You clearly should work for a Japanese anime studio, even as a freelancer if you have to. You have an amazing talent and good eyes to notice small imperfections.
Dude I swear to you that with the quality of your animation, if you redo the whole season I'm ready to buy it from you, even at an indecent price (and I'm sure I won't be the only one)
Mappa gives Eren like 5 different faces in every episode since season 4 part 1 ( example the table scene 🤦🏾♀️) but you made sure to give him the same one, the one and only Eren and I really like that 👏🏾😊
Your fanmade is much better. Mapa's coloring is always dark and cloudy, but I wanted it to be a little bright and colorful. And I feel so comfortable because you modified the character's face. Thank you so much for satisfying the shortcomings of Mapa!!
Season 4 looking dark and cloudy was an aesthetic choice, as there's practically no hope left for humanity, because of the Rumbling. Having a bright and colorful look like Season 1-3 just wouldn't fit the vibe of the final season
@@xenogen372 Well... Wit showed me that the world is cruel but beautiful. Seasons 1 and 3 show beautiful sky and nature in cruel and desperate situations. However, like season 4, seasons 1 to 3 are also dark. The difference between wit and mapa is shown here. It's a situation where there's no hope in war, but that's their position, and the world works well regardless of them. It's a dark content, but that's why the bright and colorful atmosphere looks more vivid and realistic. Do you think seasons 1 to 3 look bright and hopeful? That's the power of wit.
@@xenogen372 An aesthetic choice is one thing, making it look _literally_ too dark is another. With the weird filter and everything looking too dark, I couldn't see a damn thing in some scenes and had to increase my computer screen brightness. That's not an aesthetic. It just sucks. Mappa even increased the brightness later themselves in the Bluray. And Mappa defenders always say the "it was an aesthetic choice to depict the dark depressing atmosphere". Like no. That's just stuff you guys came up with to defend Mappa. Attack on Titan was always depressing and dark, from the very first episode.
One thing I've grown to hate is Mappa's overuse of those damn lines in the shadows. It doesn't mix well with how much filters and compositing they do onto the scenes that it just makes it look messier. I know it's an attempt to make the characters seem more detailed and complex without drawing more lines onto them but it just doesnt work. Wit only used those lines on very heavy, high emotion and stakes scenes where characters are emoting a lot.
The funny thing is they don't even draw those lines lmao. They use a software that automatically shades those lines on the drawings. It's why it looks so inconsistent and messy
this brings back the nuance that mappa's lacking and all the scenes seems to finally connects for me. mappa's shadow and line hatching is almost very heavy and harsh, it lose the true emotion the keyframe animators wanted to bring out. now i finally can relate to what the characters really feeling! 😭
You deserve way more recognition for these fixes. Do you post on Tik Tok? I feel like these edits would take off there. Extremely talented man this what I wish Eren looked like now.
1:28 Fellow artist here; your edits are nice, but I can see you struggle to draw faces from a downward up angle. I noticed the same pattern back in the Levi bluray video you made that I just watched before this one. In the timestamp I noted in here, the darkest shaded part of his neck is (I assume) meant to represent the part under his jaw. Because you corrected his face to be downward facing instead of upward, his neck ended up appearing elongated. The elongation occured in addition of your decision to flatten the neck straight, the original curvature of the neck occurs when the neck is in perspective (and when the neck is jutting forwards). The edited version was in overall incorrect anatomical perspective. With that being said, you've done an overall pretty good job in this video, and I wish you good improvements continuing forwards. :)
Fixing face parts like this is essential, but I have to say this is merely an INSTAGRAM version of aot. Clear and glittering taste is attractive but doesn't always make illumination great. Context, atmosphere, and emotion of each character at each moment have to be considered when deciding colorless tone.
ahh, even though they're small, i love the little details and stuff! like making eren's eyes brighter like they were in wit, and ofc, my favourite, 3:48 . the little touches made it look sm better! ah, and at 3:56 his eyes look way less haggard
They should really fix up the coordinate , imo wasn’t vibrant enough , and should polish up the colors , you kept the same character designs but just added more vibrant colors which fit really good
It's close. The official is a really good touch up, but looks like he isn't fazed at all by the Paths tree. Meanwhile here he looks appropriately transfixed and speechless.
