Since people aren't bothering to read the description, yes. I did do my own take on Tiawa's design for this video. I dont like the dof design since it has bad perspective, and the head is way too big for the body. So I tweaked the design into what I felt looked better and overall more quad-worthy (hence why i added a bit more detail to the face via purple body marks). I also added more contrast between the blue and orange since in the original those colors practically blended together in terms of value, which imo was bad since value to me is important in character design. So yea that's why Tiawa overall looks different here. Hope this clears things up.
this is absolutely astounding! you really understand this song well, the parts that felt empty in the original now feel lively, the transitions between parts of the songs is seamless and enjoyable, and each part is used in meaningful and impactful ways. i wish this was the amber island we got, this puts it to shame
This is actually fire. I really hope they do something like this with the last verse, it really makes it feel like it belongs perfectly. Also Repetilio and Wollabee sound epic, I hope they recreate it similar to that aswell! Great work!
well i dont actually think tring is gonna be that rhythmic realistically, aside from mayve doing more than just one ding should it actually get a rhythm, but it was fun to compose tring in this way regardless
@@WitherofEarth I definitely agree with that, I made this comment knowing tring was probably going to be a disappointment as always, but at least it gets one last hoorah.
@@marshmallowenthusiast9032 i honestly disagree that tring is always a disappointment. the concept of tring alone is genius, and he's just doing his job anyway. there's not much you can do with a triangle after all. that being said, if he did at least more than just one or two dings in his track i feel like he'd get a lot less hate, as more subtle yet supplementary compositions for quads are very underrated in my book (it's half the reason why i love him and plinkajou)
@@WitherofEarth look at the new wave, new tring sounds better but i love the beginning with Sneyser and Woolabee, they should have put that too, with Whaddle stills harmonyze but in the drop doesn't I dunno why. You could update this woth the newer tracks without destroying the older ones, it should be cool
I bet my left kidney that your Incisaur prediction is 100% accurate, I can SO see it playing like that! Edit: This aged like fine wine... Or perhaps a pickled kidney? 🤔
That Tiawa redesign is lit. Though, there still is a few things I’d change about the redesign to make it sit with me even better. - I’d probably change the orange fur to a more brighter tone, like in DOF - I’d also change the feet to a brighter blue - I’d bring back the DOF colours for the tubes, and maybe add some detail on the wood planks - I’d bring back the more circular and bigger eyes it had in DOF - I’d get rid of the visible eye sockets and just make a few dark blue eyelashes at the corners
Drummidary needs some more attention in my opinion, and he's usually like, loud, since in DOF you can hear him loud and clear in basically both his songs
This is fire, perfection, beauty & grace. That's all I can say, because I know if I say anything else I'll either run out of compliments to give or just end up writing out a whole ass essay in the process to convey a simple message lmao.
It pretty much has the same problem 90% of amber monsters do, sounds amazing but doesn't play much, so it could be a let down or not depending on what your opinion is on that issue, personally I say it's pretty solid, huge step up from the quints before it.
def a calmer take on the song than most predictions, I appreciate this unique factor my amber island update 2 prediction coming when adam gives me more soundfonts
I cant believe this came out only a week ago, ive listened to this so many times because its such a bop, especially when tiawa comes in, so good i hope they do this in game
The thing about this is that it probably sounds better than the actual full song 😔😰 Dissapointing that BBB keeps on making them have little tiny parts that don’t impact the song in anyway
i think that's too harsh when each part does actually impact the song in some way. woolabee helps make the pongping solo good, repatillo adds some much needed percussion to the flowah verse, and pongping is a great supporting percussion. i think what BBB is trying to do is make sure there's plenty of room for every monster while still keeping the song at least 3 minutes or under, hence why there's so much call and response. to me it's clear a new employee is composing the island and i wanna give them the benefit of the doubt
@@WitherofEarth I do agree with you to an extent but I just don’t think that BBB should and should’ve just wasted monsters (especially Phangler) that only sing for 3-5 seconds when they could’ve really added a lot more to the song in a great way. I am aware that some of the original voice actors for these monsters left but that can easily be fixed with editing old monsters sounds (like they did with Yelmut) or with new voice actors that can replicate the original sounds well (unlike with Barrb). I do like what they’re going for with the song but that cannot be achieved with giving small little parts to quite a few of these monsters (especially vocalists).
