Sayed Ammar, thank you, you are a blessing to this world. Especially to those like me, born and raised in the west, not having the ability to comprehend Arabic lectures. You are the only person on either side that has approached all these topics with grace and the humility of going back to literature and not feelings to make your point.
THIS IS THE NUMBER ONE SHAI BOOK FORBIDDING MUT3AH We also find in Al-Kafi 5/1095 from Mohammad bin Yahya from Ahmad bin Mohammad from Mu’amar bin Khallad that he said: I asked Abu Al-Hasan Al-Redha - peace be upon him - about a man getting married to a women in mutah and taking her from country to another country? He said: The other type of marriage is permissible, and this type of marriage isn’t. THIS IS A THE NUMEBR ONE SHIA BOOKS FORBIDDING MUT3AH
@@abdulelkobaitry3402 ya he’s manipulating me using your books. Buddy I get it it was temporarily banned, we’re passed that. He has new video, refute those my friend
THIS IS THE NUMBER ONE SHAI BOOK FORBIDDING MUT3AH We also find in Al-Kafi 5/1095 from Mohammad bin Yahya from Ahmad bin Mohammad from Mu’amar bin Khallad that he said: I asked Abu Al-Hasan Al-Redha - peace be upon him - about a man getting married to a women in mutah and taking her from country to another country? He said: The other type of marriage is permissible, and this type of marriage isn’t. THIS IS A THE NUMEBR ONE SHIA BOOKS FORBIDDING MUT3AH
Salam brother . #1. We must accept the fact that the only authentic book on both sides is the Quran that being said we can’t be heedless of context as well and so both sides have 3 forms of Hadiths in regard to the matter that 1. allows mutah 2. that forbids mutah . 3, allows and forbid .. but you must ask your self simple question brother and the sunni brothers feel free to respond ..How can Umar ban something if it was already banned ????? Al Ayyashi, from Muhammad Bin Muslim, from Abu Ja'far as having said: 'Jabir Bin Abdullah said, from Rasool saww that he was on a military expedition with him, ' and he as Permitted the temporary marriage for them, and did not Prohibit it. And Ali as was saying: 'Had the son of Khattab (Umar) not preceded me as, none would have committed the adultery except for the wretched'
Wrong . The rope of Allah is Ali and so the ones who remained on the straight path I.e Ali alehi Salam and held on to him are his Shia and the ones who broke away from the sunnah of the prophet pbuh continue by the ahlul bayt are not
THIS IS THE NUMBER ONE SHAI BOOK FORBIDDING MUT3AH We also find in Al-Kafi 5/1095 from Mohammad bin Yahya from Ahmad bin Mohammad from Mu’amar bin Khallad that he said: I asked Abu Al-Hasan Al-Redha - peace be upon him - about a man getting married to a women in mutah and taking her from country to another country? He said: The other type of marriage is permissible, and this type of marriage isn’t. THIS IS A THE NUMEBR ONE SHIA BOOKS FORBIDDING MUT3AH
@@ruicastro8230 Yeah but but but omar ibin khatab is a caliph who was never voted in and we must follow him regardless because he was brave in all battles (always running away like a pu$$y)
@@abdulelkobaitry3402 Man, you are so desperate it is funny! lol Whatever you do, do not stick a grenade up your rear end! It is very bad for your health!" ;)
THIS IS THE NUMBER ONE SHAI BOOK FORBIDDING MUT3AH We also find in Al-Kafi 5/1095 from Mohammad bin Yahya from Ahmad bin Mohammad from Mu’amar bin Khallad that he said: I asked Abu Al-Hasan Al-Redha - peace be upon him - about a man getting married to a women in mutah and taking her from country to another country? He said: The other type of marriage is permissible, and this type of marriage isn’t. THIS IS A THE NUMEBR ONE SHIA BOOKS FORBIDDING MUT3AH
@@abdulelkobaitry3402 Brother, we have many narrations permitting Muta'a marriage and let's not forget it is permitted in the holy Quran in 4/24. Regarding this narration, it is about a specific case where the husband is going to take his Muta'a wife outside the country and here the Imam said that this is not permitted.
@@abdulelkobaitry3402 Go look at your own books before you read ours. Once you're convinced that they include nonsense, you'll realize how much ours make more sense.
@@abdulelkobaitry3402 a shay tan is resting under every hair of yours. Herre is a link to the volume you are referring to find that hadeeth you are talking about. thaqalayn.net/chapter/5/3/96
THIS IS THE NUMBER ONE SHAI BOOK FORBIDDING MUT3AH We also find in Al-Kafi 5/1095 from Mohammad bin Yahya from Ahmad bin Mohammad from Mu’amar bin Khallad that he said: I asked Abu Al-Hasan Al-Redha - peace be upon him - about a man getting married to a women in mutah and taking her from country to another country? He said: The other type of marriage is permissible, and this type of marriage isn’t. THIS IS A THE NUMEBR ONE SHIA BOOKS FORBIDDING MUT3AH
THIS IS THE NUMBER ONE SHAI BOOK FORBIDDING MUT3AH We also find in Al-Kafi 5/1095 from Mohammad bin Yahya from Ahmad bin Mohammad from Mu’amar bin Khallad that he said: I asked Abu Al-Hasan Al-Redha - peace be upon him - about a man getting married to a women in mutah and taking her from country to another country? He said: The other type of marriage is permissible, and this type of marriage isn’t. THIS IS A THE NUMEBR ONE SHIA BOOKS FORBIDDING MUT3AH
Agree all these books written by Bukahari Sahib Muslim all have fabricated Hadith paid money by Movieyah the worst enemy of Islam umayahads hv destroyed Islam
THIS IS THE NUMBER ONE SHAI BOOK FORBIDDING MUT3AH We also find in Al-Kafi 5/1095 from Mohammad bin Yahya from Ahmad bin Mohammad from Mu’amar bin Khallad that he said: I asked Abu Al-Hasan Al-Redha - peace be upon him - about a man getting married to a women in mutah and taking her from country to another country? He said: The other type of marriage is permissible, and this type of marriage isn’t. THIS IS A THE NUMEBR ONE SHIA BOOKS FORBIDDING MUT3AH
THIS IS THE NUMBER ONE SHAI BOOK FORBIDDING MUT3AH We also find in Al-Kafi 5/1095 from Mohammad bin Yahya from Ahmad bin Mohammad from Mu’amar bin Khallad that he said: I asked Abu Al-Hasan Al-Redha - peace be upon him - about a man getting married to a women in mutah and taking her from country to another country? He said: The other type of marriage is permissible, and this type of marriage isn’t. THIS IS A THE NUMEBR ONE SHIA BOOKS FORBIDDING MUT3AH
THIS IS THE NUMBER ONE SHAI BOOK FORBIDDING MUT3AH We also find in Al-Kafi 5/1095 from Mohammad bin Yahya from Ahmad bin Mohammad from Mu’amar bin Khallad that he said: I asked Abu Al-Hasan Al-Redha - peace be upon him - about a man getting married to a women in mutah and taking her from country to another country? He said: The other type of marriage is permissible, and this type of marriage isn’t. THIS IS A THE NUMEBR ONE SHIA BOOKS FORBIDDING MUT3AH
THIS IS THE NUMBER ONE SHAI BOOK FORBIDDING MUT3AH We also find in Al-Kafi 5/1095 from Mohammad bin Yahya from Ahmad bin Mohammad from Mu’amar bin Khallad that he said: I asked Abu Al-Hasan Al-Redha - peace be upon him - about a man getting married to a women in mutah and taking her from country to another country? He said: The other type of marriage is permissible, and this type of marriage isn’t. THIS IS A THE NUMEBR ONE SHIA BOOKS FORBIDDING MUT3AH
Thank you Imam Hussain TV3 and Dr. Sayed Ammar Nakhshawani for the information and dissecting Mut'ah marriage with many references from ONLY Sunni's books.. Allah swt bless and protect you always ⚘️
THIS IS THE NUMBER ONE SHAI BOOK FORBIDDING MUT3AH We also find in Al-Kafi 5/1095 from Mohammad bin Yahya from Ahmad bin Mohammad from Mu’amar bin Khallad that he said: I asked Abu Al-Hasan Al-Redha - peace be upon him - about a man getting married to a women in mutah and taking her from country to another country? He said: The other type of marriage is permissible, and this type of marriage isn’t. THIS IS A THE NUMEBR ONE SHIA BOOKS FORBIDDING MUT3AH
Mashallah. The amount of research to make this series can only be done by someone as talented as Sayed Ammar. It’s so satisfying to watch Sunni Islam implode 😂😂😂
THIS IS THE NUMBER ONE SHAI BOOK FORBIDDING MUT3AH We also find in Al-Kafi 5/1095 from Mohammad bin Yahya from Ahmad bin Mohammad from Mu’amar bin Khallad that he said: I asked Abu Al-Hasan Al-Redha - peace be upon him - about a man getting married to a women in mutah and taking her from country to another country? He said: The other type of marriage is permissible, and this type of marriage isn’t. THIS IS A THE NUMEBR ONE SHIA BOOKS FORBIDDING MUT3AH
At 36:10 It is quite facinating how you want to put emphasis on "Then I engaged in muttah with her" and totally ignore the next immediate words "Until the messenger of Allah ﷺ forbade it". If you ignored it because you think it was temporary. Then please read the next hadith where the Prophet ﷺ said "O people, I had permitted you to contract temporary marriage with women, but Allah has forbidden it (now) until the Day of Resurrection..." -- Sahih Muslim 1406d May Allah guide us.
