Very detailed review exposing every aspect of this sword. Everything seems to be in line with what I have observed on Windlass' recent collaboration work with Matt Easton. Great measurements and study of the antique, and thoughtful designs, resulting in very faithful recreation of the originals, Windlass just needs to do a better job at QC to iron out some of the numerous smaller quirks. I look forward to the second batch of the Royal Armouries Collection models.
Thanks for the comment Kane ! I'm also very curious to see what they will come up with for this second batch. I saw and enjoyed the review you did of the hanger and longsword from the first batch, very precise and detailed.
@@philodeinos7536 Thank you! From what I have seen, the second batch has that type XIIa grete swerde of war (IX. 915) and the type XVIII arming sword (IX.1426) and a rapier.
I agree about the logos, it puts off the aesthetics. That being said, all of them except the Windlass makers mark are shallow and seem easy enough to polish out, though I never got around to doing it. Also, the TOTO marks are based on the original, though the rendition looks very modern (laser maybe?), the original looks more engraved or hammered in, to my untrained eyes at least. It came with a very good edge, though I always redo edges myself to get them just right.
At some point in the near future I'll probably be going to the Royal armouries again as I've been a few times before so I'll have a good look at it myself. I recently bought the Tod Cutler type 14 and the same can be sed for sharpness, its a very nice sword and comes with a good edge, I cut clean through 2 bottles with it straight out the box but just did little extra sharpening and it's now like a razor blade
@philodeinos7536 Well, good review. I like your cord wrapping on the fedder grip. Thanks for sharing. I've got the little fashion with the knuckle bow. It superb, easily one of my favorites. Again, good review. Don't think I've seen any other on this model, so thanks!
Nice review. I got this same sword, It is very nice. All the imperfections you comment is what a hand forged blade should have!
Very detailed review exposing every aspect of this sword. Everything seems to be in line with what I have observed on Windlass' recent collaboration work with Matt Easton. Great measurements and study of the antique, and thoughtful designs, resulting in very faithful recreation of the originals, Windlass just needs to do a better job at QC to iron out some of the numerous smaller quirks. I look forward to the second batch of the Royal Armouries Collection models.
Thanks for the comment Kane ! I'm also very curious to see what they will come up with for this second batch. I saw and enjoyed the review you did of the hanger and longsword from the first batch, very precise and detailed.
@@philodeinos7536 Thank you! From what I have seen, the second batch has that type XIIa grete swerde of war (IX. 915) and the type XVIII arming sword (IX.1426) and a rapier.
Great review, got to have one!! Thanks!
Thanks for sharing. I just ordered one today.
It is a frickin' awesome sword. Enjoy it !
Great review :)
Could you tell me how long the grip is? I couldn't find this information online.
The grip is 10 cm long.
Have you’ve tested it’s durability on hardwood? All out impact no light chopping. 🤔
Nope, not yet. I'm planning on cutting some green dowels but I won't put it through anything too rough.
It's a cool sword but all the logos on the blade put me off, also it I think it comes un-sharpend ?
I agree about the logos, it puts off the aesthetics. That being said, all of them except the Windlass makers mark are shallow and seem easy enough to polish out, though I never got around to doing it.
Also, the TOTO marks are based on the original, though the rendition looks very modern (laser maybe?), the original looks more engraved or hammered in, to my untrained eyes at least.
It came with a very good edge, though I always redo edges myself to get them just right.
At some point in the near future I'll probably be going to the Royal armouries again as I've been a few times before so I'll have a good look at it myself.
I recently bought the Tod Cutler type 14 and the same can be sed for sharpness, its a very nice sword and comes with a good edge, I cut clean through 2 bottles with it straight out the box but just did little extra sharpening and it's now like a razor blade
Are you Canadian?
No, I am half American, half Belgian.
@philodeinos7536 Well, good review. I like your cord wrapping on the fedder grip. Thanks for sharing. I've got the little fashion with the knuckle bow. It superb, easily one of my favorites. Again, good review. Don't think I've seen any other on this model, so thanks!
Typical Windlass half-assed work. Pass.