This is my ranking of the album rosie ❤️ 1) too bad for us & toxic till the end 2) stay a little longer & 3am 3) two years & not the same 4) vampirehollie & number one girl 5) gameboy & drinks or coffee 6) call it the end 7) dance all night & APT Please note* this whole freakin album is full of gems 💎 & my favorites ❤️ but I am a sucker for vocals! so here you go.
Jennie s album will break grounds! Already the most anticipated the most waited❤!! Let’s all save money and mass buy her album to support this girl J who is slaying everything she set her mind soul and hand on
I can't wait to listen the new solo album of the wonderful Jennie, and for this album to include this amazing collaboration with the beautiful Lisa, but every day that passes i'm loving more and more this new masterpiece solo album "Rosie" by the wonderful Global star Rosé.
actually the lyrics of vampire hollie is becaming true everday cz a lot of people don't want ROS'E to sign don't want to believe her hardwork and talent shame on them
The audacity to say nothing revealing and exiting when rosè revealed her relationship and that got every one pretty much exited because its the first time an idol is revealing their relationship herself
This is true now all knows fans loved rosé so much bcuz of not touching any man or going to close them means she is making always distance...on other hand in TTTE she kissed after that her reviews slowly got worse fans got angry jealousy bad comments hates...now who forced her to do that taylor swift or someone else...she needs to think that who is her enemy..
Honestly, I wonder how Lisa was nominated. The nomination period was until June 20, 2024, and Rockstar was released on 28 June. Before you call me anti or something, see VMA 2024's Wikipedia, where they mentioned the dates of the nomination period.
@arshiyakaukab8814 VMA personally invited her so ? Who are you to judge and you 🤣believe in wikipedia?.Most of the List and date never genuinely correct nor updates in wikipedia pages. 🤡
@@arshiyakaukab8814 Lisa was invited to the VMA's as a fans choice . And in VMA's , they often select idols of big reach in the wish to make more coverage .
To speculate on Hybe's possible action for the negative comment, it would be interesting to know how much the JK and Jimin albums were rated. I also noticed that Ed Sheran's albums were rated very poorly, which shows the magazine's lack of seriousness.
Sorry for dragging Lisa here but how curious when a media criticizes Rose blinks and Rose fans almost eat alive the media that dares to criticize Rose but when Lisa's presentation was named as the worst of the VMA, in addition to called her kflop, no one said anything on the contrary, many fans began to harass Lisa called her kflop and other very unpleasant nicknames without forgetting that they called her fans stupid for defending her, the blinks should at least hide their favoritism a little and The worst thing is that they cry later because Lisa doesn't mention them.
@nirukhanal5358 Thank you very much for your response to my comment, my intention is not to criticize or hate Rose, on the contrary, it is very good that the fans defend her, the only thing I don't like is the hypocrisy, and it is also very true Lisa deserves a better fandom than Blink and the worst thing is that there is a lot of evidence of blinks hating Lisa and there are still blinks that deny that the fandom hate Lisa, they blame other fandoms for the hate she receives saying that the others fandoms pretend to be blinks to attack her and they also attack Lilies just for defending her
@Vrinda-m9s I think the one who lives under a rock is you, if the fans defended Lisa the cancellations promoted by the haters and blinks would not have been so big (like the time they canceled Lisa for supposedly not supporting her groupmates) "Lisa "she is more loved by blinks than Rose" how curious that the numbers of Rose's soloists (monthly listeners on Spotify, subscribers on RUclips, TikTok, etc.) the kprofiles say the opposite, of the three members of Blackpink who released music soloist this year Lisa is the one who received zero support, she is the one who has the least subscribers on RUclips, the least listeners in Spotify etc but she did receive all the hate, you are trying to do is throw a pity party for your favorite.
