I would really love to hear the referee's explanation of what exactly Koch was supposed to do differently for the penalty on the stroke of half time (5:32). The call was "not rolling away" - but he makes the tackle, hits the ground, and then *instantly* moves away. He doesn't rest on the Scottish side of the ruck for even a fraction of a second.
The problem is the ref sees the hands rather the body movement to move away for clear release. Koch had his hands on the ball always without releasing after tackling. Which constitutes an infringement in the ruck
Koch didn't do much wrong himself and neither did the south african player over the top of the ball - the problem was koch rolling away allowed the SA man to get his hands on the ball because the scottish players weren't able to clear the ruck, due to Koch. It's been penalised a fair few times before and is more just unlucky but fair as koch allowed SA to turn the ball over
@@TheTruthDon Sure, but what's he supposed to do differently? Law 14.5: Tackle - Player Responsibilities "Tacklers must: - Immediately release the ball and the ball-carrier after both players go to ground. - Immediately move away from the tackled player and from the ball or get up. - Be on their feet before attempting to play the ball. - Allow the tackled player to release or play the ball. - Allow the tackled player to move away from the ball." At what moment exactly did Koch breach one of those responsibilities? There's nothing in there about making sure that when you make a tackle, you fall in a position that is convenient to the opposition players trying to clear out at the ruck. It just says you have to move away immediately, which he did.
A All Time Great in a All Time Great Team . SPEED , POWER AND GAME INTELLECT .THE BOKS THAT WIN THE 2019 WORLD CUP . WERE A AWESOME TEAM . Still a Awesome team . From MUNSTER .
This wasn’t the commentary I heard watching on Amazon Prime. 1st Scottish try did have a flat pass, but no more than the boks. Say what u like, great to see Scotland play well against, arguably, the best team in the world. Boks forwards were fantastic, turned over lots of play, scrum master class and line out skills. This could have been a cricket score match for Scotland. GG.
A bit late to the party here, but, I am so uncertain about Scotland. This game, and the most recent game against England, they have been pretty poor. Of couse against England, they squeeked the win, and here, despite how bad the attack was, they were still within scoring range until the last 10 minutes against the best team in the world, despite probably the worst attacking performance in a year or more. You just get this feeling with the Scotland squad that if they can iron out the attacking issues this six nations, they could become the best team in the world, or at least close to it. Like even the tries Scotland scored in this game, were extremely messy and not very clinical or accurate for Scotlands standards. End more recently against England, the same as this game their defence was probably top 3 in the world, but their attack seemed to be missing that cutting edge, despite really good accuracy
@@davidw.robertson448 yeah I think the past decade more so than ever. They are always the team that almost did. Big performances against big teams, but just losing out. Poor performances against poor teams and just squeezing the win It's a shame, because every year i get so hopeful and there seems to be so much promise and every year it never happens However, for sure this is the best period in terms of performance from a Scottish team since the early 2000's
That's what's wrong with Scotland and its supporters. The score was 30 to 15. they were twice as good as you on the scoreboard. It wasn't close. And even if it was you lost. Stop settling for being gallant losers. It's the wrong mentality, you can drown in a foot of water, or a thousand metres, you're still dead. Stop saying good game, well played, they did well. They didn't they were comprehensively beaten
@@Sunshinez732 I heard a stat that, at the last World Cup, De Allende made more meters _after contact_ than some other backs did in the entire tournament!
@@Britishbandogge I’ve played it for 7 years lmao. I’m a MMA fighter tho, I prefer it because there is no team. If something goes wrong it’s my fault and I have no one to blame
The first penalty should go to the Boks. Mapimpi over the ball then taken out from the side, and the SA 14 tried to get out the way. after a brilliant tackle.
He did go to tmo they ruled not gorward his hands were in a backwards motion plus the pass was totally fine only looks forward because Kolisi stopped runiing after the pass was made
When the Scottish commentator started talking about how Frans Steyn was a baby faced prettyboy back in 2006/7 and was now a ruggard bearded ugly Boer I spat my 0% Alcohol beer out 😂😂🤣🤣... Steyn looked like a model back then... Wtf happened. They edited it out of this package
Scotland first try was pass forward ! SA with pollard is a different animal . Their coach needs to figure out that he has to use those top notch backs more .
