Modi vs non-BJP CMs: When most popular isn’t all-powerful & why Centre-state ties will worsen
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 18 сен 2024
- This week on #NationalInterest: Why Modi’s inability to win many states, and the huge popularity his rivals enjoy there, is pushing Indian politics in a more robustly federal direction. Shekhar Gupta explains why Centre-state ties are likely to worsen further.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Join our channel to get access to perks. Click 'JOIN' or follow the link below:
/ @theprintindia
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/su...
» Subscribe to our RUclips Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintI...
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
Early access, exclusive content, special privileges - Discover the great benefits of being a Member of ThePrint’s RUclips channel. Take a Paid Membership today. It costs just Rs 159/month.
ruclips.net/channel/UCuyRsHZILrU7ZDIAbGASHdAjoin
Most of the popular CMs are from regional parties. National parties like BJP and Congress do not allow strong regional leaders. Even in regional parties, no leaders are allowed to be popular than CM. For example in Kerala, where Shylaja teacher became more popular than Pinarayi, she was removed. This is true for all parties.
India can't afford strong regional parties. They only propagate regional extremism.
Exactly. Also, it's the high command culture that is prevalent accross parties, be it regional or national. None of them have clear, merit based democratic pathways for leaders to rise within the party.
@@lioness5838 strong regional party's during a rule of authoritarian far right central government is good only force that will defend a polarised party is regionalism at current moment we need strong regional party's
Modi himself was CM so was PVN Rao. also moraji desai, VP singh
@@njnihal3049 you are a muslim right.... I understand you
If Ashok Gehlot is popular then you need to define what is the meaning of “popularity” am sure all the villages in Up were covered
Yes, I as a Rajasthani am surprised that gehlot is this popular. Lol,he is now more hated, its just that BJP has a widely unpopular Vasundara and that's why people don't vote for BJP?
Lesser popularity of Bjp ministers is because of the reason that they have to share the popularity with Mr Modi, where as in non Bjp states don't have to share it with centre.
Modi giving Congress back for all the humiliation he got as the CM of Gujarat when UPA was in power..
Correct. Country jaaye bhaad mein 🥳
@@eshaan1110 UPA ke Samay me bhi bhaad me thi bhai.... abhi kuchh to shi hua hai
Himanta Biswa Sarma is probably the most ideology flexible guy of all.
Started his career with anti-outsider pro-assamese student politics in the Guwahati Students Union
Betrays the student movement. Roped into Congress by Hiteswar Saikia
Biggest Congress face for 15 years. Full sickular.
Changes team to BJP. Full Hindutvawadi.
🤭🤭🤭🤣🤣🤣
Very true!
His everything is about being in power no matter whatever he needs to compromise with...
@@SIDSresent hi
True but close to 40 percent of Assam is muslim (they won’t like hbs ever) so his popularity is very strong amongst Hindus
@@tomriddle4110 might be true for now... But his popularity among assamese regionalists is not that high... If CAA issue goes out of hand again then he might be in trouble
Bhupesh baghel at 51% is a joke.. He spends more time in other states than in his own..
Being from Assam, I can assure you that Himanta will lead this chart in next MOTN survey... He is a true politician.. Almost everyone (even non BJP supporters) love him.. Trust me on this
😂😂😂
Haan sahi baat... Agar mask lagayenge to parlor kaise chalega !!
This poll is a joke
@@Aparup985 most probably you are a joke too
@@rj14053 yes that was a stupid statement but I'm talking about his popularity.. He is damn popular bhai
I am from Tamilnadu and I would like to disagree with Stalin rank!! His management of the state for the last 8 months is disappointing. Corruption at every level and it has increased many folds than previous government!!!
same with Mamta Banerjee and Udhav Thakray...both are dismal
@@abhisekdas435 MK Stalin and Banerjee are popular, Uddhav Thakeray isn’t, Delhi polls showcase him as popular but local polls show him as average
@@tomriddle4110 BMC elections in 2022 will be a good litmus test.
You represent the 2% BJP supporter/voter base from TN. Your opinions don't matter in TN and u know that.
@@DS-no3dc I don't belong to any party and am just a common man. U can think that my opinion does not matter but it matters in the next elections. Also, I think u belong to 200 rupees gang since we could find that in your arrogant as tone.
In Maharashtra, I don't think Uddhav Thakre as a chief minister has that much popularity. Serious covid disaster over here is the primary reason.
Strange survey, all local polls said that Uddhav is mediocre in popularity, also surprising how Jagan isn’t on the list considering he is sweeping Andhra Pradesh
Differences between center and non B J P ruled states are worrisome in case of Mamta and Kejrival and to some extent in Maharashtra. The picture isn't that glum in case of Andhra, Orissa, Kerala, Telengana, Tamilnadu and other states.
You're wrong actually. Kejriwal is not as bad as mamata first of all. But Kerala is in deep shit. Media doesn't show the cruel side of the massive forced conversions and the sdpi + pfi gang violence that ensues in that state.
@@rishavjain1867 massive conversions by pfi and sdpi my good sir i'm in kerala for so many years and toured almost all districts and i have not seen anything like that just yesterday i went to ponnani(malapuram) and i was not converted pls tell me where are getting this shit
@@rohittarur2889 You're a privileged piece of shit who doesn't want to see the ground reality. We all know conversion victims are only the poor population. Talking about pfi violence, if you're saying you haven't heard of anything related to that, bro you're just lying. Even the biggest of Communists can accept the goonism going on in Kerala.
