Is it time for PNG to enter an NRL team? Inside the 10: Sunday Footy Show | NRL on Nine
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 22 июл 2023
- On Inside the 10, Danika Mason and the Sunday Footy Show panel discuss whether a Papua New Guinean NRL team is imminent, look at Jarome Luai's future, and look at who should host the NRL Grand Final. Subscribe 👉 bit.ly/2lvAJT2 NRL News👉 bit.ly/2mPWIV9
NRL on Nine is the home of everything rugby league so stayed tuned for more NRL highlights, analysis, opinion and video.
Watch NRL LIVE and FREE: www.9now.com.au/nrl-premiersh...
Facebook: / nrlonnine
Instagram: / nrlonnine
TikTok: www.tiktok.com/@nrlonnine?lan...
Twitter: / nrlonnine
#NRLonNine #WideWorldofSports #NRL Спорт
as a papua new guinean myself i dont think we have the grassroots or pathways or proper infrastructure.......until we get our pathways and grassroots set up proper i think we still far away
PNG is already going downhill as a country.
Yeah it would be great for the game and for PNG, it's just the logistics of it is the real issue.
Blah blah who cares
Well said. What happens when players are injured or suspended . You need the young fellas coming thru the ranks to step in. The nrl would also need to help build stadium and training facilities as well.
It's more about geo politics via sports. The PNG bid need not be like any other NRL club.
The Nrl really need to do something in PNG and if they don't have proper pathways they need to make it happen now. As we all know Rugby League is PNG's number sport
Justin Olam made it clear, yes we will have an NRL team sometime in the future BUT not Now. Our good PNGRL need to step up developing jnr pathway system inorder to have a greater pool of player coming into the system. We need more work in getting our house in order before taking this step. PNG will definitely field a team in the NRL sometime in the future, thats for sure. Australian govt must be very careful as we need a quality side that could actually win NRL matches, be successful as a professional rugby league team and a well oiled busines entity. That should be the foundamental objective.
Too much politics involved already, the Aussie govt are against the clock to stabilize geo political relationships between PNG and Australian. The last I checked from 60mins Australia, The chiness are building airports and wharves in the western province which is not far from Darwin.
Take note NRL, Politics will ruin the NRL we use to love.
👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
olam is not png rl thats his personal opinion he should talk negetive where the can do attitude he better win games for png for starts put in more take the lead not take a backseat
They need to do more for NZ.
500 players a year leave NZ according to Tony Kemp.
Who tf is Tony kenp
New Zealand needs a second club, and the NRL needs to be divided into two conferences: North and South. Half of the Sydney clubs should be in North and the other half in South. NZ's North Island and the PNG club will be in the North conference, and NZ's South Island will be in the South conference.
cant be that greedy its the nrl not nz league lol@@poppinc8145
A team in the South Island would be nice so that NZ have two clubs, I hear that there's rich history in rugby league there around the Christchurch area if I'm not wrong.
PNG already has a rugby league system in place which is being improved. From what I have read, PNGRFL is working on establishing game structures, performance development and management, coaching, and training within existing PNG Rugby League paths to the QCup PNG Hunters, and PNG Kumuls including Junior Kumuls through the School Boys rugby league system which is being revived. Look at the available talents in the Digicel Cup, PNG Hunters, PNGs in other QCup teams, and PNGs in Super League, with some in NRL teams. That's evidence of investment over years of commitment.
With both government supports, PNG will eventually have an NRL team, backed by PNG LNG and PNG investers.
Yes, there will always be negative rugby politics, public politics, and government politics around PNG NRL bid.
Don't forget, It's just rugby league right? But it brings nations together right?
So where's sportmanship in all the talks?
The PNG NRL bid is being processed thoroughly by all stake holders to mitigate risks.
So bloody let the bid be processed till an end result is evident.
PNG NRL TEAM A must.
I have lived in Cairns Qld and seen lost of PNG, Fijians, Tongans, Samoans and TI mixed kids who playing in college or suburban teams. It's a great opportunity for this kids to play in the PNG NRL team in future. Down in Brisbane Suburbs there lots of PNG and pacific Islands playing in college teams plus intrust and feeder clubs through out Brisbane and Goal Coast and Townsville as well.
