This is how idols should be if they have songs they should be at least good singers. Aespa having superior vocals really means they are true singers not just dancers
Let's not forget that it was their first performance in front of a huge audience, I meant, they debuted during pandemic, no concerts no nothing, straight up Coachella, if they were given another chance they'd slay more 😭
Only thing they lacked was stage presence back then, but they've grown so much since and it would've been iconic to see them back at Coachella on a bigger stage with the stage production budget they deserved in 2022, no doubt they would've brought the dramaaaaah
That’s because they literally debuted in the middle of the pandemic, though not even music shows have an audience. but I agree if they are the ones that attend this year’s coachella, definitely bring that dramaaaaah 🔥
@@ucihaitachi3869 nobody said anything abt them??? lol ??? actually rent free💀 i mentioned how bad of a company sm is and you’re like “yeah but lsfm” u fr don’t seem to understand how weird that is
Coachella was the first event where aespa performed live. Before this they always do lip sync and people criticized them when they were announced in coachella lineup. They not only performed live but also shut the haters mouth. I litterally startd stanning them after their coachella performance....
The Coachella stage wasn't the first stage they sang live, because during 'Forever' promotions they also performed live, if I'm not mistaken it was for Arabic TV? I forgot, basically at that time they had to wear more closed clothes, but they were still filming in Korea. The Coachella stage is the first stage where they have to perform in front of audience. Sorry for my bad english
And mind you people, Aespa was considered rookie and debut with no audience, they performed with small amount of audience to COACHELLA!? they don't have experience to hype the audience that much BUT THEY DID SO GOOD!!!
I agree, I'm not a fan of aespa but they did so well considering their Covid release and the band is only 1-2 years old, I don't understand why LS fans are bringing up the issue of the band's age. Because AESPA then and LS now have the same age group, AESPA is doing very well. Their singing voices set the stage on fire. They are very talented. I admire them from my heart. Again, I'm not an AESPA fan, I'm a BP fan.
Aespa getting the recongnition they deserve after 2 years 😭 the way i remember how some of yall were bashing this performance to the ground during aespas hate train era
Ningning's and winter's high notes are just so amazing..sm really produces great singers..nd Karina is literally an ace..she is the lead rapper, leader of the group,main dancer,face of the group ,and also can easily be the lead singer..her capabilities must be well appreciated! Giselle is improving day by day! Love her!🍭
@@k_pop_entertainment Shup up, this performance is great for a rookie who debuted on 2020. They were stable, singing live while dancing and they interacted with the public during the performance.
@@k_pop_entertainmentthey were a rookie group and debuted during pandemic so most of the time they were not performing infront of live audience then suddenly they got pushed into this huge international stage,i feel like they did very well but yeah they lacked stage presence but except that everything was great
Ppl are hypocrites honestly, they hated Aespa and Blackpink for their "performances" at Coachella but now their comparing Le Sserafim to them saying Aespa and BP done very good. What's wrong with ppl????
@@clock2010 it’s a positive comment. it was a failed translation because of the slang but in english terms the op was saying aespa will “slay” if they go to coachella next year
Why are mys repeating the same thing? They were badly critized by kpop fans back then cuz of lack of stage presence and boring performance but now they are do the same thing to le sserafim. The same with blackpink fans, they were critized for lazy or provocative dancing, doing the same thing to other about their vocals. I can accept the criticism. But they are really hated for no reason. Why does kpop fans never unite or couldn't mind their own business. I bet the next group who will go to Coachella will be hated the same at this point.
But... Is this obviously, no?.. Hybe's groups have lack and weak vocal (except Seventeen), SM groups always was the best in vocal. Right now SM groups is not so good and not leaders in vocal, but better than Hybe's still. Le Sserafim on the last place about vocal in 4th gen gg. Aespa on the 3th plase (after Nmixx and StayC) and Ningning personally is #3 girls vocalist of gen after Lily and Haewon.
