Yeah, I left a comment on that in the description. Too much confusion due to folks being new to the nations they played. We're doing another one in a few weeks. Thanks for watching and commenting!
From an earlier comment said, I have an update. My friend and I decided to start over and play with several expansions and all available optional rules while recording each turn (as most people do with general updates.) I will be letting people know when I'm doing this event.
You're too kind... I did have some great success with my Nationalist Militia in Spain, that's for sure! See you at the next one! (Check your email for the updates!)
Thanks for watching, Derek! Yeah, it's starting to gain some traction in our area now, so we are hoping to get some more games up in the next while. Hard to get guys to commit to two or three days, though, but we'll do what we can!
The Hilltop Pillbox thinking back to the Italian strategy, I decided that taking Paris didn't work, and that surrounding it was easier to protect the Italians. That, and the capital was always stocked with troops that were extra. Rome is too important to not defend!
Thanks for watching and commenting! Yep, the Spanish Civil War sure adds a layer to the game, and gives the major powers something to do while slowly building towards the "real" war.
You are absolutely correct! We didn't see that, and that's why I was taken by surprise. The note on that is written in Italy's breakdown on page 72, but not on UK's or France's info. Thanks for pointing that out!
if you take over an enemies capital, e.g. japan takes Nanking, would china just not collect an income until they get it back? Im pretty sure that is correct, but if i am wrong please tell me. Im also pretty sure that the only case where the victor (the power that takes over the capital) gets the countries money is when Germany takes paris.
Well, according to the rule book, (pg 48), when a capital is taken, that nation just loses all of its saved money. A few countries can actually set up a second capital and begin gaining income again, so be aware of that. Also, China doesn't really act like a normal power, and will only surrender when all of its units are off the board, and it has no remaining territories. (China is a tough one to completely eliminate, and Japan must be careful about leaving territories open, as the Allies can hop in and activate China again!) Do you happen to have info on Germany taking French money when Paris falls? Our rules set (which may be out of date, only says France loses its money, not gives it to the Germans.) Thanks!
What would the strategy be for build up as it’s quite a change for the axis normally just straight off taking territory now they have 3 turns of build up
I think it's important for the Axis to get whatever they think they'll need up to the front. The Germans need to be mobile, and the Italians MUST put huge pressure on Africa. If Germany doesn't build a sub or two each round, the German navy will be gone, or emasculated, on the first turn UK declares war on Germany. The UK navy is huge, and there's nothing Germany can do about it. The Spanish Civil War can be a big drain, so be careful!
the map is divine!! sorry, but what miniature depicts a sea unit and looks like a sharp nose and square stern !? landing craft or TBDs?? please tell me, you have (the Germans) two types of bomber planes: Dornier 217 and Heinkel 111 (and do not forget that there are also Junkers 87 and 88). Question: do you have a difference between them, are there different characteristics of defense, attack, movement? and the same question on tanks, the difference between light, medium and heavy?
Thanks for watching and commenting! Those sea units depict TBD's, as I don't have the sculpts yet. They weren't even available when we filmed, but they should be here soon! The Heinkels are the strategic bombers, while the Do217's represent air transports. I am still getting all the sculpts, but it takes a while! Tanks are depicted mainly by size - the tiny ones are the light armor, and the huge ones (didn't get that far in this video) would be the heavy tanks. Check out the National Sheets for each nation to see the attack/defense/move/cost for the different units... www.historicalboardgaming.com/Download-Rules-for-GW-1936_c_660.html
Nothing so sci-fi...they are from HBG's game 2025. I was play testing for them, but their focus is on 1936 right now. They carry attack helicopters. Pretty nice sculpt!
Hello Stephen, thanks for watching! I have the big one (96X48), and it is worth it! With the large variety of units (militia, infantry, cavalry, different tanks, different planes, facilities, etc.) the extra space is needed! Enjoy!
Different editions of Risk over the past decade-and-a-half will yield different types of cavalry. There are three of which I am aware: cavalryman on the march with sword held against leg (oldest), cavalryman charging with sword raised, and dragoon firing carbine from horseback (newest). Each set comes in slightly different colors. You can probably buy huge lots of older pieces on eBay for peanuts.
A similar question, I know it says to use Axis and Allies pieces however I see some pieces not in Axis and Allies such as in Spain. Do you know where you got them?
During your video I noticed white units in Europe and was wondering where you got them. Also can you tell me where you get most of your units from, I noticed you had the calvary from Risk.
