You know what? I do NOT think that Trevor is Lisa’s brother. I think that he was Lisa’s boyfriend/crush, judging by two cryptic tidbits stated by both he and Isabella…1) Isabella said something along the lines of she and Trevor creeping behind Lisa’s back to see each other and her finding out, with regard to, I guess, that fateful night and (especially) 2) Trevor made some smart arse remark to Isabella about history repeating itself with her having eyes for her BFF’s boyfriend. Whew!!! Her past is getting shadier and SHADIER…
I kinda think isabella still liked luke and back off because of megan's feelings. but everyone in the show lacks boundaries which kinda bugs me. Best friends who dated the same guy? mom dating daughter's bf dad?Also the mom bugs me so much she is so ridiculously nonchalant abt everything happening. Like is she ok? Its surprising it took her so long to realize her daughter needed a lawyer and with the tape and the pregnancy she is just so chill. Like why is that the case??
10:19 I, totally, agree!! It’s like Debbie is giving “awkward step-mother & step-daughter relationship ” energy with Megan, at times. I can’t even say she acts more like a “friend” with Megan because it looks like, even Isabella, woulda been more pressed about learning the same things about Megan than Debbie has been
Fun fact: Ned's screen name "CBABBAGE5" is a reference to Charles Babbage, who "originated the concept of a digital programmable computer," according to Wikipedia.
I love listening to your theories and recap - thank you!! Couple of things: 1) In 2000, we see Debbie taking medication for some kind of sickness that I don't think we've been disclosed on with the details. Maybe she is having some mental illness and not behaving/thinking/comprehending straight starting around the holidays of 1999. 2) I think that Luke has more secrets than the girls. In episode 1 he got out of the sheriff's car and said it was a ride along - but I wonder if he was working with the sheriff as an informant. He could have been spying on his dad or someone else and was getting caught. We saw the sheriff looking undercover in the bar in summer 1999.....there's definitely side stuff going on. The letter Luke left may have been a cover to the fact that he was really going into hiding but was murdered before he could leave. The girls may have witnessed it and that's what they are keeping secret. And the shock/stress could have caused Megan to have a miscarriage.
For what it's worth: Lisa's obit says she died on February 8th, 1999. Trevor says the last time he saw Isabella was "5 months ago" so that would have been at the time of the death when Isabella left the country. The news article says that Lisa was "a popular and respected student in Gustavia" and that she was enjoying time off with friends between semesters and that her death rocked the "tight knit community" so Lisa lived on the island and went to school there.
Soon as I’m done watching the episode I come straight to your reviews lol I definitely think Ned and Megan either had a relationship OR he SA’d her and that’s what made her do an 180 regarding her goth type style and piercings . I also think Luke found out about Ned and a fight happened at the cabin which led to the blood being on the floor. Also I do think Luke was alive and held in the cabin by Ned and Megan to scare him into keeping quiet (similar to season one). But I think Isabella being the “ride or d” she is figured she’d handle the situation for Megan by getting rid of Luke. And with Isabella best friend Lisa, I’m thinking it was accident that was probably Isabella fault because she was drunk . I don’t see her purposely offing her bestie and continue to write her letters unless she’s really a complete psychopath lol
I don't think they will repeat a theme from s1. The show runner just interviewed they went over things with a fine tooth comb not to overlap (the initially wanted to use a "necklace or bracelet" as a running theme.) Megan and Ned both have computer interest and skills. My guess is Ned is Megan's actual father and he figured it out and used a way to get close. I also think he and Megan are the ones in it deep re: Luke and Isabella is just a way to throw things off to the viewer.
anyone notice the tiny butterfly necklace that Megan wears in Summer 2109 and December 2019 but she’s not wearing it in Summer 2020? Also little sister had a butterfly necklace on- it was bigger than Megans. And Megan has a butterfly picture on the wall in her room. Not sure how butterflies could be a theme or whatever but I’ve been watching for it.
@@RockCityTumblers usually nothing but butterflies mean transformation, I think apple guy could be related, I also don't know why no one mentioned that she hact the feds, Meg was trying to do something for money I don't think with her Mom being a pregnant teen that she would keep baby
Love your recaps! For Lisa: Since it's established that Isabella and Trevor were sneaking around behind her back, maybe she found out about it when they were all drunk (Isa and Trev snuck off and she found them) and the girls got into an argument where Isa told Lisa to go away and she did, to the beach and drowned since she was intoxicated. Isa probably regretted what she said to Lisa and went to find her and thats what looked suspicious? For Megan: I think she told Luke about her pregnancy at New Years and he was telling her they need to get away to have it, but then Isa walked in and they got in a fight about her staying out of their business. They go to the cabin for more privacy, not knowing that Isa is following them. There Luke starts planning on faking running away to go somewhere to prepare for Megan to join him at a later time but then he asks whats up with her and the older dude and if the baby is really his ehich gets them in a fight and alerts the paranoid dude who goes over there and sees someone sneaking around the cabin (Isa) and shoots, grazing Luke. Isa tries to help by giving him pills to calm down ... and that's as much as I've got. For the mom: I think she doesn't act all mom-ish because Megan is also a provider in the house and she doesn't want to rock the boat and her stop helping.
