Japanese Lugers - Real or Urban Myth?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 29 сен 2024

Комментарии • 444

  • @Franky46Boy
    @Franky46Boy Год назад +351

    Most 'Japanese' Lugers I have seen were of Dutch origin, captured in the Dutch East Indies.
    And some were recaptured by American Marines on Guadalcanal...
    In fact, Ian of 'Forgotten Weapons' posted a movie yesterday about a museum on that island where many 'Japanese' items are shown that were found on the island over the years.
    To his surprise he discovered many weapons of the Dutch colonial army (KNIL) in that museum, among these a couple of Dutch Lugers!
    Even during the Vietnam War, US forces encountered some Dutch KNIL Lugers in the hands of Vietcong fighters!
    None of the KNIL Lugers had the lug to attach a shoulder stock, but had a grip safety...

    • @nicholasvaneyk4565
      @nicholasvaneyk4565 Год назад +31

      I was just about to bring up Ian's video haha

    • @hippiesaboteur2556
      @hippiesaboteur2556 Год назад +23

      Yep, me too. I watched it just yesterday as well. Interesting timing on these two videos, and both incredibly well done!

    • @henryturnerjr3857
      @henryturnerjr3857 Год назад +12

      You guys beat me to it!

    • @Yeoman7
      @Yeoman7 Год назад +10

      The ones found (dug up 80yrs later) on Guadalcanal were Dutch East Indies .

    • @alt7488
      @alt7488 Год назад +13

      gun jesus is always on the pulse .....

  • @lanceday13
    @lanceday13 Год назад +10

    The Forgotten Weapons / Mark Felton subscriber Venn diagram is probably just a circle 🙂 Time for a collab surely??

  • @theforcedmeme
    @theforcedmeme Год назад +2

    A Mark Felton and Forgotten Weapons colab would be cool sometime

  • @mitchmatthews6713
    @mitchmatthews6713 Год назад +5

    A great Sunday morning history lesson! Thank you, Mark!

  • @Mandalore_Space_Marines
    @Mandalore_Space_Marines Год назад +39

    Fun fact: after the Japanese surrender, a couple of captured dutch lugers and papa nambu pistol fell into the hands of Indonesian nationalist when they seize Japanese arms depots. General Soedirman, the Commander of Indonesian forces fighting the Dutch, personnaly has a dutch M. 11 as his personal sidearms.

    • @allangibson8494
      @allangibson8494 Год назад +3

      A significant part of the Indonesian nationalist forces actually consisted of Japanese troops who didn’t surrender…

    • @kimwit1307
      @kimwit1307 Год назад +2

      @@allangibson8494 And the nationalists got a lot of their weapons and ammunition from the Japanese, who rather gave it to them than to the allied forces.

    • @Mandalore_Space_Marines
      @Mandalore_Space_Marines Год назад +1

      @@allangibson8494
      Wow, really?! I never learned about that in school here in Indonesia, do you mind giving me the link? I want to read it for myself.

  • @ФилиппЛыков-д8е
    @ФилиппЛыков-д8е Год назад +1

    5:51 The 1908 Luger missed grip safety while the manual safety switch operated in reverse with respect to earlier modifications. Shown at 5:51 is a P06 "New" model, still with grip safety but with a coil main spring instead of a laminated one.

  • @waltie1able
    @waltie1able Год назад +3

    Magnificent pistol, still available in conservative states within the US at a high price. Field stripping this pistol is difficult.

  • @FINNIUSORION
    @FINNIUSORION Год назад +2

    Legacy collectibles has a very in depth lugar history/ collector's guide on RUclips. And of course he's mentioned Felton on at least one occasion I can remember.

  • @garymckee8857
    @garymckee8857 Год назад +2

    And a good Sunday morning to everyone 😊

    • @fn2s145
      @fn2s145 Год назад +1

      Good Morning!!

  • @fraiday7292
    @fraiday7292 Год назад +1

    Great video, as if that's a surprise. I never knew that Vickers made Lugers.

  • @SpliefDaGrief
    @SpliefDaGrief Год назад +1

    Discovered today that Norinco made two Luger prototypes for sale in the US market.
    Very unfortunately, it never came into mass production. The two prototypes did make it into the US and are currently in the private collections of two lucky individuals

  • @nodarkthings
    @nodarkthings Год назад

    Absolutely fascinating, Dr. Felton. Thank you.

  • @Quadrenaro
    @Quadrenaro Год назад

    Hearing Mark Felton say, "Wauser," has made my day.

  • @nigeh5326
    @nigeh5326 Год назад +8

    So we have
    A German designed 9mm pistol that post WW1 was copied and built by the British for the Dutch who then had them taken by the Japanese who then had them taken by Americans as war booty back to the United States, wow quite a story 👍
    Thanks Dr Felton for a v interesting and informative video.

