Agreed. One of the worse part of the whole show. What is Madame Fa thinking? She is not the Queen, for goodness sake. There was no sensitivity towards the Mirror members. I feel so bad for everyone of them. I am glad AK looked her right in the eye and spoke up. Somebody had to. She was trying to do a "good" show in the expense of others. The last speech by the host was terrible as well. He was trying to make something out of this awkward, embarrassing moment. But what he said would have hurt those who got worse rankings, like Lokman, Anson Lo and Frankie. It is like rubbing into a bleeding wound. It would have been better if he could just quit saying anything.
Actually is 當眾侮辱 Mirrors, 傷害人的自尊, this is why they said they have 心病 among themselves, is 公司 gave them, just let 參賽者 pick which mirror they like, they know who is popular, 當眾 show who is 考第尾, 考第一, just ridiculous, 冇聊排名
This ranking of mirror members is solely for the purpose of getting attention on the TV program. While everyone is saying Ahfa is wrong on doing this, her boss Mr. Lu would be properly very happy and thinking Ahfa did a great job.
AK 係嬲得啱
非常贊成AK 無論係唔係鏡粉睇到都會嬲😤😤
+1
呢個制度簡直係垃圾，一啲都唔好睇，好欣賞AK嘅真性情，唔好向不公義嘅制度屈服
AK嬲得啱，呢啲咁嘅制度根本係傷害緊佢哋
AK嘅反應完全正常，唔會因為礙於花姐或者公司而扮無嘢，十分欣賞！
很尊重Alton！Alton因為被排了第12名，有壓力都正常！根本就是虐待！RESPECT！
好多人都比世俗嘅實力標準set 左，但我覺得12個都各有各好，各有各長處嘅。
又話想Mirror團結, 各人要有自信, 要大家同聲同氣。但經常玩分化, 玩排擠, 玩羞辱, 打擊士氣, 咁樣做似想攪心病, 攪積怨, 攪散Mirror 多啲。
將心比心....醒少少, 咁做有乜好處。
It was a totally stupid idea.
佢哋十二位EQ真喺好高。
花姐本身對早前Mirror的內部紛爭需要負返d責任，佢地早已存在比較，加埋呢單嘢可能令問題惡化
佢無形中開始左大家互相比較，加上資源不足，各人工作安排有差異，越積越深， 一直去到梅窩營先化解。
今時今日再睇，只睇到十二個條路真的行得不易。無論經歷幾多，捱過幾多，我只睇到你哋各人在不同範疇上也各有進步，希望你哋繼續發光發亮。什麼排行榜，什麼樂壇成績，什麼頒獎禮也不要看得太重，不要太比較。最仲要保持初心，最好每次的表演，珍惜可以一起進步、一起分享丶一起流汗的兄弟🔥🔥
唔怪得之鏡仔今時今日可以咁謙卑。就係呢啲殘酷既經歷，先訓練到佢地提早面對面真正觀眾負面評價和比較既壓力，領悟到一切來得𣎴易，或者fans 要多謝制作組既「用心良苦」。
排名意義係咩?咪就係話題同收視囉
辛苦mirror一班成員
ＡＫ這次比隊長更隊長，黑面黑得好
應該十二個全部黑面。
黑面好有自己嘅性格支持
其實我覺得排行榜真係冇乜意義所以真係黑面黑得好
冇追開造星，真係唔知，亦無法想像佢哋竟然受到咁嘅待遇，仲要賽前一次，賽後一次；皮皮好慘囉，見佢响調校入面講到對自己响Mirror好冇信心，都唔知係咪呢件事影響咗，好彩佢拍IT狗都有返啲成績；Tiger都係呀，都係廿歲仔啫，就要面對啲咁嘅嘢，我哋睇嘅人同當事人都好難堪囉！為咩呀？！
今次我係全力支持AK黑面，以後我都會支持佢黑面，因為佢黑得面係真係有佢道理！
Respect AK👍🏻👍🏻12 個都係最好💪🏻👍🏻
AK講得啱！簡直on x
AK嬲得岩, 撐你
原來嗰陣就係咁不斷破壞大家關係🥲
重覆再睇，十二位都咁好！
雖然時隔九個月先至追到哩一集，但不得不表態留言，呢個環節真係極度不知所謂及感受到侮辱，完全睇唔到此舉對 Mirror十二位精英經歷
#赤條條揭開肚皮
#重重挑戰
#艱苦訓練
嘅孩子們，
？？有何實際提升意義？？
任何人都需要〖尊重〗。
甚至始祖級~外國電視台此類節目，所有知名度更高嘅評判都以禮相待，並以鼓勵説話表態，絕對唔會侮辱所有參賽者。
真心極度不滿此環節!!!
