And a great show put on by Mr. Andy Healey, who drove the locomotive in place of his friend despite his grief. That Britannia is a beautiful display of workmanship.
Glorious, the miniature stuff doesn't get enough attention. Good lord the chap with the Britannia at the start, what a sad story but what a lovely send off.
Three things... 1) Welcome back SLIP! And what better way to kick off a new series, than going miniature for a change! 2) 11:08: R.I.P to Karl Midgley; thoughts and sympathies going out to his family, at their time of loss. 3) Well done to all who took part in the contest. A great, big thumbs up once again Chris; great to see SLIP finally resuming after many months of uncertainty.
@@ChristheXelent Trust me Chris, the people that think 20 minutes of slips is "too much" are in the wrong place. Don't cater to them. Believe me, your fans like long episodes full of facts and interesting titbits. We're not "geeks" for nothing. :D
- IMLEC 2021 DRINKING GAME - Drink whenever: - There is some kind of catastrophe that stops a run (e.g. blow out (running out of steam), derailment, or gears jamming etc etc). - Any passengers get off the train (either to lessen the weight carried and to let the run continue, or to enable to train to get back to the start so it can retire). - A loco retires or is disqualified. - Chris (the presenter), when interviewing a contestant, says "How do you think you'll get on?" (or variation thereof). - Onlookers clap for no reason other than because a small train is passing them (Easy mode: disregard clapping when a run starts or finishes). - The driver of Polly 6 (blue loco named "Bluebelle") blows his whistle, thus wasting steam. - A train drives backwards as part of a run (usually to have another go at the enormous hill that makes up like half the route). - An animal is on screen, front and centre. - You inevitably guess wrong as to how well a run/loco did when the ranking screen is shown. - Chris feigns surprise as to well a run/loco did when showing it's place in the rankings (as is the nature of post-production voice overs). - Lastly, raise a toast in Karl's honour.
@@SuperAzusa well that and, to be fair, some of the results weren't what you might expect on first impressions. I was looking back at the results of previous IMLECs recently. A 7F came first in 1992 and a GWR Dean Single won way back in 1971. Not the sort of thing you'd expect to find at the top, for sure. Don't worry, I wasn't taking your words as an attack. But it would be fun to try the drinking game out sometime.
2:27 - No lie, when you revealed the venue for the event, my jaw hit the floor. All the memories came rushing back! I used to live out in Kent when I was a small child, firstly in Headcorn then in Gillingham. And trips to Maidstone and Mote Park were a regular occurrence - with that mighty railway at the bottom of the park being the holy grail for little me! There's plenty of photos in old albums in the loft of me and my folks riding the trains at Mote Park, it was like the best model railway I'd ever seen :) what a lovely event and video Chris!
I love seeing how passionate people are about there engines....if I even could make or afford one I'd probably get rather a model of Shannon, or an ivatt 2 mogul
You guys were so on-top of the camerawork that each development was captured in real time and all the footage looks splendid. Without the availability of reshoots, that's impressive beyond words.
Thank you. We couldn't have done it without the extra hands we had on deck from Frontline Steam and Online Models Ltd. There were some bits we missed, like one contestant turning up without a boiler ticket and then being sent away before we could capture it on camera, but that's the trouble with having to be everywhere at once.
Well that was surprisingly captivating! Was Mr Eden-Green's commentary was intended to be so side splittingly hilarious? I mean literally, LOL! Loved it. Can't wait for the 2022 coverage.
1:13:00 I’m just happy the P2 did as well as she did. It certainly bodes well for the full size version when she’s finished, assuming they can get the vibration fixed. Also, the tank engines: “Little engines can do big things”
Brilliant video Chris - definitely one of the most enjoyable I’ve seen in ages. I adore miniature steam like 5inch and 3.5inch gauge, and this had me hooked from the start. I really loved your comments on the history of the locos, particularly more obscure ones such as the P1s (one of my favourites), and the soundtrack was brilliant. Amazing work as always: don’t ever stop being awesome mate!
