Got to be in control to lose it! World politics at the moment demonstrates that any nuffers can be elected. We blame them but the reality is people in the constituencies vote these people in. Societies and communities need to have a hard look at what we stand for and elect smarter people.
@@diarmuidkelleher5319 - Rulers like citizens who are just smart enough to work the machines but not smart enough to ask questions. Boris snd Farage said 'jump' and Britain jumped, it's the greatest demonstration of how poorly informed our society is.
Top Comment James. Nailed it. People need to get engaged and take control -THEN its a Democracy. Until that happens, the shit show continues. We are getting the BS we deserve, no more and no less.
So, I'm an American from literally half a world away [US West Coast], and I'm only informed on the Brexit issues to a casual degree. However, I have British friends and recognize that this is a major political issue in their lives that directly effects their livelihood. As a historian and an outsider, I'm seeing the Brexit issue as being a major crossroads in the UK's politics. This might very well be the 'Policy of Appeasement' or the 'Retreat from Empire' for this generation of British voters. On a more personal note, I'm sort of, well, encouraged I guess, that the US isn't the only democracy to lose its Goddamn mind since 9/11. Good luck and Godspeed to Great Britain as she wrestles with this issue. Just like your upstart colony across the pond, you seem to have found yourself with major issues on your plate and a lousy set of politicians who are doing a lousy job of dealing with them.
@@manxlancs No insult intended, Manx. Just a personal observation, nothing more. My point here is only that we share similar problems: major issues mired in partisan politics from politicians who can't seem to wrap their head around the idea that 'politics as usual' isn't going to cut it.
@StealthyMonk You're never going to stop conspiracy theorists. Half of that particular breed of idiot think aliens from Area 51 were hired by the CIA to kill Kennedy in black helicopters from the UN. My personal standard for conspiracy is Hanlon's Razor: "Never attribute to malice [or conspiracy] that which can easily be explained by incompetence or stupidity." You'd be amazed at just how much nonsense that clears up.
As an American- Believe that every nation gives you a round of applause for being our wise global saviour! As an American- (What people really think) I am actually belong to an extremely inward thinking nation and come from a land where many people no nothing outside their country. However I believe it is now my given right to make patronising and ignorant opinions on matters I don't fully understand and watch others chuckle at me because our news channels go international if they show a story about what is happening in the state next door!
@@cambs0181 Not my intention at all, Cambs. I point out that I'm an American for two reasons: 1. To clearly state that my opinion is an outsider's opinion and to be taken for whatever that's worth, and 2. That I'm not nearly as read in on the issues involved as someone whose livelihood depends on them. I like to think that I know a bit more than the average American insofar as international news goes; I keep up with Reuters and BBCN. Call it a leftover from my tour in Europe in the US Army in the way back. But I don't present myself like I have any kind of authoritative knowledge on the ins and outs of Britain's Parliament. I freely admit that I don't fully understand the internal politics involved. Look, I love my country but I know my people. We can be incredible idiots at the least provocation. That can be said about most countries, but because of the footprint the US has in the world our stupidity is broadcast to the neighborhood with a bullhorn. Just as Great Britain did at the height of her Empire 125 years ago. My end point here was to offer sympathy for the UK and mention that I see similarities in our respective political situations, nothing more.
would anybody vote for me to become "supreme ruler"..? as supreme ruler I promise to publically "shame" (Full Game of Thrones style) one prominent person/celebrity a year(decided by me). I say we pubically "shame" Emma Watson personally(because she needs to be knocked down a peg or two and brought back to reality).
Just in case you were under the misguided belief that our country was being led by intelligent, right-minded and ethical adults, watch 5-minutes of house debates...
craig mitchell pillred I mean we voted to leave, so just leave. I’m no politician either. It’s like what ever either prime minister does parliaments always there to block it. It’s like the prime minister has no control at all
@Barba Ra No there is no majority in Parliament to leave the EU. In fact more than 80% of MPs were backing Remain in the run up to the Referendum. According to a survey of all 650 MPs carried out by the Press Association ahead of the referendum on June 23: 480 MPs said they would be voting Remain, including 184 Conservatives 159 MPs said they would be voting Leave, including 139 Conservatives 11 MPs were undeclared, including four Conservatives 218 Labour MPs said they would vote Remain while just 11 backed Leave. All eight Liberal Democrat MPs intended to vote Remain, along with all 56 SNP MPs, all three Plaid Cymru MPs, all four Sinn Fein MPs and all three SDLP MPs. Green MP Caroline Lucas also said she would vote Remain, as did independent MP Sylvia Hermon and the two Ulster Unionist MPs. The eight DUP MPs said they would be voting to Leave, along with Ukip MP Douglas Carswell. However the people voted to leave and it is the Governments job to deliver on that result. Unfortunately May was a weak leader and a Remainer at heart. May's deal was not a DEAL it was another TREATY with no deadline or mechanism for the UK to actually leave the EU. Tied to the EU and the ECJ, paying into the project but with no say on what happens there. That is not just a bad deal it is absolutely the worst possible deal.
@@svxntt - "because cancelling brexit would cause nationwide riots" I'm not convinced it would. The kind of people who voted for brexit don't really seem the type to actually put up a showing. There absolutely will be riots though if the UK leaves without a deal - what with food and medicine shortages. So really, it's a question of which kind of riot you'd rather have.
The British Parliament should ban jeering and mocking when a member is speaking. All these makes a mockery of the parliament in session which sounds so much like a circus.
And the British Government has the gall to criticize certain other countries for being undemocratic dictatorships and "not representing the will of the people".Mother of Parliaments ? Mother of Hypocrites more like.
@M Bacon thank you. Exactly my point: the referendum said nothing about all this. All this was added later by those who lost and wanted to remain. The referendum itself was a simple question: ... stay or leave.
+robert + Slim Rudy + Julio Helder Good , you should have stayed in your own nation and you wouldn't have this problem :) It's not their fault you have such low birth rates. lol
Why aren't we talking about the guy mowing the lawn?? Fluorescent reflective jacket, fluorescent reflective pants, face shield, earmuffs, gloves, helmet, covered wheels on the mower...Wow, overkill much?
@FlyingMonkies325 Nothing to do with the EU, I'm in Australia and this is a worldwide phenomenon (well the first world anyway). The UK has been in the EU while many things have changed in many areas, and therefore (wrongly) blame all the changes on the EU.
Am I the only one who thinks highlights of government look like children throwing insults on the playground rather than professionals trying to run a country? 😒
@@ludogibson7067 Too bad Charles Bronson is dead. He could've been PM. It's not good when we're bickering with ourselves. If our government was focused on finding the best possible result for all, or even a basic outline that they could improve over time, there would be merit in them being confrontational. But they can't even agree on simple things. If both of your feet were solely determined to kick the other, you're not walking ten feet without kissing the pavement.
Jeremy corbyn all his life has been a eurosceptic look at his voting record Jeremy Corbyn voted for Britain to leave the European Economic Community (EEC) in the 1975 European referendum. Jeremy Corbyn opposed the creation of the European Union (EU) under the Maastricht Treaty speaking and voting against it in Parliament in 1993. Jeremy Corbyn voted for a referendum on Britains membership of the EU in 2011 (breaking the Labour whip to do so) what a disgrace of a man.
