed her meds and she decided to actually take them. Remember, they think that they can solve everything through the lord and wouldn’t typically take such a logical or mainstream approach.

  • @christinajanzen1601
    @christinajanzen1601 3 года назад +6

    I think Anna is pregnant. She looked pregnant in the latest special on TLC. There was one shot in there where u caught a glimpse of her stomach she looked expecting.

  • @Nickabod79
    @Nickabod79 3 года назад +1

    JD's comment at the beginning of this video is the most truthful and straightforward thing to come out of a Duggar's mouth.

  • @honeybunch5765
    @honeybunch5765 3 года назад +1

    Nothing shames Josh, he has no skin on his face no matter if his family calls him out on his sins. This man has no end to his deviant behavior.

  • @Emper0rH0rde
    @Emper0rH0rde Год назад

    "One of the toughest things I ever had to tell my older brother was 'I don't want to be like you anymore.'" Damn.

  • @metaphoricallyspeaking45
    @metaphoricallyspeaking45 3 года назад +2

    I don’t think they acknowledge the issues anymore.

    • @lostinwonderland6873
      @lostinwonderland6873 3 года назад

      They want to sweep it under the rug the way they did for so long they probably think that the girls are married and out of the house what could go wrong, but when you are sick in your mind the way he is, their is no fixing and he never got the help he needed and not by getting beat with a Bible he was going to get fixed, look what he did now that he is older what makes us believe it would not happen to the other girl's or any girl off the streets, they failed as parents and started their own cult

  • @cbeyer23
    @cbeyer23 3 года назад +4

    They were all angry the difference is it is acceptable for the guys to express it while the girls (even those he molested) are expected, if not legally obligated to "stay sweet."

    • @busyscrapbooking
      @busyscrapbooking 3 года назад +1

      Yes, I stopped watching the show before this but I am surprised the boys discusses this on camera. It’s my guess the girls wouldn’t be able to talk so negatively about him.

    • @cbeyer23
      @cbeyer23 3 года назад +2

      @@busyscrapbooking Derrick has pretty much said outright that Jill was forced to defend Josh

    • @busyscrapbooking
      @busyscrapbooking 3 года назад +1

      @@cbeyer23 that is terrible. I could never forgive my parents for that.

  • @rosemarydoran9907
    @rosemarydoran9907 3 года назад +2

    Josh should be pushed to the side. He is a disgrace. I am afraid for his daughters and his younger sisters who are in vulnerable positions being so close to Josh. I hope Anna never let's him watch the kids unsupervised. John David and Joe seem to be the kindest and sweetest and most stand-up guys. They seem to be living husbands and fathers.

    • @rosemarydoran9907
      @rosemarydoran9907 Год назад

      @@LisaKoffler true but I hope he is never around his grandchildren even after his supervised release is over!

  • @elainethomson5826
    @elainethomson5826 3 года назад +4

    Well you can forgive but not forget

  • @mtrezise1
    @mtrezise1 Год назад

    Now that Josh is in prison, I don't think his siblings will ever forgive him for inappropriately touching his sisters, cheating on his wife, being caught with inappropriate content, etc. Josh's actions were so horrifying. I think that's why John-David and Joseph both said they don't want to be like Josh anymore and are very angry with him. I'm sure all the younger brothers (from Josiah all the way down to Jackson) are also very angry with Josh and want nothing to do with him.

  • @GeorgeGlass298
    @GeorgeGlass298 3 года назад +9

    She is 100% pregnant. I worry there is something wrong with the baby and they are going to pretend she was never pregnant.

    • @lindalambert6716
      @lindalambert6716 3 года назад +3

      I was thinking this too, very sad if this is what’s going on.

    • @aj25055
      @aj25055 3 года назад

      My thought as well.

    • @GeorgeGlass298
      @GeorgeGlass298 3 года назад

      @@patriciaceja6112 You seem like the type that would pray for her

  • @booklover2404
    @booklover2404 3 года назад +1

    The other boys didnt make that mistake like Josh.

  • @paulinewhite4771
    @paulinewhite4771 3 года назад +3

    Hope john david watches over his younger sisters now that josh lives so close . John david you are a wonderful caring brother and husband.You have a beautiful family

  • @Fuzzyin08
    @Fuzzyin08 3 года назад +4

    Love your eye shadow today Katie! I believe John David is the honorable brother. He appears to be to be an honest man. Josh needs to fall off the face of the earth. Save Anna, but no more Josh!

  • @Kayla-Moon
    @Kayla-Moon 3 года назад +1

    Josh's actions are unforgivable. I have a hard time justifying his actions because he wasn't "educated enough". He definitely knew right from wrong and continued to display his inappropriate actions as an adult (as you mentioned). So frustrating that TLC would allow any sorts of mentions of Josh on the show or even ever consider his return. Sick.

  • @kathydimario5263
    @kathydimario5263 2 года назад +1

    John David has a mind of his own

  • @jshearouse
    @jshearouse 3 года назад +1

    The parents weren't supposed to be on the show very much. Slowly they have brought them back.

  • @lauren.g5382
    @lauren.g5382 3 года назад +1

    John David is also educated. Educated as a first responder. He’s the most respectable one whom anyone can rely on. And luckily his wife is educated too as a nurse

  • @racheladams9364
    @racheladams9364 3 года назад +2

    I feel bad for the family because I'm sure growing up the siblings were close likebest friends, from watching them on tv and other families with similar beliefs you realize having siblings are these kids only friends. So I'm sure it was heartbreaking to see their best friend grow up into someone they can't stand or want nothing to do with.

