नहीं लगेगा,,, highcourt द्वारा Ispai पहल हो tabhi सम्भव हो सेंट्रल भी यहि चाहता है,,,, Article 355 lag jaye wo bhi bahut hoga sara police kanun central k pas chala jayega,,, ye dekhne mil sakta hai
Kanoon vyavastha west bengal me to bahut samay se kharab hai aur dino din kharb ho hoti ja rahi hai pata aur kitni samvidhanik vyavastha kharab hone dene ka intjaar hai vaha koi surakshit nahi hai president kab tak nirnay le paate hai .
Rebuttal Against the Imposition of President’s Rule in West Bengal The recent clamour for the imposition of President’s Rule in West Bengal by certain political factions, particularly the BJP and CPI(M), appears less a genuine concern for constitutional integrity and more a desperate attempt to seize power where they have repeatedly failed to win the people’s mandate. Such demands, in light of isolated incidents like the tragic events at R.G. Kar Hospital, betray a fundamental misunderstanding-or deliberate misrepresentation-of the Constitution and the principles that safeguard our democracy. Firstly, it must be emphasised that the imposition of President’s Rule is a grave and extraordinary measure, governed by Article 356 of the Indian Constitution. It is not a tool to be wielded at the whims of opposition parties who cannot accept their electoral defeats. The Supreme Court of India has consistently upheld that President’s Rule can only be justified in cases where there is a clear and demonstrable breakdown of constitutional machinery-not on the basis of isolated incidents, however unfortunate they may be. The tragic incident at R.G. Kar Hospital, while deeply concerning, does not constitute a breakdown of governance across the entire state. It is a law-and-order issue that must be addressed with seriousness and urgency, but it does not justify the suspension of an elected government. The BJP and CPI(M)’s persistent cries for President’s Rule, despite their failure to win the confidence of West Bengal’s electorate, reveal their political desperation rather than any genuine concern for the rule of law. Their inability to connect with voters and secure electoral victories should prompt them to introspect and rebuild, rather than seek unconstitutional shortcuts to power. Moreover, the Supreme Court, as an independent and impartial guardian of the Constitution, is not swayed by political noise or rhetoric. The judiciary operates on the basis of constitutional principles, legal precedents, and the evidence before it. The landmark S.R. Bommai judgement, which established strict guidelines for the imposition of President’s Rule, is a testament to the judiciary’s commitment to preventing the misuse of Article 356. Any attempt to impose President’s Rule in West Bengal on flimsy grounds would likely be met with rigorous judicial scrutiny, and rightly so. It is also important to recognise the historical context in which these guidelines were shaped. Leaders like Jyoti Basu, who fiercely defended the autonomy of state governments and the principles of federalism, were instrumental in shaping the discourse that led to the S.R. Bommai judgement. Basu, who served as West Bengal’s Chief Minister for over two decades, understood the dangers of central overreach and the importance of respecting the democratic mandate of the people. In conclusion, the calls for President’s Rule in West Bengal are not only constitutionally unfounded but also politically motivated. They reflect the frustration of parties that have failed to earn the trust of the people through democratic means. The Constitution and the judiciary provide robust safeguards against such overreach, ensuring that the will of the people, as expressed through their elected representatives, remains paramount. Instead of resorting to undemocratic tactics, these parties should focus on earning the trust of the electorate through constructive engagement and credible leadership.
Pashim bangal me 356 aur 365 dono hi fit karta hai lekin rastrpati shasan nahi lag para hai. Shyad lagegi bhi nahi. Iske parinam ko sare desh ko bhugatna parega.
Non supportive centre ki government humesha isi mauke ki talash me rehti hae. Par agar state government machinery khud me strong ho to centre ki aesi koi mansha kabhi poori nahi hogi. State level par strong hold rakhne wali sarkar state government ke against mahaul banane walon ko strictly deal kare yahi us state ke interest me hae. Aap yadi apne rajya ke sage nahi hue to apne desh ke kabhi bhi nahi honge.