@@tedverse5726 He hasn't switched, he's still trying to play both sides. Come general election time, he will have to declare one way or the other, and then he'll have to deal with millions of pissed off remainers, or millions of pissed off leavers.
How NPC of you, lemme break it down. Boris could have called a GE the minute he took office. Why has he waited until now? Because calling a GE before the anti-no deal legislation has been put into law means, theoretically, he could shift the date of the election to after October the 31st - ignoring the will of parliament with a dirty political trick. All the opposition have instead said they will vote for a GE, but only after this legislation has been written into law.
Oh yeah shutting down parliament early ie shutting his opposition off is so democratic. Oh you are speaking about his election and now it magically makes him democratic because he cannot force it?
@BeastlyPanda Actually, the "best" dictators hold elections that they can't lose in order to validate their rule. While that's not necessarily the situation here, as, one would hope and imagine that our electoral system is not that corrupt; Boris Johnson's current approach of riding a populist wave certainly does share parallels with the methods used by dictatorships. Logic, evidence and debate should be at the foundation of our nation's governance; not blind loyalty to a character that promises the world. You would have been better saying "all dictators love [fair] elections, it's a great way to silence people's voices", with the sarcasm too, of course.
lewis diver I agree......we are at ‘stalemate’ so a GE would be the best way out, call it a second referendum in disguise but either way the U.K. needs to move on in a direction before we implode!
Craig Roberts no Corbin will have no voters most of the remain voters are backing the Lib Dem’s and the leavers are split between the tories and brexit party brexit is the main topic and Corbins spending plans have been matched by boris so he has no appeal
The thing is, they want to support a General Election, but first want a bill to pass to prevent a no deal from happening in the meantime during the elections. Conservatives are trying to frame it as if they don't want a general election at all. Have watched the who session. The conservatives lying was very cringeworthy.
I can imagine The Queen walking in with pizzas & sees the entirety of parliament just in flames, with Boris saying, "ITS FINE!!!" More fun to watch than Canadian Politics, but slightly less than US politics.
"People should be able to express themselves politically, sometimes outside of what the party thinks". People should. Elected MPs shouldn't if it flies in the face of both their constituents and party, at least if they want to keep pretending they represent said constituents and party. The number of MPs doing the exact opposite of what their constituents want while saying that Boris is the one being undemocratic is ludicrous.
@@frankstein7631 A stink with stealth bombers. I wouldn't think you would wish to lose them as friends, Franklin. Perhaps they could start a world war with those bombers. Then they could be on par with their European cousins.
Its Corbyn, NO that's not an allegation but RATS do stink! and looking a Dianne hlf the time sitting next to him asleep it must be the effect of that same Odor! like friggin chloroform!
Labour and the Lib Dems: "Lets go back to the people!" Boris: "Ok fine lets have an election then" Labour and the Lib Dems: "No!" It doesn't matter what side you are on, this is just a joke now.
Are you deliberately ignoring their reason for abstaining on a GE right now? They do want and will vote for an election, just after they're sure Boris Johnson can't force a no deal Brexit through election timings.
Parliament so out of touch. 60% of labour held electorates vote leave but almost all labour mps want remain. That is why the don’t want an election anymore
People voted for BREXIT, yes, but the majority of registered voters didn't and that means STAY... (37.4% for Brexit, 62.6% against or OK with the status quo)
Im wondering where the 17.4 Million people have put their own pitch forks? if being lied to isn't enough NOW - TODAY - even your official votes DONT COUNT!
But a parliament vote is the will of the people, not the will of a lunatic PM. I don't think that the EU could refuse especially when it is being accused of being non democratic.
@@Kitiwake Parliament defended the people?!?! We were supposed to have left the EUSSR 6 months ago...i voted for WTO no deal!!! We are now fighting for democracy!
Obviously you fail to understand the situation and the ramifications of overturning a democratic vote due to your personal opinion. By stopping legitimate vote on any subject you set up the overturning of every vote thereafter. Local elections, general elections, referendums, everything! You give grounds for being told "wrong do it again" every time the people go to the ballot box. Such a sad and dangerous move.
@Hauke Holst What a ridiculous statement...I love Europe and Europeans, I hate the EU...a political construct....you deliberately twist my meaning...shame on you...moron.
I undear stand the hand in which he was trying to play as I do jeremy Corbin's. But why they insist on backing themselves in to a corner I will never undear stand. I am speaking from experience, I have being backed into a corner. not of my own making while trying to make a deal. It was in a will we had to sell it to this one person. They now we had to sell to them, so they offered half the price it was worth on the open market. There was nothing we could do, If you can't walk away you lose badly.
@@AviChetriArtwork well the one to stop the no deal has had the amendments voting on so it's not back to the House of Lords. So we will know at some point this or next week if it's throw
Just give us an election, we need to end this hung parliament. It ain't working, we need a government that has a majority to get deals through parliament.
*For the love of Zod* just have a referendum on the options (deal, no deal, rescind Article 50) and then you have your mandate to do what needs to be done.
The result of such a vote would never be accepted by the opposition. Just as the first ref result has been rejected. This is why we must leave eventually. You cannot ignore the voice of the people, in time the opposition will come to understand the absurdity of their position, as much as they may not like it.
Just put in the motion that all these useless MP’s would agree to any outcome of the impending referendum on whatever option is tabled on the deal/brexit issue. no parliament votes, no ayes, no noses, nothing else from the parliament that they would need to further debate on . Still, i dont think that they would even consider that as an option....
There never was a DEAL what May was peddling was just another TREATY binding the UK to the EU with no date or mechanism for leaving. The Referendum was to LEAVE or REMAIN nothing else. A free trade deal would have been ideal but another TREATY is not just a bad deal, it is no deal at all.
@Sensual Digest - "No Deal is Brexit the END " If only there was some way for you to make your voice heard on that matter in an official capacity, and to determine how many people actually agree with you. *_IF ONLY_*
Does Britain realise that France, (at least) considers Britain an ex-UE member state already? (new school books, official government websites etc....).
I very much doubt it. Only a vegetable couldn't see what's stopping him - a now thoroughly spent and discredited Corbyn, and cowards who want to overturn the referendum decision on the one hand, and/or undermine the bargaining position on the other. No deal is the default position, and no deal means the EU get no 39 billion...which they desperately need. The best route to a deal, is to have no deal as an option.
@@jjthecat9692 the Lib Dems will hurt Labour, Hardline Brexiters who vote Conservative will vote Brexit party. Of course the conservatives could win well if the Brexit party packs it's bags and fucks off, but they are not going to do that.
@Barba Ra Here, take a look at this: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Escalation_of_commitment It's only a wiki page, but there's an element of it at play in the Brexit "debate", I dare say.
Why don't the British people just do another vote on if they want to leave the EU or not? If the vote yes again, then just leave without a deal. If they vote no, probably shows they were not drunk this time?
