it is not the right attitude to oppose/condemn people for what they try to do. I really enjoyed this because i dont have the tools/knowledge to dissect the music intellectually/grammatically... such a great listening experience....
Above all, no body in this world has the authority to tell any attempt "a mockery of music" - since nothing is certified as pure and imminent by itself..it is all dependent on how your mind and ear are conditioned.. However educatively or carefully you try to explain purity/immensity, it is only your own likes decorated with words..
I've seen this sivaraman in so many videos(to the extent that i think this person's only job is doing this), dropping hate comments .This person should be reported for harassment to RUclips
I am a big fan of Vidushi Sairam, but I thought this effort was a little tame. Perhaps it is first in a series. Quite pleasant, but both musicians playing it a bit safe and resting in their own domains.
V.S.Sivaraman, age 71, Hyderabad - Being the diciple of Smt Brinda who was an ardent follower of PURITY and CLASSISM, why you do such experiments. I can understand you are trying to adjust yourself with clarinet's scale (not toned to our music) but it is jarring. Madam you are a senior Vidwan, you guide others as you are an excellent exponent of Carnatic music. Please do not make a moclkery of music.
V.S.SIVARAMAN, age 71 HYDERABAD - Why this kolai veri Mrs Aruna Sairam . After becoming popular, though you are good singer in your own style, you cannot spoil the sanctity of classism of carnatic music. Why this experiment of mixing western and Carnatic music both have different scale. Your abhogi is normally good and you are capable of singing better, but the western instrument unless it is toned to our style is not good combination. I feel sorry for your followers including me that you female singers start doing such gimmicks and disappoint them. Being the diciple of Brinda who was traditional pesonfied I do not appreciate thi "gelikoothu".I am really sad for her.
You are a geriatric idiot - age has apparently made you more rigid and stupid. You are being mean and cheap with your comments. Reminds me of a tamil family who got a Kannada lady married to one of their sons. The amount of torture she endured for making rasam "differently" - with a wee bit of jaggery was terrible. Get out of your "well" and see and taste the world outside - it is broader, wider, more diverse than your myopic view. In Samskritam - you are the Manduka in the Koopa ("Koopa Manduka Nyaya"). You may not like something or know something... but you have zero rights to dictate "purity" in anything... You have a few more years... I hope you get a tinge of delayed wisdom. For the record, I love Carnatic, Hindustani, western music and fusion gives me a "wow" factor - something new and interesting - like vidushi ma'm is delivering with painstaking efforts - in spite of whether oldies like you appreciate it or not.
Génial ♥
It's out of this world 😣❤
it is not the right attitude to oppose/condemn people for what they try to do.
I really enjoyed this because i dont have the tools/knowledge to dissect the music intellectually/grammatically...
such a great listening experience....
Exceptional
Awesome performance !!
is the guitar riff from nothing else matters? Pretty sweet!
Nice!!!
I liked it.
Above all, no body in this world has the authority to tell any attempt "a mockery of music" - since nothing is certified as pure and imminent by itself..it is all dependent on how your mind and ear are conditioned.. However educatively or carefully you try to explain purity/immensity, it is only your own likes decorated with words..
I've seen this sivaraman in so many videos(to the extent that i think this person's only job is doing this), dropping hate comments .This person should be reported for harassment to RUclips
அருணா அம்மாவின் தீவிர ரசிகை தான் என்றாலும்., சண்முகப் பிரியாவின் ஆழமான ரசம் எங்கேயோ குறைகிறது.... மன்னியுங்கள்.
saxaphone scale differ with vocal...but i heard shanmugapriya in karukuruchi arrunachalam and TNR s nadaswaram ..here the purity some what missing
I am a big fan of Vidushi Sairam, but I thought this effort was a little tame. Perhaps it is first in a series. Quite pleasant, but both musicians playing it a bit safe and resting in their own domains.
pl clap if u like else keep quiet as music is one's personal expression.
V.S.Sivaraman, age 71, Hyderabad - Being the diciple of Smt Brinda who was an ardent follower of PURITY and CLASSISM, why you do such experiments. I can understand you are trying to adjust yourself with clarinet's scale (not toned to our music) but it is jarring. Madam you are a senior Vidwan, you guide others as you are an excellent exponent of Carnatic music. Please do not make a moclkery of music.
It's not Clarinet it's Saxophone
No infact she has scaled it into a different platform which is loved by many like me
V.S.SIVARAMAN, age 71 HYDERABAD - Why this kolai veri Mrs Aruna Sairam . After becoming popular, though you are good singer in your own style, you cannot spoil the sanctity of classism of carnatic music. Why this experiment of mixing western and Carnatic music both have different scale. Your abhogi is normally good and you are capable of singing better, but the western instrument unless it is toned to our style is not good combination. I feel sorry for your followers including me that you female singers start doing such gimmicks and disappoint them. Being the diciple of Brinda who was traditional pesonfied I do not appreciate thi "gelikoothu".I am really sad for her.
You are a geriatric idiot - age has apparently made you more rigid and stupid. You are being mean and cheap with your comments.
Reminds me of a tamil family who got a Kannada lady married to one of their sons. The amount of torture she endured for making rasam "differently" - with a wee bit of jaggery was terrible.
Get out of your "well" and see and taste the world outside - it is broader, wider, more diverse than your myopic view.
In Samskritam - you are the Manduka in the Koopa ("Koopa Manduka Nyaya").
You may not like something or know something... but you have zero rights to dictate "purity" in anything... You have a few more years... I hope you get a tinge of delayed wisdom.
For the record, I love Carnatic, Hindustani, western music and fusion gives me a "wow" factor - something new and interesting - like vidushi ma'm is delivering with painstaking efforts - in spite of whether oldies like you appreciate it or not.