@@gamebond6248 субъективно конечно, но два кадра улучшить, это называется - особо ничего, к тому же и так сроки у студии были, если бы это видео вышло одновременно с выходом серии, про сроки можно было бы и не говорить, но видео вышло через 2 недели после выхода серии, то есть дали бы ещё 1-2 месяца, и у маппы было бы тоже самое(как минимум не хуже)
@@snowier studio with deadlines is not the topic nor subjective. You said there's no fix but there's exactly is. Check the Mappa's eren design itself and the corrections are consistent with original design.
@@snowier the anime adaptation and manga design are completely different. The designs for S4 by Kishi are the blend of WIT and Manga design but not individual. Besides manga has rough art and suffers from same face syndrome most of the time while S4 has the most amount of inconsistent drawings in all of the series. You get to see 5 different weird looks of Eren in same season. Previous ep had 12 ADs but only 3 CADs so the facts are obvious. Stay delusional and enjoy the season who am i to convince? I just want the consistency that this season heavily lacks.
![Атака Титанов - "чеховские ружья" Исаямы / Как мангака играет со зрителем? [Обзор Аниме]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ICmsbcuheYk/mqdefault.jpg)
![Attack on Titan - Declaration of War [Historical Footage]](/img/1.gif)
Join the Discord Server, there are many surprises waiting for you there.
The link to the discord is in the description under the video.
You did a great job but you do know mappa drew his hair to short here it was longer in the manga
Absolutely fantastic. Polished like previous seasons. Thanks for fixing his weirdly drawn lips.
3:48 is godly.
i wouldnt say his lips are weird
"polished like previous seasons"
Season one and season three, with clear animation issues: *stares motherfuckerly*
you kinda smell like a baka eren yeager
You clearly should work for a Japanese anime studio, even as a freelancer if you have to. You have an amazing talent and good eyes to notice small imperfections.
Dude I swear to you that with the quality of your animation, if you redo the whole season I'm ready to buy it from you, even at an indecent price (and I'm sure I won't be the only one)
Man you're so freaking talented , you should work as a chief character designer
ruclips.net/video/9g4XtLzFulU/видео.html
Mappa gives Eren like 5 different faces in every episode since season 4 part 1 ( example the table scene 🤦🏾♀️) but you made sure to give him the same one, the one and only Eren and I really like that 👏🏾😊
Mappa is taking faithful to the source material too much, because the manga is more inconsistent with Eren's face not to mention uglier
The way you made the Coordinate bright and shine is soo good! Mappa tried like 3 different versions of it but none looked so beautiful like yours 🤩🌌🌌
I love the higher contrast a lot, and more colors, and man I love erens green eyes
Ok, this is actually breath taking. I have no words.
Your fanmade is much better. Mapa's coloring is always dark and cloudy, but I wanted it to be a little bright and colorful. And I feel so comfortable because you modified the character's face. Thank you so much for satisfying the shortcomings of Mapa!!
Season 4 looking dark and cloudy was an aesthetic choice, as there's practically no hope left for humanity, because of the Rumbling. Having a bright and colorful look like Season 1-3 just wouldn't fit the vibe of the final season
@@xenogen372 Well... Wit showed me that the world is cruel but beautiful. Seasons 1 and 3 show beautiful sky and nature in cruel and desperate situations. However, like season 4, seasons 1 to 3 are also dark. The difference between wit and mapa is shown here. It's a situation where there's no hope in war, but that's their position, and the world works well regardless of them. It's a dark content, but that's why the bright and colorful atmosphere looks more vivid and realistic. Do you think seasons 1 to 3 look bright and hopeful? That's the power of wit.
@@xenogen372 An aesthetic choice is one thing, making it look _literally_ too dark is another.
