In 20th century and late nineteenth, in the Bangla language most literature & poetry written were of Renaissancist & nationalistic tones thus perpetuating Social Revolution (Earliest home of Indian Renaissance) & Political Revolution (the hub of Independence Movement) . If u can read Bankim Chandra and also then Sarat Chandra, Vibhutibhusan, Rabindranath etc then you would understand the tremendous effect. In Gitanjali, most of the poems of are severe high quality like "Where the Mind is without fear..." that ends with " Let my Bharat awake in that heaven". A socio-political liberation message it leaves. Similarly Sarat Chandra(who town I live) wrote in "SriKanta" novel " at one place addressing a Christian Convert Babu, "...speaking in bengali only doesn't make one bengali, being bengali it's a hindu ethnicity" !!! And Everyone knows about Bankim too.
The Bengali humanist and liberalist movement has been hijacked, imo. I guess there was an undercurrent even in the days of the Bengal Renaissance, but started surfacing sometime in the 60s and became mainstream by the 80s.
Kya har kabhi purani movies ka gungaan gane lag jate ho. Pata bhi he ise kisi ne pasand nhi kiya tha us samay? Banti to Aaj bhi he, tum log Singham aur Pathaan ke aage dekho tab toh pata chalega na.@@sachinsharma-vi3lr
Movie name - Party (1984) Yeh movie ek naatak pe addharit hai aur ise National Film Development Corporation ne produce ki thi. Isiliye isme masala kum aur substance jyaada hai......
I did not know people watch this kind of content on YT, Thank you for creative use to ask relevant questions and provoke the audience in the RIGHT direction.
Correct your sentence.... Narrative can also be flown through Art... Art can even be weaponized to demonize the narrative. Art can live isolated. But Narratives need medium. Same is true with Politics. Politics need mediums. Art is more sought-after by politicians. Also politics made Art vulnerable too.
@@elfvibe241 I will disagree , urdu words are on decline compared to 80s and 90s and that's a good sign because they are replaced with English when I listen dialogues from movies 50%+ words are hindi and 20 % still are from urdu but still it is a decline from where 50% urdu words in 80s movies , however news Channels still use urdu words which is surprising because rural India incline on more hindi words, this shows urdu writers are like communists trying their best to not die....
जब लोगों को ये विषय समझ नहीं आते थे तब ऐसी फिल्में बनाई जातीं थीं अब जब लोग ये समझने मे सक्षम हैं तो विक्की विद्या का वो वाला वीडियो जैसी फिल्में बनाई जाती हैं। हमारी शिक्षा ने हमारी काबिलियत तो बड़ाई पर हमें उसे प्रयोग में लाना नहीं सिखा पाई।
दरअसल ये विषय तब तो समझ आते थे क्योंकि उस वक्त माहौल और शिक्षा दोनों में इस विमर्श को समझने लायक़ शिक्षा दी जाती थी । आज स्तर इतना गिर चुका है कि आज का स्नातक का विद्यार्थी भी इस विमर्श को नहीं समझ पाएगा ।
@@dixitanupam मेरा मतलब एक बड़ा वर्ग कृषि से जुड़ा था तो शिक्षा इतनी विस्तारित नहीं थी। आज अगर इंजीनियरिंग का छात्र भी है तो इंटरनेट के माध्यम से भी इन बातों को समझ सकता है बशर्ते वह ऐसा चाहे।
@@AbhimanyuSingh-ps4leकृषि से जुड़े वर्ग को समझदार न समझना ही नासमझ कि निशानी है। समाज में एक म्यूचुअल एंड मॉरल अंडरस्टैंडिंग थी पहले जो अब विलुप्त होती जा रही है । पहले वर्ग थे सबके जैसे आज के समय हर काम हर कोई नहीं कर सकता वैसे हि पहले भी कृषि करने वाले को कृषि आना चाहिए बाकी सब सेकेंडरी था । जबकि अब जानते सब है लेकिन काम एक भी ढंग से नहीं कर पाते और सामाजिक तानाबाना भी अब ध्वस्त हो गया है और आत्मभोगी बन कर रह गए है सब।
Hindus need to see their way of life as the biggest objective to save. It's no secret that we Hindus place over emphasis on financial stability over other things. Art is a big force to bring back that change in Hindu mindset. More intellectuals, artists, opinion makers need to carry forward that re-inforcement with their writings, arts, depictions, articles....🚩
KolaKata - The birth place of Indian Communists/Marxists politics which used to be one of the most prosperous piece of this huge land we call Hindustan, now in 2024 is one of the most poor land. It's poverty is severs then sub-sharan land of Af. Shame! Kolkata's politics/society was hijacked by these scoundrels.
The ecosystem is created with the help of political awareness among masses and long-term vision of the leadership, somehow both are missing among Hindus.
Absolutely important lesson. I appreciate your stance. That's why people like Sanjeev Sanyal, Vikram Sampath must be supported from large no of hindus. If you want to change the narrative then you will require such intellectuals in academic.
Iss pure video may sirf ek pal hai jaha pay communist/vampanti vichardhara khud apne pair pe kulhadi maar leta hai. OM Puri ka character 4.04 pay full commitment maangta hai but asli zindagi se usse kuch matlab nahi hai. Bohot ache se ye drishya banayi gayi hai. Excellent work!!!
This reminded me of the movie "man from the earth". Few people sitting in a room having an awasome discussion about life and meaning. Kind of movies.. serials they were creating that time in Indian cinema. We are clearly going backwards from that time. Mass studios are killing art.. We are loosing meaning.
The purity of art comes from the heart. It's an expression of the divine. Such a pure work gains appreciation and becomes a source of wonder and inspires generations through the passage of time. True art is divine which inspires today and forever. The source of it is pure love, for the pure love of giving and doing the best without an itch in the heart for future appreciation or returns. Such a state of working is consistent devotion which is aligned with the principles of Dharma I.e. to support, to hold, to maintain. Dharma is often referred to as the law of righteousness, providing guidelines of ethics, behaviors, and traditions meant to help people fulfill the best versions of themselves. To sum up, it is the artist's duty to dedicate his / her work towards the divine which of it's own promotes Dharma over time. However, utilization of art for political purposes in modern times has seen the corruption of art and the artist, as the mind of the artist has got swayed or influenced by powers which seem to be very noble on the surface, but deep down these powerful people have selfish agendas. Essentially, this is the beginning of the exploitation of the artist's simple heart and his / her artistry. To conclude, being talented is not enough, but along with that being rooted in Dharma is the anchor that is needed so that the talent is not hijacked by Adharmic forces, posing as a Dharmic force, as Communism / Leftism has been portraying itself over the last century by it's limited understanding or denial to appreciate Spirituality and Religion, by misleading generations, because at the core of Communist power are a handful of megalomaniac leaders. Similarly, artists who work for their selfish interest and who use their talent to knowingfully corrupt society and justify their action as freedom of expression and speech are simply prostitutizing their talent. Unfortunately, under Leftist influence, people and especially the youth are brainwashed upon the appreciation of Spirituality and Religion which is showcased as a 'system' to stifle people whereas it is the reverse as Spirituality and Religion helps to dive within to know one's true nature and come to appreciate the Divinity within and come to understand the unity in diversity, unlike Communism where individual freedom has no place, and where people are treated as slaves under the command of the megalomaniacs in power. On the surface Communism seems quite seductive, but in reality it is not productive for the betterment of humanity.
