Asia's Sinking Cities: Jakarta | Insight | Indonesia
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 23 сен 2024
- Will the decision to relocate the country's capital city from Jakarta to East Kalimantan help safeguard the city from being engulfed by the sea?
For more great INSIGHT into the top issues affecting Asia: • Insight | Full Episodes
==========================
ABOUT THE SHOW: Insight investigates and analyses topical issues that impact Asia and the rest of the world.
==========================
#CNAInsider #CNAInsiderInvestigates #Insight #SinkingCities
For more, SUBSCRIBE to CNA INSIDER!
/ cnainsider
Follow CNA INSIDER on:
Instagram: / cnainsider
Facebook: / cnainsider
Website: cna.asia/cnain...
Indonesia tv needs to expand its awareness of cleanliness.Don't just focus on entertainment programs only coz they need to be educated how to maintain the environment around them.
Thats why I never watch TV anymore, its full bias news and share looking programs
Ye, the news almost rarely talk about it
Lunya aja yang kebanyakan nonton sinetron jadi ga tau berita di tv lol
@@pemula4075 Justru berita mah jarang bgt ngebahasin kebersihan, kalo berita lebih fokus kepada kebersihan pasti bakal banyak yang tahu akibatnya.
Kalo sekarang mah palingan cuman ngebahasnya pas pengen dan sesudah banjir doang.
@@rebuskecebong for the sinking problem of Jakarta. It's only in the part of North Jakarta by the beach .. 👍
from my perspective, this few ideas may be work as solution for Jakarta issue
1. Education about cleanliness etiquette and environment responsible (pre-school, regular town hall, aggressive municipal campaign)
2. Reduce migration : partnership with privatisation for entrepreneurs and self-sufficiency economy initiative for rural population - vocational class, apprentice program and agropreneur courses.
3. Reduce traffics congestion : improve bus connection between railway station to population area (bus real time schedule, less waiting time, affordable, special lane)
Consider those 3 as Phase 1. If it can be success, then Phase 2 of land rezoning, population relocation and flood mitigation plan will be more easier.
Great idea, but won't happened, local government has a very corrupt mind
@@MichaelRiswandi decentralised and reduce bureaucracy, less corruption happen.
@@crafael. Wrong, more corruption happened, Local Ruller usually not accountable at all. Jakarta wasn't managed by the central government, instead, it was managed by its own governor. Indonesia has already separating the local and central governments since the reformation era in early 2000. More like the USA with its states.
Easier said than done, to be honest.
You try to rule people of Jakarta, get ready for the city riot.. Wkwk
Stop water extraction, and bulid water filtration systems.
With what money?
Use lifestraw It's quite effective
@SmaCk You d1cK
We filter water from the sea, not your urin -_-
@@RUHappyATM idk. Maybe the royal family and or your local politicians are probably hiding their money somewhere outside the country.
@@mr.rhidon8883 can ask Singapore nicely to help. Highly unlikely for indo to develop this technology in a 100 years lol
Moving Indonesia' capital wont solve its problems. The way to solve those problems are to educate the people and using smart n safe energy resources.
Moving the capital will only raise up new problems : low educated people will 'death', corruption, benefits for those behind government and investors, new poluted area which could be as same with Jakarta, and so on
Excellent. That is the point.
Hope their goverment will have a better city planning for the new capital and invest into recyling center and water filter instead of skycrapers
You're right
Archipelagos in the Pacific like Indonesia, Philippines and Papua NG should be the most prepared in this kind of issue. There’s no other option. It is now a phenomenon that can’t be prevented.
Maldives & Venice will be gone in the next 50 years.
Almost decades passed by, MATIRA MATIBAY NALANG. Lagi naman phenomenon eh. Ring Of Fire nga na located.
@Oppo 2018 Thanks for the correction 😊Sorry, I was actually thinking of the Malay and Melanesia archipelagos where it belongs but yeah NG itself is not an archiphelago 😅
This problem is not confirmed to Southeast Asia. Coastal cities around the world are being affected by rising ocean levels. Because Artic and polar regions of Earth are getting warmer melting polar ice caps.
