What I expected going into Dune as a Star Wars fan and hearing about how it inspired George Lucas to make Star Wars was basically just another space film about an intergalactic war. But after watching the film, I must say that it is way better than I had expected. The cinematography was gogeous, and the technical design and visual effects were masterful. It also opened me up to a whole new world of action and adventure storytelling in the sci-fi genre. Dune is a hell of a movie, and will make one hell of a franchise, and I can tell it will be one of the giants that people look at next to Star Wars or Lord of The Rings when thinking of films and pop culture.
@ThegrandKrild Yeah, he said that the Dune books inspired the idea of making sci-fi films. Not to mention the Sarlac, which is a giant sandworm. And they both have a galactic empire that is at war with a smaller group of people
@@Crusader47 quantity doesnt really matter. it already "competes" with them with just two. It's about the quality of the story and the world building which all of them do better than any other in their respective genre. Star Wars may be more vast and lord of the rings more intricate, but there's no denying that Dune is just as good with its story and world building and certainly deserves to be right up there with the other three (startrek being included).
@@HossLUK nah quality quantity defo does and star wars and lotr have done that. Also time is what determines how successful a franchise is star wars and lotr have been here for decades so it will take time and way more good dune movies to make it iconic like star wars and lotr
I think the delay meant that he wasnt really that good at it first the voice was better than him he couldnt properly command his voice but it was a good transition when it overlapped
I'm a lifelong Star Wars fan but comparing Anakin to Paul in their movies, Paul takes the cake no question (not in a fight, just in which is a better character). Anakin could have been handled SO much better in the movies
Heavily agree. I love Star Wars, especially the prequels, but it is very obvious that George Lucas doesn’t understand dialogue, or at least doesn’t say out loud what his characters say. There was an interview with Mark Hamill when he was younger about how he made George Lucas change one of his lines because it sounded ridiculous when said out loud and was a literal tongue twister.
I don't really like Anakins transition to the dark side I believe it could have been done much better.The way Paul changes tho is actually scary for the audience.
@@sasukenonsense7753actually ☝️@Ola-jz7oj meant that Paul came first, he is the original character...anakin is an inspired/copied version of Paul atreides from the original frank Hebert Dune books from the late 1950s to the 60s and above and beyond. Ultimately, I agree in a way. Why? You might ask...Frank Hebert was initially going to sue George for copying Dune by making star wars so similar, he lost eventually but that's a story for another day(extra info to back my statement up). Have a great day 🤗
@@sasukenonsense7753 buddy 👁️👄👁️ Seriously man...🤦 You have to realize that Understanding the inspiration behind a character can and will provide some insight into their development and the themes they represent. It adds context to the debate about their qualities and significance within their own stories. And in this case anakin the character is copied off of Paul muad'dib atreides! Why? you might also ask 😐 from their humble beginnings to their destinies as powerful figures in their respective universes. Both undergo profound transformations, facing the same decision that Will eventually lead them into becoming villians who take over with an iron fist. Anakin's journey echoes Paul's in many ways, such as his prophesied role as the Chosen One to his struggles with the dark side of the Force, mirroring Paul's own struggles with the visions and the weight of his legacy. While both are different in their own ways you have to understand that this sheds light on the enduring influence of Paul Atreides on the creation of Anakin Skywalker thus concluding the debate withstanding my withdrawal and proudly announcing that anakin is a character inspired by PAUL MUAD'DIB ATREIDES!!! DUKE OF ARRAKKIS!!!
@@axolotl1777 Well not true LOL Star wars was still iconic for 16 years after the OT and with prequels even more, the majority of the fan base does not like disney stuff and the main thing that keeps the franchise alive is the original 6 movies
Creator: vt.tiktok.com/ZSFv3qbJD/
Timothee Chalamet is quite the actor and he has a powerful voice.
And he is hot- I mean, who said that...
