Fine and much impressive arguments based on law and logic. Notifications are violative of Articles 14, 19 & 21 of the Constitution of India both in matter of claiming ITC u/s 16 and in making assessment u/s 73. Sir, you have made out prima facie a very good case and the balance of convenience is also in favour of tax payers, you please proceed further in the matter in the larger interest of the public. Thanq sir
16(4)ITC recommendation is come in effect now ? In case of the time limit for for filling an appeal against Drc-07 will be due on 12 July in case of 16(4) ITC ineligibility (3b late filling) what remedies available now - rectification of order or to file an appeal
Period increased to Nov u/s 16(4) it is totally wrong. It should have increased at least 12 months that is can be taken within 12 months from the end of the financial year.. actually dept should remove the section 16(4) and allow credits as per 2a or 2b because registered person has paid taxes only not filed returns may be due to financial situations or other things... restrictions on the credit after 6 months is not good.. it will create double taxation... Onble CA Vimal Sir only you can do it.
Sir now I've 2018-19 belated (5days) ITC GSTR-3B filing order u/c 73 DRC-01 and appeal within 30-06-2024, can refer kerala HC judgement of extension 30-Nov-2019 ???🤔
dealer doesn't have money to make appeal. govt is sole sleeping partner kaas koi option hota iccha mritu ka to vyapari us option ko chun lena or apni body ko bech kr nirdayi nirmala ko pay kr deta
![Seungmin "그렇게, 천천히, 우리(As we are)" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kAzmhLHePqU/mqdefault.jpg)
Sir, you are right. Thank you so much for raising the voice on behalf of taxpayer. Thank you for supporting us.
Sir , excellent deliberation on issue and perfectly the issue shall be scaled up , we support you all 🙏🏻
Excellent sir, rocking
Nicely worded. Absolutely true
In M. Tradelinks Kerala High Court has allowed extended time limit of 30th November retrospectively from 2017-18.
You are absolutely right Sir. I also mailed the same to the GST council and Finance ministry.
Supreme Court has already delivered a judgement that recommendations of gstc are not mandatory to the center and stategoverment.they are free.
सर आप सही कहते है . जीएसटी काऊन्सिल पुरी तरह सोनेका नाटक कर रहा है .
जो सचमूच सोता है उसे जगाया जा सकता , लेकीन जीएसटी काउन्सिल को कोन जगायेगा !
Thank you sir for sharing important case law update 👍👍
Fine and much impressive arguments based on law and logic. Notifications are violative of Articles 14, 19 & 21 of the Constitution of India both in matter of claiming ITC u/s 16 and in making assessment u/s 73.
Sir, you have made out prima facie a very good case and the balance of convenience is also in favour of tax payers, you please proceed further in the matter in the larger interest of the public. Thanq sir
16(4)ITC recommendation is come in effect now ? In case of the time limit for for filling an appeal against Drc-07 will be due on 12 July in case of 16(4) ITC ineligibility (3b late filling) what remedies available now - rectification of order or to file an appeal
Sir, those who received scn for this, how do they respond? is it required for them to reply as govt itself extended the time limit.
Period increased to Nov u/s 16(4) it is totally wrong. It should have increased at least 12 months that is can be taken within 12 months from the end of the financial year.. actually dept should remove the section 16(4) and allow credits as per 2a or 2b because registered person has paid taxes only not filed returns may be due to financial situations or other things... restrictions on the credit after 6 months is not good.. it will create double taxation... Onble CA Vimal Sir only you can do it.
THANK YOU SIR
why pay thrice time gst just because due to delay file of return while tax along with late fee is already paid.
excellent explanation
Sir now I've 2018-19 belated (5days) ITC GSTR-3B filing order u/c 73 DRC-01 and appeal within 30-06-2024, can refer kerala HC judgement of extension 30-Nov-2019 ???🤔
What ease of buisness sir,gst has ensured that there are no medium scale buisnessess left..
dealer doesn't have money to make appeal.
govt is sole sleeping partner
kaas koi option hota iccha mritu ka to vyapari us option ko chun lena or apni body ko bech kr nirdayi nirmala ko pay kr deta
👍
Sir pl share ur email, I would like to share my views on some imp points...🙏