What Did The Jedi DO?!? | The Acolyte Eo 1x2 Reaction & Review | Star Wars on Disney+

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 27 авг 2024
  • Watch the Full Length Reaction @ patreon.com/nerdynightly!
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Follow Clarus - www.beacons.pa...
    Follow Nerdy - www.beacons.pa...
    Join the Discord! - / discord
    PO Box: ​503-7700 Hurontario St unit 420 Brampton ON Canada L6W 4M3
    Patreon - patreon.com/nerdynightly
    Business Contact - nerdynightly@gmail.com
    "Nerdy Nightly Theme" by Alex Levitt - @alevitt1990
    Check out his Soundcloud - / alex-levitt-1990
    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Комментарии • 138

  • @krissmith8851
    @krissmith8851 2 месяца назад +41

    If you remember in the vision that Osha has in episode one, her and Mae both have that same hair style as children. It's probably cultural, and they've simply kept it like that.

    • @Domi_Nique811
      @Domi_Nique811 2 месяца назад +7

      Most certainly it's cultural. Once it was inspired by the Ethiopian hamer hairstyle.

  • @hushRD
    @hushRD 2 месяца назад +25

    If it wasn't obvious (there is a lot of makeup), the apprentice with white and orange skin is played by Dafne Keen, who was X-23 in Logan and Lyra in His Dark Materials, I recognised her voice lol

  • @AngeloBarovierSD
    @AngeloBarovierSD 2 месяца назад +24

    RE: Weapons
    (This comment written prior to watching the whole reaction.)
    The mysterious master was referring to some threshold of being an “Acolyte” which requires killing a Jedi in declared hand-to-hand combat. It’s a classic test of mettle.
    The mysterious master has no such constraint. His lightsaber is therefore immaterial to the conversation.
    And, Mae is having trouble passing the test. She wants revenge more than she wants to complete the test, which will likely create conflict with her master.

    • @TimSedai
      @TimSedai 2 месяца назад +4

      I think Qimir IS her master in deep cover keeping tabs on her progress

    • @AngeloBarovierSD
      @AngeloBarovierSD 2 месяца назад +2

      @@TimSedai I think it’s a fair theory, especially given the Star Wars naming conventions. Qimir is pronounced in a way which suggests Chimera, a mythological analogue of duality or multiplicity.

    • @zippomage
      @zippomage 2 месяца назад +1

      i think it's possible she's meant to figure out how to do force choke on her own, and thus kill without a weapon that way. But i really don't know what to expect, th is story is kinda sideways.

  • @Rogue.13
    @Rogue.13 2 месяца назад +17

    I like the calmness of the Jedi Masters in fight, very much appropriate to the lore, that they remain calm and trust in the force to guide them in addition to their combat training.

    • @Fedaygin
      @Fedaygin 2 месяца назад +2

      Yeaah spot on 🙂

    • @crimsonjedi
      @crimsonjedi 2 месяца назад

      Then, easily get killed by a dagger when they've shown people get ran through with a lightsaber and survive.

  • @matdrat
    @matdrat 2 месяца назад +17

    Master Torbin is played by Dean-Charles Chapman. Tommen Baratheon all grown up.

    • @Blinkptx
      @Blinkptx 2 месяца назад +6

      "Baratheon" lol

  • @AngeloBarovierSD
    @AngeloBarovierSD 2 месяца назад +15

    I am so slow to realize “Jason Mendoza” was Qimir. Haha! It all fits. I loved that show, so much!
    I’m glad his career is still in a, ehem, Good Place.

  • @abessia1494
    @abessia1494 2 месяца назад +5

    I think the first two episodes are playing tropes to subvert them -- setting up a murder mystery where the whodoneit is solved immediately being the biggest. The real question is "Who is the Sith?"
    Other tropes I noticed: the fugitive falling out of a high-up cave (pipe, in the original Fugitive) only to be caught by a Jedi in this version; the Padawan asking permission to speak freely until Master Sol says "you know we don't do that right?" Etc. etc. There's a bunch of little nods and easter-eggs to other things, and they get consistently subverted.

