Part 4 || Reply to Dr Zubair sahib on Imamat || shia k bishumar firqi
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 9 сен 2024
- Part 4 || Reply to Dr Zubair sahib on Imamat || shia k bishumar firqi
#hazratabubakr #imamat #imamahussain
In this video, Dr. Muhammad Zubair's Imamat lectures have been criticized, Dr. Sahib's ignorance of Imamat has been described, and the unnecessary objections to Imamat have been answered in spite of the Shias.
The series of Imamate lessons is going on, each and every objection of the doctor will be answered in detail. inshallah
Part 1 || Reply to Dr Zubair sahib on Imamat || Ten mistakes of Dr. Zubair Sahib || Syed Abuimad
• Part 1 || Reply to Dr ...
Part 2 | Musliheen or Munharifeen | Dr Sahib! Please don't cheat academically. Explained by Abuimad
• Part 2 | Musliheen or...
Part 3 | the Difference between Bukhari and kafi | Reply to Dr Zubair sahib by Syed Abuimad official
• Part 3 | the Differenc...
Part 4 || Reply to Dr Zubair sahib on Imamat || shia k bishumar firqi
• Part 4 || Reply to Dr ...
Part 5 | Imamat | Reply to Dr Zubair sahib by Syed Abuimad official
• Part 5 | Imamat | Repl...
Part 6 || Reply to Dr Zubair sahib on Imamat || Imamat ka bary baity ko intiqal?
• Part 6 || Reply to Dr ...
@DrHafizMuhammadZubair
@NahdStudio
Amazing video, JazakAllah
Jazakallah
MashaAllah MOLA salaamat Rakhay Aameen
asm............1) Is THIS man-made story a Proof of Shia Imamat from This Quran or U got it from Imam Ghaib from a Cave ??????
2) Do U believe that 28/7 = 13 or NOT ???????? (Very important for Proof of Shia Imamat from Quran, so answer this as well. It will not take more that 5 sec to answer it as YES or NO….). As It is an Open-Book Q, U can also get help from any Shia Ayatullah or Imam Ghaib as well to answer this simple Math Q..
3) What is the purpose of Imam Ghaib of Shia, if He can not help YOU even to solve this Simple Math problem???? In this regards, Imam of Agha Khani (Ismailis) is FAR FAR BETTER, at least He (Present Agha Khan, who made Aga Khan University & Hospital in Karachi) tries HIS best to solve the problems of His Nation (Ismaelis). I am sure If ask from HIM about this SIMPLE Math Problem, He will solve it in few Seconds!!!!! Even a 10 year’s old school child of Agha Khani can solve this Math Problem. I must tell you that NOT only YOU but 99% Shia Do not answer this Simple math Q ?????????
❤❤❤❤❤
MashAllah
Stay happy always brother Abu Imad Haidri sahb
Masha'Allah 😊 very helpful 💓🔥😊
سلامت رہیں قبلہ
بہت زبردست جواب دیا سید۔ سلامت رہیں استاد ❤
rab...........1) Is THIS man-made story a Proof of Shia Imamat from This Quran or U got it from Imam Ghaib from a Cave ??????
2) Do U believe that 28/7 = 13 or NOT ???????? (Very important for Proof of Shia Imamat from Quran, so answer this as well. It will not take more that 5 sec to answer it as YES or NO….). As It is an Open-Book Q, U can also get help from any Shia Ayatullah or Imam Ghaib as well to answer this simple Math Q..
3) What is the purpose of Imam Ghaib of Shia, if He can not help YOU even to solve this Simple Math problem???? In this regards, Imam of Agha Khani (Ismailis) is FAR FAR BETTER, at least He (Present Agha Khan, who made Aga Khan University & Hospital in Karachi) tries HIS best to solve the problems of His Nation (Ismaelis). I am sure If ask from HIM about this SIMPLE Math Problem, He will solve it in few Seconds!!!!! Even a 10 year’s old school child of Agha Khani can solve this Math Problem. I must tell you that NOT only YOU but 99% Shia Do not answer this Simple math Q ?????????