No one care was Pitchfork said true because they more of joke today like Ice spice got the high review all out some great album in part 25 years also Rosé's solo album "rosie got great review by big news channel like example The Grammys, Teen Voges, billboard you see no one how like music well going take this seriously.. Like if even look view of video no one care because is a joke of review everyone know the only people we care it toxie fan they we try to use but it won't work and this album "rosie" is very love here a example ROSÉ’s No. 3 Debut With ‘Rosie on the billboard 1. ROSÉ debuts at No. 3 on the Billboard 200 this week with Rosie, moving 102,000 equivalent album units. If you’re ROSÉ or one of her team members, how excited are you feeling about that bow, on a scale of 1-10? Rania Aniftos: I’m thinking 9. Sure, it’s not No. 1, but to rank so highly on the Billboard 200 with your debut album as a solo artist is a major accomplishment. It also must be validating for ROSÉ to know that while she’s a major star in BLACKPINK, she can also hold strong on her own Those are people at billboard they now want people want and more of the time they do was they are talk about also it show people do care about Career that all going said but also Remember everything you need is on the ground
I think his assessment of Rosie's album not revealing much is accurate though. Rosé said this album was a look into who she really is, but 10/12 song were just about her relationships - like most of her identity is based on her relationships, and poor relationships at that. That doesn't reveal much about someone other than that they're a hopeless romantic. It's pretty shallow, really. And her story is so common, but not as relatable as you may think. It mostly only happens to people who watch/read too much romance genre and listen to too much Taylor Swift - people who have an elevated idea of what love and relationships are really like, and confuse attachment and infatuation with love. I actually don't think Rosé has been in love, not really. Most people's idea of what love is really like is misguided by our culture's obsession with romance. I don't think Alex hasn't been in a relationship before, he just hasn't been in a toxic relationship. I haven't been in a toxic relationship either, but I'm in love and buying a house with someone now, and I know what Rosé isn't what love is really like. Rosé is a great singer, but only Stay a Little Longer really showed off her vocal range. The rest just feels pretty generic and doesn't really show off her talents. I prefer to think that this album is to show the girl Rosé was and not who she is now. Because I think she needs some better and more original inspiration, but also that if she doesn't adapt of views of what love really is, then she'll be doomed to make the same mistakes and we'll be doomed to see her turn into another Taylor Swift.
1. Gameboy 2. 3am 3. Drinks or coffee 4. Dance all night 5. Too bad for us 6. Toxic till the end 7. Number one girl 8. Two years 9. Vampirehollie 10. Call it the end 11. Stay a little longer 12. Not the same These are pure gold (altho not sure how I feel about not the same) if that woman doesn't understand this stuff idk she has lived an amazing life without being worried about life or relationships
This is true now all knows fans loved rosé so much bcuz of not touching any man or going to close them means she is making always distance...on other hand in TTTE she kissed after that her reviews slowly got worse fans got angry jealousy bad comments hates they dont want to see the mv of ttte..now who forced her to do that taylor swift or someone else...she needs to think that who is her enemy...i wish if she see this
I really don't think so we can have a sub unit of blackpink because for solo blackpink are out of yg but for group they are in yg so two members from a group consisting 4 members coming together to make something is called sub unit of a group so isn't that in the hand of yg
1:35 - Sincerely, I also didn't think this album was soo amazing. But I think said "no exciting" was kind of unfair. I think fansés or blinks will get mad with criticizes because they are infatuated for her. So of course they will not be impartial about her work. Or they will have a lot of difficulty to analyze her work without passion glasses. I have no problem with this. I like her but I don't think her work was original or a breakthrough work. Well . . . Maybe inside the k-pop culture and japane/korean culture...Could be... But not to a westerner culture, like, talk about personal feelings and the "kiss" in her MV. And in this case it's more about her attitude than her music style itself. In this case her songs seem a lot of a mix of Ed Sheeran with Taylor Swift and others pop artists. It's a competent work. A good, but not an innovative one. In this days I was exploring different sounds (I'm a musicophile) and exploring Lady Gaga's and Ariana Grande's discography and in the end I just want to stop to hear them to go back to "Rosie" album, which seems more tasteful to my ears than the Gaga's and Grande's (at least their) firsts albuns. So, at least I have to give this credit to ROSÉ... And I think it's pretty normal she has more influences from other artists that she likes and that she works with in the same label or who is around her, specially because she is learning to walk with her own feet now in a solo career after many years under YG protection (control) and with psycological support of her "sisters" around her. Now she is most part of time physically distant of her love ones (including her "sisters" bandates) So... I imagine that her next albuns would be better than this first one, because musicality she showed she has (and intelligence to make good connections inside this Industry too...). So it's just a matter of time to she improve herself at a point where she could release something with her own identity...
The Ramos review of ROSIE to me seemed rushed, overly subjective, and was itself strangely lacking in any comprehension of the subject, or willingness to engage with it. Ramos makes claims that are unsupported or unexplained beyond terse dismissive assertions. How are the pop references “dated?” How is heartache “generic?” What does Ramos mean by “lacks [a] sense of identity?” These are big claims, none of which are fleshed out or adequately explained, or justified. My own suspicion is that Ramos pre-judged the album, gave it barely a cursory listen, was pushed to a deadline to write something. I also get a lingering sense of superficial dismissiveness of Rose's Korean or K-Pop roots, a lingering prejudgement, a sense of resentment, even prejudice, perhaps, that prevented any true critique. It's worth noting, she was equally dismissive and scathing of BLACKPINK's Born Pink album in a 2022 review. Ramos obviously dislikes the group, and has carried that personal dislike to the output of its individual members. My rating of her review of ROSIE is 2.5.