Plz call more million and million EU people in UK and give full right for benefits every things After this vote ,EU people in UK they are celebrating and insulating us and saying you will never take freedom from EU
From a foreign point of view.. this is a great blow for democracy.. the people had a Referendum and said to leave. We vote politicians in do do as we the voters ask .. Not to do as they please
ok, but there are many different types of brexit possible offered during the debate. There was a hard brexit and a soft brexit and a no deal brexit. I can guarantee that at the time of the referendum the majority of people who voted for brexit didn't think that brexit meant no deal brexit. Its like someone offering you tickets to go to the cinema and you say yes. But when you see that the only film available is some crappy low budget film, would you still want to go to the cinema? Just because you said yes to the cinema doesn't mean that you have to go and see a really bad film, once you see the options and you dont like them you could then say no. That is pretty much the sentiment that some politicians have, in a basic way.
@@squirllovechild I believe that when people voted to leave they want to leave, when you go to leave a house you do walk out of a single room and stay in the building do you? I would argue that they majority would be fine to leave with no deal, many would be fine with a deal but its perfectly clear that the EU prior agreement with May was not in good faith the longer this goes on the more the pot continues to boil.
Yes ... the details are crucial.. So now that the public has seen the complications and the political problems as well.. Make an election issue..and hope the turnout is high and that the desire to leave or stay is also clear.. The western world is greatly divided over so many things... our division will be our eventual down fall... good luck you guys But me I believe in being one's own master as much as possible.. Nationalism and no global community .. . Cheers
Misleading title... the House of Commons is not the UK Parliament. One would think the BBC would know the difference about the political structure of its own country.
David Harrison Wow they haven't been elected you say. Bloody hell and I thought Boris Johnson was the only member of the House of Commons thwarting the will of Parliament.
karol Z04 it’s impossible to make a deal we want red the eu needs blue to be a separate entity. It isn’t going to happen. It’s stupid to act like it can
Boris has been near destroyed! Such humiliation and utter contempt for him in The Commons. I applaud MP's for their efforts yesterday evening. The country's eyes are open to the Government's flawed strategy and lies.
How come the public can vote to leave the EU and this is ignored, but a vote in parliament to block a no deal or prevent an election is upheld? Who is actually in charge here?
So the MPS want a hung parliament as well as limbo on Brexit vs Remain. Now that is completely the end of any shred of respect one can have for the MPs. If they can't stand Brexit then they should give the people a choice as soon as possible.
It's amazing that Johnson who only had a majority of one with the DUP just decreased his majority by 21 seats to now a minority government, even with the 8 DUP seats. Just absolutely amazing.
@glyn hodges it's a game and Johnson has played it terribly. The ball is in Corbyn's court and he is playing it very well. Getting what he wants and forcing Johnson to do things he said he wouldn't do.
@glyn hodges he doesn't have to have a general election to do that. Which he won't anyway. Corbyn's plan is to get an extension, get a deal and split the conservative party with a general election after the extension has been granted. If granted. That's his play and judging by the events of the last 2 days he's playing it very well
@glyn hodges that's not what people see. People see that Johnson has failed and Corbyn has got what he wanted. What the Labour manifesto says for the inevitable soon to come General Election I can't say, as you can't either as it has not been released yet. We will see when they release it. But I really doubt it will hand all decision making over to the EU because just as you said it's "unelectable" and he knows that.
@glyn hodges no the alternative is no deal. And with a no deal you will have no choice but to sign some shit desperate last chance deal with the US. Not a very good thing to do. Just look at NAFTA. Take that as an example of how any deal with the US is always on their terms and is usually terrible for the other countries ie, Canada and Mexico. Trump will know that the PM at the time, be it Boris or whoever, will be desperate for any trade deal. And they will get the shitest deal that Trump wants to give. I'm an ex Pat that lives in Canada. I've seen it firsthand. Any good deal with the EU will be a thousand times better than any deal with the US.
Pretty clear what will happen now. Since a no deal Brexit (with its implication that the 32 Billion Euro payment would not be made by the the UK) will be taken off the table by the opposition, the EU can simply revert back to its previous stance that the deal negotiated with Mrs. May's team is their final offer. So .. the clock is now turned back to where parliament may have to vote again on the same deal it has already rejected multiple times, will reject it again, and ask for another extension. The EU will say they are tired of the whole thing and tell the UK to take it or leave it by January 31st (final extension), leaving parliament in the position where it needs to either accept an unsatisfactory deal (which it will not do) or cancel the idea of Brexit altogether (which they also cannot do). The opposition will then accept a general election which they will try and frame in the way they wanted to frame the "people's vote" : a choice between a clearly unsatisfactory deal and scrapping Brexit altogether (what they are hoping for) …. with the increasing popular "clean break, no deal" option removed from the options to consider. The Conservatives and Brexit parties will campaign on a "No Deal" platform arguing that they are the only parties committed to honouring the results of the referendum and, if given a majority, will reverse the block to a no deal Brexit and proceed to leave the EU with or without a deal. If a Labour coalition takes power, they will scuttle Brexit or Brexit "in name only". If neither party can form a majority coalition, parliamentary and economic chaos will ensue. This chaos and uncertainty is, and would be, far more damaging to the UK economy than a No Deal Brexit taken promptly would have caused. Pity.
However boris still has the options to go to the queen and ask her to dissolve parliament or issues a vote of no confidence in his own government both of which force a general election in hopes that a majority leave government can be formed
Well , Boris started a nasty game and surprisingly it pays off.He is already in the history books.No PM have ever achieved 3 defeats in the first 3 votes..Well done!!!
1:40 "Or is he frit" - did I spot a deliberate echo of Margaret Thatcher there? She used the word in a similar context: "The Right Honourable gentleman [Denis Healey] is afraid of an election is he? Afraid? Frightened? Frit?"
An American from New Jersey, I'm glad the UK voted to keep their sovereignty and policy decisions made for and voted for by the PEOPLE of the UK and not the cabal of the EU.
So when we eventually do have a general election, does that mean we can now just ignore the result because we don't like it and maybe just ask somebody from another continent to be our government instead.
Biased by the BBC, no screen time for IDS distinctive statement about people’s vote being pointless without a new parliament and Boris fantastic statements about both this being the first time in history that the opposition hasn’t challenged the government AND that this is the first time the opposition has shown confidence in them. “Can we show a vote of no confidence in her majesties opposition?” Can we get some news for once? PPB are not on for awhile yet, when they are we can handle bias but right now we just need to hear facts. And who gives a toss about who’s grandad a politician is, does this make him a better politician by inheritance?
This is amazing. The UK politics is in limbo right now and these people are also the ones who used to rule on many other countries not so long ago. Now they can't even decide their own fate. Lol 😂
Meh. I've read plenty of both left and right wingers whine that she's biased against them, which just points to myopic bias in the viewership who complain about bias whenever their side is held under scrutiny. She's fine. Nothing remotely outrageous.
a simpleton said no deal wasent in the referendum, it wasent because I didn't have to be, because David Cameron explained before the referendum exactly what leave was meant to be.. including pamphlets given to explain it.. so leave with a deal didn't have to be written on the referendum paper.. he said before we stay or we leave it was that simple and didn't have to be written on the referendum paper on the day we voted... that's why he cried when leave won...
this will be a Netflix series in 10 years
The Crown series 6 2022 😉
God knows they will do it better than the BBC.