    • @derekp2674
      @derekp2674 Год назад +1

      I think Vickers Ltd acted as an intermediary because German manufacturers could not sell Lugers for export post-WW1. Hence I think Vickers imported the parts from Germany and then assembled the pistols for the Dutch contract.
      During the 1970s, I sometimes saw batches of un-blued Luger parts offered for sale in the UK - these may have been squirrelled away by Vickers in anticipation of further sales.

  • @devildog4684
    @devildog4684 Год назад

    Thank you again for precious information only Dr felton can produce

  • @petewarrell3734
    @petewarrell3734 Год назад

    Another good one Mark
    👍👋🇨🇦

  • @chuckhaggard1584
    @chuckhaggard1584 Год назад

    Ian at Forgotten Weapons just did a video on battlefield relics recovered on Guadalcanal, there were at least two of the Dutch Lugers shown in that video.

  • @crownprincesebastianjohano7069
    @crownprincesebastianjohano7069 Год назад +1

    I bought a nice DWM Luger after my first deployment. As great an historical piece it was, I was not fond of firing it. It is heavy and prone to jamming even with lots of TLC. I sold it. The P38 and Walther PP are more fun to shoot.

  • @firstname2853
    @firstname2853 Год назад

    Go on Dr Feltzie giving us more great history thanks for the excellent videos sir.

  • @marioacevedo5077
    @marioacevedo5077 Год назад

    Great video. As always, well researched and very educational.

  • @Bob-gl6cg
    @Bob-gl6cg Год назад +1

    I have a Honest German Luger given to me by my Uncle, he took it from a Jap on Guadalcanal, dated 1918 There are no Japanese markings on it. I also have a picture of him holding the gun while standing next to a captured Japanese flag.

  • @eddiesimone3568
    @eddiesimone3568 Год назад +1

    Nice picture of Dutch marines in the water, with their pistols drawn. These guys didn't belong to the KNIL (Royal Dutch Indies Army), I know because they have Navy shoulder patches, as our marines still have.

  • @mcgoon8027
    @mcgoon8027 Год назад

    Thank you. This is really helpful

  • @samrodian919
    @samrodian919 Год назад

    Very interesting Mark. I had no idea whatsoever that Vickers had made copies of the Luger. Thank you for enlightening me. I will have to look in my Luger book.

    • @kevinoliver3083
      @kevinoliver3083 9 месяцев назад

      The Vickers Lugers were assembled and proofed in the UK. But the parts were made in Germany by DWM.
      The two companies had had been close since 1896 when DWM was founded to build Maxim Guns for the Imperial German Navy.

  • @shawnwhite2120
    @shawnwhite2120 Год назад

    That was a nice Father’s Day surprise thank you , happy Father’s Day

  • @ryanthompsonthompson820
    @ryanthompsonthompson820 Год назад +1

    I love this series 😃

  • @johnk1639
    @johnk1639 Год назад

    Unrelated, I wonder if you have/could cover operation aerial. I was reading about it and it’s a really interesting event

  • @kimwit1307
    @kimwit1307 Год назад

    As a dutchman I am surprised by this nugget of knowledge.

  • @tokencivilian8507
    @tokencivilian8507 Год назад

    Forgotten Weapons just had a video from a museum on Guadalcanal. This museum is of finds from the jungle - just about everything is rusted, bent and broken to a greater or lesser degree. Ian showed one of the Dutch Lugers that was found, with that brass unit plate.

  • @justinramos740
    @justinramos740 Год назад +3

    Literally just got here

  • @Fraxx
    @Fraxx Год назад +2

    Hi mark, great content as usual. Was wondering if you could do some research on one of my family members, my aunty married him 20ish years after world war 2 I believe, Kennedy Burnside from melbourne, a surgeon and POW from changy. He used a secret camera and took photos, stashed them in a artilliary shell and burried them for it to be dug up post ww2

  • @marks1638
    @marks1638 Год назад

    In a related video (posted several days ago) by Ian McCullum (Forgotten Weapons), he's in a museum in Guadalcanal set up by the locals made up of battlefield pickups from after the war up to present day. Among them are several Lugers from the Dutch military (with the brass plates about the only thing you can read off the guns) and a quite a selection of other firearms (captured during the initial Japanese successes in the war) besides the standard American and Japanese weapons.

  • @patrickmurray9409
    @patrickmurray9409 Год назад

    My dad's uncle, my great uncle Pete. He was in the pacific during ww2. His only souvenir was a German bayonet. So if they used lugers, a good possibility.

  • @masahige2344
    @masahige2344 Год назад

    It’s worth noting that the Japanese Navy used a series of contract Mauser rifles to make up small arms shortfall in 1937-38, these being the K98k, Standardmodell, and VZ. 24. There were also numerous other German-copied aircraft weapons, such as the Type 97/1 copies of the MG15. Re: the Chrysanthemum, it was applied to the foreign rifles used for service from 1874-1880s, but not thereafter. It’s also notable that many of the captured Dutch weapons stayed in ex-KNIL hands when they were rearmed as Heiho and Giyugun auxiliaries, including the famous Pembelah Tanah Air.

