I am so proud ,more so because both Behram and Zenobia are my personal friends. Bahram is my batchmate of IMA, Dehradun. He has sent me this video link as part of E- mail day before yesterday only.. Col P L Prashar (Veteran) ,Dehradun
शेर सिंह की मां वाला किस्सा सुनकर मैं इतना emotional हो गया आंखों से आंसु नहीं रोक पाया मैं धन्यवाद कहना चाहता हूं लल्लंटोप सौरव द्विवेदी जी और इस किताब को लिखने वाले और इस कथा को हमे सुनने वाले आर्मी ऑफिसर को उन्होंने हमे जनरल मनिक शाह के बारे में बताया अगर स्वर्गीय मानेक शाह जीवित होते तो सौरव सर आपके भांति में भी उनके क़दमों को अपने माथे से लगा लेता
Excellent conversation... It has really enriched my soul... what an Officer and a Gentleman FIELD MARSHAL SAM MANEKSHAW .....thankyou Saurabhji...and Kudos to the Panthaki couple... thankyou once again...
सटीक, सत्य, तथ्यपरक,मन और आत्मा को सुकून देने बाली निष्पक्ष वार्ता। विदुषी सम्मानीय महिला एवं वार्ताकार को इस सार्थक विचारविमर्श के लिए बहुत बहुत धन्यबाद।
Thanks Saurabh , SAM Badhur is a true hiro. I am very small person , this episode gives me an opportunity to refresh my memory of 71 war. I really feel proud to have him . My salute to him.
Thanks saurabh n team Lallan Top for this heartwarming episode, a good refresh of historical indo pak war 1971,where the unit to which I belong 10 Dogra won the Battle Honour Dera Baba Nanak in Western Theatre under leadership of late Brig NS Sandhu MVC, Hope the Nation values the contribution of Field Marshall and his Team in this astounding victory which resulted in Creation of New Country Bangladesh , our cumulative gratitude to Team Lallan Top for bringing out the nation through their episode .my salute to Behram sir and Mrs B Panthaki for the book as well faultless recall.
What a brilliant interview. Very, very proud to be a Parsi. We are a small community with a big heart, and always willing to serve our great motherland. Also, kudos to Brigadier and Mrs. Panthaki for donating the proceeds from the sale of their book to benefit our veterans. God Bless you both.
@@rakshittripathi7240 No Sir, Tarak Mehta is not a Parsi. Parsees though have adopted many Gujarati and Maharashtrian last names, e.g. Mehta, Joshi, Rao etc. This is one way in which we as a community have assimilated in our beautiful country
The most REMARKABLE interview that I have viewed. Absolutely fantastic. God Bless Brigadier Panthaki and his lady wife. May they have a long and healthy life together. Jai Hind. Jai Bheem.
Abhi rat ko 3 se 5 ke time ye dekh raha hu....dil aur ankhe dono unki yaad aur samman me bhar aayi hai.... Thanku Saurabh bhai... Jai hind jai hind ki sena...
I thought I would go through the glimpses of interview...but I glued with the screen after few minutes....may be my belt connected me with Field Marshal but Saurav I must say credit also goes to your interview skills and deep knowledge.
Thank you Lallan top to bring this story for viewers. I am really very much thankful to you for this.Thank you sir for this awesome story of our 1st honorable field marshal's story. He is our real hero. Really thank you from bottom of my heart
I can't stop thanking Lallantop team and Saurabh bhai for having such a wonderful episode of Kitabwala. Field Marshal Manakshaw is an inspiration for million of Indians. Thanks to the Authors for such a wonderful book.. I will definitely buy it.
FM Sam was a legend and will remain so for all times. Enjoying anecdotes relating to him is my food for soul. I appreciate your effort. Anyway comments of the author on Nehru might have disturbed you. But facts are facts. The author has depicted exemplary honesty in the narrative.