More suited to the Syfy Channel than Netflix, Too unbelievable!!
David Cameron and Theresa May will be glad they came out of this mess.
I couldnt watch all this crap again. ....
I'm really enjoying this final season of the UK.
I'm really enjoying the final series of the western world.
@@bunkerbill the west will live on, so will the EU, but the UK won't
@@succhiatoredelcazzo4689 The EU Spain and France wont either,neither will Italy.The melting pots are melting- thank God.
@@irishboer7124 Why would they collapse? The UK gave as much benefits to the EU as did for example Luxembourg.
BBC中文 is a loser in HK
It was Brexit-End Game but now is Brexit-Infinity War 😂😂😂
Excellent
Nice one
🤣🤣🤣
Not from David apparently 😂
@David By getting more votes than them?....
Got to be in control to lose it! World politics at the moment demonstrates that any nuffers can be elected. We blame them but the reality is people in the constituencies vote these people in. Societies and communities need to have a hard look at what we stand for and elect smarter people.
But then you would need a smart electorate........
@@diarmuidkelleher5319 - Rulers like citizens who are just smart enough to work the machines but not smart enough to ask questions. Boris snd Farage said 'jump' and Britain jumped, it's the greatest demonstration of how poorly informed our society is.
Wow. That's really profound.
@@cosmonautbilly9570 it got it. its called the USA
Top Comment James. Nailed it. People need to get engaged and take control -THEN its a Democracy. Until that happens, the shit show continues. We are getting the BS we deserve, no more and no less.
So, I'm an American from literally half a world away [US West Coast], and I'm only informed on the Brexit issues to a casual degree. However, I have British friends and recognize that this is a major political issue in their lives that directly effects their livelihood.
As a historian and an outsider, I'm seeing the Brexit issue as being a major crossroads in the UK's politics. This might very well be the 'Policy of Appeasement' or the 'Retreat from Empire' for this generation of British voters.
On a more personal note, I'm sort of, well, encouraged I guess, that the US isn't the only democracy to lose its Goddamn mind since 9/11.
Good luck and Godspeed to Great Britain as she wrestles with this issue. Just like your upstart colony across the pond, you seem to have found yourself with major issues on your plate and a lousy set of politicians who are doing a lousy job of dealing with them.
Thanks for sorting that out for us. Our little British brains couldn't think.
@@manxlancs No insult intended, Manx. Just a personal observation, nothing more.
My point here is only that we share similar problems: major issues mired in partisan politics from politicians who can't seem to wrap their head around the idea that 'politics as usual' isn't going to cut it.
@StealthyMonk You're never going to stop conspiracy theorists. Half of that particular breed of idiot think aliens from Area 51 were hired by the CIA to kill Kennedy in black helicopters from the UN.
My personal standard for conspiracy is Hanlon's Razor: "Never attribute to malice [or conspiracy] that which can easily be explained by incompetence or stupidity." You'd be amazed at just how much nonsense that clears up.
As an American- Believe that every nation gives you a round of applause for being our wise global saviour!
As an American- (What people really think) I am actually belong to an extremely inward thinking nation and come from a land where many people no nothing outside their country. However I believe it is now my given right to make patronising and ignorant opinions on matters I don't fully understand and watch others chuckle at me because our news channels go international if they show a story about what is happening in the state next door!
@@cambs0181 Not my intention at all, Cambs. I point out that I'm an American for two reasons: 1. To clearly state that my opinion is an outsider's opinion and to be taken for whatever that's worth, and 2. That I'm not nearly as read in on the issues involved as someone whose livelihood depends on them.
I like to think that I know a bit more than the average American insofar as international news goes; I keep up with Reuters and BBCN. Call it a leftover from my tour in Europe in the US Army in the way back. But I don't present myself like I have any kind of authoritative knowledge on the ins and outs of Britain's Parliament. I freely admit that I don't fully understand the internal politics involved.
Look, I love my country but I know my people. We can be incredible idiots at the least provocation. That can be said about most countries, but because of the footprint the US has in the world our stupidity is broadcast to the neighborhood with a bullhorn. Just as Great Britain did at the height of her Empire 125 years ago.
My end point here was to offer sympathy for the UK and mention that I see similarities in our respective political situations, nothing more.
What a great episode. Brexit drama getting better and better.
EastEnders whom?
Would U Like Some popcorn with the drama and some coke
All it needs is a Dragon......Oh Dominic. I forgot about you!
Diarmuid Kelleher ijjjjjjijiijjjiijniiijji
would anybody vote for me to become "supreme ruler"..?
as supreme ruler I promise to publically "shame" (Full Game of Thrones style) one prominent person/celebrity a year(decided by me).
I say we pubically "shame" Emma Watson personally(because she needs to be knocked down a peg or two and brought back to reality).
Clapping inside the chamber!!!!!!??? OFF WITH THEIR HEADS!
*slow claps*
I thought that was a no-no as well. Spontaneous delight at the humiliation of Boris, I suppose.
I wish somebody would give Corbyn the clap.
@@Jon908584 more like a slap
Job 908584
It's wonder he hasn't got it had some strange bed fellows🙉🙈🙊
Just in case you were under the misguided belief that our country was being led by intelligent, right-minded and ethical adults, watch 5-minutes of house debates...
Thomas Oxford Boris will get his election. No deal Brexit will happen.
bingbonga binga Without Labour Support and a very healthy majority of -43 I don’t see that happening.
Demand an election - the people have a right to vote for MP's that actually represent them
Correct , thanks to Remainer Quislings clinging to the gravy train.
Utterly disgusting
Face it the politicians just don’t want to leave
craig mitchell pillred I mean we voted to leave, so just leave. I’m no politician either. It’s like what ever either prime minister does parliaments always there to block it. It’s like the prime minister has no control at all
Barba Ra because cancelling brexit would cause nationwide riots
@Barba Ra No there is no majority in Parliament to leave the EU. In fact more than 80% of MPs were backing Remain in the run up to the Referendum. According to a survey of all 650 MPs carried out by the Press Association ahead of the referendum on June 23:
480 MPs said they would be voting Remain, including 184 Conservatives
159 MPs said they would be voting Leave, including 139 Conservatives
11 MPs were undeclared, including four Conservatives
218 Labour MPs said they would vote Remain while just 11 backed Leave.
All eight Liberal Democrat MPs intended to vote Remain, along with all 56 SNP MPs, all three Plaid Cymru MPs, all four Sinn Fein MPs and all three SDLP MPs.
Green MP Caroline Lucas also said she would vote Remain, as did independent MP Sylvia Hermon and the two Ulster Unionist MPs.
The eight DUP MPs said they would be voting to Leave, along with Ukip MP Douglas Carswell.
However the people voted to leave and it is the Governments job to deliver on that result. Unfortunately May was a weak leader and a Remainer at heart. May's deal was not a DEAL it was another TREATY with no deadline or mechanism for the UK to actually leave the EU. Tied to the EU and the ECJ, paying into the project but with no say on what happens there. That is not just a bad deal it is absolutely the worst possible deal.
