I definitely think Katy is a stronger vocalist. The problem I have with her is her inconsistency. Sometimes she slays, other times she's just completely out of tune. It's hard to guess how she is going to be from one performance to the next.
She always slays, sweetie. It has become really easy for me to recognize how she is going to sing as the years have passed by. If you were her fan, you would know.
That was years ago that she was off and on... when the prism era started she stared to become a stronger singer and ever since 2016 she has been amazing
Um,, what was that? Taylor has so many good clips, and the ones here are very meh? Whoever compiled this didn't try to show her is any kind of positive light!
Albert Lopez it was made by a demi fan so stfu, Katy Perry is a talented singer, taylor is mediocre. Katy is better in everything, vibrato, belting, support, agility, runs, range, musicality etc.
@@mauvid That is incorrect. The clips were not from The Hello Katy Tour, most of the clips were from Witness Tour and Reputation Tour. And the others were from different live performances.
I don't have a preference for either singer but agree that you can't make a fair comparison this way because you don't know if the clip you are watching is just a bad night or the general quality of their singing. At minimum, you would have to look at many clips of each person singing that note in a performance and it would still depend on the bias of the person collecting the clips.
Thats not a fair comparison! Taylor absolutely destroys katy in low notes, while they choose the most horrible clip for C#5 and D5. I am not saying taylor is better than katy which is not true because everyone knows that katy is a better singer than taylor but this video was soo biased. Taylor is not that bad as showcased in this video.
Katy Perry is just much better vocally, that’s not even arguable. Katy is stronger in everything except low notes. Katy supports her voice until C5, has a nice strong vibrato, much better agility & Falsetto/HV. Katy’s vocal capabilities are much more developed & she has a wider range. just look at their songs, taylor’s are easy asf while katy perry’s song are a lot more of a challenge. Taylor is great but not on her level
That video is probably made by a Katy Perry fan. In that head voice part they seriously put a clip of Taylor joking around while Katy's was serious.(It's disappointing because Taylor's head voice is pretty much better)
Jov SeC For falsettos and stuff they could have used like the Out Of The Woods clip from the 1989 World Tour or way better clips instead. It’s just unfair tbh
Jov SeC Katy Perry is just much better vocally, that’s not even arguable. Katy is stronger in everything except low notes. Katy supports her voice until C5, has a nice strong vibrato, much better agility & Falsetto. Its because taylor swift doesn’t even have vocals of the sixth octave live that are not exclamation or scream. Katy would have won anyway her head voice is much much better thats not even comparable. taylors is weak and not agile.
I really wish this women wld find her own clips, I've watched a few of these by her and after a couple of clips u can tell who's fan made the compilation. Like this was clearly made by a Katy Perry fan and some of those clips were like 3 seconds long for both of them how can u judge anyone vocals on like a 3 second clip. Just seems dumb to me.
MyViewFromMyCouch no lol it was made by a Demi fan so, stfu Katy Perry is just much better vocally, that’s not even arguable. Katy is stronger in everything except low notes. Katy supports her voice until C5, has a nice strong vibrato, much better agility & Falsetto.
@@sass_king5576 Demi fan, of course. I think she's a great singer, but some of her hi-energy dance songs just don't do her justice (No Promises, Sorry Not Sorry, Daddy Issues, and Cool For the Summer were basically earrape). The ones where she mellows out and tells a story are the ones I find most intriguing like Stone Cold, Tell Me You Love Me, and Give Your Heart a Break. For me, I prefer Taylor's sharp and soft vocals over Katy's because of the overall emotional quality Taylor delivers. I love Ellie Goulding and Halsey so what do I know. lol
I love both, but it just bothered me the fact that it’s not fair. I’ve seen Taylor’s and Katy’s vocals in videos for a really long time and I can perfectly see they didn’t choose the best videos for Taylor as they did in some for Katy. Also, they gave like 3 seconds for Taylor in some and more to Katy. For example, most of the performances of Taylor there were recorded with phones and the quality was bad, while you can actually find the same performances with good quality, professional camera recorded, with way better audio quality. Also, why choosing a clip of Taylor just playing around with her voice and an actually clip of Katy playing a concert? While you literally have Taylor doing falsettos in the 1989 World Tour and stuff? Like, not fair ahah. Another thing that kinda bothered me was the fact of you mocking Taylor for doing the thing with the mic. Like, it’s her way of doing it, if she wants to do it, and if it’s her style and her thing, while bothering about that, or making fun of it? Again, love both, but didn’t find it fair. Love your reactions and the fact that you’re actually honest ❤️ As a request, could you react to Taylor more often? Like for example the Reputation Stadium Tour and stuff? She has good content!
Katy's falsetto is absolutely uncomparable. The point of the matter is that don't compare Katy Perry with Taylor Swift. Stop, they have nothing in common, apart from the fact that they both are women. Just because they had a feud doesn't mean, you'll make a "vocal battle".
@@kaw7760 I disagree with that,so many Katy stans said that,I really don't get that,have you watch her live performances but not just belting notes before??? Her way how she sings live just so annoying, one word by one word,it should be a sentence by a sentence, but she just sing it one word by one word,that's how she record her music??? it's so laughable, of course this kinda thing Katy Perry will have a chance to win,and this person who made that video just like Katy Perry so much,I guess,I guess that person just find the best of her live,but find worse Taylor Swift live,talk about live performances, Taylor Swift might be worse than other singers, but that one is definitely not Katy Perry,(go to watch her live at summertime ball 2012,I just watched Part of Me yesterday, such a bad performance, and 2015 superbowl half time show is the same,she's not sing a song,she just sing one word by one word,Taylor is much better at live performances in general for sure,no need to think about,if you watch their lives you'll definitely sure that Taylor is better, might worse than other singers, but that one is definitely not Katy Perry)
ZayPlays they def aren’t on the same level, Katy Perry is a vocalist while taylor is more of a singer. big difference. and even in the songs, way of singing, the ranges, the support, the agility and belts etc.. Katy Perry is just the better vocalist, especially in 2020. Taylor is still good but not as good. katy could sing taylor songs but taylor wouldn’t be able to sing katy’s songs in the key katy sings.
@@sass_king5576 In reality, Taylor could sing Katy's songs. Katy's belts are long but are not too high. Taylor has a higher range but lacks the ability to hold the notes like Katy does. Katy's notes and belts are longer but lower.