  • @deanthemachine7489
    @deanthemachine7489 2 месяца назад +9

    The Jedi Council being like “no! Don’t go protect the Wookiee we know to be in immediate danger! Come ALL THE WAY BACK TO CORUSCANT so we can have a meeting instead of just holo’ing you in to meeting while you’re on your way to warn the Wookiee”
    I *hate* when characters are written to be stupid just for plot purposes. There are ways to write the intention of “the Jedi organization is full of morons doomed to fall apart” without making them openly dumb and illogical. Ahsoka did that too with the idiot on the New Republic council that was just a plot element the protagonists needed to overcome instead of an actual character

    • @GentleGiantJason
      @GentleGiantJason 2 месяца назад +4

      Totally agree. It’s very stupid

    • @Fedaygin
      @Fedaygin 2 месяца назад +2

      Indeed.. Kind Wookiee gonna die because Mirialan blindly wants to ignore the use of HoloTech 😮‍💨 I hope Kelnacca somehow survives.. 🤞

    • @crimsonjedi
      @crimsonjedi 2 месяца назад +2

      Contrived writing is all over the place

  • @Animalfriend777
    @Animalfriend777 2 месяца назад +47

    You say there is no tension but I like that people are talking to each other and being reasonable. I was afraid we were going to drag out the whole OSHA isn’t the killer thing or they wouldn’t listen to her when they found her with the body in this ep. Aren’t you always complaining when characters don’t talk or listen to each other ?

    • @foxtrot-gamesandwit4475
      @foxtrot-gamesandwit4475 2 месяца назад +8

      You hit the nail on the head they’re always complaining

    • @Ehterlink
      @Ehterlink 2 месяца назад +4

      I am glad too that they are not dragging this little mysteries till they overstay their welcome. But people feel different about such things, which is fine, of course.

    • @ThunderBZaper
      @ThunderBZaper 2 месяца назад

      Yeah, I like how these characters are surprisingly being very smart and rational in this show unlike so many others

  • @QuickdrawMcShawthe1st
    @QuickdrawMcShawthe1st 2 месяца назад +13

    Still waiting for the moment when they realize that Mae's hair has been noticeably longer than Osha's this entire time...

    • @oiat
      @oiat 2 месяца назад +3

      Ikr

    • @stevena.7022
      @stevena.7022 2 месяца назад +1

      Braids are curled counterclockwise on Mae and clockwise on Osha.

  • @thejuansnow
    @thejuansnow 2 месяца назад +1

    The hair thing is as simple as its the hair they had as kids. Ive gone between the same 2 hair styles since like 5th grade lol

  • @MbgFire2067
    @MbgFire2067 2 месяца назад +5

    I think there is plenty of mystery in this show and the main point isn’t necessarily the killing of the Jedi. The greater mystery for them is who this overarching “master” behind it all and for us the additional mystery is what did the Jedi do to incur the wrath of Mae (who is evidently at odds with the designs of her master). Lots of twins end up with the same hair styles and cuts even when separated from each other. Even styles of clothing and mannerisms tend to be similar as well among twins.

  • @btgardener39
    @btgardener39 2 месяца назад +4

    "Oh right. The poison. The poison for Torbin, the poison chosen especially to kill Torbin. Torbin's poison." 😜

  • @alexkramerblogs
    @alexkramerblogs 2 месяца назад +6

    5:49 Our Yord and Savior, the One Guardian of Peace and Yorder

    • @btgardener39
      @btgardener39 2 месяца назад

      Oh, you mean Yord Prefect, traveller of the galaxy? Or is he technically a Yord Ranger? Perhaps if he wanders from the tenets of the Jedi Order he'd be a Yord Maverick. ;)

  • @AnaCVazquez
    @AnaCVazquez 2 месяца назад +1

    The hairstyle thing doesn’t bother me. I’ve seen documentaries about identical twins separated at birth. They often live identical lives right down to their haircuts, clothes and jobs. It’s weird but true.

  • @richardbrown3055
    @richardbrown3055 2 месяца назад +2

    While their hair isn’t actually that close, my obvious answer is that it isn’t a coincidence, we know that Mae’s master is altering her perception, we don’t know that he didn’t seek out her Osha prior to this and make sure that they look similar in styling. Honestly I think Space Jason is actually her master, hiding in plain site as a fool….there was something to the look he gave after Mae told him not to tell their Master about the poison.

  • @MrNathansdad
    @MrNathansdad 2 месяца назад +15

    It's a twin thing. It's totally believable

    • @AngeloBarovierSD
      @AngeloBarovierSD 2 месяца назад +7

      Also, they clearly have a strong Force connection. It’s perfectly believable it would lead them to do something like keep their hair the same.
      …but it sure makes production easier if the actor doesn’t have to change hairstyles between characters.

    • @foulrot
      @foulrot 2 месяца назад +8

      Their hair also isn't exactly the same, Mae's hair is significantly longer than Osha's; Osha's stops at the shoulder and Mae's goes down to her stomach.