Scottish scrum gets demolished Commentators: "It's happened again, they being pushed back. But they've played very well for Leicester and had a stellar season." Clearly this isn't Leicester. They getting shown the true definition of scrummaging. Not the willy wally scrumming in English Premiership. Boks showing why they have one of the best forward packs in the world
This was only a year ago and I reckon at most only half this Scotland team will feature against SA in the World Cup. There's three in this side who will never play for Scotland again (McInally, Hogg, McLean.) Literally only one of the backline is likely to start (VDM.)
It’s typical Scotland, they win one game and they are talking themselves up. Hogg does it especially, it’s funny. They act up as well trying to win frees.
Most comment threads for rugby matches are so chill, congratulatory and friendly, but then you have a game with SA/Scotland and everyone is bitching? I think Rassie is part of the problem here.
Yeah, I love the guy but he really brought out a terrible attitude in us Springbok fans. I hope we can get over it soon because it's frankly embarassing the way we bitch about every single decision that goes against us and in this match's case even decisions that don't go against us.
Mate saffers would complain at a funeral, they win 30 to 15 got away with a couple of decisions and they're moaning . I'm a kiwi and since neutral referees came in we beat them 3 out of 4 tests, home and away. But they honestly believe they won most of those tests. No One ever beats them, you just score more points than them
I thought the ref favoured the boks. The Scottish were actually the better team although they made a few midtskes but the ref loved pinging them just when they were getting on top. Scotland could have won that game. The Boks are definitely beatable.
That first penalty against Jesse Kriel? I mean, what is he supposed to do? He tackles van der Merwe and immediately gets away from the ruck, but is pinged for not rolling away? Trigger happy refereeing
I saw that it was obvious that it was a foward pass but because it was two maybe three passes before the ball hit the South African player, I think they just let it slide but I agree it was forward for sure. And im not a Springbok fan im an Aussie.
I know that springboks can't except that they can concede tries and always blame the referee, but cmon guy your acting as though the ref has been paid off XD
Winter MARIE HAINES RAD FORD 21 44 ILOVE YOU RIG ON BOX MARY ILOVE ❤ YES 😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤ WATER TONIGHT BABY and PREGNANT LAST NIGHT NETS
12:45 Malcolm Marx, 3 Scot players can't get him off the ball. Its not only Marx, the Boks are undoubtedly master's at the breakdown. They will molest you all day long at the breakdown.
At 4 m and 30 seconds Scotland should have received a yellow card for a shoulder charge on Makazoli Mapimpi. Where was the referee, linesman and the two. Oh wait that only applies when Springboks are at fault. Watch out for karma if you play with bias😂
What did the Bokke do wrong when the Referee gave that penalty to Scotland ? The scots were diving over the pack - not standing on their feet.The referee gave that penalty as soon as the ball hit the ground. The rules about this game is becomimg weirder and weider. No wonder Sonny Boy Williams 'refer' to the game as becoming complicated. Stop messing around with rules of the game. All those northern hemp' teams want to change the rules of the game so that they dont look so bad . Stephen Jones, Matt Williams, Keith wood & Willie John McBride. The 1972 B Lions in South Africa had depth in their teams and beat the Springboks 3.5 to .5. Guess who was the captainof the B Lions ? Willie John McBride. Now he question the depht of the Springboks ?
![Blox Fruits Dragon Rework Update [Full Stream]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EqDAp8udhm0/mqdefault.jpg)
Up the south! Greetings from Argentina
Beautifully worked first try via Scotland, hands/heads up rugby. Marx so strong over the ball. Mapimpi brilliant as always
I would really love to hear the referee's explanation of what exactly Koch was supposed to do differently for the penalty on the stroke of half time (5:32). The call was "not rolling away" - but he makes the tackle, hits the ground, and then *instantly* moves away. He doesn't rest on the Scottish side of the ruck for even a fraction of a second.