Jaider Mosquera Katy has a bigger range actually. Katy has 3 octaves and Taylor has 2. The information you have stated is inaccurate and I am confused where you got these ideas. X
Rodrigo Dutra it was made by a demi fan, the clips were from both their lastest tout’r, Katy Perry is a talented singer, taylor is mediocre. Katy is better in everything, vibrato, belting, support, agility, runs, range, musicality etc.
I think it's pretty fair, Katy is pretty decent, her power is scary good. Tremolo is one of her weaknesses. She almost never had a stable and consistent vibrato. Meanwhile Taylor is just ok, she can sing but definitely not better than Katy. Taylor's chest voice is pretty shaky above B4. The result is still true despite of the fairness of each clip.
Driton Musaj haha 😂😂 I don’t think that’s true at all hun, whatever works for Taylor then good on her. Yeh it may be annoying to some but if her notes come out well because of it, then I’m HAPPY 😍
Chrissy I get it may be annoying to some, but there’s a difference with saying it’s annoying and then mocking it. I think it’s rude. Georgina knows by now Taylor does that, she needs to get over it 😂
I don't know, why your so annoyed that she's finds it annoying that Taylor Swift holds her Mike like that(pretty hypocritical sis).... Oh wait actually I do know it's called an OPINION 😂 now look at that,now you know the answer to your question
@@nikki6265 you didn't have to say that you were annoyed, by writing that you prove that you were....or at least trigger in some way..... You didn't just magically decide to state your opinion... Something made you do it.....
@@kindomofmoo1362 Actually, I decided to state it because I was curious as to why she was annoyed by it, which is why I asked why she was annoyed by it.
Yes. I sensed some bias too, ngl. She literally kept mocking taylor during her part instead of properly listening to her voice. And during Katy's parts FULL attention was paid...💔Even the *eyeroll* during taylors parts...
@@ButeraVids actually the way your body stands when you are singing is so much important for the technique... A lot of coaches talk about sing in this position and sufferdizziness...
The only thing that bugged me a little here was how the vocal coach judged Taylor for how she held her mic while singing. She kept on rolling her eyes...
I don't want to be rude, but I need to say this. That Taylor's pose you underline everytime is something she always does since the very beginning of her career. I don't know if she does that cause it helps her reaching the note or just cause she like it (she's a singer, but also a performer and all of her movements are part of the performance too), but it's kinda of annoying that you always had to make "fun" of what she does with her body on the stage. You don't like it, it's okey, we understood that, but you don't need to point it out everytime she does it. ps. Of course it's your video, your reaction, so despite of what I'm saying, you can do whatever you want. This is just my opinion.
Celine does it too, but it's weird using it as a build up to something not super impressive? Not as a dig but, Taylor doesn't hold notes that long typically without going off the rails a bit because she doesn't have the greatest vocal support unless it's just one HELD note. Which she generally strains for. I mean it can sound cool because of its build up but on its own? You and I can get the same effect with similar level technique probably.
She’s not really making fun of it, like at all. I think the problem is just that people don’t want to see you do the same move whenever you belt out a note. It makes it seem like she doesn’t really have any real performative nature, because her style is so redundant
Katy Perry actually has a very beautiful voice quite honestly despite contrary belief. I think most people just crap on her as a singer because of the kind of pop music she makes. I knew she was going to win before it started.
Exactly... She has more of a lower register for a female. Much like Cyndi Lauper. My favorite Badass in Pop music. "Sally's Pigeons" is my favorite Cyn song.
Christopher Mayen still Katy Perry completly destroyz Taylor swift when it comes to singing & giving vocals. Katy is better in everything, whether it is agility, range, Vibrato, falsetto / HV, Belting, support & Musicality. Taylor only has her tone & even then that’s subjective to like or not. she has ease when it comes to low notes but thats it. she isn’t on Katy Perry’s level
8:15 how can you say they were both out of tune???! They both sang the note they intended to sing, it's a bit difficult to judge due to the bad audio quality but your judgment in really weird. Taylors note was supported and a bit more rock in tone which makes it stand out from her usual singing style and she does it well and Katy sang the high note with amazing vibrato and it sounded amazing. I really dont agree with you in almost any of these points in any of your videos similar to this. Maybe it is only me but...
It's a fact that Katy Perry's vocal abilities are way better than Taylor Swift and I agree Taylor's clips were short but the mentioned notes ended within that time so why would the clips be any longer?Katy held the notes longer so longer clips. Maybe Taylor has better clips which weren't included.
You should react to just Taylor Swift's best vocals next. I'm not necessarily a huge Taylor fan (I was with her country music, but I'm not a fan of her pop stuff), but I know she is better than what these clips show lol
That's probably because Katy sings a lot, and I mean A LOT, more dance-pop tracks (non-emotional) with her own style of narrative, but I've also heard her more emotionally charged singles like Thinkin Of You, Wide Awake, and Unconditionally. But I really don't think Katy can deliver the same emotions as Taylor does for me.
@@aaliyahfoster2705 Lmao! Go listen to Firework, Wide Awake (Acoustic), The One That Got Away, By the Grace of God, Thinking of You, Lost, Legends Never Die, I'm Still Breathing, Double Rainbow, Into Me You See, Save as Draft, Part of Me (Acoustic), Search Me, Dance with the Devil, Unconditionally, Miss You More, Teenage Dream, Ghost, Roar, Simple, etc. Katy delivers real emotion into her songs, and slays Live/Acoustic. Don't ever compare her to Taylor, Britney or Selena. Katy delivers different emotions like: sadness, motivated/inspired, love, sexiness, joy, surprised, anticipated, etc.
Sorry, But this reaction was not good. You didn't take into account that most clips of TS were too noisy because of the crowd. And also you were paying attention more to the way TS hits a note and not to the note itself. I'm so pissed off because Taylor's D5, Eb5 and E5 were really great and resonant, and you were like "nah". And I'm not a fan of hers.
No she is not biased, she is talking the truth, she might have the other clips which are better but in this video she is awful. If u think, she is biased watch the other videos she compared taylor swift with other singers. She praised her a lot so
Katy Perry is definitely a better vocalist, and as someone who has seen her live, she does sound great. Whenever I've watched Taylor she's been off-pitch.