It's the first time in nearly 2 years I've even able to watch this video ,I'm Karl's Nan we took him to all IMLECS since he was about 10, he couldn't wait for the day that he could enter with grandad Ben's locos and later with his own APOLLO, miss you our dear karl
Thank you so much for posting! Great to see the whole competition covered in detail, a truly riveting watch. I've driven that track myself, though about 50 years ago (!) and it's a great ride around but as I recall the rails are aluminium, which makes for rather variable traction. The smaller engines have the odds stacked against them. For a start, in a tiny boiler the hot gases from the coal are through the tubes and up the chimney so quick they don't have time to pass their energy into the water. But also the ratio of surface area of the boiler to volume is greater, so they lose proportionately more heat to the air around. Bear in mind a full size steamer could achieve as much as 8% efficiency - bigger is ALWAYS more efficient in any power plant, all other things being equal. And high speed is a natural advantage simply because covering more distance means doing more work (energy output = distance covered x load pulled), and the more useful work you generate, the better the ratio of useful work to heat lost from the hot surfaces. So a bigger engine going faster and dragging more load, always has a better chance. However the other variables are many, including driver skill, and I think the 2.2% efficiency of the winner is quite astonishing - few engines of this scale achieve such a high thermal efficiency. Great story, great competition and very well reported. I'd send you a "Thank$" if you had a button!
This is a very impressive showcase of small gauge engine doing as well as standard gauge, The music at 1:10:54 fits the mood, and Karl's Britannia really put on a show, may he rest in peace
I wish my late Dad could have seen this. He built several locos in his time and as a little girl I spent a lot of time with him while he worked in his shed and when he ran his locos at various tracks/exhibitions in Dorset and Hampshire. (One of the first that he built from scratch, he named 'Bitza' - made from bitsa this and bitsa that!) This video brought back so many happy memories for me. Thoroughly enjoyed it!
This must be the finest video you have done Chris, the commentary, the music and particularly the videography was of the highest order for such a long video, I’m a great fan of your locomotive profile series, looking forward to more of the same from you. Thanks.( even if I do come from Southport.).
this was such an interesting video and change of pace! awesome seeing so many miniature models competing like this, though the competition aspect was surely less important than seeing everyone bring their best models to the track. excellent stuff!!!
What a wonderful episode! Maybe IMLEC SLIPs should become a yearly thing ;P Congratulations to all involved. And condolences to Karl’s family and friends, Rest In Peace..
Chris, all your videos are enjoyable, but this one is tops. Being a 3-1/2" gauge builder, and also just finishing up my elevated track after 12 years construction I enjoyed this film immensely. Most Excellent! Jack
Well done to all the drivers and everyone else involved for putting on such a great competition and well done to you Chris for such a fantastic and informative video
my old man has a 5" scale brit, took him 8 years or so to complete, it looks fantastic and i often have a go, i often head up to gilling with him for a blast around there.
And I was involved in one… It was bloody terrifying… And that was only a battery electric for context i was a bath & west track a good few years ago (pre-covid) and i was driving my class 08 when the coupling chain broke, and in shock i nocked the regulator fully open and i was being pulled along by the controler wire, luckily i was able to stop it
A good performance done by all! I thoroughly enjoyed this, so IMLEC is basically a mini railway show? I was cheering for Karls Britianna, whilst it wasnt Top 5, i say that Top 10 is a great sendoff to Karl
Dads good friend who he worked under at British Rail depot in Shirebrook spun about 17 of these Locomotives up on his lathe. Superb detail and great to see these works of art still running. He was also one of the "Go to" guys in the UK for the boiler test on these beauties. His name was "Uncle" Ted Hazlehurst lovely bloke RIP Ted & Dad, Roger Stansall. Dad built me an electric shunter with a car dynamo as the motor but we never laid the track.
I wonder how much a Lempor would improve the performance of a 5" gauge loco. Would be interesting to see. I reckon an advanced 5" gauge QJ would perform quite well.
Really enjoyed this change of format, it's quite difficult to get miniature railways to be interesting on video and you've done it! Perhaps visit the 7 1/4 Gauge Society AGM or the Gilling Mainline Rally and do something similar?
I love how this contest shows pretty much all aspects of a steam engine, from strength to weakness. Utter shame about the some of the Retirees, and particularly about Karl, rest his soul. But his ‘Apollo’ did him proud, and really everyone did well
Beautiful production! You've done a wonderful job presenting the event and it's participants with attention to both the details and the excitement of competition.
Bit more of a 7.5 inch gauge fan myself, mostly from that being the main gauge of the place my grandfather used to take me when I was a kid, Long Island Live Steamers.