Im a Pacific islander & one thing i have not seen on those islands is Coconut trees 🌴
From where i come from every time after a storm when a sand bar arises above the ocean we immediately plant coconut trees on them so the coconut can hold the sand together & eventually an island is born.
fun fact th old name of Jakarta is Sunda Kelapa, kelapa means coconut
They not a pacific island🤷🏽♂️
Dari semua dokumenter dng tajuk serupa ini mungkin the best. Risetnya dalem, bahasanya luas, shotnya aja yg beberapa banyak diulang2 🤭
Tapi gw nunggu yg di bahas isu di amerika dan eropa juga. Jangan cuma di asia🤪🤪🤪
@@jojopratama285 gk akan ada bro di CNA Insider ini, karna mereka khusus bahas isu di Singapura dan Asia.
Jakarta People : Jakarta SInking
Governor : No Problem. Water is from God. Just Pray
Tell me it’s just a joke
@ISISraHELL bro then why you people don’t protest against protecting your land
Kirimkan linknya, jika apa yg lu bilang benar, mana link beritanya atau at least videonya. Jangan jadi pasukan babi bipang yg gak punya otak kalau share info. Prove it with the credible link that you are not a liar...
@@ruizsyajudha5994 goblok. google aja kadrun perusak bangsa . anjing
@ISISraHELL white people should stick to our Bali island instead of our capital which is full of selfishness. Bali people love all people here who pick up trash.
When I was religious, I attributed everything to biblical prophecy, while acknowledging the role of human agency, so now I wonder, listening to the Islamic lady tell her experience - if she also frames things in terms of her religious beliefs. Does she think this is god's will or simply the byproduct of human activity?
Somehow the water pollution has been successfully and blatantly ignored in the documentary
They've already covered that in another episode.
Different topic.
@@BayuAkbarK probably CNA can reuse the footages with different narrations, right?
@@jrukawa11 that'll be more relevant if CNA reporting about "Jakarta Giant Sea Wall's ESTUARY". Water quality and geology are two different issues.
Yeah, I noticed how much garbage was strolled along coastal areas after water receded.
deep well is the culprit not the buildings. Everyone knows that when there is ground water extraction the land will sink.
Their city is lack of trees...
Loads of comments ignore the subject. Really useful, chaps.
Isn't the Netherlands also below sea level, and the only thing preventing it from being engulfed by the sea are the sea walls? Maybe they can do the same thing in Jakarta.
Still the same old story-foreign countries should save Indonesia.
why not plant Mangroves?
It's built on swamp land, what do you expect?
Dutch the one who built it and make it a central ecenomic when they rules Nusantara for 300 years.... now Jokowi try his best to realocate the capital to Kalimantan because Java is too crowded (again because Dutch moves people for forced farming in Java)
Vincent Lius what good does blaming the Dutch do? They aren’t living in Indonesia now are they? The Indonesian government knew about this issue decades ago but didn’t do much and now Jokowi has to scramble to deal with it when it should have been gradually tackled.
New York was built on a swamp land..
@@madouzo1423 Yes and it sinking as well and will disappear into the ocean as well.
Yeah. Also upon observation, some capitals in the world are built on swamplands
Semoga kota kota Indonesia makin di perbaiki lagi semoga kota kota Indonesia makin maju dan berkembang.tertib buang sampah pada tempat nya untuk Indonesia. Semangat Indonesia 😊
The same problem in Metro Manila areas also. In, my opinion Indonesian government should be strict in construction of high rise building at low lying areas of Jakarta and other infrastructure to reduce the weight at underlying strata. Construct pumping stations around the city.
Apartments and high-rise buildings also cause the city to sink, but many Indonesians will probably deny this and blame only on the poor.
Soon they'll need submarines to get around town
@@PumpkinEater-dm1xx ha ha he he ho ho
@@PumpkinEater-dm1xx but we have it alot 'pempek kapal selam'
@toxic prince Pertama kali di internet?
Hehe😅
Relocating an entire capital? I have my doubts, since it would also mean relocating the government.