@@rajsuhail "i can see who is arrogant" yeah just proved my point. what cherry picking? are you okay? if there is something he warped, it would make sense if it was cherry picked but he completely justified it. If a hadith is authentic and there shouldn't be any confusion for anyone to read, why is that cherry-picking? It's called one-sided history on your end, and he countered any arguments that your scholars had in their own books. May Allah guide you. 28:56 You surely cannot guide whoever you like ˹O Prophet˺, but it is Allah Who guides whoever He wills, and He knows best who are ˹fit to be˺ guided.
@@MindWit > "he countered any arguments that your scholars had in their own books" There was no counterargument. Ammar is just gaslighting people. Just listen to this with no bias and you will see the truth in front of you. I will give you one hadith to ponder on. What does this hadith mean where the Prophet ﷺ said "O people, I had permitted you to contract temporary marriage with women, but Allah has forbidden it (now) until the Day of Resurrection..." -- Sahih Muslim 1406d What does "UNTIL THE DAY OF RESURRECTION" mean? Can you find any Sahih hadith where it says the Mut'ah was banned before until the day of resurrection and now it is permitted again?
Dr. Sayed Ammar Nakshwani was brilliant and to the point. Once again he proved a Quranic fact beyond the shadow of a doubt. By the way there is no verse in the Quran abrogating verse 4:24. Meaning the verse of Mutah(4:24) is good until judgment day. Now it is time for me to rip apart Mufti Menk or Mufti fox, whatever he calls himself. He said this was pagan practice. Does he not read the Holy Quan? Does he not ponder upon it? Then for what reason is he turning a blind eye to the verse in the Holy Quran? What do we call when someone goes against the Verse of the Holy Quran and covers up a fact. Is that not Kofr? After all the word cover comes from the word Kofr from the Arabic Language. Now that we know the verse and the attempt to go against the verse and trying to cover it up by saying this was a Pagan practice, is he not insulting the Holy Quran? Is he not insulting the Holy Prophet? What does the Holy Quran say about such people? Surah Baqarah Ayat 159 in Arabic Text إِنَّ ٱلَّذِينَ يَكۡتُمُونَ مَآ أَنزَلۡنَا مِنَ ٱلۡبَيِّنَٰتِ وَٱلۡهُدَىٰ مِنۢ بَعۡدِ مَا بَيَّنَّـٰهُ لِلنَّاسِ فِي ٱلۡكِتَٰبِ أُوْلَـٰٓئِكَ يَلۡعَنُهُمُ ٱللَّهُ وَيَلۡعَنُهُمُ ٱللَّـٰعِنُونَ Innal lazeena yaktumoona maaa anzalnaa minal baiyinaati walhudaa mim ba’di maa baiyannaahu linnaasi fil kitaabi ulaaa’ika yal’anuhumul laahu wa yal’anuhumul laa ‘inoon English Translation Here you can read various translations of verse 159 Sahih International Indeed, those who conceal what We sent down of clear proofs and guidance after We made it clear for the people in the Scripture - those are cursed by Allah and cursed by those who curse, Yusuf Ali “Those who conceal the clear (Signs) We have sent down, and the Guidance, after We have made it clear for the people in the Book,-on them shall be Allah’s curse, and the curse of those entitled to curse,- Abul Ala Maududi Indeed Allah curses, and the cursers, too, curse those who conceal the clear teachings and guidance We have sent down, after We have made these plain in the Book for the guidance of all mankind.
THIS IS THE NUMBER ONE SHAI BOOK FORBIDDING MUT3AH We also find in Al-Kafi 5/1095 from Mohammad bin Yahya from Ahmad bin Mohammad from Mu’amar bin Khallad that he said: I asked Abu Al-Hasan Al-Redha - peace be upon him - about a man getting married to a women in mutah and taking her from country to another country? He said: The other type of marriage is permissible, and this type of marriage isn’t. THIS IS A THE NUMEBR ONE SHIA BOOKS FORBIDDING MUT3AH
What I find ironic is that most of these speakers corner dawah guys will preach and boast about “objective morality” when debating atheists and Christians. But when it comes to them trying to disprove mutah with fellow Muslims, they’ll use questions that appeal to ones subjectivity, emotions and “fitra” (Eg. “would you let your family or your sister do this?”) Who are you to undermine Allahs wisdom and what he made halal?
Please don’t insult our ahl sunnah brothers in the comment section. Leave our political differences aside we all are the part of Prophet Muhammed (PBUH)’s ummah.
You broke away from the rope of Allah i.e Imam Ali alehi Salam . Your argument is the argument of the bani Israel. Which is to say disregard the fact that we disobeyed and did not follow prophet Aaron as when he was left in charge because while Prophet Musa as was around we obeyed him
@@ruicastro8230 I am not saying anything but to follow your own marja and treat your brothers with respect. In many houses people live with different minds and opinions. Allah has given us the intellect to seek the truth. Not to curse at people who don’t believe what you and I believe in. Spreading negativity doesn’t help at all.
Brother I don’t follow a marja and to my understanding both the Sunni madhabs ( all 4) and Marjas are in opposition to the Rasul pbuh and the imams as who stated taqleed is the hellfire and that is in fact what ALL the scholars do on both sides and i can give you plenty of example but I don’t see anyone of us cursing anyone one here . So my question to you is do you have a problem with Cursing which is Sunnah of the momin or do you simply have a problem with the cursing of abu bakr and Umar? And please keep it a buck
You read the hadith about Mutah marriage in Sunan Nisai, but you left out the one that was above ; which was clearly prohibiting Mutah Marriage. This was very deceitful.
After Uthman, when Hazrat Ali (A. S) took over the chair of caliphate, is there his any clear take on Muta mentioned in any book. Please give the reference.
Alhamdulilah, I am a proud Shia of Ali (as). Due to Sunni sects hate toword Prophet and his progeny thus shia just because we are the follower of Prophet.. Why should we bother to save them? Why not leave them lost in the leaves of Ma-awia and Omar?
Omar in khatab has accumulated enough to fall his lowest in the matter of which Allah has permitted to mankind ( for sure Allah created this need for his creation and allowed it). Now we know that he did not care others except “ his likes and dislikes”. For sure he was a rebel to Allah and we know where man belong at the day of judgement.
Wow..u missed the part when they show how imam Hussein a.s comes to your grave if you had visited him in ur lifetime..it's most heart felt ❤😢😢😢...may he visit us all when we die. IA!