@alison4dice I wonder if maybe it was a case of mistaken identity. How crazy would it be if the brother was the actual target. Maybe Megan and Isa were in cahoots with the Apple guy in the woods. They meant to get brother out, but Luke showed up instead, then 💥 BOOM! The wrong person is dead.🙁 🤨🤔🤫 Cover-up ensues... 😶
[Sorry about the HUGE text] I was just rewatching the show (because my boyfriend doesn't speak english so I was trying to translate for him) and I've been noticing how Megan seems jealous about Isabella. The first time Megan saw Isabella she already looked at her with such a jealous face, because she was waiting for a "freak" with no friends to show up, but turns out that Isabella was a hot chick with a very exciting life. There's also the part when Isabella was telling that she was born in NY but already lived in so many places around the world and we can see in Megan's face that she was jealous, also there's the fact that Megan never left the city and she hates it. I also think that the show is tricking us to think Isabella is the problem, but I trully beleive that what happened to Lisa was just an accident that resulted in a tragedy and Isabella kissed Trevor because she was scared about losing the new friends if he told them everything. Now about Megan, she gets really weird about Isabella's money and gifts, but I don't beleive this is just because of the prices, but because Megan wants to have Isabella's life, money, travellings, style, boyfirend... We already noticed that Megan changed her style and it looks more like what Isabella wears. And speaking of boyfriend, that thing about Megan telling she has feelings for Luke just right after Isabella and Luke did that thaaaaang... I don't buy it! I wouldn't be surprised if Megan turns out into a psych0 because of the friendship between Luke and Isabella. She could be faking a pregnancy to keep her relationship by thinking Luke was interested in Isabella. The blood in the sheets could be Luke's blood because of a fight or something even worse. I think Megan's relationship with Ned has some very shady motive, maybe it's related to selling s3x tapes in the dark web (I think Luke's father and brother are responsible for recording it) and maybe Ned was the one who leaked the tape with Megan and Luke on it (because Ned has some inappropriate feelings for Megan). I just don't trust Megan at all.
My guess is Megan got pregnant with Ned’s baby, Luke found out and things spiraled out from there. As to who pulled the trigger or drowned? I guess we’ll see! Love this show and its twists
I keep wondering if maybe Luke did it to himself. Like he took the drugs to calm his nerves and then because of the drugs or because he changed his mind he missed with the gun only grazing himself. He possibly could have wondered out to the water and fallen in due to the drugs and head injury. The girls may have known or been involved somehow and that's what they're covering up. I also wonder if maybe this could all have something to do with Y2K since it happened on January 1st. Idk
That’s what I’m thinking cuz first episode they dropped he rlly doesn’t wanna follow in his dads footsteps and the whole twist w grooming in season one, the creators of the show said they wanna talk about something important w this season too if it’s suicide or drug use that’s what I’m thinking
I've been coming here after I watch the episodes. This show does keep you guessing just like in season 1. I think there's a possibility that neither Megan or Isabella killed him. However, I think Ned is suspicious. Maybe Lukes dad because Luke didn't want to follow in his footsteps.
9:20 not to be petty, but this isn’t the first time I’ve noticed them using terms that were created (I believe) AFTER this time period- I don’t think “girl code” was really a mainstream saying back in the 99 and the 2000…and I, also, heard Isabella say “cray-cray” (aka crazy) regarding the cabin guy…and I KNOW that term wasn’t created until the late 2000s, if not, the 2010s
I thought the same thing about cray cray. And what is the deal with the matrix? Does Megan have multiple personalities or something? Maybe she “woke up” on Y2k(?)