  • @shawnr771
    @shawnr771 Год назад

    Thank you for the lesson.

  • @Roverflyover
    @Roverflyover Год назад

    I think that there are Lugers on display in a Guadalcanal museum

  • @randomcoyote8807
    @randomcoyote8807 Год назад

    Great video! I am curious about the long barrel Lugers issued to the German Navy; I understand that long barrel Lugers with buttstocks were issued to land forces for Sturmtruppen units to storm trenches, but what was the rationale for issuing long-barrel Lugers to Naval units?
    The only reason I can think of was because Naval crews (especially on U-boats) had limited space to store firearms and a long-barrel Luger with a buttstock gave a bit more "rifle-ish" performance without the storage demands, but that's all I can think of.

    • @kevinoliver3083
      @kevinoliver3083 9 месяцев назад +1

      When the German Navy adopted the Luger in 1906 they specified an effective range of 200m. So their pistols had a 150mm barrel.
      The German Army expected pistols to be used only at shorter ranges so had a 100mm barrel on their 1908 pistols.
      It was later that the artillery decided that carbines were too cumbersome. And asked for a long (200mm) barrelled pistol with a detachable stock to arm their gunners.

  • @scottscott4674
    @scottscott4674 Год назад

    Wish my dad had hung on to his German officer's Luger. Traded it for a French resistance pistol.

  • @wadeguidry6675
    @wadeguidry6675 Год назад

    My first squirt gun was a transparent green luger.

  • @craxd1
    @craxd1 Год назад

    You should do a video about what occurred at FN in Belgium, where POWs were used. They sabotaged many, and the pistols could blow up in your hand. I don't know if anything like that occurred at Mauser or Walther. Saying this, I believe that I would have preferred the Walther P-38 during the war, especially over it being a double-automatic similar to how a revolver's action works.

    • @HootOwl513
      @HootOwl513 Год назад +1

      I knew a Navy Captain, whose admiral brother gave him a Czech-made PPK. [The brother had been in the ETO.] It was beautifully finished, but he was afraid to shoot it, as it was probably made with slave labor and could well have been sabotaged.

  • @EnterpriseXI
    @EnterpriseXI Год назад +1

    I’m sure the fake Japanese markings one those Lugers greatly devalued them

  • @davidbell5528
    @davidbell5528 Год назад +1

    ruclips.net/video/PzKEQoKQtvI/видео.html shows a couple of dutch/japanese lugers on Guadacanal

  • @waltmex6099
    @waltmex6099 Год назад

    Io possiedo una DWM 1916 matricola 385 olandese con il crest perfetto giapponese e la canna è con i caratteri giapponesi, certamente rifatta in una fabbrica in Giappone..qualità elevata e non certo copia per imbrogliare gli acquirenti...

  • @stevejorgensen5274
    @stevejorgensen5274 Год назад +316

    I have a Russian NCOs nagant revolver that my Dad traded for in the late 40s. My Dad was WWII vet army and army Air Corp. The story he got with it was the vet had taken it off a dead German. Feel sorry for the German. Survived the eastern front only to get kill on the western front. As always great video.

    • @Mr_Fancypants
      @Mr_Fancypants Год назад +22

      Might aswel be the German was issued the gun.
      Late war Germany was using everything they could.

    • @Rustythemouse
      @Rustythemouse Год назад +5

      @@Mr_Fancypants Except they were not the WW2 FPS type on the eastern front.
      Lacked simple pistols of their own, so they not only late war but always used captured pistols.
      For example in the Hungarian Army my own grandpa owned a 37M pistol, this pistol was a high price bartel at the Germans.

    • @drvonschwartz
      @drvonschwartz Год назад +1

      K

    • @drakron
      @drakron Год назад +9

      @@Mr_Fancypants Yes but also no.
      The problem is that weapons need ammunition and you cannot just take a Thompson M1928A1 that uses .45 as Germany only used the .45 with the Kongsberg Colt that were Norwegian produced Model 1911 Colt, German did gain the MP 34 from Austria but they were re-barrelled to chamber 9×19mm ammunition.
      The standard German ammunition was 9×19mm Parabellum for automatic pistols and submachine guns and 7.92×57mm Mauser for rifles, meanwhile the Red Army used the 7.62×54mmR for riles and machine guns as well the 7.62×25mm Tokarev for rifles leading to being incompatible with their own ammo supply stock if either side tried to use their enemy weapons.
      And if you dont have the ammo a German weapon is as perfectly fine as a Russian one, Germany would not "supply" their own troops weapons they had no ammunition for, the Nagant M1895 uses 7.62×38mmR ... I have no idea were that German got the gun but he wouldnt have much of ammunition for it on the Western Front.