Moving the capital will not help. What Indonesians need to do is to educate themselves.
At least Indonesia have the choice to move to many ideal location, imagine those city state island around the region, in the event of any miscalculated mistakes, where can they move? on top of the sea?
Jakarta sinking
Indonesia media:jakarta vs KL
Indonesia people:jakarta win
Malaysia people:ok u win 🏆🏆🏆👏👏👏
Open your mind buddy, don't arrogant n rude.from Pluto
Jakarta win yo
@@hafizilmi7255 in your sweetdream 😂🤣😂🤣
@@МохамадФадзил Hmm, whatever😉🥱
Even you said we're going to sinking but most people from Singapore coming to Jakarta to sell their products here.
I lived here for more than 20 years and we can enjoy it.
are you singaporean?
@@sultanarya5538 ibukota baru titipan Singapore mas.. orang WNI jadi penonton.. Dan terpinggirkan.. para tokoh GK mementingkan rakyt..Padahal negara Kita NKRI bisa jadi boneka Ngr sblh haha
@@nz2580 Rakyatnya aja banyak Bodoh* ,Males Hobbynya Ngeluh ..gimana Mau Maju menikmati..Bukan Pemerintahnya aja yg salah Tapi rakyatnya pun juga salah Mindsetnya masih low
Hope All of our world gov and leaders will pull together to help solve global warming issues "O
Perhaps they needed dredging and expand land reclamation with depth higher than that of their existing land.
I'm Indonesian, but most of those guys deserve it, nothing can help it if they still throwing rubbish into the water, running the street with their own vehicle instead public transport cause traffic jam, alot of outsider moved to Jakarta to gamble their life; increase population density and too many huge tall building concentrated in 1 place.
Dont think like that bruh even tho they do that no one still deserve it theres innocent kids, fam etc there dont think bad of someones misfortune just peace and love
That was a bit ignorant its not the poeple fault for not being educated enough about all this stuff life was already hard enough for them
I've been reading a lot of comments saying the capital will be moved and some forest will be destroyed then... guess I will be watching only old rain forest documentaries now huhu
actually its a special area that are designated for it. so no crucial rainforest being destroyed
@@danieldniswara7972 phew~ what a relief
This is the fourth CNA Insider Sinking cities in Asia, I have watched. Everybody blaming nature and climate change, etc. but NO ONE mentioned anything how to curb the population explosion which happened to be the major issue here, if you'd ask me.
Beautiful. God 🙏 Indonesia. . Watching from Philippines
God bless Philippines and the entire South East Asia 🙏 ...
first of all, mentality,
please be clean huhu
You can't. Ask them to not litter the river.
90% of Jakarta's is uneducated or didn't finish junior high school.
Those 90% also has low income and prefer to spend the monthly Rp. 50.000,- somewhere else.
@@era7928 dapat data dari mana 90% orang jakarta tidak lulus sampai SMP?
@@era7928 50000 just Worth an half day my man. Stop lying
Singapore also had the cleanliness problem before
emang bisa orang indonesia bersih?
Watched this back2back with the Manila version, Manila and its neighboring areas are in far worse shape than Jakarta's 😭
Sinking too?
Yes. One advantage of Jakarta is not too far in the south, the elevation is much higher and protected from the sea.
Manila is not sinking, only a few part of the neighboring province of Bulacan. Don't know what's going on CNA's mind why they included it when they should only cover mainly on Manila itself.
how can "bertahan dermaga disitu" translated to "its sad"? 05:56
Lmao right
WOW that was a rly bad transcription
We're not Chinese, so, we're good with any translation.
"Bererot" gakdiartiin🤣🤣
@@angore_ its indonesian ?
24:06 the land stop sinking yet the sea level is getting higher.
Nope.. land still sinking cos Jakarta people still extracting their groundwater for usage.
It looks like in the Philippines situation nowadays, lack of sewage program, lack of underground tunnel just Japan had, and lack of infrastructure. But all I can say that we are reach in natural resources. At this point our government shall be doing a build! Build! Build program to sustain the cleanliness and peaceful movement in our country. Nevertheless, we are all educated that matter 😊😁👍
...