I dont know why its hard to understanding that There is verse of prohibition of alcohol in Quran kareem But there is no such verse about mutah in Quran
@@zehrakarmali6370 where in Quran it says that mutah is not allowed ? Or I guess u got me wrong ino there is a verse in Quran about mutah but nothing such to make it prohibited
THIS IS THE NUMBER ONE SHAI BOOK FORBIDDING MUT3AH We also find in Al-Kafi 5/1095 from Mohammad bin Yahya from Ahmad bin Mohammad from Mu’amar bin Khallad that he said: I asked Abu Al-Hasan Al-Redha - peace be upon him - about a man getting married to a women in mutah and taking her from country to another country? He said: The other type of marriage is permissible, and this type of marriage isn’t. THIS IS A THE NUMEBR ONE SHIA BOOKS FORBIDDING MUT3AH
In Sahih Muslim it was also forbidden. Mutah marriage also doesn't satisfy the rules of inheritance from Husband for his wife.There was also time when people didn't have to perform Prayer 5 times a day. There was also time when PROPHET MUHAMMAD (PBUH) was performing prayer not facing KABA.When ALLAH(SBH) TOLD HIM TO FACE KABA THEN HE STARTED PERFORMING PRAYER FACING KABA. HE IS ALSO TALKING ABOUT SHIA AND SUNNI. SHIA AND SUNNI CREATED BY OURSELVES. PROPHET MUHAMMAD DIDN'T CREATE SHIA OR SUNNI.
The reason Prophet gave permission was because the companions were away from their wives. But today Shia practice Muta while residing happily with their wives, they practice it with their maids or whoever they fancy. I have witnessed it personally.
THIS IS THE NUMBER ONE SHAI BOOK FORBIDDING MUT3AH We also find in Al-Kafi 5/1095 from Mohammad bin Yahya from Ahmad bin Mohammad from Mu’amar bin Khallad that he said: I asked Abu Al-Hasan Al-Redha - peace be upon him - about a man getting married to a women in mutah and taking her from country to another country? He said: The other type of marriage is permissible, and this type of marriage isn’t. THIS IS A THE NUMEBR ONE SHIA BOOKS FORBIDDING MUT3AH
Saying mut3a was part of the teaching of the prophet saw because it was made Haram later on, is like saying alcohol was part of teaching of prophet saw, astaghfirallah
Riadhus saliheen - volume on nikkah - says that temporary marriage is allowed but not preferable. It is not outlawed in the Koran. It might have been that mutah was outlawed only on the day of the battle. Perhaps the Prophet AS felt that the men were going to be unruly on the day of battle. There is another account that some sahabah asked the Prophet if they could marry temporarily when they were on the way to battle or expedition. He said that he didn't like it - I suggest that the Prophet AS didn't want his men to be distracted when on a mission as excessive practice leads to the fall of men, with strange women. Such excessive practices defeat the idea of love and marriage. Unmarried women feel resentful that their men are marrying strange women and they, themselves are unsaturated. Such men are accountable before Allah for leaving their duties and leaving them alone.
It is not haram and it is mentioned in Quran sura 4 verse 24 & better than sunni temporary marriages like Siahi marriage Mosiaf, Damm, Rammil or sand,orrfi,Missiar ,Misfar , and marriage with the intention of divorce the male's intention is to divorce his wife without telling her about his intention & more !!!!!
Clearly not listened to the lecture it was banned and allowed again it was banned before battles as intimacy makes you weak that's even a scientific fact. Hence boxers abstain from intimacy before training or a fight.
Stones are waiting for him in Akehra while his order was caused adultery ( a basic need which was allowed by Allah and to fulfill this need through adultery continued. He is responsible for this while he band it. Only someone whose heart did not accept Islam deep through its core would confront, misrepresent it. See what he has done through out his life. We all know it well
I believe Mut'ah marriage was banned during multiple events because the Companions didn't do it correctly. Two Companions went to a woman SIMULTANEOUSLY to ask for marriage. Simultaneously asking and competing for a marriage from a woman is not allowed for any type of marriage. The approach is likely to cause hatred, jealousy, and potential fight between the two companions. Rasulullah forbid to ask a woman for a marriage by a group of men. Companions kept repeating similar mistakes when making Mut'ah during military expeditions. So Mut'ah marriage is allowed, but the method of doing it must be correct.
33:22 - pretty much 'seals the deal'... it's definitely not a nice thing to use a piece of information and totally neglect another to prove a point. Especially when the other piece(s) of information are just as important.... this type of 'cherry picking' is done to mislead individuals... The brother presented things in an orderly and straightforward manner. Of course this is just the tip of the iceberg.
Question: Didn’t it say in sahih muslim - book of marriage page 25, [3422] that the Messenger of Allah s.a.w.a forbade the mutah marriage? The page was in the video. Im a bit confused..
It was a temporary ban according to Muslim not a permanent one. Watch the whole video he clearly covers Ahadith that contradict each other about when mutah was forbidden
@@jojoszn9684 the better question to ask is that if temporary marriage was permanently banned, why did Umar have to shed light on it after not only the Prophet’s death but Abu Bakr’s death and forbid mutah? And why were there Sahabah who did mutah after the Prophet’s death?
@@ghalibahmed6676wait but why didn’t Mr Syed Nakshawani read Book of marriage 3422? Maybe because it wouldn’t help his case??? He really fucked up there he shouldn’t had showed that page because I would’ve actually believed him
At least it'll save us from zina. The community will know about your relationship. It can be used positively as a form of halal dating until permanent marriage as well. Go and read about the rules and laws governing it. You'll embrace it wholeheartedly. It's just the process of normal marriages but the difference is time
Marshallah, Sayed Ammar you do justice to your Ph.D. Unlike some Muslim pseudo scholars you provide evidence from the Sunni school that support Shia believe and practices. I am having a dim view of Omar just now. Just like non Muslims scoff about we marrying up to 4 wives (with conditions) and they keeping mistresses ( no issue for them) Mutah makes our temporary desire Halal while Omar's prohibition cause our desperate Sheikhs to go to Lebanon, Africa and the West to commit zena. Thanks to Omar.
how many ties or with how many women can you do Muta? would you allow your daughters/ sisters/mothers to practice Muta? how many times with how many men?
I think the timing of these topics is completely off (I might be getting ahead of myself here as I don’t know what else is in store)!! In a time when we need to talk of what unifies us as ummah.. we are still focusing on the same old topics that divide us. Muttah, tabbarah on Ashaab and wives of the Prophet SAW, Taraweeh etc. come on man, talk about unity, talk about common ground and if you really want to clean up the yard, start with the practices within the school of Ahlul Bayt which are innovations rather than focusing on someone else’s backyard. We need a voice of reason in times like these.. our common ground is Quran and despite of the Shia Sunni divide, this will always be the single source of truth and unifier. You can beat around the bush all you want..
Trying to get leverage on Mufti menks and asseem al hakim backs and to obtain popularity.. They are a different class mate.. Its so clear the sources are not contradicting each other, it can also mean there is a possibility He, saw forbade it more than once, on more then one occassion.. Try harder to obtain subscribers.. Mufti menk and asseem al hakeem dont have ads on their channels, Fear Allah.. Would you allow your sister or mother to engage in Mutah? If they fall in the "category"
Yes that’s what u take from this lecture. Smh. I understand the lectures struck your ego and you do not want to be proved wrong. But what is right is right what is wrong is wrong.
@@mohamedddd983 Your response is subjective not objective mate.. Its clear to see who even looks similar to the sunnah by appearance.. Which companion or member of the ahlul bait had a fade or tatts.. Use logic
@@mohamedddd983 As a muslim male I would have loved for Mutah to be still allowed its in my interest.. But like you said what is right is right what is wrong is wrong.. Lets assume for a moment it is still allowed and you do not practise it, what sin have you committed by being wary and trying to be on the safe side by not practising it.. And then assume its truly not allowed but some scholars just cant get a hold of thinking off their willy, isnt that a dangerous risk to take?? Come on man its so logical especially for us the lay men to be on the safe side
You mean they were funded by billions of $s from their countries to do what they do and force their ideologies and viewpoints on Islam to the world stage? Yeah
You must have missed the hadiths where it clearly states the Sahara did it until Umar prevented it. Assim al hakeem and mufti men are different class as they don't know their own books
It's still no better than prostitution. Using Ibn Khathir's tafseer and claiming it's the Qur'aan allowing 'mut'ah' marriage is wrong. The whole of Surah 4 is about protecting the rights of Muslim women, most importantly giving a dowry as part of the marriage contract, while for a slave girl, the Qur'aan prohibits concubinage, even if too many Sunni scholars allowed this. When a marriage is consummated, there is a minimum waiting period of three monthly courses before a divorce. In modern times, 'mut'ah' is simply a device for seeking out prostitutes. Did 'mut'ah' actually exist in the Prophet's[saw] life time? Are the ahadith quoted by Ibn Khathir accurate? We know for definite the practice of 'zihar' divorce existed, as the Qur'aan forbids it.