You are a precious gem of this era ❤️❤️😊
We are proud of you allama Sahab 💕❣️😍😊
You are a precious gem of this era ⚠️💎💕
Bohat zabardast❤ allah apki tofeeq ma izafa kary❤
سلامت رہیں بھائی
pho................1) Whatever U are writing or speaking here is dependent on Shia Imamat. For this reason, I ask To All Shia (and Shia Ayatullah as well): 1) First prove the concept of Shia Imamat and then talk about others. I am asking this because; According to Shia MAZHAB, Imams (Like Prophets) are appointed by Allah ST and if one will not recognize/accept him, he/she will NOT be a Muslim and go into Jahanum for ever ruclips.net/video/IERVPXh9Hqo/видео.html ruclips.net/video/OIiNePgctF8/видео.html (Zakat & Ring story).
As this claim is vey very BIG, the EVIDENCE about this claim should also VERY BIG, LIKE CLEAR NAME of IMAMS in Quran. So first give any Proof from Quran (Quran Challenge) that Syadana Ali (AS & RA) was Imam declared by Allah ST after the Death of Syadana Muhammad (PBUH). This is because Quran is the final book (MEZAN, means distingusher between RIGHT and WRONG related to Islam) of Allah ST and is Alhamdolillah COMMON between Shia and Non-Shia. According to Shia the PRESENT QURAN is compiled by Syadana Ali (AS & RA). Regarding History, and even Hadeeses, they are different for Shia and non-shia, so first is Quran ruclips.net/user/postUgw7gF_08N6U1X4uVLd4AaABCQ
and then we can discuss about Hadees as well. So, show a single verse in the present Quran, which says
“O believers, after the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH), there will be TWELVE IMAMS (or especially Ali, AS & RA) chosen by Allah and you should follow them.”
Do not worry I am here and will reply you IA.
2) SUMMARY OF MY QUESTION; Gentleman my Q consists of 3 CRITICAL WORDS, i) Allah's sayings (means Quran), ii) NAME of Syadana Ali (AS & RA) and iii) IMAM. This is because as stated above "Shia Claim that, Imams (Like Prophets) are CHOSEN by Allah ST". Therefore, GO and FIND the answers of these 3 ESSENTIAL words. It is a Compulsory Q in Exam and without answering these 3 words, you will get ZERO marks by the public.
3) Do U believe that 28 Divided by 7 = 13 or NOT ???????? (Very important for Proof of Shia Imamat from Quran, so answer this as well. It will not take more that 5 sec to answer it as YES or NO….). As It is an Open-Book Q, U can also get help from any Shia Ayatullah or Imam Ghaib as well to answer this simple Math Q...,,,,,,,…
Well done 👍✅😊
Mehnati tahqiq.....good.
بہت عمدہ تحقیق ہے❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
عمدہ استدلات ھیں.جزاکﷲ
use...............1) Whatever U are writing or speaking here is dependent on Shia Imamat. For this reason, I ask To All Shia (and Shia Ayatullah as well): 1) First prove the concept of Shia Imamat and then talk about others. I am asking this because; According to Shia MAZHAB, Imams (Like Prophets) are appointed by Allah ST and if one will not recognize/accept him, he/she will NOT be a Muslim and go into Jahanum for ever ruclips.net/video/IERVPXh9Hqo/видео.html ruclips.net/video/OIiNePgctF8/видео.html (Zakat & Ring story).
As this claim is vey very BIG, the EVIDENCE about this claim should also VERY BIG, LIKE CLEAR NAME of IMAMS in Quran. So first give any Proof from Quran (Quran Challenge) that Syadana Ali (AS & RA) was Imam declared by Allah ST after the Death of Syadana Muhammad (PBUH). This is because Quran is the final book (MEZAN, means distingusher between RIGHT and WRONG related to Islam) of Allah ST and is Alhamdolillah COMMON between Shia and Non-Shia. According to Shia the PRESENT QURAN is compiled by Syadana Ali (AS & RA). Regarding History, and even Hadeeses, they are different for Shia and non-shia, so first is Quran ruclips.net/user/postUgw7gF_08N6U1X4uVLd4AaABCQ
and then we can discuss about Hadees as well. So, show a single verse in the present Quran, which says
“O believers, after the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH), there will be TWELVE IMAMS (or especially Ali, AS & RA) chosen by Allah and you should follow them.”