Where did you buy that units? They are a lot. I know that I have to buy them on HistoricalBoardGame, but it costs $3,75 for 5 units! It's too expensive, because I have to buy lots of units... Do you have any ideas? The video is awesome, but I didn't understand a thing: after the Spainish Civil War can Germany (or USSR) allign Nationalist or Repubblicans?
Hello Luca, thanks for watching and commenting! I got a lot of units from old A&A games, but also little buys here and there from HBG, or friends, or ebay. Just look for deals when they pop up! Yes, after the Civil War is done, Spain can align with the Axis. In fact, it is a Victory Objective for Germany! Have fun!
I just received my global war 1936 map (i decided 1936 over 1939) and it didn't come with national reference sheets... Are the global war 1936 maps meant to come with them? Or do you have to print them yourself.
Yes, you will need to download and print them yourself. If you have a colour printer, it's easy! If not, then a quick trip to Staples or a similar place, and you are ready to go. That's what I had to do. Well worth the cost!
Hello Hilltop, I had a question or maybe two but the first was about a comment you had in the video where you said if Rome was taken, all of the Rome units would have to be taken off the board? Does that mean any units that were in Rome and maybe left and went to say Africa have to be removed or am I reading way too much into it? Also I've been wanting to get one of those printed A&A maps that cliffside had made to enhance my gaming experience but then I found out about this game. I love the nice colors of the 1940 game but this game looks so clean and realistic in it's own way. Everything I've seen so far that you've put out on this game has made me want to get this game more because I can see how realistic it is. But my second question is (finally) can infantry attack a bomber in this game? Sorry for the rambling.
Yes, it is a gorgeous map! And, yes, if Rome falls, Italy surrenders and removes ALL Italian forces are removed from the board. That is printed on the Italian National Sheet. If that happens, it is then up to Germany to protect the southern European sector, just like in the real war! And, yes, if a territory with a bomber is attacked by infantry, they can attack the bomber! Defensive bombers cannot "carpet bomb", as per the rules on page 46 - it's pretty clear it's that it's an attack in enemy territory. Enjoy!
Hey, PS8000, thanks for watching! You can get the map and everything you see here at www.historicalboardgaming.com You can hunt around for a wide variety of units/markers/tokens/expansions. Enjoy!
No, I just put some videos of the game on my channel...if you are wanting it, please head over to historicalboardgaming.com and you'll find what you need! Have fun!
We're pretty sure that China is a bit of a different situation, and yes, they would still collect income from any territories they hold. The only way KMT surrenders is if they lose all their territories and units. Otherwise, they keep slugging away. I think that's a good way to do it, mainly because if the Japanese only have to take and hold Nanking to stop Chinese production, well, that'd be too easy. And boring, strategically-speaking.
Thanks for watching! If I remember correctly, they are the BB's from the Xeno Games "World at War" game. I just painted them white. Seem to work well enough!
Ah, those are sculpts from HBG's Global War 2025. They hold helicopters. (That game is still under development, but I've been play-testing it for them.) We use them for our Torpedo Boat Destroyers until those sculpts are available.
Hello Jorun, You're not the first person to mention that! Just FYI: IPC's are Industrial Production Certificates, which are used in Axis and Allies games. This is a game from Historical Board Gaming, and they use IPP's, which are Industrial Production Points. Hope that clarifies things!
You are one of my favorite axis and allies RUclipsrs
Thanks for that! There are so many of us out here, so make sure you check them all out! Cheers!
Not done watching yet, but France couldn't have declared war on Italy if Italy hadn't yet declared war on anyone else.
Yeah, I left a comment on that in the description. Too much confusion due to folks being new to the nations they played. We're doing another one in a few weeks. Thanks for watching and commenting!
From an earlier comment said, I have an update. My friend and I decided to start over and play with several expansions and all available optional rules while recording each turn (as most people do with general updates.) I will be letting people know when I'm doing this event.
Awesome! I look forward to it!
Excellent video THP! Had a blast and you don't roll too bad, I just rolled above average :)
You're too kind... I did have some great success with my Nationalist Militia in Spain, that's for sure! See you at the next one! (Check your email for the updates!)
I'd like to watch a round in its entirety, purchases, combat moves, combat resolutions, non com moves, placements
This is a great video. Love to see more people playing it!!
Thanks for watching, Derek! Yeah, it's starting to gain some traction in our area now, so we are hoping to get some more games up in the next while. Hard to get guys to commit to two or three days, though, but we'll do what we can!
The Hilltop Pillbox thinking back to the Italian strategy, I decided that taking Paris didn't work, and that surrounding it was easier to protect the Italians. That, and the capital was always stocked with troops that were extra. Rome is too important to not defend!