Well done to all competitors. Chris, i would love to see this again in 2022. A question to the commenters: If you build a miniature what would it be and why? I would build a 5" Norfolk and Western J Class 4-8-4. With roller bearings on every moving joint, I would think it would get better fuel economy.
In a miniature like these, roller bearings would only make a very very small difference. It’s all to do with cylinder, valve gear and boiler design, plus drivers skill.
Like the question posed 🤔 I'm going out of the box for a international miniature idea, I would go for a NSW 12 4-4-0 having remembered 1210 from footage of Flying Scotsman's Australian visit 😌
Most likely a JNR C62 (They were built for primarily passenger duties during WW2.) or a modified E2 with an extended coal bunker, flat running board and a mixed-traffic boiler.
My ideal miniature would have to be a 5” model of the biggest non-articulated locomotives on the Reading *BEFORE* the T-1s rolled out of the shops: The K1 2-10-2 Santa Fe type. That, or a 5” Reading G3 4-6-2 Pacific.
9:03 side note, one was briefly preserved. 9875 Midlothian was rebuilt for preservation in... 1937 i think...? Anyways, in 1939, due to the metal shortage in Britain, it was scrapped again.
Out of all the miniature locomotives in this competition, the LNER Gresley 'P1' Class 2-8-2 No. 2393 is my favourite as this locomotive's design was outlined for Ravenglass & Eskdale Railway's No. 9 "River Mite". It's great to see these lovely little engines in action especially as minimum gauge locomotives are very close to my heart. :)
a competition on steam live steamers !!! It's worth seeing this. Congratulations to everyone, thank you very much for the video you are the geniuses of steam !!! !!
Brilliant Chris, just brilliant. Enjoyed every minute of this 'different' SLIPs. More please in the same vein - model steam loco engineering. Though not necessarily as a competition. Perhaps about some of the miniature engineering aspects and interviews with builders? Nice change, though.
29:08 “Still, 90 mph is cruising speed for an A4” Flying Scotsman: Ahem! I went 100 mph! Mallard: AHEM! I did 126 mph! PRR T1 5550: I will do…. Sorry T1, you will not do any speed records in 2030
@@electrik_loss no just no Steam locomotive world speed record breaking in the 21st century is now redundant. Just use PRR T1 5550 on mainline excursions…..nothing else. If steam locomotives go beyond the safe speed of 75 mph (121 km/h), trouble with the crews can hav consequences
I actually would prefer that 5550 not attempt any record breaking. I meant the "one can hope" as "oh maybe someone hopes that 5550 would break the world steam speed record", sorry if that caused any confusion. I'm happy with Mallard staying at the top.
That was GOOD. Sad tales, high drama, A a very clever juxtaposition of 2 Riddles 2-10-0s (Yes, we noticed...). and by Gad what a beast that P2 is....Looking forward to seeing the 12" / Ft model ! Thanks to all involved for a great Hr+ of entertainment .
Great stuff, thanks Chris. I remember when it was held at Bedford MES waay back. I wonder how the efficiency characteristics compare with the full size locos.
Well this was more interesting then I initially thought it was going to be. What a nice little film you put together here. Each machine was an sight to behold and each seemed to be an excellent examples of engineering. That two of these engineers had passed on is very sad to hear, but hopefully their lovely little engines will remain as examples of their skills and of the men themselves. Shame the Southern competitors didn't do well though...
I know the gentleman who owns that 4mt Ben was running, the owner has told me all about the amount of work ben has put into it... needless to say my jaw hit the floor when I heard about all the little things he had to do to it to get it running right. A real credit to him and his work.
The tanker was dripping degreaser on the rails to help maintain a clean track for all competitors. The guards van provided an extra pair of axles to brake up any grease that may be there.
I've often wondered how something like a Stirling Single would do at IMLEC, the large diameter driving wheels should mean rather low steam consumption since they'll run at a lower rpm, but I imagine the lack of tractive effort and thus lack of passenger load, would be the biggest hamper. You'd have to be very light on the fire to make up for it, and that's the other aspect that makes IMLEC interesting. Driver skill makes nearly as much a difference as the engine itself, as you need to balance using as little coal as you can, against risking a blowup, every shovel you toss in the fire lowers your score, so you really need to think about if you really need that shovel. And a good grasp of throttle regulation goes a long way in preventing wheel slips and wasting more steam. Judging efficiency over just raw power and speed is definitely a more skill based competition.