It was a weak call but because he was there, the other player was able to contest and win the breakdown turnover.
The problem is the ref sees the hands rather the body movement to move away for clear release. Koch had his hands on the ball always without releasing after tackling. Which constitutes an infringement in the ruck
@@johncena5991 we didnt watch the same highlights
Koch didn't do much wrong himself and neither did the south african player over the top of the ball - the problem was koch rolling away allowed the SA man to get his hands on the ball because the scottish players weren't able to clear the ruck, due to Koch. It's been penalised a fair few times before and is more just unlucky but fair as koch allowed SA to turn the ball over
@@TheTruthDon Sure, but what's he supposed to do differently?
Law 14.5: Tackle - Player Responsibilities
"Tacklers must:
- Immediately release the ball and the ball-carrier after both players go to ground.
- Immediately move away from the tackled player and from the ball or get up.
- Be on their feet before attempting to play the ball.
- Allow the tackled player to release or play the ball.
- Allow the tackled player to move away from the ball."
At what moment exactly did Koch breach one of those responsibilities? There's nothing in there about making sure that when you make a tackle, you fall in a position that is convenient to the opposition players trying to clear out at the ruck. It just says you have to move away immediately, which he did.
A All Time Great in a All Time Great Team . SPEED , POWER AND GAME INTELLECT .THE BOKS THAT WIN THE 2019 WORLD CUP . WERE A AWESOME TEAM . Still a Awesome team . From MUNSTER .
Murrayfield is such a gorgeous stadium.
That is a very weird remark. It's just like all the other national stadia, except worse.
This wasn’t the commentary I heard watching on Amazon Prime. 1st Scottish try did have a flat pass, but no more than the boks. Say what u like, great to see Scotland play well against, arguably, the best team in the world. Boks forwards were fantastic, turned over lots of play, scrum master class and line out skills. This could have been a cricket score match for Scotland. GG.
A bit late to the party here, but, I am so uncertain about Scotland. This game, and the most recent game against England, they have been pretty poor. Of couse against England, they squeeked the win, and here, despite how bad the attack was, they were still within scoring range until the last 10 minutes against the best team in the world, despite probably the worst attacking performance in a year or more. You just get this feeling with the Scotland squad that if they can iron out the attacking issues this six nations, they could become the best team in the world, or at least close to it. Like even the tries Scotland scored in this game, were extremely messy and not very clinical or accurate for Scotlands standards. End more recently against England, the same as this game their defence was probably top 3 in the world, but their attack seemed to be missing that cutting edge, despite really good accuracy
Can’t argue with you there lad, Scotland did well and I respect that 🇿🇦❤️🏴
@@ShanleH That's the history of Scottish rugby. Ever the bridesmaid, never the bride. At least for the past thirty years.
@@davidw.robertson448 yeah I think the past decade more so than ever. They are always the team that almost did. Big performances against big teams, but just losing out. Poor performances against poor teams and just squeezing the win
It's a shame, because every year i get so hopeful and there seems to be so much promise and every year it never happens
However, for sure this is the best period in terms of performance from a Scottish team since the early 2000's
That's what's wrong with Scotland and its supporters. The score was 30 to 15. they were twice as good as you on the scoreboard. It wasn't close. And even if it was you lost. Stop settling for being gallant losers. It's the wrong mentality, you can drown in a foot of water, or a thousand metres, you're still dead. Stop saying good game, well played, they did well. They didn't they were comprehensively beaten
Well done, Bokke! Greetings from Buenos Aires
Damian de allende is criminally underrated
He is a beast.
@@Sunshinez732 respect your honesty
@@Sunshinez732 I heard a stat that, at the last World Cup, De Allende made more meters _after contact_ than some other backs did in the entire tournament!
DUHAN IS A FANTASTIC PLAYER, FAST, STRONF GREAT HANDS.
He’s actually rated pretty accurately He’s well selected…that’s why he’s a springbok
Mapimpi, Am and De Allende deadly triple threat
Not anymore it seems 😢
Can I just take my hat off to Gardner, he refereed so well.