@@rohittarur2889 ignore it... It's just another right wing it cell
@@rishavjain1867 so you are an unprevilidged peice of shit fine then tell me do you have any data that so many number of people have been converted to pfi ,pls dont take random acts of violence and portrait them as some thing that happens on a large scale i'm talking of solid data
becoz my data tells that pfi/sdpi has not won a single seat in municipality forget niyamasabha
and talking of poor ppl getting converted in kerala there 0.71% of ppl who are poor next best is tn(i think) with 3%so pls dont give this dumb argument
okay for the benefit of doubt i will ASSUME according to a hypothetical situation that it is hapening then what is your prime minister ,home minister .,hindu hriday samrat(yogi adityanath)
doing send in the army,nia cbi
this clearly shows they dont care about you they will use you for election then throw you like out garbage when results are announced no wonder up,mp are still backward ,underdeveloped bimaru states
Yesterday on TV, they showed Yogi's popularity at 49 percent, now ashok gehlot is no. 9 with 45🤣🤣
So there are 2 types of Popularities: One of a CM within his own state and other of one nationally across all states.
So Yogi is more popular across India as BJP voters identify with him but in his own state UP people had 49% Satisfaction with his work but 40% dissatisfaction: which means only 9%+ popular rating.
@@KshitijBhambri1 so? how come Gehlot at 45 is no 9, when Yogi 49 is not there? Is TV report of India Today wrong?
@@maheshrane2996 Gehlot is 45+ Net rating(according to Survey) within Rajasthan...ok?
Yogi is 49 Satisfied and 40 dissatisfied so 9+ Net Rating
@@KshitijBhambri1 then what - Navin Patnaik is +71 Net Rating? So 85.5 satisfied and 14.5 dissatisfied? That doesn't sound right at all
@@bharathraman2098 Even I cannot believe this.. I'm just quoting their methodology. Anyways I dont believe such opinion polls/surveys.
India Today is known for its BJP-phobia. The survey is done with unparalleled mendacity. If giving back to the centre in its own terms with the use of state police is the right thing to do, which, in Maharashtra means shielding the ransom-seekers and drug peddlers, that should explain the great popularity of the state's CM. Similarly, the reign of terror unleashed in WB has the approval of a large section of people, god save this country. Your analysis, as that by a leftist, is, as usual, well-put but is as doubtful as the survey is suspect.
"Differences are 'also' part of politics". I thought managing and navigating differences "is" politics. It is naive to think that entire India with its diversity will have and should have one view on everything. Hence federal structure is working.
So, isn't it the Onus of Central Govt to talk to Opposition and other State Govts? Okay, They too should sort out issues for larger interest and for the country but why is it that it happens only when we have Full Majority Govt's at Centre with Strong Leaders like Indira & Modi? Not when we have coalition Govts of Vajpayee & Manmohan?
@Devendra Jha I see, so it the duty of the child to talk cordially, not to cry for milk, and work for the family. Father sits down and gives orders.
Try that on your family and your family will be in ruins in 3 generations.
It's the children who will do all the work, father is there to support them in their quests and challenges, they'll cry, cause ruckus, do nonsense... But father should accomodate all of those and love each one of his children.
There's a flaw in this analysis. A high approval rating for the CMs in their respective state does not necessarily mean a lower popularity rating for Modi in all these states. Good example is Odisha. If we get more CMs emulating Naveen Patnaik, we can be a strong nation.
😂😂😂
Naveen patnaik is only about bbsr
@Ashima Batra Basically, we need educAted leaders. Manmohan was naive, but he was principles.
The thing with Modi is we've not seen one proactive decision made in the past 8 years. Not even one. All the responses come after the thing has happened.
But under Manmohan, we saw that. We've seen 2008 market crash handled well. Government still doesn't know what happened after GST and Demonetisation.
How did he even became cm when he cannot even speak odia fluently, I mean how did he connect with the masses. What did odisha people saw in him to elect him this many times?
@@riteshpradhan8625 ohhhh with only bhubaneswar he has been ruling odisha for 20 years....grow up kid...he is a mla from ganjam which is south odisha and win election from bijepur which is in western odisha.....and i am not a bjd supporter...only saying the facts....
I think Maharashtra will go back to BJP in the next election. That's a no brainer provided they prop up a local face as the primary face. That state has a lot of BJP support.
It will become like chuttarpardesh
@@YankeeForever2001 BJP has come only once in up in 75 years
@@arvindkumarmahato6587 and they have made it even worse
Already gone...
Modi is actually a repeat of Indira Gandhi. The so-called Center-state "fracture" has always been there and was actually started by Indira Gandhi. The only lesson that the BJP needs to draw is perhaps focussing on empowering its own CMs.
that too is unacceptable for sahib, he doesnt like anyone rising in strature above anyone else, he clipped gadkari, rajnath has no proper footing now, shah is with him, yogi will definitely be clipped after winning a thin majority, rest are puppets or have weak governments
Damage done by IG and RG was being slowly undone by PVNR, ABV, AND MMS. Not any more.
Nope. "Center-State fracture" was not started by Indira Gandhi!! Anyone who knows the history of subcontinent would know that the "North Indian Kings" who successfully captured Delhi, ALWAYS found it hard to control other linguistic people down south and in the east. India was formed only in 1947. Before that there were like two dozen countries in subcontinent who were fighting each other over resources, wealth, land, etc,. People in the subcontinent were murdering each other for over 2500 years. If you go back 2000 years or 1000 years or 600 years or 250 years then the people lived in South, consistently flipped middle finger to the once who tried to take control over them from North, and vice-versa. India was never a single country in the past, it's just 75 years old, and the actual history of 2500 years is haunting it.