I can understand the mixed opinions about Rose. It's not that I dislike Rose. After a big hit song, there is always an explosion of attention on the artist. I'm also curious about Rose's recent behavior. I understand that it was a production, but seeing Rose singing with her feet up on the table feels strange. If Lisa did the same thing, it would cause a stir. Solo songs are also highly praised and deserves Grammy singer? I don't think so. Is call singer-songwriter because rose been involved in all of the works and name is listed? If don't write lyrics, you can't call a singer? It feels contrived.
Ngl but this is the sad reality. Since most of blinks itself turn their back towards Lisa if she had done anything like that. Most of blinks are already no 1 Lisa hater and ot3 stans.
Ngl If they both collab that definitely going to break the Internet since both solo stans of them are so powerful along with so much toxicity they will definitely will compete for each thats benefit for both if they release it before her whole album release but chance is low for both to collab 😔
Why would you show BTS's Instagram here? Also, didn't you say she gives inconsistent ratings to other albums? Then, that person would have done the same thing with Rose.
She showed the history of pitch fork following bts official and lets not get ahead of ourselves and deny that hybe was not stalking blackpink and not writing negative media against blackpink to make them seem negative and tarnish their Image
@BLINKWORLD-26774 yup I agree hybe did that but here the author has always given inconsistent reviews also everyone has an opinion and the author has an opinion too and she shared it. No matter what BTS aren't related here.
@@arshiyakaukab8814 the op did not said bts but hybe artist also her opinion okay but The audacity to say nothing revealing and exiting when rosè revealed her relationship and that got every one pretty much exited because its the first time an idol is revealing their relationship herself.
@@BLINKWORLD-26774 If they follow hybe artists does it mean hybe paid them? Pitchfork follows a total of 1263 people. If Hybe does something wrong it's not Hybe artists fault.
Alex was lttrly just saying her opinion about rosie. she was criticizing it but it a RESPECTFUL way. we should all be allowed to have our own views and opinions on certain things and alex was just expressing hers.
Pitchfork even gave her a high review considering their history. I mean, when your whole album almost talks about the same topic, then you should play more with lyrics or sound to make it unique. Just like Olivia when she debuted and although people call her Swift's daughter, she has her own touch which makes her different. Right now, Rosé and Gracie Abrams fall into one category - Copy and Paste
It is absolutely NOT so-called 'copy and paste'. If you understand anything about music and music history, all genres and sub-genres of music are INFLUENCED by previous generations and new musicians make what came before them better while standing on the shoulders of giants. Music INFLUENCING has been the norm since the age of classical music and it is NOT so-called 'copying'. For example, Taylor Swift was INFLUENCED by the likes of Shania Twain, Dolly Parton. Faith Hill, etc.... in her earlier, country music years. As her career evolved, particularly with the release of her album 1989, her sound shifted towards synth-pop, INFLUENCED by 80s pop icons like Cyndi Lauper and Madonna. This transformation was also informed by more modern pop stars like Katy Perry and Lorde, blending nostalgia with contemporary styles. So, if you claim that Rosé and Gracie Abrams were so-called 'copying and pasting', then you will also have to claim the same for the likes of Taylor Swift, and that practically applies for every other musician in existence.
@@musicinterest-dib And it is true to my opinion that it is absolutely and categorically NOT so-called 'copy and paste'. By the way, music INFLUENCE is not just my opinion, it is an established fact and that is how commercial music has evolved since the dawn of time.
@@IanSchultz-u3b Influence is being inspired by someone's approach to music and try it in yours - Olivia. Copy and paste is taking that approach, deliver the song the same way as the original artist, cover it with sound that can be found in early pop - Gracie and Rosie. Two totally different things. I feel like people mistake influence with what I meant. Don't think I don't like the album cause I do like it and I listen to it, but I cannot close my eyes for such thing and say what you say just because I am a Blink, cause I am one, I follow the girls and stream their stuff (without Lisa's cause I am disappointed by her releases except for Rockstar) but to me personality is above anything else (lyrics, melody, etc).
