Star Wars Has Too Many Writers! Star Wars Is Destroyed
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 30 сен 2024
- Star Wars has too many writers of Star Wars content for each Star Wars publication that is released by Disney. Star Wars has lost its way due to a total lack of focus from George Lucas who is Mr Star Wars and always will be Mr Star Wars. I fear Star Wars will be totally destroyed if it keeps down this path of awful productions which dilute the story further and further. What a mess!
Canon Lore video Playlist:
/ playlistlist=plagwqgvr...
Legends Lore video Playlist: • Galactic Empire Star W...
Imperial Rank Insignias Playlist: • Imperial Ranks Star Wars
Andor Imperials Explained: • Andor Star Wars Explained
Mandalorian Imperials Explained: • Mandalorian Imperials ...
For more future imperial explained videos please give a ‘like and ‘Subscribe’ to this channel.
I remember when Disney bought Lucasfilm, about 15 years ago. The hope this gave the community, that new and better Star Wars were coming... How wrong we were...
Fr, biggest let down in history
It's not writing. It's the direction. Kennedy has kept making errors.
She greenlights stuff that should not be greenlighted and people working at lucasfilm are starting to transform their work so that it can get greenlighted.
They know that adding DEI and agendas WILL get stuff greenlighted.
I hate Disney.
Amen! All of it is junk! EU legends is more better!
@@arturourbina6656Damn right.
Who doesn't 😂🥲
@@baradmemarkermani2184 Good point.
The Virgin 21st century Disney vs the Chad 20th century Disney.
All Disney+ SW series should be prefaced with a disclaimer-"Based on a bad Star Wars idea from a corporate toady"
they don't have enough GOOD writers who aren't beholding to the "message" Andor Two is coming up,hopefully The Mouse won't f*ck that up...
Yeah I think you summed it up perfectly
Long Live The Empire!
Disney killed Star Wars. I feel like pre Disney lore is the best!!! And I call it True Star Wars!!!
Filoni, who currently fills the position you want to be filled, isn’t going to make things better; he’s the reason the EU and Star Wars died in the first place-he basically led the charge, because he doesn’t care. He does whatever he wants, whenever he wants, damn whoever’s work he has to pave over.
He’s produced, cleared, or mentored, almost every one of the shows that’ve come out from Disney-and has a history of chasing out better people, such as Sue Rostoni, Karen Traviss and now John Favreau
Welcome to the Orthodox fanbase. If Disney can reject the material we embraced as canon, we can reject their canon.
Yes, I believe I am beginning down that path, apart from Andor which I do like
@@ImperialsExplained Andor and rogue one are consistent with the original movies. More so even than much of filoni's work.
This is an obvious but fresh take that actually delves into the wide array of issues in new star wars without sounding repetitive and generic. I couldn't agree more
Thanks, my friend 👍
Its similar to manda-Lore WHO Had the healthy Take of leaving Star wars Disney Canon and filonis stuff Out and Just Focus on the Expanded Universe
I never like dianey what they did to star wars! Their stories they made are lame! I always stick with EU legends, their the true canon stories
I couldn't agree more. The original trilogy will be to star wars fans what Bach, Beethoven, and Motzart is to classical music. But as much as they're mocked, I really really like 1- 2- & 3. But this is my view of Disney Star Wars. And I apologize ahead of time if it gets a bit political.
From my POV Disney never bought Star Wars to make good content or to make $$$. They bought it because the Entire company is run by the wokest of the woke. They bought Star Wars from Lucus because it was wildly popular and had a Huge fan base to tell their woke stories to. These people, people like KK & Hedland are left wing activists first and foremost and will run Star Wars into the ground & their company into complete bankruptcy to do it.
I feel this way because it's been almost 10 years since they bought it and over that time they must have had literally millions of fans All bitching about the same thing. But they've Never, not one time changed a single one of those things. They just double down & call those that don't like the stuff they put out terrible names.
They're all far left wing activists and until/unless Star Wars is bought by someone that isn't we'll keep getting Indoctrination pieces on the toxicity of the patriarchy and chicks that can fight 10 men.
And I will keep calling them out.
It's been dead since 2017. Hell, to me it died after the SWEU had beed canned.
EA’s Battlefront 2 was ultimately killed my interest in the Disney Canon
The sad Part IS they are some Disney Canon books writers WHO can created good Stories that IS logical in the star wars universe hell they Made even the sequels barely tolerable but then comes along Guys Like Dave filoni WHO Bulldozered all over established Lore because Guys Like Filoni need their "creative vision" so the Readers dont Care and books writers dont Care since their Work gets destroyed by the next idiot TV writer
@@laisphinto6372 Well said 👏
Couldn’t agree with you more. Star Wars is unfortunately dead it’s already too late - so sad
Just leave it at Dave and John and everything will be alright
They don't know what Star Wars is they've never read it and to be honest with you my friend they couldn't care less.
Honestly I think if they just give up the woke DEI bullshit, then they can make good works. Honestly Rouge One, Bad Batch, Andor, and The Mandalorian were pretty good. Unfortunately even if that does happen, their will always be fans that hate it.