見到AK 的正義勇敢。
宣佈結果時見到大家其實唔開心。花姐傷害左鏡仔, 從此互相有比較就有傷害。
呢個環節係唔需要有, 係為節目更刺激定收視?
Ian第10🤯😨
重點係就算想帶出觀眾印象可以喺睇完表現後改觀呢個道理，都唔應該係mirror12個人互片，AK同Alton都講到明，難受嘅係佢地12個兄弟面要分高下，要搵一個墊底，mirror最有力量嘅地方係喺才華之上夠團結，香港宜家咁散，mirror展現到香港此時此地少見到嘅團結同情誼。真係好少團咁團結，花姐係咪想mirror團結互相扶持？定喺想分化面排高低排階級？
有冇人都認為AK 果句 I don’t care 好型呀？
有
AK 好Man!!!!!❤️❤️❤️❤️
其實依家睇返呢個重新排行榜，我只會覺得系一個對表演者EQ 考驗及提早令各成員有心理準備面對市場殘酷嘅一面，好明顯如果心態可以接受到打擊，可以走得更遠，要先明白呢個世界冇公平。
又話12-1=0⋯又話要佢哋團結⋯又話要調教佢哋⋯其實day 1 分化佢哋⋯令佢哋有心病就係呢班人⋯節目效果？我相信除咗憎mirror 嘅人⋯冇人會覺得好睇⋯而家再睇返都係😡
BTW⋯真心撐AK⋯真心man爆愛兄弟⋯其實早喺mirror go已經有留意⋯每次兄弟要大懲罰⋯好多人都食緊花生笑緊嘅時候⋯佢每次都係好緊張好擔心⋯雖然我唔係「生粉」⋯但真心撐佢尊重佢👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
看了會心疼💔
AK說得對.無論第12名或第一名我都支持☺️
第十二名唔開心，第一名亦尷尬，有咩為？
12個都係第一 浪费时间
1:53 Lokman 個樣 relatable
點解唔倒翻轉由12位，選擇適合的組別呢。
教主見陳仔10排名好震驚
對，好才現在是頭6個
又殘忍多一次，坦白講，無需要咁做，即使我鍾意嘅係第一，我都唔捨得其他任何一個受傷害。其實如果放佢哋响第二或第三屆，佢哋有幾位都比冠亞季軍都優勝得多，我自己心中Mirror都有一個排行榜。🤔🤔
而家先睇返呢一集，反而覺得咁樣嘅安排係別有用心，令佢哋早啲一齊經歴呢啲壓力，往後嘅日子更加齊心，唔再怕有什麼失敗，更認清自己，接受自己，令佢哋更加有進步嘅空間！如果話呢個安排好殘忍，咁當佢地真正面對出邊嘅唔好輿論仲更加殘忍！
支持你地！mirror 、花姐加油💪！每次見到你哋嘅演出都係付出100%嘅努力，我哋觀眾係睇到！用心同專業的一班歌手同製作團隊！香港樂壇有希望☺️
😜我係一個80後媽媽
剛剛睇返d舊片，發現呢條片，正正就系你所講嘅！
我想當日個個話AK 黑面系應該嘅時候，可能估唔到佢會在叱咤公然黑面😑！觀眾唔會有時間去了解AK，只會第一感覺差😑
2021都仲嬲緊
人哋十二個係兄弟ok?！你竟然攪啲咁嘅排行鎊？😒😒😒😒😒
雖然我最鍾意姜濤佢第一當然開心，但 舉行呢个選票實在太冇聊且好傷害其他排得尾嘅成員
增加話題，製造傷害
Jer攞第9? 冇野呀！
跟本係個時既人氣排名
當時未識mirror都睇得勁唔舒服，唔係個個都鍾意睇殘酷環節🙄
睇到呢一集我直接quit咗造星2！
公司為咗話題分化12個仔，前排咁多心結，積怨，少不免係由呢啲搞出嚟🙄
AK質疑得有道理
Edan點會得第8啊 he is always creative in his performance👍🏻
Live一般 唔穩定
@@freakymui Edan 一定頭二啦 八級鋼琴八級小提琴又唱得又跳得又演得 朗誦又得綜藝又得英文又好港大畢業又靚仔 有咩可能差過Alton lol 😂
@@adalove7564留左個又搞笑😂
今日再睇返到嬲 制度係節目組定 做咩要搞到佢地難受
Agreed. One of the worse part of the whole show. What is Madame Fa thinking? She is not the Queen, for goodness sake. There was no sensitivity towards the Mirror members. I feel so bad for everyone of them. I am glad AK looked her right in the eye and spoke up. Somebody had to. She was trying to do a "good" show in the expense of others. The last speech by the host was terrible as well. He was trying to make something out of this awkward, embarrassing moment. But what he said would have hurt those who got worse rankings, like Lokman, Anson Lo and Frankie. It is like rubbing into a bleeding wound. It would have been better if he could just quit saying anything.
