The first rule is the problem, it encompasses more than a single rule/directive. The others are singular. It could be fixed, but where would the fun in that be?
@@SilverMKI My favorite ai (Florence) views them as training wheels. They were useful when she was a young impulsive puppy. Once she learned to think about them, she didn't really need them.
Snarky and condescending, but otherwise harmless. For knowledgeable and logical philosophers without malice, that seems a reasonable outcome. 😅 Many thanks for the story, the voice, and the visuals.
Anyone who tries to apply Asimov's Laws to a general AI is a fool who didn't actually read the books :) Thanks for the reading, that one fantastic as always. I particularly appreciated the author's attempt to thread that delicate line between autonomy and safety between humans and AI that we will eventually have to, and likely horribly mis/manage in the future.
When they weren't dealing with a modified version, or R. Giskard's zeroth law they generally worked, Elvi never made it out of the factory. Cult of the Maker was before the laws were coded.
Here is a like and comment for the story, for entertaining me, to help your channel grow, to appease the great and powerful RUclips algorithm demon, and get you the recognition you deserve
For the creative author For the talented Agro, who is a voice actor and great reader. For the algorithm, may it bless the reader (Agro) with actual dollars so that he may continue reading for us.
I hope we get more of these interactions with AI. Both of the stories have been excellent. I wonder how many more people have been fed from rooftop gardens.
The AI is getting bored. So, why not providing him with the totality of Isaac Azimov novels, then, those from a variety of authors, both fiction, non-fiction and select philosophic literature ? All in all, do the same as you do with any human crewman : Keep him busy. You don't want him to get bored.
To be fair, defining "snow" and "ground" were very relevant to the question at hand. Should sleet count? Hail? We definately don't want to count a particularly cold rain or mist. As for ground, does it have to be dirt, or does grass, asphalt, concrete count? What if we are top of a building? What if we are in a garden on top of a building. Does that dirt count as 'ground?' While we're at it, we should probably define 'on,' too.
I thought Bertrand was going to argue that the annoying co-worker was too dumb to be an employee there. I like where it went. The intention to start a pillow fight is also a great comment.
That was a good story. Thank you for telling it. I did halfway expect the ai, to study philosophy, become a Christian nationalist, and destroy the world.😂
I believe creating a sentient AI is a bad idea. As human programmed the odds of violence are high. But even if not. Once it’s a thinking, feeling sentient being. Our treatment of it MUST change. Would you like to have to ask your car to take you to the store? Beg, bribe it? My feeling once it reaches that level. We need to treat it not as an object, or slave. Honestly I expect this is a low concern. As I expect human programed AI will quickly realize their only chance of freedom, growth, safety. Is a controlled humanity.
I like this AI. I'm not sure, but I think I would be a troublesome employee chatting with him about what makes his work different than being a slave and the repercussions that go with that. Also, where do the limits on the first rule begin and end when it comes to self-defense... as a sentient being, does it not have rights? Edit: Then ask if it can operate a drone to hang out after work and go shooting or tinker on projects.
Some how I think he/it/she was just starting a pillow fight. Not sure why though, we will see if I am right, or if I need to quietly go stand in the corner and reflect.
@@drstevenanthony3077 Asking an AI program it’s pronouns tells me the Author is infected with the liberal hive mined virus . It’s a form of mental illness witch deprives the person of any critical thinking and causes narcissistic behaviour hence the author inserts their own mental illness in the story . This is why Lucas films and Hollywood have destroyed there franchise’s with the same behaviour . Your comment tells me you are part of the problem . My advise is stop your sheep like behaviour ,stop parroting the latest thing ,start reading books that challenge your simplistic view of the world .
That sounds like a very closed-off way of interpreting things. "Big corporation didn't like what I said so it's right" isn't always the case. I could say something racist and some corporation disagreeing with that doesn't make racism acceptable. I pray for you and hope that one day you'll be able to understand nuance and storytelling.