@@TomsWorkshop42 I'm aware, my whole comment is talking about how judging by efficiency over raw power is neat, _however_ bigger loads give you an advantage. If two engines burn the same amount of coal going the same distance, but one is pulling twice as much weight as the other, it has done more work with its coal and thus is much more efficient. Which is why I said with a Stirling you have to be very light on coal usage to make up for the lack of loading. It's neat to hear one won though, must've been a really skilled engineer to make the most out of every shovel.
Although it would probably to hugely expensive and just massive in general, i wonder if a narrow gauge loco like the ffestiniog farlies or whr garrats would perform well in imlec
RIP Karl. That Brittania put on a great show
And a great show put on by Mr. Andy Healey, who drove the locomotive in place of his friend despite his grief. That Britannia is a beautiful display of workmanship.
@@NextEevolution I think his late friend would have been over the moon with how well the engine ran along the track.
Indeed. Gone way too soon at just 35. Such a shame.
A jolly good one indeed .
@@NextEevolution karl was not a friend he was my nephew thank you for your kind words . andy healey
Glorious, the miniature stuff doesn't get enough attention.
Good lord the chap with the Britannia at the start, what a sad story but what a lovely send off.
Mini slips in profile? (Covers small live steam)
Apparently Karl was only a young lad aswell, all the more impressive, all the more tragic 😢
Never Overlook A Little Engine; I firmly believe in that phrase. :)
God my heart when I saw the RIP Karl headboard. She did him proud!
Three things...
1) Welcome back SLIP! And what better way to kick off a new series, than going miniature for a change!
2) 11:08: R.I.P to Karl Midgley; thoughts and sympathies going out to his family, at their time of loss.
3) Well done to all who took part in the contest.
A great, big thumbs up once again Chris; great to see SLIP finally resuming after many months of uncertainty.
Kamakazi squirrels!🙀
An hour-long episode of SLIPS? Am I in heaven?
Yes
To some people, even a 15=20 minute episode of SLIPs is their idea of hell
@@ChristheXelent lol
@@ChristheXelent do you like driving live steam models when you get the chance to do so?
@@ChristheXelent Trust me Chris, the people that think 20 minutes of slips is "too much" are in the wrong place. Don't cater to them. Believe me, your fans like long episodes full of facts and interesting titbits. We're not "geeks" for nothing. :D
- IMLEC 2021 DRINKING GAME -
Drink whenever:
- There is some kind of catastrophe that stops a run (e.g. blow out (running out of steam), derailment, or gears jamming etc etc).
- Any passengers get off the train (either to lessen the weight carried and to let the run continue, or to enable to train to get back to the start so it can retire).
- A loco retires or is disqualified.
- Chris (the presenter), when interviewing a contestant, says "How do you think you'll get on?" (or variation thereof).
- Onlookers clap for no reason other than because a small train is passing them (Easy mode: disregard clapping when a run starts or finishes).
- The driver of Polly 6 (blue loco named "Bluebelle") blows his whistle, thus wasting steam.
- A train drives backwards as part of a run (usually to have another go at the enormous hill that makes up like half the route).
- An animal is on screen, front and centre.
- You inevitably guess wrong as to how well a run/loco did when the ranking screen is shown.
- Chris feigns surprise as to well a run/loco did when showing it's place in the rankings (as is the nature of post-production voice overs).
- Lastly, raise a toast in Karl's honour.
Good drinking game. Though would you rather I was faking cynicism and gloominess when announcing results?
@@ChristheXelent Oh no of course not. I know how it must be due to doing voice overs in post. I couldn't think of a kinder word!
@@SuperAzusa well that and, to be fair, some of the results weren't what you might expect on first impressions.
I was looking back at the results of previous IMLECs recently. A 7F came first in 1992 and a GWR Dean Single won way back in 1971. Not the sort of thing you'd expect to find at the top, for sure.
Don't worry, I wasn't taking your words as an attack. But it would be fun to try the drinking game out sometime.
The Polly will see participants sloshed in no time
We I’ll say, prepare to get a cause of alcohol poisoning or getting down right drunk
I can't imagine how much work truly went into all this
You and the crew must be so proud of yourself for such an amazing project
2:27 - No lie, when you revealed the venue for the event, my jaw hit the floor. All the memories came rushing back! I used to live out in Kent when I was a small child, firstly in Headcorn then in Gillingham. And trips to Maidstone and Mote Park were a regular occurrence - with that mighty railway at the bottom of the park being the holy grail for little me! There's plenty of photos in old albums in the loft of me and my folks riding the trains at Mote Park, it was like the best model railway I'd ever seen :) what a lovely event and video Chris!