Taylor should 🏆win. She lost only because:1) you didn't like the way she was singing the big vocals, 2) because the last video of hers was when she was making the song and she was trying to mime the sound of a specific part of her song and 3) because the videos of her in this video didn't have good quality because they were taken by fans
It's so funny to criticize the way the artist holds the microphone. You forgot that the microphone belongs to this artist in question and the concert is also about this artist in question, so she does what she wants to do, it's simple 😂🤷🏻♂️
I commented similar. It seems like she hates taylor because she mentioned everytime and mimicked when taylor held the microphone above her head for high notes but never did for Katy perry.
That has nothing to do with how she holds it, it's because it's bad to hit a high note with a high larynx. U need to have a good posture when ur hitting high notes
@@sohyangworld1544 Lmao! Every fan base has subscribed to her Channel. Even though they hate her, they still step foot to the comment section. Hilarious!
I heard Katy Perry's been doing vocal classes with the same vocal coach of Ariana Grande, at least she tries to get better and Taylor is average, she didn't really care to improve, she has a beautiful and marketable timbre so she counts on that!
She made a livestream with him about warming up her voice. It have about an hour and is very educative, even about body moves to help with resonate high notes
You were clearly biased in this video against Taylor swift,,,, I don’t think you should be comparing 2 Amazing female artists, I was starting to like your channel but I’m so over this. You should be EMPOWERING WOMAN! P.S - Stop mocking her,,, it’s a bit rich coming from you 💖 no hate to Katy or Taylor fans- both great artists 🔅
No, she wasn't biased the video she was watching was biased....she's not comparing two female artist,she's comparing two females artist vocals!! there's a difference.... So comparing two female artists vocally is not putting them down, we need to know the actual difference sis, so when people like you say things like this,it makes it harder to recognize when people are actually putting women down..... You just use that as an excuse to justify your argument, she can mock whoever she wants even if it is rude,because it's her opinion that she is entitled to, and it's very hypocritical for you to stay "it's a bit rich coming from you" because that seems like you're putting her down, but I thought you JUST said you should be empowering women??? What's up with that..... And I just think you're a hardcore Stan and that is why you unsubscribed or whatever you did not because she was biased or she's was "putting women" down that was just an excuse.
Katy’s voice is stronger and she is technically a better singer so your opinion doesn’t really matter since this video is discussing their technical skills with vocals and not just who sounds better. I love both of their voices though.
Taylor really has a good and sweet voice but Katy is just a little bit better. I don´t know why Swifties are saying "it was a Katy fan video" that is so annoying. She is a professional singer and she knows exactly what techniques they are using. Even if someone chooses the best clips of Tay, she won´t lose because Katy jas improved a lot, but if you compare Katy and Céline, for sure Céline win, the same if you compare Taylor and Selena Gomez for sure Tay win. Swifties stop acting like and asshole. That´s why because people hate Taylor Swift fans. I mean if she has a Grammy doesn´t mean she is the best singer. What about if you compare Tay and Ariana or Tay and Demi...Swifties will say that videos were made by Ariana´s fan or Demi´s fans? Oh really?
Celine Dion is classically trained and we all know that. Katy has a gospel singer background when she was in high school. Taylor has always been focused more on songwriting and delivering emotionally charged songs in her works. Demi and Ari just kept working on their vocals and went onto Disney and Nickelodeon respectively for it.
Swifties trying to avoid the fact that Taylor isn’t anywhere near Katy Perry vocally by talking about the clips, I love taylor but she’s really average as a singer compared to Katy. You should compare taylor to Selena, Lana or others. Katy is a league above
Because Katy is actually a vocal beast. She has a strong, powerful voice. Even if you put her up with the best of the best, she'll give them a run for their money.
Omgg you finally reacted to this! I am commenting this before even watching the video.. its my request for you to please react to taylor swift 1989 world tour best live vocals or reputation best live vocals. Hopefully you will see this comment.. I love your reactions ♥♥😘
Taylor's voice is errr not good. Great songwriter but not a vocalist for sure. You might get a lot of thumbs down....Swifties are vile so don't take it personal. Katy is ok, she's improved a bit.
I am a stan of both artists tho... I love them both but Katy still has a wider vocal range which always sounds so much better. Taylor, she is really good in song writing as well as ms perry they both are awesome. By the way it's kinda biased because tswift's clips were in low quality
Maybe Taylor has better clips, but I think even with her best notes Katy would clearly win, she is a better singer, just my opinion. I love both, no shade.
I’ve seen them both live and I personally think Katy is much better. She really has a great voice, and when she sang a couple songs that weren’t hers she really extra killed it. So I agree with you, Katy wins!
Until 8:00 I thought you were being fair, but that last one showed that you were just really done with Taylor Swift’s act at that point and willing to give Katy the point even though that clip was absolute garbage. Great videos on the whole though, I live your channel! And also I think Katy Perry is a better singer, even if I much prefer Taylor’s music.
Katy Perry definitely won. Face it Taylor has better control on lower vocals but Katy has more range and just better everything. Your fav just isn't that good
It's just an opinion first of all, she didn't say Taylor didn't take her singing seriously she said she THINKS she doesn't take it seriously there's a difference.... And don't tell someone to think before they speak because it's their opinion it's not fact...... it's not a fact that she takes her singing seriously ..... Let's learn to crawl before we walk sis
I definitely think Katy is a stronger vocalist. The problem I have with her is her inconsistency. Sometimes she slays, other times she's just completely out of tune. It's hard to guess how she is going to be from one performance to the next.
Kayla Mueller it depends on where she is performing, she gets nervous when it broadcasted
She always slays, sweetie. It has become really easy for me to recognize how she is going to sing as the years have passed by. If you were her fan, you would know.
@@mynameissurya19
Katty Perry is fan of Gaga darling !
That was years ago that she was off and on... when the prism era started she stared to become a stronger singer and ever since 2016 she has been amazing
@@victorzuniga7542 what relevancy is this to anything-
What even is this video? Taylor’s clips are literally a few seconds long and you can barely hear her in most of them.
Elena Lacey Thays probably the point. Her voice is just not as strong as Katy’s.
Because that's how long Taylor's notes last
@@LilCraftyNook You need to watch her reputation performances
@@shreyanshsharma4302 Please check your statement
Seriously all of Taylor’s clips were like 2 seconds long
and?