    • @JohnTitor20361
      @JohnTitor20361 Год назад +3

      Poor guy :-(

  • @coreys2686
    @coreys2686 Год назад +82

    Forgotten Weapons just did a video that had Lugers in it.
    A Japanese garrison unit from the Dutch East Indies was sent to Guadalcanal as reinforcements. They brought Dutch Lugers with them.
    There's a museum in the capital on Guadalcanal where every piece is recovered comes to.
    In addition to the 10 tons of live ordinance that gets found and disposed of every year, there are literal tons of small arms recovered from the jungle.
    Ian recorded two Lugers, one definitely had the Dutch unit plaque on the left side of pistol.

    • @remko1238
      @remko1238 Год назад +2

      @ Corey S saw it too 🙌🏾

    • @micumatrix
      @micumatrix Год назад +1

      just wanted to post the same :)

  • @john-pauljones878
    @john-pauljones878 Год назад +49

    Great content Mark. Always a must watch

    • @4strokesarejokes
      @4strokesarejokes Год назад +2

      Absolutely. Dr Felton's content, no matter the topic is always light-years above similar channels. Top tier almost seems an understatement.

  • @chlebowg
    @chlebowg Год назад +15

    Ian on Forgotten Weapons just reported couple of the captured Dutch M.11s found on Guadalcanal just a few days ago. Japanese unit was known to have come from the Dutch East Indies and transferred to the Canal. Couple of Dutch carbines and Madsen LMGs with short barrel

  • @hughgordon6435
    @hughgordon6435 Год назад +6

    Think it was "Forgotten weapons" just a couple of days ago who explained luger finds in Guadalcanal? Dutch eastindies troops,

  • @1DoctorMoo
    @1DoctorMoo Год назад +48

    Thank you for this video. Growing up my best friend's Father, a veteran of the Pacific Campaign, showed us a pistol he brought back from the war. I only saw it that one time and my friend always called it a Luger. I've often wondered if it was or if it was actually a Nambu. That's over 40 years ago. However, your video has confirmed that Lugers were indeed used by the Japanese. Thank you.

  • @romanbrough
    @romanbrough Год назад +10

    Ian of Forgotten Weapons has recently done a video of a museum in Guadalcanal that has loads and loads of weapons and other WW2 stuff. Dutch lugers in plenty.

  • @JamesThomas-gg6il
    @JamesThomas-gg6il Год назад +73

    That faked mum mark on that luger is certainly well done. Unless you know exactly what is being offered or have paperwork to back up anything, always buy the gun at a price for the gun, not the story. As we can see, someone took a thousand dollar luger, ruined it by altering it, and probably sold it to some unweary buyer for 5 thousand or more. Thank for showing this, Mark.

    • @enscroggs
      @enscroggs Год назад +6

      The uneven bluing is a giveaway that ought to alert a buyer that something is fishy. That area just forward of the toggle was frequently used for some type of authentic and legitimate marking, so engraving or stamping that fake imperial chrysanthemum meant filing off quite a bit of original metal along with the deep rust bluing applied by the DWM factory. Then there were a number proofing stamps and other markings to file off or obscure.
      However, the gun is far from ruined. There are many gun collectors who prefer to collect fakery or bizarre copies like the so-called Chinese mystery pistols of the warlord era. A "Wauser" in good condition is worth more these days than an authentic "Red 9" in a similar state of preservation.

    • @JamesThomas-gg6il
      @JamesThomas-gg6il Год назад +4

      @@enscroggs oh I get it. Like mis prints and such. I just can't see spending above and beyond a typical luger price. Yes its neat, but the real collector value is ruined.

  • @FrenchTaunter12
    @FrenchTaunter12 Год назад +28

    Just a few days ago Forgotten Weapons uploaded a video showing a museum on Guadacanal dedicated to the battle fought there. The museum exhibits one of the dutch Lugers found on the island. The weapon is in pretty poor condition, but the brass plate is still readable.

    • @Franky46Boy
      @Franky46Boy Год назад +5

      There were a couple of Dutch Lugers visible in that movie... or what remained of them.
      Also a number of Dutch KNIL M95 Steyr/Hembrug Mannlicher carbines in 6.5 mm Dutch.
      I knew the Japanese captured a lot of these carbines in the Dutch East Indies and issued them to Indonesian auxiliary forces, but carrying them (and the different ammo!) all the way to Guadalcanal?

    • @roykliffen9674
      @roykliffen9674 Год назад +1

      beat me to it 😄

  • @SteveM-ly7oy
    @SteveM-ly7oy Год назад +4

    I know it's totally unrelated, but I've just seen a photo of a Ukrainian soldier using a Russian PM 1910 heavy machine gun, in an image from today's Guardian. Amazing. Still in use.

    • @selfdo
      @selfdo Год назад

      It'll still SHOOT, and that's what COUNTS. Both sides have busted out old T-54 and T-55 tanks and have sent them into action. I believe both the Ukrainians, and the Russians, at their Uralvagonzavod factory, have refitted T-55s with modern fire-control and communications gear, and have stuffed the 2A46 125 mm gun into that already-cramped turret. The engine powering those beasts is, I believe, an uprated version of the original v2 12-cylinder ALUMINUM diesel engine that powered T-34 tanks during the "Great Patriotic War".