You’d always be welcome to visit again, some of us would love to see some of your old photos if you ever stumble on them.
RIP Graham and Karl. Your little engines put on big performances and are now immortalised on RUclips.
They will ride eternal, shiny, and chrome, to misuse a quote from a movie
What a great competition!! RIP Karl, his Britannia gave a great performance! I think my favorite engine was the P2, that engine was truly Awesome!
Agreed
That p2 was a draft horse. She pulled a truly staggering load behind her.
I love seeing how passionate people are about there engines....if I even could make or afford one I'd probably get rather a model of Shannon, or an ivatt 2 mogul
This is an incredible special, SLIP never fails to amaze me
You guys were so on-top of the camerawork that each development was captured in real time and all the footage looks splendid. Without the availability of reshoots, that's impressive beyond words.
Thank you. We couldn't have done it without the extra hands we had on deck from Frontline Steam and Online Models Ltd.
There were some bits we missed, like one contestant turning up without a boiler ticket and then being sent away before we could capture it on camera, but that's the trouble with having to be everywhere at once.
Well that was surprisingly captivating! Was Mr Eden-Green's commentary was intended to be so side splittingly hilarious? I mean literally, LOL! Loved it. Can't wait for the 2022 coverage.
1:13:00 I’m just happy the P2 did as well as she did. It certainly bodes well for the full size version when she’s finished, assuming they can get the vibration fixed.
Also, the tank engines: “Little engines can do big things”
Holy shit Chris! I was today years old when I learned you are a member of 'Tugs the exhibition'!!!
I've stumbled upon this channel by accident and I'm really impressed by these beautiful machines and the people who made and operate them.
Brilliant video Chris - definitely one of the most enjoyable I’ve seen in ages. I adore miniature steam like 5inch and 3.5inch gauge, and this had me hooked from the start. I really loved your comments on the history of the locos, particularly more obscure ones such as the P1s (one of my favourites), and the soundtrack was brilliant. Amazing work as always: don’t ever stop being awesome mate!
It's the first time in nearly 2 years I've even able to watch this video ,I'm Karl's Nan we took him to all IMLECS since he was about 10, he couldn't wait for the day that he could enter with grandad Ben's locos and later with his own APOLLO, miss you our dear karl
I'm sure wherever he is, he's looking down on you with such gratitude and love. Thankyou for sharing
Thank you so much for posting! Great to see the whole competition covered in detail, a truly riveting watch. I've driven that track myself, though about 50 years ago (!) and it's a great ride around but as I recall the rails are aluminium, which makes for rather variable traction.
The smaller engines have the odds stacked against them. For a start, in a tiny boiler the hot gases from the coal are through the tubes and up the chimney so quick they don't have time to pass their energy into the water. But also the ratio of surface area of the boiler to volume is greater, so they lose proportionately more heat to the air around. Bear in mind a full size steamer could achieve as much as 8% efficiency - bigger is ALWAYS more efficient in any power plant, all other things being equal. And high speed is a natural advantage simply because covering more distance means doing more work (energy output = distance covered x load pulled), and the more useful work you generate, the better the ratio of useful work to heat lost from the hot surfaces. So a bigger engine going faster and dragging more load, always has a better chance.
However the other variables are many, including driver skill, and I think the 2.2% efficiency of the winner is quite astonishing - few engines of this scale achieve such a high thermal efficiency.
Great story, great competition and very well reported. I'd send you a "Thank$" if you had a button!
This is a very impressive showcase of small gauge engine doing as well as standard gauge, The music at 1:10:54 fits the mood, and Karl's Britannia really put on a show, may he rest in peace
That was great fun Chris! Would love to see you cover more IMLEC events in the future!
Good to see you back Chris. I missed yearly Slips content. Looking forward to seeing more in the future.
I wish my late Dad could have seen this. He built several locos in his time and as a little girl I spent a lot of time with him while he worked in his shed and when he ran his locos at various tracks/exhibitions in Dorset and Hampshire. (One of the first that he built from scratch, he named 'Bitza' - made from bitsa this and bitsa that!) This video brought back so many happy memories for me. Thoroughly enjoyed it!