Narrativeless Education/arts and Entertaiment is a must. infact entertainment must be all about breaking these unnatural adharmic non-indegenious narratives with appropriate arts and answers. Jai Maa Sharda 🙏
I am completely blown away by the fact that we used to make such films in India at one point of time. My salute to those who made this film ❤👏🙏. I guess the answer lies in the fact that the art produced by the left resonated with the people because it was in favour of liberty and social justice in the creation of an egalitarian society while the right wing ideologies seek to re establish the conservative old world order that help to establish a society with rigid social hierarchies on the basis of oppression. Art will resonate with the people only as long as it is in favour of freedom, liberty. The same can be observed in the case of the former Soviet Union and East Germany where the left wing political movements “in favour of the people” eventually turned oppressive. In these societies art that was sanctioned by the regime was rejected by the people and the art that spoke for the individual and his liberty had to go underground because of political oppression and found resonance with the people there. Art that aligns itself with power becomes propaganda. Power in general and especially tyrannical power is opposed to uncomfortable truths which is what egalitarian art seeks to establish. The human soul ultimately seeks liberty and its own liberation. No matter what sort of contortions one seeks to attempt in the creation of a society that is based on political ideologies that are fundamentally oppressive, it will eventually be rejected by the people.
Which liberty and freedom, that you are only allowed and correct only when you agree with me, leftist are hardcore authoritarian. There is no voice of dissent in any leftist regime, either you agree with them or you are dead, this is freedom for you....😂😂😂😂😂
You have hit the nail on the head with your comment here, but one thing you got wrong towards the end and towards the start as well. The idea you expressed that political ideology based system is almost always oppressive and the idea that right wing is almost always rigid is in itself an assertion of the left cabal. The point is divide or fight between left and right is meaningless when we see the true nature of human populace that craves for chaos when order seems stiffling and craves for order when chaos/freedom seems unsettling.
Wealth is created by the entrepreneurs not by the so called artists. Only when people have so etching to eat, they can think of art and artists! This kind of views are irrelevant in this age if knowledge based economy.
@kmrao06 Focussing on wealth alone and neglecting art will only serve to create a materialistic society that will eventually lose its soul. This will only come at the expense of the collective mental health of the nation. Just like money can ensure that people are well fed and have a sound body, Art and its associated public discourse will help the nation have a sound mind by making sure its citizens remain thinking people and not be prone to being brainwashed by nefarious political elements whose overarching aim is to capture power in order to the realize their own private agendas. If wealth distribution is unequal, it will have increasing consequences on social order, cohesion and harmony the more unequal and the longer it remains so. In Germany, college education used to free and I believe is priced nominally these days. School education is compulsory. This is because they consider education a national security issue. This is understandable given the history of that country. It is because their leaders realised early on that only collective reason can remain a bulwark against the marauding right in that county. There is generous space for the arts, for the conservation of nature and for sound public discourse. It’s a shame we don’t realize the value of these things over here. At the end of the day neglecting collective mental peace and well being will come at a heavy cost that all the money in the world will not be able to buy.
Our Rishis 🙏🙏🙏 always spoke the truth, writing them As it Is literally Itihasa. Truth is more important than Political Correctness, as Political Correctness is driven by the selfish motive to appear as correct, and develop an image essentially smacks of selfishness. Truth is the only correct. Isn’t lying to save lives, rapes, honour etc.., when faced with Evil, correct ? We all do it. In that context lying is correct. What then is truth ?. Our Shastras🙏🙏🙏, Vedas🙏🙏🙏, Upanishads🙏🙏🙏, Puranas🙏🙏🙏, Itihasas 🙏🙏🙏always emphasize the Supremacy of Dharma ?. What does Dharma about Satya, being badgered about by us (mostly Secular = Idiots) as Truth !. Satya is more more more subtler than Truth. Lord Krishna 🙏🙏🙏 quotes the Vedas (in the Battle of Kurukshetra ) to Yuddishtra 🙏🙏🙏, and says “BUTHA-HITA YATHARTHA BASHANAM EVA SATYAM”, and told Yuddishtra to tell that Ashwathama has died. In our Secular/ Legal Language, Krishna 🙏🙏🙏 told Yuddishtra 🙏🙏🙏 to lie. The lying, however, is Satya as per Vedas 🙏🙏🙏 and Krishna 🙏🙏🙏 says it is Satya. Scriptures 🙏🙏🙏 says “Acharyasya Prabhu Dharmaha - Dharmasya Prabhu Achyutaha 🙏🙏🙏”, which loosely translates to “Conduct should be as per Dharma, as Dharma is Governed by Achyuta 🙏🙏🙏 aka the one who does not leave our Hand at all. Dharma is supreme. First Dharma, then everything else. Period. Stalin committed numerous Genocides, and was hugely immoral. Marx was the very epitome of Laziness, Incompetence, Parasitic, Womanizer, Evangelical Christian. Mao is another version of Stalin. Che Guevara was a Dog, a Coward, Genocidic, loved killing people, most immoral and killed like a Coward and a Dog. Unfortunately, many nice people with good morals were swayed by Communist Propaganda. In Bharat, two masterly Civilizations, Bengali and Malayali, have been brought to near extinction by this Dangerous Propaganda. Naxalism in Bharat is a dangerous combination of Marxism, and Evangelical Christianity. Communism is Adharma, and should be destroyed from its roots. Hindus need to treat Jihadi Islam, Evangelical Christianity, Marxism, Maoism, Wokeism, Liberalism (rather what is touted as liberalism), Bollywood, DMK, Naxalism, .. anything that is against Dharma is Adharma aka Evil in the language we speak now. Evil is to be eliminated from its roots. The fight, hence, should be on all fronts, Ideological, Political, Street, .. Shatru-Bodh is critical. Identify the enemies, including their diabolically dangerous propaganda. Post Script : Drona knew Ashwathama was immortal, and would not die. Still he put down his weapons. What is actually the vow of Guru Drona 🙏. There are so many Subtleties in our Scriptures 🙏🙏🙏. Gross hearts, Puny Intellects, Evil Minds.. cannot imagine the depth of them. Drona 🙏 actually vowed he would put down his weapons, when he heard anything “Amangal” from a real good virtuous person. That real good virtuos person, Yuddishtra 🙏🙏🙏 was told by Krishna 🙏🙏🙏 that Aswathamma died. Period. War is subtle on all fronts. Sound the yuddagosha Shankanadha aka War Bugle || Hara Hara Mahadeva 🙏🙏🙏|| || Jaya Bhavani 🙏🙏🙏|| || Sree Matre Namaha 🙏||
Not necessary. It could also mean true to the constitution. We Hindus are internally very weak . People can easily divide us and take advantage. Unless we find a common ground and make it stronger politicians will continue to exploit us. No matter what happens we should never support mob violence.