Cringe*
@@apinezstats2237 stfu then
Every city in philippines had trees and they have water system unlike jakarta whole city covered by buildings and deep well is still source of water...
You have no idea how Jakarta is compared to Manila.....
#MarcosDutertePaMore
Better to change capital earlier before it's too late.
Ed Methuselah That won’t change anything, it’s more of abandoning the city.
The new capital also flooded
@@mr.rhidon8883 I thought it's a forest city design which will mix construction of skyscrapers with the environment?
@@mr.rhidon8883 you can see the new design,which is forest and city
Forest City.
from my perspective, this would be a problem if the next president won't continue this big project or even just neglecting these 20 to 30 years of the project. in political sides, the 'hassle(s)' won't be small at all. let see if the project would start before 2030 then the whole place would be worth investing (for small and medium investor alike)
In popular culture, Jakarta was mentioned on the novel "Twilight of Jakarta" which in Filipino as "Takipsilim sa Jakarta" which is often on high school grade 8 students
But the wonderful title has afromentioned of today's city including sinking water levels, traffic, disasters and population caused to change to Nusantara which is become a reality in 2045
ITS planned for first world city underwater! And evolve human to fishman. And latter Jakarta will be called Aquakarta
shut up leave me alone
Welcome to our future city Aquakarta😁
Even Aquaman can't survive there due to pollution
😅
Atlantis (in Dufan) Will come true
Flood is annual season in Jakarta.
jakarta great wall is coming dont worry
Hows the progress of the giant sea wall? Is it going well?
Still on track
Awal tahun 2021 musim ujan tapi jakarta enggak banjir,mantap sekrang udah ada kemajuan.
Masakkk
@@krakarchannel1812 masak apa kak nasi goreng apa rendang
@@alkatiry5827 curah hujan ga kyak tahun2 sebelumnya bro, masa lo ga nyadar
I know why Jakarta is sinking. Its because many in the city uses deep well
Seharusnya pemerintah memberdayakan hutan manggrove untuk melingkari pulau.
Hal yg sederhana tapi g kepikiran kan?
Sekalian penghijauan
Pemerintah indo (secara general) jarang yg peduli isu lingkungan. Mentok2 setahun sekali acara tanam2 pohon itu doang
@@fadhly5192 wkwkwkwk. G taulah. Aq cari penanaman hutan magrove dan bakau saja di youtube emang jarang.
Anda tau g, kalo pantai utara jawa ada yg tergerus loh, kayak jakarta. Org2 disana rumahnya pada hilang jadi lautan. Sekarang mulai menanam bakau. Aneh jg ya knpa tdk jadi berita utama. Padahal kalau jakarta, semua nyinyir. Giliran yg lain g ada beritanya.
@@fadhly5192 padahal pake mangrove enaknya itu kan g perlu biaya perbaikan. Mangrove kan makhluk hidup, bisa memperbaiki sendiri
@@fadhly5192 salahnya jg pembangunan g diatur mas. Semua dibangun dan di beton.
Kayak desa saya. Ladang dan sawah jadi beton. Air g ada tempat resapan. Auto banjir lah.
Semua daerah masalahnya sama.
Kalau pemerintah g kasih peraturan dalam pembangunan misal hanya 60% wilayah yg boleh dibangun dan sisanya utk hutan/taman/tanah resapan, saya rasa lama2 jawa bakal hilang.
Karena air g masuk ke tanah tapi langsung ke sungai, sedangkan air tanah dikuras terus jg.
Ini cuma opini loh ya.
Anda bisa cek dan lihat lingkungan sekitar anda, pasti jarang ada pohon. Dan yang padat penduduk biasanya saluran pembuangannya kecil atau bahkan atasnya dibeton sama yg punya rumah. Sampah nyangkut g ada yg bisa bersihin jg.
Dgn semua masalah itu dan g ada ruang terbuka hijau. Setiap kota auto menuju banjir mas.