    • @crimsonjedi
      @crimsonjedi 2 месяца назад

      Keep chugging that copium

  • @stephenparker3120
    @stephenparker3120 2 месяца назад +6

    I really love how this show is showing of the mastery levels between each level of Jedi. Masters only rely on the force unless forced to use their weapon, but Yord is constantly reaching for his and igniting it at the first chance of danger.

  • @garretttroke8800
    @garretttroke8800 Месяц назад

    "He cast Globe of Invulnerability." Um, actually, that would be Otiluke's Resilient Sphere. - Your Friendly Neighborhood Rules Lawyer

  • @TimSedai
    @TimSedai 2 месяца назад +2

    I think Qimir IS the masked dark-sider in deep cover. I also assume (given the anti-woke response from people with early access) that the twins were somehow conceived using the force. This would've had the Jedi uncomfortable if not outright hostile towards Osha and Mae's mother(s). Mae could've caused a fire in a fear response and the guilty cover-up ensued. I'm not sure yet if Sol was occupied saving Osha and is in the dark or if he has skeletons in HIS closet too...

  • @dead_and_devine1505
    @dead_and_devine1505 2 месяца назад +3

    they had the same haircut when they were younger, also i feel like Andara being a Jedi Master would have never fell for the trick that Osha used to kill her. I feel like Andara got the Cpt. Phasma treatment lol.

    • @AnotherScribbler
      @AnotherScribbler 2 месяца назад +2

      See, I kinda felt like she went for it-saving the barkeep-even knowing it might kill her.

    • @dead_and_devine1505
      @dead_and_devine1505 2 месяца назад +2

      @@AnotherScribbler we have seen Masters do both tho, maybe a Knight would have fell for the trick but not a Master, That's my opinion.

    • @AnotherScribbler
      @AnotherScribbler 2 месяца назад +2

      @@dead_and_devine1505 That’s fair, truly. It read to me as her not being sure if she could do both (and you figure that if she really was that much overwhelmingly powerful she could have just pinned Mae’s arm or what have you with the Force).
      Actually, my last comment makes me wonder if they were having her sorta slowly ramp up her level of response and using only the minimum required force (as Sol did, though he had for warning that his opponent had a penchant for knives and was good enough to get Indara).
      That said, if it rang poorly for so many then that’s all the evidence that it could have been better set up.

    • @dead_and_devine1505
      @dead_and_devine1505 2 месяца назад +2

      @@AnotherScribbler there were things I liked but even more that I disliked but it's only 2 episodes and we don't have the full story so my view can definitely change. It's just confusing why they would get such a big actor to kill them off unceremoniously so quickly

  • @Vyan00
    @Vyan00 2 месяца назад

    Not only is the color not natural, that hair-style is hand-weaved. So they both have the same stylist. Although, Mae's cut is longer in the back - and she has the Witch's coven mark on her forehead.

  • @brettholcomb3763
    @brettholcomb3763 2 месяца назад

    The point of Osha going through the "shortcut" way to the crime scene was to remind us of her visions of young Mae and show them in another context, for reasons we don't yet understand. But, her vision of young Mae got her to the crime scene faster than everyone else, which seems significant.

  • @thejuansnow
    @thejuansnow 2 месяца назад

    If you look real close the binoculars do have a red indicator on them i believe they are recording

  • @cody2oo
    @cody2oo 2 месяца назад +2

    9:35 I made my first commentary video off this moment 🤣.
    45 seconds from when Sol senses his death and starts running while Osha stumbles across the body on accident.
    Took me so far out of the episode cause I knew instantly they were going to accuse her of doing it and I waited 45 seconds for them to finally rush in.
    Wild choice.

    • @AnotherScribbler
      @AnotherScribbler 2 месяца назад +1

      I do think that perhaps they are trying to show things playing out around the same time but aren’t using the visual language that usually makes that work.

  • @nicolascardillo7615
    @nicolascardillo7615 2 месяца назад +3

    Nerdy: "Do u think the WOOKIEE dies?"
    Everyone Online: Well its a prequal n we know, The Jedi don't know about the Sith returning, so Everyone involved most die for continuity.

    • @foulrot
      @foulrot 2 месяца назад +3

      Or the Jedi cover it all up, like they seemingly did with whatever happened when Mae & Osha were children.

    • @nicolascardillo7615
      @nicolascardillo7615 2 месяца назад

      @@foulrot Yoda is part of the Consul, n they just call them back because they are convening a meeting to discuss the correct actions to take. Even if Yoda is away for other reasons he would had been informed. All the Jedi already known of a dead Jedi Master was killed be a force user.