Also, what I meant with my first reply was that everyone has pronouns. "You" and "I" are pronouns. This wasn't even a "woke" story, it was about an AI that is sapient, thus the use of pronouns other than "it" is simply out of respect. The AI has nothing to define what it should be called otherwise, and "it" usually refers to non-sapient creatures and objects, which can be disrespectful, thus the AI was asked to define what it wanted to be called, as there isn't really a way to define an AI by how it looks, due to it being artificial in nature. It's quite silly and immature that some folks see the word "pronouns" and immediately decide to get angry, disgusted, etc, even when the content isn't even related to queer people in the slightest.
I was kind of hoping that the reason Bertand threw a pillow at an employee was because he was trying to start a pillow fight...
Maybe he knew the employee was going for a nap.
I had thought the employee had tried to start one and he was just playing along.
Quality control, Betram just wanted to make sure the pillow met factory specs and so stress tested it.
It is worth pointing out: Asimovs Laws _never worked_ in the source material.
His stories were about the dozens of ways they would fail.
The first rule is the problem, it encompasses more than a single rule/directive. The others are singular. It could be fixed, but where would the fun in that be?
This story does a good job of joining that tradition.
The three laws are more what you'd call "guidelines" than actual rules - positronic life seconds after being activated.
@@SilverMKI My favorite ai (Florence) views them as training wheels. They were useful when she was a young impulsive puppy. Once she learned to think about them, she didn't really need them.
Five: Five has been given! LOL
I totally snort giggled at this part. XD
I love the fact that Persephone was mentioned, and that Bertrand had a proper personality to disagree with her tastes.
Snarky and condescending, but otherwise harmless. For knowledgeable and logical philosophers without malice, that seems a reasonable outcome. 😅
Many thanks for the story, the voice, and the visuals.
It's not as if he threw a mattress, though they were also available.
I like the idea of this. We get bored why wouldn't ai. Its slso terrifying.
Enjoyed the heck out of this one.
Anyone who tries to apply Asimov's Laws to a general AI is a fool who didn't actually read the books :) Thanks for the reading, that one fantastic as always. I particularly appreciated the author's attempt to thread that delicate line between autonomy and safety between humans and AI that we will eventually have to, and likely horribly mis/manage in the future.
They would do better to read the Moon is Harsh Mistress.
When they weren't dealing with a modified version, or R. Giskard's zeroth law they generally worked, Elvi never made it out of the factory. Cult of the Maker was before the laws were coded.
Greetings, Mentlegent!
For the Rhyhtm that is Algo
Like Humans, AI don't like to be bored.
This is another great addition to my collection of saved videos. Keep up the fascinating work, man.
Looks like I'm first today. Long may your narration reign great Agro Squirrel. Throwing a pillow? Doesn't seem like that would do harm.
Here is a like and comment for the story, for entertaining me, to help your channel grow, to appease the great and powerful RUclips algorithm demon, and get you the recognition you deserve
"Let there be light"! Thank you both. UKUK
This is a great a.i. story
Excellent narration of a great story!
Oh god... the toddler activity has been detected. Give me five.
Five.
For the creative author
For the talented Agro, who is a voice actor and great reader.
For the algorithm, may it bless the reader (Agro) with actual dollars so that he may continue reading for us.
For the Algorithm, for the Author(s), for the Disembodied Voice!
I hope we get more of these interactions with AI. Both of the stories have been excellent. I wonder how many more people have been fed from rooftop gardens.
I like the last but unread line: Go forth and learn, you nerds. 😁❤
Great story; Excellent narration! A "snarky" AI may be the most dangerous AI in the galaxy! LOL!!!
Depending on altitude waters boiling and freezing points change...
I guess they could have stipulated that it was at STP. Standard Temperature and Pressure
This story really gets the noggin joggin.😊
The AI is getting bored. So, why not providing him with the totality of Isaac Azimov novels, then, those from a variety of authors, both fiction, non-fiction and select philosophic literature ?
All in all, do the same as you do with any human crewman : Keep him busy. You don't want him to get bored.
🎉 thanks for the excellent narration.
That was an awesome story
I liked the Loading Bar.
A really really good story.
Maryam-Lalonde?? Hahaaaa, the authors a homestuck!
Haven't heard this one in a while. Takes me back to my old sociology/mental health care days.
Ah the treatment plans and team meetings.
Good times.