I have a serious question. In the month of ramadan instead of focusing on good deeds, repenting and doing lots of ibadah. Why are you going to give lectures in sectarian issues which will cause division in the ummah. This is no hate but a serious question
Because what Allab has allowed ymar forbade and he's bringing the real face of umar to the to the world. Paul brought what's Christianity today and umar brought what's sunnism is today. 😅
@@tawabturkmani1838 you know that sunni scholars have answered these objections right? Anyways. Again this is what's wrong it 's always focus on post prophetic islam and not the 99% we have in common as the entire muslim ummah. We have one label and that is muslims as given by the quran. You are seriously worried about if mutah was made impermissable wrongfully do you seriously think you will be asked about this on the day of judgement? May Allah guide as all and protect us from sectarianism
😂 in every Hadith he brought it said the prophet FORBADE IT, whether it was at khaybar, Hunain, Conquest of Mecca. Umar FORBABDE IT because the prophet forbade it. ALI FORBADE IT because the prophet forbade it. FORBADE IT, FORBADE IT, FORBADE IT. Key word here that is mentioned again and again; FORBADE.
The sheik also said it was stopped by the prophet saw during his life saw, we don't make fun of its historically we make fun of yous marrying of your daughters temporarily
So Umar ra was only reminding and implying the teaching of the prophet as you have just showed us in about 10 narrations it tells us the prophet forbade it. For Muslims that won't around when this happened didn't know, there was no social media back then. You act smart but your really not wallah the weakest points I've ever seen
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 bro because of a difference of opinion you think you've outsmarted everyone, explain to us how some shias say Ali will be our lord on the day of judgement 😂😂😂😂😂😂 bahah oh another difference of opinion in shia schools , well Wich one is ya Ammar Al kalb
I don't understand how dumb people can be he literally shows something the shiekh says and then babbles on something that doesn't answer the question at hand bahahah
So there is a difference on a opinion on the time it was made haram😂 you know how much difference of options there is in shia books bahahahahahahah brother gooo homee
So there was another opinion in sahih Muslim somebody clap for him please😂😂😂 all opinions lead to the same conclusion 😂😂😂😂😂😂 umm can you explain how wiping peices of cloth on the grave of a sheikh bring blessing. Ohhhh this is a difference of opinion is it bahahahah so Wich one is ya kethabbb
11imams plus imam Mahdi and his 4 representatives more than 300 yrs were present after prophet Mohammed s.w. passed away ,prophet Mohammed said follow the Quran & my purified Ahlu al beit in 6 Sunni Sahih books ,Egyption Dr.Mohammad Hedaiah confirmed it it is Ahlu al beit they have the true interpretation of the Quran and the true hadiths
THIS IS THE NUMBER ONE SHAI BOOK FORBIDDING MUT3AH We also find in Al-Kafi 5/1095 from Mohammad bin Yahya from Ahmad bin Mohammad from Mu’amar bin Khallad that he said: I asked Abu Al-Hasan Al-Redha - peace be upon him - about a man getting married to a women in mutah and taking her from country to another country? He said: The other type of marriage is permissible, and this type of marriage isn’t. THIS IS A THE NUMEBR ONE SHIA BOOKS FORBIDDING MUT3AH
Sayed Ammar, thank you, you are a blessing to this world. Especially to those like me, born and raised in the west, not having the ability to comprehend Arabic lectures. You are the only person on either side that has approached all these topics with grace and the humility of going back to literature and not feelings to make your point.
THIS IS THE NUMBER ONE SHAI BOOK FORBIDDING MUT3AH We also find in Al-Kafi 5/1095 from Mohammad bin Yahya from Ahmad bin Mohammad from Mu’amar bin Khallad that he said: I asked Abu Al-Hasan Al-Redha - peace be upon him - about a man getting married to a women in mutah and taking her from country to another country? He said: The other type of marriage is permissible, and this type of marriage isn’t. THIS IS A THE NUMEBR ONE SHIA BOOKS FORBIDDING MUT3AH
He's only manipulating you
@@abdulelkobaitry3402 ya he’s manipulating me using your books. Buddy I get it it was temporarily banned, we’re passed that. He has new video, refute those my friend
@@abdulelkobaitry3402 CRY HARD NASIBI! CRY MORE!
He is the one who has done many Muth with the girls just because he is not married yet .
Dr. Sayed Ammar Nakshwani is TOP G
Mashallah syed dissected the issue of mutah for the people 😂 have some shame all sunni brothers..stop covering the crimes of ummar bin khattab
THIS IS THE NUMBER ONE SHAI BOOK FORBIDDING MUT3AH We also find in Al-Kafi 5/1095 from Mohammad bin Yahya from Ahmad bin Mohammad from Mu’amar bin Khallad that he said: I asked Abu Al-Hasan Al-Redha - peace be upon him - about a man getting married to a women in mutah and taking her from country to another country? He said: The other type of marriage is permissible, and this type of marriage isn’t. THIS IS A THE NUMEBR ONE SHIA BOOKS FORBIDDING MUT3AH
Salam brother . #1. We must accept the fact that the only authentic book on both sides is the Quran that being said we can’t be heedless of context as well and so both sides have 3 forms of Hadiths in regard to the matter that 1. allows mutah 2. that forbids mutah . 3, allows and forbid .. but you must ask your self simple question brother and the sunni brothers feel free to respond ..How can Umar ban something if it was already banned ?????
Al Ayyashi, from Muhammad Bin Muslim,
from Abu Ja'far as having said: 'Jabir Bin Abdullah said, from Rasool saww that he was on a military expedition with him,
' and he as Permitted the temporary marriage for them, and did not Prohibit it. And Ali as was saying: 'Had the son of Khattab (Umar) not preceded me as, none would have committed the adultery except for the wretched'
I love Shia Islam!!!The Islam of Rasulullah, Salawat.
Shia islam? Islam is islam dont divide the ummah in friqas
Wrong . The rope of Allah is Ali and so the ones who remained on the straight path I.e Ali alehi Salam and held on to him are his Shia and the ones who broke away from the sunnah of the prophet pbuh continue by the ahlul bayt are not
THIS IS THE NUMBER ONE SHAI BOOK FORBIDDING MUT3AH We also find in Al-Kafi 5/1095 from Mohammad bin Yahya from Ahmad bin Mohammad from Mu’amar bin Khallad that he said: I asked Abu Al-Hasan Al-Redha - peace be upon him - about a man getting married to a women in mutah and taking her from country to another country? He said: The other type of marriage is permissible, and this type of marriage isn’t. THIS IS A THE NUMEBR ONE SHIA BOOKS FORBIDDING MUT3AH
@@ruicastro8230 Yeah but but but omar ibin khatab is a caliph who was never voted in and we must follow him regardless because he was brave in all battles (always running away like a pu$$y)
@@abdulelkobaitry3402 Man, you are so desperate it is funny! lol
Whatever you do, do not stick a grenade up your rear end! It is very bad for your health!" ;)
He proved Muta'a is allowed without touching any Shia book. That is the power of Shiism.
THIS IS THE NUMBER ONE SHAI BOOK FORBIDDING MUT3AH We also find in Al-Kafi 5/1095 from Mohammad bin Yahya from Ahmad bin Mohammad from Mu’amar bin Khallad that he said: I asked Abu Al-Hasan Al-Redha - peace be upon him - about a man getting married to a women in mutah and taking her from country to another country? He said: The other type of marriage is permissible, and this type of marriage isn’t. THIS IS A THE NUMEBR ONE SHIA BOOKS FORBIDDING MUT3AH
This the power your talking about ^
@@abdulelkobaitry3402 Brother, we have many narrations permitting Muta'a marriage and let's not forget it is permitted in the holy Quran in 4/24. Regarding this narration, it is about a specific case where the husband is going to take his Muta'a wife outside the country and here the Imam said that this is not permitted.