I'm a casual listener but i gotta admit aespa is perfect for me; their song, their live performance; their personalities and their visual is top notch! 😻
This and Lesserafim's, show us that charisma and stage presence its what really works for giving a show, Aespa did sing good but public was so dead, Lesserafim did sing bad but people were hyped...
Their stage was literally very good the only thing lacking was a lill stage presence watching this year's Coachella feels like "ohhmaaagawwddd wuttt is thattt"😭💀
No one steps back from criticizing Aespa for their stage presence but for other artist, 'Oh its okay not to have stable vocals since the choreo is hard',,, so much double standards.. Every group out there works hard equally,, every group has their own lacking,, so they should be treated equally..
The main problem with other group is not the vocals but the songs, I mean it's common knowledge that most idols can't actually sing or do high notes, so what they have to do is release songs with easier notes
@@pipicute615 it's only hybe though. Kpop still has a lot of talent if you look around . Riize and kiss of life debuted a few months ago and they slay in vocals. Hybe does a lot of promotions but no vocal training
They lacked stage presence during their performance considering they were just rookies at that time but they eventually improved over time, I bet they will rock the stage if they perform again. Plus their song isn't something that should be perform on that event.
This is why groups need to have set positions most groups with unofficial positions lack a really good main vocalist and their main vocalists are at lead vocalists level and not get me started at other members
A lot of blinks felt threatened back then and made a lot of videos twisting it around as if aespa were bad and that the audience didn't like them even though that wasn't the case.
I didnt, I was trying so hard to defend them But it’s very hypocrite that the same ppl that criticized them are the same ppl who are comparing them with lsm
there's more to idols than just vocals. it's so funny cs it's so clear a lot of u are js jumping into the hate bandwagon for le sserafim. if anything, the only thing they lacked was vocals (which they did okay with but people were only showing the WORST parts of it), but stage presence and dancing wise they were so good. aespa had vocals and dance but they didn't have stage presence. blackpink had great stage presence and vocals but the one thing they lacked was choreo (even though i like it simple but compared to other groups, their choreos are easier).
![[MPD직캠] 에스파 1위 앵콜 직캠 4K 'Spicy' (aespa FanCam No.1 Encore) | @MCOUNTDOWN_2023.5.18](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/edHydgKcCwQ/mqdefault.jpg)
![Kodak Black - Dis Time [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/V3g4JDQkE9U/mqdefault.jpg)
y’all lose your minds over the bare minimum when it comes to kpop performances it’s sad.
because it’s so rare these days with company’s debuting looks over talent
@@thisisarandomurl2000PREACH
Because some groups these days don't know how to sing
Because the new Coachella performance of some Kpop group is trash so praising Aespa is their right..
@@moon_princess000'the new Coachella performance' don't need to hide it we all know who you are talking about and you are not wrong 😂
This is how idols should be if they have songs they should be at least good singers. Aespa having superior vocals really means they are true singers not just dancers
Let's not forget that it was their first performance in front of a huge audience, I meant, they debuted during pandemic, no concerts no nothing, straight up Coachella, if they were given another chance they'd slay more 😭
"They are singers not just dancers" idk why but it feels like you're talking about le sserafim coachella performance 💀
@@StrawbeLia_Solosthey can’t sing so probably
Hybe should hire aespa to train their talents, especially sakura and moka.
@@rianekafauziah7825debut in front of an audience indeed! this was 2022 the pandemic prevented us from having any live shows
Only thing they lacked was stage presence back then, but they've grown so much since and it would've been iconic to see them back at Coachella on a bigger stage with the stage production budget they deserved in 2022, no doubt they would've brought the dramaaaaah
That’s because they literally debuted in the middle of the pandemic, though not even music shows have an audience. but I agree if they are the ones that attend this year’s coachella, definitely bring that dramaaaaah 🔥
@takecarebilly_ True, but even so, they still did a fairly good job
This was Aespa FIRST EVER LIVE PERFORMANCE with crowd (audience)
they will have another opportunity for sure
it's better than lacking vocals 💀
Karina’s tone at the beginning is so pretty
she's not main vocalist but still manage to slay omagahhh
so true i love her vocal tone the most
@@richardk-iz9qu fr she definitely slayed the vocals
Typical SM group. The main vocalists are there to elevate the group, but all members must have a solid singing skill.