  • @derek-press
    @derek-press Год назад +11

    my Granndad told me this many moons.ago (RIP granddad Bill ),he was in North Africa artillery for 4 and a half years and was de-mobbed but his "return home ship" was diverted to Scilly,he was then put in a camp next to the Canadians where he said they shared rations and it was the best food he had eaten in 4 years and he at some point he said he bought a German luger from a Canadian guy but when he finally was put on a ship back to blighty they confiscated it..I'm pretty sure that luger ended up in some RN officer's cellar

  • @bobhill3941
    @bobhill3941 Год назад +13

    Very interesting and informative as always. This is a great companion piece to the Forgotten Weapons video on Chinese Lugers and Warlord pistols.

  • @wayneantoniazzi2706
    @wayneantoniazzi2706 Год назад +21

    Great and interesting video Doctor Felton, and you did Luger collectors a real service by pointing out the "Mum" marking on a Luger is fake. You've probably saved a lot of people some serious money and embarassment, although not the embarassment for those who've already been stung!
    I've handled both Lugers and Nambu pistols and quality-wise there's no comparison. The Nambu's serviceable but that's as far as it goes so it's no surprise a Japanese officer of means would purchase a Luger if he could afford one. The disadvantage would be the 9mm cartridge fired by the Luger since it wasn't Japanese standard and the officer would have to buy as much as he thought he might need before deploying. The fact ammunition for the Nambu would be much easier to obtain would more than likely have a bigger influence on a Japanese officer's purchase decision than patriotism would, at least in my opinion.

    • @slcpunk2740
      @slcpunk2740 Год назад +2

      Do you really think officers are firing so many rounds from their pistol that they can't buy enough up front? This is a sidearm and they're officers. If they can afford a Luger I'm sure they can afford some ammo for it.

    • @LD-Orbs
      @LD-Orbs Год назад +3

      (Scratching my head over "mum", before realizing it's short for "chrysanthemum"!)
      Sorry, slow on the uptake! 🙃

    • @genericpersonx333
      @genericpersonx333 Год назад +3

      @@slcpunk2740 They also have to CARRY said ammunition with them, which means space in their luggage and much of the time for the Imperial Japanese Army, that means their own bodies as they didn't always have trucks, pack animals, and/or porters to carry things for them.
      So while any officer could carry a few rounds of 9mm for their immediate use, they'd not always be free to carry enough for practice or a long campaign, whereas they could just ask the quartermaster for a fresh box of 8mm every now and then.
      Also the issue of armorers being trained on the Japanese weapons, not so much the foreign ones. If one's Luger had a problem, one couldn't be sure the armorer could fix it for him like he could if he brought a Type 14 or similar pistol.

    • @wayneantoniazzi2706
      @wayneantoniazzi2706 Год назад +2

      @@LD-Orbs "Mum" is a LOT easier to spell too! Which is why nurseries and flower shops spell it that way. Mum takes up a LOT less space on signage as well! 😉

    • @wayneantoniazzi2706
      @wayneantoniazzi2706 Год назад +2

      @@slcpunk2740 I didn't say that, you completely misunderstood. If an officer bought a Luger and all the ammunition for it he thought he might need that's ALL the ammo he was going to have when he deployed to wherever, there'd be no easy resupply. That means no shooting for fun or showing off, he'd have to save what he had for when he really needed it especially if he was an officer of lower rank like an infantry platoon or company commander.
      Were you ever in the service yourself?

  • @r2gelfand
    @r2gelfand Год назад +22

    Keep up the great work Mark, as a avid gun collector, I learned a lot today!

  • @TheFlutecart
    @TheFlutecart Год назад +5

    American soldiers would find these and sometimes accidentally shoot themselves with it because they were not trained with it. Although heavier, the 1911 pistol was the best semi-auto pistol of WW2. A darn near perfect design by Mr. Browning. That pistol and his Browning M2 .50 cal machine gun are still very common in militaries today.

  • @QuantumPyrite_88.9
    @QuantumPyrite_88.9 Год назад +21

    Another well researched and edited documentary which only Dr. Felton can produce . Thank You once again and all the best.

  • @wes11bravo
    @wes11bravo Год назад +14

    My hopeful preconceptions about being able to smugly list sources for Japanese Lugers in the comments were dashed by this excellent video - you even provided avenues I hadn't considered. Thanks once again for the education, Mark. All the best from Pittsburgh USA.

  • @chrismichael6048
    @chrismichael6048 Год назад +7

    In a movie Letters from Iwojima directed by Clint Eastwood and starring Ken Watanabe,there is a scene of General Kuribayashi receiving M1911 pistol as a parting gift from a group of US commanders and he gladly used the M1911 as a sidearm in his final last stand in the Battle of Iwojima。

  • @docnoc66
    @docnoc66 Год назад +142

    My father was a World War II vet posted in the Philippines in New Guinea and brought back a Nambu pistol, dated pre-war 1937 with the cleaning kit and holster and a certificate when he entered the San Francisco, allowing him to own the piece. It is quite valuable.