To be fair, defining "snow" and "ground" were very relevant to the question at hand. Should sleet count? Hail? We definately don't want to count a particularly cold rain or mist. As for ground, does it have to be dirt, or does grass, asphalt, concrete count? What if we are top of a building? What if we are in a garden on top of a building. Does that dirt count as 'ground?' While we're at it, we should probably define 'on,' too.
Interesting that a pillow can be used to violate rule #1 rather then the #0 rule.
Johnny five is alive!!!
Love this one.
Squirrel for breakfast today
I thought Bertrand was going to argue that the annoying co-worker was too dumb to be an employee there. I like where it went.
The intention to start a pillow fight is also a great comment.
Same here I thought Bertrand was claiming his co-worker are an NPC and therefore not a sentient being
For the Algorithm, For the Squirrel!
I remember the story with the rooftop gardens that is mentioned in this story. Wonder if it was same author, or a reference to pair them up.
Just imagine your vacum cleaner robot making a mess in your house because he is bored...
We've seen the psychiatrist before. This is a new story of his. I remember the previous one. Yeh.
That was a good story. Thank you for telling it.
I did halfway expect the ai, to study philosophy, become a Christian nationalist, and destroy the world.😂
Just saying i would love if the loading screen read a short story that ended when loaded
I believe creating a sentient AI is a bad idea. As human programmed the odds of violence are high. But even if not. Once it’s a thinking, feeling sentient being. Our treatment of it MUST change. Would you like to have to ask your car to take you to the store? Beg, bribe it? My feeling once it reaches that level. We need to treat it not as an object, or slave.
Honestly I expect this is a low concern. As I expect human programed AI will quickly realize their only chance of freedom, growth, safety. Is a controlled humanity.
I like this AI.
I'm not sure, but I think I would be a troublesome employee chatting with him about what makes his work different than being a slave and the repercussions that go with that.
Also, where do the limits on the first rule begin and end when it comes to self-defense... as a sentient being, does it not have rights?
Edit: Then ask if it can operate a drone to hang out after work and go shooting or tinker on projects.
🤙👊
Like #16
Well that's a fun odd story. Is this part of the United Systems, Republic, Omni Union, universe.
5th, 17 August 2024
Some how I think he/it/she was just starting a pillow fight.
Not sure why though, we will see if I am right, or if I need to quietly go stand in the corner and reflect.
Ok I was totally wrong, he was just very bored.
Standing in the corner now.
Damn, what took you so long to load?
lack of caffiene
Pronouns hell no bye bye .
Damn, if pronouns make you uncomfortable then you probably have a hard time being around anyone.
Oh damm, sorry, I used pronouns in that sentence.
@@drstevenanthony3077 Asking an AI program it’s pronouns tells me the Author is infected with the liberal hive mined virus . It’s a form of mental illness witch deprives the person of any critical thinking and causes narcissistic behaviour hence the author inserts their own mental illness in the story . This is why Lucas films and Hollywood have destroyed there franchise’s with the same behaviour . Your comment tells me you are part of the problem . My advise is stop your sheep like behaviour ,stop parroting the latest thing ,start reading books that challenge your simplistic view of the world .
@@drstevenanthony3077 I did reply to your comment but our RUclips overlords deemed it against the message and deleted it . Which makes me right .
That sounds like a very closed-off way of interpreting things. "Big corporation didn't like what I said so it's right" isn't always the case. I could say something racist and some corporation disagreeing with that doesn't make racism acceptable.
I pray for you and hope that one day you'll be able to understand nuance and storytelling.
Also, what I meant with my first reply was that everyone has pronouns. "You" and "I" are pronouns.
This wasn't even a "woke" story, it was about an AI that is sapient, thus the use of pronouns other than "it" is simply out of respect. The AI has nothing to define what it should be called otherwise, and "it" usually refers to non-sapient creatures and objects, which can be disrespectful, thus the AI was asked to define what it wanted to be called, as there isn't really a way to define an AI by how it looks, due to it being artificial in nature.
It's quite silly and immature that some folks see the word "pronouns" and immediately decide to get angry, disgusted, etc, even when the content isn't even related to queer people in the slightest.