@ARCtrooper65 Yes, agreed, as the damage is already done, it seems
The Thing is yeah they are maybe some good parts but unfortuanly they are getting retconned, people accuse the Expanded Universe of Not making Sense and are inconsistent but Disney Star wars managed to completely butcher their own Canon because they dont even try to make it consistent and people who try get punished because despite the fairy Tale about all Media mattering the Same in Canon ,books and Comics Always get shafted and Sometimes TV Shows contradict the previous TV Show or even the movies
@laisphinto6372 to be fair, even George Lucas believed that the canon of the shows and movies were more important the that of books and comics, but I don't think he meant for it to be like this
This is the kind of show that makes me explore Legends in much, much, more detail.
@grayflaneur4854 Legends content is what l mainly focus on because of Disney's failure to make consistent and decent SW.
If George wanted to save Star Wars he would have sided with Nelson Peltz
Honestly I don’t think it’s the number of writers that’s the issue, but rather who’s writing. I mean just look at GW and Warhammer They have dozens if not hundreds of writers and for the most part what they produce is good.
Because they actually care about quality control, unlike Disney.
In terms of the number of writers its about continuity and feel of the production. It's very much about that in my view and that is what worries me that they will continue to dilute Star Wars until no one is watching because its lost it appeal to even the average fan. It's so worrying that this will happen now and I am seriously considering whether it is ever worth continuing with my channel.
All the criticism of Disney-era Star Wars is earned. However, I think a lot of people these days are giving George Lucas way more credit than he deserves. I honestly don’t know if the quality of writing would be any better with him still in charge.
The list of good Star Wars writers is short… and George Lucas himself is not on that list.
Even though I grew up on the Clone Wars and the Sequels and all the New Star Wars, as I've come into my Teen Years and been able to find and buy the older Legends Books I've found it to be my favorite past time and have loved reading them. Currently I'm reading Isard's Revenge and The Black Fleet Trilogy after having finished the Thrawn Trilogy, I was disappointed when Ahsoka sort of underprovided for Thrawn and the Chimaera after reading three books about the Last Grand Admiral, I feel S3E7 of the Mandalorian did better with a Five Minute Conference for the Empire than 75% of Ahsoka's Imperial Scenes
Agreed, I feel Disney is going to make a mess of Thrawn's story in terms of his return and gathering the imperial remnant. It just won't be the same as the old stories.
@@ImperialsExplained Indeed, Thrawn, and even Daala's work in Darksaber are just so amazing for how it was written, and even when Timothy Zahn said that Rebels and Ahsoka Thrawn was how he imagined it feels different
These people didn’t mean to screw everything up. Nobody ever intended to disregard Lucas’ vision.
@59rlmccormack l agree but just made a Disney version of Star Wars in a lot of shows without enough continuity for me to shallow a lot of changes in storyline, characters, and plots .
However, Andor, to me, is a good example of what they really do when they put their minds to it.
@59rlmccormack Another thing, they are disregarding him now.
It died the minute they threw out the Expanded Universe.
the reason star wars is on the decline, is because Disney dose not care about star wars but to use it as a platform for their politics, the Acolyte was just so blatant in pushing the agenda that even the most hard core defender of Disney star wars recognize how bad the Acolyte is, but dont give up hope real star wars is being kept alive by the fans, there are countless fan projects that are true to George Lucas star wars, such as fan animations like: For the empire, skyforge space battle animations,DarthAngelus fan made version of heir to the empire, and even lore channels like this one, we are keeping star wars alive, forget the slop Disney makes, embrace legends, we will still be true fans long after Disney have throw star wars in the trash for a fresher franchise to milk and ruin
Long Live the Empire, Long Live the Fans, Long. Live. Star Wars
The same 'true' star wars fan that was responsible for George selling Star Wars to Disney after their toxic attitude towards the prequels? It's both Disney's and you 'true' star wars fan's fault that star wars was ruined.
I agree with what was said in the video, but the EU had a lot of writers and incoherent plot threads throughout the books too. But in terms of film and tv there needs a consistent and constant thread. Most of the tv shows and film have no grandiosity. It feels way too small
There needs to be a Kevin Feige type of figure for the Star Wars property. That loves making great movies at all interconnect in someway or some form. He did a great job with phase 1 through three. Phase 4 and five will that’s debatable, but there was other factors into that as well. I know Kathleen Kennedy is supposed to be that person but I reluctantly agree with you. There’s no continuity. We keep jumping time frames. Like right now we have something 100 years before. Before that we had something 15 years after. Stick with one time frame and move forward. Or go back in time and stick with that timeline. But it all has to connect to The Jedi, Sith, Skywalkers. Palpatine. That’s my opinion.
I mean about the acolyte, I mean wow. That new episode probably had one of the best lightsaber action scenes we’ve ever seen
@omarbaba9892 Personally, l could stand the Acolyte for reasons in which l could go on and on to explain.