Series of events on women and specially Hindus Rohingya issues Hindus migration in some areas started as state is supporting Rohingyas and Anti social elements
This is been discussed since last 3 years ...but do you think modi government will get the support in rajya saba and bidhan sava. What will be the impact. Whatever maybe we need tmc to resolve asap..
Aakhir bengal ko destabilise kiyon karna chahti hain centre government Kolkata ki ghatna bahut buri hai doshi ko maut kai alawa koi aur saza nahi milegi cbi apna kam kar rahi hai jo bhi is karguzari main shamil hoga usko maximum punishment milega uttarakhand main bhi isi tarah ki ghatna huyi hai madhya Pradesh main bhi isi tarah ki ghatna huyi hai wahan president rule kiyon nahi lagaya ja skta bengal aur Bengali shaktishali state hai aur centre ne koi ghadbad ki to centre government ko hi nipta dega aakhir uttar bharat ka bharat kai liye contribution kya hai koi aik kam hai accha Bengalis noble jeet jate hain uttar bhartiye dange fasad karne kai liye buldozer ka istemal karte hain gunde ko palte poste hain police custody main bhi logon ko golimaar di jati courtroom main hatya ho jati hai uttar Pradesh main to uttar pradesh kai gundaraaj ko dekhte huye wahan president rule lagna bahut zaroori hai uttar bharat sirf pm de skta hai jo lootmaar kare na noble vijeta de skta hai aur na hi acche engineers aur scientist de skta hai bengal kai sath centre ko chhedkhani nahi karni chahiye Kanoon apna kam karega maharashtara main masjid par hamla ho jata hai koi shaitan apna moh nahi kholta aisi hukumat jo masjid mandir ki raksha na kar ske wahan president rule lagna chahiye
Mahila president and state me mahila CM phir bhi mahila Dr ki cruelty se hatya, but sorry to say strong action ke jagah rajniti shame shame..... Political netao koa kursi pyari.....
@@sudeep1392 बलात्कार करने वाले तो हिंदू है फिर तुम ममताबानो क्यों बोल रहे हो । एक आरोपी को गिरफ्तार भी कर लिया गया है और बाकी को भी गिरफ्तार किया जा रहा है ।
Cob hogi bangal ka admi ko bohuti porisani say gujara kor raha hai jab bhidhan saba election may rastropoti sasan jari hona chahiya taki santi may vote ho sayky
Only only presdent rule can save bengal otherwise bengal will be ruined by mamata her mission & vission to make bengal an islamic state Mr. Governor pl Initiate artical 356 without delay
अभी बहुत समय है जब २-४ हिंदू रह जाएँगे तब लगाना।
😢😢😢❤❤
Yes sir 🙏 president rule lagna jaruri h kyu ki vaha ke CM ka rule thik ni h
ᶜᵐ ᵏᵃ ᵈⁱᵐᵃᵍ ᵗʰⁱᵏ ⁿᵃʰⁱ ʰᵃⁱ
तुरन्त राष्ट्रपति शासन लगाया जाय
बिहार में भी लगना चाहिए और मणिपुर के सीएम को जेल में डालना चाहिए और दुबारा चुनाव कराना चाहिए
इस से पहले मणिपुर,असम व बिहार में लगना चाहिए।
If this is done in bengal,it will also be surely done in Manipur and it should be@@naveen8947
Yes right president rule should be implemented
Lagana hi chahiye...vo bhi jaldi
Must be needed president rule...
Impose president rule in Bengal immediately. But I have doubt over NDA central Gov't.
Its need to implement president rule in west bengal
Laga dena chaiya president emergency
We want justice
As soon as possible President rule should should be Imposed in west bengal. when the Honble President of India will look into the matter ??????