Do not worry I am here and will reply you IA.
2) SUMMARY OF MY QUESTION; Gentleman my Q consists of 3 CRITICAL WORDS, i) Allah's sayings (means Quran), ii) NAME of Syadana Ali (AS & RA) and iii) IMAM. This is because as stated above "Shia Claim that, Imams (Like Prophets) are CHOSEN by Allah ST". Therefore, GO and FIND the answers of these 3 ESSENTIAL words. It is a Compulsory Q in Exam and without answering these 3 words, you will get ZERO marks by the public.
3) Do U believe that 28 Divided by 7 = 13 or NOT ???????? (Very important for Proof of Shia Imamat from Quran, so answer this as well. It will not take more that 5 sec to answer it as YES or NO….). As It is an Open-Book Q, U can also get help from any Shia Ayatullah or Imam Ghaib as well to answer this simple Math Q...,,,,,,,…
ماشاءاللہ اللہ تعالیٰ آپ کو سلامت رکھیں
Bohat zabardast allah apki tofeeq ma izafa kary
sye............1) Whatever U are writing or speaking here is dependent on Shia Imamat. For this reason, I ask To All Shia (and Shia Ayatullah as well): 1) First prove the concept of Shia Imamat and then talk about others. I am asking this because; According to Shia MAZHAB, Imams (Like Prophets) are appointed by Allah ST and if one will not recognize/accept him, he/she will NOT be a Muslim and go into Jahanum for ever ruclips.net/video/IERVPXh9Hqo/видео.html ruclips.net/video/OIiNePgctF8/видео.html (Zakat & Ring story).
As this claim is vey very BIG, the EVIDENCE about this claim should also VERY BIG, LIKE CLEAR NAME of IMAMS in Quran. So first give any Proof from Quran (Quran Challenge) that Syadana Ali (AS & RA) was Imam declared by Allah ST after the Death of Syadana Muhammad (PBUH). This is because Quran is the final book (MEZAN, means distingusher between RIGHT and WRONG related to Islam) of Allah ST and is Alhamdolillah COMMON between Shia and Non-Shia. According to Shia the PRESENT QURAN is compiled by Syadana Ali (AS & RA). Regarding History, and even Hadeeses, they are different for Shia and non-shia, so first is Quran ruclips.net/user/postUgw7gF_08N6U1X4uVLd4AaABCQ
and then we can discuss about Hadees as well. So, show a single verse in the present Quran, which says
“O believers, after the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH), there will be TWELVE IMAMS (or especially Ali, AS & RA) chosen by Allah and you should follow them.”
Do not worry I am here and will reply you IA.
2) SUMMARY OF MY QUESTION; Gentleman my Q consists of 3 CRITICAL WORDS, i) Allah's sayings (means Quran), ii) NAME of Syadana Ali (AS & RA) and iii) IMAM. This is because as stated above "Shia Claim that, Imams (Like Prophets) are CHOSEN by Allah ST". Therefore, GO and FIND the answers of these 3 ESSENTIAL words. It is a Compulsory Q in Exam and without answering these 3 words, you will get ZERO marks by the public.
3) Do U believe that 28 Divided by 7 = 13 or NOT ???????? (Very important for Proof of Shia Imamat from Quran, so answer this as well. It will not take more that 5 sec to answer it as YES or NO….). As It is an Open-Book Q, U can also get help from any Shia Ayatullah or Imam Ghaib as well to answer this simple Math Q...,,,,,,,…
ID blocked
1) Please note that my ALL Four IDs are blocked for Video sites and I am unable to write my comments. They are soon deleted after uploading here. I do not know, WHY. Otherwise I have same answers for your ALL comments on Video as well. However, Alahmdolillah my IDs are working for Audio sites (as this). If any SHIA is doing this highly unethical act, then He/she must think that they have to answer Allah ST on day of judgement (if they believe on THAT day of JUSTICE) ....So do not worry when my IDs will be open I will write answers to ALL of your's comments.
2) Your feed-back is highly appreciated.