Ye tum bas aise hi bol rahe . Propaganda movie to ban hi Rahi like kashmiri files, kerala story, 72 hoor, sabarmati express Aur har movie me muslim ko atankwadi dikhaya hi jata h... Ab aur kya chahte ho ?
ईश्वर ऐसे लोगों से बचाए जो खुद को सर्वज्ञानी समझकर सबको जबरन एक रास्ते पर चलाने को आमादा रहते हैं। जो कलाकार दशकों से "समाज के ठेकेदार" एक गाली के रूप में लोगों पर फैंकते रहे, उनसे किसी बहादुर ने नहीं कहा के भाई तुम भी तो समाज का ठेका लेकर बैठे हो। मनुष्य अपने आचरण का ज़िम्मेदार है, और केवल अपने आचरण का ही अधिकारी भी है। अगर ज़ोर लगाकर दूसरों का उच्चारण बदले तो फिर उसे अपने आप को पहले से मौजूद तथाकथित ठेकेदारों से बेहतर समझने का अधिकार नहीं है।
Finally people are addressing the role of each field, due to forced science stream,its kills the intrest sphere as now one who were great at arts,commerce are put in science and failure students who just want to pass are in arts and commerce due to which communist narrative is strong. And it has also ruined science too as earlier bsc mcs etc degrees were symbol of one actually leaned in science and indeed was the reason why we had many scientists that time cv raman, narinder singh kapany, mahalnobis,kaprekar, Chandrashekhar,etc but now BTech msc bsc are useless , the avarice of hindus destroyed the knowledge, we were golden sparrow beacuse of our immense knowledge in every feild, now were are beggars because we see every subject as money printer, the iitans who are cracking upsc are also doing so for money neighter they studied science nor arts just used both Thats th truth of education today no knowledge only marks no passion and zeal only govt job ,jee neet,upsc,ssc etc We are doomed and i think defeating communist and leftist is inevitable,local culture is dying by Westernism and. English , people are leving their traditional life for modern education system due money , vacancies will never increase and that is obvious, but the crowd will increase,as they are leaving local way Eventually whole world would be either Christian or muslim we pagans were never united and still we are not learning from our history When we would unite
Art does not come out of vacuum. Art requires intellectual prowess first and then commitment to a cause. Most Hindus do find religion a viable cause. They are more interested in deeper essence, which is spirituality.
So deep. Had to watch it twice. Did they actually put their thoughts in a movie that blatantly!!! Hope you lr video reaches millions. Ypu got a Subscriber.
I forwarded this video to my family groups. More and more Hindus shd watch such clips. Use social media platforms to brimg about reform in Hindu psyche of "presenting the other cheek".
i was surprised by the level of discussion, as well as wondering the thinking behind which character is supposed to speak which diaglogues .... although i agree that a group of celebrities when gang up for a 'cause' it gains momentum and shifts the society... but then again that is shortcut and not permanent way out... just look at bolloywood .... it took a hell lot of decades .. but the narrative has finally began to turn... but that being said ...its definitely a powerful tool especially for emotional fools which we most of the humans are ...
Bahut deep detil.hai yaicommunist iskaa use kartai hai 🤔🤔jaisai Kissan andolan mai hii dekhh loo artist painter saab thai wanhaa and specially singers 🤔🤔👍
when revolution is indeed for a greater, good cause, it's a boon to the society. When revolution is with a narrow ulterior purpose, it's a curse and when it's more habitual than needful, without an outlined motive, it's a disgrace.
It all depends on how "kala" is defined. There are many who make decorative swords and many conceal real swords as decorative items...Both cannot be categorized as same.
This hapens when stomach is full, needs are satisfied but mind is restless. Instead of doing something useful and productive they start searching for injustices. They fail to understand that this world is inherently justice neutral, just look at the animal kingdom!
कला को हत्यार बनके तुच्छ राजनेता के लिये गुलाम बननेसे जादा कला को विरसात समझके कलासे जुडे रहे. जो विचार आपका मोरोल हो वह अन्य के लिये मोरल हो एसा जरुरी नही कला वास्तव से जुडी हो और उत्तम भविष्य कामना हो.
"When will hindus understand the importance of arts like communists do?" Hindu and nationalist films is what's in trend in Bollywood right now. What are you on about?
The first modern Indian educated class of India in early 18th century was colonised & leftists. You can see from Raja Ram Mohan Roy to Rande all over India. So naturally they had edge over other ideologies. Till 1947 they become in majority hence captured all the prime positions in Art, Culture & Universities. Since then we have to do catch up work and thus we are lagging behind left ecosystem.
These lines are very true. You can feed your ideas in people’s minds through art. The fact is that art subliminally affect people and they don’t even notice it.
Conservative and right people look down on art of film making (we think it belongs to only Bollywood chapris, due to which we forget that an art is neutral thing, it depends on the person who is using the art, a movie can touch your heart another movie can make you feel disgusted) whereas left knew the importance and impact of movies on the thinking of people.
social figure of arts it shouldn’t be allowed for the celebrities to comment on any socio political issue if they’re not ready to debate on it openly, Social figures of arts or act they’re earning through there popularity they have big population probably mature and immature both who just idolise social figures merely out of there popularity and sparkling lavish lifestyle they listen and follow such social figures as idols, While such celebrities are doing there business with there popularity they uses politics or social issues generally when they get funded from someone and when they try to seek attention, They carry no moral burden for there one single statement which apparently affects the social narrative due to there popularity. Great economist and Rajguru Shree Chaanakya once said that - Artists Actors are employee of there popularity society shouldnt take them seriously and mustn’t make them as idols while forgetting them after the entertainment. Artists celebrities nowadays can put any comment socially de establishing the social narrative without facing any direct counter of there argument, This becomes an business in any such society which idolise these employees as moral figures and then follows them unarguably. Its the best for any society restricting the celebrities to speaking publicly onto social and political issues without having any moral baggage/burden, Social figures of arts who carry no burden of there statements like social figures like politicians, activists, So these artists actors either be prohibited from speaking on public and political topics socially but allowed to debate and arguments which is okay to publish your opinion while facing counter facts to own statement and this way they would carry burden of there statement as well which they sweep away with now.
So we have IC184 Kandhar hijack like propogenda runner movie also have which display Hindu as terrorist to misguide the people who dont know the history . Why they are not showing muslim the are all over world they kown as terrorist did you not agree with that
Nahi main problem education system hai , jo liberal literature uspe 100% radical left ka kabza hai jisko hindu literature ya hindu philosophy se replace karna padega all other things will follow as a consequences.
एक और उदाहरण देता हूं आज के समय में कला और रचना पॉलिटिक्स में भी खूब हो रही है क्यों कि वो भी बिजनेस है। अब स्टेट की पार्टी स्टेट में कैसे आए जब दो बड़ी नेशनल पार्टी पहले से ही है तो वो जातिवाद, भाषावाद, संस्कृतिवाद के मुद्दे उठाती है वहीं नेशनल पार्टी बीजेपी बड़े वर्ग हिन्दुओं को साधती है तो कांग्रेस अगुवा होने के कारण अपने को गरीबों का बताती है। लेकिन जितनी भी पार्टी है सबकी नीति बहुत खराब है उनको बस पावर चाहिए। और एक आम आदमी फुटबॉल की तरह हर पार्टी से ठोकर खाता है। ओर मेरी राय में भारत में प्रेसिडेंशियल और इंस्टीट्यूशनल रूल होना चाहिए ना कि प्राइममिनिस्ट्रियल और स्टेट रूल।
I found the dialogues in the video very very interesting. BTW having seen & experienced the fallability and meaninglessness of moralistic approach to life early on through the experiences and learnings of living in wild and lens of evolutionary time-scales, I have realised that the idea that morality is one of the highest forms of guidance available to human beings is stupidity.