    • @guyfawkesuThe1
      @guyfawkesuThe1 Год назад

      Who says they are valuable? Too me they are only valuable if they came off a dead Jap.

    • @noway57
      @noway57 Год назад +1

      Own it? He had it.

    • @partridgepimp3363
      @partridgepimp3363 Год назад +3

      Not pre war for Japan

    • @docnoc66
      @docnoc66 Год назад +1

      @@noway57 yes my brother has it

    • @jwhiskey242
      @jwhiskey242 Год назад +1

      @@noway57 He needed a paper from his unit so he could bring the gun home.

  • @sid2112
    @sid2112 Год назад +3

    Well I have one in my desk, so I know for a fact they did :)

  • @brianjschumer
    @brianjschumer Год назад +10

    My dad had brought back an awesome Walther PP from Europe during WW2..Originally 8thAAF, had a cushy time as a training instructor in Miami, later transfered to Anti tank miner group, one of those guys with a metal detector who walks in front of the tank, for a few extra bucks. Send over after bulge push, came back on a hospital ship and ended up at Walter Reed. I didnt think much of the Walther as kid, but used to see it in a drawer from time to time..fast foward years later, my dad now moved to Fla, now into guns, i asked him what happened to the old Walther, no answer, after a few months passed i asked again..my father finally said he sold it..me saying, but i wanted it, how much did you get for it..his reply was..it wasnt about the money, it was about looking at it, i felt like using it..never talked about it again..

    • @LD-Orbs
      @LD-Orbs Год назад

      Understood. Smart - and brave - father!

  • @chiphailstone589
    @chiphailstone589 Год назад +2

    I personally bought owned a .30 cal DMW Luger my old WWII Pacific Vet friend, JR Ruben, brought home from Burma along with a very nice Katana, and an issued Shin Gunto (SP?) sword in 1946.
    He got them after the surrender from his airfeild where the Japanese had disarmed and camped.
    Sadly, I had to sell it due to family needs along with the Katana

  • @stc3145
    @stc3145 Год назад +10

    British Webley revolvers have also been found in Japan or on Japanese battlefields. Likely also private purchases or captured models.

    • @matthewlok3020
      @matthewlok3020 Год назад +1

      They would more likely be captured ones than bought in private by an individual officer

    • @kirbyculp3449
      @kirbyculp3449 Год назад

      Probably from the surrender of Singapore.

    • @karlheinzvonkroemann2217
      @karlheinzvonkroemann2217 Год назад

      Could be either one or both! How many British small arms were captured just on Singapore?

    • @karlheinzvonkroemann2217
      @karlheinzvonkroemann2217 Год назад

      @@kirbyculp3449 Certainly very possible.

    • @kirbyculp3449
      @kirbyculp3449 Год назад

      @@karlheinzvonkroemann2217
      I am unsure of the amount of small arms. According to the National Museum of Australia 130,000 troops surrendered. So amount guns should be commensurate. That is a heck of a lot.

  • @JonHanzoII
    @JonHanzoII Год назад +4

    in 2005 I obtained a Colt Browning model MG38BT .30 CAL BMG receiver on a table at a gun show in of all places Brisbane, Australia for fifty dollars.
    Receiver had been cut in half.
    Turns out only about one thousand were ever made, a contract for the Dutch East Indies in WW2, so it is quiet rare.
    I had it welded back together, fitted some standard 1919A4 parts, and now it is a nice deactivated display piece on a 1919A4 tripod.

    • @rpm12091
      @rpm12091 Год назад

      There will be a loud knock on your door very soon.

    • @JonHanzoII
      @JonHanzoII Год назад +3

      @@rpm12091 I forgot to mention, I also registered it with the police, and as I had a licence allowing me to possess MGs, I was allowed to keep it , so long as I obtained a deactivation certificate, and it remained deactivated.

  • @diegoferreiro9478
    @diegoferreiro9478 Год назад +5

    Recently I watched a Forgotten Weapons video where Ian MacCollum did the walkaround of a military museum in Guadalcanal (where war debris keep on surfacing today).
    I don't recall seeing any Luger but Dutch rifles were present and at least one ZB.26 LMG. According to Ian, at least one specific Japanese unit was fully equiped with captured Dutch hardware, so it is not unlikely that some Japanese Luger shows up sooner or later there.

  • @opencarry3860
    @opencarry3860 Год назад +6

    The Japanese produce very well made firearms. The new Winchester 1873 lever actions are made by Miruko in Japan for Winchester.

    • @wes11bravo
      @wes11bravo Год назад +4

      Agree - one of the shotguns I sold after my dad died that I should have kept was a Japanese made Browning over/under 12 gauge - absolutely beautifully made.