We support you 👑
Thanks, my friend. Lost a few subs recently
@@ImperialsExplained love your videos, we should kick this Disney
@@baradmemarkermani2184 You've made my day. I am feeling a little disillusioned by Star Wars at the moment. These are dark days but I am going to focus on Legends material for a while.....
@@ImperialsExplained no problem, after all we are the same family, we must not let others come and destroye what we love, I hope you get 100k subs a day😂 long live the empire 👑
“Poor writing, Poor dialogue and poor acting.” Well, to be fair The prequels were also that as well. Regardless of one’s opinion, what do you think of Andor and rogue one?
I do like those productions as they are respectful to the original films. Andor is what l call 'down-to-earth' star wars and enjoy watching the first season. But obviously, that is because it's Tony Gilroy writing it
@@ImperialsExplained Since you mention in you're video that you version of tales of the empire would included ISB would you'r version would included barriss (at least the different outcome like she stay as an inquisitor.) same with Morgan (But better written.) considering she is the one brought Thrawn back to the galaxy.
What weird when it come the current problems with Star Wars is that Leslye Headland also did Russian Doll and that show was good/great? either something happened or she is suffering the same thing that Matthew Vaughn is been doing lately with his new movies?
Regardless if You were the one in charge at Lucasfilm say you somehow convince GIlroy to do more spin off series (after Andor season 2.) what would they be about? would they be a series on The Separatist Coalition, A Imperial Senate show, A Mon Mothma Show (either before or after Andor where it would her during the galactic civil war and the original trilogy) a Anto Kreegyr show during the clone wars (finally given the separatist a story from their perspective?) Saw Gerrera and the Partisans or the New Rebel Factions that Saw mentions and list to Luthen like the Neo-Republicans. or even a luthen show about his backstory, Or Hell maybe a show finally telling the story of the Bothans stealing the second Death Star plans or even a band of brothers show set during the galactic civil War?
I will admit don't hate both Jon Faverau (afterall he was the one who convinced the Marvel Studio to cast Robert Downey Jr for the role of Iron Man.) and Dave Filoni Ultimately I always feel it more of the system that is to blame then the individual themselves. Like even Mando Season 2 has tons of cameos and was more connected to the Skywalker era then season 1 at least it was a well written season plus Lucas admitted he regret on killing Boba Fett off in Return of the Jedi so that's that.
I also wonder what do you think of George Lucas ideas for his sequel trilogy where he based on the state of the galaxy post Endor from The Post Iraq War? Finally and I forgot to mention this what do think of some of the canon books and comics like Alphabet Squadron trilogy, The New Thrawn Novels (Both Imperial and Ascendancy Trilogies.) Battlefront: Twilight Company, The Living Force, Rebel Rising (which tells the story of what happened to Jyn Erso between the prologue scene from Rogue One to when we see her in prison.) Tarkin (The Novel by James Luceno.) Charles Soule's Darth Vader comics (2017.) and Catalyst (The Prequel Novel to Rogue One also by Luceno.)
I agree either 100% of what you said and feel exactly the same. I lost faith in Disney after Kenobi and I am not even watching the latest a content.
When Disney announced that the EU is going to be scrapped in favour of their own canon in 2014. My immersion for Star Wars completely broke. I was 16 back then and just got into the EU after 2008 because of the force unleashed. Every battlefront 2 mission, Empire at War campaign, or any other media had that magical feeling of being a historical document and that “wow this really happened at this point in time” moment. Ever since 2014 that’s all gone. As much as I want legends back I fear it won’t be the best solution. We are exactly 10 years into the Disney lore with an entire generation of kids and young adults who grew up with Disney’s canon ans getting rid of that will destroy their enjoyment as well. But on the other hand… I don’t care, I want the EU restored but Dave Feloni should not be allowed to make retcons I mean stories for it. I believe that the clone wars (2008) is the main reason why we even got a new timeline in the first place. As much as I enjoy certain episodes of TCW it came with a terrible cost.
I think Disney have just got mostly wrong apart from Andor, which proves to me that they produce good stuff when good writers like Tony Gilroy gets involved. It's just a real shame that they are using Star Wars as a political weapon.
@@ImperialsExplained aside from Andor I view most of the stuff Disney puts out as very expensive fan fiction. That’s the only way I can cope with it these days
@@MalenGarek me too
Diabolical
For ahsoka it’s fine though since Thrawn is clearly being set up to be a bigger villain in the future
And nah legends would be really bad to follow for a potential retcon as it was extremely messy and it would’ve been entirely retconned anyway by George if he made a sequel trilogy
I didn't mean follow it entirely, but emulate the stories rather than pretend to care and make up their own. However, I agree the old Legends material does get messy but George would have used the parts that he liked etc
I disagree because Legends IS nowhere near AS messy AS Disney Canon accomplished in far less of a timeframe
The last (Star Wars) created was the book crucible back in 2012.
I’m interested to see you review on the third episode of SW: Acolyte.
...
And you think the EU had LESS writers?
Come on...
But had to be commissioned by George as a central person to largely govern it. My point is there isn't anyone at Disney that, and for that reason, there is a lack of continuity.
IDK, I thought Atlantis: The Lost Empire was an underrated masterpiece.