आदरणीय सौरभ जी, आप बहुत अच्छा काम कर रहे हैं। वैसे तो हम आपकी सभी रिपोर्टस ध्यान से सुनते हैं, लेकिन यह पूरी वार्ता हमने व्यस्तता के दौरान भी शब्दश: सुनी। प्वाइंट्स भी नोट किए। आपको बहुत-बहुत साधुवाद। प्रभु आपको स्वच्छता के साथ लंबी आयु दें। ब्रिगेडियर दंपत्ति को हमारा हार्दिक भाग्योदय प्रणाम।
यह एपिसोड बहुत ही स्मरणीय और प्रेरणादायी है। हमारे भारत की सेना के यह अद्वितीय रत्न हैं। हर भारतीय को गर्व है। ऐसा व्यक्तिव बिरलो में देखने को मिलता है। फ़ील्ड मार्शल मानिकसा को देर सही भारत रत्नसेभारत सरकार को सम्मानित करना चाहिए। हिन्दी में किताब आ गई? ह जानकारी के लिए बहुत बहुत धन्यवाद
I haven't the words to describe the importance of this video and the way/style/gratitude you interviewed them! How do I thank you?...... not possible for me......
Thank you lallantop and Saurabhji for such beautiful program...I wish you people would have been around 15years back ....had it been so today I must be collector some where...ha ha ha
Wonderful interview. My compliments for all. Such a lovely couple. May you both live a long healthy life and it is so nice of you to bring the couple too the forefront.
Thank you lallantop for this awesome interview... This talk will always near to my heart... And yes I will surely read more about our HIRO of this story....
बेहराम दम्पत्ति को मेरा प्रणाम सादर प्रणाम आप ने जनरल मानेक शॉ की जिंदगी और उनके कार्य क्षेतर पर प्रकाश डाला आप की कोशिश सराहनीय है धन्यवाद शुक्रिया जयहिंद !
SAM MANEKSHAW WILL BE REMAINED IN OUR HEART FOR EVER. SALUTE SALUTE SALUTE SALUTE SALUTE TO HINDUSTHANI ARMY KOTI KOTI PRANAM JAY HINDUSTHAN BANDEMATARAM BHARAT MATA KI JAY HO JAY
My god!!! Amazing interview and amazing story! Hats off Saurabh to you for such a beautiful n inspiring interviews.... And of course thanks to Brig n ma’am to take time to pen down such a legend! Jai Hind!
Very very nice programme. Awesome. Sourabh you were asking very good questions and details of incidents. At a stretch I saw the whole episode. Keep it up .
The new generation does not know about Sam Bahadur. Congress suppressed Sam’s contribution including when Field Marshal died, not a single Congress minister went to pay respect.
@@1saurabhd It was the book written by Lieutenant general Depinder Singh, PVSM, VSM. He was Military Assistant to Field Marshal when he was Army chief from 1969 to 1972. It primarily covers his days as Army chief and Bangladesh Liberation War
“If anyone tells you he is never afraid, he is a Liar or he is a GORAKHA.” Field Marshal Sam Hormusji Framji Jamshedji Manekshaw. It is our misfortune that our country did not respect to him.😕
Wow Saurabhji thank you for doing this interview. Thank you all defense forces of India for what they do for the country. Gussa bhi aaya the way Field Marshall was treated by govt and bureaucrats.
It was really very much informative discussion about the First Field Marshal Manek Shah. I would like to thank both of patriot writers and Saurabh Ji for this.
