Will Gambhir be the right pick as India coach?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 2 окт 2024
- Anil Kumble and Varun Aaron on the hunt for India's next head coach and whether they should consider a split-coaching system.
About Channel:
🏏 Stay updated with the latest T20I, ODI and Test match highlights, cricket match news, and in-depth analysis from the most exciting cricket tournaments.
Subscribe to ESPNcricinfo now and unlock a world of exclusive cricket content to catch every boundary, every wicket, and every unforgettable moment of the T20I, ODIs, Test, Domestic and International Matches
Subscribe to our RUclips channel: / espncricinfo
Get more cricket updates at: www.espncricin...
You can also find us at:
/ cricinfo
/ espncricinfo
/ espncricinfo
Download Android and iOS Apps for more cricket news & updates:
Android: bit.ly/2vFVfzX
iOS: apple.co/2vGj8rg
Those visual advertisements while someone is speaking are distracting. Please change that.
Kumble has aged like a fine wine.
I personally feel that we need a foreign bowling coach especially for fast bowling. We have to develop young bowlers who are showing promise so that we have a pipeline after Bumrah, Shami and Siraj
Bharat Arun is still the best bowling coach available in India. We were a strong bowling side under him. He should either be the bowling coach or work at the NCA with the young fast bowlers. We need to groom the likes of Mohsin Khan, Harshit Rana, Mayank Yadav, Vaibhav Arora, Kuldeep Sen and also work on Umran Malik and Prasidh Krishna..This should be the priority of the BCCI along with grooming fast bowling all-rounders for Test cricket..
We should hire wasim akram or soibh akthar as bowling coach
Looks like Gambhir is considering my comment .
If India wants to win big icc events Gambhir is correct person 😊
One man can't do everything unless he is completely backed by the board and selectors..Also the captain needs to resonate with him as well..
Gambhir ego is big problem
No ego just facts dhobi can't digest that @@Article39A
@@Article39Aego❌❌
Passion with aggression☑️☑️
Mohd. Azharoodin Must be the Next Bharateean Cricket 🏏 Team Coach He will do a magic behind the screen with the Tips of Batting and other departments of cricket ➕ Coaching them on Spot at nets
To be honest, I am a GG fan, but I don't think the GG head coach of cricket will work out. He is too honest for this role. It's like Kiran Bedi becoming the CM of Delhi, where being too honest doesn't work out
I get what you are saying but we need to nourish new player with evolving aggressive mindset of T20 for which gg is best
WRONG.
Same thing was guessed for Rahul Dravid for T20 coach, he being a test player, but he did wonders winning WC.
You cannot do guesses on GG role in cricket comparing with political CM role.
@@RameshKumar-ng3nf irony is that Rahul Dravid is test playe but he made team India agressive in bothe one day and t20
@@subhamsinghrajput6281 except for Rohit, where did you see aggressiveness, Kohli kept on stat padding every time
@@AdeeSesh except kholi all are aggressive players the reason for kholi to be subtle is becoz he is the playemaker of the team who rotates the game in time his nature is that of playemaker
Will Gambhir manage the bcci? That is the question, team India can win everything but the politics in BCCI is like any govt.
where is the politics? Can you specify few decisions or team selection which got affected by politics? They played so so well in ODI world cup, won Asia cup very convincingly, entered finals of both WTCs. They are not able to win finals but politics is not a factor behind the losses in finals.
@@shubhamkumar-gx5vx winning in home is easy than winning abroad, the politics by picking up dube over Rinku, there are 35+ associations under BCCI, they are interested in their own benifits, this is politics
@@shubhamkumar-gx5vxyou can see politics in on going wc .Jaiswal is legitimate opening batsman and fearless batter for T20 format version.
Suddenly after landing in usa Rohit along with bcci masters drops him and make Virat as opening partner and to accommodate their picks in middle orders.
Very open case..
Hope you agree on this. 👍
@@tseringangchok7540 your whole family was rigged
@@hmmer3471 yeah bro politics made sure that fatty Sharma is leading India in a T20 WC after ghosting the team in every T20WC since 2016😋
Need someone with vision , cricketing expertise and humility.
Someone who is willing to do what is right and not have a personal or a narrow agenda.
India needs another Rahul Dravid.
Gambhir appears to be opinionated; besides being a politician do you think he would fit the bill?