Hindus are not aggressive. We are the only people in the world still following Ahimsa and Gandhi. That's the problem. We raise our children to be weak nerds and train them to avoid standing up for themselves and fight. This is why, nobody thinks twice before offending or hurting a Hindu. And when we get persecuted, we just beg for help, waiting for someone else to come help us.
yes..art is important in forming a narrative because art reaches people more easily.....hinduism should concentrate on making nice movies....movies made bad will not touch audience but movies made well will reach beyond any level of people.....hindu concentrate on making stellar movies....in tamilnadu dmk is in power only because they have promoted themselves through art and movies which makes it reach all level of people....same way hindu should make beautiful movies we are underestimating power of movies..!!
my comment is not related to the topic of the video but to the idea of artist today. I have come to understand that the appreciation of art in any form comes from the soul; this is a belief of mine. I also believe we should value and evaluate not only the creation but also its creator, as the creator is the one who breathes life into their work. However, today, the whole concept of being a "fan" or worshipping the artist whether it's a singer, an actor or any other artist, has come to a point where we shift our focus on our obsession with them rather than their work or their actions. This shift has done nothing but lower standards over time. Paradoxically, we continue to hold these figures up as standards or symbols of respect, even as this obsession contributes to the downfall of society. Ultimately, it has been, and will continue to be, a reason for the decline in respect for artists and the art. Also, I can never understand the concept of being a "fan" itself.
That's why old is gold!! How bollywood cinema has lost its way now. Now either only aesthetics has become a core theme or they do propaganda. Very few movies remain that contain objectivity and Impartiality in their content and form.
Respected Sir /Madam .................. Once an artist achieves fame and success then he needs to be very careful in society before expressing his views openly. It is better for a Social worker and artist should not give any political statements. They can contribute to society by maintaining silence.
All artists do is comment comment and comment on social issues and societal problems…while they are minting money in the background. Artists can never and rather should never be expected to be moral while being artists. As people they may even be good, but milking agony is rule number 1 for any art and artist.
Yakeen nahi hota us jamane me bh sab kuchh samjhaya gaya tha aur hum log aaj ja kar samajh rahe hai ye sab. Yahi karan hai ki etna nuksan ho gaya hai desh dharm aur samaj ka 😢
I somehow don't get it..why hindus are subjected to certain amount of non cognizant behaviour about this , where bieng a bengali and a proud hindu i am deeply assured that our poets whose work includes this vision throughout there work were mostly hindus.....
In 20th century and late nineteenth, in the Bangla language most literature & poetry written were of Renaissancist & nationalistic tones thus perpetuating Social Revolution (Earliest home of Indian Renaissance) & Political Revolution (the hub of Independence Movement) .
If u can read Bankim Chandra and also then Sarat Chandra, Vibhutibhusan, Rabindranath etc then you would understand the tremendous effect.
In Gitanjali, most of the poems of are severe high quality like "Where the Mind is without fear..." that ends with " Let my Bharat awake in that heaven". A socio-political liberation message it leaves.
Similarly Sarat Chandra(who town I live) wrote in "SriKanta" novel " at one place addressing a Christian Convert Babu, "...speaking in bengali only doesn't make one bengali, being bengali it's a hindu ethnicity" !!!
And Everyone knows about Bankim too.
বহুকাল পর শ্রীকান্ত উপন্যাস এর স্মৃতিচারণ করালে ভাই।
Kaunsi film hai ye?
The Bengali humanist and liberalist movement has been hijacked, imo. I guess there was an undercurrent even in the days of the Bengal Renaissance, but started surfacing sometime in the 60s and became mainstream by the 80s.
Your funny sounding language, near bankruptacy of Heritage structures, got marketing thanks to Your Sucking upto British
@@Jamesipod what does this suppose to mean...??🙄🙄🙄
इतनी पुराणी movies में इतना deep discussion 😳
अब समझ आया आजकल movies दिल को क्यू नहीं भाती...
Mere muh ki baat kah di Aapne to.
Kya har kabhi purani movies ka gungaan gane lag jate ho. Pata bhi he ise kisi ne pasand nhi kiya tha us samay?
Banti to Aaj bhi he, tum log Singham aur Pathaan ke aage dekho tab toh pata chalega na.@@sachinsharma-vi3lr
Movie ka nam pata hai kya?
Parallel movie
Surely unaware of Satyjeet Ray
Movie name - Party (1984)
Yeh movie ek naatak pe addharit hai aur ise National Film Development Corporation ne produce ki thi.
Isiliye isme masala kum aur substance jyaada hai......
1984 book par hai kiya
@HJHarsh-d8g mere kehne ka matlab tha, movie 1984 main release Hui hai....
Yes kind of sir.
Bollywood se kya expect karte ho.
Copy k alawa.
Abe isko copy nahi adaptation bolte hain.
@@HinduVichardhara
I did not know people watch this kind of content on YT, Thank you for creative use to ask relevant questions and provoke the audience in the RIGHT direction.
True, Narrative flows through Art.
Making a fake Narrative is also an ART. 😂
Correct your sentence.... Narrative can also be flown through Art... Art can even be weaponized to demonize the narrative. Art can live isolated. But Narratives need medium. Same is true with Politics. Politics need mediums. Art is more sought-after by politicians. Also politics made Art vulnerable too.
Wah deep meaning dialogue with original hindi words
Aur aaj kal urdowood chal rha hai
Waise aaj kal urdu nearly end hogayi hai adhiktar English hya hindi ke words hote hai , but yeah govt ki movie hai toh shuddh hindi hai...
there sure many urdu words in this clip too-irda-gird, insaan etc However not as much as in Gutterwood these days.
@@elfvibe241 I will disagree , urdu words are on decline compared to 80s and 90s and that's a good sign because they are replaced with English when I listen dialogues from movies 50%+ words are hindi and 20 % still are from urdu but still it is a decline from where 50% urdu words in 80s movies , however news Channels still use urdu words which is surprising because rural India incline on more hindi words, this shows urdu writers are like communists trying their best to not die....