What an amazing Personality Sam Manekshaw Sir.. Respect from Heart. Nice effort Lallantop team. It hurts to hear the way ppl dnt remember the Actaul, Great Heros of our country. Those who can buy and help the noble cause, please buy the book and read it. :)
CORPS OF SIGNALS IS WELL DISCIPLINED CORPS OF INDIAN ARMY,LT Kanika Rane collected the gallantry medal of her husband Major Kaustubh Rane who was killed in an encounter with terrorists along the Line of Control in 2018. SMT KANIKA RANE GREAT OFFICER In CORPS OF SIGNALS.ALL THE SOLDIERS OF INDIAN ARMY FACED PAY AND ALLOWANCE PROBLEMS NO BODY IS RESPONSIBLE FOR SOLDIERS ,PAYMENTS BUT ALL ACCOUNTS AND PERSONAL ASSISTANCE FOR GEN
What a great delight to see this video . I think the who video was superbly conducted by Mr Saurab Dwivedi and both Mrs and Brig Pantkiki recapitulated the honest TIMES of the greatest Field Marshal of all time. I have been tracking Field Marshal since a long time and whenever he is renembered anywhere at any time or place , believe me as a gentleman I get a sense of pride to salute such a great SOLDIER. THANKS FOR THIS VIDEO
Very touchy abhi bhi deir nahi hui Sudharna jaruri Hai Hamari Ministry ko Desh k Liye Kurban hone wali Fouji k Jaisa Field Marshall Manek Shah k prati bhool ki Future m ainsa kabhi n Ho. JAIHIND Thanks S. Divedi
It is understood R&AW's role was not only restricted to report on the misbehaviour of some army officers. It played a great and decisive role in 1971 war.
I am so proud ,more so because both Behram and Zenobia are my personal friends. Bahram is my batchmate of IMA, Dehradun. He has sent me this video link as part of E- mail day before yesterday only.. Col P L Prashar (Veteran) ,Dehradun
Thank you sir for your service
❤️❤️❤️🙏🙏🙏
@@pinakibanerjee4311 iii
शेर सिंह की मां वाला किस्सा सुनकर मैं इतना emotional हो गया
आंखों से आंसु नहीं रोक पाया
मैं धन्यवाद कहना चाहता हूं लल्लंटोप सौरव द्विवेदी जी और इस किताब को लिखने वाले और इस कथा को हमे सुनने वाले आर्मी ऑफिसर को उन्होंने हमे जनरल मनिक शाह के बारे में बताया
अगर स्वर्गीय मानेक शाह जीवित होते तो सौरव सर आपके भांति में भी उनके क़दमों को अपने माथे से लगा लेता
yes brother
same with me also
मेरी आँख नम हो गई
Eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee
Really same are my feelings 🙏
.
Excellent conversation... It has really enriched my soul... what an Officer and a Gentleman FIELD MARSHAL SAM MANEKSHAW .....thankyou Saurabhji...and Kudos to the Panthaki couple... thankyou once again...
We the people of India can still think ofconferring many more honours to this great man s v Singh d g p rtd pb 8699016826
सटीक, सत्य, तथ्यपरक,मन और आत्मा को सुकून देने बाली निष्पक्ष वार्ता।
विदुषी सम्मानीय महिला एवं वार्ताकार को इस सार्थक विचारविमर्श के लिए
बहुत बहुत धन्यबाद।
Thanks Saurabh , SAM Badhur is a true hiro. I am very small person , this episode gives me an opportunity to refresh my memory of 71 war. I really feel proud to have him . My salute to him.
Sir first field was kariapa
Thanks saurabh n team Lallan Top for this heartwarming episode, a good refresh of historical indo pak war 1971,where the unit to which I belong 10 Dogra won the Battle Honour Dera Baba Nanak in Western Theatre under leadership of late Brig NS Sandhu MVC, Hope the Nation values the contribution of Field Marshall and his Team in this astounding victory which resulted in Creation of New Country Bangladesh , our cumulative gratitude to Team Lallan Top for bringing out the nation through their episode .my salute to Behram sir and Mrs B Panthaki for the book as well faultless recall.
What a brilliant interview. Very, very proud to be a Parsi. We are a small community with a big heart, and always willing to serve our great motherland. Also, kudos to Brigadier and Mrs. Panthaki for donating the proceeds from the sale of their book to benefit our veterans. God Bless you both.