With the weird filter and everything looking too dark, I couldn't see a damn thing in some scenes and had to increase my computer screen brightness. That's not an aesthetic. It just sucks.
Mappa even increased the brightness later themselves in the Bluray.
And Mappa defenders always say the "it was an aesthetic choice to depict the dark depressing atmosphere". Like no. That's just stuff you guys came up with to defend Mappa. Attack on Titan was always depressing and dark, from the very first episode.
I didn't realize how "off" his eye color was here until you edited them to their usual green. He also just looks more on-model. Very nice!
I love the way you made the paths look! They look so pretty
One thing I've grown to hate is Mappa's overuse of those damn lines in the shadows. It doesn't mix well with how much filters and compositing they do onto the scenes that it just makes it look messier. I know it's an attempt to make the characters seem more detailed and complex without drawing more lines onto them but it just doesnt work. Wit only used those lines on very heavy, high emotion and stakes scenes where characters are emoting a lot.
The funny thing is they don't even draw those lines lmao. They use a software that automatically shades those lines on the drawings. It's why it looks so inconsistent and messy
those 'damn lines" were used in the manga frequently aswell
@@drawsection that's used for shading, those are light. The lines MAPPA use are thick and often used unnecessarily
@@befano691 oh ok
A wait Eren "hear me all subjects of Ymir " fan version.
THIS IS SO PERFECT, OMG. IT LITERALLY LOOKS LIKE IT'S MADE BY WIT, OUTSTANDING JOB
this brings back the nuance that mappa's lacking and all the scenes seems to finally connects for me. mappa's shadow and line hatching is almost very heavy and harsh, it lose the true emotion the keyframe animators wanted to bring out. now i finally can relate to what the characters really feeling! 😭
i’m glad u used the fx on the tree it was lacking without it
amazing work! you work so fast and you do such a great job at bettering these scenes!
Glad you’re back, man. I’ve been dying to see more of your work.
WIT Studio
the rumbling with the comic spine and zero eclipse in the back would have been perfect! (i am big fan of yours, i replaced my og aot with your edits!)
incredible work as always
ep4 has many off looking faces
Mappa does a great job but your attention to lighting is exactly how I want it to look. Great job as always
It's just those little fixed imperfections that what makes the scene much better.
Official blue ray will probably fix these scenes but Mappa should do the lightining much better
As much as I like Mappa's work, this honestly looks way better
3:48 luv that ❤️
I like that your paths are more animate instead of being a static painting of Mappa
good job as always
eren in ep 78 looks weird
Bro back at it again and nailing every detail
Thanks for making these edits
Thank god you clear those lines on the faces, they look disgusting at times
You deserve way more recognition for these fixes. Do you post on Tik Tok? I feel like these edits would take off there. Extremely talented man this what I wish Eren looked like now.
Amazing
1:28 Fellow artist here; your edits are nice, but I can see you struggle to draw faces from a downward up angle. I noticed the same pattern back in the Levi bluray video you made that I just watched before this one. In the timestamp I noted in here, the darkest shaded part of his neck is (I assume) meant to represent the part under his jaw. Because you corrected his face to be downward facing instead of upward, his neck ended up appearing elongated. The elongation occured in addition of your decision to flatten the neck straight, the original curvature of the neck occurs when the neck is in perspective (and when the neck is jutting forwards). The edited version was in overall incorrect anatomical perspective.
With that being said, you've done an overall pretty good job in this video, and I wish you good improvements continuing forwards. :)
So this is like mappa vs wit style But in blu ray now huh
Очень хорошо исправлены лица, но по-моему такой акцент на зеленые глаза явно лишний, ведь в путях синее освещение
I don't get why eren has many different faces throughout the episodes
WoW amazing. Fantastic I wish you made all the animation.
You have to edit the skeletal titan transformation sequence.
But that sequence was already amazing on it's own.
masterpiece
When Vlayd posted I was like "It can't possibly get better its already great" oh how I was wrong 😀
correctly noticed everything from the beginning. Ways and some moments with Eren's face may look better only
perfection
how are you not more popular-
Fixing face parts like this is essential, but I have to say this is merely an INSTAGRAM version of aot. Clear and glittering taste is attractive but doesn't always make illumination great. Context, atmosphere, and emotion of each character at each moment have to be considered when deciding colorless tone.