@@RockCityTumblers exactly!! I was like, “😒😒😒 REALLY, show writers??” Like, HOW did y’all even THINK of incorporating the term “cray-cray” WITHOUT a SLEW of people bringing up how that was nowhere NEAR created?? As far as The Matrix references?? Aside from it being a groundbreaking movie around that time, I can only figure that they kept focusing on it as a plot device to show the audience, through Isabella’s eyes, how “made for each other” Megan and Luke were, by having them BOTH referencing it
@@sammidizzle5599 Maybe the show writers are trying the inception route- which came first- cray cray in the REAL world or cray cray in the cruel summer world… Or we are still in the matrix and everything taste like chicken 🤷♀️🥄
@@RockCityTumblers yes ..luke and meg are also endgame was not what would say in 99/2000 now cray cray I kinda remember making that slang with scary movies or like older sibling or cousin when you were acting up like boy don't get cray-cray, still think jeff and meg would make the matrix jokes since he was film buff... I dont know if you seen ep 6 yet but I was getting scream 1 vibes
Why would Debbie be “raging mad” at Megan for having sex, having a sex tape made of her without her consent and released without her consent, and for getting pregnant? And why would she even think about disciplining her? She didn’t do anything wrong. Megan is the victim here and it seems that all her mom wants to do is support her, like a good parent should.
Isabella and Lisa probably got into a fight over Trevor. Lisa might have drunk and fell into the water and accidentally drowned but Isabella leaving made her suspect number one in the case.
Theory: Trevor is Lisa. Isabella is bisexual and into threesomes. Isabella and Lisa were together and Lisa wanted to transition into Trevor. Isabella and Lisa had a third partner who drowned, which was Isabella's fault but was an accident (Isabella had been drinking). Lisa/Trevor (who has transphobic parents) realizes that this is her/his chance to disappear forever in his/her new identity. He blackmails Isabella into identifying the body as Lisa and in return, Trevor will hide the fact that this other death was Isabella's fault. When Isabella tells Trevor "We should have told Lisa," she is referring to Lisa/Trevor's mother, who is also named "Lisa." At the beginning of this episode, when Isabella is writing to "Lisa" she remarks that the "three" of them together would be awesome (a reference to threesomes). When she says this, she looks at the picture of her, Megan and Luke. Isabella was hoping to recreate a threesome with Megan and Luke, that's why she's cozying up to both of them. It was Isabella who made the sex tape, because they were all having sex together. Cruel Summer likes having edgy themes/relationships. This one will have a trans character, bisexuality and threesomes.
@@truthtalker3498 I can believe Isabella to be bisexual. Maybe Isabella just wanted to both Trevor or Lisa but Lisa didn’t want that. Now that Megan and Luke are together, she wants them both too
@@Lboogie0711 I definitely think that a threesome (or foursome with Jeff? or Ned?) is part of the plot (now and in Isabella's past) and that Isabella made the sex tape (that's also why her sweater is in the video). It could have been consensual and Luke kept it and Brent found it and played it at the party to take his brother down a peg out of jealousy. Remember that scene of Megan and Isabella dancing sexy together at the Christmas party and Luke checking both of them out? Also, I just got a "Trevor is Lisa" vibe when he was interacting with Isabella. Like in Season One when Anabel was a bait and switch. I think "Lisa" is, too. Or Trevor was Lisa's boyfriend, not brother. Trevor does say, referring to Isabella getting with Luke..."a guy your best friend's close to? Yeah, I've seen that movie before."
I wasn’t sure at first, but after seeing this episode, Ned definitely has something to do with Luke’s death. I also think that Megan had a secret relationship with Ned and he possibly found out about Luke, and decided to kill him.
Nah, just because he's different and is uncomfortable around people doesn't make him weird or a murderer. I think he's a big nerd and he wants to help Megan learn coding. We'll see LOL!
Also what happened to Megan’s sister ? She’s barely in the episodes anymore. What’s up with that ? I wonder if they kind of showing us that the person who hurted luke isn’t being shown that much ?
I agree- I think the little sister is pregnant. Especially since Megan was worried that “she’d get a reputation”. Also- something happened to Megan in the 4th grade that caused her ridicule from the town for a long time. I wonder if it had something to do with her sister- which causes Megan to be overly cautious and responsible now.
I don’t know it someone’s said this but… why is the younger sister hardly in the show? Any theories if something happened to her? I know the last time she was mentioned she was at Olivia’s sleepover… but physically not seeing her & not seeing how she’s reacting to things makes me wonder…
I honestly don't think the little sister is important to the plot at all. I think they just have her there to show why Megan needs to make money and support the family because it's not just her she's supporting but her sister.
Also in the 2 truths, 1 lie- Luke said he had a pen pal in California. And Isabella might be a sleepwalker (?) They weren’t really clear about which of her 3 tales was the lie.
When I saw the cabbage thing I thought it was an adult but a different one I thought it was Luke’s father and Meghan and him were sneaking around idk why I went there in my head
I kind of feel like Isabella is obsessive with her besties. So, I think maybe her and Megan caused the death, or Isabella believes Megan is guilty and was covering for her anyway. It just might be a killer from left field. But, if Luke caused his own death by accident, I would be disappointed with the writers.