@@aryaaswale7316 BJP owes its current success to the consolidated OBC vote. Promoting Gadkari or Rajnath beyond a point will give the opposition the opportunity of rebooting the "forward-caste party" slogan. Apart from Modi, BJP does NOT have any other OBC face. I know many think Yogi or Fadnavis might become successors to Modi but considering the caste equations, both won't be easy picks. BJP is a very calculative party and keeps its cards close to its chest unlike the Congress whose leaders spend most of the year partying abroad.
@@BruceWayne-qe7bs Don't indulge with "radicals". They know nothing apart from profanity and bootlicking.
The only reason states are getting away is because Modi is too soft. He doesn't abuse his agencies to do unjust things like state CMs do with their police. That's why we day it's time for Modi to hand over the baton. Wait till Yogi becomes PM.
Modi is too soft!!!!! Just before the elections Opposition parties in Punjab, West Bengal, Orissa, UP, and Assam get IT raids from the CBI and ED. If they were really guilty, why does the agencies wait for election season to come.
2 things
1.Modi does not use agencies to abuse opponent (shows your knowledge)
2.Waiting for yogi to become pm so he can abuse agencies( shows your character).
Now decide where do you stand as a human. A leader who has openly declared to rape women of other communities to take revenge is unfortunately the role model of people like you.
M.K.Stalin is a laughing stock in Tamil Nadu these days, how come he garnered this much popularity is a seventh wonder.
he must be spending his entire day dying his hair black... 😂😂
Joker. You have no clue and it shows ur a 2% BJP Sangi supporter in TN.
@@DS-no3dc @DK Srini heard a young girl committed suicide due to pressure of conversion... TN people still have faith in your CM? if so u and ur TN ppl are the joke!
Mk Stalin is 67% and you r showing that data... Which is so fabicated and unbelievable... A minor was raped and burnt alive, a young girl is forced to commit suicide due to conversion pressure from her school... Pongal gifts given was equal to trash.... Shows your loyalty to your dying dynasty ! Wow what a bakthi!
So is UT
The joke of the millennium is India today showing 7 percent voting for Pappu as PM. He could probably be PM of Italy or mayor of Bangkok probably.
u r forgetting one thing...face is irrelevant in parliamentary democracy. all congress needs is to win more than 150 seats and make an alliance with regional parties and elect him as the one to lead it...thats how vajpayee was defeated in 2004 by congress despite having no one face...congress just needs to increase its organizational strength to compete against bjp in north indian states...bjp wont win all seats in states like chhattisgarh and rajasthan next time...they will also lose seats in haryana himachal uttarakhand Maharashtra bihar jharkhand..and west bengal..
@@subhodeepforu buddy you seem to be slightly removed from current indian political scene...first off congress reaching 150 seats is same as pigs flying in sky! And there are 10 PM contenders in the opposition...so is it as easy as aligning with regional parties when those parties are running away from Congress...look at UP and west Bengal :)
@@hirakantshet9631 even if thr r 10 pm candidates, and in case one of them become pm its normal that congress having largest electoral footprint will call the shots...and pigs flying may be part of a dream sequence..but bjp losing seats bcoz of anti incumbency is not a dream sequence...with all the sense of neutrality i can clearly see bjp losing seats in many states whr bjp won all of them last time...in bengal they won 18..even if they dont lose all of it..they will certainly lose a significant number of seats...and as a result opposition will gain the maximum out of that lose..in states like chhattisgarh congress will be the main beneficiary of bjp's loss
@Ashima Batra opposition will accept a bjp rule with a significantly reduced majority which has to depend on its allies, and an aging modi. it will create organizational space for the opposition parties like congress...not a bad deal tbh..
Good analysis. Most of the CMs from non-BJP states are family oriented and promote their own families and their men. Their CMs becoming strong/popular in the state only help personal purposes. Often they offer lot of freebies divide the voters. Interestingly, all of them fight for more powers and independent administration. Not a good sign for the integrity of India as a single country.
Jay Shah became BCCI secretary purely because of his management skills. Right.....🤣🤣By saying "Their CMs becoming strong/popular in the state only help personal purposes" is simply translates to that the voters/supporters of those CMs are all idiots and they don't understand their own goods. Only electing Modi/Shah's puppet CM in their respective state would solve the problems according to your logic. During Bengal election campaign, BJP promised more freebies than TMC. Yogi in UP is giving out 1 crore free laptops/smart phones/tablets, cuts 50% electricity bills for the farmers are not freebies right....? Yogi's rant about 80% Hindus vs 20% Muslims to win election is very inclusive and integrating politics. But, if Non-BJP CMs win elections on back of handing out doles, then that becomes very "Divisive"...LOL
@@somnathmukherjee255 you dont deserve this name plz change it 🚽🚽
@@anonymousindia27 😏😏
@@somnathmukherjee255 legally this nation should not be for muz"lms because they got there share in 1947 in form of bangaldesh afanistan and paksitn .. domt count them tmc wins because pecfuls cross 40% population mark there and one day they will try to demand a spreate country in west Bengal you are too ignorant and naive you dont understand this
@@anonymousindia27 chap sala....ye desh sabka hai...jitna amir khan ka utna hi akshay kumar ka...wo Hinduism bala bakbak 24 ke bad kaha rahta hai dekhunga
Popularity of Uddhav Thakre is insane 😂 . Maharashtra has totally lost it🧠. 😑🤦🏻
Maharashtra never had it. Only silver lining is, we didnt vote for them. The BJP was the single largest party by a massive margin but they messed it up. The way these 3 parties are behaving in government id reckon any state with basic common sense will kick them out overwhelmingly and for good. Problem is, next elections are a long way off in MH
Some straws for SG to clutch at.