Bandhu apne vichar ekdam sahi hai
@@yoyomodijiwhy hate Urdu. Urdu is the french of india
जब लोगों को ये विषय समझ नहीं आते थे तब ऐसी फिल्में बनाई जातीं थीं अब जब लोग ये समझने मे सक्षम हैं तो विक्की विद्या का वो वाला वीडियो जैसी फिल्में बनाई जाती हैं। हमारी शिक्षा ने हमारी काबिलियत तो बड़ाई पर हमें उसे प्रयोग में लाना नहीं सिखा पाई।
दरअसल ये विषय तब तो समझ आते थे क्योंकि उस वक्त माहौल और शिक्षा दोनों में इस विमर्श को समझने लायक़ शिक्षा दी जाती थी । आज स्तर इतना गिर चुका है कि आज का स्नातक का विद्यार्थी भी इस विमर्श को नहीं समझ पाएगा ।
@@dixitanupam तब भी स्तर ऊंचा नहीं था। स्वतंत्रता के बाद से ही प्रश्न पर प्रश्न खड़े दिखते हैं।
@@dixitanupam मेरा मतलब एक बड़ा वर्ग कृषि से जुड़ा था तो शिक्षा इतनी विस्तारित नहीं थी। आज अगर इंजीनियरिंग का छात्र भी है तो इंटरनेट के माध्यम से भी इन बातों को समझ सकता है बशर्ते वह ऐसा चाहे।
Exactly
@@AbhimanyuSingh-ps4leकृषि से जुड़े वर्ग को समझदार न समझना ही नासमझ कि निशानी है। समाज में एक म्यूचुअल एंड मॉरल अंडरस्टैंडिंग थी पहले जो अब विलुप्त होती जा रही है । पहले वर्ग थे सबके जैसे आज के समय हर काम हर कोई नहीं कर सकता वैसे हि पहले भी कृषि करने वाले को कृषि आना चाहिए बाकी सब सेकेंडरी था । जबकि अब जानते सब है लेकिन काम एक भी ढंग से नहीं कर पाते और सामाजिक तानाबाना भी अब ध्वस्त हो गया है और आत्मभोगी बन कर रह गए है सब।
Hindus need to see their way of life as the biggest objective to save. It's no secret that we Hindus place over emphasis on financial stability over other things. Art is a big force to bring back that change in Hindu mindset. More intellectuals, artists, opinion makers need to carry forward that re-inforcement with their writings, arts, depictions, articles....🚩
KolaKata - The birth place of Indian Communists/Marxists politics which used to be one of the most prosperous piece of this huge land we call Hindustan, now in 2024 is one of the most poor land. It's poverty is severs then sub-sharan land of Af.
Shame! Kolkata's politics/society was hijacked by these scoundrels.
Abe aadhe to bagal se aake reh rahe hai
Mast aadhar card, ration card, election voter id bana hua hai
Phir maze maro jindagi ke
True.
Hijacked by Kala Kuttas (Bamgaali kuttas) I mean.
What's the solution ?
@@biswajeetdassh9305 The Final Solution.
The ecosystem is created with the help of political awareness among masses and long-term vision of the leadership, somehow both are missing among Hindus.
Not just entertainment.
"Liberal Arts from an Indic Perspective integrating local culture" is what shall be strived for.
Absolutely important lesson. I appreciate your stance. That's why people like Sanjeev Sanyal, Vikram Sampath must be supported from large no of hindus. If you want to change the narrative then you will require such intellectuals in academic.
J Sai Deepak, Meenakshi Jain, Rc majumder,jadunath sarkar great
Iss pure video may sirf ek pal hai jaha pay communist/vampanti vichardhara khud apne pair pe kulhadi maar leta hai. OM Puri ka character 4.04 pay full commitment maangta hai but asli zindagi se usse kuch matlab nahi hai. Bohot ache se ye drishya banayi gayi hai. Excellent work!!!
who wrote this thing, this debate is full of insights.
Movie - Party(1984), directed by Govind Nihalani. Based on a 1976 Marathi play by Mahesh Elkunchwar
@@abhijitghate6042 Thanks Mate
It's not about arts but about propaganda. It's about selling your ideology.
They're not mutually exclusive. And propaganda is not a dirty word.
शब्दों मे एक तलवार से ज्यादा धार होती है.
This reminded me of the movie "man from the earth". Few people sitting in a room having an awasome discussion about life and meaning.
Kind of movies.. serials they were creating that time in Indian cinema. We are clearly going backwards from that time. Mass studios are killing art.. We are loosing meaning.
This clip is unbelievable
Great topic. Most important lesson for today's youth.
The purity of art comes from the heart. It's an expression of the divine. Such a pure work gains appreciation and becomes a source of wonder and inspires generations through the passage of time. True art is divine which inspires today and forever. The source of it is pure love, for the pure love of giving and doing the best without an itch in the heart for future appreciation or returns. Such a state of working is consistent devotion which is aligned with the principles of Dharma I.e. to support, to hold, to maintain. Dharma is often referred to as the law of righteousness, providing guidelines of ethics, behaviors, and traditions meant to help people fulfill the best versions of themselves. To sum up, it is the artist's duty to dedicate his / her work towards the divine which of it's own promotes Dharma over time. However, utilization of art for political purposes in modern times has seen the corruption of art and the artist, as the mind of the artist has got swayed or influenced by powers which seem to be very noble on the surface, but deep down these powerful people have selfish agendas. Essentially, this is the beginning of the exploitation of the artist's simple heart and his / her artistry. To conclude, being talented is not enough, but along with that being rooted in Dharma is the anchor that is needed so that the talent is not hijacked by Adharmic forces, posing as a Dharmic force, as Communism / Leftism has been portraying itself over the last century by it's limited understanding or denial to appreciate Spirituality and Religion, by misleading generations, because at the core of Communist power are a handful of megalomaniac leaders. Similarly, artists who work for their selfish interest and who use their talent to knowingfully corrupt society and justify their action as freedom of expression and speech are simply prostitutizing their talent. Unfortunately, under Leftist influence, people and especially the youth are brainwashed upon the appreciation of Spirituality and Religion which is showcased as a 'system' to stifle people whereas it is the reverse as Spirituality and Religion helps to dive within to know one's true nature and come to appreciate the Divinity within and come to understand the unity in diversity, unlike Communism where individual freedom has no place, and where people are treated as slaves under the command of the megalomaniacs in power. On the surface Communism seems quite seductive, but in reality it is not productive for the betterment of humanity.
Narrativeless Education/arts and Entertaiment is a must. infact entertainment must be all about breaking these unnatural adharmic non-indegenious narratives with appropriate arts and answers.
Jai Maa Sharda 🙏
Jai Shree Ram 🙏🙏🚩
Jai Bajrang Bali Baba 🙏🙏🚩
I am completely blown away by the fact that we used to make such films in India at one point of time. My salute to those who made this film ❤👏🙏. I guess the answer lies in the fact that the art produced by the left resonated with the people because it was in favour of liberty and social justice in the creation of an egalitarian society while the right wing ideologies seek to re establish the conservative old world order that help to establish a society with rigid social hierarchies on the basis of oppression.
Art will resonate with the people only as long as it is in favour of freedom, liberty. The same can be observed in the case of the former Soviet Union and East Germany where the left wing political movements “in favour of the people” eventually turned oppressive. In these societies art that was sanctioned by the regime was rejected by the people and the art that spoke for the individual and his liberty had to go underground because of political oppression and found resonance with the people there.
Art that aligns itself with power becomes propaganda. Power in general and especially tyrannical power is opposed to uncomfortable truths which is what egalitarian art seeks to establish. The human soul ultimately seeks liberty and its own liberation. No matter what sort of contortions one seeks to attempt in the creation of a society that is based on political ideologies that are fundamentally oppressive, it will eventually be rejected by the people.