@@liltone9614 - "I’m no politician"
That much is obvious, given how little thought you put into your "so just leave" comment.
@@svxntt - "because cancelling brexit would cause nationwide riots"
I'm not convinced it would. The kind of people who voted for brexit don't really seem the type to actually put up a showing.
There absolutely will be riots though if the UK leaves without a deal - what with food and medicine shortages.
So really, it's a question of which kind of riot you'd rather have.
The British Parliament should ban jeering and mocking when a member is speaking. All these makes a mockery of the parliament in session which sounds so much like a circus.
It builds character.
Why? That’s what make British Parliament so entertaining! I wish the US does the same!
Boris Johnson is not doing well.
are you confused or something?
@@Flippinloon No, I'm not familiar with British Politics. I apologize. 😆
Aaron F No need to apologize. You are perfectly correct.
Boris is Prime Minister so in that respect he's head and shoulders above the traitors..:)
@@tungstenkid2271 Well , im agree about the shoulders
I literally want the Queen to take control now
You think she has any interest in the lives of the people
I do too! I'm actually hoping she refuses to given Royal Assent to this latest bill so we can just leave on the 31st...
Pathetic.
And the British Government has the gall to criticize certain other countries for being undemocratic dictatorships and "not representing the will of the people".Mother of Parliaments ? Mother of Hypocrites more like.
@M Bacon it actually, literally, did.
Remain or leave.
That simple.
@M Bacon thank you.
Exactly my point: the referendum said nothing about all this.
All this was added later by those who lost and wanted to remain. The referendum itself was a simple question:
... stay or leave.
From a third person's perspective one can only recall one word to describe the goings on...."SHENANIGANS"
Fuckwitery is also a good term
@@tonyjenkins7156 might I offer "jackassery"?
It's a bloody good word
This is 'cock blocking' plain and simple. About as petty as a national stage gets.
The poor fellow, only know as uk Trump.
The way things are carrying on we might as well get colonised by uganda
You are. Lol
😁
+robert + Slim Rudy + Julio Helder
Good , you should have stayed in your own nation and you wouldn't have this problem :) It's not their fault you have such low birth rates. lol
Why aren't we talking about the guy mowing the lawn?? Fluorescent reflective jacket, fluorescent reflective pants, face shield, earmuffs, gloves, helmet, covered wheels on the mower...Wow, overkill much?
You seem to be smoking it
Good spot Matt. lol
@FlyingMonkies325 Nothing to do with the EU, I'm in Australia and this is a worldwide phenomenon (well the first world anyway). The UK has been in the EU while many things have changed in many areas, and therefore (wrongly) blame all the changes on the EU.
The earmuffs are to drown out the sound of screeching gammon
@FlyingMonkies325 you been reading to much of what Boris printed when he was a fake journo hack!
Am I the only one who thinks highlights of government look like children throwing insults on the playground rather than professionals trying to run a country? 😒
LexiconWaffle are you not entertained
Vulpes Lagopus very entertained, just slightly concerned
LexiconWaffle Yh but that’s why our form of government is good, because it’s so confrontational
@@ludogibson7067 Too bad Charles Bronson is dead. He could've been PM.
It's not good when we're bickering with ourselves. If our government was focused on finding the best possible result for all, or even a basic outline that they could improve over time, there would be merit in them being confrontational. But they can't even agree on simple things.
If both of your feet were solely determined to kick the other, you're not walking ten feet without kissing the pavement.
Could you imagine this lot running a Kitchen ?
Rogue Parliament!
Jeremy corbyn all his life has been a eurosceptic look at his voting record Jeremy Corbyn voted for Britain to leave the European Economic Community (EEC) in the 1975 European referendum. Jeremy Corbyn opposed the creation of the European Union (EU) under the Maastricht Treaty speaking and voting against it in Parliament in 1993. Jeremy Corbyn voted for a referendum on Britains membership of the EU in 2011 (breaking the Labour whip to do so) what a disgrace of a man.
Typical Labour they make their living complaining and being obstinate!
Turncoat but he switched to the right side :-p
@@tedverse5726 He hasn't switched, he's still trying to play both sides. Come general election time, he will have to declare one way or the other, and then he'll have to deal with millions of pissed off remainers, or millions of pissed off leavers.
MI6 hello bro
It’s the CIA what’s up fam?
@@johnbull1568 That man is unfit to lead our country. He's most likely going to lose quite a few seats so hopefully he'll never will
The title should be - UK parliament rejects the will of the people. Disgraceful. But we always new that?
I love how people look to Thatcher as a model of "how to behave," a ruthless, contemptuous and cruel vicious woman.
@erushbass Mmmm, how do those boots taste?
Brexit = Clusterfuxit
Not an original comment
Your a phonyyy
That’s what happens when you have 5th columnists in Parliament.
@@kokofan50 5th Columnists? Okay, space cadet...
Gary Constantine, look it up.
@@algoreneedssubscriberstost3902 I couldn't resist it lol
I love British comedy :). This is one of the best TV series in decades.
Just like what we have here in the US. What's not funny is people's lives who are affected by stupid decisions these buffoons make.
Just give the power back to the Queen and let her sort it out
Adidonu joy Sautudina What we need is a one man president- someone like Trump.
@@Username-ww2cd trump 2020
@John Saunders Queen is a strong woman despite being 90yrs old.63 yrs in power i believe she has the experience to solve this problem
>Boris asks for an election
>Parliament refuses
bUt B0riS iS a dIcTaToR
He is a wannabe dictator, no one is saying he is one, he acts like one. is that too complicated for your little brain?
Sieben Q acts like one, wants to be one. I’m not sure what type of dictators you’ve been looking at for you to think that
How NPC of you, lemme break it down. Boris could have called a GE the minute he took office. Why has he waited until now? Because calling a GE before the anti-no deal legislation has been put into law means, theoretically, he could shift the date of the election to after October the 31st - ignoring the will of parliament with a dirty political trick. All the opposition have instead said they will vote for a GE, but only after this legislation has been written into law.
Oh yeah shutting down parliament early ie shutting his opposition off is so democratic. Oh you are speaking about his election and now it magically makes him democratic because he cannot force it?
@BeastlyPanda
Actually, the "best" dictators hold elections that they can't lose in order to validate their rule.
While that's not necessarily the situation here, as, one would hope and imagine that our electoral system is not that corrupt; Boris Johnson's current approach of riding a populist wave certainly does share parallels with the methods used by dictatorships.
Logic, evidence and debate should be at the foundation of our nation's governance; not blind loyalty to a character that promises the world.
You would have been better saying "all dictators love [fair] elections, it's a great way to silence people's voices", with the sarcasm too, of course.
Meanwhile out of the bubble the rest of Britain is falling apart
If they really wanted the people to have a voice they should have a general election
I'm not sure anything would change. Brexit party splits Tory voters and Corbyn splits everyone else and Boris ends up with a slim/nonexistent majority
lewis diver I agree......we are at ‘stalemate’ so a GE would be the best way out, call it a second referendum in disguise but either way the U.K. needs to move on in a direction before we implode!