@@eirinha2287 and had way worse audio quality in the midst of audience ambiance
Um,, what was that? Taylor has so many good clips, and the ones here are very meh? Whoever compiled this didn't try to show her is any kind of positive light!
Marta S Taylor has good clips, lmaoooo so funny
Yes, but Katy is a better vocallist in general, apart from the clips shown
Marta S that wouldn’t have change the outcome. best taylor clips vs best Katy clips = Katy still wins
Marta S same was done to Ariana clip
Right? Whoever did this took good clips of Katy's and bad clips of Taylor's.
That video was obv made by a katy fan. Taylors clips are all cut short while katys are longer and showcase her vocal talent more than taylor. 💁
Albert Lopez Probably because Katy Perry has more vocal talent 🤷🏼♂️
Albert Lopez it was made by a demi fan so stfu, Katy Perry is a talented singer, taylor is mediocre. Katy is better in everything, vibrato, belting, support, agility, runs, range, musicality etc.
i know who did the video.. and trust me he would NEVER be biased
Katy perry has a better voice thats all.
Albert Lopez your just salty that you lost 😂
The clip was highly biased against taylor swift
Taylor isn’t a good singer over all though
@Vulan Lovena Lmao! Katy is far from being, "average". You're Hilarious!
@Vulan Lovena no, they're not from their last tour. There are clips from Katy's first tour and from Taylor at the Victoria Secrets Fashion Show.
@@mauvid That is incorrect. The clips were not from The Hello Katy Tour, most of the clips were from Witness Tour and Reputation Tour. And the others were from different live performances.
Ikr
All of Taylor's videos were crap quality... I don't think they should be compared from this..
This person obviously was a Katy fan who made this..
LOLOL Katy Perry can still sing circles around Taylor, crap quality or not.
@Vulan Lovena Hardly can anyone agree with that statement but delusional fans like you
Still Katy>>>>>>>>>>> Taylor
Sam but Taylor can write great lyrics, just in my Personal Opinion ;)
@@peaceful_chaos14 nobody said that, but I won't choose that video cause it's unfair
I don't have a preference for either singer but agree that you can't make a fair comparison this way because you don't know if the clip you are watching is just a bad night or the general quality of their singing. At minimum, you would have to look at many clips of each person singing that note in a performance and it would still depend on the bias of the person collecting the clips.
bad clips or not Katy Perry is still the stronger vocalist and that’s not even up for debate lmao
@@sass_king5576 yess
"what key is that?!" sksksksksksks 🤣
MC space bootz 🙌🏻😂
It's the wrong one, I'll tell you that much LOL
Thats not a fair comparison! Taylor absolutely destroys katy in low notes, while they choose the most horrible clip for C#5 and D5. I am not saying taylor is better than katy which is not true because everyone knows that katy is a better singer than taylor but this video was soo biased. Taylor is not that bad as showcased in this video.
Katy Perry is just much better vocally, that’s not even arguable. Katy is stronger in everything except low notes. Katy supports her voice until C5, has a nice strong vibrato, much better agility & Falsetto/HV. Katy’s vocal capabilities are much more developed & she has a wider range. just look at their songs, taylor’s are easy asf while katy perry’s song are a lot more of a challenge. Taylor is great but not on her level
Neither Katy.Theyrw both Great Artists,vocally and generally but Katy wins.
@@sass_king5576 yeah yeah yeah we get it 😑
Really? I always thought Katy had a better lower register. I used to listen to " Thinking of You " and " Brick by Brick " on repeat for her lows.
Katy low notes are actually better than taylor now so there is anything that taylor is better than katy in vocal terms
Gurl, the clips they used for Taylor was LOW QUALITY AS HELL i smell sabotage
exactly this
still, taylor’s best vocals aren’t on par with katy’s best vocals
@@sass_king5576 same way as Katy's best vocals aren't even near Gaga's worst vocals 🤣
@@sass_king5576 periodt
@@rajisraj415 gaga was never mentioned 🗿
That video is probably made by a Katy Perry fan. In that head voice part they seriously put a clip of Taylor joking around while Katy's was serious.(It's disappointing because Taylor's head voice is pretty much better)
Love your sense of humour 😄
Jov SeC For falsettos and stuff they could have used like the Out Of The Woods clip from the 1989 World Tour or way better clips instead. It’s just unfair tbh
Jov SeC Katy Perry is just much better vocally, that’s not even arguable. Katy is stronger in everything except low notes. Katy supports her voice until C5, has a nice strong vibrato, much better agility & Falsetto. Its because taylor swift doesn’t even have vocals of the sixth octave live that are not exclamation or scream. Katy would have won anyway her head voice is much much better thats not even comparable. taylors is weak and not agile.
fr they should've used the clip of Taylor when she was recording don't blame me
iTiago she still didn’t hit a D6 properly & her falsetto isn’t as good as katy.
Katy has an amazing voice. Taylor too💖
Taylor ♥️♥️♥️ they chose some bad clips for Taylor 😑 the person who sent the clips to her I felt was biased against Taylor 😣
katy still better
Taylor's voice is limited
I really wish this women wld find her own clips, I've watched a few of these by her and after a couple of clips u can tell who's fan made the compilation. Like this was clearly made by a Katy Perry fan and some of those clips were like 3 seconds long for both of them how can u judge anyone vocals on like a 3 second clip. Just seems dumb to me.
MyViewFromMyCouch no lol it was made by a Demi fan so, stfu Katy Perry is just much better vocally, that’s not even arguable. Katy is stronger in everything except low notes. Katy supports her voice until C5, has a nice strong vibrato, much better agility & Falsetto.
@@sass_king5576 Demi fan, of course. I think she's a great singer, but some of her hi-energy dance songs just don't do her justice (No Promises, Sorry Not Sorry, Daddy Issues, and Cool For the Summer were basically earrape). The ones where she mellows out and tells a story are the ones I find most intriguing like Stone Cold, Tell Me You Love Me, and Give Your Heart a Break. For me, I prefer Taylor's sharp and soft vocals over Katy's because of the overall emotional quality Taylor delivers. I love Ellie Goulding and Halsey so what do I know. lol
You realize they have to find clips of the exact same notes that are distinct and not the same easy notes you hear 24/7
@@aaliyahfoster2705 emotional quality?sksjskjsk
Sass_King5 well katy's lows sounded better here. Taylor was just whispering/speaking those notes
I love both, but it just bothered me the fact that it’s not fair. I’ve seen Taylor’s and Katy’s vocals in videos for a really long time and I can perfectly see they didn’t choose the best videos for Taylor as they did in some for Katy. Also, they gave like 3 seconds for Taylor in some and more to Katy. For example, most of the performances of Taylor there were recorded with phones and the quality was bad, while you can actually find the same performances with good quality, professional camera recorded, with way better audio quality.