That’s how it should be singers need to know how to sing
they all have it are you deaf?
hybe could neva😂
@@ringofsolomon268 i think misunderstood
Avg sm artists slaying vocals
probably cause they’ll be forced to work out for hours on end, or not be able to eat dinner if they mess up, just SM things 🥰
@@sybill123fulfr but still that's better than what's happening with leserrafim now
It’s aespa.. cmon now! They were obviously going to have exquisite vocals ❤
@@ucihaitachi3869 nobody said anything abt them??? lol ??? actually rent free💀 i mentioned how bad of a company sm is and you’re like “yeah but lsfm” u fr don’t seem to understand how weird that is
@@sybill123fulOr the SM auditions are very strict and selective on who should be a trainee
Finally seeing appreciation for aespa, I stan the right group, always for improvement of their craft
I love your name
Me too🦋🌙💙⭐
cause finally they sing live
Coachella was the first event where aespa performed live. Before this they always do lip sync and people criticized them when they were announced in coachella lineup. They not only performed live but also shut the haters mouth. I litterally startd stanning them after their coachella performance....
it isn't the first time they performed live tho. but it was the first time they performed in front of a audiences that's not staffs.
The Coachella stage wasn't the first stage they sang live, because during 'Forever' promotions they also performed live, if I'm not mistaken it was for Arabic TV? I forgot, basically at that time they had to wear more closed clothes, but they were still filming in Korea. The Coachella stage is the first stage where they have to perform in front of audience.
Sorry for my bad english
@@MonalisaNeverCryDontYouSeeno these arabkitv also was online wo audience
@@snowminL485 I never said that Arab tv has an audience
That's how live singing should be. Soooooo stable
Whilst Ningning and Winter are slaying those final highnotes Karina and Giselle are slaying their dance 😮❤
I really want them to perform again
X2 ahora todos dicen perdonenme a aespa xd
And mind you people, Aespa was considered rookie and debut with no audience, they performed with small amount of audience to COACHELLA!? they don't have experience to hype the audience that much BUT THEY DID SO GOOD!!!
Nahh honestly they were fckn amazing
I agree, I'm not a fan of aespa but they did so well considering their Covid release and the band is only 1-2 years old, I don't understand why LS fans are bringing up the issue of the band's age. Because AESPA then and LS now have the same age group, AESPA is doing very well. Their singing voices set the stage on fire. They are very talented. I admire them from my heart. Again, I'm not an AESPA fan, I'm a BP fan.
@@t_e_e01thank you❤
It’s weird because aespas performance wasn’t bad, they just weren’t popular in the us at the time so know one knew who they were
True
Plus their songs aren’t suited to Americans. Americans love R&B like LeSserafim’s “Easy”
Aespa getting the recongnition they deserve after 2 years 😭 the way i remember how some of yall were bashing this performance to the ground during aespas hate train era
Fr
Ningning's and winter's high notes are just so amazing..sm really produces great singers..nd Karina is literally an ace..she is the lead rapper, leader of the group,main dancer,face of the group ,and also can easily be the lead singer..her capabilities must be well appreciated! Giselle is improving day by day! Love her!🍭
do you also remember how aespa criticized about this performance? they deserved better
NO. Stop. please. WE deserve better. This stage is not good, just Le Sserafim was too much terrible. K-pop standarts too low already
@@k_pop_entertainment lol idk what you mean, even before le serrafims performance, aespa did really well, their vocals were amazing
@@k_pop_entertainment Shup up, this performance is great for a rookie who debuted on 2020. They were stable, singing live while dancing and they interacted with the public during the performance.