Craig Roberts no Corbin will have no voters most of the remain voters are backing the Lib Dem’s and the leavers are split between the tories and brexit party brexit is the main topic and Corbins spending plans have been matched by boris so he has no appeal
The thing is, they want to support a General Election, but first want a bill to pass to prevent a no deal from happening in the meantime during the elections. Conservatives are trying to frame it as if they don't want a general election at all. Have watched the who session. The conservatives lying was very cringeworthy.
Boris wins an election now. After no deal is taken off the table, he could lose an election. Then Corbyn can cancel Brexit.
Lock them all up for Treason
Biased broadcasting corporation
*Neil Chapman*
Ah, yes. I see that you’ve taken to my country’s wonderful method of childishly name-calling media outlets. Nice moves, keep it up
I can imagine The Queen walking in with pizzas & sees the entirety of parliament just in flames, with Boris saying, "ITS FINE!!!"
More fun to watch than Canadian Politics, but slightly less than US politics.
"People should be able to express themselves politically, sometimes outside of what the party thinks".
People should. Elected MPs shouldn't if it flies in the face of both their constituents and party, at least if they want to keep pretending they represent said constituents and party. The number of MPs doing the exact opposite of what their constituents want while saying that Boris is the one being undemocratic is ludicrous.
Odor! Odor! Seriously, what is that odor?
Your attempt at humour!
@@MrExEssex It was my attempt, yes. What of it, good sir or madam?
Dios67
The stink of American orthography.
@@frankstein7631 A stink with stealth bombers. I wouldn't think you would wish to lose them as friends, Franklin. Perhaps they could start a world war with those bombers. Then they could be on par with their European cousins.
Its Corbyn, NO that's not an allegation but RATS do stink! and looking a Dianne hlf the time sitting next to him asleep it must be the effect of that same Odor! like friggin chloroform!
Parliament utterly disgusts me .Never forgive !
I love how the British keep talking about yet another extension as if the EU will give one...
Of course. But the EU are pragmatic and will attempt to save Britain from itself.
Tyrone Johnson if only they wouldn’t.... but they will because they want our cash. And our lot are daft enough to keep giving it to them.
@@deathguarddavegoogley2022 🤔??? How much of your cash do they want?
charly van buuren they want a top slice of all the tax I pay. Money that should be being spent on public services in this country. ;)
Let’s hope they won’t hey boy.
Labour and the Lib Dems: "Lets go back to the people!" Boris: "Ok fine lets have an election then" Labour and the Lib Dems: "No!"
It doesn't matter what side you are on, this is just a joke now.
Are you deliberately ignoring their reason for abstaining on a GE right now? They do want and will vote for an election, just after they're sure Boris Johnson can't force a no deal Brexit through election timings.
"Have you lost control Prime Minister" haha why do I find that so hilarious of a question?!
Because you a foreigner that doesn't give a shit OR have a clue, or because your the simply the GENERIC left wing fairy! It is one of them!
Or maybe because it seems absurd to ask such a question when the answer is so obviously yes... at least for now.
No to no deal.
No to election.
No to previous deals (by tmay)
No to another referendum (voted last year)
They dont NO what they want!!
That's BoJos voting record
They want to remain in the European Union but don’t have the balls to say it outright, that’s what.
The whole place stinks
Parliament so out of touch. 60% of labour held electorates vote leave but almost all labour mps want remain. That is why the don’t want an election anymore
It's an utter disgrace that we have not left the EU yet, after a clear majority in 2016.
Not that clear
You russkis aren't even in the EU studarse.
That's because you cant just leave a union that took 20 years to build and negotiate in an afternoon. Are you stupid?
People voted for BREXIT and that means LEAVE...
Elections kick all the remainers OUT
People voted for BREXIT, yes, but the majority of registered voters didn't and that means STAY...
(37.4% for Brexit, 62.6% against or OK with the status quo)
BBC must be happy...
"A desperate disease requires a dangerous remedy."
Quite True; Where is Oliver Cromwell when we need him......
@@roberttreborable Hell no, Cromwell let the tribe back in. They're the cause of all of Europe's problems.
The only disease is the mp,s who say they are for the people yet go against what we voted and cry it's undemocratic to not let them cancel Brexit wtf
What a load of drivel. The actual disease is both sides believing the means are justified by the ends.
@@christiangarvin7351 - What did the people vote for? Pray tell because it seems none of the people who voted Brexit can agree on anything.
still priceless all this time later.
3:00 Why is the devil's pitchfork laying on the floor? I have so many questions.
they stick that up your arse whilst screaming "Democracy"
I love how they keep showing the shot as if the camera man is like "Err... Guys.... *nudge nudge*"
Im wondering where the 17.4 Million people have put their own pitch forks? if being lied to isn't enough NOW - TODAY - even your official votes DONT COUNT!
Shh.. for the after lunch ... recreation ... ;-)
They don't wan't a hard Brexit crashing out but they voted down May's deal too.
So they're stuck.
poodtang2 hard Brexit was a media thing to scare people please don’t be sheepish
@@pauldunne5230 Yeah I know, just trying to make a point.
i was under the impression that the EU would need a unanimous vote to grant an extension and that they were in no mood for it.
But a parliament vote is the will of the people, not the will of a lunatic PM. I don't think that the EU could refuse especially when it is being accused of being non democratic.
@@aidanclarke6106 i understand, but i'm afraid that a threat of being labeled hypocritical and undemocratic has lost it's mojo these days. :)
Truly Theresa May is an iron lady!. To resist in this disaster environment for three years..
Yup and I cant stand her but you have to give her her due
@px321 dxu432 maybe he might send some to you as well
@@greatdelusion7654 lol she tried to get a brexit bill passed 3 times ffs
The opposition has confirmed they believe a bad deal is better than no deal.
Absolute disgrace. The parliament no longer represents the people. We demand a general election
The Parliament defended the people, the economy and applied the law.
Parliament defended the people?? funny joke sheep!!
@@Kitiwake
Parliament defended the people?!?! We were supposed to have left the EUSSR 6 months ago...i voted for WTO no deal!!!
We are now fighting for democracy!
Obviously you fail to understand the situation and the ramifications of overturning a democratic vote due to your personal opinion. By stopping legitimate vote on any subject you set up the overturning of every vote thereafter. Local elections, general elections, referendums, everything! You give grounds for being told "wrong do it again" every time the people go to the ballot box. Such a sad and dangerous move.
@Hauke Holst
What a ridiculous statement...I love Europe and Europeans, I hate the EU...a political construct....you deliberately twist my meaning...shame on you...moron.
Jeremy Corbin: "give the people there vote in a general election"
Boris Johnson: " okay lets have one"
Jeremy Corbin: " "
Corbin was at least smart enough to fall for that Elephant Trap! BoJo would change the date to November the 2nd on them.
I undear stand the hand in which he was trying to play as I do jeremy Corbin's.
But why they insist on backing themselves in to a corner I will never undear stand. I am speaking from experience, I have being backed into a corner. not of my own making while trying to make a deal. It was in a will we had to sell it to this one person. They now we had to sell to them, so they offered half the price it was worth on the open market. There was nothing we could do, If you can't walk away you lose badly.