@@musicinterest-dib Firstly, I don't mistake what 'influence' in the context of music means. A simple definition is - 'music is a continuously evolving art form, and every new style, genre, or trend builds upon the musical traditions that preceded it. Elements like melody, harmony, rhythm, and even specific instruments have been passed down through time. Each new generation incorporates and reinterprets these elements, sometimes innovating on them, but still remaining connected to the past.' By the way, do you know what 'copy and paste' means ? From the perspective of music (as well as other aspects), it means taking something that has already been published EXACTLY without any changes to it, and claiming that to be your own. Another term for this is plagiarism. I'm sure that is not what you meant. If not, then you'll have to really define what you mean by 'copy and paste'
Ahm..making assumptions about someone's personal life and their ability to feel emotions just because they didn't make a good review on your favourite artist's album...? Not cool...Grow some maturity please
Isn't that the same thing with your fandom ? When peppa pig rating was revealed your fandom was becoming dank in the quotes so if someone is stating facts why it's a problem the call should go to your home. And please teach that maturity lesson to your fellow mates also you might be sleeping because hybe is revealed to make a negative media against blackpink and it's truth no assumptions because if that's truth why not this? There's a possibility and every one is speculating and that hybe internal documents helps the assumptions I fear it's the truth 😥
@@Luvvvlivvlifffe first of i and you know that anything blackpink members will release is not satisfactory to you so quit this high expectations because if you don't love that album you will not like any of the blackpink releases.
@@BLINKWORLD-26774 yk what I don't know how do u know me but lemme tell u it ain't like that, I love BLACKPINK even apt , mantra, pink venom were my top 3 songs of the year , i love them but as a fan I was criticizing, I'm swiftie so she was literally sounding like her so I couldn't help n I said it out, idk why is it so hard to digest this fact that I didn't like it much
![American reacts to Posts That Prove American's Think That Only They Exist [part 3]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/23r5nlvkqA4/mqdefault.jpg)
![BABYMONSTER [DRIP] POP-UP STORE DOCUMENTARY - YG PRODUCTION EP.5](/img/1.gif)
This is my ranking of the album rosie ❤️
1) too bad for us & toxic till the end
2) stay a little longer & 3am
3) two years & not the same
4) vampirehollie & number one girl
5) gameboy & drinks or coffee
6) call it the end
7) dance all night & APT
Please note* this whole freakin album is full of gems 💎 & my favorites ❤️ but I am a sucker for vocals! so here you go.
you nover music no expert gnom.
STRAY KIDS IS THE KING OF KPOPSTRAY KIDS IS THE KING OF KPOP,
Rosie album is great ❤
Jennie s album will break grounds! Already the most anticipated the most waited❤!! Let’s all save money and mass buy her album to support this girl J who is slaying everything she set her mind soul and hand on
OMG yesss 🎉❤
Jennie Kim JNK1 Album will Massive Hit🫶🏻🛐 Can't wait for Queens Versatility and Impactful Music..
Her single flopped hard 😂 she's nothing without weknd
I can't wait to listen the new solo album of the wonderful Jennie, and for this album to include this amazing collaboration with the beautiful Lisa, but every day that passes i'm loving more and more this new masterpiece solo album "Rosie" by the wonderful Global star Rosé.
actually the lyrics of vampire hollie is becaming true everday cz a lot of people don't want ROS'E to sign
don't want to believe her hardwork and talent
shame on them
OMG😭🥳 JNK1 must be coming soon accordingly 🙌🎵🔥🔥💖
The audacity to say nothing revealing and exiting when rosè revealed her relationship and that got every one pretty much exited because its the first time an idol is revealing their relationship herself
Because it reviews western albums....
@Dropletsojoy and still rates them. Low lol also this article rated brat as 8/10 like ?.
Her album flopped though
@@Lil-h2x Absolute nonsense ! What do you define as so-called 'flop' when her album is breaking chart records left, right and center ??
@@Lil-h2x your life is a big so don’t talk about others
2:31 tht must be happen cuz he confessed tht he tried to frame rosé in drug case so its 100% possible he do this too
Thts too muvh from tht man😒
True
He is so jealous
ikr it's all hybe's doing!! because in their internal document they talked about how they'll drag rosé in her solo era and now they doing their work😶
This is true now all knows fans loved rosé so much bcuz of not touching any man or going to close them means she is making always distance...on other hand in TTTE she kissed after that her reviews slowly got worse fans got angry jealousy bad comments hates...now who forced her to do that taylor swift or someone else...she needs to think that who is her enemy..
Waiting for Jennie's full album❤ i really loved Mantra ❤
Can't wait for jennie new album ❤❤❤❤❤❤
Its nothing new hybe also done the same thing to lisa after her VMAs performance
Honestly, I wonder how Lisa was nominated. The nomination period was until June 20, 2024, and Rockstar was released on 28 June. Before you call me anti or something, see VMA 2024's Wikipedia, where they mentioned the dates of the nomination period.