Nice!!! Awesome work
Would like this 1000x if I could
Amazing work my guy. Whats your opinion on the design of the beast titan in this part of season 4?
I cant believe how fucking good this is, you killed it man
Great work man 👍
so much better
Very nice!
I really like Mappas work. Just wish they didn't make Eren look so chubby.
ahh, even though they're small, i love the little details and stuff! like making eren's eyes brighter like they were in wit, and ofc, my favourite, 3:48 . the little touches made it look sm better!
ah, and at 3:56 his eyes look way less haggard
Goated.
Oh, I like it
Can you do the eren manipulation scene? Its a good scene i just think it needs a bit of reshading and model fixing would be awsome if you did 😈
You should do fan made blu ray for s3 as there’s a lot of off models s with titans and humans.
❤️👌
Holy shit
Somebody show this to Mappa please
Their Path Eren looks like shit
Noice 😌
They should really fix up the coordinate , imo wasn’t vibrant enough , and should polish up the colors , you kept the same character designs but just added more vibrant colors which fit really good
Apply for mappa man 🙌✊
nice keep it up
Mappa paths & Fan-Made Eren
2:57 the official change looks better
It's close. The official is a really good touch up, but looks like he isn't fazed at all by the Paths tree. Meanwhile here he looks appropriately transfixed and speechless.
Are you working for SNR?
エレンといったらやっぱこの鋭い目だよなぁ
Show this to Mappa
Você devia produzir o blu ray do anime incrivel
Wow
Can someone put all the things he fixed and make a episode lol
2:57 and 3:24 Eren looked really off in these shots in the original.
Mappa drawings sucks is not as good as wits...
@@animedxst1105 They fixed it in the Blu Ray.
it looks very cool, that's how WIT would have done it, it keeps WIT's style very well
It's not really wit's style.
Please fix the "That Scenery" scene next 🙏🏼🙏🏼
umma make this in geometry dash too UWUWUWUWU
OwO
ooa
Opa
Эрен накачал губы
Animate Eren's face from the last episode please 🙏
你的修正版把漫畫原作者的作畫特色全部刪除了
並不是你自以為的好看就是好看
雖然二次創作是你的自由
但說真的 一點都不有趣也不尊重漫畫作者還有MAPPA
Eren no tiene los ojos tan verdes, más bien los tiene turquesa, son esa luz de los caminos tan azul ni cagando se le deberían ver así como en el edit.
The 3:48 is what I like in your blu ray, but I think all the other scenes dont really need bluray fix because they are already amazing.
I dont like the idea of everything being so shiny.
особо ничего не исправил
Get some pair of eyeballs sir.
@@gamebond6248 субъективно конечно, но два кадра улучшить, это называется - особо ничего, к тому же и так сроки у студии были, если бы это видео вышло одновременно с выходом серии, про сроки можно было бы и не говорить, но видео вышло через 2 недели после выхода серии, то есть дали бы ещё 1-2 месяца, и у маппы было бы тоже самое(как минимум не хуже)
@@snowier studio with deadlines is not the topic nor subjective. You said there's no fix but there's exactly is. Check the Mappa's eren design itself and the corrections are consistent with original design.
@@gamebond6248 чек манга, чел. Исаяма сам иногда рисовал Эрена как попуща и это передали в адаптации
@@snowier the anime adaptation and manga design are completely different. The designs for S4 by Kishi are the blend of WIT and Manga design but not individual.
Besides manga has rough art and suffers from same face syndrome most of the time while S4 has the most amount of inconsistent drawings in all of the series.
You get to see 5 different weird looks of Eren in same season. Previous ep had 12 ADs but only 3 CADs so the facts are obvious.
Stay delusional and enjoy the season who am i to convince? I just want the consistency that this season heavily lacks.