There should be a program of selected schoolplayers of PNG and pacific Islands be travelling to PNG for comp
NRLPA would disagree
Luai isn't worth $1M
No but there's few clubs that would becuase there ain't that much quality halves and whether you like luai or not he is a quality player yes not a million but i say around 750k minuim- 850k
He's a grub just like Ennis was
@jacobmurphy423 he's really not though. He rarely turns up. When he's on, he's on but its not often enough. I pitty the team that signs him next..
Gus Gould has been going around to different NSW prisons attempting to recruit inmates for the Bulldogs. I hear the dogs are gonna throw Jarryd Hayne a bone once he's finished his rape bid.
@@kers225abk2 I massively disagree with you, luai is a great 5/8, he passes and actually gives outside backs good quality ball, good ball runner, really good in defence, i agree he isn't a 1mill player but you forgot about he took Samoa into a wc final, don't underestimate how good luai is, you need to have a 5/8 that can distribute the ball really well, alot of halves are so one dimensional because they don't have a great ball playing but as a five eight you need to be able create
I think if they want to have the Grand Final in Brisbane I know we have Suncorp / Lang Park but we really need a bigger stadium to house more spectators
QLD government's building a new Olympic stadium at the Gabba soon. 😉
@@AJWRAJWRand kicking out the kids! Stuff their education!
We have QEII stadium that just needs to be reinvested in and rejuvinated. It could comfortably hold 80,000+ and be adjustable depending on whether its needed for league or athletics.
@@AJWRAJWRthat has no added seats
🤣🤣 hay you know it and we are the only one love your footy game prepare what needs to prepare coz once we enter nrl stadium would be one of my house🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Love these videos
Surely a second NZ team
Nah, if they do there needs to be proper pathways and resources to be able to create and maintain a quality team. Not just for them to battle for last place with the tigers.
PNG is way too third world for it to be viable. Why not just setup a grassroots/feeder system for PNG talent with the NQ Cowboys?
And Melbourne isn't They can't even run a Commonwealth Games
I think they have a reserve grade club in the QLD cup but it’s not a feeder club. Makes sense for it to be a feeder club for the Cowboys
yeah when jus recently gained independence from oz because of looting free for all resource grabs by oz companies u want example look @ bougainville u want stale waters put in a wa team heart of afl team eagles&docker grow the game out of oz for once cant be backwards @this day &age lol
we know really goin on there lol one man.....@@BenWick-oc8pv
Random PNGn here, pretty sure most of us are happy with the QRL Hunters as our team for a NRL feeder... what about Perth?
speaking of pride so a team would be even better
Almost a quarter of the teams are now from qld so it would make sense to play a grand final at suncorp once every 4 years
em now makim sense na dollars yah 🤓
Yes yes ❤❤❤❤ I agree ☝️ 🎉🎉🎉
Maybe a Polynesian team, or a melanesian team would be a better choice...
I would like to see a secod tier competiton with PNG, North Sydney, Ipswich, Cairns, Newtown and a second NZ team to name a few. For example. Maybe a Perth team and Pacific Island team.
It would hold enough relevance and prestige to attract fans and corporate money and then when the time comes to bring in another team the best suiter from that comp is ready to be promoted. If not promtoed they stay but still compete and learn how to operate as a proftiable and competivie organisation until then.
That competition would bring in about 8 cents and cost more then the NRL
There already is. They play before the NRL Grand Final every year
@@BenWick-oc8pv thats one game which is a little shorter than a season. I think?
@@piritekanawa They play a whole season. The winners of the NSW comp then play the QLD comp winners on Grand Final day. PNG are in the QLD comp
@@BenWick-oc8pvmy bad. I didn't realise that all the teams from the NSW cup and QLD cup played each other during the year up until that game.
The problem is who is going to fund the team if it were to happen? Cost of flights for home games would be insane.
I personally would say that, do not underestimate PNG's ability when it comes to NRL.
Most PNG indigenous players are naturally talented and they played rugby for their life since rugby was introduced to png. Only if NRL give them an opportunity to play in such high pressured games i personally think that they can withstand that because NRL is a national recognized sport in the country and every boys play rugby just like any other fun sports.
Just give them that chance and see what they can produce on the NRL level.
Money can make anything happen, Put your money where your mouth is.. Those PNG critics can go chew your buai and dream. Let's make it happen for NRL Bid.