Awesome video!
Looks like a very cool game, the Spanish civil war looks interesting.
Thanks for watching and commenting! Yep, the Spanish Civil War sure adds a layer to the game, and gives the major powers something to do while slowly building towards the "real" war.
I believe you cannot declare war on Italy before Italy has declared war on another country
You are absolutely correct! We didn't see that, and that's why I was taken by surprise. The note on that is written in Italy's breakdown on page 72, but not on UK's or France's info. Thanks for pointing that out!
if you take over an enemies capital, e.g. japan takes Nanking, would china just not collect an income until they get it back? Im pretty sure that is correct, but if i am wrong please tell me. Im also pretty sure that the only case where the victor (the power that takes over the capital) gets the countries money is when Germany takes paris.
Well, according to the rule book, (pg 48), when a capital is taken, that nation just loses all of its saved money. A few countries can actually set up a second capital and begin gaining income again, so be aware of that. Also, China doesn't really act like a normal power, and will only surrender when all of its units are off the board, and it has no remaining territories. (China is a tough one to completely eliminate, and Japan must be careful about leaving territories open, as the Allies can hop in and activate China again!)
Do you happen to have info on Germany taking French money when Paris falls? Our rules set (which may be out of date, only says France loses its money, not gives it to the Germans.) Thanks!
What would the strategy be for build up as it’s quite a change for the axis normally just straight off taking territory now they have 3 turns of build up
I think it's important for the Axis to get whatever they think they'll need up to the front. The Germans need to be mobile, and the Italians MUST put huge pressure on Africa.
If Germany doesn't build a sub or two each round, the German navy will be gone, or emasculated, on the first turn UK declares war on Germany. The UK navy is huge, and there's nothing Germany can do about it.
The Spanish Civil War can be a big drain, so be careful!
The Hilltop Pillbox thanks very interesting
the map is divine!! sorry, but what miniature depicts a sea unit and looks like a sharp nose and square stern !? landing craft or TBDs??
please tell me, you have (the Germans) two types of bomber planes: Dornier 217 and Heinkel 111 (and do not forget that there are also Junkers 87 and 88). Question: do you have a difference between them, are there different characteristics of defense, attack, movement? and the same question on tanks, the difference between light, medium and heavy?
Thanks for watching and commenting! Those sea units depict TBD's, as I don't have the sculpts yet. They weren't even available when we filmed, but they should be here soon! The Heinkels are the strategic bombers, while the Do217's represent air transports. I am still getting all the sculpts, but it takes a while! Tanks are depicted mainly by size - the tiny ones are the light armor, and the huge ones (didn't get that far in this video) would be the heavy tanks.
Check out the National Sheets for each nation to see the attack/defense/move/cost for the different units...
www.historicalboardgaming.com/Download-Rules-for-GW-1936_c_660.html
Thanks for the answer) so how come these sharp-nosed and what is it at all? they are from the space game?))
Nothing so sci-fi...they are from HBG's game 2025. I was play testing for them, but their focus is on 1936 right now. They carry attack helicopters. Pretty nice sculpt!
thanks, I understand)
Hey Hilltop, what size map did you order for 1936? Love how you get some room to breath with units.
Hello Stephen, thanks for watching! I have the big one (96X48), and it is worth it! With the large variety of units (militia, infantry, cavalry, different tanks, different planes, facilities, etc.) the extra space is needed! Enjoy!
Love It... I see China green cavalry and Russian colored cavalry. How can I get those pieces? Where I mean? Thank you again for great Battle Report.
Thanks for watching! Those cavalry pieces are the ones from a particular version of Risk. Andy brought those, and they worked well.
Different editions of Risk over the past decade-and-a-half will yield different types of cavalry. There are three of which I am aware: cavalryman on the march with sword held against leg (oldest), cavalryman charging with sword raised, and dragoon firing carbine from horseback (newest). Each set comes in slightly different colors. You can probably buy huge lots of older pieces on eBay for peanuts.
Yep! Deals are out there!
A similar question, I know it says to use Axis and Allies pieces however I see some pieces not in Axis and Allies such as in Spain. Do you know where you got them?
Michael Twilling, Historical Board Gaming’s website.
During your video I noticed white units in Europe and was wondering where you got them. Also can you tell me where you get most of your units from, I noticed you had the calvary from Risk.
Can you do gameplay on axis and allies Europe 1999 edition please
That's on the horizon...the Christmas break should help with a few rounds of A&A of different varieties.