Didn't he say if the bill passes?
@@AviChetriArtwork well the one to stop the no deal has had the amendments voting on so it's not back to the House of Lords. So we will know at some point this or next week if it's throw
Just give us an election, we need to end this hung parliament. It ain't working, we need a government that has a majority to get deals through parliament.
What is going on right now is essentially the equivalent of your 2016 votes going straight into a shredder.
Why?
Britain is still on to leave.
In what the advisory referendum
@@airdude12345 That became law when they voted to enact it, remember? Oh wait, sorry, Remainers only like votes when it suits them.
2016 wanted to leave. 2019 might not. It was always stupid to have a referendum before a deal.
@@WankersCramp69 Blobby Jobby doesn't like votes when they're against him wanky.
*For the love of Zod* just have a referendum on the options (deal, no deal, rescind Article 50) and then you have your mandate to do what needs to be done.
The result of such a vote would never be accepted by the opposition. Just as the first ref result has been rejected. This is why we must leave eventually. You cannot ignore the voice of the people, in time the opposition will come to understand the absurdity of their position, as much as they may not like it.
Just put in the motion that all these useless MP’s would agree to any outcome of the impending referendum on whatever option is tabled on the deal/brexit issue. no parliament votes, no ayes, no noses, nothing else from the parliament that they would need to further debate on . Still, i dont think that they would even consider that as an option....
There never was a DEAL what May was peddling was just another TREATY binding the UK to the EU with no date or mechanism for leaving. The Referendum was to LEAVE or REMAIN nothing else. A free trade deal would have been ideal but another TREATY is not just a bad deal, it is no deal at all.
@FlyingMonkies325 BS
@Sensual Digest - "No Deal is Brexit the END
"
If only there was some way for you to make your voice heard on that matter in an official capacity, and to determine how many people actually agree with you.
*_IF ONLY_*
And the show goes on
Does Britain realise that France, (at least) considers Britain an ex-UE member state already? (new school books, official government websites etc....).
A Tory mess for tories to fix
If Brexit doesn't happen by 31 Oct, then the Tory Party will lose badly in the next General Election.
Yep, loose Alot of seats to the Brexit party. If that happens the conservatives will loose badly, and Johnson's days will be numbered.
I very much doubt it. Only a vegetable couldn't see what's stopping him - a now thoroughly spent and discredited Corbyn, and cowards who want to overturn the referendum decision on the one hand, and/or undermine the bargaining position on the other.
No deal is the default position, and no deal means the EU get no 39 billion...which they desperately need. The best route to a deal, is to have no deal as an option.
@@bubba842 I think the Brexit Party will harm Labour more in a general election tbh
Deffo Tories will be no more! Now those idiots who voted them into power initially will finally realise what the Tories are really like!
@@jjthecat9692 the Lib Dems will hurt Labour, Hardline Brexiters who vote Conservative will vote Brexit party.
Of course the conservatives could win well if the Brexit party packs it's bags and fucks off, but they are not going to do that.
I love this chaos
🍿🍿🍿
@@jacqdanieles Exactly
me to i want a brexit its going to happen but even worse than corbyn even knows
Really ?
chaos is a ladder.
Who said Jeremy wouldn't make a great Prime Minister
The Country as fallen!!!! Democracy is Dead ....
We had a referendum, we want our independence day.
@1 your deluding yourself if you think we will go down the tubes
@Barba Ra
Here, take a look at this: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Escalation_of_commitment
It's only a wiki page, but there's an element of it at play in the Brexit "debate", I dare say.
You've been beating the shit out of countries for centuries. Have a little patience.
@Barba Ra not everyone can see the future like you obviously can... You are very lucky
The some MP's are attempting to repudiate the will of the people.
Why don't the British people just do another vote on if they want to leave the EU or not? If the vote yes again, then just leave without a deal. If they vote no, probably shows they were not drunk this time?
Plz call more million and million EU people in UK and give full right for benefits every things
After this vote ,EU people in UK they are celebrating and insulating us and saying you will never take freedom from EU
From a foreign point of view.. this is a great blow for democracy.. the people had a Referendum and said to leave.
We vote politicians in do do as we the voters ask ..
Not to do as they please
ok, but there are many different types of brexit possible offered during the debate. There was a hard brexit and a soft brexit and a no deal brexit. I can guarantee that at the time of the referendum the majority of people who voted for brexit didn't think that brexit meant no deal brexit. Its like someone offering you tickets to go to the cinema and you say yes. But when you see that the only film available is some crappy low budget film, would you still want to go to the cinema? Just because you said yes to the cinema doesn't mean that you have to go and see a really bad film, once you see the options and you dont like them you could then say no. That is pretty much the sentiment that some politicians have, in a basic way.
@@squirllovechild I believe that when people voted to leave they want to leave, when you go to leave a house you do walk out of a single room and stay in the building do you? I would argue that they majority would be fine to leave with no deal, many would be fine with a deal but its perfectly clear that the EU prior agreement with May was not in good faith the longer this goes on the more the pot continues to boil.
Yes ... the details are crucial.. So now that the public has seen the complications and the political problems as well..
Make an election issue..and hope the turnout is high and that the desire to leave or stay is also clear..
The western world is greatly divided over so many things... our division will be our eventual down fall... good luck you guys
But me I believe in being one's own master as much as possible..
Nationalism and no global community .. .
Cheers
Misleading title... the House of Commons is not the UK Parliament. One would think the BBC would know the difference about the political structure of its own country.
It’s like a Christmas Panto , embarrassing that these so called elected MPS do not bother listening to the people who put them there.
David Harrison
Wow they haven't been elected you say.
Bloody hell and I thought Boris Johnson was the only member of the House of Commons thwarting the will of Parliament.
You got that right! They have no intention of listening to the people, chuck em all!
Frank Stein ?
I think it’s time for the Queen to shake it up and start again.
Down with the selfish greedy unelected monarchy!
Balian maybe. Reptiles love the same rock!
4:35 Finally ! Two even minded, calm and reasonable adults...
the horses, that is...
So no Brexit. Won’t happen now. Just never ending postponement
Civil war
Blood pressure medicine must be passed out as they enter the chamber there
How hard is it really to make a deal.....that’s your one job
karol Z04 it’s impossible to make a deal we want red the eu needs blue to be a separate entity. It isn’t going to happen. It’s stupid to act like it can
74% of them couldn't manage a knees up in a brewery ffs that's why their in favour of staying!
ruclips.net/video/agZ0xISi40E/видео.html
You can't square a circle
Craig Roberts CGP! Yeah he was a great help in seeing that there is no deal possible. He puts it wel
Forget brexit forget any of your votes being valid either way..what a diabolical situation 😐
Things will never get better in the UK
Not while the EU's around.
Boris has been near destroyed! Such humiliation and utter contempt for him in The Commons.
I applaud MP's for their efforts yesterday evening. The country's eyes are open to the Government's flawed strategy and lies.
@FURRIANWARRIOR I'm not a Labour supporter. Their demise is inevitable also - I agree.