Jerome has a baby to support now! Do you know how much baby formula costs? 🧑🏻🦲🤔
No. We need a team in Perth… I’m pretty sure they love their nrl over there too.. put another origin in Perth to boost popularity
why not make nrl bigger nsw fans are bored so add some more png wa and a new nz if the fans want it let em have it
Luai is statistically average as a half. Definitely not worth 1 million as he also doesn't organise his teams
Organise Samoa to a World Cup Final!
@@BrettGrady-vf4kx Where he lost by a mile against England and then again in the final hahahahahahahahahahaha. 'Leading' an international team vs an NRL team are very different as well. The guy is an objectively average five eighth.
@@zaneplatt3533 did you not see the game today? Again was outstanding.
@@BrettGrady-vf4kx Huh? Still doesn't organise a team and is still statistically middle of the pack... Middle of the pack halves still have good games mate
@@zaneplatt3533 3 premierships, and leading a 2nd tier nation to WC final over the tournamentvwhere he was outstanding suggests otherwise
Why not 👍👍
Thinking Luai is one of the most despised players in the comp.
Terrible idea to put a team in PNG. No one would want to play for them/live there. They don't have feeder clubs, good stadiums. Why is a second NZ team never talked about? They live and breath rugby
It’ll be in talks when warriors win atleast 5 prems
Yes! Bring in the Wellington Orcas
terrible comment what u worried about lol
Png are u serious
They are at least 20 yrs behind
A stupid suggestion
wrong paced has moved up now biggest opportunity what a stupid think to say @nagibkanaan
🤦
The NRL has to bring in the PNG Hunters into the competition at some point. As Rugby League is the national sport of Papua New Guinea, which will mean an infinite surplus of loyal and passionate fans.
However, the NRL would need to assist the Hunters with Junior Pathway Programs, Team Infrastructure, Player Recruitment, etc.
So it will probably be a while before the Hunters make their NRL debut, but it's something that has to happen at some point fairly soon.
They should build more in Melbourne's, imagine a Melbourne's local derby.
He will be going to the Tigers.
If it is, the team ahould be based in Australia. Our country is not ready for it.
lol opportunity knocks should u back off say no think big not small be a man grab the bull by horns cobber
Be good for Both PNG and Australia for them to have a team not just the NRL.
Closer bonds through sport are the way to great friendships..
yeah but they bring no TV revenue...their country has no GDP comparable to, say, Perth or NZ.
Yep and Madge to coach!
@@turbodewd1 you can still have WA or NZ..
Just get rid of West's tigers simple....
Your exactly right,PNG is a strong ally of Aust,PNG are rugby league mad, they are deserving of opportunity to enter NRL and there is the mutual benefit of enhancing national security
@@turbodewd1 Corpoarate sponsorship from Mining companies would easily float venture. Do you think Melbourne Storm are in the NRL because they have a massive audience of Victorians tuning in?
People need to actually look at this realistically and not just by what sounds good on paper. Firstly this is purely a political stunt. Secondly the infrastructure, grassroots pathways and resources in PNG is lacking significantly and needs time and more importantly $$ to develop. Thirdly consider average income per household, TVs per household, demographics and ratings etc. Yes rugby league is the #1 sport in PNG but that doesn't mean it'll equate to success especially when you consider the ceiling for financial growth - very, very low compared to other places like Perth, NZ2 etc. Even if you based that team out of QLD, you might as well just award a license for a 5th QLD team which would guarantee more $$, more TV ratings, more pathways etc. Love for PNG but the fact we're even talking about this proposal over other cities is nonsense. Give them time to build and invest more into Pasifika rugby league then we can come back to this convo.
Give a trial to PNG.
Just like Western Reds or Adelaide Rams were trial out and did not have the money to continue.
Money may not be a problem with Government backup here in PNG.
I don't think PNG should have a team in a NRL we got long way to go
opportunity knocks should u walk away say no lol strike while the irons hot
next team should be in NZ. New Zealand, like Brisbane, should have NRL played there every weekend
They can barely support one team. Don't need another one
@@ethanriice8456 the Warriors are third on the ladder and selling out their stadium so how do you figure that? The Tigers and dragons have struggled for a decade, does that mean all Sydney clubs are doomed?