बहुत बहुत जरूरी है प.ब. में राष्ट्रपति शासन की ।
Very nice knowledge
I am from west bengal, we need president rules
नहीं लगेगा,,, highcourt द्वारा Ispai पहल हो tabhi सम्भव हो सेंट्रल भी यहि चाहता है,,,,
Article 355 lag jaye wo bhi bahut hoga sara police kanun central k pas chala jayega,,, ye dekhne mil sakta hai
Thank you so much sir and sanskriti team ❤️✨
अगर पश्चिम बंगाल मे राष्ट्रपति शासन लगता है तो बिहार में भी लगना चाहिऐ दोनों जगह की घटना निन्दनीय हैं
उत्तराखंड में भी एक नर्स के साथ बलात्कार हुआ है लेकिन कोई उसे पर बात ही नहीं कर रहा ।
Series of events on women and hindus
Yes you are right,if it is success in Bengal,then by this example lots of state like bihar will get freedom
We needs president rules save for bengal Peoples
Yes
Yes
President rule in bangla needed
to maintain law and order
until a new c.m is elected
with mamta's resignation
We Want Justice
I want president's rule in West Bengal.
Bengal mein president's rule hona joruri hein.
Our beloved PM having no positive attitude for WEST BENGAL .
Some statements to be collected from the labour who demolish the seminar room wall, they can describe the actual situation the wall before demolish.
Yes 💯 Right Sir
We need this rule
Immediately impose president rule in bengal
ऐसी स्थिति बहुत बार आइ कुछ नहीं हुआ आगे भी कुछ होने वाला नहीं है
But still we should try
All right
Central administration is thinking so much time to decide whether President Rule can be imposed
Kanoon vyavastha west bengal me to bahut samay se kharab hai aur dino din kharb ho hoti ja rahi hai pata aur kitni samvidhanik vyavastha kharab hone dene ka intjaar hai vaha koi surakshit nahi hai president kab tak nirnay le paate hai .
Rebuttal Against the Imposition of President’s Rule in West Bengal
The recent clamour for the imposition of President’s Rule in West Bengal by certain political factions, particularly the BJP and CPI(M), appears less a genuine concern for constitutional integrity and more a desperate attempt to seize power where they have repeatedly failed to win the people’s mandate. Such demands, in light of isolated incidents like the tragic events at R.G. Kar Hospital, betray a fundamental misunderstanding-or deliberate misrepresentation-of the Constitution and the principles that safeguard our democracy.
Firstly, it must be emphasised that the imposition of President’s Rule is a grave and extraordinary measure, governed by Article 356 of the Indian Constitution. It is not a tool to be wielded at the whims of opposition parties who cannot accept their electoral defeats. The Supreme Court of India has consistently upheld that President’s Rule can only be justified in cases where there is a clear and demonstrable breakdown of constitutional machinery-not on the basis of isolated incidents, however unfortunate they may be. The tragic incident at R.G. Kar Hospital, while deeply concerning, does not constitute a breakdown of governance across the entire state. It is a law-and-order issue that must be addressed with seriousness and urgency, but it does not justify the suspension of an elected government.
The BJP and CPI(M)’s persistent cries for President’s Rule, despite their failure to win the confidence of West Bengal’s electorate, reveal their political desperation rather than any genuine concern for the rule of law. Their inability to connect with voters and secure electoral victories should prompt them to introspect and rebuild, rather than seek unconstitutional shortcuts to power.
Moreover, the Supreme Court, as an independent and impartial guardian of the Constitution, is not swayed by political noise or rhetoric. The judiciary operates on the basis of constitutional principles, legal precedents, and the evidence before it. The landmark S.R. Bommai judgement, which established strict guidelines for the imposition of President’s Rule, is a testament to the judiciary’s commitment to preventing the misuse of Article 356. Any attempt to impose President’s Rule in West Bengal on flimsy grounds would likely be met with rigorous judicial scrutiny, and rightly so.
It is also important to recognise the historical context in which these guidelines were shaped. Leaders like Jyoti Basu, who fiercely defended the autonomy of state governments and the principles of federalism, were instrumental in shaping the discourse that led to the S.R. Bommai judgement. Basu, who served as West Bengal’s Chief Minister for over two decades, understood the dangers of central overreach and the importance of respecting the democratic mandate of the people.