3) Is this Teaching of Syadana Ali (AS & RA) ??????????
4) For this reason I can not reply Shia's video's comments.......... Simple as that....
ruclips.net/video/JdXwgA8cp2w/видео.html
I will appreciate if you will upload my this Shia Imamt Q on this site. Thanks in advance.
@@hassanjaved4068 🤣🤣🤣🤣😂😂😂😂😂
@@SyedHussainiOfficial2771
1) Is THIS man-made CARTOON a Proof of Shia Imamat from This Quran or U got it from Imam Ghaib from a Cave ??????
2) Do U believe that 28/7 = 13 or NOT ???????? (Very important for Proof of Shia Imamat from Quran, so answer this as well. It will not take more that 5 sec to answer it as YES or NO….). As It is an Open-Book Q, U can also get help from any Shia Ayatullah or Imam Ghaib as well to answer this simple Math Q..
3) What is the purpose of Imam Ghaib of Shia, if He can not help YOU even to solve this Simple Math problem???? In this regards, Imam of Agha Khani (Ismailis) is FAR FAR BETTER, at least He (Present Agha Khan, who made Aga Khan University & Hospital in Karachi) tries HIS best to solve the problems of His Nation (Ismaelis). I am sure If ask from HIM about this SIMPLE Math Problem, He will solve it in few Seconds!!!!! Even a 10 year’s old school child of Agha Khani can solve this Math Problem. I must tell you that NOT only YOU but 99% Shia Do not answer this Simple math Q ?????????
@@SyedHussainiOfficial2771 .................
1) Is THIS man-made story a Proof of Shia Imamat from This Quran or U got it from Imam Ghaib from a Cave ??????
2) Do U believe that 28/7 = 13 or NOT ???????? (Very important for Proof of Shia Imamat from Quran, so answer this as well. It will not take more that 5 sec to answer it as YES or NO….). As It is an Open-Book Q, U can also get help from any Shia Ayatullah or Imam Ghaib as well to answer this simple Math Q..
3) What is the purpose of Imam Ghaib of Shia, if He can not help YOU even to solve this Simple Math problem???? In this regards, Imam of Agha Khani (Ismailis) is FAR FAR BETTER, at least He (Present Agha Khan, who made Aga Khan University & Hospital in Karachi) tries HIS best to solve the problems of His Nation (Ismaelis). I am sure If ask from HIM about this SIMPLE Math Problem, He will solve it in few Seconds!!!!! Even a 10 year’s old school child of Agha Khani can solve this Math Problem. I must tell you that NOT only YOU but 99% Shia Do not answer this Simple math Q ?????????
Karbala and To All Shia (and their ALL Ayatullah);
Karbala was in REALITY a Test Case (KARAMAT) of YA ALI MADAD .... but Ali (AS & RA) could not help in Karbala to save his Beloved son and others (or may be RAN AWAY after looking the ARMY Of YAZEED !!!!!).....This is the main Cause of this Shia Matum (GIRYA) that Why Ali (AS & RA) did NOT come (or did NOT Fulfil his promise, means KHAIN according to Shia) from His Grave (or RAN AWAY !!!) to help in Karbala and this Mataum Cont till Ali (AS & RA) does NOT come from His grave (and HE can not come till Quamat) !!!!! And now He will come after Quamamt and will be under the SHADE of FIRST Three Khalifa (as He was in Madina for about 25 years)…..Simple as that. Listen the following (Dil Tham Ke zara);
ruclips.net/video/FVe2Y_BVqh0/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/9rcw_gPNF44/видео.html
@@SyedHussainiOfficial2771
1) Is THIS man-made story a Proof of Shia Imamat from This Quran or U got it from Imam Ghaib from a Cave ??????
2) Do U believe that 28/7 = 13 or NOT ???????? (Very important for Proof of Shia Imamat from Quran, so answer this as well. It will not take more that 5 sec to answer it as YES or NO….). As It is an Open-Book Q, U can also get help from any Shia Ayatullah or Imam Ghaib as well to answer this simple Math Q..