Also, why choosing a clip of Taylor just playing around with her voice and an actually clip of Katy playing a concert?
While you literally have Taylor doing falsettos in the 1989 World Tour and stuff? Like, not fair ahah.
Another thing that kinda bothered me was the fact of you mocking Taylor for doing the thing with the mic. Like, it’s her way of doing it, if she wants to do it, and if it’s her style and her thing, while bothering about that, or making fun of it?
Again, love both, but didn’t find it fair.
Love your reactions and the fact that you’re actually honest ❤️
As a request, could you react to Taylor more often? Like for example the Reputation Stadium Tour and stuff? She has good content!
Katy's falsetto is absolutely uncomparable. The point of the matter is that don't compare Katy Perry with Taylor Swift. Stop, they have nothing in common, apart from the fact that they both are women. Just because they had a feud doesn't mean, you'll make a "vocal battle".
Katy has a very good unique quality voice period.
Perry@ bestie hahahah 😍
This is such a bad compilation.
Taylor's clips were worst.
nnn..still katy better than taylor (vocal)
No it's not, Taylor's clip are good
•MIGHTY POTATO• most of them were not that good tbh
@@kaw7760 I disagree with that,so many Katy stans said that,I really don't get that,have you watch her live performances but not just belting notes before??? Her way how she sings live just so annoying, one word by one word,it should be a sentence by a sentence, but she just sing it one word by one word,that's how she record her music??? it's so laughable, of course this kinda thing Katy Perry will have a chance to win,and this person who made that video just like Katy Perry so much,I guess,I guess that person just find the best of her live,but find worse Taylor Swift live,talk about live performances, Taylor Swift might be worse than other singers, but that one is definitely not Katy Perry,(go to watch her live at summertime ball 2012,I just watched Part of Me yesterday, such a bad performance, and 2015 superbowl half time show is the same,she's not sing a song,she just sing one word by one word,Taylor is much better at live performances in general for sure,no need to think about,if you watch their lives you'll definitely sure that Taylor is better, might worse than other singers, but that one is definitely not Katy Perry)
@@kaw7760 I disagree.
The videos with Taylor are worse, she has a lot of amazing vocals, like Don't blame me high note or Idk, this isn't the right video
Tbh we can judge any of them they are both literally on the same level. They are both amazing.
ZayPlays they def aren’t on the same level, Katy Perry is a vocalist while taylor is more of a singer. big difference. and even in the songs, way of singing, the ranges, the support, the agility and belts etc.. Katy Perry is just the better vocalist, especially in 2020. Taylor is still good but not as good. katy could sing taylor songs but taylor wouldn’t be able to sing katy’s songs in the key katy sings.
I agreeeeeee 😭
@@sass_king5576 In reality, Taylor could sing Katy's songs. Katy's belts are long but are not too high. Taylor has a higher range but lacks the ability to hold the notes like Katy does. Katy's notes and belts are longer but lower.
Jaider Mosquera Katy has a bigger range actually. Katy has 3 octaves and Taylor has 2. The information you have stated is inaccurate and I am confused where you got these ideas. X
9:22 was literally a small funny clip from Taylor
Unfair competion here. The clips from taylor sucks, are too short and bad quality, impossible to compare
Rodrigo Dutra it was made by a demi fan, the clips were from both their lastest tout’r, Katy Perry is a talented singer, taylor is mediocre. Katy is better in everything, vibrato, belting, support, agility, runs, range, musicality etc.
@@sass_king5576 Hahaha whatever you said
taylor can't get any better though. haha
@@kvin2647 Hahaha whatever you said katy still better than taylor
I think it's pretty fair, Katy is pretty decent, her power is scary good. Tremolo is one of her weaknesses. She almost never had a stable and consistent vibrato. Meanwhile Taylor is just ok, she can sing but definitely not better than Katy. Taylor's chest voice is pretty shaky above B4. The result is still true despite of the fairness of each clip.
Katy Perry’s voice is getting really better over time. The Witness era was when she really started improving her skills!!
It´s always the same thing, the person o made the video was a fan of Katy Perry.
It´s never a fair competition.
Bruno Pereira yeah, I have also noticed that. Taylor has very short clips like those were very shorts.
But that is okay. I still love Katy
Vocally katy is still better.
@@kurtarcos5981 But Katy still has a better voice. It doesn't matter the footage. Taylor is a better songwriter though.
I love both equally i just wanted to use different notes insead the same notes that everyone use 😭
Why do you keep mocking the way Taylor moves with her high notes? You mock it every time, just let her be.
Thans Kay Exactly.
Its because it is annoying! It’s every time...
@Driton Musaj
It's not health to hold a microphone how you want? .....ok😑🤔
Driton Musaj haha 😂😂 I don’t think that’s true at all hun, whatever works for Taylor then good on her. Yeh it may be annoying to some but if her notes come out well because of it, then I’m HAPPY 😍
Chrissy I get it may be annoying to some, but there’s a difference with saying it’s annoying and then mocking it. I think it’s rude. Georgina knows by now Taylor does that, she needs to get over it 😂
Katy perry improved so much after her single bon apetit
This vid was created by a biased person.
this comment tho.
Katy would still have won since she’s a much better vocalist
9:20 are u kiddin'? Taylor was just joking at the moment!!!!
OH MA GOODNESS!!!! KATY PERRY’S VOICE HAS DEFINITELY IMPROVED!! Lemmie just take a small break from Taylor Swift, and relive my young, childhood.
I don't get why u get so annoyed by Taylor's mic thing lol it's her thing how is it annoying
I don't know, why your so annoyed that she's finds it annoying that Taylor Swift holds her Mike like that(pretty hypocritical sis).... Oh wait actually I do know it's called an OPINION 😂 now look at that,now you know the answer to your question
@@kindomofmoo1362 I never said I was annoyed ahahah chill I was just stating my opinion just like her
@@nikki6265 you didn't have to say that you were annoyed, by writing that you prove that you were....or at least trigger in some way..... You didn't just magically decide to state your opinion... Something made you do it.....