How come the public can vote to leave the EU and this is ignored, but a vote in parliament to block a no deal or prevent an election is upheld? Who is actually in charge here?
How can you say the referendum result has been ignored? Have you not been following politics for the last 3 years!?
@@MrExEssex its been 3 years and nothing has happened I think to safe to say there's been some ignoring
So the MPS want a hung parliament as well as limbo on Brexit vs Remain. Now that is completely the end of any shred of respect one can have for the MPs. If they can't stand Brexit then they should give the people a choice as soon as possible.
It's amazing that Johnson who only had a majority of one with the DUP just decreased his majority by 21 seats to now a minority government, even with the 8 DUP seats.
Just absolutely amazing.
@glyn hodges it's a game and Johnson has played it terribly. The ball is in Corbyn's court and he is playing it very well. Getting what he wants and forcing Johnson to do things he said he wouldn't do.
@glyn hodges he doesn't have to have a general election to do that. Which he won't anyway. Corbyn's plan is to get an extension, get a deal and split the conservative party with a general election after the extension has been granted. If granted. That's his play and judging by the events of the last 2 days he's playing it very well
@glyn hodges that's not what people see. People see that Johnson has failed and Corbyn has got what he wanted. What the Labour manifesto says for the inevitable soon to come General Election I can't say, as you can't either as it has not been released yet. We will see when they release it. But I really doubt it will hand all decision making over to the EU because just as you said it's "unelectable" and he knows that.
@glyn hodges no the alternative is no deal. And with a no deal you will have no choice but to sign some shit desperate last chance deal with the US. Not a very good thing to do.
Just look at NAFTA. Take that as an example of how any deal with the US is always on their terms and is usually terrible for the other countries ie, Canada and Mexico. Trump will know that the PM at the time, be it Boris or whoever, will be desperate for any trade deal. And they will get the shitest deal that Trump wants to give.
I'm an ex Pat that lives in Canada. I've seen it firsthand. Any good deal with the EU will be a thousand times better than any deal with the US.
Pretty clear what will happen now. Since a no deal Brexit (with its implication that the 32 Billion Euro payment would not be made by the the UK) will be taken off the table by the opposition, the EU can simply revert back to its previous stance that the deal negotiated with Mrs. May's team is their final offer. So .. the clock is now turned back to where parliament may have to vote again on the same deal it has already rejected multiple times, will reject it again, and ask for another extension. The EU will say they are tired of the whole thing and tell the UK to take it or leave it by January 31st (final extension), leaving parliament in the position where it needs to either accept an unsatisfactory deal (which it will not do) or cancel the idea of Brexit altogether (which they also cannot do). The opposition will then accept a general election which they will try and frame in the way they wanted to frame the "people's vote" : a choice between a clearly unsatisfactory deal and scrapping Brexit altogether (what they are hoping for) …. with the increasing popular "clean break, no deal" option removed from the options to consider. The Conservatives and Brexit parties will campaign on a "No Deal" platform arguing that they are the only parties committed to honouring the results of the referendum and, if given a majority, will reverse the block to a no deal Brexit and proceed to leave the EU with or without a deal. If a Labour coalition takes power, they will scuttle Brexit or Brexit "in name only". If neither party can form a majority coalition, parliamentary and economic chaos will ensue. This chaos and uncertainty is, and would be, far more damaging to the UK economy than a No Deal Brexit taken promptly would have caused. Pity.
However boris still has the options to go to the queen and ask her to dissolve parliament or issues a vote of no confidence in his own government both of which force a general election in hopes that a majority leave government can be formed
@@robertbobson9344 True !! The next few days should be interesting !
Thanks for this video! Using this in class.
Well , Boris started a nasty game and surprisingly it pays off.He is already in the history books.No PM have ever achieved 3 defeats in the first 3 votes..Well done!!!
The funny thing is all the MPs trying to block No-Deal are complaining about democracy. But we had democracy June 2016
@@svxntt We are a representative democracy, by the way.. Not a direct one, if you make some difference
Iv Hristov either way The remoaning MPs have no clue and are going to ruin this country
You all have had plenty of time to work a better deal.....you had our chance now take your lumps and LEAVE. WTO is better than a terrible deal !
Well it really isn't...
WTO is caveman primitive ....
1:40 "Or is he frit" - did I spot a deliberate echo of Margaret Thatcher there? She used the word in a similar context: "The Right Honourable gentleman [Denis Healey] is afraid of an election is he? Afraid? Frightened? Frit?"
Leave ASAP
An American from New Jersey, I'm glad the UK voted to keep their sovereignty and policy decisions made for and voted for by the PEOPLE of the UK and not the cabal of the EU.
Oh my god!! You don’t do business letting the other person know that you absolutely need to make a deal. It would be costly to say the least
So when we eventually do have a general election, does that mean we can now just ignore the result because we don't like it and maybe just ask somebody from another continent to be our government instead.
Well, USA was willing to purchase Greenland, why not see if they will buy the UK ? ;-)
Childish it’s all childish
I heard Boris can kill the law by letting the time run out on it before giving it to the queen
Biased by the BBC, no screen time for IDS distinctive statement about people’s vote being pointless without a new parliament and Boris fantastic statements about both this being the first time in history that the opposition hasn’t challenged the government AND that this is the first time the opposition has shown confidence in them.
“Can we show a vote of no confidence in her majesties opposition?”
Can we get some news for once? PPB are not on for awhile yet, when they are we can handle bias but right now we just need to hear facts.
And who gives a toss about who’s grandad a politician is, does this make him a better politician by inheritance?
This is amazing. The UK politics is in limbo right now and these people are also the ones who used to rule on many other countries not so long ago. Now they can't even decide their own fate. Lol 😂
Karma
The BBC really need to fire Laura Kunesburg for her outrageous bias.
Meh. I've read plenty of both left and right wingers whine that she's biased against them, which just points to myopic bias in the viewership who complain about bias whenever their side is held under scrutiny. She's fine. Nothing remotely outrageous.
There will be no delay and no extension.
It’s almost an impossibility at this point.
generic username Have you been watching current events🤔 .... I don’t think you have🤦♂️
@Leigh Chapman
Very closely and I am obviously better informed than you 😎
a simpleton said no deal wasent in the referendum, it wasent because I didn't have to be, because David Cameron explained before the referendum exactly what leave was meant to be.. including pamphlets given to explain it.. so leave with a deal didn't have to be written on the referendum paper.. he said before we stay or we leave it was that simple and didn't have to be written on the referendum paper on the day we voted... that's why he cried when leave won...
batfink forever
Thank God you didn't have to be in the referendum or otherwise we'd have been rightly up the wazoo.
Anyone know where Guy Forks is buried , the British people need him..
56? His own party didnt vote for him?
Well, he isn't being very nice to his party and he attempted to flush the debates down the toilet.
The fact they didn't vote for it says it all
How disrespectful to clap in the House of Commons, everyone knows you're not allowed to clap, that's why you say "here here".
Wtf?!
These MP's and respect don't correlate
Good!!!!
We want a people's vote. We want a people's vote. We want a people's vote. We want a people's vote. We want a people's vote. No, not really
- corbyn