@arshiyakaukab8814 VMA personally invited her so ? Who are you to judge and you 🤣believe in wikipedia?.Most of the List and date never genuinely correct nor updates in wikipedia pages. 🤡
@@anungketan2285ur right she is probably sad that her fav didn’t win because lisa was better 😂
@@arshiyakaukab8814
Lisa was invited to the VMA's as a fans choice . And in VMA's , they often select idols of big reach in the wish to make more coverage .
@@Lisa-e5p2k sorry to say my fav wasn't nominated if he was nominated he would have outsold someone who wins awards with influence of their boyfriend.
Rosie❤
Waiting for jennie ❤❤❤
Waiting for jenniesss masterpiece ❤❤❤
Can't wait for JENNIEEEEE
a jennie x Lisa collab would make me literally poop my pants
To speculate on Hybe's possible action for the negative comment, it would be interesting to know how much the JK and Jimin albums were rated. I also noticed that Ed Sheran's albums were rated very poorly, which shows the magazine's lack of seriousness.
That's insane, Ed Sheeran is basically one of the most talented artists of his generation.
Jennnieeee❤❤❤
Sorry for dragging Lisa here but how curious when a media criticizes Rose blinks and Rose fans almost eat alive the media that dares to criticize Rose but when Lisa's presentation was named as the worst of the VMA, in addition to called her kflop, no one said anything on the contrary, many fans began to harass Lisa called her kflop and other very unpleasant nicknames without forgetting that they called her fans stupid for defending her, the blinks should at least hide their favoritism a little and The worst thing is that they cry later because Lisa doesn't mention them.
Bro u talking like a literate educated person here....love u so much....lisa deserves better fandom than blinks...
@nirukhanal5358 Thank you very much for your response to my comment, my intention is not to criticize or hate Rose, on the contrary, it is very good that the fans defend her, the only thing I don't like is the hypocrisy, and it is also very true Lisa deserves a better fandom than Blink and the worst thing is that there is a lot of evidence of blinks hating Lisa and there are still blinks that deny that the fandom hate Lisa, they blame other fandoms for the hate she receives saying that the others fandoms pretend to be blinks to attack her and they also attack Lilies just for defending her
lol do you live under a rock ? people did defend lisa . Also lisa is more loved by blinks as compared to rosè . Lisa is already so overhyped
@Vrinda-m9s I think the one who lives under a rock is you, if the fans defended Lisa the cancellations promoted by the haters and blinks would not have been so big (like the time they canceled Lisa for supposedly not supporting her groupmates) "Lisa "she is more loved by blinks than Rose" how curious that the numbers of Rose's soloists (monthly listeners on Spotify, subscribers on RUclips, TikTok, etc.) the kprofiles say the opposite, of the three members of Blackpink who released music soloist this year Lisa is the one who received zero support, she is the one who has the least subscribers on RUclips, the least listeners in Spotify etc but she did receive all the hate, you are trying to do is throw a pity party for your favorite.
Stop comparing both the idols! They are both loved..all the hating comes from Hybe its not blinks! Dont you see what they doing!
Not me thinking Jennie and Rosé's collab after jennie adding caption for her recent insta post ❝drinks &&❞[hinting Rosé's album song]
😭😭
Lisa ❤❤❤
Jennie's only 1 song shook the whole K-pop industry, wondering what her album will do. Can't wait!
Happy for all of them 😊
Jennie!! Waiting!❤❤❤❤❤
Why don't HYBE just take care of their own idol's than framing other idol's
No one care was Pitchfork said true because they more of joke today like Ice spice got the high review all out some great album in part 25 years also Rosé's solo album "rosie got great review by big news channel like example The Grammys, Teen Voges, billboard you see no one how like music well going take this seriously.. Like if even look view of video no one care because is a joke of review everyone know the only people we care it toxie fan they we try to use but it won't work and this album "rosie" is very love here a example ROSÉ’s No. 3 Debut With ‘Rosie on the billboard 1. ROSÉ debuts at No. 3 on the Billboard 200 this week with Rosie, moving 102,000 equivalent album units. If you’re ROSÉ or one of her team members, how excited are you feeling about that bow, on a scale of 1-10?