@@Pufflune i think phangler and barrb are just fine personally. right now my biggest issue is the jarring transition between the two different rhythms in the verses, as right now it feels a bit too unnatural
basically fix the general perspective and anatomy, since as of right now her dawn of fire design has terrible perspective, and the torso is basically too small to support the head and legs imo
I loved this idea for the amber island song. It is fire. Which would make sense for the full song of the revival of the fire elementals, every one from DOF. You added these perfectly from DOF to this song. I loved this, and i am really hoping this is at least somewhat like the final official amber island song
I like your tiawa design, it looks a lot more regal and feminine, which I think was the original intention. (I am kind of surprised they didn’t make it purple, since that is the “royal” colour).
i redesigned it. i don't like the original DoF design due to the fact it has bad perspective, wonky anatomy, and very poor value (literally the blue and orange blend together if you desaturate the monster all the way), so i expect that tiawa is gonna get the sneyser treatment and have these issues ironed out by the time it comes to amber island
@@WitherofEarth I do not really like your custom one I didn’t even know if it was tiawa when I saw it I kinda thought like “what is this your oc monster???”
Since people aren't bothering to read the description, yes. I did do my own take on Tiawa's design for this video. I dont like the dof design since it has bad perspective, and the head is way too big for the body. So I tweaked the design into what I felt looked better and overall more quad-worthy (hence why i added a bit more detail to the face via purple body marks). I also added more contrast between the blue and orange since in the original those colors practically blended together in terms of value, which imo was bad since value to me is important in character design.
So yea that's why Tiawa overall looks different here. Hope this clears things up.
The new Tiawa actually looks great. It reminds me of when Sneyser got that massive redesign
I definitely prefer the official Tiawa, but yours is also pretty rad. I don't like Incisaur's design because its head is way too big for me.
I could definitely see your version as a rare or epic pretty good design
The dog design is so cute and this looks like you drew it as a grandparent
they will do the same thing they did with edamimi krillby yelmut etc trust me it wont change at all
this is absolutely astounding! you really understand this song well, the parts that felt empty in the original now feel lively, the transitions between parts of the songs is seamless and enjoyable, and each part is used in meaningful and impactful ways. i wish this was the amber island we got, this puts it to shame
This is actually fire. I really hope they do something like this with the last verse, it really makes it feel like it belongs perfectly. Also Repetilio and Wollabee sound epic, I hope they recreate it similar to that aswell! Great work!
Haha, I guess you can say it's *litreally* fire.
@@miloyall so this is why the fire monsters disappeared for ages people were making fire puns on fire islands
@Dave Miller and you are the reason why 5 children are trying to kill you
I mean, it's called "amber" island for a reason
uhhhhhh grandpa jokes 🤣
I actually like how Barrb sounds in this one!
Barrb sounds OK in this, but the old barrb would sound much much better.
@@policepolicepolice I agree
The sound isn’t changed from the original amber island, but it sounds better because it isn’t by itself.
@@WoeUponThee Yes But BBB might not do a great job at making Barrb sound good in the full song… like other monsters…
The fact you made tring actually impact the song, and add some really good percussion astounds me. Absolutely perfect.
well i dont actually think tring is gonna be that rhythmic realistically, aside from mayve doing more than just one ding should it actually get a rhythm, but it was fun to compose tring in this way regardless
@@WitherofEarth I definitely agree with that, I made this comment knowing tring was probably going to be a disappointment as always, but at least it gets one last hoorah.