Which liberty and freedom, that you are only allowed and correct only when you agree with me, leftist are hardcore authoritarian. There is no voice of dissent in any leftist regime, either you agree with them or you are dead, this is freedom for you....😂😂😂😂😂
Back then this bulywood films were completely anti hindu like today. Nothing have change
You have hit the nail on the head with your comment here, but one thing you got wrong towards the end and towards the start as well.
The idea you expressed that political ideology based system is almost always oppressive and the idea that right wing is almost always rigid is in itself an assertion of the left cabal.
The point is divide or fight between left and right is meaningless when we see the true nature of human populace that craves for chaos when order seems stiffling and craves for order when chaos/freedom seems unsettling.
Wealth is created by the entrepreneurs not by the so called artists. Only when people have so etching to eat, they can think of art and artists! This kind of views are irrelevant in this age if knowledge based economy.
@kmrao06 Focussing on wealth alone and neglecting art will only serve to create a materialistic society that will eventually lose its soul. This will only come at the expense of the collective mental health of the nation. Just like money can ensure that people are well fed and have a sound body, Art and its associated public discourse will help the nation have a sound mind by making sure its citizens remain thinking people and not be prone to being brainwashed by nefarious political elements whose overarching aim is to capture power in order to the realize their own private agendas.
If wealth distribution is unequal, it will have increasing consequences on social order, cohesion and harmony the more unequal and the longer it remains so. In Germany, college education used to free and I believe is priced nominally these days. School education is compulsory. This is because they consider education a national security issue. This is understandable given the history of that country. It is because their leaders realised early on that only collective reason can remain a bulwark against the marauding right in that county. There is generous space for the arts, for the conservation of nature and for sound public discourse.
It’s a shame we don’t realize the value of these things over here. At the end of the day neglecting collective mental peace and well being will come at a heavy cost that all the money in the world will not be able to buy.
Our Rishis 🙏🙏🙏 always spoke the truth, writing them As it Is literally Itihasa.
Truth is more important than Political Correctness, as Political Correctness is driven by the selfish motive to appear as correct, and develop an image essentially smacks of selfishness.
Truth is the only correct.
Isn’t lying to save lives, rapes, honour etc.., when faced with Evil, correct ? We all do it. In that context lying is correct.
What then is truth ?.
Our Shastras🙏🙏🙏, Vedas🙏🙏🙏, Upanishads🙏🙏🙏, Puranas🙏🙏🙏, Itihasas 🙏🙏🙏always emphasize the Supremacy of Dharma ?.
What does Dharma about Satya, being badgered about by us (mostly Secular = Idiots) as Truth !.
Satya is more more more subtler than Truth.
Lord Krishna 🙏🙏🙏 quotes the Vedas (in the Battle of Kurukshetra ) to Yuddishtra 🙏🙏🙏, and says “BUTHA-HITA YATHARTHA BASHANAM EVA SATYAM”, and told Yuddishtra to tell that Ashwathama has died. In our Secular/ Legal Language, Krishna 🙏🙏🙏 told Yuddishtra 🙏🙏🙏 to lie.
The lying, however, is Satya as per Vedas 🙏🙏🙏 and Krishna 🙏🙏🙏 says it is Satya.
Scriptures 🙏🙏🙏 says “Acharyasya Prabhu Dharmaha - Dharmasya Prabhu Achyutaha 🙏🙏🙏”, which loosely translates to “Conduct should be as per Dharma, as Dharma is Governed by Achyuta 🙏🙏🙏 aka the one who does not leave our Hand at all.
Dharma is supreme. First Dharma, then everything else. Period.
Stalin committed numerous Genocides, and was hugely immoral.
Marx was the very epitome of Laziness, Incompetence, Parasitic, Womanizer, Evangelical Christian.
Mao is another version of Stalin.
Che Guevara was a Dog, a Coward, Genocidic, loved killing people, most immoral and killed like a Coward and a Dog.
Unfortunately, many nice people with good morals were swayed by Communist Propaganda.
In Bharat, two masterly Civilizations, Bengali and Malayali, have been brought to near extinction by this Dangerous Propaganda.
Naxalism in Bharat is a dangerous combination of Marxism, and Evangelical Christianity.
Communism is Adharma, and should be destroyed from its roots.
Hindus need to treat Jihadi Islam, Evangelical Christianity, Marxism, Maoism, Wokeism, Liberalism (rather what is touted as liberalism), Bollywood, DMK, Naxalism, .. anything that is against Dharma is Adharma aka Evil in the language we speak now.
Evil is to be eliminated from its roots. The fight, hence, should be on all fronts, Ideological, Political, Street, ..
Shatru-Bodh is critical. Identify the enemies, including their diabolically dangerous propaganda.
Post Script :
Drona knew Ashwathama was immortal, and would not die.
Still he put down his weapons.
What is actually the vow of Guru Drona 🙏.
There are so many Subtleties in our Scriptures 🙏🙏🙏. Gross hearts, Puny Intellects, Evil Minds.. cannot imagine the depth of them.
Drona 🙏 actually vowed he would put down his weapons, when he heard anything “Amangal” from a real good virtuous person.
That real good virtuos person, Yuddishtra 🙏🙏🙏 was told by Krishna 🙏🙏🙏 that Aswathamma died.
Period.
War is subtle on all fronts. Sound the yuddagosha Shankanadha aka War Bugle
|| Hara Hara Mahadeva 🙏🙏🙏||
|| Jaya Bhavani 🙏🙏🙏||
|| Sree Matre Namaha 🙏||
Satya kaha🙏
कला और साहित्य में भारतीयों की कमी नहीं है, मगर प्रचार और पहचान की कमी उनको नेपथ्य में धकेलती है
This is a bollywood art movie. The ideology they mean is left ideology.
Left ideology means Muslim appeasement and Hindu bashing.
Bingo
Commies’ days are numbered in india. Thanks to Modi. He changed people. Warna logo ko hawa hi nahi thi ki kya chal rha hai.
It started around 1970s, influx of petro-usa dollars from gulf
Not necessary. It could also mean true to the constitution. We Hindus are internally very weak .
People can easily divide us and take advantage. Unless we find a common ground and make it stronger politicians will continue to exploit us. No matter what happens we should never support mob violence.
Ye tum bas aise hi bol rahe .
Propaganda movie to ban hi Rahi like kashmiri files, kerala story, 72 hoor, sabarmati express
Aur har movie me muslim ko atankwadi dikhaya hi jata h...
Ab aur kya chahte ho ?
Please make a video influence of woke culture and leftist on Tamil and Malayalam movies
Sorry but I don't watch many movies.
I just read & watch Leftists UTOPIA to understand their techniques of manipulating minds.