@@abdulelkobaitry3402 Go look at your own books before you read ours. Once you're convinced that they include nonsense, you'll realize how much ours make more sense.
@@abdulelkobaitry3402 a shay tan is resting under every hair of yours.
Herre is a link to the volume you are referring to find that hadeeth you are talking about.
thaqalayn.net/chapter/5/3/96
Alhamdulillah! This will be an excellent series. I hope the Sunnis will learn from this wonderful brother.
THIS IS THE NUMBER ONE SHAI BOOK FORBIDDING MUT3AH We also find in Al-Kafi 5/1095 from Mohammad bin Yahya from Ahmad bin Mohammad from Mu’amar bin Khallad that he said: I asked Abu Al-Hasan Al-Redha - peace be upon him - about a man getting married to a women in mutah and taking her from country to another country? He said: The other type of marriage is permissible, and this type of marriage isn’t. THIS IS A THE NUMEBR ONE SHIA BOOKS FORBIDDING MUT3AH
I’m tired of seeing Shias disrespected. Speak the truth! At whatever cost.
Subhanallah, another knowledgeable Ramadan from Sayed Ammar. #Facts
THIS IS THE NUMBER ONE SHAI BOOK FORBIDDING MUT3AH We also find in Al-Kafi 5/1095 from Mohammad bin Yahya from Ahmad bin Mohammad from Mu’amar bin Khallad that he said: I asked Abu Al-Hasan Al-Redha - peace be upon him - about a man getting married to a women in mutah and taking her from country to another country? He said: The other type of marriage is permissible, and this type of marriage isn’t. THIS IS A THE NUMEBR ONE SHIA BOOKS FORBIDDING MUT3AH
@@abdulelkobaitry3402 “and taking her from country to another country”
I am Shia i thank my father everyday for becoming Shia then I did then my whole family, we frm AfG
Dr Sayed Ammar destroying them from their own books. What a legend! he’s a blessing.
Agree all these books written by Bukahari Sahib Muslim all have fabricated Hadith paid money by Movieyah the worst enemy of Islam umayahads hv destroyed Islam
Yes, but it is not about destroying. It’s about all of us learning, both Shia and sunni
what is the purpose of this comment? The whole point of this series is to build unity and you talk about destruction. smh
THIS IS THE NUMBER ONE SHAI BOOK FORBIDDING MUT3AH We also find in Al-Kafi 5/1095 from Mohammad bin Yahya from Ahmad bin Mohammad from Mu’amar bin Khallad that he said: I asked Abu Al-Hasan Al-Redha - peace be upon him - about a man getting married to a women in mutah and taking her from country to another country? He said: The other type of marriage is permissible, and this type of marriage isn’t. THIS IS A THE NUMEBR ONE SHIA BOOKS FORBIDDING MUT3AH
"Destroying their argument" - I'm sure is what you mean!
Sayed Ammar my brother.
May Allah bless you with Infinite blessings and wisdom.
You are a phenomenal man.
May Allah bless all of us in this world.
THIS IS THE NUMBER ONE SHAI BOOK FORBIDDING MUT3AH We also find in Al-Kafi 5/1095 from Mohammad bin Yahya from Ahmad bin Mohammad from Mu’amar bin Khallad that he said: I asked Abu Al-Hasan Al-Redha - peace be upon him - about a man getting married to a women in mutah and taking her from country to another country? He said: The other type of marriage is permissible, and this type of marriage isn’t. THIS IS A THE NUMEBR ONE SHIA BOOKS FORBIDDING MUT3AH
THIS IS THE NUMBER ONE SHAI BOOK FORBIDDING MUT3AH We also find in Al-Kafi 5/1095 from Mohammad bin Yahya from Ahmad bin Mohammad from Mu’amar bin Khallad that he said: I asked Abu Al-Hasan Al-Redha - peace be upon him - about a man getting married to a women in mutah and taking her from country to another country? He said: The other type of marriage is permissible, and this type of marriage isn’t. THIS IS A THE NUMEBR ONE SHIA BOOKS FORBIDDING MUT3AH
Imam Ali peace be upon him said " You can not fight the truth because it will always prevail.
THIS IS THE NUMBER ONE SHAI BOOK FORBIDDING MUT3AH We also find in Al-Kafi 5/1095 from Mohammad bin Yahya from Ahmad bin Mohammad from Mu’amar bin Khallad that he said: I asked Abu Al-Hasan Al-Redha - peace be upon him - about a man getting married to a women in mutah and taking her from country to another country? He said: The other type of marriage is permissible, and this type of marriage isn’t. THIS IS A THE NUMEBR ONE SHIA BOOKS FORBIDDING MUT3AH
Exaclyy so explain that ^
😂 this guy crying all over the comments cause his books go against him. Go home Abdulkobe, yall got finished like Aisha at Jamal😂
Thank you Imam Hussain TV3 and Dr. Sayed Ammar Nakhshawani for the information and dissecting Mut'ah marriage with many references from ONLY Sunni's books.. Allah swt bless and protect you always ⚘️
Excellent Research...God bless you
THIS IS THE NUMBER ONE SHAI BOOK FORBIDDING MUT3AH We also find in Al-Kafi 5/1095 from Mohammad bin Yahya from Ahmad bin Mohammad from Mu’amar bin Khallad that he said: I asked Abu Al-Hasan Al-Redha - peace be upon him - about a man getting married to a women in mutah and taking her from country to another country? He said: The other type of marriage is permissible, and this type of marriage isn’t. THIS IS A THE NUMEBR ONE SHIA BOOKS FORBIDDING MUT3AH
Hatta naha unhu Umar (memorize it kids)
Mashallah. The amount of research to make this series can only be done by someone as talented as Sayed Ammar. It’s so satisfying to watch Sunni Islam implode 😂😂😂
Because you are your own channel you have not religion only witchcraft and do mutta carry on😂
Helpfull informative And BelieveAble And Now Clear My Whole Concepts about Mut,a
Wow , a big respect for Sayed Ammar Nakshawani who really proved that muta’a is allowed. You are a real son of Mutah ya Sayed Ammar proud of you
Go redo your Wudu. (Read Surah Maidah ayat 6 in Arabic)
Shia: deen of rasulaallah swt
Others : deen of omar 😂
😂😂😂😂😂😂
Ya musaylamah ya kethab
THIS IS THE NUMBER ONE SHAI BOOK FORBIDDING MUT3AH We also find in Al-Kafi 5/1095 from Mohammad bin Yahya from Ahmad bin Mohammad from Mu’amar bin Khallad that he said: I asked Abu Al-Hasan Al-Redha - peace be upon him - about a man getting married to a women in mutah and taking her from country to another country? He said: The other type of marriage is permissible, and this type of marriage isn’t. THIS IS A THE NUMEBR ONE SHIA BOOKS FORBIDDING MUT3AH
@@abdulelkobaitry3402kable online. Send a link to the hadeeth. I challenge you.
At 36:10 It is quite facinating how you want to put emphasis on "Then I engaged in muttah with her" and totally ignore the next immediate words "Until the messenger of Allah ﷺ forbade it". If you ignored it because you think it was temporary. Then please read the next hadith where the Prophet ﷺ said "O people, I had permitted you to contract temporary marriage with women, but Allah has forbidden it (now) until the Day of Resurrection..." -- Sahih Muslim 1406d
May Allah guide us.
He already disproved that point in the other texts. Wow you are arrogant.
@@MindWit I can see who is arrogant. Cherry picking Hadiths won't get anyone of us anywhere.
May Allah guide us
@@rajsuhail "i can see who is arrogant" yeah just proved my point. what cherry picking? are you okay? if there is something he warped, it would make sense if it was cherry picked but he completely justified it. If a hadith is authentic and there shouldn't be any confusion for anyone to read, why is that cherry-picking? It's called one-sided history on your end, and he countered any arguments that your scholars had in their own books. May Allah guide you.
