As IAF’s Jammu airbase is hit, here’s how drones redefined warfare between Azerbaijan & Armenia
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 12 ноя 2020
- #CutTheClutter #NagornoKarabakh #Armenia #Azerbaijan
Azerbaijan crushed Armenia earlier this week, making it the second country since World War II to surrender in a war, after Pakistan in 1971. In episode 618 of ThePrint’s Cut The Clutter, Shekhar Gupta explains what gave Azerbaijan its decisive edge over Armenia, which defeated it over the Nagorno-Karabakh enclave in the 1990s, and what this war tells us about the new revolution in warfare.
Research by Raghav Bikhchandani
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Brought to you by Tata Motors / @tata.evofficial
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Watch Cut The Clutter ep 580 here: • Why faraway Azerbaijan...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Read the Washington Post article here: www.washingtonpost.com/world/...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Read Amrita Nayak Dutta's article here: theprint.in/defence/iaf-hunti...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Read the Carnegie article here: carnegieendowment.org/2020/11...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Read the Oryx article here: www.oryxspioenkop.com/2020/09...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Read the Eurasia article here: eurasianet.org/in-karabakh-de...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint : bit.ly/SubscribeToThePrint
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintIndia
Please support good journalism by paying for it. Subscribe to ThePrint. Links for both domestic & overseas subscribers are provided here: theprint.in/subscribe/
Dear Sir,
Why in India we cannot speak against our judiciary or its way of arbitrary functioning. Please do not say history that it was like this during that time and this time, etc. Democracy is a evolutionary process which means it should progress. I completely understand about legislature division because it is depending on vote bank politics for power. But judiciary being a constitutional body, which draws salary from public taxes saying it should not be criticized (hardly) is unfair to the people of india who pay them those salaries and perquisites. Please do a video about recent judiciary functioning and it's thin skin for criticism of late. As a common citizen of this country I feel painful and deeply hurted by the way courts are functioning these days (bullying for criticisms). Why can't we pass sharp criticisms against judges or supreme court when I feel that it is not doing its job appropriately. I write this out of deep hurt the judiciary causing to the destruction of faith in the system in this nation.
Pls talk about the attack on evms and elections
❤❤❤🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰❤❤❤🖕🖕🖕
@@sayedhasan2668 it's all about Pakistan mate ❤❤❤🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰❤❤❤🖕🖕🖕
@@sayedhasan2668 Sheikh is a good man but he also has made mistakes in the past so nobody is perfect.
This is also the first war in a long time where USA's role has been limited to just reporting it.
Bcz usa is no more super power , even no one cares about them , bcz if you elect the people like trump then that,s the result
Petrol is one of recipe for US's democracy delivery system. No oil no interference.
Because there is no oil in Armenia
Unless you count System Of A Down getting involved, and literally making songs encouraging Armenians to fight for their land. Awkward.
@@Omegacrafton Trump may have decreased USA role in intl politics but US is still US ! These chingi drones are nothing in front of US predators.
Turkey played very clever game here.
And their drones proved that they're very capable war machines
Turkey didn't get everything they wanted though. Despite their claims of unity with Azerbaijan, Azerbaijan agreed with Russia in only allowing Turkey an observer role in a remote location.
@@Gustav_Kuriga But in exchange Azerbaijan is now giving Turkey extraction rights to the oil within their waters now. A huge part of the Turkish foreign policy shift towards the north has been to reduce their reliance on Russia for oil.
@@Gustav_Kuriga I doubt that.
@Enles Freedom if if if 🙈
No it's not. Basically rich oil Azerbaijan supported by biggest country in the region Turkey gang up against smaller and weaker nation like Armenia. Against other strong country however, the result could be different.
Russia: The Caucasus is mine.
Turkey: Hold my Drones.
you mean israeli drones
actually russia actually gained more from this conflict than turkey
@OttomanSlapX true russia was the real winner
@@axel665 how so?
@@NoName-go6oz so isn't russia the winner
Drones were half of the victory, the other half was our special forces. Shusha city was captured with superb tactics, without drones, without armored vehicles or tanks. (After victory in Shusha Armenia surrendered.)
We were astonished to learn that the myths about Azerbaijani special forces are actually underestimation of their real power.
Some armenian news outlets saif that "Azerbaijani special forces infltrated through the inner territories of Kharabakh just to raise their flags and take pictures of it".
Pakistan and turkey always stand with Azerbaijan. There were news that Pak and turk soldiers also helped Azerbaijan in strategic matter.
No one, but NO ONE, is ever going to doubt or criticize or laugh at the military capabilities of Azerbaijan again. This will be cited in textbooks as one of the most brilliant campaigns in modern history. No wonder Azerbaijanis are so proud.
@@Jagatai8925 all of these type of fake informations were considered for the armenian society by the armenian government.
ESEK TURK 😂😂😂😂😂
It just Game of Drones ✈️🚀🔥
Wars 1-7 were very well fought....the 8th war will disapoint everyone.
Remember it was the Turks that came to Constantinople with Gunpowder technology and canons. They took the city in a way that showed that gunpowder was the way to go. It also marked the end of Medieval era.
Today we see a similar situation. The Turks came again, and took Nagorno Karabakh. In a fashion that shows that Killer Drones are the way to go.
Turks are Great Fighters and Champions Alhumdulilah .
US has been fighting with Drones in Middle east for almost a decade. The only reason they came in Choppers and didnt send drones for Osama is to try and capture him line or get DNA samples.
It was the performance of bosnian gunners
@@theknowledgehubinternation5969 war is our business! We go to war like it is our wedding 🙌🏽
@@almandi8209 we won a lot after ww1. Ottomans lost and Turks won. And we didn’t lost our alphabet, the Arabian alphabet isn’t compatible with Turkic language, so Atatürk reformed it. That was a win too, cause Arabic alphabet is bullshtt 🖖🏽 At least we have no turkish spring, unlike Arabs, who still have their western masters 🤦♂️ They better accept us as their masters again 😂
Throughout human history there have been defining incidents in the nature of warfare, and how warfare was changed, and we have all witnessed one.