What this shows is that Indian democracy is healthy and strong. Centr- State relations would be in good shape if the non-BJP Chief Ministers do not misinterpret their mandates to be a mandate to pick a fight with the BJP ruled Centre
How the heck it shows democracy is healthy ? State govt is losing authority day by day.
First u wrest the financial sphere of the states into your hands (using GST in particular), then you wreck the executive sphere ( via Governors, Central agencies) and finally you make the mockery of Parliament by passing bills in 5-10 minutes (only to be withdrawn after a year). How come these are all "healthy signs"?
Excellent point
Indian democracy is now a partial democracy! Something Dying is not healthy. And who told you states are picking up fights with the center?? It's the other way round.
@@BRIJESHKUMAR-pm4hh GST is a thing which India needed for a long time I still wonder why congress didn't do it when they had a chance back in 1992. Taxing complication was one of the main reason why foreign investors had to think twice before investing here. Coming to bills passing. Look its either gonna stay there for years by opposition opposing it without any need for it or the ruling party gonna cut corners by just passing it ASAP. Both are wrong I'm not gonna justify any of these but it was not like India was proposing gr8 bills before BJP they sucked then and suck now too but atleast some are getting passed. So what I'm trying to tell you is if you want to highlight BJP's mistakes there could be a bible on it but the one's you mentioned are not it.
I would choose modi over any gandhi, any day every time
20% of India's population has always voted for BJP for the last 30years. You are not unique.
@@walterwhite9520 Uncle G, ur teleprompter joke is not funny.... Btw ur beloved Sonia and Rahul can't even give normal speech without script. Mayawati most of the time reads from paper lol. So called great economist PM from Cambridge Manmohan always used to read from paper.
If u analyse his rallies before 2014 election, he attracted youths through his speeches in rallies where he spoke without teleprompter or script. In parliament he spoke for hours without teleprompter. Without speaking skills he'd not have become PM coz he's not from Gandhi family to inherit PM seat.
At international forums, almost all global leaders either read from script or use teleprompter. Even US presidents, their mother tongue is English but still they use teleprompter in summits. When Barack Obama addressed Indian parliament he used teleprompter. Do u say Obama lacked speaking skills?
I had to write all these to help u get rid of stupidity.
@@StarSprangledBanner but around 25 percent voted bjp in just 2014 and 2019 elections, he could be one of those people too
Sekhar, you are awesome, man...I just recently saw your interview in door darshan channel in 1998, where you were sitting as a panelist...oh man....you are still going good, man...god bless..
Naveen patnaik deserves his position at top, silent performance, no fight with centre for sake of politics, great example for all CMs to follow;
For being a poor state inspite all his long tenure 😂😂😂
@@ajaybeast_7461 it had been far below and it had improved a lot, I had travelled across Odisha 35 years ago and also some 5 years ago I could see change , when you interact with people living there they hold him in high regard . I do not think this respect comes with no reason🙏🏻
Being from Odisha, I have seen from childhood village days. as Oriya are very humble and religious. Where Congress which rule for many years did not thing but ruined everything. EVen people hate tp speak on congress. Self esteem is more important for us even though we are poor , but live happylies in Jagannath culture. Ex crime rate. murder almost nill.
@@bibhudattaardu9711 nice it is almost matching with my observations, very hard working as well
Cooperative Feudalism
😂
To all the flag bearers of "Do one CTC on Mood of Nation poll" comment ,finally you get one National interest episode..!
The state governments cried against the centralisation of vaccine orders, but when the procurement was decentralised, they cried again on the decentralisation of vaccine orders. All crying stopped when India finally managed to increase its vaccine manufacturing. After that, it doesn't matter which government makes the order.
Moral of the story - Politicians will always fight with each other, Journalists will always predict catastrophic doom ahead, as long as our economy rises and everyone gets rich, nothing really matters anyway.
Uddhav is 3rd ,gehlot and baghel are ahead of Yogi,well that's astonishing and looks far from ground reality
भाई तुमको क्या पता है ग्राउंड रियलिटी? पोस्टर पर बड़े बड़े फोटो लगाने से पॉपुलर नही होता समझे। राजस्थान की मेडिकल पॉलिसी देखो एक बार। और फिर up की देखो जाके। अभी कोरोना मैं इतनी हालत खराब हो गई थी की PM को स्पेशल आफीसर IAS ak Sharma को बनारस भेजना पड़ा था स्थिति को सामान्य करने के लिए।
राजस्थान या छत्तीसगढ़ की किसी नदी किनारे लाशें देखी थी क्या आपने? जिस तरह गंगा किनारे फेक दी गई थी।
या ऑक्सीजन की कमी के बारे में शिकायत करने पर CM द्वारा "प्रॉपर्टी छीन लेने" की धमकी दी थी गहलोत और बघेल ने?
I find it very hard to believe that Shivraj Singh Chouhan does not make it to the list, he is extremely popular leader in Madhya Pradesh (except Pappu fanboys Ofcourse). But apart from that every one admires his style of governance : Rural and urban, nationalist and socialists, modern and orthodox no one hates him.
I am from tamilnadu our money is used for feeding your people you need to thank.our cm stalin
@@sureshharinathbabu9717 whole nation is run by tn money huh?