3) What is the purpose of Imam Ghaib of Shia, if He can not help YOU even to solve this Simple Math problem???? In this regards, Imam of Agha Khani (Ismailis) is FAR FAR BETTER, at least He (Present Agha Khan, who made Aga Khan University & Hospital in Karachi) tries HIS best to solve the problems of His Nation (Ismaelis). I am sure If ask from HIM about this SIMPLE Math Problem, He will solve it in few Seconds!!!!! Even a 10 year’s old school child of Agha Khani can solve this Math Problem. I must tell you that NOT only YOU but 99% Shia Do not answer this Simple math Q ?????????
Boht Aala guftagu farmaei aap ne,,,❤
Dr, zubair sahb sirf tasub ki aag main jaltay rahtay Hain,,, or aksar jhooth bayan kartay Hain,,,
Finally aapse ek hi request hai ye jo sifaat e Rab ka matter usme hamara aqeeda kisa hona chaiye, kya ashaira ki tarah ya maturidi ki tarah hina chaiye.
Ahle bayt e athar ka Mouqif kya hai sifaat e bari tali se related quran ki ayato ka.
Please thode vedios ispe banade
@@ahlussuffiya4225
جی ضرور ان شاءاللہ
ارادہ ہے کہ توحید پر مفصل ویڈیوز بنائی جائے۔ ان شاءاللہ
zaidi tu shia nahi hai isliye zaidi kaha jata hai , ismaili bhi shia nahi hai isliye ismsaili kaha jata hai, agar yeh do ferqe shia hote tu shia kehlate . umari jamat ke khulafa ke pas aqal nai tha unke manne waalo ke pas tu bilkul aqal nai hai . Quran aur Ahle Bait a.s se doori nasle begaarti hai .
ڈاکٹر زبیر حسن اللہ یاری سے مار کھا چکا ھے
مومنین میں حافظ زبیر کے ان شبہاتی لیکچرز کی وجہ سے بہت اضطراب تھا
اضطراب کیوں ہے حافظ صاحب کو اگر اور نہی تو اپنے ذہن میں جواب دیا کریں انکی باتیں اتنی خرافات سے بھری ہیں بہت آساں ہے اُن صاحب کا رد کرنا
@@parasali2613
1) Whatever U are writing or speaking here is dependent on Shia Imamat. For this reason, I ask To All Shia (and Shia Ayatullah as well): 1) First prove the concept of Shia Imamat and then talk about others. I am asking this because; According to Shia MAZHAB, Imams (Like Prophets) are appointed by Allah ST and if one will not recognize/accept him, he/she will NOT be a Muslim and go into Jahanum for ever ruclips.net/video/IERVPXh9Hqo/видео.html ruclips.net/video/OIiNePgctF8/видео.html (Zakat & Ring story).
As this claim is vey very BIG, the EVIDENCE about this claim should also VERY BIG, LIKE CLEAR NAME of IMAMS in Quran. So first give any Proof from Quran (Quran Challenge) that Syadana Ali (AS & RA) was Imam declared by Allah ST after the Death of Syadana Muhammad (PBUH). This is because Quran is the final book (MEZAN, means distingusher between RIGHT and WRONG related to Islam) of Allah ST and is Alhamdolillah COMMON between Shia and Non-Shia. According to Shia the PRESENT QURAN is compiled by Syadana Ali (AS & RA). Regarding History, and even Hadeeses, they are different for Shia and non-shia, so first is Quran ruclips.net/user/postUgw7gF_08N6U1X4uVLd4AaABCQ
and then we can discuss about Hadees as well. So, show a single verse in the present Quran, which says
“O believers, after the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH), there will be TWELVE IMAMS (or especially Ali, AS & RA) chosen by Allah and you should follow them.”
Do not worry I am here and will reply you IA.
2) SUMMARY OF MY QUESTION; Gentleman my Q consists of 3 CRITICAL WORDS, i) Allah's sayings (means Quran), ii) NAME of Syadana Ali (AS & RA) and iii) IMAM. This is because as stated above "Shia Claim that, Imams (Like Prophets) are CHOSEN by Allah ST". Therefore, GO and FIND the answers of these 3 ESSENTIAL words. It is a Compulsory Q in Exam and without answering these 3 words, you will get ZERO marks by the public.