Very true. Those who note it down and do something about it will survive and prosper. Those who bury their heads in the sand will die and get swallowed up.
I don't think this is a change in the nature of warfare. This is an example of air superiority/supremacy controlling the battlefield. This has been the case at least since WW II. This happened on the western front, and also recently in the first Gulf War. The drone is just a new tool to achieve this, and clearly this is a relatively inexpensive method of achieving air superiority/supremacy to systems employed in the past.
It’s a Revolution in Military Affairs
Not really. Two third world nations, one of which gets a cash inflow to buy 3rd tier modern equipment which it then throws at its enemies 50 year old gear. Not really indicative of anything.
We'll have to see how drone systems compete against modern air defence to really know what impact they'll have in modern warfare.
@@jimmehjiimmeehh9748 Yeah, Azerbaijan at least had some money to spend on new stuff and upgrade their old stuff. Poor Armenia had very little money in that time and their equipment as a result is little better, overall, than it was 30 years ago. Nevertheless, we musn't ignore how effective drones can be when used imaginatively like Azerbaijan did. There are always lessons to be learnt.
Haha! Bayraktar TB-2 used Canada's Wescam MX-15 just because it's weight was 15 KG less than Turkey's indigenous CATS. When Canada put embargo on Turkey, Turkey replaced their system with mor advanced targeting system built indigenously.
İt's always good when the enemy thinks of you less. You have more opportunity to shock them when you own them on field.
45 days of Bayraktar TB2 diplomacy worked better than 30 years of Minks( Russia, US and France) group diplomacy.
Long live Bayraktar TB2 and up coming TB3 and Akinci.
The Turkish drones are great!
The best at the time!
Cheap and proven effective. Like it or not others are just big and empty talks.
@bro ha what do you mean
@sooje nite yes they good too
@sooje nite isreali drones are not so good they destroy themselves but Turkish drone fire more then four missiles and come back safely.
Turkey is the successor of Ottomans. Powerful country. You don’t mess with them.
For those who don’t know Turkey and Azerbaijan speak the same language and have a lot of ties, culturally and emotionally. You can hardly find any other two countries that as close as they are.
The only thing spectacular in this war was the global silence.
Even more spectacular : the US was not involved.
nothing spectular about Pisslamic jihad, love to our Armenia Brothers and Sisters
Turkey and Russia helped
@Amar Hussain 😅🐫🐪🍻🍺🖕🖕
@iVulkan_ These jihadis will only stop when you fight back, I pray for Europe.
Turkish drones completed mission successfully.
Yes but they failed to retake Sirte in Libya and to stop Syrian army to retake saraqib and the M5
@@rhodium1096 yes they are successfull because the Arminians have outdated equipt and arminians cant afford to purchase equipt with better technology. Without their oil money Arminia will destroy them.
Its not turkey but it is Israel help and gift that helped Azerbaijan to victory.
@@rhodium1096 if it wasn't for Turkey's intervention the GNA government would have been over thrown by now.
@@rhodium1096 The stopped The offensive of idlib If know The plan of Al asad was to retake that region
Russia did not help armenians... india should learn this
Armenia is Russian ally ?
@@parth6115 yes even they have treaty of defence
@@parth6115 yes russia has military base in armenia
We are nuke power,we dont need anyone's help.
It was because the Armenian PM was increasingly building ties with europe , and Russia did not like it. He even openly questioned Putin
I am the one man of victorious Azerbaijan. Thank you for the analysis!
Bu pis Hintliler Ermenistan'ı Ruslardan bile çok severler.
Men de ;)
12 34 Yok la Azerbaycanı destekliyor hepsi😂
@yoyoo yooo buthurt? Its technology time, smaller, bigger doesnt matter. Small Israel help you or sell you weapons. So you are the last one to talk, you better keep shaking your head..)
@yoyoo yooo Armenians are good at flying. I guess they drink lots of redbull)
The osmanic turks we’re the first to use combined artillery with big cannons. The modern turks are the first to use drone swarm attacks and tactical drone attacks combined with electronic warfare. Turkey 🇹🇷 is the best!!!
Govt : Even Turkey is producing better quality drones than India.😶
Meanwhile Babus in South block : We shall draft a policy to build 100% indigenous local drones by 2050 with imported engine, imported telemetry and Chinese screws. Now let us define local... 😴 (not sleeping... thinking... US, Uk, Israel sab appnay hain... Local ).
DRDO : Ready to buy PIXHAWK drone. Nice. Add toooo cart. 🛒😁
Press Conference... We did it!! Proud day for India🥳
Local entrepreneurs : Why didn't I go to USA when I had the chance? Why? 🙁
So true
Its actually Isreali drones did well.
🤣🤣🤣 asshole babus
@@spetsnazGru487 Yes. We will be importing.
@@spetsnazGru487 add more of that in cart
Shekhar Sir, Thanks for choosing this topic 🙏🏻 I was looking for Indian media's reaction on this !
@Aryan Godara Well There is no match with SG with WION , WIOn is a refined version of #Arnab_Ganda.
@IslipFact
Vagat singh was also a terrorist in British eye but in our eyes 👀 he is hero.
Hi Soham. Thanks for tuning in.
@@ThePrintIndia Thanks and Happy Diwali to the Print !
But indians don't belive in drones . Instead they were busy in buying jet fighters ,tanks, and artillery
Bayraktar drones have AI built in their computers. It has self learning capabilities that drone learned flying in difficult weather conditions. Unlike the other drones, TB2 can fly in almost any weather conditions. You said the range is 150km but that is limited because of the antenna range. Also you can put extra antenna to extend the range. Now they are working on putting SATCOM to make it satellite controlled so you can fly pretty much anywhere for 24h. Stay tuned, more drone tech is on the way.
No idea where you're getting all this. TB2s are conventional RPVs, they are remotely controlled and any autonomous capability does not extend beyond long-established, limited-use unmanned aircraft functions like autopilots/stabilization and autoland (and that's IF they are a part of the design to begin with). A far cry from "AI" or "self-learning capabilities" and other buzzwords. And there is no such thing as "extra antenna to extend the range" lmao, adding more receivers does not increase sensitivity or control station emitter power.
