As an Englishman that Low Saxon conversation was a comfortable listen. I won’t say I knew what they were saying but it felt very familiar and I knew how the conversation was flowing. I reckon If I stayed there for a year I’d learn comfortably.
It is one to learn a foreign language living there. Learning a foreign language is a completely different skill. But you need to learn a foreign language on order to have an 'in' into the conversation.
Although many people think that “German” is a language, it isn’t. German is really a catch-all term for all the West Germanic dialects spoken in the German cultural area. These dialects are descended from 3 separate ancient languages. North-Sea Germanic, which is ancestral to the Low German dialects, Weser-Rhine Germanic, which is ancestral to the West-Central German dialects, and Elbe Germanic, which is ancestral to the East-Central and Upper German dialects. Standard German, which is spoken by the majority of Germans and the one typically learned, is not a natural language, but a standardized one based on East-Central dialects.
Yeah, all these 'national languages' are developed due to standardized education and media. Happened in France, too. Noam Chomsky says that 200 years ago it was possible to go to the next town over in France and be out of your depth language-wise. Now even the Canadians speak the standardized French.
But to be fair, in some regions, Standard German has actually become a natural language. Up North, most people have completely switched to Standard German because Low German is way less mutually intelligible with the rest of Germany.
East central german has no ancestral links and should be seen as a seperate group. These dialects were koine dialects (mixed of various germanic dialects with slavs) that emerged in the middleages around the 12th century. What used to be elbe germanic was old thuringian but that one went extinct by getting overformed by franconian in the 5th century (so before the high german consonat shift). In its earlier stages this new "thuringian" was called sorbenfrankish. If you wanted to classify them in any of the 3 categories it would most closely resemble weser-rhine germanic due to its frankish routes (as unsurprisingly east central german is closest in its features to west central german and upper franconian)
Hey dude I just wanted to say this comment about your whole channel in general. It's dope as fuck. I like it a lot. I see what you're going for and I hope you continue doing more of it. I can see you're just some dude uploading for fun, kinda like myself although way more invested.....but like if you commit this basic idea for a channel to maximum effort I'm sure you'll find success with it because it's plain old interesting
@@floatingfinish2211 can you understand what I am going to say to you Ik wurd eleke ochtend wakker om acht uur sochtends en doorna smeer ik vur mezelf een broodje met een plakke kase met boter en ham en in de avond goan ik om elf uur savens nog even TV kieken en doarna slaapen
That’s why people from Northern Germany (Hamburg, Berlin, Bremen) can speak better english than people from Southern Germany. The stereotypical exaggerated Arnold Schwarzenegger type accent is Bavarian. I met someone who was from Hamburg and they could speak in a perfect British accent.
*Niederdeutsch - Hochdeutsch* ik - ich maken - machen slapen - schlafen dorp - Dorf drinken - trinken vader - Vater dat - das appel - Apfel zitten - sitzen
Using some Austrian dialect for "High German" was pretty funny. Not inaccurate at all, but also not what most German-speaking people would expect, I believe.
*Niederdeutsch - Hochdeutsch* ik - ich maken - machen slapen - schlafen dorp - Dorf drinken - trinken vader - Vater dat - das appel - Apfel zitten - sitzen
As an Englishman that Low Saxon conversation was a comfortable listen. I won’t say I knew what they were saying but it felt very familiar and I knew how the conversation was flowing. I reckon If I stayed there for a year I’d learn comfortably.
It is one to learn a foreign language living there.
Learning a foreign language is a completely different skill.
But you need to learn a foreign language on order to have an 'in' into the conversation.
Although many people think that “German” is a language, it isn’t. German is really a catch-all term for all the West Germanic dialects spoken in the German cultural area. These dialects are descended from 3 separate ancient languages. North-Sea Germanic, which is ancestral to the Low German dialects, Weser-Rhine Germanic, which is ancestral to the West-Central German dialects, and Elbe Germanic, which is ancestral to the East-Central and Upper German dialects. Standard German, which is spoken by the majority of Germans and the one typically learned, is not a natural language, but a standardized one based on East-Central dialects.