Ur fav could never@@k_pop_entertainment
@@k_pop_entertainmentthey were a rookie group and debuted during pandemic so most of the time they were not performing infront of live audience then suddenly they got pushed into this huge international stage,i feel like they did very well but yeah they lacked stage presence but except that everything was great
Isn't Karina a rapper? She can hit highnote and have vibrato?! My girl is amazing!❤
DAMN NINGNING'S VOCALS AAAAAH I LOVE HER
Giselle also slayed so hard ❤❤❤❤😢😢😢
Ikr
Gigi and ningning sp at Coachella>>>>>>>>
@@peppathetastiestbacon6310yess ghurl i mean
NINGSELLE SP >>>>>>>
WINRINA STABLE >>>>>>
Fr like, no one is praising my girl😭 ot4 slayed
Yesssss
They deserve a second chance in coachella.
지금보니 에스파는 잘했음. 성량이 작아도 가수적인 스킬이 느껴지잖아.. 그에 반해 르세라핌은 가수라는 느낌도 안든다고;
성량이 뭐가 작음?
@@DDaseok 블랙핑크에 비교해서? 암튼 잘함
현장음이라 작게 들리는 거 같음
@@user-vm6xn4sz3u 블핑은 현장음이라도 성량 개커요. 암튼 에스파 잘함
에스파는 헤드마이크니까 핸드마이크랑 비교할때 성량을 담을순 없음. 카리나 윈터는 성량 개클거같음
Let’s support Aespa !! Hybe said they wanna step on Aespa but they can’t debut talented groups so…
hybe girl groups vocal is so baaaad.. how they wanna step on vocal queens?
Aespa deserves a BIG APOLOGY!!! Compared to that group they did a very good job in their live vocals.
Ppl are hypocrites honestly, they hated Aespa and Blackpink for their "performances" at Coachella but now their comparing Le Sserafim to them saying Aespa and BP done very good. What's wrong with ppl????
내년에 가서 에스파가 코첼라 찢어질듯
제발 갔으면
그니까 지금처럼 무대에서 여유 생기고 어느정도 안정적일 때 갔으면 씹어먹었지 저때도 깡신인인데 저정도 한 거임
간지가 안 남. 걍 코첼라는 블핑급 아이돌 아니면 페기구 같은 아티스트 올려보내자 ㅠ
더큰무대로 가야져❤
@@clock2010the translation is bad the person is saying they want aespa to go back go coachella
@@clock2010 it’s a positive comment. it was a failed translation because of the slang but in english terms the op was saying aespa will “slay” if they go to coachella next year
They were the best at Coachella!And Ateez too🔥
i'd love to see aespa at coachella, the girls have so much talent the crowd would love them 🤍
karina voice is one of the best in the kpop
Blackpink and aespa really ate that crumbs.
Frrrrrrrrrrr
I remember Ningning was not feeling well during this stage. Right? And they all still slayed.
"Ningning responds" 😂
Hehe
after listening to lesserafim at Coachella 2024💆🏻♀️💆🏻♀️💆🏻♀️, aespa deserve an apology ")
True
it's all mental health matters, but only when it's a group you stan 🤒
They all did well just stop commenting bad things it's useless taking back your words after saying out
You look mad
Why are mys repeating the same thing? They were badly critized by kpop fans back then cuz of lack of stage presence and boring performance but now they are do the same thing to le sserafim. The same with blackpink fans, they were critized for lazy or provocative dancing, doing the same thing to other about their vocals. I can accept the criticism. But they are really hated for no reason. Why does kpop fans never unite or couldn't mind their own business. I bet the next group who will go to Coachella will be hated the same at this point.
Best vocal SM never disappoint in VOCALS OR VISUALS!!!!