@Julius Caesar do you think they haven’t tried jamming the signals in Libya, Syria and Azerbaijan? Apparently, it is not like that simple. Yes drones are not better than human controlled jets but drones can fly longer than a human can fly. Remember there is no washroom on the jet planes so they pee into a bag and pilots can’t do #2 so they have to regulate their diet accordingly. These are all part of pilot training and not all NATO countries has long duration flight capabilities. Drones are a lot cheaper to fly compare to jet planes and reduces the requirements of jets and there is no risk.
@@Batuhan1988 US took the ISIS drones out of the sky with Jammers brought in after ISIS drones stoped and threw back Iraq forces.
@@RedRocket4000 yeah because that is cheap ISIS drones lol. Aren’t they commercial drones that you can buy online? Btw I am talking about Bayraktar TB2. It took down Russian air defence systems without being detected and Jammers didn’t work on them. Otherwise Armenians could have stopped them.
@@Batuhan1988 Russia did not backed Armenia so not sure what you are talking about
The short answer: Oil powered economy buying AI powered drones.
no! this is not oil powered economy. Azerbaijan is autocratic state which has money from oil. There is a difference. with your "short answer" you are misleading people. Norway also has a lot of oil and can afford drones but they don't conquer Sweden's lands, because they have democracy. Evil is driven by wealth, but by an autocracy.
@@Zura_Lanch Anyone, who wants a detailed analysis would never look at a "short answer", which by definition is just a smirk. What makes u think that I don't know these? Plz preserve your wisdom(!) for proper context.
They didny buy our drones. We supported them for we are one nation two states
@@Zura_Lanch What the hell are you talking about? Nagorno Karabakh and surrounding 7 regions are INTERNATIONALLY RECOGNIZED territories of Azerbaijan?
@@yarasa2109 I didn't say that those regions are not internationally recognized lands of Azerbaijan. Territorial disputes between two countries will not be solved by warfare if there is a democracy in those two countries. I’m not sure about Armenia, but Azerbaijan is an autocratic state.
No other media highlighted the importance of this drone warfare. 👍🏾 to SG and his team.
I just realized this is how Aegon conquered Westeros. He had dragons.
Who?
@@bryangracida Aegon Targaryen. The lords of Westeros only had spears, swords and arrows. Aegon baked the continent with dragon fire. The lords couldn't fight back.
😂 Perfect place for the reference man 🤣
Well thats more aerial warfare than drones. But you're right.
@@alexanderphilip1809 Haa. I was referring to the fact that the Westerosi did not have an answer to dragons just like the Armenians don't have an answer to the drones. Thanks for replying though.
thank you for your report, i was always wandering about why the war was resolved this fast and how azerbaijan managed to advance without any notable resistance and your simple explanation made it all clear.
Bayraktar fly 27 hours, and aksungur fly 48 hours with loaded weapons.
bayraktarin ustunlugu olcusunun kucuk olmasi ve radarlara yakalanma ihtimalinin az olmasidir.fiyatlarida ucuzdur.
Dont forget that many drones sparepart build by another country... If they Stop supply it then good bay drones
@@sonidamara5018 And Armenia doesnt rely on another country to supply them weapons, apparently useless weapons?
@@muneirovalibas6194 drones change the way of war forefer
@@sonidamara5018 drones has been in used for decades, the US has been using drones for precision strikes since the 2nd Iraq war, its just now another country has a lethal drone capability that its the news. But people act like its the first time drones are used for combat in war.
Turkey is progressing like cyclone in drone tech
@@ronol4238 Nop, with there own tech
@@ronol4238 How are their drones a copy if they developed everything from the ground up during decades? You clearly dont know what you're talking about
@@quisqueyanguy120 lol do u know Akinci drone? which one have cruise missiles and even Air to air missiles israel or USA dont have it. and we started new one. tb2 is our old drone. we making new drone every year
@ Not the make first laser beam rather Turkey used a laser weapon first in a real conflict.
@ You can call the weapon laser beam but there are many laser weapon projects in many countries like Japan, US, China etc so Turkey wasn't the first country to make such a weapon but Turkey used it first in a real conflict by shooting down a chinese drone..
Thanks for enlightening us with your episode on morden warfare.
So the lesson is don't skimp on air defences, and make sure you have good radar discipline. Turning those old AN-2s into air defence radar bait was a smart move.
Turkish drones are way more deadlier than world perceives them..veerry impressive machines.
The Azerbaijanis also have Israeli drones (rumor has it some where flown by Israelis), while the Turkish Air Force kept the Armenian Air Force from intervening. The Israelis maintain a good relationship with Azerbaijan in case Israel ever needs to strike Iran
@@staubsauger2305 so what you're saying is most of the drones that were up were in fact Israeli drones?
@@shakedshani4930 where did I say "most" ? Have a look at the Azerbaijani inventory
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Azerbaijani_Air_Forces#Aircraft
I can understand why Israel does this given Iran is their big worry. However Azerbaijan is a Sharia Supremacist aggressor allied with Muslim Brotherhood Turkey and Israel is making a very big mistake. Armenia was the victim of Azeri aggression, Israel should have refused to supply spares and advise, IMHO.
@@staubsauger2305 israel has made this kind of mistake before with turkey but i think that IAI wanted a playground to test out their drones plus iran as you said is the international treat that they pay a close eye to and Azerbaijan was probably the most stable place in the area so they can establish a connection with
@@shakedshani4930 yes, but it cost Armenia a lot of lives. In the Christian world it doesn't make Israel look that great when it works with Sharia Supremacists to attack Christian nations. It's a hard enough task for us to defend Israel in the public sphere without it doing things like this. I hope the Knesset reconsiders, and stops support, as no Sharia Supremacist can ever be really 'on our side' in the long term. The installation of the mullahs in Iran in 1979 as a buffer against the USSR was a similar mistake made by the West. "The enemy of my enemy is my friend" is not true, the enemy of your enemy is still your enemy.
