People say that her voice was terrible in butterfly and rainbow era i think it is her eras that showed vulnerability through her voice. Absolutely beautiful
This song is absolutely impossible I don’t know how she did this even in the studio. She’s switching registers every other word and just when you’ve blown your voice out from high belts there’s a massive key change and like I said register switches every word. It’s insane.
Trust me it’s better to sing this in studio since on studio you can have different takes and find the best version. On live, it’s only 1 take. Don’t act like she sang this on studio in just 1 take lol
Her songs and her voice are too beautiful. But when she struggles, it becomes more real and more gorgeous. Her musicality is overflowing. And her adlibs here were genius.
@@usedtobe1197 My All was actually the penultimate song recorded for the album. And it was recorded in July 1997. It was the last song Mariah and Walter did and they fell out before it was done and that's why there is no bridge for My All. They didn't write one because they never met to finish it
@@kijanayoung2000Where exactly would the bridge be in My all? like the song is already great without it and very difficult to sing, imagine with it.😮😮
@J_rob13 last song. With Butterfly the ballad. Mid 1997. Fly Away reprise was recorded before Butterfly the ballad. Even when you hear her voice on Butterfly the ballad and My All they sound similar (listen to the F5s on "For you'll NEVER be mine" in the bridge of Butterfly and cause I can't go on on My All Chorus) they sound like they were recorded within the same month. Mid 1997
This is my favourite Mariah song and I've only just discovered she performed it in Taipei, I just moved to Taiwan for uni and have been in Taipei, I didn't think big artists like Mariah came here
Idk why you said whenever you call was gonna be bad. I can hear her voice pretty well! Only hissing but I don't mind! Love this. This is one of the best ballads. Thank you!
1 of Theee most difficult songs to sing LIVE in A FULL LIVE CONCERT OF 60 MINUTES AND MORE!!!!! NOT THAT IT WAS RECORDED MANY TIMES FOR A TELEVISION 📺SHOW......💪💪💪💪bravo MC🎤🎤🎤
As man this song is still difficult to sing even lowered a whole octave. To hold an Eb4 belt which is followed by lots of shifts between E4-G#4 in head voice or belting is very challenging. Not to say that those notes are done with riffs and runs
This was a bit of a mess. She's only human - no one is perfect, but this video also makes me think that 1997 was the year she started having voice issues. 1990-1996 were the golden years vocally. And for this song in particular, Daydream Mariah would have had this song for breakfast, lunch and dinner.
She is a human being, just like anyone else. Every singer has good days and bad days. Keep in mind that the range in which this song is placed is extremely difficult to sing. If you don't believe me, try singing this song and see if you can even get past the first chorus. It takes a lot of energy, stamina, and pretty much being in perfect form - not to mention your intonation and agility has to be insanely good - so I applaud Mariah for doing this song live during a time when we know she was struggling in her life.
@@bohlalenchabeleng1370 She hasn't smoked since she was 18yo. About alcohol, I don't know for sure, I can't give an opinion. I think the nodules and her psychological state during that period were the biggest reason.
1998 was literally the worst her voice have ever been. And to have the audacity to try to sing this hard a$$ song is just crazy. I get tired just listening to the climax let alone try to sing it.
"the worst her voice has ever been" i'm gonna stop you then and there. sure, butterfly era wasn't belting the high notes with the effortlessness of daydream era; BUT in 1998 she still was very good vocally. you want the "worst" her voice has ever been? listen to the toronto 2000 concert.