@@barasantoso1846 wkwk kana kita bukan europe .. pembangunan berkelanjutan itu nomor kesekian la kita untuk mesin hybrid aja baru dapat insentif nanti akhir tahun 2021, Inggris aja baru ngumumin insentif hybrid abis di 2035 kan telat bet pajak berdasarkan gas buang emisi ini udah 2020 padahal kan kelihatan kalau lingkungan itu isu kesekian
katanya jakarta mendunia?
Kemarin ada rencana Reklamasi teluk Jakarta + pengadaan pintu air apalah itu namanya. Terus proyeknya juga ditolak org jakarta. Hmmm, padahal bisa tuh dibuat macam sistem yang ada di Belanda
It is sinking, we got FLOOD 5 times already since beginning of the year *LOL*
I just hope they don't make the same mistake
Biarkan Jakarta tenggelam.... rakyat Jakarta kelak akan beradaptasi dengan kehidupan dua alam....under water dan darat.......jadi rakyat Jakarta adalah manusia terpilih untuk bisa hidup dibawah air dan daratan.......mereka akan berevolusi seperti di filem aquaman....jadi biarkanlah itu terjadi
Ampun bg jago
Pindahkan ibu negara di kalimantan..... Jadi kesesakkan dan korupsi bisa terpantau... Enggak tertumpu ekonomi disuatu negeri sahaja....
😱
It is in progress of moving the capital of Indonesia to Kalimantan (Borneo Island) to be specific it is relocated to Kutai Kartanegara and around as I know. CMIIW. Koreksi gw klo gw salah
the Goodbener of the city can only talk without action to support his policies, therefore the people named him "Gabener". His case provides a good example where if you are only able to present remarkable theories without any follow-up, what you get is a disaster.
Extraction of ground water made worse by inability of goverment water company to distribute the piping network
The contractors that built new high rises are held responsible for infrastructure needed to support them. The Government must make them take responsibility
Kumuh di Jakarta juga itu merata ya 😂
Tapi kalau video youtube yg lain suka nya bikin video perbandingan dengan negara tetangga.. Pas itu, kalo Jakarta ditunjukin tempat2 yang cantik doang, Kalo untuk negara tetangga, yang jelek2.. Padahal pinggir2 Kota di Jakarta mah lebih kumuh ketimbang pinggir2 kota di negara2 tetangga..
Selamat ya buat Indonesia
hahajaj
Daerah yg bersih lebih banyak.Kawasan bersih diindonesia jg lebih banyak dan luas drpada kawasan bersih negara tetangga .jakarta 3 x lebih luas drpada ibukota tetangga.setiap negara pasti ada pemungkiman seperti itu.
Maen ke amerika soul dan tokyo bro disana ada homles juga...
Buka matamu
semua negara pasti ada daerah bagus daerah kumuh. tapi ya pasti lah yang ditunjukkin yang bagusnya
Untuk jaksel kyknya ga terbilang kumuh deh,
My advise is for all unhealthy, problematic slums and shantytowns were to be demolished and the people be rehoused to Khrushchyovka-style flats or a 1960s British style council estate. With the consent of the people, of course.
Those people lives in shanty towns because new high rise buildings are far beyond their income levels. Bringing in higher paying jobs with living wage same better option.
@@paulfleming715 That's the problem. We need a revolution and the restoration of Socialism.
every country.. has something that always been through
Truee
These was seems to BULACAN the Province of Luzon, Philippines who had sinks other parts of Baranggay. But CNA Insider reports BULACAN then the title was MANILA SINKING. How ridiculous reports. FYI, CNA Bulacan is not part of Metro Manila it is a Province itself. How many decades pass by, many disasters come in Luzon but still Metro Manila are in solid.
ah ground water extraction will affect the who city of Jakarta wherever deep well is built within the city. To stop Jakarta from sinking further stop all deep well water extraction. When I mean all means all of it even deep wall use by the mayor, even wells use by all religious leader and even ground water wells use by water agencies and their family.
You already featured sinking Bangkok, Jakarta, Manila. How about sinking Singapore?
Singapore is sinking?