YOU R THE BEST, Shekhar...Thanks a bunch @theprint🙏
Turkey was the first country to use gun powder in the battlefield. Now, she is the first to use drones in the modern conventional warfare.
Bullshit turks weren't the first one
That's just misinformation,
Uhhh..I am pretty certain USA were the first to use drones. They have been taking out terrorists and made attacks with drones all over the place.
😂😂😂
Maybe they weren't the first, but the Ottoman Turks are called "the Gun Powder Empire" because they introduced rifles and canons into the battlefield and used them very efficiently. That's how they even conqured Istanbul.
This is some impressive reporting, analysis and journalism. Congrats from Ireland
Please rply to me
What a great channel! Thanks for the excellent analysis from a new viewer. Much appreciated.
azerbaijan destroyed many armenian equipments with drone attack without losing one soldier
True. Big credit to Israel
Turkey bayraktar
@@xplor313 Azer imported 1.6bn worth of only drones from Israel. These drones are far more superior than tirkish drones
@@neelscooldude1 can u explain why Israel sell to Azerbaijan and is friends with them?
@@chaitanyakandwal7827 Because Azerbaijan has huge gas reserves and Israel is interested in them. Most of Azerbaijan's telecommunication sector is owned by Israel and is one of the top trade partners of Azer. Armenia on the other hand chose to be closer to Russia. Interestingly, Russia, Turkey and Israel all want access to the gas reserves
Turkey is excercising their influence
I am Greek, and will be the first to admit that Turkey is a near superpower.
Brilliant lessons to learn on modern warfare
One minute in and I know I'm going to like this guy and will be checking in with his other lectures.
Unfortunately... Same will happen with india if we go in a war with china.. India needs to really work towrds faster modernisation localisation of drone technology.. And anti drone system
But most of fund goes to pension.
We have kamikaze drones.....were you not watching?Besides it's harder for drones to be that effective in the Himalayas.
that may not be the case even now if the war breaks between China and India. china doesn't have world backup. they may be supported by 7th gen warfare expert pakistan but Indian military is master in war tactics and jugad unlike china which rely on reverse engineer junk, india has access to world class weapons. what won the war for Azerbaijan was not the drone alone, it was tactics.
limited war, china will lose, if its full fledge war, india will lose but currently if there will be full fledge war , then it will be world war with Japan, isreal, America are major ally to india. china unlike Pakistan is not nut head , they know this.. they don't intend war, just want to pressurise india.
@@richardb874 you known kamikaze drone can be only used once.
Hamare pass bhi drone hai. Bhai IAF background hai. Even our IAF is strong.
India looks really worried about turkish drone. as pakistan will get it any time.
I think they already have got Turkish drones in inventory.
Good news I think
I've heard India is secretly working on its own drones, so nothing to be worried about.
@@kingmaker5602 yes I heard that ..choppaati drone
India always wins the war
The best analysis I came across on this war. Thanks you.
Pray for permanent peace ✌️🕊️🇦🇲🇦🇿
armenians were against the peace only their goverment did sign peace but people will not remain silent , ao azerbaijan will have to keep their armies up just like south korea and north korea
@@sakurakou2009 what are you talking about we only wish for the right to live in our own homes and for our cousins and brothers to not die from war almost every one of us wishes for peace
@@titanium_armenia6177 stop lying , I saw the videos of armenians turning mosques into pig stable , how is that peaceful so disgusting .. you lair and even if you as individual want peace this doesnt mean your goverment did what they did in peace it obvious
sakurakou2009 Thank you for the telling truth. As an azerbaijanian, i am very glad to see foreigners know how armenia humiliated our religion, our country and nation.
@@sakurakou2009 it’s unbelievable how concentrated groups of Turks can brainwash people, and you say that Mosques turned into pig stables? Cite sources that aren’t Turkish then I’ll believe you, also are you blind to all the horrible things Azeris and Turks have done to us? My cousin litteraly died in this war a several Armenian churches were destroyed completely and when the Azeri government was asked about this they said that Armenian soldiers might have been praying there please just look at non Armenian or Turkish sources to get your info. I don’t care what ethnicity you are it only matters that you understand the situation from an unbiased point of view and have a nice day.
That's why Pradeep Sahni was saying our combined army head is developing only army for land battle and it's a bullshit.
Dude it worked out for them because it's very small area to cover if you increase the perimeter you have to cover then things changes drastically. And who told you that India is not investing in the drone warfare. It's just that it's something which doesn't gets shown off as it's comes under stealth.
Sawhney is a doom monger who downplays India's capabilities because he has an agenda against the current govt.
@ just don't take the negative side man...the point is that we should give more importance to AI and automation in armed forces
@768PP one day these drones can have longer ranges which is beyond the medium range missiles also we should focus on star wars
Turkey now can sell more drones !!
India turkey should come together and target china
768PP would you please share source of information of these 150 km range ? Even though you won’t provide it . 150km range is still fine for borderline patrolling.
@768PP he didnt mention that Bayraktar has first developed it to 250km, also added satellite communication for later versions, so it will get 5000km range
@@abhishekt5522 Turkish mam-l anti tank ammunition for Bayraktar tb2 weights only 22kg, they can kill a tank or group of soldiers with each of them, without giving a sound unlike jets. With many of them imagine the result of the war and the psychology of those targeted soldiers, thinking there is always drone on top of them.. also, these are small drones, good against air deffense unit, in the beginning of the war, obviously once they destroy air deffense units, they send in jets and bigger UAVs as we saw in Nagorno Karabagh war
@@abhishekt5522 Turk AKINCI + TURK GOKsungur
thanks. your explanation made me see the entire narration about drone superiority in NK war
Thanks for analysis.
It wasn't only drones but brave Azerbaijani soldiers. You should talk about how soldiers fought in Shusha.
Karabakh is Azerbaijan!
And Indian Army was saying that Drones does not win wars. We are so behind in war tactics.