Is Dravid right choice
Is Ravi right choice
Is dada right choice
Is John wright Nice choice
Just like these all Gautam is also nice choice
You can judge his character by an incident that he has given up his 3cr I mean who leave thier money he is very responsible and he will be first to come forward if anything goes wrng best character for coach
Not about coach. Indian players need personal coaches
I don't think so that coach is that much of a issue but more about selecting player combinations, with so many options it has become very difficult to choose someone.
Bowling coach is the most important role right now for Indian cricket since we are transitioning towards young pacers because Ishant and Umesh are gone and Shami is ageing and suffering from injuries..
Along with Rahul Dravid Anil kumble is one of the best coach
This host is pretty knowledgeable unlike most others.
Do not think so, he is not a person who possesses skills in mentoring anyone. He will have Issues with the Senior Players. In the pst Kohli already had confrontation with him personally. Let us wait and see. ❤
No ,god forbid he's a moron, he's god forsaken kabhi muskurate dekha hain, we don't want a zombie as a coach, W.V.Raman is more suited, humane in approach, why ask kumble he himself was shown the door, team will be in tatters if Gambhir is appointed, don't know what jay shah is thinking
He's too serious too be a coach, with him the environment will always be intense, hence no.
With rahul dravid we played worldcup finals of all 3 formats..why change that..y changing coaches frequently..i wouldn't hv changed Dravid till champions trophy next years Personal opinion i don't think Gambhir is a right choice just few months before champions trophy..ego clashes on the way..
What has Rahul done?
I will appoint GM or Director for woman and men international team. And leave the coaching hiring to him. He will be supported by a private indian entity (corp) to get all info and do analysis.
He will have 4 year and can be extended 4 more years. We must mirror NFL in this respect. Selectors role is dummy. its honarary position. They will be informed of who is selected from which zone. They just sign off.
Gautam Gambhir will be disastrous! Coach should not have an ego larger than life! Gambhir is Ego personified!!
kick virat everything is fine, he is an egositic maniac because of whom we lost 2017 and 2019, due to favouritism selection, reason he never won big when he is in charge, be it ipl or india
@@rahul2820 ASS BURNING ?? NOW
Gambhir is not the right option as a coach of Indian cricket team. He has ego problems and little bit tempered. So he cannot balance the all things with seniors specially Rohit, Virat who played with him a few years ago. I think his political importance makes him motivated by BCCI to pick as the head coach of Indian cricket. But this is totally illogical I think. They must go for better options like Kumar Sangakara of Sri Lanka or VVS Laxman of India as the head coach of Indian cricket team. But they are just ruining Indian cricket by taking this kind of vulnerable decisions to pick Gambhir as head coach. This is not fair.
Coaching big team like india cant be handled by one person. It needs a director. not for all cricket in india . it need GM/Director of mens and womans international team. Ranji need its own director
BCCI must spend some moola. Need to develop a structure in that you minimize role of coach to small minimum.
Key for me is selectors. Now bcci pokes their nose in selection by appointing players from 4 zone. issue is not finding people from each zone. I get rid of selectors but apply zonal quota selection.
Now why get rid of selectors? Its unknown variable you are adding to equation. Meaning you get variable output.
You need to control the controllables. Selecting players and selecting pool of players. Its where people make money it seems
One of the reason india lagging behind australia. India keep selecting unathletic players out of 1.4billion indians
Let me explain something none of the indians or most humans unaware. Every word we speak some amount of truth and some amount lie. When people say Tall and Strong , they are not talking about Tall wimpy legs washington sundar or wimpy legs fast bowler. TALL but low center of gravity
Ricky Ponting would be my choice. Many ICC events winning captain. Gautam is too young for a coach.
He rejected the offer, said he can't leave his family for 10 months
DC ka halat dekha hain na ?
I think India should approach Jonathan Trott, he is the best in the world right now!!
Shadtri coaching was decent. DRAVID is terrible. Kumble was chaos king. He created sydney test fiasco. Kumble fights but he also fight against his own team. not good. HE HAD zero leadership skills.
Shashtri era looked good only because of the bowling coach Bharat Arun. But there was no consistency in selections and playing 11 at that time also. Virat-Shashtri couldn't build a strong enough team.
Appointing new coach will make no difference until the Captain and team structure are changed.
There should be white ball and red ball specialists. There should be debate on exploring a bowling captain as well and consider developing express bowling specialists.
Tje batting unit should be made to play atlesst 30% of their matches on challenging pitches and conditions too such as australia, south africa & england, rather than claiming comfort zone stats on flat belter IPL or domestic pitches.