@विष्णुकांत सिंधुसुत bavlat purna desh same hota 1947 madhe ya yadbochyanna fakta fukat hava asta sagla mhanun ajun sadtayat aplyakade ugach nahiye industrialisation jhalela evdha
@विष्णुकांत सिंधुसुत I am from Tamilnadu too , every state got some nutcases we got our share , please ignore them I loved your write up ,, between we love Shiva , karthikeya and Ganesha why are you even suggesting to change names of cities thats not fair
He is popular but I think the more important reason is the dislike of Congress's leadership choices . Digvijay Singh and Kamalnath were the party's choice but the people never liked them . Jyotiraditye Sindhiya and Ajay Singh are far more loved by the people and still weren't chosen for CM post .
Extrapolating "intrastate fracture" to BJP-nonBJP and center state fracture seems inaccurate, take for example fractures between odisha-Andhra, Tamilnadu-Andhra, Chattisgarh-Odisha, WB-Odisha, states of North East there are much deeper rafts between them. Most probably the world economic forum reports points to that only.
Percentage comparisons, about State CMs being more popular than Modi, Shekhar ji does are flawed
forgot guj-maha or maha-karnataka worst
@@aryaaswale7316 yes it is there, I was just giving examples where non BJP ruled states have conflicts, but yes you are correct at some point maharashtra was also a bjp ruled state and Gujarat-Maharashtra-Karnataka had disputes then as well.
Absolutely true. Tasmac state is having problems with all its neighboring States. Ironically it is Dravidian stock but no smooth relationship with Karnataka, Kerala and Andhra.
Yes but this is not as big as central agencies working like the stasi.
But Ashok Gehlot inspite of his popularity not getting new term
Secularism does not mean you have to be anti nationalist and apologetic to people who are incompetent or plain stupid. Modi is becoming a “verb” and that is a scary proposition for many.
Pappu should forget of becoming the PM he should open Massage palour in his favourite country Bangkok 😁
The conclusion seems inevitable. Large egos...🥸
RSS background CMs not being very popular in themselves might be due to sangh parivar-BJP strategy in states where the votes are asked in the name of party and its ideology not in the name of a person, it can be extrapolated from the affirmative rating for BJP in the states. Take WB, odisha, CG and bihar for example.
Well you must remember BJP now is kind of highly centralised party and all it's CMs(barring one or two) are just hand picked rubber stamps who are not strongmen & have no prior experience of handling state affairs. GJ is a unique example of that in recent times. Also it's an altogether different issue about the party popularity & poll performance at state(with sub regional identity & local issues) and central levels (where hyper nationalism is always at the core).
@@BRIJESHKUMAR-pm4hh not necessarily. Bonmai and Fadnavis have their own strong local following (co-incidentally also the non hindi heartland states with significant BJP following). Gujarat is more an exception to the rule, given that Modi himself is from Gujarat.
@@libshastra Bommai was chosen as a compromise over other stronger contenders esp. Murugesh Nirani who belongs to a more dominant Panchamshali sect of Lingayats and who knows how long Bommai will last in the chair. Whereas Fadanvis is concerned (I do admire him) he is prominent now but back then he was no equal to other strong leaders from MH esp. Nitin Gadkari who was clearly sidelined.
@@libshastra Bommai and Strong Following 😂 plz Tell me its a joke.
Its just to sideline Yeddyurappa and Cong beat BJP in Bommai's own home Constitutency in By-elections in November
@@BRIJESHKUMAR-pm4hh They will bring in Chandrakant Patil now as CM face
I cannot agree with CM ranking. Indian media is biased with not credibility
Very good analysis. Some new facts are placed in front of people which definitely need to consider.
With the rise of Modi state leaders of BJP like Shivraj Chouhan, Raman Singh, yedurappa, Vijay Rupani are cut to size to fit in the equation that centre government wants. It creates an unease among leaders they imitate Modi style of functioning and end up in mess like Khatter did in Haryana in farmers protest. The magic of Shivraj and Nitish is missing. Only Yogi looks different it's because he refused to become puppet in hand's of high command.
BJP infact destroying state leadership of its own party. This will eventually bring a big loss to the party also. As and when the fall of Modi begins the results will become visible.
Khattar is the failure, seriously bjp doesn’t deserve to rule in a state like Haryana with him at top
@@vsx862 but what else has he done?
I wonder if this National interest was even required. Shekhar had to pick something that could show something against Modi. "if you torture data enough, it will say anything you want."
I thought his recent action was Anti farmers and he had to repeal the law after death of so many farmers,i thought he has become quite unpopular among singhs but now realize whatever Modi Ji does there will be blind supporters even at the cost of their countrymen...continue your devotion and say " all is well"
When congress was in power , BJP state didn't act like this.
Mr. Gupta there are numerous parties in UP which are cast affiliated. So, they all have different aspirations. Hence, comparing him with other CMs is grave injustice.
About Uddhav Thackrey: There are 4 main parties in Maharashtra- BJP, Shiv Sena, NCP and Congress.
Out of these 4, 3 are in power. Hence, he is bound to get favours from the supporters of other parties too. This is the reason he is in top 5. The party does not even have pan Maharastra presence as strongly as it is in Mumbai.
Also, He has been a "CM in absentia" owing to his health issues and is unlikely to be the joint CM candidate in the next election.
@True Data it’s because he has got support from NCP-cong supporters as well as shiv sena supporters due to their alliance, same was the case for nithish Kumar in 2015 but now he has hardly 40 seats in his control. Of shiv sena fights alone they will get a max of 40 seats most of them in konkan region.
Great points
@True Data
Bro, pro-tem u can sleep soundly thinking this. But, this is completely false.