Tarak mehta is also Parsi
Are all mehtas parsi
I grew up with Parsis as my neighbours .. Very colourful community and a enjoyable companionship
@@rakshittripathi7240 No Sir, Tarak Mehta is not a Parsi. Parsees though have adopted many Gujarati and Maharashtrian last names, e.g. Mehta, Joshi, Rao etc. This is one way in which we as a community have assimilated in our beautiful country
The most REMARKABLE interview that I have viewed. Absolutely fantastic. God Bless Brigadier Panthaki and his lady wife. May they have a long and healthy life together. Jai Hind. Jai Bheem.
NatoHero forever
Belonging to army background...I heard this Bangladesh war frm my father ..I loved it... really got emotional..
Goosebumps ....... any time you heard about Field Marshal Manecksaw
Abhi rat ko 3 se 5 ke time ye dekh raha hu....dil aur ankhe dono unki yaad aur samman me bhar aayi hai....
Thanku Saurabh bhai...
Jai hind jai hind ki sena...
I thought I would go through the glimpses of interview...but I glued with the screen after few minutes....may be my belt connected me with Field Marshal but Saurav I must say credit also goes to your interview skills and deep knowledge.
Thank you Lallan top to bring this story for viewers. I am really very much thankful to you for this.Thank you sir for this awesome story of our 1st honorable field marshal's story. He is our real hero. Really thank you from bottom of my heart
ये पूरी कहानी हमें बहुत कुछ सिखाती है,कितने भी बड़े क्यों न बन जाओ पर ज़मीन से जुड़े रहो। शुक्रिया 🙏
I can't stop thanking Lallantop team and Saurabh bhai for having such a wonderful episode of Kitabwala. Field Marshal Manakshaw is an inspiration for million of Indians. Thanks to the Authors for such a wonderful book.. I will definitely buy it.
Very true.
This is my best kitabe wala episode......
FM Sam was a legend and will remain so for all times. Enjoying anecdotes relating to him is my food for soul. I appreciate your effort. Anyway comments of the author on Nehru might have disturbed you. But facts are facts. The author has depicted exemplary honesty in the narrative.
Sat sat naman in sabhi mahanubhavo ko aur specially field Marshal SAM sir ko
आदरणीय सौरभ जी, आप बहुत अच्छा काम कर रहे हैं। वैसे तो हम आपकी सभी रिपोर्टस ध्यान से सुनते हैं, लेकिन यह पूरी वार्ता हमने व्यस्तता के दौरान भी शब्दश: सुनी। प्वाइंट्स भी नोट किए। आपको बहुत-बहुत साधुवाद।
प्रभु आपको स्वच्छता के साथ लंबी आयु दें। ब्रिगेडियर दंपत्ति को हमारा हार्दिक भाग्योदय प्रणाम।
यह एपिसोड बहुत ही स्मरणीय और प्रेरणादायी है।
हमारे भारत की सेना के यह अद्वितीय रत्न हैं। हर भारतीय को गर्व है।
ऐसा व्यक्तिव बिरलो में देखने को मिलता है।
फ़ील्ड मार्शल मानिकसा को देर सही भारत रत्नसेभारत सरकार को सम्मानित करना चाहिए।
हिन्दी में किताब आ गई?
ह
जानकारी के लिए बहुत बहुत धन्यवाद
One of the best interviews ever...kamaal kar dia Saurabh bhai
Salutes Dil se Field Marshal Manikshah ji ko...Jai Hind.
Just loved it. I big salute to late Field marshal Sir Sam Manekshaw.
Hat's off to such officers of the Indian Army! THANK YOU saurabh for a well conducted interview! Lots of information on the brave leader Sam Bahadur.
Field Marshall SAM MANECKSHAW, an absolute legend❤🙌
Oh sir ! Adorable
Sam sir my shat shat vandan 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼
Great great interview... salute brigadier sir and maam
Awesome
Respect for The Legend.
I haven't the words to describe the importance of this video and the way/style/gratitude you interviewed them! How do I thank you?...... not possible for me......