@@CoriolanusSnowIsMine fr
That's a lame junkie. Are you special
What I expected going into Dune as a Star Wars fan and hearing about how it inspired George Lucas to make Star Wars was basically just another space film about an intergalactic war. But after watching the film, I must say that it is way better than I had expected. The cinematography was gogeous, and the technical design and visual effects were masterful. It also opened me up to a whole new world of action and adventure storytelling in the sci-fi genre. Dune is a hell of a movie, and will make one hell of a franchise, and I can tell it will be one of the giants that people look at next to Star Wars or Lord of The Rings when thinking of films and pop culture.
George Lucas never said that dune was is inspiration
@ThegrandKrild Yeah, he said that the Dune books inspired the idea of making sci-fi films. Not to mention the Sarlac, which is a giant sandworm. And they both have a galactic empire that is at war with a smaller group of people
agreed however there's many star wars films and LOTR films while dune may be limited to only about 3 so don't know if it could compete
@@Crusader47 quantity doesnt really matter. it already "competes" with them with just two. It's about the quality of the story and the world building which all of them do better than any other in their respective genre. Star Wars may be more vast and lord of the rings more intricate, but there's no denying that Dune is just as good with its story and world building and certainly deserves to be right up there with the other three (startrek being included).
@@HossLUK nah quality quantity defo does and star wars and lotr have done that. Also time is what determines how successful a franchise is star wars and lotr have been here for decades so it will take time and way more good dune movies to make it iconic like star wars and lotr
I actually way preferred the way his voice was delayed. I think it’d have been a much cooler way to showcase The Voice
I think the delay meant that he wasnt really that good at it first the voice was better than him he couldnt properly command his voice but it was a good transition when it overlapped
Low key one of the hardest dune edits I've seen. And I've seen a lot of dune edits
You forgot the SILENCE
Both cuz Holy fuck that combo will be unstopable
I think both characters are one of the best)
Ngl anakin is goated but personal in writing I would say Paul
Nah men you look like episode 7-9 fans
@@tandircemal2484anakin rider spotted bro is so sigma skibidi 😹😹👏👏🥸🥸🥸🧟🤓👺
@@repple2586lol
Anakin was inspired in Paul
@@repple2586 FRRRR 😂
should have had "SILENCE!!!"
Paul😻❤
Bro Dune 2 is A Top 2 Movie for me omg so good omgomg maybe number 1!
Anakin will forever be the better chosen one his ride as vader made him one of the best villians maybe the best in history
I'm a lifelong Star Wars fan but comparing Anakin to Paul in their movies, Paul takes the cake no question (not in a fight, just in which is a better character). Anakin could have been handled SO much better in the movies
Heavily agree. I love Star Wars, especially the prequels, but it is very obvious that George Lucas doesn’t understand dialogue, or at least doesn’t say out loud what his characters say. There was an interview with Mark Hamill when he was younger about how he made George Lucas change one of his lines because it sounded ridiculous when said out loud and was a literal tongue twister.
I don't really like Anakins transition to the dark side I believe it could have been done much better.The way Paul changes tho is actually scary for the audience.
Both.
Anakin will always be my favorite for obvious reasons
But Paul is definitely better written
Paul or better said Dune is older than star wars so Anikan is just an idea of paul
Anakin Skywalker 💙
Anakin/Vader was created base on Paul/Lisan Al-Gaib. So...
The dune books inspired star wars
@@Mr-Nobody084 The Dune book bro
@@Mr-Nobody084 star wars = Asimov + Dune
@@Mr-Nobody084 LMAOOOOOOOOOOO
@@Never283 Well Greek mythology inspired both so yeah
Paul ofc ❤
Paul clears
Paul is the OG here
I love Anakin so much so he is still best for me but Paul is FUCKING DOPE MAN HOLY SHIT
Paul is better in terms of writing and overall message
In your opinion
muad'dib clears
Lisan al Gaib
The choosen one❤
Which one 😂
@@coopatroopa-tp3zr both😂
Anakin is something else
🗣️🗣️🗣️SILENCE🔥🔥🔥
Paul walked so Anakin could run.
