Girl, you NAILED this! As a huge fan of the original, I loved this version too! Please don't feel discouraged if people complain about your voice "not fitting" or say that it isn't strong enough - unfortunately some people tend to cling to the originals so much that they don't really keep an open mind to people with naturally different timbres and voice types expressing their love for these songs. That's not on you, that's on them! I could feel the strength and emotion behind this and you performed it excellently. Hope you do more Persona covers! :)
Oh my god thank you!! You're right, many people tend to directly compare Covers to originals when it's supposed to be a different presentation of the song. Hearing that from another singer I HIGHLY admire means so much! ;v; Thank you very much and I'll definitely do more Persona! ^-^
What?!?! how can people dare say her voice isn't fitting for this song?!?! it fits perfectly and i love it!!! the like to dislike ratio should prove that :3 amazing work milky~
You know what, if they don't like the cover then how did they end up here? Prolly bc they were looking for covers or listening to the original song. If they don't like it then why are they even here? What did they click it by accident and just happened to stay the entire 5:14 min? Yeah. That's what I thought. On another note, I clicked this video bc of the cover and I'm instantly subscribing, I love her voice sm and skxwkoxso I just can't get enough of it! Brb gotta replay it another thousand times
Dang! I got 1st on accident! I feel like a jerk though that I'm pointing it out, I apologize, please don't get mad but eventually someone was going to get 1st.
I think it's really admirable that you tackled this song even knowing that some people might say "your voice doesn't fit". You did an excellent job!!!! You're pretty inspirational too to the point where I'm gonna try even harder on my voice work! Keep up the good work!! I'm definitely a fan!
That one Yuuki Not really. I don't know how to describe it, but for me, P4 is kinda too obvious, some moments even made me think that I was playing a game created for small children
I think a lot of these comments are being REALLLY picky. I thought this was excellent. As a long time fan of the Persona series and just beating this game, this was awesome.
dear god compared to the stuff you uploaded 4-5 years ago this is like another universe, I really like how you developed and are able to also reach the lower range you once had to struggle with, it's so good _(┐「ε:)_
This is my favourite song in Persona 5. I bought the soundtrack just so I could have this song. I have to say this was an amazing performance. You should be proud.
You know when I first heard it, I wasn't too impressed. But then I listened to it more, as well as reading the lyrics and realized yeah, this fits well for a final confrontation with Shido!
Pretty solid stuff! The most important thing for a cover I think, isn't so much as a carbon copy of the sound, but rather, hitting the same feeling the original is meant to give. You hit the right notes, you've got the build up, and in my opinion, a very solid rendition!
you have such a strong and beautiful voice! the perfect tones to express the feelings that the lyrics has! this is just amazing thanks for giving this piece of art!
Milkychan , I truly think this is one of my favorite songs ever and I think you just confirmed it with this cover! You have a beautiful voice and I love this song even more than I did before!! : )
I have listened to the original song trying to learn it, however I haven't seen a cover of it. So when I saw this, I instantly wanted to check it out. It's such an invigorating song and your voice compliments it so well!
this is my favorite song from the game and i enjoy your version better. you articulate the words much better giving it a stronger meaning outside just being a badass theme to listen too.
I personally like this cover more than the original. This cover makes the sound sound triumphant and defiant, which is exactly what the songs lyrics are trying to portray. A very good performance!
Personally, I like this cover more than the original song. The higher voice let it sound more emotionally for me, and I really like that. Keep up the amazing work, Milkychan :)
I really love your interpretation of this track. The unique timbre of your voice gives a different vibe from the original version, but very good in its own right. Well done!
i was looking for covers of P5 and i have to tank you, this is the first cover that from start to end gaves me chills, sorry for my English, un from México haha , thanks for doing this cover!
of course people will compare this to the original, but the whole point of a COVER is that you put your own spin on it and you take the song and almost somewhat make it your own whilst keeping the original songs motive. i think you did AMAZING, even if your voice isnt 'powerful' or anything like lyn's, you are still extremely talented and this is and will always be one of my favourite covers of this song.
Thank you very much, I am really happy that you like my Cover!! :D People are usually in comparing mode but that makes me appreciate those who look at it individually even more
Dafür, dass deine Stimme nicht die klassische Besetzung für diese Art Song ist, finde ich, dass du echt eine gute Arbeit geleistet hast! :D Die Qualität des Covers ist sehr gut, technisch kann man wie immer nicht meckern und Hauptsache ist doch, dass es dir Spaß gemacht hat :D Ich habe jedenfalls gerne zugehört :)
After listening to this incredible Cover, I decided to quickly hear into the original song (because I don't really know the Persona-games at all (shame on me °>°)) and I FIND YOUR COVER SO MUCH BETTER. Your work keeps being absolutely amazing, love the stuff you do! :3
You know what? This is great. Your voice makes the song crystal-clear, and your accent (at least, that’s what I think it is) makes me think of Ann singing the song. (Don’t ask.) EDIT: Having now seen some other covers and the original, I can definitively say this is my favourite cover of the song.