    • @foulrot
      @foulrot 2 месяца назад +1

      @@nicolascardillo7615 they specifically say they are convening a "small council", which to me say it's not the full council involved. If only a few are involved, they could easily cover things up

  • @athenacooper3130
    @athenacooper3130 2 месяца назад +2

    I want to like the show, but I don't feel the reveal of what happened when Osha & Mae were kids will be sufficiently compelling.
    I feel like it's going to go in one of two relatively unsatisfying directions.
    1) the Jedi did something horrible (in which case we really need to start having light siders as antagonists)
    Or 2) The jedi were trying to do the right thing, it went sideways for reasons outside their control, and they all feel guilty about it in a way that the person pulling the strings behind the scenes obviously wouldn't.
    And of the two, I suspect it will be the 1st and Osha's journey will be one of turning on the Jedi.

  • @ourabouras
    @ourabouras 2 месяца назад

    So we’re all in agreement that the dealer is the secret master right? Also how short is this season that Mae has already killed 2 of the 4 Jedi she’s sworn revenge against.

  • @GentleGiantJason
    @GentleGiantJason 2 месяца назад +1

    I totally agree with you that the show has these strange writing. It’s almost as if two people are writing the story and think it should go in different directions. And they alternate writing scenes and are going out of their way to mess up the other writer’s plot.

    • @FarseerOfCearath
      @FarseerOfCearath 2 месяца назад

      Well, that _would_ kind of be on brand...

  • @njebei
    @njebei 2 месяца назад +1

    If you felt these two were janky - the reviewers I've watched have said the next two episodes are rough in comparison. I think the biggest issue is Disney+ is more about CG and not about diaglogue and don't trust their actor's. This is also one of the reasons these shows cost so much. Disney+ needs to learn how to have discussion in rooms (and learn from Andor). Fingers crossed they can save it in the back half.

  • @jackiecarson859
    @jackiecarson859 2 месяца назад

    Maybe Oshi got to the body before the others because she followed the specter of her sister. Maybe not. Who knows...

  • @MJosephB
    @MJosephB 2 месяца назад

    Well, to be fair Carrie Anne Moss was also winning her fight against Mae up until the moment she died 😱😱 so why take the chance that Sol didn’t know about Mae’s hidden knife.

  • @LezArtist5iG
    @LezArtist5iG 2 месяца назад +1

    16:25 Trying to signify that the Old Republic and Jedi Order, moved too slow to stop their own destruction.
    Foreboding.

  • @davidbodor1762
    @davidbodor1762 2 месяца назад +1

    22:22 - Could always be a cultural thing. Maybe on their planet every woman has that type of hair or maybe it's something they hold onto from their childhoods, because we know they had that hairstyle as kids too based on the visions Osha had.
    Also Mae kinda has a difference in that she has those extension thingies or whatever those are, I dunno, I'm not a hair guy.

  • @thebluesmurfdude
    @thebluesmurfdude 2 месяца назад

    I have a crazy wild theory.
    What if Sol and the others thought they had found the chosen one, and had “killed” Mae so they could bring in Osha.
    The questions I’m asking myself are:
    Why did the Jedi break their rules and allow someone in the temple to be trained, especially when they were too old, and had deep trauma?
    What causes them to allow that?
    What would have made the Jedi feel they had to step outside their moral code to achieve something?
    The answer I’m leaning towards is that maybe Osha was believed to be the chosen one.
    Don’t know why, but that’s just the crazy theory I have.
    Also, aside; I keep thinking about Qui-Gon, when he talks to Anakin in episode one “Maybe I killed a Jedi, and took his lightsaber from him.”
    At the time it felt like a throw away line. But now I’m wondering if Sith Acolytes have an initiation ritual, where they need to kill an Jedi and take their lightsaber. In the first episode, Mae looks down at the lightsaber, almost like she wants to take it. I wonder if there are rules where you can’t take it unless you killed them without a weapon. To weed out the weak.
    I don’t know, lots of cool stuff to think about. Love jumping into a time I don’t know much about. It’s fun to sit and speculate.

    • @Whoo_Boy
      @Whoo_Boy 2 месяца назад

      @thebluesmurfdude okay there could be some merit to that speculation. I've also read that some people think that the guy Mae is working with might actually be the Sith master who's training her (the Sith in the mask with the red lightsaber).