@@marshmallowenthusiast9032 i honestly disagree that tring is always a disappointment. the concept of tring alone is genius, and he's just doing his job anyway. there's not much you can do with a triangle after all.
that being said, if he did at least more than just one or two dings in his track i feel like he'd get a lot less hate, as more subtle yet supplementary compositions for quads are very underrated in my book (it's half the reason why i love him and plinkajou)
but he always impacts the songs
@@WitherofEarth look at the new wave, new tring sounds better but i love the beginning with Sneyser and Woolabee, they should have put that too, with Whaddle stills harmonyze but in the drop doesn't I dunno why. You could update this woth the newer tracks without destroying the older ones, it should be cool
Givin me the vibes I need from this island. All we need are the missing quad and quintet elemental that are left
And hex
@@anthonytheyelmet9636 And heptet
@@anthonytheyelmet9636 It was confirmed in the most recent MSM live that the hex monster is actually the wubbox
@@TheLimeWarrior which one
@@TheLimeWarriorWHAT
I like how you added on to the ending. It gives it a calm ending to an epic song.
Sooza.
I bet my left kidney that your Incisaur prediction is 100% accurate, I can SO see it playing like that!
Edit: This aged like fine wine... Or perhaps a pickled kidney? 🤔
Good luck, you don't wanna lose your kidney
What would someone even do with your kidney if they win the bet
noted
@@caramelsgr they would sell the kidney
And I bet my 25 cents that the prediction of incisaur is 95% or less accurate
Amazing video! This is exactly how I pictured the flum ox and final verse to go! The candlevaara and tiawa add so much whenever they're on.
woah this is exactly how i would want the end result to sound for amber island. very nice job bro
I love how you use incisaur in this, it adds a lot
I like how the instrumentals made barrb sound good
fr fr
Their verse (Flowah & barrb) sounds very good now, the same thing about Flum Ox, this author is F-king Mozart of MSM community!
That Tiawa redesign is lit. Though, there still is a few things I’d change about the redesign to make it sit with me even better.
- I’d probably change the orange fur to a more brighter tone, like in DOF
- I’d also change the feet to a brighter blue
- I’d bring back the DOF colours for the tubes, and maybe add some detail on the wood planks
- I’d bring back the more circular and bigger eyes it had in DOF
- I’d get rid of the visible eye sockets and just make a few dark blue eyelashes at the corners
I'll definitely keep these suggestions in mind, as i do have plans to use my take on tiawa again soon
@@WitherofEarth im just wondering what came up with switching tiawa's design? did msm not finish designing it and just left it as tiawa we know today?
So just a lighter and more detailed version
@@dragon-du6ew Not really lighter. Basically just the same but with it’s DOF colour palette and eyes
I want the same design of DOF
Oh my God, this is a masterpiece, we are waiting for this island to be finished
Fr
The woolabee makes the song sound much better in the start of the song. Nice one.
Drummidary needs some more attention in my opinion, and he's usually like, loud, since in DOF you can hear him loud and clear in basically both his songs
continent: loud
clound island: quiet and calm
You did an absoloutly fantastic job on replicating monster sounds to fit this song. I am extremly impressed keep ut the good work!
This is incredible! This sounds official!
This sounds like it would be in the game, absolutely amazing.
This is fire, perfection, beauty & grace.
That's all I can say, because I know if I say anything else I'll either run out of compliments to give or just end up writing out a whole ass essay in the process to convey a simple message lmao.
i love the fact that you actually did something decent with tring
I'm kinda disappointed that repatillo doesn't sound like this in the real thing. It sounds epic here.
It literally sounds like a drill beat I wish msm actually changed repatillo
if only we got a good Repatillo. I hope Drummidary doesn’t let us down.
Don't worry, it will
Don’t worry, it didn’t
It pretty much has the same problem 90% of amber monsters do, sounds amazing but doesn't play much, so it could be a let down or not depending on what your opinion is on that issue, personally I say it's pretty solid, huge step up from the quints before it.