Not every league supporter in NZ follows the warriors, a local derby would help them out too. A second league team in NZ is a no brainer and would be a hit to a rugby union code which is struggling over there at the moment
@@tast7017yep and let Kiwi's coach Madge coach them.
@tast7017 warriors are inconsistent. And I agree numbers are up this year, numbers before covid barely hit half full.. maybe this is just NZ going out since they missed alot during covid?
When warriors don't play well the numbers are down.. 2 teams would hurt them. Do they even have a decent local league??
Sydney teams suck too, too many..
Just my opinion, need a new market before entering a NZ market that is very up and down..
Definitely New Zealand next. They have planned it out already. It would be based in Wellington and called The Orcas.
Spending money on housing and l don't think the pm will be around to much longer
Of course the NRL need to do something it will further justify the commentators' existences.
PNG Not enough money and too much politics involved. Go with a pacifika team.
This is Australia's move to counter Chinese growing footprint, massive money pumped in and massive quality infrastructure being built in PNG. Australia's motive is not a good one so forget it.why so suddenly after PNGs delegation attended Belt and Road Initiative in Beijing? PNG should just decouple from Western influence and seek real development from countries with a clear motive and not politics
why is Gus Warland on the panel?
if rubgy is their national sport why don't they have their own league
They do😂😂 simple thing called google
ask the pm of oz also for the growth of the game against afl money talks lol
Just Make a Pacific team or Perth team 👏
The stadiums are half empty. Expanding would mean more empty stadiums and lower quality games. People are sick of these 44-6 score lines. The game is crap. What they should do is bring in a perth team, an Adelaide team, and merge 4 clubs into 2 in nsw.
lol now thats a brillant thinking lol...
not
PNG has stillto get their priorities right. Their mindset is not in the right place.
better get their mind asap or yuse miss out olam is not a real leader needs to contribute to pngrl hes too big to help others succeed aye🙄
Bring in the Hunters
Attacking the head is illegal in Rugby League!😁
hunters get sold out to clubs starting fresh with new team new coach new players or ex players lol
There are far more demanding social and economic issues that needs to be taken care of in PNG rather than pushing for a PNG NRL team that will cost us PNGeans tax payers millions every year to fund their trip (to and fro Aussie) and salary.
They wouldn’t ever get close to a win , with the players they currently have
easy to say we dont know hows it gunna go down all it is is the opportunity knocks what should u do say no and walk off lol
The plantation mentality permeates fabric of the political structure of our nation.
PNG can play ping pong ✅🇨🇳
What's that suppose to mean
@@darylkanofski9327
Australia gives alot of support to PNG
If they want to make allegiance to China they can play ping pong
And not receive any aid from Australia 🇦🇺 Anymore
I hope that's clear
@beautifulsydney and have china 100kms away from mainland Australia? Your bloodline won't last another generation
yer with a oval shaped ball lol
@@ethanriice8456 China hasn't once ever invaded a country in their history over 5000 years
Luai is not capable of carrying a team 🤣 yes he made it to a world cup final but that was on the back of other Samoan superstar's at NSW he done bugger all for them in his game time there
Why is it the nrl job to do diplomacy on behalf of the government
National Rugby League, means our nation ,not other country's.
Instead of investing and spending all that money , for another nation to play Rugby league, invest in our game , in other states and raise the profile and standard for a true national comp.
Wanted 2 million sports loving peeps, to pledge 50 bucks each to create and implement a full competition in SA, 8 team comp, complete with main sports hub club.
I will pledge a grand to start
The Australian government is not going to spend millions of dollars on the NRL expanding to Adelaide
@@flaminjamin For a start, the Australian Government is a business , registered in the US.
The same as the NRL, a business
No one is asking for the "Government" to spend anything as all that goes overseas to the share holders and why would they?
If you read my comment, i asked for a pledge from sporting peeps, so where was the mention of the traitors masquerading as a government to spend money?
@@kinchegayowie6167LOL The Australian Government is a business,I’ve heard it all now. They wouldn’t be investing in PNG RL if they were a business. The reason they did this is so they could issue bonds in The US if the need ever arose.
@@nevilleapple629 yeh reckon do you, research the topic champ. look on Dunn & Bradstreet, while your there , look up every state government, council ,cops and see what you get .