I think that Ned was hiding Luke until Isabella told luke about the pregnancy and the baby being Neds and luke confronted ned and got shot she tried to break it up and had a miscarriage. Luke feels guilty runs to Isabella she gives him pills they go to the water he gets shot at jumps in the water and drowns. Thats my theory and nay be why everyone feels guilty
I don’t think Megan was pregnant with Luke’s baby. I think that Ned is the father, maybe Luke found out, and Ned killed Luke since Megan is underage and Ned will go to jail if that comes out. And of course Megan doesn’t want the father of her baby to go to jail so she covers for him. Idk maybe it’s too convoluted 😅
Haha yeah Christmas in July is definitely a thing. I think it was more of my church growing up that did it but I guess some people do it on a bigger scale
I feel Ned was the one who put Isabella's money in the cabin to set her up. Megan and Ned are close. I don't think Isabella or Megan killed Luke. The writers are doing this to throw us off. What if Megan's mom is the one that killed Luke??????? and that's why she was neutral all this time. To much things going on lol
I said this to the cause mom is just to nonchalant in all this like she know she the one who did it and maybe thats why she wanted to stay neutral between Megan and Isabella and why she didnt wanna pick a side cuz she know she one involve in it somehow but we will see u totally on to something
I think Isabella might have had a romantic relationship with Lisa..definitely had relationship vibes with her and Parker in 2000 and after being with Luke she said long time since she's liked "someone"
I do think it's possible that Megan had the baby because there are teen mothers who were even 13 and hid their pregnancy and nobody knew, whether it's just how their body held the pregnancy or if it was cryptic (we know she knew she was pregnant but she could still have not been showing much). so i'm sticking with the idea that megan had the baby and only ned knew about it and helped her give birth and he has the baby and is taking care of it or he found a home for it. the blood being fresh makes it so unrealistic for it to be luke's from january or a miscarriage from months before...i also think luke left and came back, got shot on accident by ned and then i think you said they gave him pills to help, thought he overdosed and threw him in the lake. i know megan said that isabella did something so idk how she would connect maybe she actually tried to shoot him? we know she's a terrible shot lol but if that luke theory is true then i think megan had the baby later than he died, cause she went back to clean it up and isabella didn't know about that...idk if any of that makes sense maybe i've got like half of it right or something idk
My original theory was that Jeff shot Luke because he was jealous of Megan and Isabella then he left and Megan and Isabella found Luke but he was still alive barely and so they gave him pills so the pain wouldn’t be that bad but the pills ended up actually fully killing him so they threw him in the lake and threw the gun in the lake!
What if Megan had the baby and reacted like the girl in the landmark case that’s circulating right now. The girl secretly gave birth and threw her baby in the trash can. What if Megan tried to bury her baby at Lukes cabin and he felt inclined to go to the police?
Cruel Summer 2x06 recap: ruclips.net/video/6MA81kBcUHM/видео.html
4:21 GREAT timing, Megan!! RIGHT after Isabella decided to give up the 🐱 to Luke, you FINALLY decide to spill your TRUE feelings for him to her… 🤦🏾♀️
Isabella gave Megan plenty of chances to tell her how she feels
@@mayln163 EXACTLY!!!
right?!?!
You know what? I do NOT think that Trevor is Lisa’s brother. I think that he was Lisa’s boyfriend/crush, judging by two cryptic tidbits stated by both he and Isabella…1) Isabella said something along the lines of she and Trevor creeping behind Lisa’s back to see each other and her finding out, with regard to, I guess, that fateful night and (especially) 2) Trevor made some smart arse remark to Isabella about history repeating itself with her having eyes for her BFF’s boyfriend. Whew!!! Her past is getting shadier and SHADIER…
Pretty sure the last name on the letter from Trevor matched Lisa’s but I’ll have to look again
@@Shineonmedia oohhh..ok, well, maybe, in addition to Isabella creeping with Trevor, she, also, crept with one of Lisa’s boyfriends
I took it to mean that Isabella & Trevor hid their relationship from Lisa.
I kinda think isabella still liked luke and back off because of megan's feelings. but everyone in the show lacks boundaries which kinda bugs me. Best friends who dated the same guy? mom dating daughter's bf dad?Also the mom bugs me so much she is so ridiculously nonchalant abt everything happening. Like is she ok? Its surprising it took her so long to realize her daughter needed a lawyer and with the tape and the pregnancy she is just so chill. Like why is that the case??
Isnt she sick or something she looks like shes on xanax but it could be the filters
10:19 I, totally, agree!! It’s like Debbie is giving “awkward step-mother & step-daughter relationship ” energy with Megan, at times. I can’t even say she acts more like a “friend” with Megan because it looks like, even Isabella, woulda been more pressed about learning the same things about Megan than Debbie has been
Fun fact: Ned's screen name "CBABBAGE5" is a reference to Charles Babbage, who "originated the concept of a digital programmable computer," according to Wikipedia.