Before Rootitoot : hm, hm very good and well done
In Rootitoot verse: *t-poses and ascends to the God*
def a calmer take on the song than most predictions, I appreciate this unique factor
my amber island update 2 prediction coming when adam gives me more soundfonts
This sounds WAAY BETTER than how the official ended up, sincere congratulation!
Not true, but on the moment it looked like it was better
@@me.pican.los.cocos.un.poco. it is still my opinion
What!? The official one is so much better then this
Gotta be honest, more like a remix
Best sounding prediction by far, also love the redesign (even if i dont think they needed it)
You should definitely update this. Your Candelabra part is _heavenly._
this thing banging man. isnt it crazy that amber island has been out for a year, and this still sounds better than the actual thing
I WISH WOOL BOI SOUNDED LIKE THIS
The real one sounds much worse than this
Nah this suvks
1:59 This part is a banger
the last two sections sound so good oh my goodness
The big Drop was fresh I could see myself listening to this thing every single day
This prediction sounds better than what we actually have
Exactly
Nah
Not really tbh
I agree that this prediction is better than the actual song
I agree
i keep getting this video recommended at least 2 times a day and i watch it every time
This is perfect, for everything.
Also your old videos remind me of someone else.
I cant believe this came out only a week ago, ive listened to this so many times because its such a bop, especially when tiawa comes in, so good i hope they do this in game
The ending is so beautiful, when rootitoot comes i hope they do something like this
The Last seconds was fireeeee AMAZING!❤️🔥
This is great, you made barrb actually work
Yea and yet making flowah also work
I think the problem with baarb is her verse is empty beside her vocals I think once we get more she will be a lot better
i could see this getting into the game! this is, in fact, FIRE!!!
Oh hey, I made that pun too (if you meant it as a pun)
The thing about this is that it probably sounds better than the actual full song 😔😰 Dissapointing that BBB keeps on making them have little tiny parts that don’t impact the song in anyway
i think that's too harsh when each part does actually impact the song in some way. woolabee helps make the pongping solo good, repatillo adds some much needed percussion to the flowah verse, and pongping is a great supporting percussion. i think what BBB is trying to do is make sure there's plenty of room for every monster while still keeping the song at least 3 minutes or under, hence why there's so much call and response. to me it's clear a new employee is composing the island and i wanna give them the benefit of the doubt
@@WitherofEarth I do agree with you to an extent but I just don’t think that BBB should and should’ve just wasted monsters (especially Phangler) that only sing for 3-5 seconds when they could’ve really added a lot more to the song in a great way. I am aware that some of the original voice actors for these monsters left but that can easily be fixed with editing old monsters sounds (like they did with Yelmut) or with new voice actors that can replicate the original sounds well (unlike with Barrb). I do like what they’re going for with the song but that cannot be achieved with giving small little parts to quite a few of these monsters (especially vocalists).
@@Pufflune i think phangler and barrb are just fine personally. right now my biggest issue is the jarring transition between the two different rhythms in the verses, as right now it feels a bit too unnatural
what are your thoughts, now that the song is complete? (i'm here late because this vid randomly popped up in my recommended)
I honestly love your prediction for flowah’s part
Rootitoot as a harmonica is something that i needed in my life. I wish more people did that with rootitoot.
I almost DIED while listening to this. Great job!
First of all, that Tiawa redesign is cool. Second of all, what do you mean by the Sneyser treatment?
basically fix the general perspective and anatomy, since as of right now her dawn of fire design has terrible perspective, and the torso is basically too small to support the head and legs imo
Ok makes sense
@10 Helio Alfonso De La Paz all trees are alive
@@pentumbraphantasm not what he meant but good true 😂
@@WitherofEarth they’re monsters so I don’t really see your point, but alrighty then.
This really should be added. This is the best I've heard!
Great job! Sounds really good!