Thank you lallantop and Saurabhji for such beautiful program...I wish you people would have been around 15years back ....had it been so today I must be collector some where...ha ha ha
सही में सौरभ भाई ये बहुत ख़ास बातचीत थी
Wonderful interview. My compliments for all.
Such a lovely couple. May you both live a long healthy life and it is so nice of you to bring the couple too the forefront.
One of the best conversation i have seen after a long time. Thanks Lallantop 🙂
Thank you lallantop for this awesome interview... This talk will always near to my heart... And yes I will surely read more about our HIRO of this story....
बेहराम दम्पत्ति को मेरा प्रणाम सादर प्रणाम आप ने जनरल मानेक शॉ की जिंदगी और उनके कार्य क्षेतर पर प्रकाश डाला आप की कोशिश सराहनीय है धन्यवाद शुक्रिया जयहिंद !
Sam Manekshaw was indeed a great man!!
SAM MANEKSHAW WILL BE REMAINED IN OUR HEART FOR EVER.
SALUTE SALUTE SALUTE SALUTE
SALUTE TO HINDUSTHANI ARMY
KOTI KOTI PRANAM
JAY HINDUSTHAN
BANDEMATARAM
BHARAT MATA KI JAY HO JAY
Superb.. A great discussion on A Great Man The Manek Shaw.. Thank u Saurabh for having both of them on show..
loved this interview.. hope you will bring out stories of gems like these for us in the future.. absolutely fantastic..
Excellent information, great salute to all
Best ever conversation ever heard, one from the lovely people. 😊
Superb interview.....Thanks Saurav ji
One of the best episode..thank you very much. Sourabh jee. First time comment kar raha hu.
Respect to Brigadier Behram sir, he may be old by age, but he looks very young.
Great !!! Parsis are always straight forward to talking.👏👏👏
My god!!! Amazing interview and amazing story! Hats off Saurabh to you for such a beautiful n inspiring interviews.... And of course thanks to Brig n ma’am to take time to pen down such a legend! Jai Hind!
Jai hind 🙏
Awesome interview / Discussion...Sam Bahadur aka Field Marshal Sam Manekshaw was the great son of this land....
Very very nice programme. Awesome. Sourabh you were asking very good questions and details of incidents. At a stretch I saw the whole episode. Keep it up .
This interview should have had more views. Truely remarkable story.
The new generation does not know about Sam Bahadur. Congress suppressed Sam’s contribution including when Field Marshal died, not a single Congress minister went to pay respect.
Wonderful interview. My favourite section of Lallantop
Great conversation, so emotional.
*last night i was reading Soldiering with Dignity by Depinder Singh*
another great book on Field Marshal Sam Manekshaw
more details please
Is it in hindi
@@1saurabhd It was the book written by Lieutenant general Depinder Singh, PVSM, VSM. He was Military Assistant to Field Marshal when he was Army chief from 1969 to 1972. It primarily covers his days as Army chief and Bangladesh Liberation War
“If anyone tells you he is never afraid, he is a Liar or he is a GORAKHA.”
Field Marshal Sam Hormusji Framji Jamshedji Manekshaw.
It is our misfortune that our country did not respect to him.😕
Agar aaj manekshaw jinda hote unke Pakistan wale byan ko leykar unka kya hall hota.He would have been doomed a anti nationalist.
I am not agree with you
Lovely couple, Respected couple
Genl. Great human being we love very much.
gonna purchase this book today right away...jai hind aur Bahadur Jindabad tha aur rahega jindabad
One of the best episodes so far 😊
Love respects and salutes to great sam 😍😍😍
Wow Saurabhji thank you for doing this interview. Thank you all defense forces of India for what they do for the country. Gussa bhi aaya the way Field Marshall was treated by govt and bureaucrats.
Bs maza aa gaya sun kar, bs I have to change in reader. Bahoot kuch pata chala aaj..
Jai Hind 🇮🇳🙏
Hindustani log itne ache aur itne pyare hote hai ki bs mai bata nhi skta jai hind 😍😍😍😘😘😘😘
Shandar lajwab behtarin.dil khush hogaya.