That’s cool!
I love listening to your theories and recap - thank you!! Couple of things: 1) In 2000, we see Debbie taking medication for some kind of sickness that I don't think we've been disclosed on with the details. Maybe she is having some mental illness and not behaving/thinking/comprehending straight starting around the holidays of 1999. 2) I think that Luke has more secrets than the girls. In episode 1 he got out of the sheriff's car and said it was a ride along - but I wonder if he was working with the sheriff as an informant. He could have been spying on his dad or someone else and was getting caught. We saw the sheriff looking undercover in the bar in summer 1999.....there's definitely side stuff going on. The letter Luke left may have been a cover to the fact that he was really going into hiding but was murdered before he could leave. The girls may have witnessed it and that's what they are keeping secret. And the shock/stress could have caused Megan to have a miscarriage.
Headed STRAIGHT HERE, after I saw this last episode!!😙😙😙🥤🍿
For what it's worth: Lisa's obit says she died on February 8th, 1999. Trevor says the last time he saw Isabella was "5 months ago" so that would have been at the time of the death when Isabella left the country. The news article says that Lisa was "a popular and respected student in Gustavia" and that she was enjoying time off with friends between semesters and that her death rocked the "tight knit community" so Lisa lived on the island and went to school there.
Soon as I’m done watching the episode I come straight to your reviews lol I definitely think Ned and Megan either had a relationship OR he SA’d her and that’s what made her do an 180 regarding her goth type style and piercings . I also think Luke found out about Ned and a fight happened at the cabin which led to the blood being on the floor. Also I do think Luke was alive and held in the cabin by Ned and Megan to scare him into keeping quiet (similar to season one). But I think Isabella being the “ride or d” she is figured she’d handle the situation for Megan by getting rid of Luke.
And with Isabella best friend Lisa, I’m thinking it was accident that was probably Isabella fault because she was drunk . I don’t see her purposely offing her bestie and continue to write her letters unless she’s really a complete psychopath lol
Thank you for watching these! You’re awesome. And love your thoughts!
Isabella did tell Megan she’d kill for her (or something like that)
I don't think they will repeat a theme from s1. The show runner just interviewed they went over things with a fine tooth comb not to overlap (the initially wanted to use a "necklace or bracelet" as a running theme.) Megan and Ned both have computer interest and skills. My guess is Ned is Megan's actual father and he figured it out and used a way to get close. I also think he and Megan are the ones in it deep re: Luke and Isabella is just a way to throw things off to the viewer.
anyone notice the tiny butterfly necklace that Megan wears in Summer 2109 and December 2019 but she’s not wearing it in Summer 2020? Also little sister had a butterfly necklace on- it was bigger than Megans. And Megan has a butterfly picture on the wall in her room. Not sure how butterflies could be a theme or whatever but I’ve been watching for it.
@@RockCityTumblers usually nothing but butterflies mean transformation, I think apple guy could be related, I also don't know why no one mentioned that she hact the feds, Meg was trying to do something for money I don't think with her Mom being a pregnant teen that she would keep baby
Love your recaps!
For Lisa: Since it's established that Isabella and Trevor were sneaking around behind her back, maybe she found out about it when they were all drunk (Isa and Trev snuck off and she found them) and the girls got into an argument where Isa told Lisa to go away and she did, to the beach and drowned since she was intoxicated. Isa probably regretted what she said to Lisa and went to find her and thats what looked suspicious?
For Megan: I think she told Luke about her pregnancy at New Years and he was telling her they need to get away to have it, but then Isa walked in and they got in a fight about her staying out of their business. They go to the cabin for more privacy, not knowing that Isa is following them. There Luke starts planning on faking running away to go somewhere to prepare for Megan to join him at a later time but then he asks whats up with her and the older dude and if the baby is really his ehich gets them in a fight and alerts the paranoid dude who goes over there and sees someone sneaking around the cabin (Isa) and shoots, grazing Luke. Isa tries to help by giving him pills to calm down ... and that's as much as I've got.
For the mom: I think she doesn't act all mom-ish because Megan is also a provider in the house and she doesn't want to rock the boat and her stop helping.
It was so awkward how Debbie asked Meghan how the pregnancy ‘resolved’
I’m so glad your reviewing the show season 2 has been crazy and I’m liking it so far ❤ it’s so messy
I still don't think that Isabella is the culprit. You know there is always a twist.
Definitely! Leading you one way then bam!