Where did you buy that units? They are a lot. I know that I have to buy them on HistoricalBoardGame, but it costs $3,75 for 5 units! It's too expensive, because I have to buy lots of units... Do you have any ideas? The video is awesome, but I didn't understand a thing: after the Spainish Civil War can Germany (or USSR) allign Nationalist or Repubblicans?
Hello Luca, thanks for watching and commenting!
I got a lot of units from old A&A games, but also little buys here and there from HBG, or friends, or ebay. Just look for deals when they pop up!
Yes, after the Civil War is done, Spain can align with the Axis. In fact, it is a Victory Objective for Germany! Have fun!
I just received my global war 1936 map (i decided 1936 over 1939) and it didn't come with national reference sheets... Are the global war 1936 maps meant to come with them? Or do you have to print them yourself.
Yes, you will need to download and print them yourself. If you have a colour printer, it's easy! If not, then a quick trip to Staples or a similar place, and you are ready to go. That's what I had to do. Well worth the cost!
Hello Hilltop, I had a question or maybe two but the first was about a comment you had in the video where you said if Rome was taken, all of the Rome units would have to be taken off the board? Does that mean any units that were in Rome and maybe left and went to say Africa have to be removed or am I reading way too much into it?
Also I've been wanting to get one of those printed A&A maps that cliffside had made to enhance my gaming experience but then I found out about this game. I love the nice colors of the 1940 game but this game looks so clean and realistic in it's own way. Everything I've seen so far that you've put out on this game has made me want to get this game more because I can see how realistic it is. But my second question is (finally) can infantry attack a bomber in this game? Sorry for the rambling.
Yes, it is a gorgeous map! And, yes, if Rome falls, Italy surrenders and removes ALL Italian forces are removed from the board. That is printed on the Italian National Sheet. If that happens, it is then up to Germany to protect the southern European sector, just like in the real war!
And, yes, if a territory with a bomber is attacked by infantry, they can attack the bomber! Defensive bombers cannot "carpet bomb", as per the rules on page 46 - it's pretty clear it's that it's an attack in enemy territory. Enjoy!
Thank you for the reply. I'm making my way through your 1936 series. Im really enjoying your content! Keep up the good work!
Thanks for watching and commenting! There sure is a lot to this game, and we still make mistakes, but the more we play, the better we get!
Thanks for watching! I appreciate the support!
Where do I get this?!?!?!?!
Hey, PS8000, thanks for watching! You can get the map and everything you see here at www.historicalboardgaming.com
You can hunt around for a wide variety of units/markers/tokens/expansions. Enjoy!
And can you do it with Klaus and all the other people like Ivan and Nigel
I'll see if I can afford them...ugh. Unions.
nice car alarm
Do u sell a set of 1936?
No, I just put some videos of the game on my channel...if you are wanting it, please head over to historicalboardgaming.com and you'll find what you need! Have fun!
so it does collect income even if Nanking is occupied?
We're pretty sure that China is a bit of a different situation, and yes, they would still collect income from any territories they hold. The only way KMT surrenders is if they lose all their territories and units. Otherwise, they keep slugging away.
I think that's a good way to do it, mainly because if the Japanese only have to take and hold Nanking to stop Chinese production, well, that'd be too easy. And boring, strategically-speaking.
"Just Like Canadian Money! Probably worth more too" HA!
Sad, but not so far off...
What sculpt are you using for neutral battleships?
Thanks for watching! If I remember correctly, they are the BB's from the Xeno Games "World at War" game. I just painted them white. Seem to work well enough!
The Hilltop Pillbox, maybe I’m thinking of the cruisers? The ones that look fairly flat. Like arsenal ships.
Ah, those are sculpts from HBG's Global War 2025. They hold helicopters. (That game is still under development, but I've been play-testing it for them.) We use them for our Torpedo Boat Destroyers until those sculpts are available.
Nice! Helicopter carriers sound like a great addition to the Modern War game.
Yep! The helicopters aren't ready, either, so we use the ones from Fortress America. Fun!
Ipcs NOT IPPs ARG
Hello Jorun,
You're not the first person to mention that! Just FYI: IPC's are Industrial Production Certificates, which are used in Axis and Allies games. This is a game from Historical Board Gaming, and they use IPP's, which are Industrial Production Points.
Hope that clarifies things!
I would um bulldozer up in Pakistan if i was france the germans have to go through ther to get around the lansikio Line
Is that what it,s caled?
Are you perhaps referring to the Maginot line between France and Germany? If so, that was the French hope, but it didn't work out!
Frenc resitenc
Ipc