Please do this again next year.
This must be the finest video you have done Chris, the commentary, the music and particularly the videography was of the highest order for such a long video, I’m a great fan of your locomotive profile series, looking forward to more of the same from you. Thanks.( even if I do come from Southport.).
@8:20 😊 Definitely my favorite entry in the competition. I like the North British olive livery.
this was such an interesting video and change of pace! awesome seeing so many miniature models competing like this, though the competition aspect was surely less important than seeing everyone bring their best models to the track. excellent stuff!!!
Please do this again next year!
You've absolutely outdone yourself Chris, this is incredible! :D
This was an amazing thing I did not know I needed to see until you showed it to us, so thank you very much for doing so.
Great to see SLIPs back and what an amazing special to return the series with!
What a wonderful episode! Maybe IMLEC SLIPs should become a yearly thing ;P
Congratulations to all involved. And condolences to Karl’s family and friends, Rest In Peace..
This was wonderful to see. The biggest surprise for me was seeing two local engines in the top 5, absolutely made my day!
Chris, all your videos are enjoyable, but this one is tops. Being a 3-1/2" gauge builder, and also just finishing up my elevated track after 12 years construction I enjoyed this film immensely. Most Excellent!
Jack
Such a good video this!! Great fun to watch, had this on a second time when I was working
RIP Karl. How lovely to see that Brittania and what a show
This is a top video with interviews with the owners/builders, plenty of variety of locos and efficiency data for all to see!
33:05 I wasn't expecting that. This kind of reminds me of Top Gear's time trials and I love it.
well done on great Film, well done to all the Runners ( finisher and DNF ),Sam Brown "Well it Just did an Tangmere" was Priceless
As it happens, that was Will Hawks of Frontlinesteam who captured that moment. But you're right, it was a moneyshot moment
Well done to all the drivers and everyone else involved for putting on such a great competition and well done to you Chris for such a fantastic and informative video
33:03
“With a shrieking crack, something broke…”
Truly interesting. I always enjoy miniature stuff simply due to its availability and charm. Well done!
my old man has a 5" scale brit, took him 8 years or so to complete, it looks fantastic and i often have a go, i often head up to gilling with him for a blast around there.
imagine having a run away train in miniature scale still scary but small
It’s happened… consequences can end in a lot of repair work.
And I was involved in one…
It was bloody terrifying…
And that was only a battery electric
for context i was a bath & west track a good few years ago (pre-covid) and i was driving my class 08 when the coupling chain broke, and in shock i nocked the regulator fully open and i was being pulled along by the controler wire, luckily i was able to stop it
A good performance done by all! I thoroughly enjoyed this, so IMLEC is basically a mini railway show?
I was cheering for Karls Britianna, whilst it wasnt Top 5, i say that Top 10 is a great sendoff to Karl
WOW! These Locomotives are absolutely stunning, Well done to all owners/drivers, a joy to watch.
Dads good friend who he worked under at British Rail depot in Shirebrook spun about 17 of these Locomotives up on his lathe.
Superb detail and great to see these works of art still running.
He was also one of the "Go to" guys in the UK for the boiler test on these beauties.
His name was "Uncle" Ted Hazlehurst lovely bloke RIP Ted & Dad, Roger Stansall.
Dad built me an electric shunter with a car dynamo as the motor but we never laid the track.
This would be the perfect event to go full Andre Chapelon and LD Porta on... Lempor exhausts, gas production systems in the smokebox, the whole works.
Don’t forget roller bearings on all axles and rods
Chapelon's never built 2-10-4 would be a place to start!
I wonder how much a Lempor would improve the performance of a 5" gauge loco. Would be interesting to see. I reckon an advanced 5" gauge QJ would perform quite well.
@@The_New_IKB I think a 2-8-4 would be better since a Texas might be approaching curve limits
@@blackbirdgaming8147 I have a 4.75" gauge 2-10-2 and it really isn't bad on curves.
Need another one of these, one of my favourite videos by far
Really enjoyed this change of format, it's quite difficult to get miniature railways to be interesting on video and you've done it! Perhaps visit the 7 1/4 Gauge Society AGM or the Gilling Mainline Rally and do something similar?
I'm sure I have saw that Black Five 5241 before...