Is this a Christmas joke!
What a joke! Ref should be embarrassed.
True I wish he should
Vergonzoso
Почему в России не так востребованно регби, как футбол? Это же реально зрелищнее вид спорта.
No it's harsh game
Play cricket in Russia.It's spectacular to play.
@@mohammedabdulrahaman4528 cricket is one of the least spectacular sports in the world
Rugby is the king of sports. Try playing it. It will make you feel like a man
@@Britishbandogge I’ve played it for 7 years lmao. I’m a MMA fighter tho, I prefer it because there is no team. If something goes wrong it’s my fault and I have no one to blame
@@robbiejohnston3174 good man!!!
Kobus is actually fast asf he almost caught hogg for that second Scotland try
His dad was 400m champ in South Africa . And an ex-bok.
Kolisi was so lucky with the pass leading to the first try. He gave it so early that the defender almost got to Mapimpi.
Wouldn't call it lucky, it was calculated he kept both players guessing in that split second ,to open up space for Mapimpi..
Ok
What worries me is that the gap was compliments of penalty kicks......if Manie has an off game , we are in trouble
- you were right...
Go SA and go SH ! love from Argentina to our big brothers !
As a NZ member of the world wide tight five, that game finisher by Eben Etzebeth is probably my favourite I’ve ever seen 😂
References to three other sports in this commentary: football, boxing, and then tennis. He must’ve planned it, surely 😂
When they mention cricket during a game then you know it’s bad.
i say try reinach at right wing sounds very random but his speed can be good (used) for our team
How was that first Scottish try not called forward ?
Your right, and on two South African tries
@@Sunshinez732 yeah cause we gifted u penalties for fun
@@Goubo2000 'gifted' nah you guys got physically dominated that's why we got pens.
3:35 obstruction on Am just before the try. Should’ve been a penalty anyway, useless TMOs.
@@Sunshinez732 how many teams in SA only 2 in Scotland get real plus a population of 5m
6:03 The one touch judge raises his flag and the other one keeps his down 😂
Deliveroo - Always on time, except for when painting their own promo.
I like the Etzebeth accolades in the end.
The first penalty should go to the Boks. Mapimpi over the ball then taken out from the side, and the SA 14 tried to get out the way. after a brilliant tackle.
14:34 there was about a 60% chance Eben would mess up this kick
And whys that?
Mapimpi 💥
Clean sweep for the South. Bring on next weekend!
No it's not
Great to see the Scots with some free running rugby. Definitely a team to watch in RWC.
I came back for this comment 😂😂😂😂
Why is de Allende never allowed to show all his phenomenal skills? Cos he has the strongest leg drive in the game ?
@(09:17) "hey boys relax, hey hey, it's okay...are you alright?"
Best on pitch chat I’ve ever heard 😂
@@jonnydaly5011 because its all Scotland will ever have , is a bit of on field chat 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣, because being halfway decent at rugby .... naa
SA first try was at least a foot forward of the receiver why the ref did not go to the TMO?
He did go to tmo they ruled not gorward his hands were in a backwards motion plus the pass was totally fine only looks forward because Kolisi stopped runiing after the pass was made
Maybe drink less ales while watching...
The scattergun approach...
Scotland's not going to dominate the set-piece this Sunday, so I suppose it's; get the ball to Duhan
Eben is not the ONLY player who smashes people around.
When the Scottish commentator started talking about how Frans Steyn was a baby faced prettyboy back in 2006/7 and was now a ruggard bearded ugly Boer I spat my 0% Alcohol beer out 😂😂🤣🤣... Steyn looked like a model back then... Wtf happened.
They edited it out of this package
Agreed. Steyn was a good-looking boy once upon a time.
The reason is because he is back. At this level, at that age, a forward looks like Quasimodo. I'm prop, I know what I'm talk
Name of the song at 11:39 please 😅👌
Thank you 👍😇
Did you find it?