28:56
You surely cannot guide whoever you like ˹O Prophet˺, but it is Allah Who guides whoever He wills, and He knows best who are ˹fit to be˺ guided.
@@MindWit > "he countered any arguments that your scholars had in their own books"
There was no counterargument.
Ammar is just gaslighting people. Just listen to this with no bias and you will see the truth in front of you. I will give you one hadith to ponder on. What does this hadith mean where the Prophet ﷺ said "O people, I had permitted you to contract temporary marriage with women, but Allah has forbidden it (now) until the Day of Resurrection..." -- Sahih Muslim 1406d
What does "UNTIL THE DAY OF RESURRECTION" mean?
Can you find any Sahih hadith where it says the Mut'ah was banned before until the day of resurrection and now it is permitted again?
@@rajsuhail This hadith is unreliable to start with. Who narrated this? And Ammar already showed why it's invalid/a contradiction.
May Allah bless you sheikh
El estudio es la base del éxito, gracias sayed Ammar ,por compartir conocimiento con nosotros !!!❤❤❤❤❤❤
Dr. Sayed Ammar Nakshwani was brilliant and to the point. Once again he proved a Quranic fact beyond the shadow of a doubt.
By the way there is no verse in the Quran abrogating verse 4:24. Meaning the verse of Mutah(4:24) is good until judgment day.
Now it is time for me to rip apart Mufti Menk or Mufti fox, whatever he calls himself.
He said this was pagan practice. Does he not read the Holy Quan? Does he not ponder upon it? Then for what reason is he turning a blind eye to the verse in the Holy Quran? What do we call when someone goes against the Verse of the Holy Quran and covers up a fact. Is that not Kofr? After all the word cover comes from the word Kofr from the Arabic Language.
Now that we know the verse and the attempt to go against the verse and trying to cover it up by saying this was a Pagan practice,
is he not insulting the Holy Quran? Is he not insulting the Holy Prophet? What does the Holy Quran say about such people?
Surah Baqarah Ayat 159 in Arabic Text
إِنَّ ٱلَّذِينَ يَكۡتُمُونَ مَآ أَنزَلۡنَا مِنَ ٱلۡبَيِّنَٰتِ وَٱلۡهُدَىٰ مِنۢ بَعۡدِ مَا بَيَّنَّـٰهُ لِلنَّاسِ فِي ٱلۡكِتَٰبِ أُوْلَـٰٓئِكَ يَلۡعَنُهُمُ ٱللَّهُ وَيَلۡعَنُهُمُ ٱللَّـٰعِنُونَ
Innal lazeena yaktumoona maaa anzalnaa minal baiyinaati walhudaa mim ba’di maa baiyannaahu linnaasi fil kitaabi ulaaa’ika yal’anuhumul laahu wa yal’anuhumul laa ‘inoon
English Translation
Here you can read various translations of verse 159
Sahih International
Indeed, those who conceal what We sent down of clear proofs and guidance after We made it clear for the people in the Scripture - those are cursed by Allah and cursed by those who curse,
Yusuf Ali
“Those who conceal the clear (Signs) We have sent down, and the Guidance, after We have made it clear for the people in the Book,-on them shall be Allah’s curse, and the curse of those entitled to curse,-
Abul Ala Maududi
Indeed Allah curses, and the cursers, too, curse those who conceal the clear teachings and guidance We have sent down, after We have made these plain in the Book for the guidance of all mankind.
THIS IS THE NUMBER ONE SHAI BOOK FORBIDDING MUT3AH We also find in Al-Kafi 5/1095 from Mohammad bin Yahya from Ahmad bin Mohammad from Mu’amar bin Khallad that he said: I asked Abu Al-Hasan Al-Redha - peace be upon him - about a man getting married to a women in mutah and taking her from country to another country? He said: The other type of marriage is permissible, and this type of marriage isn’t. THIS IS A THE NUMEBR ONE SHIA BOOKS FORBIDDING MUT3AH
Don't lie to yourself we can make alcohol and drugs halal if we use your understanding
@@abdulelkobaitry3402 do it, see you on judgement day.
@@abdulelkobaitry3402
Dear brother,
Imam Reza is talking about moving from country to country with temporary partner.
Please try more🥲
@@abdulelkobaitry3402 You already did make it legal. Omar drank alcohol and so did mawia and yazid
What I find ironic is that most of these speakers corner dawah guys will preach and boast about “objective morality” when debating atheists and Christians.
But when it comes to them trying to disprove mutah with fellow Muslims, they’ll use questions that appeal to ones subjectivity, emotions and “fitra”
(Eg. “would you let your family or your sister do this?”)
Who are you to undermine Allahs wisdom and what he made halal?
Alhamdulillah
Thought provoking for......
Great❤
JazakAllah, amazing series. Could at the end Sayed do an episode on unity and how can it be achieved
Mashallah
Let's leave all aside and ask this, can an ayah of the Qur'an be abrogated by a hadīth?
hassan allahyari & syed ammar should have a podcast together!!
احسنت
Ahsant
Please don’t insult our ahl sunnah brothers in the comment section. Leave our political differences aside we all are the part of Prophet Muhammed (PBUH)’s ummah.
You broke away from the rope of Allah i.e Imam Ali alehi Salam . Your argument is the argument of the bani Israel. Which is to say disregard the fact that we disobeyed and did not follow prophet Aaron as when he was left in charge because while Prophet Musa as was around we obeyed him
@@ruicastro8230 I am not saying anything but to follow your own marja and treat your brothers with respect. In many houses people live with different minds and opinions. Allah has given us the intellect to seek the truth. Not to curse at people who don’t believe what you and I believe in. Spreading negativity doesn’t help at all.
@@Ishi1XP You ignorant clown. Calling the differences "political". Are you serious? It's religious differences, nothing political about it.
Brother I don’t follow a marja and to my understanding both the Sunni madhabs ( all 4) and Marjas are in opposition to the Rasul pbuh and the imams as who stated taqleed is the hellfire and that is in fact what ALL the scholars do on both sides and i can give you plenty of example but I don’t see anyone of us cursing anyone one here . So my question to you is do you have a problem with Cursing which is Sunnah of the momin or do you simply have a problem with the cursing of abu bakr and Umar? And please keep it a buck
❤❤❤
I love him🤣🤣🤣🤣
Nobody have a right to change world of Allah even a prophet
You read the hadith about Mutah marriage in Sunan Nisai, but you left out the one that was above ; which was clearly prohibiting Mutah Marriage. This was very deceitful.
After Uthman, when Hazrat Ali (A. S) took over the chair of caliphate, is there his any clear take on Muta mentioned in any book. Please give the reference.
❤
I need some of your books. Am in ghana
please, do not disrespect out Sunni brothers with unnecessary comments or animosity. Let's learn from eachother to become better Muslims.
Brother , Shias sects are being disrespected even today , Syed Ammar is stating facts from the Sunni books - can’t see how Syed Ammar has disrespected
How many people here would be happy with their sisters or mothers doing a mutah marriage?
Would you ask that same question to umar? Or abu bakr? Or even the prophet (pbuh)? Please bro enough with the ridiculous question
💡💡💡💡💡
Alhamdulilah, I am a proud Shia of Ali (as).
Due to Sunni sects hate toword Prophet and his progeny thus shia just because we are the follower of Prophet.. Why should we bother to save them? Why not leave them lost in the leaves of Ma-awia and Omar?
Why support Palestine they kill shia
Omar in khatab has accumulated enough to fall his lowest in the matter of which Allah has permitted to mankind ( for sure Allah created this need for his creation and allowed it). Now we know that he did not care others except “ his likes and dislikes”. For sure he was a rebel to Allah and we know where man belong at the day of judgement.
Is there any hadith stating complete banned ??
Sala, FYI - I don’t think anyone watches the first 6 minutes and rather skip straight to the lecture. So not sure if there is a need for it.
I was looking for the comment that says when the actual thing starts 😂 so thank you
Wow..u missed the part when they show how imam Hussein a.s comes to your grave if you had visited him in ur lifetime..it's most heart felt ❤😢😢😢...may he visit us all when we die. IA!