  • @wanda4573
    @wanda4573 3 года назад +1

    Hes become a stain on the most of the family. Issue is the inlaws who grew up in a healthy family wont have a bar of it. The cheating on anna shocked me the most as hes an adult.. made me realise how narcissistic he is and anna such a loving good forgiving church wife, co dependent.

  • @meganlopez560
    @meganlopez560 3 года назад +3

    Your makeup is on point. Especially that eyeshadow 🙌🏻

  • @Kwd123
    @Kwd123 3 года назад +2

    If it is weight gain I can see hiding it. She has been in a cult that values women staying ‘thin’ and ‘attractive’ and puts the blame on the women for men acting poorly. If she gained weight it could feel like a shame for her that she doesn’t look the way she thinks is ‘valuable’ . And that might mean she feels blame that her appearance could make josh reoffend.

  • @lruss5050
    @lruss5050 3 года назад +4

    John David is a sweetheart!❤️

  • @MaryTatarelli
    @MaryTatarelli 3 года назад +2

    They probably didn’t include josh as a groomsman because TLC probably paid for the wedding to film it and they can’t air josh. So it’s easier that he’s not in the footage

  • @Holdenwhat
    @Holdenwhat 3 года назад +1

    have you considered that Anna may be pregnant with a baby who might have a difference? This might be something she doesn't want judged by the media, at least not yet. She may be having a difficult or risky pregnancy. If there is a problem, they will not abort- and not everyone will agree with their decisions. It could be anything.

  • @marlenefilicevelasco5333
    @marlenefilicevelasco5333 3 года назад +1

    My concern is Josh being around his own kids..

  • @debbietrego1540
    @debbietrego1540 2 года назад

    Those dresses on the Duggar girls are so unflattering, style and color!

  • @MsHathawaykj
    @MsHathawaykj 3 года назад +1

    Can you imagine I wouldn’t want him around my wife, my kids, if I was Jon David.

  • @nickiehines5319
    @nickiehines5319 3 года назад

    The light of the family !
    So brave to share his heart he will be blessed
    And will protect those younger kids !

  • @kamirobey175
    @kamirobey175 3 года назад +1

    I really only come to watch videos to see your dog, so cute. Seriously though, John David is a police officer, and would be more likely to detest Josh for what he did to the sisters, not to mention the latest allegations. He seems like an upstanding guy who has never been one to harp endlessly on the familiar Duggar mantra of "Oh look at us aren't we wonderful Christians because we do..." As for the younger Duggar boys, by the time they all came into the world, Josh was much older and within a couple of years had met and married Anna and moved out of the house, then went on to his position in Washington where he hypocritically espoused family values. It would make sense that the younger boys do not have a close relationship with him, whereas with John David, he has been a part of their lives since day one and seems to have played the role of big brother admirably. I think of all the boys, he's the one I actually respect.

    • @ShainaCilimberg
      @ShainaCilimberg 3 года назад

      HE is a Christian for God, which is the real way not for others

  • @filmfury743
    @filmfury743 3 года назад +1

    I think these kids feel betrayed over the parents actions over the past decade. The girls should feel betrayed how their parents handled the molestation

  • @veroncasi3689
    @veroncasi3689 3 года назад +1

    Mztie joy# you are so right about oldest brother being patriarch.
    We are traditional catholics and my oldest son has that role

  • @amandavasquez2505
    @amandavasquez2505 3 года назад +1

    When is Anna even due?? It seems like she's been pregnant since the start of the pandemic

  • @aaronaakre9470
    @aaronaakre9470 3 года назад +1

    Every family has a “black sheep”. They are lucky they only have one

  • @lynnkavanagh7361
    @lynnkavanagh7361 3 года назад +1

    I think the Duggar kids do not like Josh at all. I'm sure Jim Bob & Michele are the only ones who have a sliver of faith in him. If it were up to the kids I think they wouldn't have him around at all, but Jim Bob & Michele are all about how it looks & they want to perceived as one big happy family. Pathetic if you ask me.

  • @lilacscentedfushias1852
    @lilacscentedfushias1852 3 года назад

    All those able bodied people there & they’re using disposable plates 😤 probably cups & cutlery too.

  • @kasseliz7043
    @kasseliz7043 3 года назад +2

    You look so great in this color purple!! 💜 You're being too nice about his sneakers...how does he not have a pair of black dress shoes for how often he goes to church supposedly? He looks like an even bigger clown 🤡 than usual! Yuck!

  • @debwiley3914
    @debwiley3914 3 года назад +2

    As you look at the girls in Claire's wedding photo, who is next to her on the right?

  • @CoffeeLover-mz7bk
    @CoffeeLover-mz7bk 3 года назад +1

    I'm glad that the other boys don't want to be like Josh. John David is such a great guy. Abbie definitely got the best Duggar boy!

    • @lostinwonderland6873
      @lostinwonderland6873 3 года назад

      Their marriage is the only one I see that they truly love each other and the others just got sold to the highest bidder.

  • @nadinekuzinski
    @nadinekuzinski 3 года назад

    I think the kids don't really support what their older brother did, especially to the girls.