It was at some steam Museum place on a caravan site in Scarborough, unless it's a similar loco
I love how this contest shows pretty much all aspects of a steam engine, from strength to weakness. Utter shame about the some of the Retirees, and particularly about Karl, rest his soul. But his ‘Apollo’ did him proud, and really everyone did well
Beautiful production! You've done a wonderful job presenting the event and it's participants with attention to both the details and the excitement of competition.
Thanks for a truly impressive production ,this sets new standards for IMLEC records .
Bit more of a 7.5 inch gauge fan myself, mostly from that being the main gauge of the place my grandfather used to take me when I was a kid, Long Island Live Steamers.
Please Chris do more content of this competition . I've watched this 5 times
I really enjoyed this. Mostly because there was lots of engines and a brief history about there design. Thank you for making this :)
What a wonderful hour and twenty. Some track maintenance seems in order. Beautiful colours.
Well done to all competitors. Chris, i would love to see this again in 2022.
A question to the commenters: If you build a miniature what would it be and why?
I would build a 5" Norfolk and Western J Class 4-8-4. With roller bearings on every moving joint, I would think it would get better fuel economy.
In a miniature like these, roller bearings would only make a very very small difference. It’s all to do with cylinder, valve gear and boiler design, plus drivers skill.
Like the question posed 🤔 I'm going out of the box for a international miniature idea, I would go for a NSW 12 4-4-0 having remembered 1210 from footage of Flying Scotsman's Australian visit 😌
Most likely a JNR C62 (They were built for primarily passenger duties during WW2.) or a modified E2 with an extended coal bunker, flat running board and a mixed-traffic boiler.
A New York Elevated Line Forney. I think that the bunker full of coal would make firing easier.
My ideal miniature would have to be a 5” model of the biggest non-articulated locomotives on the Reading *BEFORE* the T-1s rolled out of the shops: The K1 2-10-2 Santa Fe type. That, or a 5” Reading G3 4-6-2 Pacific.
A fantastic video with so much technical engineering in miniature. Quite a competition. Cheers Chris.
Amazing work Chris. Well done and thank you for bringing the competition to YT.
Splendid account of what must've been a wonderful event...thank you so much, I loved it!
I really enjoyed seeing that, thank you. Now must find time to get our Polly back in running order
A beautiful special! Thank you. Your cinematography is spot on.
This just shows how powerful steam is
Right 💪🏾💪🏾
9:03 side note, one was briefly preserved. 9875 Midlothian was rebuilt for preservation in... 1937 i think...? Anyways, in 1939, due to the metal shortage in Britain, it was scrapped again.
Out of all the miniature locomotives in this competition, the LNER Gresley 'P1' Class 2-8-2 No. 2393 is my favourite as this locomotive's design was outlined for Ravenglass & Eskdale Railway's No. 9 "River Mite". It's great to see these lovely little engines in action especially as minimum gauge locomotives are very close to my heart. :)
44:54 still that little engine pulling roughly 1.7tonnes for 1.7km on ~630g of coal is impressive.
Dads wd . First imlec with it . Learnt a lot and done him proud as took him 18 yrs to build
Thanks for a fantastic video, really good to see and hear the stories behind the people & loco's. Looking forward to next year :-)
A really wonderful edition of SLIPs. Thank you Chris. I’d love to have time and skill to make one of these wonderful scale locomotives.
Can u do this every year from now on please
I was absolutely glued to this!
I could only wonder how a large scaled Hunslet would do competitively...🤔😂
a competition on steam live steamers !!! It's worth seeing this. Congratulations to everyone, thank you very much for the video you are the geniuses of steam !!! !!
This was an absolutely brilliant film!! Please do this again ☺️
Honestly would love to see this in person. I was rooting for the large freight (goods) engines to at least get somewhere near the top
Brilliant Chris, just brilliant. Enjoyed every minute of this 'different' SLIPs. More please in the same vein - model steam loco engineering. Though not necessarily as a competition. Perhaps about some of the miniature engineering aspects and interviews with builders? Nice change, though.
Well that was fantastic!! Let’s hope that a really good locomotive won the competition!!
29:08
“Still, 90 mph is cruising speed for an A4”
Flying Scotsman: Ahem! I went 100 mph!
Mallard: AHEM! I did 126 mph!
PRR T1 5550: I will do….