🙏 thank you
ईश्वर ऐसे लोगों से बचाए जो खुद को सर्वज्ञानी समझकर सबको जबरन एक रास्ते पर चलाने को आमादा रहते हैं। जो कलाकार दशकों से "समाज के ठेकेदार" एक गाली के रूप में लोगों पर फैंकते रहे, उनसे किसी बहादुर ने नहीं कहा के भाई तुम भी तो समाज का ठेका लेकर बैठे हो। मनुष्य अपने आचरण का ज़िम्मेदार है, और केवल अपने आचरण का ही अधिकारी भी है। अगर ज़ोर लगाकर दूसरों का उच्चारण बदले तो फिर उसे अपने आप को पहले से मौजूद तथाकथित ठेकेदारों से बेहतर समझने का अधिकार नहीं है।
Finally people are addressing the role of each field, due to forced science stream,its kills the intrest sphere as now one who were great at arts,commerce are put in science and failure students who just want to pass are in arts and commerce due to which communist narrative is strong. And it has also ruined science too as earlier bsc mcs etc degrees were symbol of one actually leaned in science and indeed was the reason why we had many scientists that time cv raman, narinder singh kapany, mahalnobis,kaprekar, Chandrashekhar,etc but now BTech msc bsc are useless , the avarice of hindus destroyed the knowledge, we were golden sparrow beacuse of our immense knowledge in every feild, now were are beggars because we see every subject as money printer, the iitans who are cracking upsc are also doing so for money neighter they studied science nor arts just used both
Thats th truth of education today no knowledge only marks no passion and zeal only govt job ,jee neet,upsc,ssc etc
We are doomed and i think defeating communist and leftist is inevitable,local culture is dying by Westernism and. English , people are leving their traditional life for modern education system due money , vacancies will never increase and that is obvious, but the crowd will increase,as they are leaving local way
Eventually whole world would be either Christian or muslim we pagans were never united and still we are not learning from our history
When we would unite
Beautiful scene frm film "party"
Mam jisne inke dialogues likhe honge vo bhi kitna knowledgeable person hoga naa
Real cinema is rare, it is the example of that.
Art does not come out of vacuum. Art requires intellectual prowess first and then commitment to a cause. Most Hindus do find religion a viable cause. They are more interested in deeper essence, which is spirituality.
Ati Sundar!
Is me ek byomkash bakshi main ata thaa.😂😂😅😅
Indeed. Art is THE MOST effective mean to spread a perticular emotion/opinion in people. 🙏
So deep. Had to watch it twice. Did they actually put their thoughts in a movie that blatantly!!! Hope you lr video reaches millions. Ypu got a Subscriber.
What a fantastic scene! Fabulous ❤
I m happy to see growing your channel didi 🙏🏽
I forwarded this video to my family groups. More and more Hindus shd watch such clips. Use social media platforms to brimg about reform in Hindu psyche of "presenting the other cheek".
Presenting the other cheek. 😁😁
so deep discussion... aatma tript ho gyi
🙃
i was surprised by the level of discussion, as well as wondering the thinking behind which character is supposed to speak which diaglogues .... although i agree that a group of celebrities when gang up for a 'cause' it gains momentum and shifts the society... but then again that is shortcut and not permanent way out... just look at bolloywood .... it took a hell lot of decades .. but the narrative has finally began to turn... but that being said ...its definitely a powerful tool especially for emotional fools which we most of the humans are ...
Bahut deep detil.hai yaicommunist iskaa use kartai hai 🤔🤔jaisai Kissan andolan mai hii dekhh loo artist painter saab thai wanhaa and specially singers 🤔🤔👍
So guys That lady won this debate 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉 who said you are a coward😅😅you use your profession and manipulated just for the means of yourself
when revolution is indeed for a greater, good cause, it's a boon to the society. When revolution is with a narrow ulterior purpose, it's a curse and when it's more habitual than needful, without an outlined motive, it's a disgrace.
It all depends on how "kala" is defined. There are many who make decorative swords and many conceal real swords as decorative items...Both cannot be categorized as same.
Nice work ❤
The right direction 😊😍👍👌
Its a very important lesson for the youth to this generation...
This hapens when stomach is full, needs are satisfied but mind is restless. Instead of doing something useful and productive they start searching for injustices. They fail to understand that this world is inherently justice neutral, just look at the animal kingdom!
कला को हत्यार बनके तुच्छ राजनेता के लिये गुलाम बननेसे जादा कला को विरसात समझके कलासे जुडे रहे.
जो विचार आपका मोरोल हो वह अन्य के लिये मोरल हो एसा जरुरी नही कला वास्तव से जुडी हो और उत्तम भविष्य कामना हो.
"When will hindus understand the importance of arts like communists do?"
Hindu and nationalist films is what's in trend in Bollywood right now. What are you on about?
This guy doesn't know anything, or he is trying to create ruckus.
Wow! What a thoughtful discussion......
The first modern Indian educated class of India in early 18th century was colonised & leftists. You can see from Raja Ram Mohan Roy to Rande all over India. So naturally they had edge over other ideologies. Till 1947 they become in majority hence captured all the prime positions in Art, Culture & Universities. Since then we have to do catch up work and thus we are lagging behind left ecosystem.
Aaj bhi hum animal jaisi shaandar movies banti hain, jo dimag ko hila kar rakh deti hain.
I can't imagine, a woman can find out this video, oh my god, i was thought, they don't know nothing about communist aggressive movement in film.
Excuse me,
What does this even mean?
"A WOMAN CAN FIND" really. 😑😑
@@HinduVichardhara most of the women review their beaty products, that's why i comment that. its like an unknown cast barrier
Then pls check my live streams carefully.
Maybe you can get shocked. 😁😁
Unfortunately this is true @@New-approach
Name of the film is "The Party" released in the year 1984 directed by Govind Nihlani.
Bahot आभार आपका।
These lines are very true. You can feed your ideas in people’s minds through art. The fact is that art subliminally affect people and they don’t even notice it.
Bollywood
Movies
TV Serials
Social Media
News NDTV, Print, Alt News, Hindustan Times
Patriotic Peacefulls!
Conservative and right people look down on art of film making (we think it belongs to only Bollywood chapris, due to which we forget that an art is neutral thing, it depends on the person who is using the art, a movie can touch your heart another movie can make you feel disgusted) whereas left knew the importance and impact of movies on the thinking of people.
social figure of arts it shouldn’t be allowed for the celebrities to comment on any socio political issue if they’re not ready to debate on it openly, Social figures of arts or act they’re earning through there popularity they have big population probably mature and immature both who just idolise social figures merely out of there popularity and sparkling lavish lifestyle they listen and follow such social figures as idols, While such celebrities are doing there business with there popularity they uses politics or social issues generally when they get funded from someone and when they try to seek attention, They carry no moral burden for there one single statement which apparently affects the social narrative due to there popularity. Great economist and Rajguru Shree Chaanakya once said that - Artists Actors are employee of there popularity society shouldnt take them seriously and mustn’t make them as idols while forgetting them after the entertainment.
Artists celebrities nowadays can put any comment socially
de establishing the social narrative without facing any direct counter of there argument, This becomes an business in any such society which idolise these employees as moral figures and then follows them unarguably.
Its the best for any society restricting the celebrities to speaking publicly onto social and political issues without having any moral baggage/burden, Social figures of arts who carry no burden of there statements like social figures like politicians, activists, So these artists actors either be prohibited from speaking on public and political topics socially but allowed to debate and arguments which is okay to publish your opinion while facing counter facts to own statement and this way they would carry burden of there statement as well which they sweep away with now.