  • @nathancline4000
    @nathancline4000 2 месяца назад

    I suspect that the 4 Jedi attacked thir family who was unarmed.Possibly in response to a vision, and in doing so, set the vision in motion.

  • @Whoo_Boy
    @Whoo_Boy 2 месяца назад

    I was thinking the same thing about Osha and Mae's hairstyles but then I noticed something during this reaction. It appears that Mae's bangs hang a little lower than her eyebrows while Osha's bangs a the top of hers. I don't know if that's consistent between the two episodes but it seems consistent throughout this episode.

  • @Adideva3
    @Adideva3 2 месяца назад

    I agree that those 4 Jedi did something really bad, the fact that Osha and Mae never knew that each other were alive, paints a picture that the Jedi cover their asses.
    Secondly I found some interesting information online from the High Republic novels, which states that Mae and Osha live with Mother Aniseya’s coven of witches on the planet Brendock and it was just assumed that Mae and Osha were just part of the coven, so to find the twins could be the daughters of Mother Aniseya is huge.
    So my theory is that maybe the Jedi killed the witches from the coven when Jedi weren't supposed to kill because it is not the Jedi way.

  • @leisastalnaker3790
    @leisastalnaker3790 2 месяца назад

    Well I think Mae’s master is speaking of no weapons, theoretically. What kills the dream??? Fear. If you can project fear you don’t need a weapon.

  • @stephenparker3120
    @stephenparker3120 2 месяца назад

    I still think Osha might have another issue we are not aware of yet. Because Mei did not see the same vision that Osha did or else she wouldn’t have been shocked to see her in the alleyway.
    Also, we FINALLY got to see a different Jedi temple! Yes, we saw them in animated series but it was also abandoned and never had other Jedi in it

    • @Whoo_Boy
      @Whoo_Boy 2 месяца назад +1

      @stephenparker3120 I was thinking that Mae might be having Force visions from the Sith master who's training Mae. He might have plans for turning both of them to the darkside.

  • @dwmarch
    @dwmarch 2 месяца назад

    Osha got to the murder scene first because those mall cop ass Jedi were making the visiting Jedi do paperwork for visitor passes. Bureaucracy is the real Sith.

  • @brettholcomb3763
    @brettholcomb3763 2 месяца назад

    I think the "you kill a Jedi without a weapon" is like a Sith koan. Killing a Jedi (physically) is not the goal of the Sith. Killing a Jedi's faith and/or the faith of people in the Jedi is the goal (one that Palpatine eventually succeeds in). I also think Qimir is the Sith we saw in Ep. 1 and is gaslighting Mae's misunderstanding of the koan. Or, not. lol

  • @Vyngr4nn
    @Vyngr4nn 2 месяца назад

    yeah, the only explanation (mental gymnastics) for Yord and his binoculars imo is that he was recording with them

    • @Vyngr4nn
      @Vyngr4nn 2 месяца назад

      and the thing about the twins, my theory is that they have some sort of force connection (force diad) and jedi kidnapped one of them from the cult/had them intentionally seperated so they wouldnt meet

  • @houseofsledge6891
    @houseofsledge6891 2 месяца назад

    Yord as space himbo is now official canon.

  • @eggmansizzle
    @eggmansizzle 2 месяца назад +7

    Love this show so far. Only a few scenes I thought were slightly odd, but overall it's good so far. As a personal preference I wish they followed Mae (May? Mei?) more exclusively but that's just my inner "i love the bad guys" coming out.

  • @stephenparker3120
    @stephenparker3120 2 месяца назад +1

    I definitely agree on the physical acting. I also wonder if these first few sets are the lower budgeted ones because when she runs away after the dust she moves one alleyway away from where they were fighting. Then the other Jedi pretending to not see them on the balcony and a very wide open alleyway felt like acting you would see on like the Indiana Jones show at Disney World, where you have to pretend the set is much larger than it actually is

  • @Fedaygin
    @Fedaygin 2 месяца назад +1

    Good talks as usual 🙂 I'm gonna restream both nice episodes with "65 Led Telly before third lands. I totally got the nice Star Wars Galaxy atmosphere from both 🙂 I wish you good time when relax by streaming beautiful The Acolyte S01 via D+ 🙂 Happy to share El Bueno Word because it deserves it 😋

  • @gadfly149
    @gadfly149 2 месяца назад

    Acolyte needs a Pink 5 cameo. The older masters are chill, but the younger Jedi and padawans are too quick to escalate, disdaining the carrot for the stick. Yord holing a saber in front of his face illuminates nothing. Bright light in your faces night vision.