@@kindomofmoo1362 Actually, I decided to state it because I was curious as to why she was annoyed by it, which is why I asked why she was annoyed by it.
same sis
“ I don’t think Taylor take her singing seriously” girl are you even serious? DELETE DELETE DELETE.
She is serious. haha
If Taylor did, she'd stop sighing and calling it falsetto and use more breath support.
Afiq Akmal SHE IS A FUCKING COACH, YOU DONT KNOW WHAT YOURE TALKING ABOUT DUDE
lol who are you telling her to delete she's a vocal coach lul
I was definitely expecting Katy to win, but honestly I had the feeling you were a little bit biased. Anyway yeah, Katy's still definitely better!
Yes. I sensed some bias too, ngl. She literally kept mocking taylor during her part instead of properly listening to her voice. And during Katy's parts FULL attention was paid...💔Even the *eyeroll* during taylors parts...
She is not biased, it was the vídeo imo
??? You're wrong
Listen to 5:17, Katy did better but she point for both
this was an unfair video because there are so many good clips of Taylor's best vocals
Its from their last tour and not best vocals
@@feridedogan7653 they were not all from their last tour, and on taylor side he put the worst quality clips that you can find of reputation tour
I don’t know what is your problem with taylor’s position when singing high notes
shes a vocal coach... technique is important
Taylor can’t hit high notes
JD the way she is standing has nothing to do with technique, NOTHING.
@@ButeraVids actually the way your body stands when you are singing is so much important for the technique... A lot of coaches talk about sing in this position and sufferdizziness...
ButeraVidsu um... actually it does
The only thing that bugged me a little here was how the vocal coach judged Taylor for how she held her mic while singing. She kept on rolling her eyes...
Literally
Honestly it seems like she absolutely despises Taylor lol
I think she doesn’t like Taylor. Taylor definitely got that E5… She wasn’t out of tune😂
katy may not have the best sing technique, but she really can convey the emotions and feelings behind the songs by her unique sound . and that's true
Not the better technique? Bruh, did you see the end?
Katy Perry ♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️
yeah these clips were biased af but whatever
Mhmm sure taytay just sucks
The fact that this got y'all really pressed...Katy has a stronger voice because she's a full lyrics soprano while Taylor is well Taylor
I don't want to be rude, but I need to say this. That Taylor's pose you underline everytime is something she always does since the very beginning of her career. I don't know if she does that cause it helps her reaching the note or just cause she like it (she's a singer, but also a performer and all of her movements are part of the performance too), but it's kinda of annoying that you always had to make "fun" of what she does with her body on the stage. You don't like it, it's okey, we understood that, but you don't need to point it out everytime she does it.
ps. Of course it's your video, your reaction, so despite of what I'm saying, you can do whatever you want. This is just my opinion.
And I love Taylor as a songwriter as well 😏
Celine does it too, but it's weird using it as a build up to something not super impressive?
Not as a dig but, Taylor doesn't hold notes that long typically without going off the rails a bit because she doesn't have the greatest vocal support unless it's just one HELD note. Which she generally strains for.
I mean it can sound cool because of its build up but on its own? You and I can get the same effect with similar level technique probably.
It's actually unhealtly lifting your head up while singing,I think that thats what she's trying tô point out
She’s not really making fun of it, like at all. I think the problem is just that people don’t want to see you do the same move whenever you belt out a note. It makes it seem like she doesn’t really have any real performative nature, because her style is so redundant
Eireen she uses that pose to hit the high notes????? LOOOL she can’t hit really high notes, she’s not a vocalist and doing that is a bad technique
In Taylor's head voice one she was messing about. You should react to her singing don't blame me live on tour
LoveFor Swift there was a clip of dbm high note and the girl said she was off key... um where?
stanningswift she was OFF key like always, she can’t reach that note
@@larryisnotreal2593 girl stop hating, you are just embarrassing yourself
Katy Perry actually has a very beautiful voice quite honestly despite contrary belief. I think most people just crap on her as a singer because of the kind of pop music she makes. I knew she was going to win before it started.
Lew Lew lmao sure she is.
I’m Living Like Jim Morrison yeah she is
Katy Perry's voice is difficult to sing high notes actually. So katy won is certainly❤
Exactly... She has more of a lower register for a female. Much like Cyndi Lauper. My favorite Badass in Pop music. "Sally's Pigeons" is my favorite Cyn song.
yeah cuz taylor's clip were trash
@@maximilienrobespierre7595 that won't change a thing, taylor is a mediocre vocalist, everybody knows that except here fans
@@maximilienrobespierre7595 both clips were trash
@@theeinkar24 mediocre but Katy is flopping so hard.
Come into the video, thinking Taylor and Katy can't really sing. I'm shook
They could've included so many clips from the highest grossing usa tour of all time but it was obviously made by a Katy fan
Christopher Mayen still Katy Perry completly destroyz Taylor swift when it comes to singing & giving vocals. Katy is better in everything, whether it is agility, range, Vibrato, falsetto / HV, Belting, support & Musicality. Taylor only has her tone & even then that’s subjective to like or not. she has ease when it comes to low notes but thats it. she isn’t on Katy Perry’s level
Oh please. I got free tickets to that show and a majority of the show was playback and/or her real voice was drowned in the backing track.
@@jambon6451 really ? Hhahahahah you just jealous that she has highest grossing tour this year 😂😂
@@sass_king5576 but then Taylor is still way more successful in terms of tour, awards, gross etc 😂. I wonder why
@@hazwanahmad2273 Keep dragging awards over real talent, which is what Taylor never had and never will have.
Even though Taylor’s videos were the worst chosen, we know and we have to admit Katy has a better vocal range and beltings than Taylor
8:15 how can you say they were both out of tune???! They both sang the note they intended to sing, it's a bit difficult to judge due to the bad audio quality but your judgment in really weird. Taylors note was supported and a bit more rock in tone which makes it stand out from her usual singing style and she does it well and Katy sang the high note with amazing vibrato and it sounded amazing. I really dont agree with you in almost any of these points in any of your videos similar to this. Maybe it is only me but...