Rania Aniftos: I’m thinking 9. Sure, it’s not No. 1, but to rank so highly on the Billboard 200 with your debut album as a solo artist is a major accomplishment. It also must be validating for ROSÉ to know that while she’s a major star in BLACKPINK, she can also hold strong on her own
Those are people at billboard they now want people want and more of the time they do was they are talk about also it show people do care about Career that all going said but also Remember everything you need is on the ground
I think soon blackpink comeback preparation starts
JENNIE❤ KIM VILLIAN OF KPOP IS COMING TO SHOW HYBE HIS STATUS 😂
Can't wait
Special girl
This chanel always ot3 stan
I think his assessment of Rosie's album not revealing much is accurate though. Rosé said this album was a look into who she really is, but 10/12 song were just about her relationships - like most of her identity is based on her relationships, and poor relationships at that. That doesn't reveal much about someone other than that they're a hopeless romantic. It's pretty shallow, really. And her story is so common, but not as relatable as you may think. It mostly only happens to people who watch/read too much romance genre and listen to too much Taylor Swift - people who have an elevated idea of what love and relationships are really like, and confuse attachment and infatuation with love.
I actually don't think Rosé has been in love, not really. Most people's idea of what love is really like is misguided by our culture's obsession with romance. I don't think Alex hasn't been in a relationship before, he just hasn't been in a toxic relationship. I haven't been in a toxic relationship either, but I'm in love and buying a house with someone now, and I know what Rosé isn't what love is really like.
Rosé is a great singer, but only Stay a Little Longer really showed off her vocal range. The rest just feels pretty generic and doesn't really show off her talents.
I prefer to think that this album is to show the girl Rosé was and not who she is now. Because I think she needs some better and more original inspiration, but also that if she doesn't adapt of views of what love really is, then she'll be doomed to make the same mistakes and we'll be doomed to see her turn into another Taylor Swift.
Who cares about Rating?
True music lover will obviously like Rosé's album
1:20 joke of the year😂😂😂
1. Gameboy
2. 3am
3. Drinks or coffee
4. Dance all night
5. Too bad for us
6. Toxic till the end
7. Number one girl
8. Two years
9. Vampirehollie
10. Call it the end
11. Stay a little longer
12. Not the same
These are pure gold (altho not sure how I feel about not the same) if that woman doesn't understand this stuff idk she has lived an amazing life without being worried about life or relationships
Jenlisa rule 🖤❤️❤️❤️💀💯
Rosieeee ❤
If jennie has a solo song featuring lisa, it would be too epic. Jenlisa fans would go nuts
LISA My Lovely.👑🤘🌟💛🌻🐣😻💋
This is true now all knows fans loved rosé so much bcuz of not touching any man or going to close them means she is making always distance...on other hand in TTTE she kissed after that her reviews slowly got worse fans got angry jealousy bad comments hates they dont want to see the mv of ttte..now who forced her to do that taylor swift or someone else...she needs to think that who is her enemy...i wish if she see this
Rosé is better no one will reach her ☠️☠️
2:26 ohh i got it, i got it🤣🤣
that yellow company is doing their work as they said in their internal documents🤣
It is definetely Hybe trying to sabotge Rosé but we should not let that happen:( We can see that even Grammy noticed the album so it is very good!
I really don't think so we can have a sub unit of blackpink because for solo blackpink are out of yg but for group they are in yg so two members from a group consisting 4 members coming together to make something is called sub unit of a group so isn't that in the hand of yg
All the Rose álbum is a jewel.....poor other hater..
You have to be a PAID "hater" for you to write hate about Blackpink or any of its members :-)
Rose 🌹 ❤❤❤❤❤❤
1:35 - Sincerely, I also didn't think this album was soo amazing. But I think said "no exciting" was kind of unfair. I think fansés or blinks will get mad with criticizes because they are infatuated for her. So of course they will not be impartial about her work. Or they will have a lot of difficulty to analyze her work without passion glasses. I have no problem with this. I like her but I don't think her work was original or a breakthrough work. Well . . . Maybe inside the k-pop culture and japane/korean culture...Could be... But not to a westerner culture, like, talk about personal feelings and the "kiss" in her MV. And in this case it's more about her attitude than her music style itself. In this case her songs seem a lot of a mix of Ed Sheeran with Taylor Swift and others pop artists. It's a competent work. A good, but not an innovative one.
In this days I was exploring different sounds (I'm a musicophile) and exploring Lady Gaga's and Ariana Grande's discography and in the end I just want to stop to hear them to go back to "Rosie" album, which seems more tasteful to my ears than the Gaga's and Grande's (at least their) firsts albuns. So, at least I have to give this credit to ROSÉ... And I think it's pretty normal she has more influences from other artists that she likes and that she works with in the same label or who is around her, specially because she is learning to walk with her own feet now in a solo career after many years under YG protection (control) and with psycological support of her "sisters" around her. Now she is most part of time physically distant of her love ones (including her "sisters" bandates) So... I imagine that her next albuns would be better than this first one, because musicality she showed she has (and intelligence to make good connections inside this Industry too...). So it's just a matter of time to she improve herself at a point where she could release something with her own identity...