Also, industries are exiting MH. Infra projects are at hault. What about the Metro project ?? Why suddenly the project has come out to be infeasible ?? Why the deadline is only slipping forward ?? I can go on an on.
So, all the best wid ur thoughts and Good night.😊
@@sankalp6872 I think someone like Ajit Pawar or Eknath Shinde will likely be the next cm if MVA fights together again. In order to win you need to actually interact with the people.
I would prefer Modi to be powerful at the Centre and the CMs at the State. The risk of autocratic rule can be averted. Modi can be implicitly trusted to navigate the country during these challenging times.
I don’t trust our present opposition leaders to lead the country in this critical time. They are untrustworthy and won’t hesitate to sell their mothers if the price were right.
Bhupesh Baghel is not popular CM in Chhattisgarh state.
Hi sir ,
There is one incident in Tamilnadu about teen girl Lavanya M , how school harassed and killed her .would you please do the clutter on this also how many things which are not allowed in such school please let us know ..Thanks 🙏
@Harshit how far has the enquiry gone? The center deployed some big investigation team there right?
Sometimes I do think in India if you get harassed & get killed you should be minority no Hindu to become headlines and to get justice !!!
Feeling Sad 😔 how the family is going through a Trauma ...
Take for example Kashmiri Pandit no media make this as a issue .
I asked myself question ..
1. Who is CM of Gujrat when riots happened
Ans : I know
2. Who is CM of kashmir when kashmir Hindus exodus happened?
Ans : I don't no.
Becoz they were Hindu 😞😞
No one launched investigation against kashmir CM ..on the other hand CM Gujrat have to face probed ..
Polls can be misleading as the sample chosen can be biased or not diverse enough, I may be wrong, but it is a clear possibility
बकवास कर रहे है
This is the perfect way country is going politically... More federal structure will keep India united..
It's trade, trade & trade alone that unites a country - nothing else. We should build extensive intrastate infrastructure and supply chains which is currently underway.
More federalism will weaken india.. India needs strong center.. If you want a federalism then divide present big states into three parts.
@@adithyaadi1363 just say you want hindi belt domination, why shy to express your ulterior motive. Civil war will ensue if you play Hindi-hindu-hindustan politics, and we will defeat you. i want south indian leader in centre for next 50 years. North india is useless. they just can produce uneducated babies and are labour class
@@helcurt2509 i am southie telugu... Yes i want all states to be divided and india needs 60-70 states. Even i can i say if you dont support this you are a separatist....
@@helcurt2509 you are racist dravidian.. Learn about frieght equalisation policy and how it helped other states and made eastern states like bihar and bengal, jharkhand,mp, odiya poorer...
The art of speaking without saying anything.
Shekarji, come and live in Maharashtra. Centre state politics was always fractured. Outside of the Hindi heartland, States with strong local cultures always has the space for local leaders. This was always a point of contention between Delhi and the States.
It would be interesting to know survey results of ‘which current CM can be PM’
Yogi ji only cm to be pm now
It mamata banerjee
Yogi Adityanath of course
Aurangazeb aka Stalin
@@cyrusthegreat3081 is it? Unmaiyava?
SG can you do a cut the clutter on amaravathi issue in Andhra Pradesh , we are a state with no capital from last 8 years🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️
he did one about it it was about overall state of our cities
Its a pity that our contestants like modi and rahul where ideally we should have people as Naveen Patnaik
He is a state leader, nothing more. Maybe popular there but on a national level and in the Hindi heartland, he wouldn't win a single seat.
If the CMS of Rajasthan and Chattisgarh are so popular in their home state, I can only doubt the report...
Naveen pattnaik is in power for more than 20 years but one of the most resource rich state is still 33% poor, 29% anaemia effected women and more over little industrialization, corruption is still at a greater level .. Same as crime against women
The Opinion poll only shows anti-incumbency to some extent but the reality is that NDA remains the most popular alliance at national level, BJP should now focus on addressing issues like Inflation, Domestic Manufacturing and Healthcare for the next 3 years. BJP should also monitor how efficiently Central schemes are being implemented in states like Bihar, Haryana and Karnataka and start grooming popular leaders at state level
Only if they gets time from spreading hate then they will look into these things
@@parnamsingh1716 That’s what you think after watching excess of NDTV
@@pksingh3232 glad I don't watch Godi Media at least... Anjana Om Modi😂🤣😂
@@parnamsingh1716 NDTV is the actual Godi media of Congress, so first learn what is journalism
@@pksingh3232 🤣🤣🤣 what a joke. Congress is an old horse I don't bet on it. Still I never seen ndtv praising congress like dalal anchor sit on their chair and shout out Modi Modi... Thats what I hate about. Media should be asking question from leaders. What is happening in India not a journlism. It is comedy shows run on everyday. You tell me a single interview where Modi been asked tough question. Yes there was one which he left half way and ran coz Modi don't have the answers for true joirnlist. He can only give interview to his puppet.
People should reject Single party rule and encourage Federalism for the health of the Democracy (Unity in Diversity).
This is slightly wrong analysis in my view. In last 3 years (since 2018) BJP lost to Mamta Banerjee where also it's seats were significantly increased. Also, in Maharashtra had BJP fought independent, it might ended having bigger chunk of seats. MP happened to be 15 years of ruling, Tamilnadu never been BJP stronghold, Bihar Nitish happened to be face again and surely bound to lose considering current chaos.
Now left, Rajasthan, so let's wait.
Punjab, Delhi and in other states BJP was never since Modi.