  • @Jcewazhere
    @Jcewazhere 2 месяца назад

    The force grew their hair that way....
    yeah, it's weird.

  • @DrSpaceCapeTV
    @DrSpaceCapeTV 2 месяца назад +1

    9:46 It feels like there is a scene missing before Osha finds Torbin's body. It made no sense that she beat them to that room, even if Yord was following Osha, it still makes no sense that they would arrive at that room before Sol and the rest of the Jedi. Sol even has a moment when he feels Torbin die through the Force and rushes down the hall. I feel like they just shoehorned Osha into that spot for some unneeded skepticism and tension.

    • @MadSlantedPowers
      @MadSlantedPowers 2 месяца назад

      Seems pretty simple to me. She took a shortcut.

  • @ravenward626
    @ravenward626 2 месяца назад

    If they did the twinsy haircut before becoming separated, then maybe they maintained it in honor of their presumed dead sister.

  • @rhonecherrington2131
    @rhonecherrington2131 2 месяца назад

    They said hes taken a vow of silence, and the town folk say he hasn't spoken to anyone in 10 years... so while several channels took it the way u did, i for one thnk he just hasnt talked and meditates that way for long periods of time, i felt like she was waiting for him to wake when she gave him the poison, wich eventually he did, im assuming he wakes up to eat and use the bathroom, or is he force carrying his turds to the toilet?

    • @AnotherScribbler
      @AnotherScribbler 2 месяца назад

      The real life traditions the Jedi are partly based on have stories of monks meditating to the point that all their bodily processes slow down, etc.
      I am assuming the added quality of the Force makes the upper limit on that basically fantasy levels.

  • @jamesskates7558
    @jamesskates7558 2 месяца назад

    Love your vids! Loving the reactions, glad to have caught it so early

  • @pauldhoff
    @pauldhoff 2 месяца назад +6

    It is called, building the story line. If they told you everything with only 2 of 8 episodes watched what would be the reason to watch more.

    • @brettholcomb3763
      @brettholcomb3763 2 месяца назад

      People have zero chill when it comes to Star Wars. They can't wait to see what things might mean. They start trying to connect everything and figure out the plot from the first few moments.

  • @jackiecarson859
    @jackiecarson859 2 месяца назад

    Yeah... *about* Ahsoka wearing that thing. Every woman, regardless of breast size, knows about the unreliability of tube tops. Yoinking a lightsaber all over the place means boobs boink-boinking all over the place. *Then again, according to George Lucas, there are no bras in Star Wars, so...?*

  • @kirkdarling4120
    @kirkdarling4120 2 месяца назад

    I think Osha and Mae don't have "hair." I'm guessing it's actually a kind of lekku head growth. Otherwise, I'd have to say it doesn't make sense for them to have the exact same hairstyle now, after their decidedly different lives, and had the same hair style as children. So, it must be a head structure like lekku, not a hair style. Or it doesn't make sense.
    So, they know who Mae is going to kill next...but they need a council meeting to decide whether to warn him.
    They are trying to create a false mystery. They're not doing mystery right because they have a protagonist who knows the "big secret" that they're deliberately and unnecessarily keeping from the audience. It seems like the "big reveal" is that those four Jedi did something very wrong, but thinking they were doing right. Well, we've actually seen bad guy Jedi before, so I can't make myself care about _that_ as such a big deal. I think they're going to try to be very, very much more clever than they really are by trying to keep the audience fooled by an extremely convoluted plot.

    • @dilarabankoley1109
      @dilarabankoley1109 Месяц назад

      My opinion is just that locs as a hairstyle take a lot of time and dedication and since they already started getting them as kids they stuck with them, it’s sort of a commitment thing

  • @alohamilkyway
    @alohamilkyway 2 месяца назад

    Jason Mendoza here playing space Jack Sparrow. I love it!

  • @LittleMan27
    @LittleMan27 2 месяца назад

    I think y’all should react to New Rockstars breakdowns

  • @topher6410
    @topher6410 2 месяца назад

    With a few exceptions, I’ve been quite disappointed with Disney+ SW, but so far I’ve enjoyed the first two episodes. Far from perfect, but entertaining…

  • @evanflynn4680
    @evanflynn4680 2 месяца назад

    Memory wipe thing:
    Play Star Wars Knights of the Old Republic. Jedi don't execute their prisoners.