This is what you call live!🔥✨
This is how you sing live ❤
There's no lie when people say "AESPA VOCAL AS A GROUP IS NOT JOKE "✨
Winter is always the best at live
This is how she became my bias, she's incredible live, like the CD and sometimes even better! Saw them in Tx and she was insane 🙀
Can we talk about karina's vocal to?!!! Her voice so good
Aespa vocal better than le sserafim 😅
But... Is this obviously, no?.. Hybe's groups have lack and weak vocal (except Seventeen), SM groups always was the best in vocal. Right now SM groups is not so good and not leaders in vocal, but better than Hybe's still.
Le Sserafim on the last place about vocal in 4th gen gg.
Aespa on the 3th plase (after Nmixx and StayC) and Ningning personally is #3 girls vocalist of gen after Lily and Haewon.
@@k_pop_entertainment aespa vocal is better then nmixx and stayc.
Facts
🎉🎉🎉
NMIXX better in vocals even I"m AESPA stan @@krushers135. Most of NMIXX members can sing live
a certain group from hybe could never
Lol u are so jobless.. btw that group was dancing their heart out meanwhile these girls are bearly dancing so before comparing atleast think bro
@@snehakindo5798 I love LSFM but Sakura, Eunchae and Kazuha can't even sing while standing still on stage
@MeagannBolton newjeans are pretty good actually, their encores are stable considering their choreos
They are bad what medicore my neice can sing better@MeagannBolton
@MeagannBolton your standards are so low i guess u havent heard great vocals listen to exo pr wendy or taeyeon or babymonsters rami ahyeon covers
I'm a casual listener but i gotta admit aespa is perfect for me; their song, their live performance; their personalities and their visual is top notch! 😻
아니진짜 ㅈㄴ잘함
이번 르세라핌 코첼라 봤더니 계속 타돌 코첼라 무대 영상 뜨네ㅋㅋ 알고리즘이란..
블핑은 신이였고 에스파는 선녀였다
Ateeze was pirate 😂
그래도 르세라핌에 비하면 에스파도 신이지.......
Вокал ниннин просто рай для ушей и винтер кстати очень хороша ❤
dancing + singing ,no stupid lame excuses aespa girls are the best
they should return at Coachella
I’ve come here to cleanse my ears after listening to Coachella and encore performances.
R u ready to shake some ass 😅😅
NINGNING ❤❤❤
Giselle herself could outsing 90% of the 4/5th gen
gilssss queen ningning ❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥
Anyone here after Leseraffims Coachella Performance
This and Lesserafim's, show us that charisma and stage presence its what really works for giving a show, Aespa did sing good but public was so dead, Lesserafim did sing bad but people were hyped...
Their stage was literally very good the only thing lacking was a lill stage presence watching this year's Coachella feels like "ohhmaaagawwddd wuttt is thattt"😭💀
SM artists are no joke when it comes to vocals, raps and dance.
No one steps back from criticizing Aespa for their stage presence but for other artist, 'Oh its okay not to have stable vocals since the choreo is hard',,, so much double standards..
Every group out there works hard equally,, every group has their own lacking,, so they should be treated equally..
NINGNING FIYAH!!
on fireee all ❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥🤟
this person's 'aAAaAAaAaAaAAaAaAAHhhh' at the end is the mist relatable thing I've heard
Omg it gives me goosebumps
Как прекрасно видеть такое пение после видео выступлений молодых групп (вы понимаете, о ком я 💀💀💀)
Я понимаю, что ты чувствуешь, но давай будем добрее 🙂(извините, если перевод неправильный, мне помогает приложение для перевода)
@@serenaslay ❤️
The main problem with other group is not the vocals but the songs, I mean it's common knowledge that most idols can't actually sing or do high notes, so what they have to do is release songs with easier notes
What companies have to do is train their idols to sing properly and keep training them even after debuting
@@lynxzen.2884 yeah but sadly kpop is only about visual nowadays
@@pipicute615 it's only hybe though. Kpop still has a lot of talent if you look around . Riize and kiss of life debuted a few months ago and they slay in vocals. Hybe does a lot of promotions but no vocal training
@@pipicute615well mostly girggroups excluding SM groups ofcourse and a few others like nmixx , itzy, idle , babymon
@@pipicute615The phrase "KPop is only about visuals" only applies to Hybe
歌唱力は確かに素晴らしい👍👍盛り上げる力は向こうが勝ってるね
They lacked stage presence during their performance considering they were just rookies at that time but they eventually improved over time, I bet they will rock the stage if they perform again. Plus their song isn't something that should be perform on that event.