13:03 the respect for this ballie hahaha
Champions 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉❤❤❤❤mzansi
South Africa dominant #1World Rugby 🏉
Angus gardener best ref so far
7:38 watch Duane here - haha he's just the elder with experience organising the team on the field.
Commentary simply brilliant
10:10 only penalty for a high tackle. That should have been a yellow one, and with some referee pretty sure a red one.
Only in sevens and he was right there.
❤well done South Africa
See you guys on Sunday
Scotland first try was pass forward !
SA with pollard is a different animal . Their coach needs to figure out that he has to use those top notch backs more .
Pot meet kettle, the two passes before Mpimpis try were both forward
South Africa without a doubt are the most complete team in the world. If only england can get their shit together...
bien igual por Escocia, el único de los britanicos que juega sólo con jugadores nativos igual que los pumas
Respect por Escocia, nativos solo
They have the most foreign born players out of the 6 nations…
They have 3 RSA, Nel, Schoeman, DVM
Wow, for 15mins of rugby the amount of ads are just next level.
Ad blocker or ad blocker plus. You can thank me later.
Get youtube premium 🤣
Mate stev wonder can see that netball pass 100%
no 11 try
Scottish scrum gets demolished
Commentators: "It's happened again, they being pushed back. But they've played very well for Leicester and had a stellar season."
Clearly this isn't Leicester. They getting shown the true definition of scrummaging. Not the willy wally scrumming in English Premiership. Boks showing why they have one of the best forward packs in the world
This was only a year ago and I reckon at most only half this Scotland team will feature against SA in the World Cup. There's three in this side who will never play for Scotland again (McInally, Hogg, McLean.) Literally only one of the backline is likely to start (VDM.)
The refs was hammering us in this game
Plusieurs passes en avant qui ne sont plus sifflé . Est-ce une évolution du rugby ?
How was that not a forward pass?
(9:19) its okay 🤣
70 minute books penalty is a very poor call- that player helped make the tackle
So the Springboks are suppose to fear this Scotland teams at the RWC 😂
I never realised how big headed a lot of SA fans are, would love to see any other team win the cup apart from them.
@@-Jay-001 when you’re the world champions it’s hard to be humble my friend
Pity, if you had more of a humble fan base then the rest of the world might care about the teams achievements.
@@-Jay-001 Respect thy champions 😂
@@ayandamoeketsi1325 Ireland currently number 1 in the rankings 🍀😏
Scottish captain was talking as if they have ever won the world cup lmao🤣🤣😂
Don’t start with this shit about Hogg again yes he was wrong end of the story
Madness.
@@kerrvalenti2874 It's funny because Hogg said they controlled the game hahaha.
It’s typical Scotland, they win one game and they are talking themselves up. Hogg does it especially, it’s funny. They act up as well trying to win frees.
And that's whats wrong with Scotland rugby, they were well beaten and reckon they played well.
Scotland has great commentators! Non bias just like rugby. Australia is the opposite of that.
Most comment threads for rugby matches are so chill, congratulatory and friendly, but then you have a game with SA/Scotland and everyone is bitching?
I think Rassie is part of the problem here.
Yeah, I love the guy but he really brought out a terrible attitude in us Springbok fans. I hope we can get over it soon because it's frankly embarassing the way we bitch about every single decision that goes against us and in this match's case even decisions that don't go against us.
Get a life, you were so lucky with so many calls!
Mate saffers would complain at a funeral, they win 30 to 15 got away with a couple of decisions and they're moaning . I'm a kiwi and since neutral referees came in we beat them 3 out of 4 tests, home and away. But they honestly believe they won most of those tests. No One ever beats them, you just score more points than them
I thought the ref favoured the boks. The Scottish were actually the better team although they made a few midtskes but the ref loved pinging them just when they were getting on top. Scotland could have won that game. The Boks are definitely beatable.
wtf, francois steyn is still playing?? He still got it !!
Best in the world
Murrayfield?
That first penalty against Jesse Kriel? I mean, what is he supposed to do? He tackles van der Merwe and immediately gets away from the ruck, but is pinged for not rolling away? Trigger happy refereeing
Good to see refs wise to the boks spoiling tactics at the breakdown
When did Adrian Peterson start playing rugby for South Africa
This refs idea of rolling away is crooked
Job was done kicking sorted so all good😅
extended highlights but yet you left out the bok try....