There hasn't been a sovereign government since 1973 , ya nong , and since 1999 , the has been no sovereign countries either .
There is a document called the Clearfield Doctrines read it , get educated and then get some tinea cream for your massive gob as your feet will be sticking out it
Psssst Santa is not real, sorry
And let China move on PNG and pose a national security risk? Ok you clown!
My personal opinion as PNGean, I feel PNG preparation is not up to a standard to put up an NRL team yet. The whole move behind this is more political than on merit.
All we need is the funds from the government
18 nrl team to enter nrl team is png the question is up png government and Australian government depends on fund s
How are they going to competitive as a team if they are only going to use pacific players
Other teams in the nrl can take players from anywhere
How is a limited player pool going to be competitive over a long run against a teams that have an open pool of players to pick from
How are they going to attract talent from Sydney Melbourne Gold Coast and Brisbane
Hey want to come play reserves in our third world nation
Leave representative football
do a trade with png they can have an nrl team and us australians can have all their minerals
Imperialism!
nah australians..they don't use their minerals anyway so win win@@S.M.A.W.K
where was u preworld war two lol aus was there ripping the gold out of png flatout for yrs matey thats why it gained independence from wait for oh oz bugger me suprise suprise go read the history books again🤣
png is still poor and can't have their own league comp@@dusmangi
it maybe poor u looking in seeing only people inthe cities most of population lives in rural grow their own food fish hunt & have land being mined from they dont have social welfare like getting benifits from gov or depend on families share money food ect unlike oz if the system goes down tomorrow what r people going to do u see it but dont get the pacific way of life they depend on nature mining royalities r also kicking in so clans have income only thoes in cities r the losers wondering round robbing people its all about tribal & land were as oz its all crown own land lol u understand mate@@dutchvanderlinde2488
1:28 what's chamas on about. Jerome Luai is signed for the Tigers next year. This guy is hopeless
click bait description
I think it's about time we need png an others to join the competition for sure do it
No. Next question
Why not give png a team and let them base in QLD..PNG have the highest league fan than any other country
There's no point having a team here.. it needs to be based in PNG so fans up there can support from the grandstands
nothins for free gotta ask nicely and put sum koins inthe piggy bank then play like bigboys do inthe nrl lol
We have enough bongo’s
A big No for PNG. Need to fix up its PNG hunters and local comp before even thinking about it.
why not while opportunities knocks are walking away from a lifetime gig good for the game and people
Not ready maybe in 15 years time... PNG has zero school boys and pathways systems, no academy for coaching, referrees and trainers. Players welfare during injuries and life after football. Better League administrators.
Referee's and player welfare will be under the nrl so not to worry..
Coaching staff can easily be formed, look at adrian lam, doing wonders in london, im sure he will be the first to put his hands up..
Only issue is proper rugby programs from under 10 up.. government needs to start sponsoring 12 to 15yr olds to come to aus for highschool and rugby progams. Will help develop, and in the mean time start a grass roots program to pick out the good ones
No way PNG...
then we all can sleep in the park
Imagine paying 1mil for luai anyone doing that is not right in the head
There are nicer places to live than Penrith
Luai should come to Dolphins 🤝
Koapim dolphin you asskan
Ew.. dolphins wouldn't want him.
PNG won't happen, but they'll keep talking about it just for something to talk about
never say never now didnt papa always tell ya 🤣
This segment used to be a highlight of the show. Too much time wasted on arguing rather than expressing views, weak topics selected to discuss and too often spending too much time on one issue. Sterlo come back!!!!!!
Do not put them in Australia RL,,waste of money and they are still underdevelop
international Rugby League lol
It won't work
never say nver
PNG will be a financial disaster for the league. Perth is obvious choice and majority of teams feel the same way.
Laui not worth a million
Its got to his head
Thats why people hate him
Its all politics no real Intension here
Luai is a 60k player max
60k over 3 seasons
@LifeSlushie minus all costs to have him at the club including any water he drinks or grass repairs after he stands on it
It’s called national rugby league why not a English team bring back the bears
lol what good will that do lol
Nope, axe the Tigers and go back to 16 teams.