@@sakinakassam2434 well then they should add it as a separate video.
So what does this mean?
"i did not come out until messanger of ALLAH forbade it"
Man i need the references written here in the comments, i cant find them 😂
I dont know why its hard to understanding that
There is verse of prohibition of alcohol in Quran kareem
But there is no such verse about mutah in Quran
Ofcourse there is only if you all read the Quran properly n understand not from wrong sources ok
@@zehrakarmali6370 where in Quran it says that mutah is not allowed ? Or I guess u got me wrong ino there is a verse in Quran about mutah but nothing such to make it prohibited
@@zehrakarmali6370 can you give me reference, don't lie mam
YOU MISSED IT TO READ CAREFULLY IS TO DO THE CORECT TAFSEER
THIS IS THE NUMBER ONE SHAI BOOK FORBIDDING MUT3AH We also find in Al-Kafi 5/1095 from Mohammad bin Yahya from Ahmad bin Mohammad from Mu’amar bin Khallad that he said: I asked Abu Al-Hasan Al-Redha - peace be upon him - about a man getting married to a women in mutah and taking her from country to another country? He said: The other type of marriage is permissible, and this type of marriage isn’t. THIS IS A THE NUMEBR ONE SHIA BOOKS FORBIDDING MUT3AH
In Sahih Muslim it was also forbidden. Mutah marriage also doesn't satisfy the rules of inheritance from Husband for his wife.There was also time when people didn't have to perform Prayer 5 times a day.
There was also time when PROPHET MUHAMMAD (PBUH) was performing prayer not facing KABA.When ALLAH(SBH) TOLD HIM TO FACE KABA THEN HE STARTED PERFORMING PRAYER FACING KABA.
HE IS ALSO TALKING ABOUT SHIA AND SUNNI.
SHIA AND SUNNI CREATED BY OURSELVES. PROPHET MUHAMMAD DIDN'T CREATE SHIA OR SUNNI.
Hatta naha anhu umar 😂😅
Bro when he repeated that like 20 times it was super annoying. I had to mute it till he was done
@MuhammadAbdullah-pe2ze lol 😆 no it was fun for me... I couldn't stop laughing 😅🤣
The reason Prophet gave permission was because the companions were away from their wives. But today Shia practice Muta while residing happily with their wives, they practice it with their maids or whoever they fancy. I have witnessed it personally.
It's quite simple, they reject it because they prefer deception.
THIS IS THE NUMBER ONE SHAI BOOK FORBIDDING MUT3AH We also find in Al-Kafi 5/1095 from Mohammad bin Yahya from Ahmad bin Mohammad from Mu’amar bin Khallad that he said: I asked Abu Al-Hasan Al-Redha - peace be upon him - about a man getting married to a women in mutah and taking her from country to another country? He said: The other type of marriage is permissible, and this type of marriage isn’t. THIS IS A THE NUMEBR ONE SHIA BOOKS FORBIDDING MUT3AH
Can you please tell me in what evidence shia believe that yazid and...killed our imams?
Saying mut3a was part of the teaching of the prophet saw because it was made Haram later on, is like saying alcohol was part of teaching of prophet saw, astaghfirallah
So before the prohibition of alcohol it was fine for the sahaba to drink alcohol?
what is the difference between extra marital affair or live in relationship out side of the wedding and Muta?
Riadhus saliheen - volume on nikkah - says that temporary marriage is allowed but not preferable. It is not outlawed in the Koran. It might have been that mutah was outlawed only on the day of the battle. Perhaps the Prophet AS felt that the men were going to be unruly on the day of battle. There is another account that some sahabah asked the Prophet if they could marry temporarily when they were on the way to battle or expedition. He said that he didn't like it - I suggest that the Prophet AS didn't want his men to be distracted when on a mission as excessive practice leads to the fall of men, with strange women. Such excessive practices defeat the idea of love and marriage. Unmarried women feel resentful that their men are marrying strange women and they, themselves are unsaturated. Such men are accountable before Allah for leaving their duties and leaving them alone.
I have a question. When u concieve a child in mutah, is it legitimate because the marriage has expired?
You still have to care for the child wether or not you are married or separated.
Can a single shia please explain Al kafi saying it it's Haram
It is not haram and it is mentioned in Quran sura 4 verse 24 & better than sunni temporary marriages like Siahi marriage Mosiaf, Damm, Rammil or sand,orrfi,Missiar ,Misfar , and marriage with the intention of divorce the male's intention is to divorce his wife without telling her about his intention & more !!!!!
Clearly not listened to the lecture it was banned and allowed again it was banned before battles as intimacy makes you weak that's even a scientific fact. Hence boxers abstain from intimacy before training or a fight.
He destroyed all of them beautifully 😂.
Go watch the first episode, the purpose of these lectures is not to "destroy" Ahlul Sunnah
Stones are waiting for him in Akehra while his order was caused adultery ( a basic need which was allowed by Allah and to fulfill this need through adultery continued. He is responsible for this while he band it. Only someone whose heart did not accept Islam deep through its core would confront, misrepresent it. See what he has done through out his life. We all know it well
I believe Mut'ah marriage was banned during multiple events because the Companions didn't do it correctly. Two Companions went to a woman SIMULTANEOUSLY to ask for marriage. Simultaneously asking and competing for a marriage from a woman is not allowed for any type of marriage. The approach is likely to cause hatred, jealousy, and potential fight between the two companions. Rasulullah forbid to ask a woman for a marriage by a group of men. Companions kept repeating similar mistakes when making Mut'ah during military expeditions. So Mut'ah marriage is allowed, but the method of doing it must be correct.
33:22 - pretty much 'seals the deal'... it's definitely not a nice thing to use a piece of information and totally neglect another to prove a point. Especially when the other piece(s) of information are just as important.... this type of 'cherry picking' is done to mislead individuals...
The brother presented things in an orderly and straightforward manner. Of course this is just the tip of the iceberg.
41:19 😂😂 so laughing
HATTA NAHA UNHU UMAR.....who did he think he was to forbid ?
Question: Didn’t it say in sahih muslim - book of marriage page 25, [3422] that the Messenger of Allah s.a.w.a forbade the mutah marriage? The page was in the video. Im a bit confused..
It was a temporary ban according to Muslim not a permanent one. Watch the whole video he clearly covers Ahadith that contradict each other about when mutah was forbidden
@@ghalibahmed6676what about Sahih Al-bukhari 4216???
@@ghalibahmed6676so Donkey meat was banned permanently but Mutah was not?????
@@jojoszn9684 the better question to ask is that if temporary marriage was permanently banned, why did Umar have to shed light on it after not only the Prophet’s death but Abu Bakr’s death and forbid mutah? And why were there Sahabah who did mutah after the Prophet’s death?
@@ghalibahmed6676wait but why didn’t Mr Syed Nakshawani read Book of marriage 3422? Maybe because it wouldn’t help his case??? He really fucked up there he shouldn’t had showed that page because I would’ve actually believed him
Ok let’s say it’s all legit. Will you be happy for your sisters, daughters and mothers even wives to engage in mut’ah as described ?
At least it'll save us from zina. The community will know about your relationship. It can be used positively as a form of halal dating until permanent marriage as well. Go and read about the rules and laws governing it. You'll embrace it wholeheartedly. It's just the process of normal marriages but the difference is time
@@neymarnexycole1069answer the question will you let your mum, daughter and wife to do it. He didn't ask you about Zinnah
Marshallah, Sayed Ammar you do justice to your Ph.D. Unlike some Muslim pseudo scholars you provide evidence from the Sunni school that support Shia believe and practices. I am having a dim view of Omar just now. Just like non Muslims scoff about we marrying up to 4 wives (with conditions) and they keeping mistresses ( no issue for them) Mutah makes our temporary desire Halal while Omar's prohibition cause our desperate Sheikhs to go to Lebanon, Africa and the West to commit zena. Thanks to Omar.