My vote is still on the jerky older brother
@alison4dice I wonder if maybe it was a case of mistaken identity. How crazy would it be if the brother was the actual target. Maybe Megan and Isa were in cahoots with the Apple guy in the woods. They meant to get brother out, but Luke showed up instead, then 💥 BOOM! The wrong person is dead.🙁 🤨🤔🤫 Cover-up ensues... 😶
@@musicalone74 interesting idea
Maybe the father is more involved than we think 🤔
To me, what is even weirder about cleaning the blood in the cabin is that the floor is WOOD. How is she able to clean that whether or not it is fresh🤪
[Sorry about the HUGE text]
I was just rewatching the show (because my boyfriend doesn't speak english so I was trying to translate for him) and I've been noticing how Megan seems jealous about Isabella.
The first time Megan saw Isabella she already looked at her with such a jealous face, because she was waiting for a "freak" with no friends to show up, but turns out that Isabella was a hot chick with a very exciting life.
There's also the part when Isabella was telling that she was born in NY but already lived in so many places around the world and we can see in Megan's face that she was jealous, also there's the fact that Megan never left the city and she hates it.
I also think that the show is tricking us to think Isabella is the problem, but I trully beleive that what happened to Lisa was just an accident that resulted in a tragedy and Isabella kissed Trevor because she was scared about losing the new friends if he told them everything.
Now about Megan, she gets really weird about Isabella's money and gifts, but I don't beleive this is just because of the prices, but because Megan wants to have Isabella's life, money, travellings, style, boyfirend... We already noticed that Megan changed her style and it looks more like what Isabella wears.
And speaking of boyfriend, that thing about Megan telling she has feelings for Luke just right after Isabella and Luke did that thaaaaang... I don't buy it!
I wouldn't be surprised if Megan turns out into a psych0 because of the friendship between Luke and Isabella. She could be faking a pregnancy to keep her relationship by thinking Luke was interested in Isabella. The blood in the sheets could be Luke's blood because of a fight or something even worse.
I think Megan's relationship with Ned has some very shady motive, maybe it's related to selling s3x tapes in the dark web (I think Luke's father and brother are responsible for recording it) and maybe Ned was the one who leaked the tape with Megan and Luke on it (because Ned has some inappropriate feelings for Megan).
I just don't trust Megan at all.
My guess is Megan got pregnant with Ned’s baby, Luke found out and things spiraled out from there. As to who pulled the trigger or drowned? I guess we’ll see! Love this show and its twists
I keep wondering if maybe Luke did it to himself. Like he took the drugs to calm his nerves and then because of the drugs or because he changed his mind he missed with the gun only grazing himself. He possibly could have wondered out to the water and fallen in due to the drugs and head injury. The girls may have known or been involved somehow and that's what they're covering up.
I also wonder if maybe this could all have something to do with Y2K since it happened on January 1st. Idk
That’s what I’m thinking cuz first episode they dropped he rlly doesn’t wanna follow in his dads footsteps and the whole twist w grooming in season one, the creators of the show said they wanna talk about something important w this season too if it’s suicide or drug use that’s what I’m thinking
Really enjoy your reviews & theories! Keep up the great work!!
I've been coming here after I watch the episodes. This show does keep you guessing just like in season 1. I think there's a possibility that neither Megan or Isabella killed him. However, I think Ned is suspicious. Maybe Lukes dad because Luke didn't want to follow in his footsteps.
9:20 not to be petty, but this isn’t the first time I’ve noticed them using terms that were created (I believe) AFTER this time period- I don’t think “girl code” was really a mainstream saying back in the 99 and the 2000…and I, also, heard Isabella say “cray-cray” (aka crazy) regarding the cabin guy…and I KNOW that term wasn’t created until the late 2000s, if not, the 2010s
I thought the same thing about cray cray. And what is the deal with the matrix? Does Megan have multiple personalities or something? Maybe she “woke up” on Y2k(?)
@@RockCityTumblers exactly!! I was like, “😒😒😒 REALLY, show writers??” Like, HOW did y’all even THINK of incorporating the term “cray-cray” WITHOUT a SLEW of people bringing up how that was nowhere NEAR created?? As far as The Matrix references?? Aside from it being a groundbreaking movie around that time, I can only figure that they kept focusing on it as a plot device to show the audience, through Isabella’s eyes, how “made for each other” Megan and Luke were, by having them BOTH referencing it
@@sammidizzle5599 Maybe the show writers are trying the inception route- which came first- cray cray in the REAL world or cray cray in the cruel summer world… Or we are still in the matrix and everything taste like chicken 🤷♀️🥄
@@RockCityTumblers yes ..luke and meg are also endgame was not what would say in 99/2000 now cray cray I kinda remember making that slang with scary movies or like older sibling or cousin when you were acting up like boy don't get cray-cray, still think jeff and meg would make the matrix jokes since he was film buff...