Yeah, all these 'national languages' are developed due to standardized education and media. Happened in France, too. Noam Chomsky says that 200 years ago it was possible to go to the next town over in France and be out of your depth language-wise. Now even the Canadians speak the standardized French.
But to be fair, in some regions, Standard German has actually become a natural language. Up North, most people have completely switched to Standard German because Low German is way less mutually intelligible with the rest of Germany.
East central german has no ancestral links and should be seen as a seperate group. These dialects were koine dialects (mixed of various germanic dialects with slavs) that emerged in the middleages around the 12th century. What used to be elbe germanic was old thuringian but that one went extinct by getting overformed by franconian in the 5th century (so before the high german consonat shift). In its earlier stages this new "thuringian" was called sorbenfrankish.
If you wanted to classify them in any of the 3 categories it would most closely resemble weser-rhine germanic due to its frankish routes (as unsurprisingly east central german is closest in its features to west central german and upper franconian)
I feel Low German has more of a connection to English than High.
As an english speaker who studied german high german is way easier to understand.
Yup! Low German sounded more Danish to me
Which is official? Low or high German ?
@Albion89 they're both official, but I believe (at least from what I have learned) high german is the more standard version that you'll encounter....
@@dux_bellorum Low German is similar to Dutch and High is free to learn on Duolingo
well of course because that's what they teach in schools usually
low german seems more familiar with english
Hey dude I just wanted to say this comment about your whole channel in general. It's dope as fuck. I like it a lot. I see what you're going for and I hope you continue doing more of it. I can see you're just some dude uploading for fun, kinda like myself although way more invested.....but like if you commit this basic idea for a channel to maximum effort I'm sure you'll find success with it because it's plain old interesting
In my part of East Frisia, people "proten" Low German, no one "snacks"
You snack in the "snack bar" (chip shop), or at the french fries stand
Du bist ja auch Friese und kein Sachse ;)
@@floatingfinish2211 can you understand what I am going to say to you
Ik wurd eleke ochtend wakker om acht uur sochtends en doorna smeer ik vur mezelf een broodje met een plakke kase met boter en ham en in de avond goan ik om elf uur savens nog even TV kieken en doarna slaapen
Sounds like a mix between German, Dutch and Swedish/Norwegian!
I speak Dutch Low-Saxon, and its so simular to German Low-Saxon.
That’s why people from Northern Germany (Hamburg, Berlin, Bremen) can speak better english than people from Southern Germany. The stereotypical exaggerated Arnold Schwarzenegger type accent is Bavarian. I met someone who was from Hamburg and they could speak in a perfect British accent.
Lower Saxony the home of my 11th great- grandfather Tobias Von Cramer
*Niederdeutsch - Hochdeutsch*
ik - ich
maken - machen
slapen - schlafen
dorp - Dorf
drinken - trinken
vader - Vater
dat - das
appel - Apfel
zitten - sitzen
I prefer Low German
Using some Austrian dialect for "High German" was pretty funny. Not inaccurate at all, but also not what most German-speaking people would expect, I believe.
It wasn't dialect tho, just southern accent
Also the only officially recognized seperate dialect in Austria is Wienerisch, all dialects not from Vienna are officially variations of Bavarian
That's not High German, that's a thick Bavarian accent. 😬
Which is a high german dialect
Im assuming its similar to southern and northern UK accents
it’s much more different than in the UK. english itself evolved out of what is now low german so it should sound more familiar
*Niederdeutsch - Hochdeutsch*
ik - ich
maken - machen
slapen - schlafen
dorp - Dorf
drinken - trinken
vader - Vater
dat - das
appel - Apfel
zitten - sitzen
No, they are seperate languages
hitla
Spelt "I'm a loser" wrong
nuh uh
If your trying to be funny, then your not. Germany doesn’t mean Hitler, kid.
Bro learned to spell in kfc