She’s a vocal coach she’s not just making stuff up
And whats wrong with you?? Thats her way of holding her mic.. don'k make faces😤
Nothing's wrong with her, that's just her opinion , she doesn't like it when she does that, same thing with the faces... It's her opinion
Lifting your head up while singing it's not healtly actually,I think thats what she was poiting
It's not about poses, it's about vocals and yes Katy wins anyway but...yk
Queen of bops katy perry
But it's sad
I am the only one in this comment who is appreciating queen katy perry.
Katy has like twice of range Taylor has. Katy has a lot of G5, A5 in mix. Also a lot of head voice.
Taylor Swift has a lot of G5 but of course you haven't heard anything
@@flabbergabbot1242 ikr
@@flabbergabbot1242 Taylor's "ring to it" ends at C5 making her sound like she's yelling while Katy has many resonant G5's
@@flabbergabbot1242 her g5 is screechy
@@aryanverma3368 The NFL halftime show didn’t think so.
Yes taylors clips werent the best ones but we can all agree that katys voice is stronger..
Merziah Kardashian Definitely!! The comment I’ve been looking for
yes
Ofcourseee
Katy perry is a better vocalist in my opinion but taylor is def a better song writer but I love both if the queens ❤
It's a fact that Katy Perry's vocal abilities are way better than Taylor Swift and I agree Taylor's clips were short but the mentioned notes ended within that time so why would the clips be any longer?Katy held the notes longer so longer clips. Maybe Taylor has better clips which weren't included.
I loved Taylor's clip when she sung dont blame me but Georgina completely shut it down. Something I'm missing?
Apparently because SHE'S the vocal coach here.... And even if she wasn't, it's her preference, you know her opinion that she can express
You have some nerve talking about queen swift missy
I love both of them but I think Katy Perry has a better control
You should react to just Taylor Swift's best vocals next. I'm not necessarily a huge Taylor fan (I was with her country music, but I'm not a fan of her pop stuff), but I know she is better than what these clips show lol
She has
Finally someone who likes her country music better instead of her poppy
Let's put it this way. Katy can sing any taylor swift song with ease. I don't know about Taylor though. But both are equally talented
That's probably because Katy sings a lot, and I mean A LOT, more dance-pop tracks (non-emotional) with her own style of narrative, but I've also heard her more emotionally charged singles like Thinkin Of You, Wide Awake, and Unconditionally. But I really don't think Katy can deliver the same emotions as Taylor does for me.
@@aaliyahfoster2705 Lmao! Go listen to Firework, Wide Awake (Acoustic), The One That Got Away, By the Grace of God, Thinking of You, Lost, Legends Never Die, I'm Still Breathing, Double Rainbow, Into Me You See, Save as Draft, Part of Me (Acoustic), Search Me, Dance with the Devil, Unconditionally, Miss You More, Teenage Dream, Ghost, Roar, Simple, etc. Katy delivers real emotion into her songs, and slays Live/Acoustic. Don't ever compare her to Taylor, Britney or Selena. Katy delivers different emotions like: sadness, motivated/inspired, love, sexiness, joy, surprised, anticipated, etc.
Sorry, But this reaction was not good. You didn't take into account that most clips of TS were too noisy because of the crowd. And also you were paying attention more to the way TS hits a note and not to the note itself. I'm so pissed off because Taylor's D5, Eb5 and E5 were really great and resonant, and you were like "nah". And I'm not a fan of hers.
Marcelo Modesto LMAOOOO none of taylor’s note were resonant or supported so next. Katy’s D5 alone destroys all of taylor swifts note in this video
Marcelo Modesto taylor has never supported a note above Bb4
They were so bad she didn't want to show them
You're biased against Katy and so is the video lmao. Plus why does it matter if Taylor holds her mic like that anyway?
7:41 is me watching this video
No she is not biased, she is talking the truth, she might have the other clips which are better but in this video she is awful. If u think, she is biased watch the other videos she compared taylor swift with other singers. She praised her a lot so
your taylor impersonation with the mike shold be a meme lololol
Katy Perry is definitely a better vocalist, and as someone who has seen her live, she does sound great. Whenever I've watched Taylor she's been off-pitch.
Katy is sometimes off pitch & flat on her live though
*Swiftie when TS win something* : she's queen and no one can beat her 🐍👑
*Swiftie when TS lose* : iT rEaLlY nOt a fAiR cOmpArISoN!!!!!
Yeah sis that's true 😂
exactly
Lmfao exactly bestie 😂
"that was dreadful" part make me laugh so damn hardddddddd
Taylor should 🏆win. She lost only because:1) you didn't like the way she was singing the big vocals, 2) because the last video of hers was when she was making the song and she was trying to mime the sound of a specific part of her song and 3) because the videos of her in this video didn't have good quality because they were taken by fans
Stop crying about taylor clips katy perry is much better vocalist
NO KATY CAN'T SWITCH GENRES LIKE TAYLOR SHUT UP
Katy for sure
It's so funny to criticize the way the artist holds the microphone. You forgot that the microphone belongs to this artist in question and the concert is also about this artist in question, so she does what she wants to do, it's simple 😂🤷🏻♂️
I commented similar. It seems like she hates taylor because she mentioned everytime and mimicked when taylor held the microphone above her head for high notes but never did for Katy perry.
That has nothing to do with how she holds it, it's because it's bad to hit a high note with a high larynx. U need to have a good posture when ur hitting high notes
She's just mad she's a small, no sub youtuber and Taylor is famous.
@@sohyangworld1544 Lmao! Every fan base has subscribed to her Channel. Even though they hate her, they still step foot to the comment section. Hilarious!
I heard Katy Perry's been doing vocal classes with the same vocal coach of Ariana Grande, at least she tries to get better and Taylor is average, she didn't really care to improve, she has a beautiful and marketable timbre so she counts on that!
She made a livestream with him about warming up her voice. It have about an hour and is very educative, even about body moves to help with resonate high notes
she is so much better than she was when she first started! get real.
Taylor Swift don't care to improve, but she improve
You were clearly biased in this video against Taylor swift,,,, I don’t think you should be comparing 2 Amazing female artists, I was starting to like your channel but I’m so over this. You should be EMPOWERING WOMAN!