To be honest, I was also afraid your voice wouldn't fit the song. Your saving grace was that you managed to pour soul into your voice, which I loved. the pitch of the instrumental had to be altered for copyright reasons, but it works with your voice. Overall: 8.7 / 10
Very nice. Honestly I think your voice would make this cover great as a version that plays opposite of the original. Dividing them up between the phases of a boss for example.
Shido: I was supposed to steer this country, but you, a bug in tights, ruined everything! Spider-Man: You ruined my life first... Thought I'd return the favor.
Girl, you NAILED this! As a huge fan of the original, I loved this version too! Please don't feel discouraged if people complain about your voice "not fitting" or say that it isn't strong enough - unfortunately some people tend to cling to the originals so much that they don't really keep an open mind to people with naturally different timbres and voice types expressing their love for these songs. That's not on you, that's on them! I could feel the strength and emotion behind this and you performed it excellently. Hope you do more Persona covers! :)
Oh my god thank you!! You're right, many people tend to directly compare Covers to originals when it's supposed to be a different presentation of the song.
Hearing that from another singer I HIGHLY admire means so much! ;v;
Thank you very much and I'll definitely do more Persona! ^-^
What?!?! how can people dare say her voice isn't fitting for this song?!?! it fits perfectly and i love it!!! the like to dislike ratio should prove that :3 amazing work milky~
adrisaurus i completely agree with you when she nailed this
Honestly part of why I️ love the cover so much is because it’s different.
You know what, if they don't like the cover then how did they end up here? Prolly bc they were looking for covers or listening to the original song. If they don't like it then why are they even here? What did they click it by accident and just happened to stay the entire 5:14 min? Yeah. That's what I thought. On another note, I clicked this video bc of the cover and I'm instantly subscribing, I love her voice sm and skxwkoxso I just can't get enough of it! Brb gotta replay it another thousand times
Pronunciation really changes this song.
like proper pronunciation? I like the original but my god the engrish was too much
they used verb desert not noun desert so it just sounds like dessert, so really the song could be called Rivers in a Dessert
I think this cover used Marin Karin against me...
-miss-
Djoing goddammit Mitsuru
Are you an Oni?
TheVentus91 mitsuri, calm the fuck down
but Main Karin has like a 5% hit rate lol
A few seconds in and this already sounds amazing
Dang! I got 1st on accident! I feel like a jerk though that I'm pointing it out, I apologize, please don't get mad but eventually someone was going to get 1st.
I think it's really admirable that you tackled this song even knowing that some people might say "your voice doesn't fit".
You did an excellent job!!!! You're pretty inspirational too to the point where I'm gonna try even harder on my voice work!
Keep up the good work!! I'm definitely a fan!
Thank you so much for the comment, it makes me really happy to hear this! ❤
Milky + Persona?
I can die happily now!
Door-Kun [The Great Seal]
Pilky?
Mersona?
Someone You Don't Know Maybe
PILKSONYCHAN!
YES
I think i have witnessed weebs who somehow outweeb me
3:40 is where Milky's voice really shined.
I personally haven't played a game from this series. but after listening to this cover, you just motivated me to do so.
SolidSnake702 Dude you should've a WHILE AGO, this series is amazing, usually deserving of the praise it gets, the music is amazing. Etc.
id start with P3 (P4 is literally Scooby Doo simulator)
That one Yuuki Not really. I don't know how to describe it, but for me, P4 is kinda too obvious, some moments even made me think that I was playing a game created for small children
I think a lot of these comments are being REALLLY picky. I thought this was excellent. As a long time fan of the Persona series and just beating this game, this was awesome.
What's wrong with being picky? Just asking, no hate
5 years later, and I still love this.
This song is gushing with awesomeness.
Just like...*A RIVER IN A DRY LAND!!!!*
THE LAST ACE IN A LOST HAND
Grandark Zephyrum *A HEARTBEAT FOR A TIN MAN*
AdtAuthor44 An Oasis in a singed land!