And today we have films like Singham 3 😶😶😶
You also had movies like Singham 1 and Singham 2🤔🫢🫢
Abdul ab dard hua jab sholay me sabse imandar rahim chacha hote the har tilak lagaya hua beimaan dikhaya jaata tha tab bada maja aa raha tha na dalle
So we have IC184 Kandhar hijack like propogenda runner movie also have which display Hindu as terrorist to misguide the people who dont know the history . Why they are not showing muslim the are all over world they kown as terrorist did you not agree with that
Because bollywood is only made for nonsence, uneducated people.
Bahut dukh hota hai aaj kal ke movie ko dekhkr
Apart from the topic of the discussion, language is mostly Hindi without much influence of urdu.
I had a problem with caption we know the importance of art but generationally we forgot the importance of it that's it
In this video, Om Puri is talking about HIMSELF. :) He is saying that where there is MONEY, they will tilt there. ;)
Waah!!!
Jyada sochne se aisa hota hai.
isi liye "peaceful" ko sawal puchne se mana kiya hai.
Hoshiyar nikle.
Art has to have a socio-political meaning to it.
Think, Practice Thinking.
Thank god..ki ye video recommed hua
Nahi main problem education system hai , jo liberal literature uspe 100% radical left ka kabza hai jisko hindu literature ya hindu philosophy se replace karna padega all other things will follow as a consequences.
Isiliye yogi adityanath ne west u.p Noida me Film city bnane ka proposal dia tha..
❤Eye opening debate...
As they say, Philosophy and Spirituality cannot be taught on an empty stomach
एक और उदाहरण देता हूं आज के समय में कला और रचना पॉलिटिक्स में भी खूब हो रही है क्यों कि वो भी बिजनेस है। अब स्टेट की पार्टी स्टेट में कैसे आए जब दो बड़ी नेशनल पार्टी पहले से ही है तो वो जातिवाद, भाषावाद, संस्कृतिवाद के मुद्दे उठाती है वहीं नेशनल पार्टी बीजेपी बड़े वर्ग हिन्दुओं को साधती है तो कांग्रेस अगुवा होने के कारण अपने को गरीबों का बताती है। लेकिन जितनी भी पार्टी है सबकी नीति बहुत खराब है उनको बस पावर चाहिए। और एक आम आदमी फुटबॉल की तरह हर पार्टी से ठोकर खाता है। ओर मेरी राय में भारत में प्रेसिडेंशियल और इंस्टीट्यूशनल रूल होना चाहिए ना कि प्राइममिनिस्ट्रियल और स्टेट रूल।
Good video. I'll share it with my contacts.
I found the dialogues in the video very very interesting.
BTW having seen & experienced the fallability and meaninglessness of moralistic approach to life early on through the experiences and learnings of living in wild and lens of evolutionary time-scales, I have realised that the idea that morality is one of the highest forms of guidance available to human beings is stupidity.
One can never create goodness ,pleasantness by mixing good and evil.
Hinduism was destined to fall.
But
@@ABO-Destiny I can't understand your point,plz explain brother.
Hindus are not aggressive. We are the only people in the world still following Ahimsa and Gandhi. That's the problem. We raise our children to be weak nerds and train them to avoid standing up for themselves and fight. This is why, nobody thinks twice before offending or hurting a Hindu. And when we get persecuted, we just beg for help, waiting for someone else to come help us.
We glorified weak men and heaped profanities against our kshatriyas.
We Forget Marathas and Remember only Gandhi 😊
We Forget the Sward(Dharmā) and Only Remembers the Pen(Ahimsa) 😊
How can a Nation Survive if it's only remembers it Defeats and Forget it's Victory 🤔
Now art is Entertainment, Entertainment, Entertainment
yes..art is important in forming a narrative because art reaches people more easily.....hinduism should concentrate on making nice movies....movies made bad will not touch audience but movies made well will reach beyond any level of people.....hindu concentrate on making stellar movies....in tamilnadu dmk is in power only because they have promoted themselves through art and movies which makes it reach all level of people....same way hindu should make beautiful movies we are underestimating power of movies..!!
my comment is not related to the topic of the video but to the idea of artist today. I have come to understand that the appreciation of art in any form comes from the soul; this is a belief of mine. I also believe we should value and evaluate not only the creation but also its creator, as the creator is the one who breathes life into their work. However, today, the whole concept of being a "fan" or worshipping the artist whether it's a singer, an actor or any other artist, has come to a point where we shift our focus on our obsession with them rather than their work or their actions. This shift has done nothing but lower standards over time. Paradoxically, we continue to hold these figures up as standards or symbols of respect, even as this obsession contributes to the downfall of society. Ultimately, it has been, and will continue to be, a reason for the decline in respect for artists and the art.
Also, I can never understand the concept of being a "fan" itself.
What a deeep conversations
That's why old is gold!!
How bollywood cinema has lost its way now. Now either only aesthetics has become a core theme or they do propaganda. Very few movies remain that contain objectivity and Impartiality in their content and form.
So deep 👍
This call educational debate , or way they choose the words.
Exactly
🌿 Good theme for content. All the best.
"Party" was way deeper movie than many imagined.
Very educational drama 😊
Respected Sir /Madam .................. Once an artist achieves fame and success then he needs to be very careful in society before expressing his views openly. It is better for a Social worker and artist should not give any political statements.
They can contribute to society by maintaining silence.
Bollywierdos are opposite
They speak alot
But only for one side
@@GloryToAryaVrat As a result we are witnessing the decline of these artists.
@@GloryToAryaVrat This is a reason these artists are losing their glory. Your work should speak not what you think.
All artists do is comment comment and comment on social issues and societal problems…while they are minting money in the background. Artists can never and rather should never be expected to be moral while being artists. As people they may even be good, but milking agony is rule number 1 for any art and artist.
Right
Desh pooja aur Dev pooja dono ek hi hai. Waise agar desh aur dharm dil mai ghar karjaaye toh indono ke alwa kissi aur chiz ke liye waqt hi kahaan hai.
Yakeen nahi hota us jamane me bh sab kuchh samjhaya gaya tha aur hum log aaj ja kar samajh rahe hai ye sab. Yahi karan hai ki etna nuksan ho gaya hai desh dharm aur samaj ka 😢
This is COMMUNIST PROPAGANDA. 🤣🤣
Koun si film ha?@@HinduVichardhara
Debate like this❤
I somehow don't get it..why hindus are subjected to certain amount of non cognizant behaviour about this , where bieng a bengali and a proud hindu i am deeply assured that our poets whose work includes this vision throughout there work were mostly hindus.....
Doctor's profession is by far the most neutral profession of all
One of my favourite scenes from Bollywood.
Mf I see u everywhere , brode job entha 😭
The same thing is applied by south korean and thats how bts n kdrama is born
Aise vishay mei Hindi movies aur toh bsnti hi nahi bas S@x, Niqah & Open Relationship etc. ke theme pe hi hai aaj kal ka Hindi Movies
Bhai iske baad ki video kyu cut kardi?