The coaching pannel (head coach, bowling coach, fielding coach) should have flexibility along with team mgmt and selectors to influence captain's decision making esp if deemed arbitrary.
Performance reviews of central contracts should be basis recent performances and not archaic historical performances. More Credit should be given to performances in ICC world cups and performances in a winning cause esp in knock out matches of world cups. Stats and individual milestones should not be the only sekection criteria.
With old timers Kohli and Rohit still in the team, it will be a nightmarish experience for Gambhir as a coach.
Ravi & Dravid too have coached indian team for years, but in the leadership of Kohli and Rohit, have failed to get even a single ICC cup in any format for India since past 13 looong years, a shameful drought of wins at the world stage.
Yep alpha clash
The first step is seniors like Rohit, Virat, Jadeja voluntarily retiring from T20Is after this WC.
Second is grooming young pacers under an apt bowling coach like Bharat Arun.
Third is grooming a fast bowling all-rounder for Test cricket as well as white ball cricket..
The fourth is implementing the Australian way of playing cricket by having a strong plan against each and every player of the opposition team with data analytics.
If these 4 steps are seriously taken, India will soon win an ICC trophy. God also makes those win who are brave and do the hard yards.
@AyushRaj-rt6bb Few senior players in Indian cricket retire voluntarily. Many times, they have to be forced to do so.
Developing a group of talented express seamers would make sense only when the pitches are also made conducive - grass tops, supporting bounc & pace, lateral movement, etc. So far Indian cricket has been a batters only game playing on dead, flat, belter wickets most of the time. So whenever the batters play in testing conditions, e.g., Perth, Brisbane, Cape Town, Lord's, etc, they struggle.
As long as the benchmark for performance is going to be runs scored statistically on flat dead IPL wickets, Indian batters are going to struggle in overseas conditions including ICC world cups held overseas esp AUS, SA, ENG. India needs more bowlers like Bumrah who are accurate, consistent, have variations and create match winning impacts. India also needs a seam bowling Captain who can additionally focus on developing quality seam bowlers. Some examples of such bowlers in past and present have been Wasim Akram, Trent Bolt, Glen McGrath, Malcolm Marshall, Richard Hadlee, Mitchel Starc, James Anderson, Jasorit Bumrah etc. That is the benchmark- the benchmark should NOT be Siraj, Hardik, Avesh, Khaleel type of bowlers. Each seam bowler should be a match winning wicket taking bowler and myst have ability to bowl optimally on variety of surfaces, conditions, against bedt batters in the world (not just limited to IPL).
@@sgtaneja I think domestic cricket should have a variety of pitches. Green tops, Bouncy and pacy ones, turning tracks and some batting tracks as well..There should be balance between bat and ball.
Right now most pitches in domestic cricket are green tops with so much grass covering. The bowler has to do nothing but deliver the ball on right length and pitch will do the job. It seams too much and the ball keeps low most of the times. Such pitches promote mediocre medium pacers who bowl 120-130 and take a lot of wickets. Also such pitches dent the confidence of young batters who look to score runs. Such pitches are really degrading the quality of domestic cricket in India..
Coach job is just Enabler and inspirational figure. Who in india have that credential. For me coach should not be ex players. They bring their baggage to the team and kill the chemistry and create groupism
No never, Gautam Gambhir is poor coach
I was backing Stephen Fleming.
We need kumble replacement in test..
Gautam Sir is the best option 😍🙌🔥🔥
There should be two coaches. Let Gambhir take care of White ball formats.
Let somebody else handle Test cricket.
That should be the way forward.
This won’t workout
I don't think popular cricketers like Gambhir are interested for coaching job for Indian team. Throughout their career cricketers spent time away from family. If cricketers like Gambhir takes up coaching job for India then they can't spend time with their family. Retired cricketers have money why do they want to take up a difficult job and scarifies the time. For Gambhir time is more important then money or coaching job for India.
BCCI should look for other alternatives, for example two coaches for red ball and white ball cricket and hire lesser known retired indian cricketers.
Being popular or less known doesn't matter. The only thing that matters is the commitment and vision. GG has openly expressed his views about coaching the national side and he says it will be a matter of honour for him..
Please don’t pick, the guy has talent but mostly negative….
What negative? Because he had a fight with Virat? But Gambhir did not start this, he just replied to Virat in his own language.