It is too early to discount Modi popularity in State Election because while winning is majoring criteria one must not forget that it is only party in last 40 years whose footprint are still increasing and with cadre of RSS and BJP let's not discount BJP presence in Southern States.
Irony of our country is when we talk about diminishing federal structure we tend to forget the attitude of other non BJP ruled CMs who were envy of Modi even befor he became PM so the disconnect is less political but more personal.
You forgot jharkhand where modi is extremely popular
But they lost the state election
The list surprisingly does not have the name of Nitin Gadkari.
A fractured mandate would be disastrous
The fact that uddhav thakre as w popular leader shows this stats are biased
UT becoming CM was never imagined but after he became many people accepted it. His party may not win many seats but anyone who understands people of Maharashtra will accept that yes UT is popular. Especially when you see through UT vs DF angle..
@@rohitsharma4363 Idealogy or Personality?
Do you live in Maharashtra? There is nothing wrong of his name came in this list. He work for our state. Well! I am Maharashtrian. From which state you are?
@@pratikshapatil9763 I live in Maharashtra and uddhav Thackeray hasn't shown his face in past 8-10 months. He is ill. And then they talk about making his wife the CM. Lol
@@radbrad8150 They are not making her CM. Even though he is ill, his cabinet has managed the state well. He also checks some things by online or someway. I don't want to boast about him, but then we can't blame someone for being ill and not coming as things are being managed.
Centre state relations were always fractured in the states mentioned by Gupta - Orissa, Bengal, Maharashtra, Tamil Nadu etc. It’s a fallacy to opine that BJP started this trend.
Also Covid strategy was abysmal as the state level and caused most damage initially. It was only after centre took charge of covid fight that we could control the infections and also vaccinate 1B within a few months.
States have shown to be corrupt and ill governed who use factional, castist politics to stay in power. This status quo seems desirable to the Print and their ilk. Shame…
Totally distorted article, and a wishful thinking for some. Maharashtra , Bengal are disasters , in law and order, and administration.
In Bengal Mamata Banerjee is very popular, no reason to deny. In Maharashtra Uddhav Thakeray has allied with almost all non bjp parties so that is why his popularity is inflated
And Uttar Pradesh's law and order is best if all with highest crime rate 👍👍
I also really doubt the popularity numbers of Maharashtra, Chhattisgarh and Rajasthan, the ground reality is completely opposite, MVA alliance will lose Assembly Elections if it is held today, also Congress will lose Rajasthan and Chhattisgarh if BJP comes up with a popular CM face
@@vsx862 I agree , today AAP is more popular party than most other Opposition parties, so these numbers really look doubtful as most of Opposition State Govts will get ousted in the next Assembly Elections, we are already seeing that in Punjab where AAP is winning, I am expecting BJP to win Maharashtra and Rajasthan in the next Assembly Elections. At the same time BJP will face challenges in Bihar and Haryana where State Govt is not popular
Sir I am from Maharashtra I and people of Maharashtra know what kind of work Uddhav does? He is not working from Nov the govt is run by Sharad Pawar....crores of Rs corruption is going in Maharashtra
Its high time we abolish states and let only administrative districts with 50% powers of states remain. This federalism will lead to division of this country.
u mad or what??that will be a disaster in states with less affinity towards center and thr will be a huge backlash against north indian dominant politics of center... secessionists will rise and governance will take a huge blow
@@subhodeepforu ...keeping states on basis of lang is achieving same regional fanaticism. In districts fanatics will at max only have a district to rule & ruin.
@@gauravnilay instead of doing that why not reduce north indian dominance in delhi's politics and instead run the central administration with a broader view and focus on other non hindi speaking parts of india...all of the pms have been frm north except deve gowda but still the all the focus is on north...that is the main bone of contention
You don't need to do a National Interest on Godi Media poll SG sir! It sounds just ridiculous.
Mk Stalin is 67% and you r showing that data... Which is so fabicated and unbelievable... A minor was raped and burnt alive, a young girl is forced to commit suicide due to conversion pressure from her school... Pongal gifts given was equal to trash.... Shows your loyalty to your dying dynasty ! Wow what a bakthi!
I don't know how young girl death or conversion related to popularity.
@@logeswaran1823 yeah the more he kills Hindus, he gets more popular among the sikulars like u
@@sanitizer6585 another unlogical statement.
Naveen Patnaik is best person to lead the country
Family level interogations, this is the deepest fundamental reason nothing else.
When it comes delivering public services without leakage and building infra(roads/electricity/railways/ports) etc or promoting industries, ease of doing business and reducing corruption to larger extent in central government, Modi has delivered a lot in past 8 years. Today, Indians can compare corrupt in effective UPA vs BJP government and they think there is no better alternative to BJP/Modi for a long time to come.
When all BJP CM are Modi Bhakta, naturally he will be more popular. In Karnataka CM acts like PM representative..
Going to comment on Lavanya case from TN?
Offcourse no.it will damage his "secular" credentials
Uddhav Thackeray has popularity of 61.8% ahead of Kejriwal.😲
Poor try to justify the arrogance of so-called secular parties and their CM, instead of wholeheartedly accepting the popularity of Mr. PM. But this is what expected by The Print, so no surprise 😊
The biggest joke is M.K.Stalin with 68%.
When you Don't like the truth, hate it's provider and go to OpIndia.
Yes Naveen Patnaik is quite popular here, maybe as his party is in power almost since i was born around 25 yrs
What will happen after Pattanaik? Who will lead BJD?