And in sahih Muslim he said we done it untill the prophet forbade it, why you using he first part of the Hadith and not the end bahahha
Why he not accept adnan rashid challenge
Come him in front of Allahyari
Tell sitting in room no adnan always present peaker corner where hebtake shia from ups nnd down
What a goat man 😂 41:10
He was on rewind and repeat 😂😂😂😂
really in today's generation fornication is easier than Marriage 😢
So misleading, that imam, earlier said mutah was allowed on special occasions means in the times of war
Stop misguiding
how many ties or with how many women can you do Muta? would you allow your daughters/ sisters/mothers to practice Muta? how many times with how many men?
حتی نها عنه عمر 😂😂😂😂😂😂
I think the timing of these topics is completely off (I might be getting ahead of myself here as I don’t know what else is in store)!! In a time when we need to talk of what unifies us as ummah.. we are still focusing on the same old topics that divide us. Muttah, tabbarah on Ashaab and wives of the Prophet SAW, Taraweeh etc. come on man, talk about unity, talk about common ground and if you really want to clean up the yard, start with the practices within the school of Ahlul Bayt which are innovations rather than focusing on someone else’s backyard. We need a voice of reason in times like these.. our common ground is Quran and despite of the Shia Sunni divide, this will always be the single source of truth and unifier. You can beat around the bush all you want..
Spend 20 minutes on hadiths before the Haram please stop manipulating people
Go back to school
Why cant you talk physically with the Sunnis.
Trying to get leverage on Mufti menks and asseem al hakim backs and to obtain popularity.. They are a different class mate.. Its so clear the sources are not contradicting each other, it can also mean there is a possibility He, saw forbade it more than once, on more then one occassion.. Try harder to obtain subscribers.. Mufti menk and asseem al hakeem dont have ads on their channels, Fear Allah.. Would you allow your sister or mother to engage in Mutah? If they fall in the "category"
Yes that’s what u take from this lecture. Smh. I understand the lectures struck your ego and you do not want to be proved wrong. But what is right is right what is wrong is wrong.
@@mohamedddd983 Your response is subjective not objective mate.. Its clear to see who even looks similar to the sunnah by appearance.. Which companion or member of the ahlul bait had a fade or tatts.. Use logic
@@mohamedddd983 As a muslim male I would have loved for Mutah to be still allowed its in my interest.. But like you said what is right is right what is wrong is wrong.. Lets assume for a moment it is still allowed and you do not practise it, what sin have you committed by being wary and trying to be on the safe side by not practising it.. And then assume its truly not allowed but some scholars just cant get a hold of thinking off their willy, isnt that a dangerous risk to take?? Come on man its so logical especially for us the lay men to be on the safe side
You mean they were funded by billions of $s from their countries to do what they do and force their ideologies and viewpoints on Islam to the world stage? Yeah
You must have missed the hadiths where it clearly states the Sahara did it until Umar prevented it. Assim al hakeem and mufti men are different class as they don't know their own books
Muttah is legal but not practicing in the world
It's still no better than prostitution. Using Ibn Khathir's tafseer and claiming it's the Qur'aan allowing 'mut'ah' marriage is wrong. The whole of Surah 4 is about protecting the rights of Muslim women, most importantly giving a dowry as part of the marriage contract, while for a slave girl, the Qur'aan prohibits concubinage, even if too many Sunni scholars allowed this. When a marriage is consummated, there is a minimum waiting period of three monthly courses before a divorce. In modern times, 'mut'ah' is simply a device for seeking out prostitutes. Did 'mut'ah' actually exist in the Prophet's[saw] life time? Are the ahadith quoted by Ibn Khathir accurate? We know for definite the practice of 'zihar' divorce existed, as the Qur'aan forbids it.
Wallah it baffles me how you able to convince these people but then I remember that there all shia
I don't even consider these Wahabi muslims anymore
Temporary sex and abuse
Allah allowed it in the Quran, you are rather accusibg Allah not us, blinded heart after all the proofs from your books, shame on you
I have a serious question. In the month of ramadan instead of focusing on good deeds, repenting and doing lots of ibadah. Why are you going to give lectures in sectarian issues which will cause division in the ummah.
This is no hate but a serious question
Because what Allab has allowed ymar forbade and he's bringing the real face of umar to the to the world. Paul brought what's Christianity today and umar brought what's sunnism is today. 😅
Say these words to Sunni Mullas who spend 24/7 accusing Misquoting, and misrepresenting SHIA Islam.
@@tawabturkmani1838 you know that sunni scholars have answered these objections right? Anyways. Again this is what's wrong it 's always focus on post prophetic islam and not the 99% we have in common as the entire muslim ummah. We have one label and that is muslims as given by the quran. You are seriously worried about if mutah was made impermissable wrongfully do you seriously think you will be asked about this on the day of judgement? May Allah guide as all and protect us from sectarianism
He is giving lectures to EDUCATE PEOPLE ABOUT WHAT IS RIGHT. Are you suggesting we don’t out of fear we may offend the liars? DONT MAKE ME LAUGH
@@sasuke.7251the Shias are being attacked CONSTANTLY and we are entitled to defend ourselves.
Those who follow him have nothing to do with Allah st and His prophet sawaw
😂 in every Hadith he brought it said the prophet FORBADE IT, whether it was at khaybar, Hunain, Conquest of Mecca. Umar FORBABDE IT because the prophet forbade it. ALI FORBADE IT because the prophet forbade it. FORBADE IT, FORBADE IT, FORBADE IT. Key word here that is mentioned again and again; FORBADE.
Just a man looking for anything against Umar ra
Maybe he is, but you can't deny he finds those things easily in sunni books.😊
Umar above Ali, is what you brainwashed sunnis do.
Think about that for a minute.
After all the proofs from your books, your heart is blind
Why you deny your own books?
The sheik also said it was stopped by the prophet saw during his life saw, we don't make fun of its historically we make fun of yous marrying of your daughters temporarily
Are you OK seem to be having a seizure with the amount of emoji you have been posting
So Umar ra was only reminding and implying the teaching of the prophet as you have just showed us in about 10 narrations it tells us the prophet forbade it. For Muslims that won't around when this happened didn't know, there was no social media back then. You act smart but your really not wallah the weakest points I've ever seen
Next .... tattos are halal....go on
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 bro because of a difference of opinion you think you've outsmarted everyone, explain to us how some shias say Ali will be our lord on the day of judgement 😂😂😂😂😂😂 bahah oh another difference of opinion in shia schools , well Wich one is ya Ammar Al kalb
Shias don't say Ali a.s. is a lord
Mut3ah was made Haram in stages like alcohol or wine. Another thing that some companions did in the early years of Islam
Many companions applied muta or temporary marriage at the time of Abo Bakr when he was a khalif or the ruler over the whole muslim countries
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
I don't understand how dumb people can be he literally shows something the shiekh says and then babbles on something that doesn't answer the question at hand bahahah
So there is a difference on a opinion on the time it was made haram😂 you know how much difference of options there is in shia books bahahahahahahah brother gooo homee
So there was another opinion in sahih Muslim somebody clap for him please😂😂😂 all opinions lead to the same conclusion 😂😂😂😂😂😂 umm can you explain how wiping peices of cloth on the grave of a sheikh bring blessing. Ohhhh this is a difference of opinion is it bahahahah so Wich one is ya kethabbb
11imams plus imam Mahdi and his 4 representatives more than 300 yrs were present after prophet Mohammed s.w. passed away ,prophet Mohammed said follow the Quran & my purified Ahlu al beit in 6 Sunni Sahih books ,Egyption Dr.Mohammad Hedaiah confirmed it it is Ahlu al beit they have the true interpretation of the Quran and the true hadiths
Excuse me, did you even watch the whole video before starting commenting?
THIS IS THE NUMBER ONE SHAI BOOK FORBIDDING MUT3AH We also find in Al-Kafi 5/1095 from Mohammad bin Yahya from Ahmad bin Mohammad from Mu’amar bin Khallad that he said: I asked Abu Al-Hasan Al-Redha - peace be upon him - about a man getting married to a women in mutah and taking her from country to another country? He said: The other type of marriage is permissible, and this type of marriage isn’t. THIS IS A THE NUMEBR ONE SHIA BOOKS FORBIDDING MUT3AH
Why does he not just go and debate but yet his clout chasing and probably giving weak hadiths serious this guy is a clown
Illusion of grandger 😂