  • @lion4611
    @lion4611 2 месяца назад

    @NerdyNightly I heard that the producer Leyslie wants to make a live action kotor show even she’s thinking about making it and putting a legend character in her Star Wars shows

    • @crimsonjedi
      @crimsonjedi 2 месяца назад

      I hope not

    • @lion4611
      @lion4611 2 месяца назад

      It’s been confirmed that she’s doing it and she played the kotor games and that Keira is her favorite character so I. Guessing she gunna put only Kreia in it only and not others since she’s feminist

  • @NicholasRawlins-tf7ug
    @NicholasRawlins-tf7ug 2 месяца назад

    It's like they don't understand how to edit a mystery story or even write characters that make any sense. This is written like a small child trying to write a fairy tale full of coincidences that don't make sense and characters that are idiots.

  • @johannesbowers7467
    @johannesbowers7467 2 месяца назад

    Ro2 era sith are always on the lookout for benchwarmers.... so "testing" prospects is common....
    Qmir... you sounding a little sussssssy there Darth Jarjar.
    Dropping Sith Code quotes wearing clothes still warm from the body you took them from.
    If you want to impress "The Master", you probably shoulda channeled Hannibal Lechter and had Torben turn his lightaaber on himself.
    *Breaking HoloNewsNet*
    Local unregistered Force user used [Pocket Sand] to evade Jedi TacTeam. It was super effective.

  • @felseyjr71
    @felseyjr71 2 месяца назад +10

    only in todays fandom will people require a level of logic in the physics and mechanics of the story in a universe that is steeped in space wizards, ninja teddy bears & underworld gangster slugs.

    • @FarseerOfCearath
      @FarseerOfCearath 2 месяца назад +6

      It's about expectations and immersion. If I'm seeing a made up fantasy thing for the first time, I don't know what to expect. But if it's a depiction of something _real,_ I expect it to behave like the real thing does unless there's some reason for why it wouldn't. If I can't tell if it's _supposed_ to work differently or if you just made a mistake, it's jarring and distracts me from the story.

    • @hoos3014
      @hoos3014 2 месяца назад +5

      @@FarseerOfCearath Star Wars is almost 50 years old. We all know that its fantasy at this point.

    • @chaost4544
      @chaost4544 2 месяца назад +2

      @@FarseerOfCearath that doesn't apply to long running franchises like Star Wars and Star Trek. There is knowledge about the franchise that are cultural things that people know about even if they haven't seen the franchise. Even if you've never seen Star Wars, most people know it's a space fantasy with wizards. Things like space fires have been a long established thing since the original trilogy.

    • @FarseerOfCearath
      @FarseerOfCearath 2 месяца назад +3

      @@hoos3014 Sure, but there's different kinds of fantasy. In The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy, people can learn to fly by "throwing themselves at the ground and missing", and that's fine because that world just happens to be comedically absurd like that. But if Lord of the Rings ended with Frodo randomly doing the same thing you'd probably wonder what the hell was going on, right? Am I making any sense?

    • @FarseerOfCearath
      @FarseerOfCearath 2 месяца назад +2

      @@chaost4544 I don't actually mind that particualr example all that much. Star Wars ship's have always seemed weirdly flammable, as you point out.
      I'm just not a fan of the whole "Why do you care about A in a story with B?" logic. *Because A and B are different things, dang it!*

  • @mathewwadsworth3015
    @mathewwadsworth3015 2 месяца назад +1

    I'll give the haircut a pass because there are so many real life stories right here on earth about the freaky connection many twins have.

  • @randyrodriguez2398
    @randyrodriguez2398 2 месяца назад

    Nerdy Revenges has to be a show to watch looooooooooool... really enojoying your videos as much as this new serie, have higher hopes in it after first two episodes, Clarus gorgeous as always! keep rocking and stay safe!

  • @sosayweall2509
    @sosayweall2509 2 месяца назад +1

    This might be the worst star wars property put to screen I clouding the xmas special

  • @samfisher6606
    @samfisher6606 2 месяца назад

    I really enjoyed these episodes. I pegged from pretty much scene 3 or 4 that it was either twins or D.I.D. I'm glad they didn’t go with DID. We don’t need more mentally ill bad-guy misrepresentation, especially with a WOC. Some of the initial reviews said this is the first Star Wars show to actually look like TV and I see what they mean. Some of the effects like the match cut of the blizzard into the forest but it was still snowing didn’t look great. But it’s nice to see that good ole Republic bureaucracy is as ineffective as always. And I like how the episode titled being two sides of the same coin hint at Osha and Mae's opposite character arcs.
    I kept waiting for Osha to write someone up for a workplace violation but nothing.