3) Do U believe that 28 Divided by 7 = 13 or NOT ???????? (Very important for Proof of Shia Imamat from Quran, so answer this as well. It will not take more that 5 sec to answer it as YES or NO….). As It is an Open-Book Q, U can also get help from any Shia Ayatullah or Imam Ghaib as well to answer this simple Math Q...,,,,,,,…
woh nasibi pagalo ke doctor hai😅
اسی لیکچر میں اسنے جھوٹ بولا ہے کہ میں نے شیعہ کی مصادر کی کتابیں کھنگالی ہیں ان میں رسول اللہ کی حدیث کا جود ہی نہیں
ایک ایک بات کا جواب دیا جائے گا ان شاءاللہ
بھائی آپ کونسی حدیث کا زکر کر رھے ھیں
Muslmanoon say alag aik nazriyya e imamat paish krna phir us mein imamoon ka apas mein shadeed ikhtalaf krna aik imam ka doosray imam ka inkar krna Shia Kay aik firqa ka kisi aur ko imam man'na aur doosray firqay ka us imam ka inkar krna bari bat Quraan o Hadees mein in imamoon ka zikr tak na hona is aqeeda Kay khudsakhta aur batil honay ki dalil hai 5:05 5:05
Puri video dekh lain sahib
تقیہ پر تقیہ کیا پر بھی مثال نہ بن پائی 😂 اور ماچس کا تھیلا خود بھی محسوس کر رہا تھا کہ مثالي نہ بن پیا 😅
Karli bakwas????? Daleel tou koi hai nhi bas zaleel hona hai 😂😂😂
Ismaili Shias are true followers of Ahlebait عليه السلام Alhamdulillah other all chains are broken now only Imam Ismail Bin Jafar Sadiq عليه السلام descendants are alive come on molvi Dr Zubair Says right about Aqeeda Imamat see our debate with Allahyari you will understand the truth
Anyways
Wslam
Ya Ali Madad
کیا شیعہ 200 سال یا 300 پرانے قرآن کا نسخه دکھا سکتے ہے؟ 1 یا 2 نسخه نہی جتنا چھپے تھے وہ سب کے سب، ضاهر ہے قرآن کے أوراق بھی پتھے ہونگی تو سوال یہ ان أوراق کو کیا کرتے ہے شیعہ
Bhai imam ghaib q h?tab shia ny jwb dia k bano umayyah k dar sy gheibat m gye h abi to koi bano umayya ni h ab q ni arahe..
Hairat Hai . . .
Kyun Kar Hairat Na Ho???
Ja Jaa Kar Kin Se Hasad Kartey Hain Ulema e ahl sunnat
RASOOLULLAH o AHLEBAIT ALAIHIMUS SALAAM ALLAH JJH Ki Noori Khilqat Hai Jabkey abubakr umer usman Khaaki Maqlooq Hai
Bohat Khoob,,, Bfai Meri DUA Hai Isi Tarah Haq Bayan Karney Ki Taufeeq Ho Aapko.
اہل حدیث کو عمری مزہب کی فکر نہیں ہے وہاں کتنے فرقے ہیں انھیں شیعوں کی پڑی ہے جبکہ انھیں حسن الہیاری نے صاف صاف جواب دیے تھے اور جب ان سے سوالات پوچھے تھے تو بولتی بند ہوگئی تھی ڈاکٹر زبیر صاحب معزرت کے ساتھ بہت فالتو آدمی ہیں
اگر میں شیعہ بننے کا ارادہ کرو تو کون میرے رہنمائی کریگا ؟ جن کا کام تھا امت کے رہنمائی کا وہ تو 1200 سال سے غائب ہے،باقی بچا شیعہ روایات ، اب کون بتائی گا کہ یہ روایات حقيقت پر مبنی ہے یا کہ تقیہ؟
It is obvious what too much ikhtilaf means.