What do you mean “to have the audacity to try to sing this hard song”, If they can why not? There are singers can sing this song with no struggle. Well, as a fan we should accept. :)
![10 Honey - Mariah Carey live at Taipei, January 24th 1998 [REMASTERED]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/rV6EIC97_QY/mqdefault.jpg)
![10 Honey - Mariah Carey live at Taipei, January 24th 1998 [REMASTERED]](/img/tr.png)
![[RARE] Mariah Carey - Whenever You Call (Live in Perth, Butterfly Tour - 1998) UNHEARD SOUNDBOARD](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/X2KWzNX9jSU/mqdefault.jpg)
![케이윌 & 효린 - Whenever You Call [101212 김정은의 초콜릿]](/img/1.gif)
People say that her voice was terrible in butterfly and rainbow era i think it is her eras that showed vulnerability through her voice. Absolutely beautiful
This song is absolutely impossible I don’t know how she did this even in the studio. She’s switching registers every other word and just when you’ve blown your voice out from high belts there’s a massive key change and like I said register switches every word. It’s insane.
No need to wonder since it’s better to sing this on studio to perfect every note by repeating the parts she struggles with.
she doesn't switch registers - this are not registers this is just a lot of vocalizing
Ofcourse she is switching registers she’s going from a breathy falsetto to a chesty belt and back and forth.
you can clearly hear the recorded track kicking in at 3:08 and then stopping at 3:20
Trust me it’s better to sing this in studio since on studio you can have different takes and find the best version. On live, it’s only 1 take. Don’t act like she sang this on studio in just 1 take lol
Her songs and her voice are too beautiful. But when she struggles, it becomes more real and more gorgeous. Her musicality is overflowing. And her adlibs here were genius.
I just wish she recorded this this daydream era, because in studio version, it sounds like she recorded that in 1995-1996.
Provavelmente no início de 1997, uma da primeira músicas a serem gravadas juntamente com My All!
@@usedtobe1197 My All was actually the penultimate song recorded for the album. And it was recorded in July 1997. It was the last song Mariah and Walter did and they fell out before it was done and that's why there is no bridge for My All. They didn't write one because they never met to finish it
@@kijanayoung2000Where exactly would the bridge be in My all? like the song is already great without it and very difficult to sing, imagine with it.😮😮
@@kijanayoung2000I thought My all was one of the first to be recorded, since it's one of the main singles.
@J_rob13 last song. With Butterfly the ballad. Mid 1997.
Fly Away reprise was recorded before Butterfly the ballad. Even when you hear her voice on Butterfly the ballad and My All they sound similar (listen to the F5s on "For you'll NEVER be mine" in the bridge of Butterfly and cause I can't go on on My All Chorus) they sound like they were recorded within the same month. Mid 1997
She makes her songs so difficult in the studio, forgetting she would one day have to sing it live 😂😂😂😂
😂 That's my queen
The best singer is the one who can do songs not even they can replicate 😂
Sounded like she was having an off day. Wasn’t bad, wasn’t too good either though lol.
the fact that she even admitted that. she really made it impossible to perform her songs live (in original key, that is) 😭
but that means her prime performances hold a greater value ✨
Wow! The pre recorded track at the climax sounds so obvious
It could be or probably she moved the mic far away from her mouth while hitting the high notes in the climax.
@@benjaminbawa5273 Yeah! A lamb told me it was pre recorded in that climax part
@@JohnDeLeon28
Okay. 👍🏻
this is breathtaking.
The lower key version of this song makes me wanna cry
Looooove 3:25 her tone on “hesitate” 😍 might be a lil pulled but it’s so powerful and emotional
I love struggled-riah.. still her voice is beautiful better than us.. hello????
Struggledriah lmao... But yeah, I mean, even at her worst moment, she's better than any other vocalist on Earth
@@qwert2020 hahaha that's very true.. mariah is a monster.
Of course if you can’t sing she’s better lol
This is my favourite Mariah song and I've only just discovered she performed it in Taipei, I just moved to Taiwan for uni and have been in Taipei, I didn't think big artists like Mariah came here
Watching this again now as I’m leaving Taiwan in less than 2 weeks :( the best country in the world 🇹🇼
I wish she also sang this on her first night in Tokyo Dome cuz her voice sounded literally like 1996riah.
But I know she recorded this song in 1997.