I dont know if you seen ep 6 yet but I was getting scream 1 vibes
Thanks!!
Why would Debbie be “raging mad” at Megan for having sex, having a sex tape made of her without her consent and released without her consent, and for getting pregnant? And why would she even think about disciplining her? She didn’t do anything wrong. Megan is the victim here and it seems that all her mom wants to do is support her, like a good parent should.
Justice for Lisa! haha
Isabella and Lisa probably got into a fight over Trevor. Lisa might have drunk and fell into the water and accidentally drowned but Isabella leaving made her suspect number one in the case.
Theory: Trevor is Lisa. Isabella is bisexual and into threesomes. Isabella and Lisa were together and Lisa wanted to transition into Trevor. Isabella and Lisa had a third partner who drowned, which was Isabella's fault but was an accident (Isabella had been drinking). Lisa/Trevor (who has transphobic parents) realizes that this is her/his chance to disappear forever in his/her new identity. He blackmails Isabella into identifying the body as Lisa and in return, Trevor will hide the fact that this other death was Isabella's fault. When Isabella tells Trevor "We should have told Lisa," she is referring to Lisa/Trevor's mother, who is also named "Lisa." At the beginning of this episode, when Isabella is writing to "Lisa" she remarks that the "three" of them together would be awesome (a reference to threesomes). When she says this, she looks at the picture of her, Megan and Luke. Isabella was hoping to recreate a threesome with Megan and Luke, that's why she's cozying up to both of them. It was Isabella who made the sex tape, because they were all having sex together. Cruel Summer likes having edgy themes/relationships. This one will have a trans character, bisexuality and threesomes.
@@truthtalker3498 I can believe Isabella to be bisexual. Maybe Isabella just wanted to both Trevor or Lisa but Lisa didn’t want that. Now that Megan and Luke are together, she wants them both too
@@Lboogie0711 I definitely think that a threesome (or foursome with Jeff? or Ned?) is part of the plot (now and in Isabella's past) and that Isabella made the sex tape (that's also why her sweater is in the video). It could have been consensual and Luke kept it and Brent found it and played it at the party to take his brother down a peg out of jealousy. Remember that scene of Megan and Isabella dancing sexy together at the Christmas party and Luke checking both of them out?
Also, I just got a "Trevor is Lisa" vibe when he was interacting with Isabella. Like in Season One when Anabel was a bait and switch. I think "Lisa" is, too. Or Trevor was Lisa's boyfriend, not brother. Trevor does say, referring to Isabella getting with Luke..."a guy your best friend's close to? Yeah, I've seen that movie before."
@@truthtalker3498yea but didn’t the episode say that Trevor is Lisa’s older brother?
I wasn’t sure at first, but after seeing this episode, Ned definitely has something to do with Luke’s death. I also think that Megan had a secret relationship with Ned and he possibly found out about Luke, and decided to kill him.
I agree…and no would be du prided if NED were her babydaddy…
Who is Ned??? Lol
@@djrn1621 I think it’s the “creepy cabin neighbor guy”
Nah, just because he's different and is uncomfortable around people doesn't make him weird or a murderer. I think he's a big nerd and he wants to help Megan learn coding. We'll see LOL!
I don’t know why I think Luke’s dad did it
Also what happened to Megan’s sister ? She’s barely in the episodes anymore. What’s up with that ? I wonder if they kind of showing us that the person who hurted luke isn’t being shown that much ?
I agree- I think the little sister is pregnant. Especially since Megan was worried that “she’d get a reputation”. Also- something happened to Megan in the 4th grade that caused her ridicule from the town for a long time. I wonder if it had something to do with her sister- which causes Megan to be overly cautious and responsible now.
I don’t know it someone’s said this but… why is the younger sister hardly in the show? Any theories if something happened to her? I know the last time she was mentioned she was at Olivia’s sleepover… but physically not seeing her & not seeing how she’s reacting to things makes me wonder…
I honestly don't think the little sister is important to the plot at all. I think they just have her there to show why Megan needs to make money and support the family because it's not just her she's supporting but her sister.
I may be wrong, but I feel like she may have went to stay with her dad
@@Shineonmedia Thank you so much for taking the time to reply! ✨ I could totally see it that way. I just hope their mom can get her stuff together!
I totally forgot all about her sister 😂😂
Also in the 2 truths, 1 lie- Luke said he had a pen pal in California. And Isabella might be a sleepwalker (?) They weren’t really clear about which of her 3 tales was the lie.
I’m getting a vibe that lukes dad killed him, possibly on accident or in a fit of rage. I just think he did it in some way.