Drones are useless in contested airspace
Armenia has only a dozen fighter aircrafts, no AWACS and some soviet era air defences. So the Azerbaijani drones could fly unchallenged over the armenians and create havoc. indian military would be geared to destroying infrastructure, destroying Pakistani army columns, providing air cover to armoured thrusts into Pakistan and so on. I doubt that drones would be useful in those scenarios.
Your bitch ass can't understand battle in three Himalayas aren't the same as battles in lower ground.
@@chaun9521 lol.. U dont know Shit
Superb work of data gathering and analysis. Clear, rational explanation. Highly recommended viewing, and I'm subscribing as a result.
When you open Pandora's box you never know who she will help or hinder.
It's a cat and mouse game between military technologies, counter measure will surely be developed to counter such drone such as laser defence system or electronic jammers, etc.
Counter to such high kinetic systems is always difficult. US/Russia made ICBMs nearly 50 years back. Still most anti missile systems are at best somewhat useful.
Turkey is gaining major War experience, They will make even better Drones..
@Anonymous They will sell those drones to Pakistan and will teach the short war tactics to the Pakistan Army
@@siddharthgoyal4008 ICBMs are actually closer to 70 years old technology. The Germans invented the first ballistic missiles, and were working on intercontinental versions of the V2 before WWII ended. The Russians did invent the first practical ICBM, though.
What makes anti-missile systems only "somewhat useful" is that the criterion for success is _extremely_ high when you are talking about stopping missiles with nuclear or chemical warheads. If you can stop 99 out of 100 incoming nukes, that one which gets through will wreak unacceptable damage. Moreover, the costs required to field a system capable of stopping 99 out of every 100 nukes is astronomical compared to those needed to deploy 100 nukes.
Making weapons to defeat defensive systems is always cheaper and easier than to develop systems to protect against those weapons. Equipping a platoon of infantry with harquebuses capable of shooting through plate armour is a lot cheaper than equipping a squadron of knights with armour capable of stopping most projectiles at reasonable ranges.
Pakistan is way ahead of India in drone development. They have their own weaponised drone and DRDO is struggling to manufacture a drone for the IAF.
@@spacexfanclub6529 Maybe but we severely lack AWACS to jam enemy radar. A huge disadvantage. Also IAF is very poorly equipped. Not state of the art.
That's what happen when you adopt back to the drawing board approach instead of induction batch to batch
@@sahastradhara just how many machines will you keep on buying from abroad? They inflate the price as much as they want and we have to buy them always? Investment in local companies should be a priority and ask DRDO to tie up with foreign companies for production just like Brahmos.
@@bala09sundaram that's true though but ghatak project has been in existence for a very long time. nowadays, I dont even read anything about that UCAV because there is a good possibility that it might take my entire lifespan to see it fly
@@spacexfanclub6529 so to get kickbacks 🤣🤣
Turkey does sell all kinds of advanced weapon systems to Pakistan, including attack helicopters (T-129) and high-tech stealth frigates (Ada/Jinnah class). Turkey doesn't sell them to Pakistan for free BUT it offers them with (1) very long-term, low or zero interest credit, (2) co-production in Pakistan which brings the costs down, and (3) as part of a barter agreement where Turkey would buy Pakistani systems in exchange. (Such as the Super Mushak basic trainer aircraft.)
Haha! Turkey building their 5th generation aircraft and you providing them weakass training aircraft. Dude Pakistan has nothing to give Turkey. Pakistan is technologically far behind Turkey.
@@PANDA-ec1il Basic training aircraft need to be small with good fuel economy and cheap to buy. They don't have to be big and powerful. Turkey makes its own tandem-seat medium training aircraft (e.g. Hurkus) that fills the gap between Super Mushak and Jet Trainer. Pakistan also has nukes that the Turks don't. But anyway TR and PK are brotherly nations and cooperate VERY closely in defense, trade, political stance, education, cultural affairs, you name it! If you go to Turkey and ask 100 random Turks what they think about Pakistan. and 99 of them will tell you they consider it a second home.
@@samikent5422 haha! Turkey doesn't have nukes that doesn't mean they can't make. They are not making nuclear weapons because of international outrage and sanctions. And i never said anything against Turkish - Pakistani relation. What i wanted to say is that Turkey is far ahead of Pakistan when it comes about Technology.
@@PANDA-ec1il what about the nuclear technology? Can't even make her own nuclear plants.
@@PANDA-ec1il Turkey's technological superiority gives them leverage for trade deals, but besides that Turkey has a strategic interest in making sure Pakistan is well-armed with Turkish weapons.
Top class video . Thanks for posting.
A good analysis of modern warfare so far the drone is concerned.
6:00 calling the operator of drone a man OR WOMAN is some 21st century change sg now adapted to.
And IAF Chief was still doubting the use of drones in modern day warfare. When all advanced armed forces are relying on drones, we doubt them and show faith in Old generation jaguar and Migs
15:40 "Boom go into you", LOL sounding like an old uncle.
In HAL Bangalore, the work culture is so laid back and relaxed, you won't see a soul after lunch. One thing HAL is so good is their lunch and afternoon snacks. Same goes for many labs in DRDO. Forget about competing with Turkey, we can't even compete with Pukistan. From winter shoes to helmet we scramble to the west. Thank God the Chinese had some cool heads in their military. Had they started a war, we would have been summarily defeated. No doubt our soldiers would have put a brave front and even laid down their lives, but like General Patton once said, you win a war not by dying for your country but by making the other bastards die for their country.
@IslipFactLow cast are banned in Army....no reservations in army....
@IslipFact -- to REMOVE RESERVATION! That’s blasphemy. You will be thrown into the Bay of Bengal by any political party😆😫
@@EragonShadowSlasher - it is perhaps a classic case of, on the part of Modi, willing to strike but afraid to execute 😩
There should be public private partnership for defence devolopment
😃then will complet next millenium..
This man is full of knowledge. Hats off.
Thanks for the good video and for proper information !!!
Thank you for sharing your insight.