Ironic that 2 years later, scotland lost again with 15 points
Ref let a forward try go to the Scotts and blowing his whistle fast
2:48 lmao stop with excuses
I saw that it was obvious that it was a foward pass but because it was two maybe three passes before the ball hit the South African player, I think they just let it slide but I agree it was forward for sure. And im not a Springbok fan im an Aussie.
Chesnay ❤
🎉
I like how the Scots can score off a forward pass, but every single phase of a Springbok try gets scrutinized even AFTER the conversion was kicked.
Forward passes are missed all the time.
Pause at 2:48 stop with the excuses man look at that pass thats clearly forward too 🤣
I know that springboks can't except that they can concede tries and always blame the referee, but cmon guy your acting as though the ref has been paid off XD
Winter Marie Haines Rad FORD Gamma Well TODAY
😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Winter MARIE HAINES RAD FORD 21 44 ILOVE YOU RIG ON BOX MARY ILOVE ❤ YES
😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
WATER TONIGHT BABY and PREGNANT LAST NIGHT NETS
I feel like some deliveroo all sudden.
Somebody please teach Mapimpi how to dive over the scoring line, this is embarrassing 😂
(9:56)
Ref says 5:40, "I will explain..."; highlights cut🤦🏽♂️
Who are these amateurs editing highlights!
Don't watch the ball watch the hands for forward passes
ALLENSE'S PASS FOR THEIR FIRST TRY WAS FORWARD.
So was scotland's
They say South Africans must back up the Buks … boy I have no idea what is going on here 😅😅😅
両者の健闘を讃えさせて戴きます❤️🌹👍🏻🐣🐥🐤🐔🤔😲😊🤗🕊️💌🌟🌠☄️🍀
Go Bokke!!!
12:45 Malcolm Marx, 3 Scot players can't get him off the ball. Its not only Marx, the Boks are undoubtedly master's at the breakdown. They will molest you all day long at the breakdown.
Pity he cant make the starting 15
Team strategy, seems to have worked fine at the 2019 world cup, and may yet get us another world cup this year.
Bollocks 💯 🏴
Both tries drifting forward a little too much
Great game. Scotland have to stop being "Plucky losers" who give the big teams a fright, and then fold.
At 4 m and 30 seconds Scotland should have received a yellow card for a shoulder charge on Makazoli Mapimpi. Where was the referee, linesman and the two. Oh wait that only applies when Springboks are at fault. Watch out for karma if you play with bias😂
i'll take this ref over wanye barnes anyday
South,Africa are peaking
next year they will get knocked off their perch by the All Blacks who are getting better every game
first try south afirca number 8 obsturctsion clearly
Explain
ERUPWAN RUGBY DESAPERS.... SOUTH RULES
Up the South.
GG EZ
Very Scotland favoured highlights here!
The only highlight from scotland was from their best player .... duhan .... oh wait .... hes a saffa .
The Northern commentators are not as good as the NZ commentators who get so much more excited by the game.
What did the Bokke do wrong when the Referee gave that penalty to Scotland ? The scots were diving over the pack - not standing on their feet.The referee gave that penalty as soon as the ball hit the ground. The rules about this game is becomimg weirder and weider. No wonder Sonny Boy Williams 'refer' to the game as becoming complicated. Stop messing around with rules of the game. All those northern hemp' teams want to change the rules of the game so that they dont look so bad . Stephen Jones, Matt Williams, Keith wood & Willie John McBride. The 1972 B Lions in South Africa had depth in their teams and beat the Springboks 3.5 to .5. Guess who was the captainof the B Lions ? Willie John McBride. Now he question the depht of the Springboks ?
Shame the referee had to help them get points.
SA first try as clear a forward pass as you'll ever see
Both sides got away with one so it's equal.
You are watching the ball, watch the hands
Scotch is a drink!!!!!!!!