When I saw the cabbage thing I thought it was an adult but a different one I thought it was Luke’s father and Meghan and him were sneaking around idk why I went there in my head
i gave on episode three. season 1 was fire
Maybe the bloody sheets are from wrapping up Luke's body.
Is that the guy that plays Carlton in Bel Air?
yea that him
It really bothered me that Debbie was reading Isabella’s postcards
Omg it’s Olly Sholotan! ☺️😀🙂😎😍
That’s what I said! Omg it’s Carlton banks! 🎉😂
The mom is definitely involved
I still think the little sister is involved. I think she is the one who got pregnant and Megan’s covering for her.
Interesting theory
I kind of feel like Isabella is obsessive with her besties. So, I think maybe her and Megan caused the death, or Isabella believes Megan is guilty and was covering for her anyway. It just might be a killer from left field. But, if Luke caused his own death by accident, I would be disappointed with the writers.
I think that Ned was hiding Luke until Isabella told luke about the pregnancy and the baby being Neds and luke confronted ned and got shot she tried to break it up and had a miscarriage. Luke feels guilty runs to Isabella she gives him pills they go to the water he gets shot at jumps in the water and drowns. Thats my theory and nay be why everyone feels guilty
I don’t think Megan was pregnant with Luke’s baby. I think that Ned is the father, maybe Luke found out, and Ned killed Luke since Megan is underage and Ned will go to jail if that comes out. And of course Megan doesn’t want the father of her baby to go to jail so she covers for him. Idk maybe it’s too convoluted 😅
I was wondering why they were in such a xmas vibes on july 1999...
Haha yeah Christmas in July is definitely a thing. I think it was more of my church growing up that did it but I guess some people do it on a bigger scale
I feel Ned was the one who put Isabella's money in the cabin to set her up. Megan and Ned are close. I don't think Isabella or Megan killed Luke. The writers are doing this to throw us off. What if Megan's mom is the one that killed Luke??????? and that's why she was neutral all this time. To much things going on lol
I said this to the cause mom is just to nonchalant in all this like she know she the one who did it and maybe thats why she wanted to stay neutral between Megan and Isabella and why she didnt wanna pick a side cuz she know she one involve in it somehow but we will see u totally on to something
Why would the mom kill Luke?
(Sorry my English, I'm still learning)
I said it before and I'll say it again Isabella & Megan are half sisters separated at birth
So what was Megan doing with Luke’s license on that computer and also she was trying to hack the feds?? 🧐😵💫
Maybe using them to create some fake identification to run away?
it was the fake licenses they had made to get into the club in a previous episode
I think Isabella might have had a romantic relationship with Lisa..definitely had relationship vibes with her and Parker in 2000 and after being with Luke she said long time since she's liked "someone"
I do think it's possible that Megan had the baby because there are teen mothers who were even 13 and hid their pregnancy and nobody knew, whether it's just how their body held the pregnancy or if it was cryptic (we know she knew she was pregnant but she could still have not been showing much). so i'm sticking with the idea that megan had the baby and only ned knew about it and helped her give birth and he has the baby and is taking care of it or he found a home for it. the blood being fresh makes it so unrealistic for it to be luke's from january or a miscarriage from months before...i also think luke left and came back, got shot on accident by ned and then i think you said they gave him pills to help, thought he overdosed and threw him in the lake. i know megan said that isabella did something so idk how she would connect maybe she actually tried to shoot him? we know she's a terrible shot lol but if that luke theory is true then i think megan had the baby later than he died, cause she went back to clean it up and isabella didn't know about that...idk if any of that makes sense maybe i've got like half of it right or something idk
I think Megan was pregnant by the neighbor Ned.
Luke could have died later I think too bc remember how Megan said to use some chemical for faster decomposition? Kinda weird that she knows that lol
i mean i know a lot of things from watching CSI and law & order svu i probably shouldn't know hahahaha
My original theory was that Jeff shot Luke because he was jealous of Megan and Isabella then he left and Megan and Isabella found Luke but he was still alive barely and so they gave him pills so the pain wouldn’t be that bad but the pills ended up actually fully killing him so they threw him in the lake and threw the gun in the lake!
* jealous of Megan and Luke*
What if Megan had the baby and reacted like the girl in the landmark case that’s circulating right now. The girl secretly gave birth and threw her baby in the trash can. What if Megan tried to bury her baby at Lukes cabin and he felt inclined to go to the police?
Am I the only one that has noticed that someone other than Luke is MISSING from the group?
Who?
the lil sis or do you mean parker
what if Luke isnt dead
It's could have been Megan Mom or Ned like it would make sense
Why would Debbie not know that Megan is pregnant !!!
I like
I said it before and I'll say it again Isabella & Megan are half sisters separated at birth
that makes sense. I can see that being true. Especially the way Debbie is around Isbella