Sorry T1, you will not do any speed records in 2030
Just want to point out the Mallard went downhill
One can hope 5550 will attempt speed records, but with Amtrak and CSX being, well, themselves, it's doubtful at best.
@@electrik_loss no just no
Steam locomotive world speed record breaking in the 21st century is now redundant.
Just use PRR T1 5550 on mainline excursions…..nothing else.
If steam locomotives go beyond the safe speed of 75 mph (121 km/h), trouble with the crews can hav consequences
@@nathanchan4653 aye I don’t really want they are thinking
I actually would prefer that 5550 not attempt any record breaking. I meant the "one can hope" as "oh maybe someone hopes that 5550 would break the world steam speed record", sorry if that caused any confusion. I'm happy with Mallard staying at the top.
That was GOOD. Sad tales, high drama, A a very clever juxtaposition of 2 Riddles 2-10-0s (Yes, we noticed...). and by Gad what a beast that P2 is....Looking forward to seeing the 12" / Ft model ! Thanks to all involved for a great Hr+ of entertainment .
Great work as always. Perhaps something to consider is a grand tour of miniature Railways and clubs across the UK?
Brilliant production! Beautiful models. Must go see for real one day soon.
Lovely to see a Southern U Class model!! An absolute stunner!!
Great stuff, thanks Chris. I remember when it was held at Bedford MES waay back.
I wonder how the efficiency characteristics compare with the full size locos.
I've been wondering what the name of that music that started around 8:30
Really enjoyable. Well done Chris and team. Top quality.
Well this was more interesting then I initially thought it was going to be. What a nice little film you put together here. Each machine was an sight to behold and each seemed to be an excellent examples of engineering. That two of these engineers had passed on is very sad to hear, but hopefully their lovely little engines will remain as examples of their skills and of the men themselves. Shame the Southern competitors didn't do well though...
And so young too in Karl’s case
It all reminds me of old photos of Walt Disney's model railroad, especially that one where he's hauling Salvador Dalí around.
I know the gentleman who owns that 4mt Ben was running, the owner has told me all about the amount of work ben has put into it... needless to say my jaw hit the floor when I heard about all the little things he had to do to it to get it running right.
A real credit to him and his work.
This railways in Maidstone I’ve been there a few months ago
What was the reason for the scaled Tanker and Guard's Van on the back of the train?
The tanker was dripping degreaser on the rails to help maintain a clean track for all competitors. The guards van provided an extra pair of axles to brake up any grease that may be there.
I've often wondered how something like a Stirling Single would do at IMLEC, the large diameter driving wheels should mean rather low steam consumption since they'll run at a lower rpm, but I imagine the lack of tractive effort and thus lack of passenger load, would be the biggest hamper.
You'd have to be very light on the fire to make up for it, and that's the other aspect that makes IMLEC interesting. Driver skill makes nearly as much a difference as the engine itself, as you need to balance using as little coal as you can, against risking a blowup, every shovel you toss in the fire lowers your score, so you really need to think about if you really need that shovel. And a good grasp of throttle regulation goes a long way in preventing wheel slips and wasting more steam.
Judging efficiency over just raw power and speed is definitely a more skill based competition.
A Stirling single has won in the past. It’s not about how much you pull, it’s how efficiently you pull it.
@@TomsWorkshop42 I'm aware, my whole comment is talking about how judging by efficiency over raw power is neat, _however_ bigger loads give you an advantage.
If two engines burn the same amount of coal going the same distance, but one is pulling twice as much weight as the other, it has done more work with its coal and thus is much more efficient.
Which is why I said with a Stirling you have to be very light on coal usage to make up for the lack of loading. It's neat to hear one won though, must've been a really skilled engineer to make the most out of every shovel.
33:26 Why am I being reminded of certain Thomas episodes?
Your best film by far. More model engineering please!
Fantastic video. A sort of model railway meets robot wars. Brilliant idea, really well executed.
Although it would probably to hugely expensive and just massive in general, i wonder if a narrow gauge loco like the ffestiniog farlies or whr garrats would perform well in imlec
This locomotive is a fantastic piece of kit!! Pretty, easy to drive and a very good little locomotive!!
Deep down was rooting for the glorious Apollo to win. Karl made a bloody good engine. RIP.
Love it Chris, well done :)
I definitely wouldn’t win the efficiency awarded. 😂
Man that atlantic on its first try just chugged along nicely and cute