BLACKPINK just stays on top
1:21 dont be shy, tell us how much they payed you to write this article 😙
The Ramos review of ROSIE to me seemed rushed, overly subjective, and was itself strangely lacking in any comprehension of the subject, or willingness to engage with it. Ramos makes claims that are unsupported or unexplained beyond terse dismissive assertions. How are the pop references “dated?” How is heartache “generic?” What does Ramos mean by “lacks [a] sense of identity?” These are big claims, none of which are fleshed out or adequately explained, or justified. My own suspicion is that Ramos pre-judged the album, gave it barely a cursory listen, was pushed to a deadline to write something. I also get a lingering sense of superficial dismissiveness of Rose's Korean or K-Pop roots, a lingering prejudgement, a sense of resentment, even prejudice, perhaps, that prevented any true critique. It's worth noting, she was equally dismissive and scathing of BLACKPINK's Born Pink album in a 2022 review. Ramos obviously dislikes the group, and has carried that personal dislike to the output of its individual members. My rating of her review of ROSIE is 2.5.
Rose 💫✨🫶🥹💗
Wait For Jennie
I can understand the mixed opinions about Rose.
It's not that I dislike Rose.
After a big hit song, there is always an explosion of attention on the artist.
I'm also curious about Rose's recent behavior.
I understand that it was a production, but seeing Rose singing with her feet up on the table feels strange.
If Lisa did the same thing, it would cause a stir.
Solo songs are also highly praised and deserves Grammy singer?
I don't think so.
Is call singer-songwriter because rose been involved in all of the works and name is listed?
If don't write lyrics, you can't call a singer?
It feels contrived.
What do you mean by the expression:"Rose singing with her feet up on the table feels strange. If Lisa did the same thing , it would cause a stir"?.
Ngl but this is the sad reality. Since most of blinks itself turn their back towards Lisa if she had done anything like that. Most of blinks are already no 1 Lisa hater and ot3 stans.
I don't think Jennie will Collab with blackpink members.. she has a lot to experience out of the group
I don't think so. Maybe Jennie collaboration with Lisa. They are best friend
Ngl If they both collab that definitely going to break the Internet since both solo stans of them are so powerful along with so much toxicity they will definitely will compete for each thats benefit for both if they release it before her whole album release but chance is low for both to collab 😔
I'm sure that review/riticism is from an Anti
So pathetic - them and their favs having stans like them
They wanted some more gossip. So no that’s not happening
Why would you show BTS's Instagram here? Also, didn't you say she gives inconsistent ratings to other albums? Then, that person would have done the same thing with Rose.
She showed the history of pitch fork following bts official and lets not get ahead of ourselves and deny that hybe was not stalking blackpink and not writing negative media against blackpink to make them seem negative and tarnish their Image
@BLINKWORLD-26774 yup I agree hybe did that but here the author has always given inconsistent reviews also everyone has an opinion and the author has an opinion too and she shared it. No matter what BTS aren't related here.
@@arshiyakaukab8814 no one said bts is related the op said hybe artist and the op opinion ok but saying it's giving nothing revealing and exiting
@@arshiyakaukab8814 the op did not said bts but hybe artist also her opinion okay but The audacity to say nothing revealing and exiting when rosè revealed her relationship and that got every one pretty much exited because its the first time an idol is revealing their relationship herself.
@@BLINKWORLD-26774 If they follow hybe artists does it mean hybe paid them? Pitchfork follows a total of 1263 people. If Hybe does something wrong it's not Hybe artists fault.
Alex was lttrly just saying her opinion about rosie. she was criticizing it but it a RESPECTFUL way. we should all be allowed to have our own views and opinions on certain things and alex was just expressing hers.