@@iskandarazman3223 Hahah Soon..If god get Angry at them, nothing impossible
30:00 This is the real problem that has never been solved by any presidents. We need to encourage more businesses to base themselves outside Java, not waste $33 billion making a new city in the middle of the jungle. It's also interesting to see that highly educated people won't migrate to Jakarta if they can earn money back home, as mentioned by the Gojek driver. Business should build regional offices around these less developed areas and hire these white-collar workers. Maybe use the $33 billion dollar as an incentive/subsidy for these business to expand to these smaller cities.
semua org bilang jakarta adalah kota yang kompleks, tapi sebenarnya manusia disanalah yang membuatnya seperti itu. seperti kata wolverine (cameo) pada xavier (muda) dalam movie X-men first class
What s the purpose making higher the house but u cant go outside
CNA Insider make a documentary about Singapore if it's sinking,I'm just curious you all make a documentary about sinking cities of your neighbors,
Sudah saatnya Jakarta harus berbenah habis2an. Pemukiman kumuh dirombak menjadi tertata, perbanyak RTH, naikan pajak kendaraan bermotor, revitalisasi sungai baik di hulu dan di hilir, perbaiki seluruh trotoar dan transportasi umum, pengelolaan sampah yang baik, pembangunan waduk dan sistem tata kelola air mencegah abrasi dan penurunan muka tanah. KALO SEMUA ITU GA DILAKUIN LO BAKAL LIAT 5-10 TAHUN LAGI JAKARTA JADI KOTA TERKUMUH DI ASIA
Kalo ketersediaan lapangan kerja di seluruh indonesia banyakmah gampang, masalahnya itu lapangan kerja di tempat lain tak seindah jakarta, kalo asal gusur hancurkan, berefek pada ekonomi nasional, pengangguran poverty bertambah, kriminalitas meningkat maybe, solusinya ya pemerintah dan masyarakat boosting ekonomi di setiap daerah di indonesia jadi ngga datang ke jakarta semua, makanya ente bangun perusahaan sendiri biar ngurangin unemployment dan poverty di indonesia, setelah itu invest uangnya di pendidikan,
anies ga tau apa2 n ga melakukan apa2. budget banjir cuman 100 m bos. budget ke ormas 2.8 t. dia ngerti kalo gw ga bs apa2 tapi kalo dpt dukungan ormas, pantat dia bakal selamat
Duitnya dari mana bos. Indonesia sekarang duitnya tipis. Pinjam sana sini, cari2 arab, cina, eropa, us buat investasi Asing karena uang sendiri nggak ada. Ibarat orang kere mau apartemen mewah. Semua orang ya mau kalo ada uang.
@@editg121 nyelenggarain formula e bisa tuhh 1.5 T, ngasih oramas 2.5 T ada tuhh, sebenernya uang ada cuma pengelolaannya aja ga bener.
Masu mending kota makassar daripada jakarta,, ya memang jakarta punya banyak bangunan bertingkatt tapi cuma itu aja kelebihannya, dan lainnya kumu 😶😶Ibukota terkumuu
The ocean will take it all. Expected sea level rise until 2100 - at least a meter
Between now in December 2020 and 20 years from now in December 2040, the July snow line within the Arctic Circle is expected to rise by about 360 meters, meaning that a large amount of Greenland ice which has been stable for the last 6,000 years will be melting over the course of the next 100 years. A similar process is also happening in Antarctica. As such, overall sea level rise worldwide will be about 4 meters over the next 100 years.
However, because of two technical reasons, whatever the overall world sea level rise is over the next 100 years, near the Equator sea level rise will be half again as much near the Equator. Indonesia is near the Equator. As such, 4 meter overall world sea level rise between now and the year 2120 will result in 6 meters of sea level rise in Indonesia and Malaysia by the year 2120.
One scientist declared a possibility of 7 meters of overall sea level rise over the next 50 years, which would equate to 10.5 meters of sea level rise in Indonesia and Malaysia over the next 50 years. That amount of sea level rise is possible if over the next 50 years the world produces an average of more than 100 million barrels of petroleum per day. Currently in 2020, the world only produces 90 or so million barrels of petroleum per day, but with new technologies recently invented, that amount of average daily world petroleum production could in theory rise to more than 100 million barrels per day.