Anakin skywalker💙
SILENCE
LIL MABU?
o thought anakin said get off me lol
Paul all day
Anakin 100%
He must be thirsty
Anakin
Name of the song please & btw great edit fr ❤
Paul on top
I think he needs to work on his physics too, not too bulky but lean body with muscles
Music name?!?
Anakin solos bro
Paul wins 1000%
Anakin absolutely demolishes Paul bro 😭both great movies and characters but Anakin is on top
🔥
Leto the second.
Because He is more powerful then Paul.
Or you take the Real Kwisatz Haderach. 😅
Actually George Lucas was inspired by Dune
And what does that do to help the debate?
@@sasukenonsense7753actually ☝️@Ola-jz7oj meant that Paul came first, he is the original character...anakin is an inspired/copied version of Paul atreides from the original frank Hebert Dune books from the late 1950s to the 60s and above and beyond. Ultimately, I agree in a way. Why? You might ask...Frank Hebert was initially going to sue George for copying Dune by making star wars so similar, he lost eventually but that's a story for another day(extra info to back my statement up). Have a great day 🤗
@@justsomegeek5764 that still doesn’t explain anything related debate wise
@@sasukenonsense7753
buddy
👁️👄👁️ Seriously man...🤦
You have to realize that Understanding the inspiration behind a character can and will provide some insight into their development and the themes they represent. It adds context to the debate about their qualities and significance within their own stories. And in this case anakin the character is copied off of Paul muad'dib atreides! Why? you might also ask 😐 from their humble beginnings to their destinies as powerful figures in their respective universes. Both undergo profound transformations, facing the same decision that Will eventually lead them into becoming villians who take over with an iron fist. Anakin's journey echoes Paul's in many ways, such as his prophesied role as the Chosen One to his struggles with the dark side of the Force, mirroring Paul's own struggles with the visions and the weight of his legacy. While both are different in their own ways you have to understand that this sheds light on the enduring influence of Paul Atreides on the creation of Anakin Skywalker thus concluding the debate withstanding my withdrawal and proudly announcing that anakin is a character inspired by PAUL MUAD'DIB ATREIDES!!! DUKE OF ARRAKKIS!!!
@@sasukenonsense7753 oh wait I see where you're going with this 😳 man...🤦 Bro, I'm sorry man, i understand what you mean now 😂
paul atreides, anakin skywalker, and eren yeager are my 3 favorite characters
❤❤
Bro no diff Anakin pls dont ask again
Silence 🙊
Anakin is always anakin
Hate how he’s being compared to Anikan tho obviously Anikan is far more powerful
How many kids did Paul kill again?
Anakin wins
Mmm willy wonka o anakin ???
This is a question,nah Anakin Skywalker win
I really like these new movie. But anakin all day.
Anakin better than Paul anyday
Twice
Почему он наорал на мать?
I need to answer This?
Silence!!!!!! 😡
Abomination 🫥
❤
Aniken
Anakin is better.
Paul will be forgotten, Anakin /Vader is one of the most iconic character in fiction 🤷♂🤷♂
Cuz nostalgia and because Disney will milk star wars dry
Dune and Paul are way better too
@@axolotl1777 Well not true LOL Star wars was still iconic for 16 years after the OT and with prequels even more, the majority of the fan base does not like disney stuff and the main thing that keeps the franchise alive is the original 6 movies
not likely, its already being hailed as one of the greatest sci-fi movies of all time
That's not a nice thing to do to your mom
Did you watch the movies bro like i agree with you in real life but Paul is justified in the books and movies to be pissed
I bet you will be nice to your mom if she force you a life that you don't want.
Dune is better than star wars but anakin is better than paul. ,✨
Anakin 😂😂
🤢🤢🤢
Anakin
Anakin