其實個個都吾係幾開心，只係AK比較喜恕形於色就算見姜濤第一個樣都好尷尬咁，成個環節真係好過份，自己製造內部矛盾。
我留言係為左唔想有任何一個人經歷完排行而唔開心，每一個都各有特色，好出色。
一直好怕你們12個會有一天壓力過大而引致情緒病。
希望我這個小小的留言水滴，能跟大家聚成大海，成為你們多一份的支持。
要加油
Edan and Ian明明就係全隊裏面實力最高，點解咁後啊😢😢😢😢😢
加AK好多分。
係人都知會排姜濤第一啦！何必要咁呢🤦🏼♀️
我睇到呢集時最想問係呢班參賽者有咩資格去評MIRROR 實力?
我覺得花姐根本係偏心囉整爛呢啲綁根本都係傷害人哋個心
德仔排12傷心，皮皮排12都傷心，Ak又傷心
花姐根本沒想過，生粉，皮寶寶，蛋白粉的 感受
雖然皮皮口中話冇嘢但係我感受到佢係唔開心㗎
其實點都會有條刺 調教完都會同刺
😞
Actually is 當眾侮辱 Mirrors, 傷害人的自尊, this is why they said they have 心病 among themselves, is 公司 gave them, just let 參賽者 pick which mirror they like, they know who is popular, 當眾 show who is 考第尾, 考第一, just ridiculous, 冇聊排名
ian 10 !what!
真係唔明點解要set排行榜，唔應該😡😡😡
最後結果Edan同教主都係造星2閃閃發亮, 哩個榜亦好無謂!
要佢哋再次參加造星11要造就AL攞到獎大獎。
好無謂
又真係無乜必要喎，佢地做咩要比佢地去評先？意思何在？就要為左令mirror啲人難堪？
同埋唔公平囉
而家睇番都好唔開心，12個冇人識笑。不過….. 佢哋而家所面對所有嘅比果時難受百倍😖😖😖唉☹️☹️
差唔多人人都鬧依part , 我反而覺得其實要諗下點解咁安排。。。
我覺得個排名係係有佢的作用
This ranking of mirror members is solely for the purpose of getting attention on the TV program. While everyone is saying Ahfa is wrong on doing this, her boss Mr. Lu would be properly very happy and thinking Ahfa did a great job.
講第9係啊jer果時, Anson Lo個表情勁驚訝
隊長也很驚訝。
所以話分化嘅從來唔係粉絲，而係佢哋自己公司同花姐😢
花姐嗰句呢個係一個節目真係睇到都嬲，癡線架，節目又點？呢個唔係公開羞辱佢哋嘅藉口，果然做慣節目嘅人連基本respect都冇埋，已經比收視同效果洗咗腦
皮皮好慘
仲要為按身高排
AK叻仔，做返自己，唔做作，真性情
❤️AK
They have their own style so not fair to judge in this way
你這個監製知不知道會很殘忍的
Ian 點會排第十
This is such a trash in Mirror’s mind
Yes, it’s useless and meaningless
好殘忍...不過娛樂圈就係咁殘忍（？）
No need 排名, why ? discouraged all Mirror singers n they may have bad feelings
難以理解，le個環節太冇謂，不知所謂
唔好啦！
Ian第十？收啦
個個個樣勁難受 勁老尷
排行榜一定有，接受事實啦！
心痛：（
攪啲咁嘅排行鎊簡直on x，一啲都唔好睇
無意中重睇都覺得呢個環節好差好過份，雖然我愛嘅姜姜都係第一，但係做埋呢啲令大家咁尷尬又難受嘅無意義排名真係好離譜👎🏻同埋當時參賽者都唔應該有呢個資格公開評佢哋分，超垃圾
黐鬼線，*one and all *公司帶頭玩分化。。。 為咗節目效果， 唔理人哋嘅感受
💪💖
第一一定係Edan/ Jer
AK嬲個樣好靚仔,真係好靚仔,好想畀AK用粗口鬧我
其實他們之間的分歧，是外間給他們還是公司內部導致？
I don't care🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😂
I don't care!
姜濤有咩咁好呀？？？
現場睇過咪知囉
就係有
個光環夠好🤪
姜濤決賽果陣評審都評佢第一
係呢到其實姜濤拎第一都唔會開心，好傷兄弟情，佢都好尷尬咁
食屎啦Lokman
點撚樣啊，靚仔大曬？
肥花你點樣做人呀⋯⋯咁嘅嘢都諗得出，唔怪得你今天俾人淘汰
你班監製高層紅館單野洗乾淨個屎忽入去痞啦