In conclusion, the calls for President’s Rule in West Bengal are not only constitutionally unfounded but also politically motivated. They reflect the frustration of parties that have failed to earn the trust of the people through democratic means. The Constitution and the judiciary provide robust safeguards against such overreach, ensuring that the will of the people, as expressed through their elected representatives, remains paramount. Instead of resorting to undemocratic tactics, these parties should focus on earning the trust of the electorate through constructive engagement and credible leadership.
We wants All justice + West Bengal ki 4 pass CM - Mamtaj Begum ko vi And P.K. Banerjee ko vi .kuki Asli kalprit tho aye hi hai 💯💯💯
Must implement president rule in bengal
To save nation
To save democracy
To save women
To save Hindu
To save law
Many more
Ji haan ye to bahot pehle laga dena chahiye
1:45 I
manipur mai lagna chahiye. Manipur ki halat bohut hi kharab hain
Aspa laga hua hai
@@Daily_short jhant laga hua hai har din rape aur murder pura manipur jal raha hai
President rules immediately
President rule please
It's too late to impose President Rule would have done long ago like agitation of sandeshkhali days
Uttrakhand and UP me quo nahi president rule impose hua west bengal me opposition ki sarkaar hai so president rule lagega
Hypocrisy kahte h esko
Bhai ap ko govt ki padi h ye ni dikh rha h vaha pr kya ho rha h vaha ki CM wrong h samjhe
Kyu ki Mamta Banarjee ka hi sarkar Mahila pe rape karwati hsi aur saboot hatati hai… aur Bangladesh se illegal immigration’s bhi West Bengal se hai
UP has improved in administration.
Gundas have fear and honest and common citizens are happy.i m from UP
I know better
Pashim bangal me 356 aur 365 dono hi fit karta hai lekin rastrpati shasan nahi lag para hai. Shyad lagegi bhi nahi. Iske parinam ko sare desh ko bhugatna parega.
West bengal ko sidha kendra shashit pradesh ghosit Kar Dena chahiye
For once bring back Smt. Indira Gandhi - she would not only have closed the Gate of the Secretariat but opened the gate of Presidency Jail.
Not for nothing a foreign country commented 'Only she wears a pant in her Cabinet'
President rule 🙏
President rule 🙏🏻
Non supportive centre ki government humesha isi mauke ki talash me rehti hae. Par agar state government machinery khud me strong ho to centre ki aesi koi mansha kabhi poori nahi hogi.
State level par strong hold rakhne wali sarkar state government ke against mahaul banane walon ko strictly deal kare yahi us state ke interest me hae. Aap yadi apne rajya ke sage nahi hue to apne desh ke kabhi bhi nahi honge.
Series of events on women and specially Hindus
Rohingya issues
Hindus migration in some areas started as state is supporting Rohingyas and Anti social elements
This is been discussed since last 3 years ...but do you think modi government will get the support in rajya saba and bidhan sava. What will be the impact. Whatever maybe we need tmc to resolve asap..
ऐसा बहुत राज्यों में हो चुका है।यूपी सबसे आगे है।
दलित है न तू 😂😂😂
NO
Mamta kannada
Ha lagana chaiye
We want justice from West bengal
Rastrapati sasan lagana chaihe
Rashtrpati ek mahila or ek mahila dard samajhna chahiye
Ye hi mouka hai
❤❤
Aakhir bengal ko destabilise kiyon karna chahti hain centre government Kolkata ki ghatna bahut buri hai doshi ko maut kai alawa koi aur saza nahi milegi cbi apna kam kar rahi hai jo bhi is karguzari main shamil hoga usko maximum punishment milega uttarakhand main bhi isi tarah ki ghatna huyi hai madhya Pradesh main bhi isi tarah ki ghatna huyi hai wahan president rule kiyon nahi lagaya ja skta bengal aur Bengali shaktishali state hai aur centre ne koi ghadbad ki to centre government ko hi nipta dega aakhir uttar bharat ka bharat kai liye contribution kya hai koi aik kam hai accha Bengalis noble jeet jate hain uttar bhartiye dange fasad karne kai liye buldozer ka istemal karte hain gunde ko palte poste hain police custody main bhi logon ko golimaar di jati courtroom main hatya ho jati hai uttar Pradesh main to uttar pradesh kai gundaraaj ko dekhte huye wahan president rule lagna bahut zaroori hai uttar bharat sirf pm de skta hai jo lootmaar kare na noble vijeta de skta hai aur na hi acche engineers aur scientist de skta hai bengal kai sath centre ko chhedkhani nahi karni chahiye Kanoon apna kam karega maharashtara main masjid par hamla ho jata hai koi shaitan apna moh nahi kholta aisi hukumat jo masjid mandir ki raksha na kar ske wahan president rule lagna chahiye
Itna bhayanak apradh bangal me hua hai ki pura desh sharmasar ho gaya hai. Agar ab kendra sarkar koi kathor nirnay nahi leti to is baar BJP haregi.