@@randyanderson6923 *REMIND US WHY WE'RE HERE FOR :*
@@mr_roadie CREATING NEW LIFE~ :)
dear god compared to the stuff you uploaded 4-5 years ago this is like another universe, I really like how you developed and are able to also reach the lower range you once had to struggle with, it's so good _(┐「ε:)_
By far my favorite “Rivers in the desert” cover I’ve heard! Fantastic Job!
This is my favourite song in Persona 5. I bought the soundtrack just so I could have this song. I have to say this was an amazing performance. You should be proud.
The bass is amazing and your style gives it a unique feel.
It's pretty great.
milky please do life will change
I'll have a look at it :3
I think her voice will fit much better with Life will Change. I'm sure we will see.
yaaaaaay
My favorite theme from the game and you done it justice, such a good song!
I can't stop listening to this, its too OP
This is BEYOND AMAZING! Milky Chan! Your Amazingness is showing brighter than ever!!
I've heard a few great covers of this song on the Internet since becoming a Persona 5 fan, but this is one of the best I've found so far. Great job!
You know when I first heard it, I wasn't too impressed. But then I listened to it more, as well as reading the lyrics and realized yeah, this fits well for a final confrontation with Shido!
so amazing! i imagined haru was singing
Pretty solid stuff! The most important thing for a cover I think, isn't so much as a carbon copy of the sound, but rather, hitting the same feeling the original is meant to give. You hit the right notes, you've got the build up, and in my opinion, a very solid rendition!
you have such a strong and beautiful voice! the perfect tones to express the feelings that the lyrics has! this is just amazing thanks for giving this piece of art!
Thank you, glad you like it! ^-^
Milkychan , I truly think this is one of my favorite songs ever and I think you just confirmed it with this cover! You have a beautiful voice and I love this song even more than I did before!! : )
Ahhh thank you, I am glad that I could bring you that effect!!
I have listened to the original song trying to learn it, however I haven't seen a cover of it. So when I saw this, I instantly wanted to check it out. It's such an invigorating song and your voice compliments it so well!
I love this so much
Dang! This is up there with my favorites from you but it's got that different feel to it that isn't like the others but it works out 110%!
THIS SONG SOUNDS SO MUCH BETTER IN THIS KEY OMG.
And I LOVE your voice so much!
MilkyChan is so good with Singing.
I wanted to post a troll comment, but this sounds actually really good, sooooo....
Good. (compliments are difficult for me.)
Thanks, I still hate you though
Same goes for me.
Milkychan Do you really? Cause i thought youre like.... best friends. Im not good with sarcasm.
Nah, she just wants me to die a horrible death.
...... okay .....
this is my favorite song from the game and i enjoy your version better. you articulate the words much better giving it a stronger meaning outside just being a badass theme to listen too.
I personally like this cover more than the original. This cover makes the sound sound triumphant and defiant, which is exactly what the songs lyrics are trying to portray. A very good performance!
Thank you very much! :3
Personally, I like this cover more than the original song. The higher voice let it sound more emotionally for me, and I really like that. Keep up the amazing work, Milkychan :)
And, subbed. Oops, almost forgot to click on that bell. Welp, enjoy your new subscriber you wonderful person you.
haha thank you ;v;
best cover I've heard on RUclips for this song
I really love your interpretation of this track. The unique timbre of your voice gives a different vibe from the original version, but very good in its own right. Well done!
i was looking for covers of P5 and i have to tank you, this is the first cover that from start to end gaves me chills, sorry for my English, un from México haha , thanks for doing this cover!
Thank you, I'm really glad you like it!
OMG I love this!
You have gained a new subscriber. (*Your Charm has increased*) :D
Dam. This is really great!
Great job :) that was the best cover of any persona 5 song I have heard yet :)
To be honest I think this sounds much better than the actual song! Awesome work Milky ^^
This would have gone perfect with a pair of certain young ladies dual boss fight.
Now all we need is Wake up, Get up, Get out there and Last Suprise
Damn . That was great . Keep it up !
Hey now, this is my jam, rock on, I love this video
Amazing cover of one of the best battle themes ever
Didn't know how much I wanted it till I had it
More persona please
This is such a great cover!! In my opinion, your voice sounds stronger than the vocals in the original.
well, now i know that milkychan can make a perfect song even more perfect
of course people will compare this to the original, but the whole point of a COVER is that you put your own spin on it and you take the song and almost somewhat make it your own whilst keeping the original songs motive. i think you did AMAZING, even if your voice isnt 'powerful' or anything like lyn's, you are still extremely talented and this is and will always be one of my favourite covers of this song.