No GG don't be a gud coach....the bcci want he to become bcz he directly send out Rohit and Virat frm T20 and maybe frm ODI also which BCCI can't do it direct. So this politics.Mark my word this gonna happen soon you can see changes frm Australia series he can't win test match
Not Gambhir at any cost
Ricky ponting should be the next Indian coach.
Anil sir 🎉 Rock and good coach 🎉
Gambhir is too Gambheer 😊
Ideally you want a foreign coach who can hire and fire but no one outside is quickly willing to do the job because of the politics involved. Kumble tried his best but didn't conform and was deposited by Shastri and Ko when he threw his toys out the pram. Partying and shopping abroad is more fun than knowing where your off stump is in swinging conditions. GG doesn't seem a bad call as he doesn't seem to be a yes man. It's time to dump some old furniture and bring in new blood
We need Gambhir
It should not be about being Indian or Foreign, it should be more about who will deliver the result positive. Ghambir as Indian coach it feels like Greg Chaplle 2.0
Why do you feel like that ? We can't decide the future of Indian cricket based on preconceived notions..
@@AyushRaj-rt6bb I hope I might be wrong but his action & behaviour might create problems in Team
@@anishs9699 I don't think so..
Stop defending players, team>>players, example australia is and will be best team beacuse they play like team while we fight if virat or rohit is better who cares who is better and who has what fan, they failed when they were given the chance to captain in golden genration of indian team. Time to pick player which plays for team win rather than individual scores, we need match winner not run machines who fails on grandest stage
This guy will be disastrous for Team India.
He's a CRAZY guy, PSYCHO.
No, he will create rifts within the team, just watch this space if he becomes
He's got a vision. I don't think he will create any rift. The seniors like Rohit, Kohli and Jadeja should retire from T20Is for the betterment of Indian cricket and everything will be fine..
@@AyushRaj-rt6bbThey will have to , doesn’t matter india will win t20 wc or not . Give chances to players like abhishek sharma, jaiswal, gill , rinku . atleast in t20 .
GAMBHIR WONT BE SUCESSFUL IN TEST HE IS JUST TOO IMPULSIVE .......YOU NEED MATURITY IN SUCH ROLES ,GAMBHIR IS TOO EMOTIONAL AND RATIONAL ......................HE IS OK IN T20 CRICKET ONLY
Broo you should check the knocks of gg in tests at his time how he played at the main situation patiently in the right time and held india draw that test match as we thought that india would lose the match he didn't take any decision as a player impulsively rather than he maintained the team and make sure that india would not lose that match
Not gambhir he has not got the finesse or communication skills
God no
Until i saw michael johnson 200m win 1996 atlanta olympics , i never thought about it. How come this guy is not huffing and puffing...his legs running his upper body looking around as though it was walk in the park. All us athlete take steroid. They only ban international teams , steroid rule never apply to USA. Everything is hedged if you play USA or even australia in cricket. They think alike.
India need to find LOW center of gravity tall players. Short legs Elongated Tall upper body.
Rahul Dravid did ok but is not enough of a coach . We need a foreign coach .
Otherwise we will not win ICC trophy for another 10 years ( we didn’t win a single one from 2014).
A tough foreign coach
This slave mentality is the reason for our downfall.
I am 100% against GAMBHIR as coach. But india left with no option. It shows JAY SHAH should not be involved in cricket. he had 6 month to find a coach. HE LAID egg and time runs out and end up Angry Dog Gambhir. No one can question patriotism of gambhir. Also his strategic acumen. BUT HE SHOULD NOT SPEAK. He has that sehwag foot in the mouth disease.
He has to be backroom enabler.
Why i dont like Gambhir then? Poor talent evaluator and recruiter. YOUNG players will be IGNORED completely under his regime. So i dont like him, I want 6-8 player under 25 all time.
Under his watch most players will be above 28.
Will he win? Only in India. Outside india . India cant win with Gambhir.
Because to win outside india you have to be tall . Its the context of being tall and effects of gravity on tall people.
As a short person he has no clue. To win against good team of australia , India should mirror them atleast 60%. That is hire Tall and strong and athletic players.
They infuse Energy into the team. I hate OLDIES.
Ishaant sharma ke cousins ko lelo sab. For someone writing such a long thread you do not add anything of value in the comments.
@@alfredo12419 Social media comments are just for tickle
Gg the best..
I consider it is a stupid idea to have the same coach all formats of the game. Gambhir would make a very good coach in T20, a good coach in ODIs and much lesser in 5day Tests.
Varun Aron is pretty smart. Didn’t know he was this cricket smart