I know before the war that Azerbaijan going to won this war
Its wasnt Azerbaijan whos won but Turkey and mercenary
@yoyoo yooo Numbers don't always win otherwise, Chinese could have been conquered everywhere.
@@AYAN-km9ir Yeah because how otherwise 3 million tini-tiny Armenia might surrender to 9 million Azerbaijan, right? It requires 2nd power of NATO to make tiny Armenia to capitulate 🤣
Seriously guys you jave huge problem with your ego. It is called delusion of grandeur.
So no, Turkey didn't participate at this war. Selling drones, providing intelligence doesnt mean Turkey participated in the war. If that logic works then Azerbaijan fought and won Russia because Russia provided you with free weapon, intelligence etc.
Remember it is enough for Turkey to fart and make Armenia to surrender. Turkey could mobilize several times more people than entire Armenian population. That is 10th world military power in the planet and even Russia has to reconcile Turkish power and therefore take its interests into consideration.
@@yarasa2109 Turkey is turkey. 🦃
@@CountingStars333 Let me guess, you are butthurt greek? It is non of your business, it doesnt touch your national interests, we have never had issues between our nations, why you still angry dude?
Turkey cleverly achieved advance technology both frm nato and russia..
It was engineered by a young Turkish Engineer Bayraktar, and Turkish government has nothing to do with its invention, there has been a drone contest in TURKEY and he joined and won it, Bayraktar are know in Turkish for Engineering, years later, the young engineer marries the youngest daughter of Erdoğan, that's how his invention played a key role in Turkeys International policy. please read the Bayraktar Drones history of invention instead of making up your story.
Thats why countries are now banning certain exports to Turkey. The drone cameras made in Canada wont be shipped there because of Turkeys involvement in the war. US has prevented them from stealth aircraft too.WHile its not likely Turkey will be kicked out of NATO, it wont be sold many weapons from NATO countries and would lose it priveledges most likely.
@@watcher63034 doesn't matter. Other turkish companies are producing the cameras anyway. Nothing special in those.
@@Jess-xi6up Its not the cameras. Its the whole of NATO moving away from sharing with Turkey.
@@watcher63034 they ban exports and then blame Turkey. Turkey bought the s400 because the US didn't want to sell their equipment, and they're blaming Turkey. Wtf were they gonna do just sit there?
This is a very good analysis and I’m sure many nations are performing similar analyses using the recent conflict for justification to purchase new weapons systems. Great reporting.
Top notch analysis. Great work, sir!
Many r feeling jealous at Turkey’s drone success 😐 LoL man LoL.
why are you concerned,you are indian or turkish .i think it is ertugul syndrome
Cuz Russia stayed quiet. Without Turkey's support Azerbaijan would not have won.
Turkey has lighted itself as a target for next centre of chaos.
Next Libya and Ghadafi.
The scientists involved in drone design will be taken elsewhere.
@Satish K shut up man
. I'm too Indian... Y u hate Turkey
@@warpdrive9229 how Turkey suplorted...? They sold drone only.
. It's natural
Shekhar sir, thanks for talking about it, we are proud of your work you take up all major events around the world and in our nation. Most of all such an unbiased journalism, you are setting benchmarks for many ❤️ A true patriot, is one who helps her/his nation to reflect and learn, you are that person.
Love and Support Azerbaijan Greetings 🚩 from Norway ✝️🇳🇴🇦🇿☪️
W you
The Turkish army really teaches the world about how the war should be and how it should be with the new generation of high technology. With their fantastic war strategies and deadly drones and achievements in Syria, Libya and Karabakh, they showed the world the modern warfare. In other words, this also shows us that wars in the world cannot be won by traditional and old methods as before. Turkish Drones, just like hunting eagles, hunted all tanks and armored vehicles in the enemy army one by one like little sparrows. These drones seem like an engineering wonder. You can never defeat and stop an army that fights effectively in this way! .. I admire the Turkish Army for this reason and for its unmatched brave soldiers.
5:26 The word *Kamikaze* actually means _divine winds_ or _spirit winds_ . This term has its origins in 1281 battle between Japan and joint Mongol-Korean-Chinese armada under Kublai Khan. At that time overearly typhoons had destroyed the invading armada and had saved the Japanese. That too two times. The Mongols didn't invade Japan after that! The same term was used by Japanese AF pilots to carry out suicidal attacks on enemy ships and facilities during WW2 thus the term got associated with 'suicidal attacks'
Sorry Dude. Kamikaze in military term means "deliberate suicidal crash"......Only literally, it means "divine wind".
@@pathfinder5068 that means I am right.
yes its important to remember though that at the time they were referred to as 神風特別攻撃隊 しんぷうとくべつこうげきたい shinpuu tokubetsu kougekitai (divine wind special attack unit) or tokkotai 特攻隊 (special attack unit) the term which uses the kanji for divine wind is a different reading than the version most westerners are familiar with. i belive it is only because of post war american influence that the older reading became associated with suicidal attacks
@@tightlikeweed9735 they not mongol they turk. Xionghu
Not Pakistan, now Bangladesh is going to acquire these drones from Turkey. The deal is already in process.
@Abhishek Singh turkish tb 2 drone used only canadian made camera. When canada blocked this export to turkey, within few days turkey had made their own cameras to attach with tb2 and sent it to Azerbaijan.
Their Akinci drone now the better version of byraktar tb 2. Which was not used in karabakh war.
Also tb2 is high altitude drone less noise compared to Israeli kamikazi suicide drone.
Turkey also produce suicide drones. They are now the top advanced drone producer in the world
Just because Drone has acted havoc on Armenia, pls don't go gaga over drones. Armenian didn't have any kind of proper air defense against these. Their air defense system is totally of Soviet era, same will not be for some technologically modern advanced country. Hence drones may be useful, but India better should first have better air defense system
@Abhishek Singh I think you are so jealous Turkish drone to be better than Indian drone but dont worry soon India will make better drones to make you happy.
@Abhishek Singh turki already successful test new engine Dan kamera (cat) local made for bayraktar tb2 drone...