Luai mate come to the Storm 😅
You joking 😂
why you need luai you have Munster and hughes 😂
We have a spot for him on the bench 😅
do a swap with olam
No
Put the national in national rugby league first
Bring back the north Sydney bear
Have Perth miners blue and gold (west coast eagle colours)
Adelaide rave navy blue red ( crows colours)
Darwin crocs blue orange
Hobart blue tongue maroon blue
South Brisbane lions yellow brown (east tigers)
Christchurch paladins white gold black (new
Orleans saints)
Pacific cup teams
Australia
New Zealand
PNG
Samoa
Tonga
Cook Islands
Fiji
USA
Pacific cup starts after Super Bowl
Nrl la starts after pacific cup
You’re welcome
The NRL shouldn't get involved in geopolitics. Expand for the right sporting & business reasoning - not government driven sinophobia.
So you get punished for developing players over 10 years and winning
That's the beauty of the salary cap. Except the roosters.
Australia has been ignoring PNGs bid for a long time. Our team in the Queensland Cup is not a feeder team so most of our talent that are way better than current NRL players don't enter the NRL. Our players have deliberately overlooked unlike other Polynesian players. This is just a political move in response to China's growing footprint in PNG. China has spent more money and built more better quality infrastructure than Australia has done. PNG should ingnore this bid and Ask China to pump money into creating a more professional commercialized comp in PNG and receruit it other Pacific Islanders to play like what Soccer has done. Too much underestimating by Westerners and we're tired of it. Why na yumi ronron bihain lo ol waitman stap
good point but the last thing u want in png is a big giant of a country coming in buying up everything and bringing their people into png with briberies it will be another colony of chine all over agan png dont need this its been thru enuff as it is this so call new deal or bid mite be a good start png has history with oz& u.s chyna is unknow territory they r corrupting and holding africa to ransom by their resources u look @ Vanuatu solomons isle theres your answer their pm jus sole their to chyna lol
Luai is overrated
👎👎👎👎
games gotta move on cobber into the next big thing lol
Player safety
Wtf no way ,New Zealand has the biggest talent be good to counter rugby as well .
lol afl still wins hands down cant be that greedy has warriors ever won the gf yet?lol
I believe there should be 9 teams in QLD & 9 teams in NSW then 2 teams in every other state, Example:
----------------------------------------
*NSW Inner-City*
_Eastern City Tigers_
_North Sydney Eels_
_West Sydney Bulldogs_
_East Sydney Roosters_
_South Sydney Rabbitohs_
----------------------------------------
*NSW Outter-City*
_East Coast Sharks_
_North NSW Knights_
_Central NSW Panthers_
_South NSW Dragons_
----------------------------------------
*QLD Inner-City*
_Northern City Dolphins_
_North Brisbane Wolves_
_West Brisbane Cheetahs_
_East Brisbane Broncos_
_South Brisbane Jets_
----------------------------------------
*QLD Outter-City*
_North Coast Titans_ (Partnership PNG)
_North QLD Cowboys_
_Central QLD Capras_
_South QLD Magpies_
--------------------------------------------
*Victoria*
_Melbourne City Storm_
_Central Victoria Lions_
----------------------------------------------
*South Australia*
_South Coast Sea Eagles_
_Southern City Rams_
-----------------------------------------
*West Australia*
_West Coast Bears_
_Western City Reds_
--------------------------------------
*ACT / Tasmania*
_Canberra Raiders_
_Hobart Steelers_
--------------------------------------
*New Zealand*
_Auckland Warriors_
_Christchurch Braves_ (Partnership Samoa)
_Wellington Vikings_ (Partnership Tonga)
_Hamilton Crushers_ (Partnership Fiji)
----------------------------------------------------
Split into 2 Conferences
lol tasie are hobart team yeah rite inthe heart of afl territory sa had a chance they went sideways for the real growth of the game look outside the box cobber get the game out if its the grestest game of all cobber
PNG realistically would have a chance in the NRL after at least 2 decades..... Politicians shouldn't meddle in sport...Luai is a team performer,,, so is Cleary... Both highly overrated, they play well only around a high performance playing team....
Yes! Affirm. We want a PNG based team in NRL🫶🏾
Can base it in Kokopo as before when Hunters first joined QRL - great tourism there too.
want is another thing winning games week in week out is another think lol
Luai should come to Dolphins 🤝
god no please no
@@figgyzox he's coming