If i'm not mistaken, Amsterdam is the city below sea water level.
That city can survive over the flood and natural disaster for many years.
Indonesia has been colonized by the dutchman over a hundred years.
I think Indonesian should learn from the dutchman, how to overcome this problem.
#Honestcomment
#SaveJakarta
#JakartaTerendam
every Indonesian people must watch this to increase his awareness to environtment
In India ancient Dwaraka submerged into ocean...And we found the temple later.
Ppl tracked using the location described in ancient texts.
Everyone will lose because of its sinking to put more infrastructure, building or investment means waste of money and times and making the land sinking faster. The question is if you are an investors or its citizens you would buy a land, housing, condominium, properties....etc in Jakarta as you knows its sinking and you will lose everything? I will sell out everything in Jakarta right now before it getting worse and lower prices when something bad happened.
WHOLE ISSUE WATER; WHAT ABOUT YRLY. FIRE 🔥 VOLCANOES, QUAKES, etc.!
See the positivity about indonesia, not only slum area. It is just focus that indonesia dirty and unneat, so if u see others area about Jakarta, u can see the imagine Jakarta can compare with other Big Cities in the world.. Jakarta advance now😇
is there a transcript for this vid?
First they should try to control the rapid population expansion, then think about other problems.
Jakarta will soon join one of the legendary cities of the ancient world, the Atlantis. Just like Atlantis, Jakarta will be under water soon.
This is why Kuala Lumpur has no beaches.
no..kuala lumpur was build on more strategic land..kawasan bukit dan pergunungan..more strategic and safe..
@@SUS-xd7ze still no beaches
Wait, jakarta has beaches??
@@waffelo4681 jakarta has another small iland with beautifull beach tht called "Pulau seribu/ thousand iland"
@@bestenemies4520 Oooo nice to know lol
still, we are more concerned about attract tourist to visit jakarta by attend formula E event... briliant!
Move people, there are plenty empty land in banten and west java, just upgrade the transportation, make it cheap and fast so people need not to live in the Jakarta, but can go to Jakarta instantly. Then little by little move the central business from Jakarta to the west (banten) and south (west java). Easy to say but not impossible, it's doable, the government has the power to do it since the beginning if the government is clean from elite corporate with only simple regulation and tax. The problem is the elite corporate player has been infiltrate the government itself so they can buy or make the rules and regulations that only benefits their own kind.
take some lessons from Holland
Mostly its the people that throw trash everywhere that causes flood
You do know that jakarta has a reclamation plan (even was help designed by dutch engineers) but was opposed by foreign environmentalist ngo. Strangely when dutch did it media praised it, when Indonesia wanna do it these ngo protests. Oh the double standard.
I have a plan scrap all modernization reclaim the land encourage subsistence farming and go back to the old way of living.
Southeast Asia is a very volatile place geologically.
From where Singapore and Natuna are, forces conspire to breakdown the once and mighty supercontinent into smaller pieces, ready to be sent to natural world-ending mechanisms that recycles the former land and spews out new land somewhere else.
Let's be honest with ourselves. Jakarta isn't that great of a place.
I hold the view that Batam Bintan- Singapura is where Indonesia's new commercial center should be.
Come on let's face it. In terms of city-states, everything all indicates that Singapore's time is over because city-states inevitably end. But unlike Mahatir and Anwar who believe that to create, one must first destroy, Indonesia can show a better path: build your future on top of ours, only can we build great cities.
But I dont think Indonesia should have just one capital. Very much like South Africa which has Johannesburg, Pretoria, Bloemfontein and Cape Town all fulfilling different roles, Plant the seed for reunification of Nusantara in the geographical center of it: Palangkaraya.
Consider, giving Eastern Indonesia independence in order to create a strong ally. One day soon, Micronesia will disappear, and I'm sure you do not want US to annex PNG or Maluku to replace Guam.
your last paragraph is really intriguing. could you elaborate it more?
camanava is the next, to include noveleta and kawit near seashore
Instead East Kalimantan, why not built
Administrative capital in Sumatra???🙏
What's up with the messed up sound mixing??