LoL if that's true there's y'all jenlisa moment 😂
Pitchfork even gave her a high review considering their history. I mean, when your whole album almost talks about the same topic, then you should play more with lyrics or sound to make it unique. Just like Olivia when she debuted and although people call her Swift's daughter, she has her own touch which makes her different. Right now, Rosé and Gracie Abrams fall into one category - Copy and Paste
It is absolutely NOT so-called 'copy and paste'. If you understand anything about music and music history, all genres and sub-genres of music are INFLUENCED by previous generations and new musicians make what came before them better while standing on the shoulders of giants. Music INFLUENCING has been the norm since the age of classical music and it is NOT so-called 'copying'. For example, Taylor Swift was INFLUENCED by the likes of Shania Twain, Dolly Parton. Faith Hill, etc.... in her earlier, country music years. As her career evolved, particularly with the release of her album 1989, her sound shifted towards synth-pop, INFLUENCED by 80s pop icons like Cyndi Lauper and Madonna. This transformation was also informed by more modern pop stars like Katy Perry and Lorde, blending nostalgia with contemporary styles. So, if you claim that Rosé and Gracie Abrams were so-called 'copying and pasting', then you will also have to claim the same for the likes of Taylor Swift, and that practically applies for every other musician in existence.
@ it is copy and paste but you are true to your opinion and that’s fine
@@musicinterest-dib And it is true to my opinion that it is absolutely and categorically NOT so-called 'copy and paste'. By the way, music INFLUENCE is not just my opinion, it is an established fact and that is how commercial music has evolved since the dawn of time.
@@IanSchultz-u3b Influence is being inspired by someone's approach to music and try it in yours - Olivia. Copy and paste is taking that approach, deliver the song the same way as the original artist, cover it with sound that can be found in early pop - Gracie and Rosie. Two totally different things. I feel like people mistake influence with what I meant. Don't think I don't like the album cause I do like it and I listen to it, but I cannot close my eyes for such thing and say what you say just because I am a Blink, cause I am one, I follow the girls and stream their stuff (without Lisa's cause I am disappointed by her releases except for Rockstar) but to me personality is above anything else (lyrics, melody, etc).
@@musicinterest-dib Firstly, I don't mistake what 'influence' in the context of music means. A simple definition is - 'music is a continuously evolving art form, and every new style, genre, or trend builds upon the musical traditions that preceded it. Elements like melody, harmony, rhythm, and even specific instruments have been passed down through time. Each new generation incorporates and reinterprets these elements, sometimes innovating on them, but still remaining connected to the past.' By the way, do you know what 'copy and paste' means ? From the perspective of music (as well as other aspects), it means taking something that has already been published EXACTLY without any changes to it, and claiming that to be your own. Another term for this is plagiarism. I'm sure that is not what you meant. If not, then you'll have to really define what you mean by 'copy and paste'
Stop spreading false information Jennie has not said anything about her album except it coming out next year
우리한테는 아직 세명의 소녀가 있다.
JENNIE SHOULDN'T HAVE LISA ON HER ALBUM. LISA IS HATED BY SO MANY FOR LIP SYNCING!!! JENNIE NEEDS TO KNOW WHAT SHE CAN OR CAN'T DO ON HER OWN!
As if Jennie can sing live too. 😂 She was drag for being out of tune in her activities like singing SPOT. Only Rosie can sing well!
Ahm..making assumptions about someone's personal life and their ability to feel emotions just because they didn't make a good review on your favourite artist's album...? Not cool...Grow some maturity please
Isn't that the same thing with your fandom ? When peppa pig rating was revealed your fandom was becoming dank in the quotes so if someone is stating facts why it's a problem the call should go to your home. And please teach that maturity lesson to your fellow mates also you might be sleeping because hybe is revealed to make a negative media against blackpink and it's truth no assumptions because if that's truth why not this? There's a possibility and every one is speculating and that hybe internal documents helps the assumptions I fear it's the truth 😥
They rated Taylor Swift album high when its subjectivly her WORST album but rose one IS low?
@@fukanoonwish999 what do you mean?.
@@BLINKWORLD-26774 If you are talking to me I'm in no fandom and i don't bit one against the other. You are missing the point of my comment
1:48 i agree to her btw
People are deaf then if they are saying that those lyrics is not providing clear message.
@BLINKWORLD-26774 i didn't like her album at all but I had high expectations
@@Luvvvlivvlifffe first of i and you know that anything blackpink members will release is not satisfactory to you so quit this high expectations because if you don't love that album you will not like any of the blackpink releases.
@@BLINKWORLD-26774 yk what I don't know how do u know me but lemme tell u it ain't like that, I love BLACKPINK even apt , mantra, pink venom were my top 3 songs of the year , i love them but as a fan I was criticizing, I'm swiftie so she was literally sounding like her so I couldn't help n I said it out, idk why is it so hard to digest this fact that I didn't like it much
@@Luvvvlivvlifffe let's be real rosè didn't sound like Taylor she sounded like herself and rosè always have this type of voice
Jenlichella ❤❤
Rosie❤