Turkey will Support all the Muslim Countries who Goverment care Muslims with modern Warfare. But not Countries like BAE, Saudi Arabia, Egypt, Iran, Syria, Bahrain which is slams ISLAM and cooperate with Anti Islam Countries.
What an excellent astute article on the dawning future of warfare!!! Thank you for your insights!
Defense minister: "... we need to replaced our old attack aircraft with new ones".
Finance minister: "But today's fighter aircrafts are cost too much!"
Turkey: Then, how about drones?
India is wasting it's time and resources trying to develop fighter planes, when it should be working on armed autonomous drones.
That’s what we been using during Vedic times, why should we work again?
@@dharamewada6922
You're right. Drones alone don't win a war...
@IslipFact Simply no. Rusians try it and failed. We (Turkey) have countermeasures.
Hahaha..this is the impulsive reactions I love to see after such stories :p You cannot win a war just with drones, geographies, and neighborhoods matter. Btw, India is investing heavily in drones too. A large order of Harop-2 already placed and Rustom-2 deliveries should begin next year. Some of the Herons already converted into combat drones.
Drones are a sitting duck in places with a dense network of SAM systems.
I am from pakistan. But I really appreciate your analysis is too fair and deeply analyse. Each and evry point. I really appreciate you're talented person
Some part of them what they to said Over Turkey Economy is Nonsens. Even What they say Over Pakistan is Nonsense. Turkey and Pakistan is making Effort in new Warfare. Turkey Create for Pakistan 4 Warships. Turkey allready Training Pakistan Pilots with Bayraktar Drone. They will get all so Bayraktar TB2 and allso the Big Brother of TB2 AKINCI which can be downing Enemy fighter jet from 200 km without to see them Optically. So Turkish Drones are working as a intelligent Robots. Canadian Cam was buyed because of cheap, but ASELSAN Produce CAM for ATAK T129 Fighter Helicopter, the next Generation TB-3 will use ASELSAN CAM and Motors from TEI(Turkish Engine Industry) and METEKSAN who create SATCOM. SATCOM means Drone can Operate globally over Satelite Communication. Turkey starts their Own Satelite and SPACE Programm with their Own Satalite Carrier as well. SONDA Rocket powered by ROKETSAN.
@@doodleydoo brother I agree with you and I am more caring for turkey even then my country because you are far from us. But this guy analysis and he is belongs from enemy side war plan from turkey for karabkh his analysis is much much realistic and 2nd may turkey will face problems after canada stopped some supplies for those drons. So overall this guy put v fair analysis
Imran Bhai he is not fair is his Analysis , how can he be fair when he doesn't belong to your country. Kardish talip is right
@@umairkhan5943 I said his analysis is fair enough. Not means that he is fair for my country
@@doodleydoo you know the truth
fantastic breakdown! thank you!\.
India has more powerful drone but they just keep it... They rather use their hands to fight mighty China ....what a brave act.
My experience say turkey aero industry is better than ours .. their quality match with nato and they was member in it
Sure, spend more $billions to buy some from Turkey, China or master Israel. Buying is all you can do keeping most the people starved or forced to commit suicide!
@@bangguyraj pakistani ho??
They're still a member of nato
Our Hal and Nal are good for nothing PSUs. Government should promote private sector defence companies rather than this white elephants. Already Indian engineers are working on software of aeronautical industry. We have R&D division of Boeing, airbus in India in addition to outsourcing work done by HCL, altran, alten, cyient, Tata Elexi etc for other aero majors. What we are lacking is in manufacturing complex hardwares. PSUs failed miserably in this sector where they have monopoly.
@@bangguyraj true for both Pakistan and India
This is so terrifying.
not at all u coward
@@macbookpro3098 U 🦃
Wow. This guy really knows his stuff.
Great informational video. It’s all about unmanned aerial and ground warfare now technology is mind blowing
I believe Turkey n Pakistan contributes a lot in this victory as admitted by Azer’s president. Though it’s Sad but a bitter truth the powers are divided in two major Blocks. I wish no more War
@iqbal sahibil Pakistan also participated in bosnia war... They were also covertly involved in this conflict.
Sir can you de clutter "world largest free trade agreements RCEP been signed without india ". Please very important topic which no one talking about.
wow u r the only sensible person here!! All r talking about war but u chose trade.
@@funnybomb2011 War is also a part of life just like trade.It will be foolishness to deny it
Sir had made a video on it previously. Search Cut the Clutter RCEP. Till sir makes a new video on the topic, that's the best resource
Does it harm India? Kindly explain.
@@sksajidali5004 It does. it shows india is a weak insecure country. in terms of trade. We can't make stuff other nations would want. Hence we are shying away from it.
Now i understand why some countries are reducing heavy armour in favour of larger numbers of lighter faster fighting vehicles. Your parallel drawn with gunpowder is interesting and just as significant now as it was then. The battlefield has seen yet again a historical moment. Interesting and very well presented, thank you Sir.
Thank You Uncle for your most interesting analysis on this war regarding the technology and drones.. But.. the operations on the battle ground took place in different invironment.. 2783 Azerbaijani Shahids gave their lives in those combat while Armenias losses are still indefinite. Over 14000 armenian soldiers were executed in those operations. The Special force units such as Yarasa, Yashma and SWAT were in actions once the DRONES were unable to fly due to mist, fog and showery rains. Special forces killed the enemy more than drones. Human factor is the only strategy that you can never predict. Alhamdulillah. Azerbaijan + Pakistan = Brothers
Why USA lost war in Afghanistan.
KORANa Virus can't be wiped out with bombs...
Because aliens are fighting against US in Afghanistan.
The bayraktar drones decimated the Pantsir systems of Armenia almost at abandon and later on when there was no cover of anti-aircraft systems left then Azerbaijan went in with its conventional figters to bomb positions. A drone swarm can also overwhelm the air defences since its far cheaper than fighter jets you can send 40-50 drones and then the anti-aircraft systems won't have a the bandwidth to deal with such a large number of threats at one time.