Why is the crowd freaking dead
Mean while sakura = playing victim after get criticm from netizen 🤣🤣
I think reason why netizens citizen them was they're more focused on singing than performing.... Anyway aespa did 100% way better for rookie group
Karina voice is so sexy and deep
Are they performing alone?! I can't hear cheers and noises of audience that much 😅😥
MY BABY AESPA❤❤❤
That's why I love Aespa ❤❤❤
their live vocals are just amazing they don't need lis syncing 🤞🏻
AESPA ATE 🦋🌙💙⭐
The way Karina is a lead rapper but can be one of the best vocalists is INSANE
Lesserafim : les tari les ges tari 😢
they ate and left no crumbs
SM focusing on BOTH of the needed skills for idols is just ✨️ Imagine just doing dancing and being pretty while your work is labeled as "IDOL"
The difference between them and Le Sserafim 😭
They love singing you can tell ❤
Powerhouse of vocals ❤aespa❤
My standard is so high since I stan SM artists
they were amazing here!! and to think they've grown so much since then...
Ughhhh I need more Aespa live singing bc THESE GIRLS CAN _SING._ My semi-ults for a reason 👏🏻👏🏻
SME LET THEM SING !!
지금 나가면 더 잘하겠넹..
Sorry?
@@serenaslay
지금 나가면 = If they perform again
더 잘하겠넹 = They will do better
❤
@@llIIllIlIlIlllIllIIllllIlIllIl ❤️👍🏻
@@serenaslayhe/she basically said that I would be good if aespa go to Coachella again
Your voice ‘s beautiful
.
They have so much talent as you can see here, I think it’s great sm is starting to let them sing live more often.
This is why groups need to have set positions most groups with unofficial positions lack a really good main vocalist and their main vocalists are at lead vocalists level and not get me started at other members
The most iconic Coachella performance
Aespa has more high notesin one song than entre hype song collections
Giselle ❤️🔥❤️🔥
Why did they get so much hate for Coachella performance? I truly don’t get it
A lot of blinks felt threatened back then and made a lot of videos twisting it around as if aespa were bad and that the audience didn't like them even though that wasn't the case.
Not y'all acting as if no one bullied them when they actually performed at Coachella
I didnt, I was trying so hard to defend them
But it’s very hypocrite that the same ppl that criticized them are the same ppl who are comparing them with lsm
@@Katarinabluu_MYsadly it's like a complete cycle that is going to happen to whichever group performs next on as well
People really forget how they were hating on Aespa huh
Oh they slayy😭😭
Aespa : 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
👥 : *Gosebump everywhere*
Que hermoso 😍😍❤❤❤❤
If Aespa actually wait a bit more their Coachella attendance would have been a big deal.
there's more to idols than just vocals. it's so funny cs it's so clear a lot of u are js jumping into the hate bandwagon for le sserafim. if anything, the only thing they lacked was vocals (which they did okay with but people were only showing the WORST parts of it), but stage presence and dancing wise they were so good. aespa had vocals and dance but they didn't have stage presence. blackpink had great stage presence and vocals but the one thing they lacked was choreo (even though i like it simple but compared to other groups, their choreos are easier).
Calm down jemal
Their live vocals are much stable than my life 😂😂
That's what i call "true singers"❤
у карины такой хороший тон голоса
NO CUZ I GOT CHILLS AFTER HEARING WINTER'S AND NINGNING'S LAST HIGH NOTES THEY'RE JUST AMAZING BRO