    • @wayneantoniazzi2706
      @wayneantoniazzi2706 Год назад +3

      For a brief time in the 1970s and into the 1980s Miroku also made Brown Bess replicas. Pretty well done too, in fact they were slightly more authentic than the Italian Pedersoli made ones being a bit more massive. Put an Italian Bess next to a real one and you can spot the difference. The only downside to the Miroku Besses were the cast springs, they were more prone to breakage than the forged springs on the Pedersoli ones.

    • @wayneantoniazzi2706
      @wayneantoniazzi2706 Год назад +1

      @@wes11bravo It's too bad a lot of traditionalists turned up their noses at the Miroku Brownings saying the Belgian made ones were better. Not so, the Miroku made ones were absolutely just as good, they just didn't have the "cachet" of the Belgian ones.

  • @GenerationKill001
    @GenerationKill001 Год назад +3

    Forgotten Weapons just put out a video from Guadalcanal where in a scrap museum he found one of those brass plaque lugers.

  • @davidschlienz9395
    @davidschlienz9395 Год назад +5

    Growing up, I found out that my neighbor served with the 1st Cavalry Division as an MP. As he was retired, I would go over and help him in his garage. One day, he pulled down his foot locker and spoke to me about his service in the Philippines and then later as part of the occupation of Japan. I remember him showing me a Dutch Luger he had salvaged from a Japanese armory that was set up in a tiny building about 500sq feet. As I was looking at it, I remember seeing a crown on it, but not a "Vickers" stamp or a brass plate. But, that was over 45 years ago.

  • @whydoyougottahavthis
    @whydoyougottahavthis Год назад +7

    As a fellow legit historian, I'd like you to do a video discussing what the Axis, and troops like Japanese thought about and did with war souvenirs and trophy's, because we only look at it from a Western eventual win scenario, when in reality for several summers the Axis was the ones bringing back captured stuff, and itd be interesting to know their views and outcomes

  • @IIDeCkArDII1
    @IIDeCkArDII1 Год назад +3

    ...Guid Efternain Mark...I work in a store in Perth up here in Scotland and while helping an elderly customer with a paint choice he'd made we started chatting about life in general (his wife rolled her eyes knowing what was coming next) and he showed me a photo of a flag with a Swastika and a gold eagle on it (random I know) I wondered where the conversation was going but apparently his Father (who'd fought in WW2) had taken it from Reichsmarschall Herman Goering's boat Carin II. I remember watching your video on the Carin II and letting him know he could view your channel here on YT. He told me he'd donated it to a military museum and produced a newspaper cutting showing himself the flag and an accompanying piece relating to his donation. It had an upstanding Swastika with a gold Reichsadler in the top right corner. I don't know if his info was correct as it looked very much like a Reich service flag but the gold Reichsadler had me thinking he was genuine?

  • @nbroadarrowz
    @nbroadarrowz Год назад +2

    Dutch Lugars were officially issued to some RNZAF units in NZ during WW2. These were brought back from the Dutch East Indies.
    Barry

  • @krisfrederick5001
    @krisfrederick5001 Год назад +3

    I still find it endlessly ironic, that Hitler shot himself with a British Walther and not a Luger. Ace as always Mark Felton Productions

    • @krtacct
      @krtacct Год назад +3

      British Walther?

    • @chkoha6462
      @chkoha6462 Год назад +3

      What is a British Walther pistol?

  • @firstcynic92
    @firstcynic92 Год назад +4

    In case you hadn't seen it, Ian from the Forgotten Weapons channel posted a video of his tour of a Guadalcanal museum with lots of WW2 guns. There were quite a few Dutch made guns as well.
    ruclips.net/video/PzKEQoKQtvI/видео.html

  • @AudieHolland
    @AudieHolland Год назад +7

    As a kid, I used to have small Luger replica that looked just perfect.
    From then on, I have always thought of the Luger as the perfect looking handgun.
    Later on, I also became fascinated by the Colt 1911, mainly through comics like 'The Spirit' by Will Eisner
    which was funny because the 1911 is the exact opposite of the Luger in that you don't even see the barrel when it's not firing.
    The Luger on the other hand, is all barrelly perfection.

  • @josephbingham1255
    @josephbingham1255 Год назад +3

    Great details and photos. A fellow down the road has a Mauser rifle that belonged to his father. Wehrmacht eagle stamps but also Chinese or Japanese characters stamped onto it.

  • @larrylongprong5219
    @larrylongprong5219 Год назад +7

    Great video, can see a lot of research went into this one! 👍

  • @warwarneverchanges4937
    @warwarneverchanges4937 Год назад +2

    2:45 $1 in 1920 ($13 today)between wars luger, take my money sir

  • @samking7213
    @samking7213 Год назад +6

    Brilliant content Mark. I certainly learn something in all your videos. I'm not sure if you have done a video on this topic or not, I used to own a Portuguese Mauser 1906 in 8mm. I certainly miss that rifle. Mine was picked up in the Timor area by Australian forces during WW2. I also believe that a heap of them were used in South Africa. Brilliant, accurate and well made bit of kit.