A lot of lessons to be learnt from this. Turkey must be given credit, it has developed its entire drone industry (Bayraktar) and missile system (Rocketsan) from scratch in just the past 10 years. We need to open this sector up to domestic private players ASAP rather than being dependent on Israel and the US. Because when the time comes and you have 10 drones while the other country has a 100 then it won't matter however technically superior and expensive your 10 drones are you won't be able to handle 100 drones. Domestic drone production is essential since it gives us the capability to induct vastly large number of drones.
Finally having low cost anti drone systems (flak based, like a simplified version of the Oerlikn from Rheinmetall ruclips.net/video/BgdWNryUhr0/видео.html) would be essential to have deployed in large quantities in forward areas.
What pantsir stupid?...NK army only had old soviet system!..even so they manage to shot down many of them
@@rhodium1096 before calling anyone else stupid learn how to google first www.globaldefensecorp.com/2020/10/26/azerbaijani-army-destroyed-pantsir-s1-of-armenia-using-israeli-harop-drone/
@@apoorvswarup Man.. Armenia dont have Pantsir system! that article is inaccurate...they bought TOR system!..and only a single one was given to NK army!..was deployed in Martuni East part and that system shot down 2 Turkish TB2 and 10 Harop drones....only could be destroyed when was hided in a warehouse as we have seen in a video posted by AZ army!
@@rhodium1096 how come that Pantsir didn't detect TB2 before went hiding in warehouse?
In Syria Russia shot down hundreds of them, not one make it. It all comes to what AA you have and Krasyha system can handle any numbers of drone attack. Armenia was punished for anti russian government policy conducted by Pashinyan
Wow, this man has so warm and likeable personality
Yoga )
i just thought that turkey be affected by US sanctions but what happened turkey stand for that challenge and develop their own technology that outclassed the other countries with their killer drones...
Turkey with a capital letter bitch, u like when ppl spell greece with small letter?!
@@johndoe-oo4os nobody cares how you spell it
🇹🇷🇵🇰🇦🇿💕 Together forever
Three Countries one nation 🇦🇿🇵🇰🇹🇷💕
I don't understand why the fuck u watch our country news. If you love your country so much or is it that your country cannot afford such quality content 😂😂😂
Izlam roxx
@@rdxx4073 such a miserable defend method :D should we say that why u use our war as a topic.dont indians have ability to create war topic ? lool :D
@@fatimemehdiyeva2439 hahah you totally nailed him😂
@@fatimemehdiyeva2439 firstly it's our news channel and we can discuss whatever the fuck we want.......the only reason why you pathetic people come sniffing in our country news media is because there is a lack of it in your pathetic country........so if you want to watch our country's content have some respect for the country and Stop using your dumb brain.....
20:30 : Turkish *Koral* EW systems also helped and shielded Azeri and Turkish drones from Armenian SPAD-GMS and AD systems.
Thats a very important point that was not mentioned in this video. Respect. Good observation. Not many people know the KORAL system. People talk about the drone warfere like they release those drones in to the air like pigeons. However the fact is its much more complicated and it needs a good support system.
As much as weapons, the capabilities of those who use them are very important.
Cadres who use the weapons of the Turkish army are young and well-educated,intelligent people.This is a very important force.
In addition, the staff of the Turkish Armed Forces are also intelligent and knowledgeable people.
Turkey has many well-educated engineers on industrial field and who work in the field of engineering.
@@canantunay2904 yes, Modern Warfare is evolving. You need both brains and brawns.
@@CengizDev KORAL system: what does that? (I could search, but reading from others who know the matter I prefer as 1st impression.)
@@scytalhyucan5269 The Koral system is a mobile electronic warfare system. It consist from 5 independant vehicles. 1 Vehicle recieve and track all radar and other communication signals and find out on which band they are.Then this vehicle give all neccasary information to the other 4 vehicles. These vehicles are the electronic attack systems. They start to jam, scramble or deceive these signals and make the enemy practicaly deaf and blind. I think (hope) thats a simple explanation.
Nice work.lm now subscribed.thanks for your excellence in news reporting
Very instructive. Good work!
Just a note : Ararat mirzoyan wasnt lynched to death ... You should correct that fact ...
I will check and correct, thank you. Sg
@@ThePrintIndia On the morning of 10 November 2020, protesters seized the parliament building and pulled Mirzoyan from a car, demanding to know the whereabouts of Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan, who announced a peace treaty with Azerbaijan just hours earlier to end the Nagorno-Karabakh War.[4][5] Mirzoyan was beaten by a mob and was later taken to hospital, where he underwent surgery and was said to be in a good condition.
@Pancho Villa what is the point of this ?? I said he wasnt killed ...
are you serious?
The age of tanks are gone in 80's.
@IslipFact can you please explain the reason ?
And yet tanks have been used in almost every conflict since 80s
Please research your opinion first before making a judgement
@@sahastradhara can u give any example where tank has been used effectively since 80's?
@IslipFact lol, seems u have a degree on "how does such equipment works" 🤣🤣
Do you know Armenia disappointed using Indian dung radar that’s why Azerbaijani won the war I think Armenia should ask for refund from India
Blablabla Turkish weapons are strong thatswhy not other guns are weak Turks are STRONG
For kind of Information it's rumors by pakistani Media actually only deal happen but not single unit of Swathi Radar is present in Armenia Delivery is not done how they failure even they not present in Armenia pakistani crying seeing Swathi Radar ghost????
Pakistani Propaganda. Truth is Armenia has no defense against drones.
That was the propaganda made by Pakistan
Show us the official statement of Armenia???
Azerbaijan won because justice was on their side
Excellent analysis. Honest and accurate journalism
Russia never came to the defense of Armenia. They wanted to introduce their "peacekeepers" at the end to assert control.
Why would they? The war was in the territory of Azerbaijan. Russians would according to treaty with Armenia if it was visa versa and they stated that many times
Excellent Analysis sir. I hope our Govt pay attention to this.
The era of "Turkeys Ababil" small yet deadly
Thank your nice analysis.Surely Turkey is rapidly improving its Defense Industry.They are also maintaining World Class quality.Now Turkey is a power to be recon with.