I loved this idea for the amber island song. It is fire. Which would make sense for the full song of the revival of the fire elementals, every one from DOF. You added these perfectly from DOF to this song. I loved this, and i am really hoping this is at least somewhat like the final official amber island song
Thank god BBB doesn't changed tiawa model too much
the Tiawa part is actual flames it is an inferno of bangers providable only by the Fire monsters that sing this song
Somehow they made a few accurate predictions, playing in specific parts, their sounds, and more-
Wow! Good job I think this island has a lot of potential!
I don't really like the Tiawa redisign you did but I love the sound they make! I also love how this song sounds like and ending to the monster world
Very well done, my friend...
Big Blue Bubble: Oh @#!?$ we gotta change the song! 😯
Tell me why this is so amazing ur just too talented! Love it!
This is by far the best one I've seen so far.
Is it mean to say I like this version a whole lot more then what it is actually turning out to be
nah i agree
Это лучше чем оригинал 😅
Решил пересмотреть
Omg I love this I’ve listened to this so many times it’s so well done I love everything
Edit:listened to this about 75 times
I don't have any words, it's a MASTERPIECE
I think that this prediction is the coolest
I hope the Island turns like this this is very nice
bro, this is literal fire and if it become official it would be so cool
literal because fire element reference lol
For Tiawa I would've just changed the perspective and made her body bigger, I like her DOF design, also Bisonorus sounds reused but I loved this.
wtf do you mean perspective. the definition of perspective is how you look at something
Exactly, To us, it looks like Tiawa is looking downwards. Doesn't take an idiot to figure that out
love what you did with Tring !
2:00 why tiawa looks rare???
Read description
or pinned comment
BigBlueBubble needs to see this
U sure u didn't just get the audio for the full song before they animated it?
Your prediction is better than the actual song ngl
THIS IS AMAZING
Very good prediction! Sounds good
I think that glowl should be playing her fire have part in that last verse when maybe plays.
But overall beautiful.
i know this is outdated but i love how it sounds
This is the best prediction bro this music is so good
This is great, I’d like a combination of this and the official song.
I like your tiawa design, it looks a lot more regal and feminine, which I think was the original intention. (I am kind of surprised they didn’t make it purple, since that is the “royal” colour).
we would love individuals!!!
Nobody else reply but wither
We would!!!!1111
Holy crap tring plays more than one note per verse 😳
My goodness this handles the monsters way better than I feel like BBB will
update after wave 6: still does
update after wave 7: STILL does
Last wave: yeah…
Are we gonna tell this man how the spider Boi looks like the new fire monster that was recently just created?
When I was watching this an add 4 msm popped up
Nice, best prediction
What the hell happened to tiawa
i redesigned it. i don't like the original DoF design due to the fact it has bad perspective, wonky anatomy, and very poor value (literally the blue and orange blend together if you desaturate the monster all the way), so i expect that tiawa is gonna get the sneyser treatment and have these issues ironed out by the time it comes to amber island
@@WitherofEarth though I agree that her anatomy is wonky, I personally think her color palate is fine regardless of the value issue.
How was tiawa's original anatomy wonky
@@WitherofEarth I do not really like your custom one I didn’t even know if it was tiawa when I saw it I kinda thought like “what is this your oc monster???”
@@WitherofEarth did Sneyser have anatomy issues in DOF?
bro I finally like the beginning now, jesus poke now I understand why woolabee is your favorite monster
DUDE THIS IS SO GOOD WHAT
Edit: though i don't like this purple hair that your tiawa has
This is so Good!
That Rootitoot sounds amazing
2:00 I think this it tiawa
This slaps hard
And yes i know its because its head is too 'big' but that is not a reason to change its design entirely.
Why does this video not have more views and likes??? The song is so good
I like ur redesign of tiawa
Man…what could’ve been 😔
ooooh, this is so good!
Hey man can you make a fan made fire monster with unused elemental cobos
I can't unhear this. *EVEN AFTER WAVE 7*
Im lovin it!
yes i do understand it was posted on may.
one small issue.
i connected a composer app to my headphones and its more hilaroius than my "dairy" memes!
another small issue whats the opposite of breakfast?