P.S - Stop mocking her,,, it’s a bit rich coming from you 💖 no hate to Katy or Taylor fans- both great artists 🔅
No, she wasn't biased the video she was watching was biased....she's not comparing two female artist,she's comparing two females artist vocals!! there's a difference.... So comparing two female artists vocally is not putting them down, we need to know the actual difference sis, so when people like you say things like this,it makes it harder to recognize when people are actually putting women down.....
You just use that as an excuse to justify your argument, she can mock whoever she wants even if it is rude,because it's her opinion that she is entitled to, and it's very hypocritical for you to stay "it's a bit rich coming from you" because that seems like you're putting her down, but I thought you JUST said you should be empowering women??? What's up with that..... And I just think you're a hardcore Stan and that is why you unsubscribed or whatever you did not because she was biased or she's was "putting women" down that was just an excuse.
All these people saying it’s just because it was bad clips of Taylor. Or maybe it’s because the girl can’t sing...
Love your videos. These clips are garbage though. Poor sound quality, short and too much background noise.
So many pressed swifties. 😂
I'm a beyonce fan and even I can see how heavily biased this video is. The sound of videos looks like it's taking from Nokia phone of 1995
I've seen Taylor and Katy perry in concert and I can confirm for myself that Taylor definitely wins and her voice in person is so beautiful
Katy’s voice is stronger and she is technically a better singer so your opinion doesn’t really matter since this video is discussing their technical skills with vocals and not just who sounds better. I love both of their voices though.
Taylor really has a good and sweet voice but Katy is just a little bit better. I don´t know why Swifties are saying "it was a Katy fan video" that is so annoying. She is a professional singer and she knows exactly what techniques they are using. Even if someone chooses the best clips of Tay, she won´t lose because Katy jas improved a lot, but if you compare Katy and Céline, for sure Céline win, the same if you compare Taylor and Selena Gomez for sure Tay win. Swifties stop acting like and asshole. That´s why because people hate Taylor Swift fans. I mean if she has a Grammy doesn´t mean she is the best singer. What about if you compare Tay and Ariana or Tay and Demi...Swifties will say that videos were made by Ariana´s fan or Demi´s fans? Oh really?
Celine Dion is classically trained and we all know that. Katy has a gospel singer background when she was in high school. Taylor has always been focused more on songwriting and delivering emotionally charged songs in her works. Demi and Ari just kept working on their vocals and went onto Disney and Nickelodeon respectively for it.
People mad because you told the truth 😂😂😂😂
Swifties trying to avoid the fact that Taylor isn’t anywhere near Katy Perry vocally by talking about the clips, I love taylor but she’s really average as a singer compared to Katy. You should compare taylor to Selena, Lana or others. Katy is a league above
Katy gospel singer she did well
Because Katy is actually a vocal beast. She has a strong, powerful voice. Even if you put her up with the best of the best, she'll give them a run for their money.
Agreed!
Omgg you finally reacted to this! I am commenting this before even watching the video.. its my request for you to please react to taylor swift 1989 world tour best live vocals or reputation best live vocals. Hopefully you will see this comment.. I love your reactions ♥♥😘
Katy perrys head/neck position is so much accurate than Taylor’s so it’s obvious that Katy is better
Taylor stans fuming here as if Taylor ever had a chance VS Katy in terms of singing. Lol wake up
She has the chance to compete with Katy, but Katy is better
Taylor fans messing up at the comments but can we just aceppt the fact she is an amazing song writer but shes not a belter!
Katy Perry is far better. She could be one of the biggest diva if she has a better breath control. Strong voice and support. But Taylor...meh
@Ashting of course there's better clips of her, but overral she's not a good singer. She's better at songwriting. Doesn't mean she's bad tho
@@alecprescott-okdisco113 Katy's Respiratory System literally creates breath control. I love her breath control!
My two favourite singers. But I agree Katy is better
Taylor's voice is errr not good. Great songwriter but not a vocalist for sure. You might get a lot of thumbs down....Swifties are vile so don't take it personal. Katy is ok, she's improved a bit.
Taylor's not the best vocalist but she's good control
I don't care about Taylor posing, it's whatever but doesn't annoy me.
It's cringe 😝
@@mattsmith9939 I cringe way more from her songs. Except Style.
She s looking always like a giraffe when she does that pose😄
It's unhealtly tô lift your head up while singing,I think thats what she's trying to point out
I am a stan of both artists tho... I love them both but Katy still has a wider vocal range which always sounds so much better. Taylor, she is really good in song writing as well as ms perry they both are awesome. By the way it's kinda biased because tswift's clips were in low quality
Maybe Taylor has better clips, but I think even with her best notes Katy would clearly win, she is a better singer, just my opinion.
I love both, no shade.
I’ve seen them both live and I personally think Katy is much better. She really has a great voice, and when she sang a couple songs that weren’t hers she really extra killed it. So I agree with you, Katy wins!
She really does!
All these Taylor stans crying in the comment section as if they don’t know Katy Perry is a better vocalist than their idol they treat like a god
Taylor Swift still good, but Katy is better
Yes the person I thought was gonna win won.
I don’t think it matters if Swift has good or bad quality clips. Shes an awful singer. Katy won. Shocking. Can Swiffy even outsing anyone?
*aka me mocking the way taylor swift holds a microphone for **11:08*
I like Katy more
Until 8:00 I thought you were being fair, but that last one showed that you were just really done with Taylor Swift’s act at that point and willing to give Katy the point even though that clip was absolute garbage. Great videos on the whole though, I live your channel! And also I think Katy Perry is a better singer, even if I much prefer Taylor’s music.
Katy Perry definitely won. Face it Taylor has better control on lower vocals but Katy has more range and just better everything. Your fav just isn't that good
10:05 TAYLOR DOES NOT TAKE HER SINGING SERIOUSLY... THINK BEFORE YOU SPEAK..SWIFTIES CAN DO WHATEVER THEY WANT..
Mayank kaushik 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
It's just an opinion first of all, she didn't say Taylor didn't take her singing seriously she said she THINKS she doesn't take it seriously there's a difference.... And don't tell someone to think before they speak because it's their opinion it's not fact...... it's not a fact that she takes her singing seriously ..... Let's learn to crawl before we walk sis
thats just a swifty delusion💀
Do more of Katy Perry!
Love both of them, I'm sure I am going to be brokenhearted
Um Why? Because katy is much better?
Katy is the queen of pop !! that's it 👑
"We all got crown" - Taylor