Thank you very much, I am really happy that you like my Cover!! :D
People are usually in comparing mode but that makes me appreciate those who look at it individually even more
Milkychan 100%! also youre welcome
I think I've become addicted to the soundtrack.
Oh my god this is the best cover ever,,,, your voice is very powerful and beautiful !!!
Glad to hear that you like it, thank you! :D
From one soprano to another, thank you for making this.
Dude this is an awesome tune I’ve heard!!! Nicely done!!!!
Dafür, dass deine Stimme nicht die klassische Besetzung für diese Art Song ist, finde ich, dass du echt eine gute Arbeit geleistet hast! :D Die Qualität des Covers ist sehr gut, technisch kann man wie immer nicht meckern und Hauptsache ist doch, dass es dir Spaß gemacht hat :D Ich habe jedenfalls gerne zugehört :)
Danke dir, Maria ^-^
Love this song is popping
After listening to this incredible Cover, I decided to quickly hear into the original song (because I don't really know the Persona-games at all (shame on me °>°)) and I FIND YOUR COVER SO MUCH BETTER.
Your work keeps being absolutely amazing, love the stuff you do! :3
I don't own p5 yet but I'm glad I listened to this anyway. It was enjoyable to listen to.
Whoooooaaa! Looking good Milky!
god I really like this cover, you did a spectacular job on this
Thank you, glad you like it! :3
This cover is way better then original theme.
wonderful cover of the best P5 song.
Just discovered you, your voice is completely amazing
Ahhh thank you very much!
No problem, this cover really made my day lol
WOW.
Just awesomeness to me!!!
You know what? This is great. Your voice makes the song crystal-clear, and your accent (at least, that’s what I think it is) makes me think of Ann singing the song. (Don’t ask.)
EDIT: Having now seen some other covers and the original, I can definitively say this is my favourite cover of the song.
why are the only available subtitles hebrew
If i say Milkychan is cute will she respond?
I never respond. (´・ω・`)
Milkychan You're evil.
MysteriousMrJ16 seems like she did
I thought I remembered you I saw you stronger than you parody last year
keep doin what ya doin
It kinda sounds like the Twins are singing it, which makes it double awesome~
WAY better than the Original i have to say... keep up the good work :D
Ich mag das sogar mehr als das Original, haha. Gut gemacht! :3
Hab P5 bis jetzt auch noch nicht gespielt, werde ich aber sehr bald tun~
I love you milkychan!
I’m gonna listen to this before my first job interview when i’m older lol
that is damn cool and it is a good game ive been playing it
To be honest, I was also afraid your voice wouldn't fit the song. Your saving grace was that you managed to pour soul into your voice, which I loved. the pitch of the instrumental had to be altered for copyright reasons, but it works with your voice.
Overall: 8.7 / 10
Very nice. Honestly I think your voice would make this cover great as a version that plays opposite of the original. Dividing them up between the phases of a boss for example.
There is a typo on the 1st word in the description btw
don't want to be rude but I don't want other people to freak out over that
U didn't see anything *whistles*
Milkychan lol
Your *Kindness* just increased.
TheDymed Awwww, why thanks! ^_^
How is this so good?!
The original is amazing, but this is a great alternative!
"Heyyy, that's pretty good". No joking, amazing work!
Better than the original.
this is great
well damn this surely made my night. Makes me wish your voice was in the actual song because that one is rather weak for a persona vocal imo
"A chance at a new start
There's no time for indecision"
THEN WHY ARE YOU STILL SINGING
Milkychan I wish I could see your beautiful face along your beautiful voice! I subscribed and hit that bell to hear you sing some more!!
It took me a little bit to get used to the differences, but I like it!
Glad to hear that!
Richtig gutes Cover! Echt gelungen :D
Ich hoffe, es gibt in Zukunft mehr Persona von dir ^^
Vielen Dank! Ich werde definitiv in mehr Persona Lieder reinschauen :3
Stumbled across this. Really nice :)
WOW. Your voice is just stunning
OOAIDSJOWJDKHSKJSIh SOUNDS LIKE CHARA SINGING THIS AHHHH I LOVE
Simplemente perfecta!
Love it
This sounds awesome!
This is so good! I like it better then the original.
I HAD TO GET THIS its too good!!
You girl are amazing! Thank you for this!
really good remix
Shido: I was supposed to steer this country, but you, a bug in tights, ruined everything!
Spider-Man: You ruined my life first... Thought I'd return the favor.
Milkychan Ich finde deine Stimme echt schön^^/
Freue mich immer wieder, wenn ich was von dir höre~
milkychan i still cant get over your voice
Hehe thank you, I appreciate it ^-^