Lack of a mutawatir or qataee suboot from quran or sunnah
Molana ishaq k 10 12 lecture hy imamat par sun ly samjh a jaye ga sab kuch
@@Walikhanzada1
وہ بھی غیر حقیقی باتوں پر مبنی ہے
@@SyedAbuimadOfficial sir bat ye hy jis tarah ap ny detail par in ka rad kia un ka bhi phir rad kren Q k molana ishaq k imamat par dalail k sath rad , hafiz sb ki tarah nahi.
@@Walikhanzada1
ان شاء اللہ
کوشش کروں گا کہ اس کے بعد وہ بھی رد ہوجائے
Dr zubair bazahir aise lagta nohat intellectual batain karte or Momineen kam ilmi ki wajah se pareshan ho jatr hala k un ki zyada tar batain qayas par mubni hoti
Jhoton par Allah ki lanat
1) Whatever U are writing or speaking here is dependent on Shia Imamat. For this reason, I ask To All Shia (and Shia Ayatullah as well): 1) First prove the concept of Shia Imamat and then talk about others. I am asking this because; According to Shia MAZHAB, Imams (Like Prophets) are appointed by Allah ST and if one will not recognize/accept him, he/she will NOT be a Muslim and go into Jahanum for ever ruclips.net/video/IERVPXh9Hqo/видео.html ruclips.net/video/OIiNePgctF8/видео.html (Zakat & Ring story).
As this claim is vey very BIG, the EVIDENCE about this claim should also VERY BIG, LIKE CLEAR NAME of IMAMS in Quran. So first give any Proof from Quran (Quran Challenge) that Syadana Ali (AS & RA) was Imam declared by Allah ST after the Death of Syadana Muhammad (PBUH). This is because Quran is the final book (MEZAN, means distingusher between RIGHT and WRONG related to Islam) of Allah ST and is Alhamdolillah COMMON between Shia and Non-Shia. According to Shia the PRESENT QURAN is compiled by Syadana Ali (AS & RA). Regarding History, and even Hadeeses, they are different for Shia and non-shia, so first is Quran ruclips.net/user/postUgw7gF_08N6U1X4uVLd4AaABCQ
and then we can discuss about Hadees as well. So, show a single verse in the present Quran, which says
“O believers, after the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH), there will be TWELVE IMAMS (or especially Ali, AS & RA) chosen by Allah and you should follow them.”
Do not worry I am here and will reply you IA.
2) SUMMARY OF MY QUESTION; Gentleman my Q consists of 3 CRITICAL WORDS, i) Allah's sayings (means Quran), ii) NAME of Syadana Ali (AS & RA) and iii) IMAM. This is because as stated above "Shia Claim that, Imams (Like Prophets) are CHOSEN by Allah ST". Therefore, GO and FIND the answers of these 3 ESSENTIAL words. It is a Compulsory Q in Exam and without answering these 3 words, you will get ZERO marks by the public.
3) Do U believe that 28 Divided by 7 = 13 or NOT ???????? (Very important for Proof of Shia Imamat from Quran, so answer this as well. It will not take more that 5 sec to answer it as YES or NO….). As It is an Open-Book Q, U can also get help from any Shia Ayatullah or Imam Ghaib as well to answer this simple Math Q...,,,,,,,…
ID blocked
1) Please note that my ALL Four IDs are blocked for Video sites and I am unable to write my comments. They are soon deleted after uploading here. I do not know, WHY. Otherwise I have same answers for your ALL comments on Video as well. However, Alahmdolillah my IDs are working for Audio sites (as this). If any SHIA is doing this highly unethical act, then He/she must think that they have to answer Allah ST on day of judgement (if they believe on THAT day of JUSTICE) ....So do not worry when my IDs will be open I will write answers to ALL of your's comments.
2) Your feed-back is highly appreciated.
3) Is this Teaching of Syadana Ali (AS & RA) ??????????
4) For this reason I can not reply Shia's video's comments.......... Simple as that....
ruclips.net/video/JdXwgA8cp2w/видео.html
I will appreciate if you will upload my this Shia Imamt Q on this site. Thanks in advance.
Apni fikar karo fitna e khawarij
زبیر کی پھٹ گئی تھی الھیاری کے سامنے کھ رہا تھا مجھے گھر جانا ہے
Allahyari ny Zubair ki "watt" Laga di..!