Some indonesian are very arrogant to criticize philippines as a slum capital yet they have no insight about jakartas slums which is bigger than manila...
@arif mark007 i used to live in the philippines before i move in indonesia jakarta has the biggest slum, vibes, atmosphere is just the same. Developed - non developed cities, slums.. let me tell you this. Most of slums in manila are in riverside and shores but they are lessen nowadays because some of them are rehabilitated already due to massive capital clean-up rehabilitation.
Let's face the fact that Jakarta struggles with the biggest climate change problem than Philippines,right?
@the last man standing Wesley Gibson yes it still has slums but the local goverments has been reducing it..
indonesia media busy of other countries problems, than their own.
وتكون تشغيلها عبر غرف عائمة لنظمن زيادة قوة دفعها في حالات تسونامي وارتفاع الموج لتشكل دوامة وهاذه الدوامة تعتبر سد منييع تجاه أي قوة دفع نصد الماء بالماء عبر قوة دفع مراوح قبالة سواحل جاكرتا لتكون عبارة عن سد يمنع تسرب اي مياه إلى جاكرتا
People must know how to take care of our nature and environment, that seawall might help but until when? Plant trees,nourish it and stop polluting waters within your city so that it can absorb the water and can help lessen the excess water.
they should stop extraction of groundwater, when water is pumped out of the ground aquifer, the land above sinks.
am I right?
edit: I'm talking 'bout Jakarta
edit 2: almost half of the city of Jakarta is above sea level
Dutch flooding : Let's fix it by building dams,
Indonesian flooding : let's move out booiiiiisss!!! 🍻🍻🍻
Ps: I'm Indonesian, I trust my nation, not the government.
If dutch has more lands, they will move, but they dont.
Look how US easily move their capital from NewYork to Washington DC, or Australia from Sydney to Canberra. Dutch will do the same, but they cant, so they build damned dam
Even dutch can handle jakarta. I don't know why dutch choose Jakarta as capital. Most of ancient/old capitals of Indonesian kingdoms are not located in coast (Yogyakarta,Palembang , East Java)
Halloo CNA we still under contruction Fast Train (Zinkanzen) and finish in 2021. Do you lazy to report that??? Or you only happy reported only our bad side?
mana mau mereka..haha.. Cna suruh liput banyaknya koruptor Indonesia yg mencuci atau menyimpan uang di Singapura.. saya akan cium kaki mereka. 😅😅.
Singapura tempatnya para bangsat dunia menyimpan uangnya.. makanya mereka cepat kaya.
@@WarzoneOfficial22789 gue doakan negara kecil itu cepat kana tsunami..biar rata mau perhi kemama mereka lagi?
“The project has been plagued with land acquisition delays and, as of early 2020, was less than 50 percent complete, while the West Bandung Regent blamed construction for causing severe flooding earlier this year. One day trains will run on this line, cutting travel time between the two cities to about an hour. But when traffic is light you can already drive from Jakarta to Bandung in a little over two hours, which begs the question of whether all of this was worth it in the first place.” The Diplomat, 10th November 2020.
may allah bless them.
I need to visit this city before it's too late!
23:11 where is that?
Regatta apartment . Pantai mutiara street
Jakarta's origin is similar to Mexico City, both converted lake and swamps to city. Thus they face same problem
Take it easy, we all just need money. All will be overcome with money and the government is not corrupt. With money, the city will not sink. What do you think is the difference between Bangkok, Manila and Jakarta with Singapore? Do you think that Singapore is not sinking with a very small area? In the coastal area? The answer is Singapore is not sinking because they are rich and developed countries, their million developing countries will certainly sink too. It is all because of the money and the behavior of the people and the government
What are you sinking about?
Mayday mayday!! We are sinking....
I aint sinking anything, just waving.
So the solution is to build another city that's also going to be overcrowded in a few years?
There are lot of homework for Jakarta Governor
Asias Sinking Squatter Capital of Indonesia
Jakarta can just move south 50 km where the elevation is higher, no? Crude solution but, at least it works.