Mahila president and state me mahila CM phir bhi mahila Dr ki cruelty se hatya, but sorry to say strong action ke jagah rajniti shame shame..... Political netao koa kursi pyari.....
जैसा हिन राष्टपति होनचही ये
Modiji rastpati sasan lagado public ab action chahti hai verna 2029 me bjp kahi nahi aayegi
ঠুটো জগন্নাথ । সাথে আছে দিল্লীর ও দুই ঠুটো জগন্নাথ
India me total politician parti croftion me dubahua.. Eha kanun besarom..
उत्तराखंड में एक नर्स के साथ बलात्कार हुआ है क्या उत्तराखंड में भी राष्ट्रपति शासन लगना चाहिए
Bilkul lagna chahiye I supported
Haan wahaan sarkar aaropi ko bacha nahi raha jaise mamta bano bacha rahi hain..
@@sudeep1392 बलात्कार करने वाले तो हिंदू है फिर तुम ममताबानो क्यों बोल रहे हो ।
एक आरोपी को गिरफ्तार भी कर लिया गया है और बाकी को भी गिरफ्तार किया जा रहा है ।
@@S.kVain625 maximum balatkari toh ek hi community kr hain.. Uttrakhand sarkar kisi ko baksha nhi mamta bano karti hain..
2x me dekh rha hai 😅
BJP to chunav nahi jeet sakti kintu by governor rule kar Sakti hai
Pehalyailgenchaijo❤
Cob hogi bangal ka admi ko bohuti porisani say gujara kor raha hai jab bhidhan saba election may rastropoti sasan jari hona chahiya
taki santi may vote ho sayky
Ha lagan a chia RASTPATI❤ Satsang
Thanks for sacking Mamta n goons
Rashtrapati shasan bahut jaruri hai na dar khatm ho gaya hai
গুজবে কান দেবেন না।
Up me bhi lagna chahi sir archan ka maha ghotala huwa hai
dalle marwane nikal gaye
Nhi. Lagega bjp tmc same same
Ut chiye
😢
Modi himmat nahi to take step
Toh itna wait kyu kar rahe ho, fatafat laga do
Governor of West Bengal repest..... Why delay for presedent rule to presedent of india
To kar na 😂😂😂😂😂 kisi maai ke laal mein dam nahi h jo rok sake😂😂😂😂😂to laga do na
Manonia tadonto + test tomra 2 jon onek kaj korecho kintu tomra 2 jone e fail akhon chutti
Lagana chahiye jaldi
Modiji Mamta se darte he rastpati sasan nehi lagapaeygi esehi chalta rahega modiji dekhte rehejaeynge
Usepoce. Jodoroka. Sason. Batme
BJP to yahi chahti hai
NDA Chanel nalla and dalla alince
मणिपुर के राजपाल को अभी दिखाई नहीं दिया ये राज्यपाल सरकार के पालतू होते हैं😂
Yes rastopatai sashon laghu karna joruri hai,
Only only presdent rule can save bengal otherwise bengal will be ruined by mamata her mission & vission to make bengal an islamic state Mr. Governor pl
Initiate artical 356 without delay
Age Implement korte hobe fir batt koro