@@jaimydionisio1633 potato
@@flyingbaloon6358 slay
@@Pkjopjpo-zm7dy ofc 🙄💅
I feel she might’ve even attempted the whole thing live if she did it in Tokyo.
Idk why you said whenever you call was gonna be bad. I can hear her voice pretty well! Only hissing but I don't mind! Love this. This is one of the best ballads. Thank you!
best performance of this song 🤥
*Me when I lie*
@@butterflyera4628 me when im correct
I'm just screwing with ya 🐸
@@butterflyera4628 what is it then? oh wait i forgot! its brisbane! definetly the best 🤥🤩
@@musicboxtour5854 NAWWWW
Lovely performance I would literally kill someone to see this live
Same here. The Perth recording/performance makes me cry
@@Neonlike0 Sameee
1 of Theee most difficult songs to sing LIVE in A FULL LIVE CONCERT OF 60 MINUTES AND MORE!!!!! NOT THAT IT WAS RECORDED MANY TIMES FOR A TELEVISION 📺SHOW......💪💪💪💪bravo MC🎤🎤🎤
3:31 So beautiful 😭
3:59 YOU BETTA RUNNN
Right? It gave me chills, I love her lower register
I really like this
As man this song is still difficult to sing even lowered a whole octave. To hold an Eb4 belt which is followed by lots of shifts between E4-G#4 in head voice or belting is very challenging. Not to say that those notes are done with riffs and runs
Where is that picture from?
brisbane
This was a bit of a mess. She's only human - no one is perfect, but this video also makes me think that 1997 was the year she started having voice issues. 1990-1996 were the golden years vocally. And for this song in particular, Daydream Mariah would have had this song for breakfast, lunch and dinner.
Why they’re laughing?
A versão de Estúdio soa como se ela cantasse em 1995 ou 1996, então gravaram antes e só lançaram em 1997
Actually no! It was recorded early 97. Nothing from the Butterfly Album was recorded before 97. The recordings were completed in July, 97.
👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍🎤🎤🎤🎤🎵🎵🎶🎶🎶🎼🎼🎼🎼
Taipei >Perth>Brisbane I think
agreed
Yuh
@@MIXANDMTCH Perth - Taipeï - Brisbane
What happens to her Voice?
Excessive alcohol abuse, smoking and overusing her voice. She was dealing with a bad divorce.
She is a human being, just like anyone else. Every singer has good days and bad days. Keep in mind that the range in which this song is placed is extremely difficult to sing. If you don't believe me, try singing this song and see if you can even get past the first chorus. It takes a lot of energy, stamina, and pretty much being in perfect form - not to mention your intonation and agility has to be insanely good - so I applaud Mariah for doing this song live during a time when we know she was struggling in her life.
@@bohlalenchabeleng1370 nodules
Alcohol and singing don't go great together. I dont even think she oversang that much.
@@bohlalenchabeleng1370 She hasn't smoked since she was 18yo. About alcohol, I don't know for sure, I can't give an opinion. I think the nodules and her psychological state during that period were the biggest reason.
1998 was literally the worst her voice have ever been. And to have the audacity to try to sing this hard a$$ song is just crazy. I get tired just listening to the climax let alone try to sing it.
"the worst her voice has ever been" i'm gonna stop you then and there. sure, butterfly era wasn't belting the high notes with the effortlessness of daydream era; BUT in 1998 she still was very good vocally. you want the "worst" her voice has ever been? listen to the toronto 2000 concert.
2022 says hi, compared to nowadays, her voice is superb here
1998 is far from her worst! 2000, bits of 2006, and 2022 were worse!
What do you mean “to have the audacity to try to sing this hard song”, If they can why not? There are singers can sing this song with no struggle. Well, as a fan we should accept. :)
Of course she can sing this in the studio because they can edit it🙄🙄
She sang it here in this video live fool. Your inferior faves will not even be able to sing the verse of this song without fainting.