  • @Npence09
    @Npence09 2 месяца назад

    Poison has to be ingested or injected

  • @a3-radio
    @a3-radio 2 месяца назад +3

    I agree with you, the show has some "leia running away in the woods from mercenaries" moments, the concept of the scene are fine but are shown in lazy ways, like the balcony from the apothecary being right next to each other and them being full in the open and nobody realizing it, the conversation with the apothecarian that gives a lot away to ocea but the jedi just don't press him, Scenes that in concept works but were done poorly

  • @rhonecherrington2131
    @rhonecherrington2131 2 месяца назад

    Shes in space, in a space suit since theres no air or oxygen in space, putting out a fire... so yeah, there are odd decisions, although im enjoying it thus far...

    • @crimsonjedi
      @crimsonjedi 2 месяца назад

      Those are not odd decisions. It's writers not having a clue. The only excuse I could see for that is there is a shield and it's keeping the oxygen in. But I doubt that.

    • @stevena.7022
      @stevena.7022 2 месяца назад

      Leia didn't come back from her space swim like: "Hey you guys, you can still hear everything out there!"
      I'm a pedantic hater. Osha tanked a planetary re-entry impact. Did she learn that at space-firefighter academy?
      It's always the failed opportunity that hits hardest with these efforts. My suggestion scene: She's strapped in to her chair when she glances at a untethered mech-nic crate... unlocks it with her Swiss Army droid.... Yay a spacesuit, a star-warsie helmet, and some mag-boots! The ship's breaking up... osha struggles on the ''wing'' surfing atmosphere like it's Dark Star... a leap of faith (the force?)... Some free fall... a cool parachute... big shot of flaming inferno as she floats onto a desolate planet. More drama? Do the damaged chute trope and high speed impact into snow. She's got a sprained ankle oh no, and the Jedi save her from hungry space Yeti.
      Yes still ridiculous, but It connects her skillset to survival. It's epic, and It's narrowly plausible.
      But no, just ignore the campfire in space. It looks like her burned childhood trauma ok. duh.

  • @gadfly149
    @gadfly149 2 месяца назад

    I gotta say, I’m eager to see X-23 fight Jedi style. Also, it’s a little known fact that the force guides hair growth in its dyads (jk).

  • @SwiftJustice
    @SwiftJustice 2 месяца назад

    ⚠️ Reminder Russia _actively_ reviewbombs Star Wars online because Star Wars is antifascist. The FBI reported it. Don't fall for Russian memes.

  • @JimmiHoevring
    @JimmiHoevring 2 месяца назад +3

    Torbin's beard looked hella fake!!!

  • @tidewillroll9274
    @tidewillroll9274 2 месяца назад

    Am I the only one terrified of the thought of a Wookie Jedi?

  • @deanthemachine7489
    @deanthemachine7489 2 месяца назад

    It’s like Filoni saw Headland’s script, it made sense, and he marked it up in a red marker that read “this is too smart for Star Wars fans. Make it less good and remove 70% of the tension”

  • @toria6719
    @toria6719 2 месяца назад

    I feel like as movie reactors and the work u guys do makes u notice things that a normal viewer wouldn’t notice or point out. 😂😂😂 like u guys will say these things that pull u out of the show that a regular person wouldn’t give a shit like who cares? This is a story about aliens, and space ninjas like pull u out from what?? That’s the one thing I keep not getting from your reactions 😅😅😅😂😂😂

  • @larryjones1333
    @larryjones1333 2 месяца назад +2

    This is not Star Wars , laughable

    • @SwiftJustice
      @SwiftJustice 2 месяца назад +3

      Yes it is
      🌈Happy Pride Month💋

  • @kaizen5023
    @kaizen5023 2 месяца назад +1

    They killed Carrie Ann Moss in the first episode -- and all the male characters are dumb and/or incompetent. No thanks. Bring back some real gritty Star Wars like Andor. This reeks of more Disney schlock.

  • @Pipss363
    @Pipss363 2 месяца назад +1

    Woke asf.😂🤡

    • @SwiftJustice
      @SwiftJustice 2 месяца назад +3

      And that's a good thing

  • @MbgFire2067
    @MbgFire2067 2 месяца назад +13

    I think there is plenty of mystery in this show and the main point isn’t necessarily the killing of the Jedi. The greater mystery for them is who this overarching “master” behind it all and for us the additional mystery is what did the Jedi do to incur the wrath of Mae (who is evidently at odds with the designs of her master). Lots of twins end up with the same hair styles and cuts even when separated from each other. Even styles of clothing and mannerisms tend to be similar as well among twins.