  • @jp18449
    @jp18449 Год назад +2

    The video by Ian from Forgotten weapons uploaded just 2 days ago shows they were real.

  • @voctur
    @voctur Год назад +3

    Forgotten Weapons recently made a video about a museum in Guadalcanal, and among their collection they had plenty of captured Dutch weapons used by the japanese that were found on that battlefield. Among those a Dutch Luger.

  • @thedoc8679
    @thedoc8679 Год назад +2

    I am loving these axis weapons series!

  • @Nick_B_Bad
    @Nick_B_Bad Год назад +2

    I’ve got an FN1910 rig that was shipped to Japan by Schroeder Brothers in 1939 and just sold a nice Japanese holster for a Mauser 14/34. I was surprised when I started seeing how many non-Japanese produced pistols ended up being used by the Japanese officers.

  • @manuelroca5289
    @manuelroca5289 Год назад +4

    Thank you so much for this and many historical videos you post. I'm writing a spy novel and this video gives me ideas about the theme. Keep it coming! 😊

  • @richardshiggins704
    @richardshiggins704 Год назад +2

    Marvellous details even when involving the more arcane aspects of WW2 .

  • @jamescrossland2599
    @jamescrossland2599 Год назад +1

    My brother mainly collected 'American Civil War'/antebellum items....but has many WW1-2, Russian n Ukrainian war items. 1 being a Ukrainian Soviet upper classed officer w/(medals 🥇 attached ) uniform jacket 🧥 the family gave him when he married into the family in Ukraine. I remember the man was crying w/pride when he gave it to my brother......the whole family was around. ( It was a big deal.) ...n reminded that the Ukrainian people are still HIGHLY saddened w/Russia today for the atrocious wars past n' present. 😢

  • @alexandersmall7380
    @alexandersmall7380 Год назад +1

    It is common knowledge that every American and allied soldier was going after Lugers and katanas, but what trophies or souvenirs did the Axis forces go after?

  • @paintedblue1791
    @paintedblue1791 Год назад +1

    Link to Forgotten Weapons where you can see actual recovered Dutch Luger pistols with brass plate.
    Fascinating Finds in a Guadalcanal Relic Museum
    ruclips.net/video/PzKEQoKQtvI/видео.html

  • @saikinninpo
    @saikinninpo Год назад +1

    Before the German-Italian alliance, Germany sold arms to China, so after the Chinese army surrendered to Japan, a significant number of German-made pistols were sold to officers. If an officer who bought a German-made pistol in China transferred to the Pacific theater, it wouldn't be strange for the Luger to be found in the Pacific theater. 現に、My grandfather said that he bought a Spanish Astra pistol when he served in the Chinese front, but was later transferred to Indonesia.

  • @WasatchGarandMan
    @WasatchGarandMan Год назад +2

    The Luger is just a wonderful pistol, I shoot mine very often. I actually just saw Ian from Forgotten Weapons video from the war museum on Guadalcanal. I knew some Dutch Lugers ended up there but not the other Dutch weapons found on the Island.

  • @mikmik9034
    @mikmik9034 Год назад +1

    As a dea;er we had to be very. very carful with the German Lugers. Too many were made by Slave Labour, who sabatoged them. I was showing one to a potential customer; it went off while closing the breach (the round went into the range table top). Lost the sale. c. 1977. Japanese weapons were embossed with the Imperial Chrysanthemum, So for a weapon to still have it, it was not surrendered. Surrendered weapons had the crest ground off.

  • @บัวสีโรเจอร์-ศ9ฝ

    Considering the various people that were shareholders in Vickers, it is very difficult to ascertain if Vickers made or merely assembled parts from DWM. Needs looking into. . .

  • @petergray7576
    @petergray7576 Год назад +1

    1:24 However, the Japanese did copy the German MP31 SMG as their Type 100 gun, the only submachine gun to be produced in Japan during WW2.

  • @guyfawkesuThe1
    @guyfawkesuThe1 Год назад +1

    I have seen Japanese Nambu pistols floating around gun stores. They are not sought after and most US gun buyers are not interested in Japanese weapons for obvious reasons.... although they probably drive Japanese cars now ;)

  • @pinetreeriot4286
    @pinetreeriot4286 Год назад +1

    Forgotten weapons had an episode that overlapped w/ Dutch Lugers yesterday. Guadalcanal had a stockpile of them!

  • @stang3787
    @stang3787 Год назад +1

    When I was in college over 50 years ago I had a fraternity brother who had a relative who fought at Guadalcanal and brought back a German Luger. nobody believed him.

  • @werre2
    @werre2 Год назад +1

    Bought my first Luger (1930 police gun in 7.65) this spring. It is awesome. Ergonomic functional beautiful and accurate.

  • @DK-gy7ll
    @DK-gy7ll Год назад +1

    It is the nature of small arms that they eventually turn up everywhere around the globe. Just ask any Iraq or 'Stan vet... the stuff they found when they rounded up weapons was unbelievable.