It was really very much informative discussion about the First Field Marshal Manek Shah. I would like to thank both of patriot writers and Saurabh Ji for this.
Last story brought tears 😥.
Great respect to both writers no words for FM sahab n our brave soldiers
2 interview
Both r best.💋💋
What an amazing Personality Sam Manekshaw Sir.. Respect from Heart. Nice effort Lallantop team. It hurts to hear the way ppl dnt remember the Actaul, Great Heros of our country. Those who can buy and help the noble cause, please buy the book and read it. :)
Ï
Fav Series. Thanks Lallantop for the time you invest. Gotta get my hands on this one!
It’s a lifetime experience hearing
I like the smile of Behram sir
Really felt proud of him and salute to him he will always remain in our hearts
Big thanks lallantop , & salute our real heroes , I'm excited to read the book sir.
Jay. Hind. Saurav. Sab
FM SAM is a national Hero. He was always jovial. It was a great discussion.
Aaj tak ka sabse best episode of kitab bala
शानदार चर्चा थी यह बहुत अच्छा लगा कुछ नई बात भी पता चली
CORPS OF SIGNALS IS WELL DISCIPLINED CORPS OF INDIAN ARMY,LT Kanika Rane collected the gallantry medal of her husband Major Kaustubh Rane who was killed in an encounter with terrorists along the Line of Control in 2018. SMT KANIKA RANE GREAT OFFICER In CORPS OF SIGNALS.ALL THE SOLDIERS OF INDIAN ARMY FACED PAY AND ALLOWANCE PROBLEMS NO BODY IS RESPONSIBLE FOR SOLDIERS ,PAYMENTS BUT ALL ACCOUNTS AND PERSONAL ASSISTANCE FOR GEN
Saurabh
It's was a great interview
Thanks bahut hi anand aaya ye sab sun kar
What a great delight to see this video . I think the who video was superbly conducted by Mr Saurab Dwivedi and both Mrs and Brig Pantkiki recapitulated the honest TIMES of the greatest Field Marshal of all time.
I have been tracking Field Marshal since a long time and whenever he is renembered anywhere at any time or place , believe me as a gentleman I get a sense of pride to salute such a great SOLDIER.
THANKS FOR THIS VIDEO
Thankyou soo much for this show ,very nice 😇😇
Very touchy
abhi bhi deir nahi hui
Sudharna jaruri Hai Hamari Ministry ko
Desh k Liye Kurban hone wali Fouji k
Jaisa Field Marshall Manek Shah k prati bhool ki Future m ainsa kabhi n Ho. JAIHIND
Thanks S. Divedi
Great, I admire you Saurabh. Keep going.
इसी का इंतजार रहता है किताब वाला
An interesting discussion esp on 1971 war which I listened with nostalgic reminiscence.
It is understood R&AW's role was not only restricted to report on the misbehaviour of some army officers. It played a great and decisive role in 1971 war.
Salute to Sir Manek Shaw as well as writers.🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Very happy smile if Sir Behram😃
Thanks both of you and lallantop
Pls buy this as tribute to The Great General and Wounded soldiers
What a beautiful interview!! Kudos to interviewees and interviewer.
And most importantly, Salute to FM Manekshaw 🫡
What an interview and story telling! Ordered the book, looking forward.
में भी उनको सैल्युट करता ,यदि आज फील्ड मार्शल माणिक शो आज जीवित होते ।
La-Lallan bhai dil khush kar diya
What a hero.
Salute to my indian army
I m big fan of SAM. BAHADUR.. SALUTE TO SAM SIR FROM HEART..
Excellent Interview 👍
Best informative discussion by Hon. Bregadiyar Sir......Thanks Sir..
Sir I like lallan top good job I like it nice interview 👏💪
Saurabh you guys are doing Brilliant Work through Kitabwala...
Thanks Indian Army and Indira Ji,
Great work Ltop
Great great episode. delighted to watch this. great man great life