Non BJP CMs think they are the head of that states but they forget that pm is the head of the whole country
federalism is India's final counter to fascism. It has always been
Facsism tga
All this proves is that:
1- all the crooks have joined hands and its all vs one now.
2- the opposition are clueless on how to be a healthy opposition
3- SG doesn’t miss a chance to bring in RSS and is nursery where its not required
What will Indian do after Modi retires??
Will India survey???
Most vulnerable situations is when you don’t have option in a population of 130+ Cr.
Modi wave is just a bubble history would tell us better..
How congress fell without indira ,bjp is heading towards that same kind of demise without modi
Just see
@@ManishGupta-jv6ll ???
Well explained as always. I admire the way you convey whatever you want to and maintain decency without being offensive. Waiting for your view on the future of India under the growing multiparty culture. Firstly the regional parties are mostly headed by a family so how long they’ll be able to sustain/survive ? Secondly how they can keep National interest above their regional interests which is basis of their politics. In my opinion we need at least 2-3 national parties who have nationwide hold to form a strong opposition or threat to the ruling party.
Shekhar: When are you going to explain and apologize for the canard you created of a coup by the Indian Army during Gen VK SIngh's tenure. I am sure you realize but never acknowledged for the immense damage that you did to India's national security by your chicanery.?\
Can speak for WB: Mamata may be single-handedly popular but TMC has lost much of its popularity. The people will no longer vote only for Mamata. With economic woes deepening, the people are increasingly becoming frustrated with the Tughlaqi administration.
What the hell is Tughlaqi??
West Bengal is robustly federal which makes decision implementation a challenge as the semi-autonomous bodies of Jungalmahal and North Bengal can impede procedures if ruled by different parties.
Pinarayi is certainly more popular than 70 % otherwise why would he win with such an outstanding majority !!
I hate bjp government because they give importance to religion, caste and not providing good budget to the southern states
The vacuum created at centre level due to lack of opposition is being filled by rise of opposition at state level.
Sure it will lead to more friction between state and centre but in a way acts as a brake on unilateral decision making at both state and central level.
Thank God for indoor shooting. No noise 🤗
Hi Shekhar, Looks like you have updated your IPad.. is it the latest one IPad pro 2021?
Popularity of CMs in own state is basically a result of how much these parties are dependent on these leaders and those who dont have any challengers within the party. Naveen Pattanaik, Mamata Banerjee, MK Stalin these folks are almost unparalleled in their own party and hence the popularity. Pinarayi's numbers are down because of some supporters of KK Shailaja must be cursing him.
Does it go same for the BJP at national level? Do you see any union ministers other than Nitin Gadkari, working independently?
Shekhar gupta ji, u r a grand master of amalgamating various datas from various, sources, even seemingly having no interrelationsand then use them to his own expertize of Modi bashing, BJP hatred & Hindu travelizing , so that he along with other Lutyan gang members, continue their anti patriotic, antinational,anti Hindu subversion activities.
You are a professor, and you say SG is anti BJP and then you go on to qualify him as anti patriotic....look at you,if this is the thought process of learned man like you then what is the difference between paid IT cell and you.
I think it is misleading to compare popularity of CMs from regional parties to that of BJP and Congress. All CM from regional parties are party supremos and have attained cult-like status in their respective area of influence (with Pinarayi V. breaking CPIM tradition) while CM from Congress and BJP are appointed by the high command and are unlikely to have personal following except for maybe Yogi Adityanath.
जिन आंकड़े भ्रामक है । क्यों कि जहां से जिस तरह ये आंकड़े जुटाए गए हैं वह तरीका विश्वसनीय नहीं है ।२०१९के लोक सभा चुनाव में स्पष्ट कर देते हैं कि कौन कितना लोकप्रिय है।
Gujarat and Maharashtra are not hindi heartland. It’s better to keep these two states with southern india then north because they have more common with south then north. From satvahana to shivaji
Gujarat doesn't . Maharashtra does. Gujarat is very poor on the Human Development Index.
They are west
Mahatma modi. We r fortunate that this leader has emerged as the savior and Hindu icon.
SG - The 2nd joke is Uddhav Thackeray being more popular chief minister than Yogi...that tells me the usefulness of this survey and hence the validity of your article. You are going down the slippery slope of biased journalism
Pinaraayi vijayan standing at number three🤣🤣🤣 the survey must have been filled in a CPM party office,🤣🤣
I don’t see any issue with it !!
How would you say he isn’t popular & there’s nothing much to say that he’s a bad leader, Infact he’s one of the best in the country, much better than a Chaiwaala !!
While SG is a bjp lover, PK is Bharat lover and his calculations seem pragmatic and correct. If he can organize an effective opposition he will dictate the rest and Modi is out.
Also counterpoint - CMs will do whatever will get them elected. Beti Bachao, Beti Padhao campaign is a good example. Centre launches BBBP campaign, TMC launches their own counter campaigns like Kanyashree. In specific ways, it has made States more competitive with the Centre.
This guy is so obsessed with how BJP can go down .. he is trying to find reason where there are none .. also
Analysis is good, but one thing, why Aravind Kejrival is behind Kerala CM Pinarayi Vijayan?
Sorry Shekhar - do not see any of the legendary opposition CMs stepping in to contest as PM. It will be PAPPU AGAIN. Also, half those CMs are regional populists - something you do not forget to remind the world about PM Modi - many winning on muslim votes.
Was speaking to a senior officer of a BJP ruled state! He said that even the CMO is unhappy with centre but can't say anything. Anyhow better to live in a bubble, isn't it!!
lies at the fullest ! No CM can be unhappy with the centre except those of Khangress