The Tudor Black Bay 41 Monochrome AFTER The Hype: Is It Still Awesome? 4 Month Review

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 2 дек 2024

Комментарии • 166

  • @thewatchidiot
    @thewatchidiot  Месяц назад +4

    If you’d like to buy my BB41 Monochrome from this video (box and papers included), feel free to email me: thewatchidiot@gmail.com
    The price is $3,950 with free insured shipping within the continental US. For international sales / shipping, send me an email. Thanks!

    • @SteveSchams
      @SteveSchams 28 дней назад

      I tried to email you but got no response. I am interested

    • @JMillz23
      @JMillz23 27 дней назад

      Just emailed you

  • @PP080PP
    @PP080PP 29 дней назад +7

    I sold the SM300M to get the Monochrome on rubber and would never go back! Love the Monochrome on the rubber but only on the rubber! on other bracelet find it very boring, no stand out at all, the rubber makes the difference(at least for me)! ✌

  • @TheKopolanpoika
    @TheKopolanpoika Месяц назад +4

    For me, it has been as good as I hoped. Maybe because it's my first entry level diver which I bought new and I got that new watch tape off experience, or something else. I had BB smiley and selling that to buy this is easily best decision I have made. Just loving contrast of all the shining parts against matte black bezel. And that jubilee is pure awesome.

    • @thewatchidiot
      @thewatchidiot  29 дней назад +1

      the new watch experience is a pretty satisfying one no doubt! Tudor did a great job with this watch for sure its pure quality. And I agree, whenever i wear it i love all the crisp contrast and the look of an aluminum bezel is fantastic. Makes me want to keep it now!

  • @EliborioAsiamah
    @EliborioAsiamah 3 дня назад

    AMZWATCH's always amazes me how much beauty and precision are added to the parts of watch 99% of people will never see.

  • @Mjaf23
    @Mjaf23 27 дней назад +1

    I bought mine in June, and I really loved it, but since then, for some reason I think I'm over the hype

  • @derrondoc
    @derrondoc Месяц назад +7

    Personally I’m loving my BB41 Monochrome. Honestly surprised how much I do like it. Simplicity and the 5 link is different from my oyster Rolex bracelets on my Explorer and Submariner. It is my Explorer which is loosing out on wrist time with the addition of BB41. That’s great thing about this hobby - we can all have our own opinions and wear what we like. For me the BB41 is a huge winner and my preferred daily over my Rolex and Omega collection.

  • @michaelbradley6488
    @michaelbradley6488 29 дней назад +1

    There is no reason that the clasp could not have a hardness coating on it, it is inexpensive and very practical. I have the Tuseno Shellback which has a similar monochrome look, Tuseno put a coating on the clasp and I still have not managed to put a mark on it. I love the look of the Black Bay 41. Nice review.

  • @zoldarzolder7767
    @zoldarzolder7767 24 дня назад +1

    Great vid as always. But help me understand that a monochrome black bay goes away, but the monochrome SPB stays? Both dont have a lot going on on the dial and could be considered a bit unremarkable. I’m considering the spb but the absolute lak of enbelishmants on the dial hold me back.

  • @tommydude969
    @tommydude969 7 дней назад

    It's all about the burgundy bezel for me. I was initially not a fan of the snowflake hand but have come around to it. The combination of the colored bezel and gilt/offwhite handset and markers are what make my particular example a standout in my collection.
    My only gripe is that the center polish clasp does scratch easily and I don't know why these larger companies refuse to use any protective coating. The clasp on my Zelos Vitesse is still flawless...

  • @edshamaham5719
    @edshamaham5719 Месяц назад +2

    Given your last video about your seamaster I'm not surprised! Although the seamaster and BB41 are pretty different i can see how they might step on each other's toes in your collection especially with the pelagos around. It would be interesting to see a comparison video of the BB41 and seamaster as well as the pelagos

    • @thewatchidiot
      @thewatchidiot  Месяц назад

      Yeah the writing was in the wall the moment the SMP came back lol! But while I was editing this video, the BB41 was tempting me again making me want to keep it but I know I can't. Yeah a comparison video between it and the SMP would be interesting given their similar ish price point and overall quality and the BB41's bracelet advantage. Time for me to get to work then!

    • @dissident_mantis7
      @dissident_mantis7 Месяц назад

      I also sold my BB58 after purchasing a Seamaster. Different watches, but if I am gonna wear a dressy diver I prefer the SMP300

  • @tommyhenriquezkayakangler8465
    @tommyhenriquezkayakangler8465 29 дней назад +1

    Is it as top heavy as your Seamaster professional?

  • @Eric-i1r
    @Eric-i1r Месяц назад +1

    I love the monochrome. I own a shyteload of modern Tudors. Prolly get a 124060 next or Glashutte SeaQ Panorama Date.

  • @user-iz9co4qf6z
    @user-iz9co4qf6z 29 дней назад +1

    The bezel on the Tudor monochrome sounds like a dolphin mating call. Cool party trick

    • @Calmness1014
      @Calmness1014 29 дней назад +1

      The new GMT clicking sound is the same as the clicks on the safe at Tudor. By design as well. I thought that was a nice touch tbh

  • @madrat5176
    @madrat5176 29 дней назад +2

    BB54 is their best current watch 👍

  • @eyeheartsushi2212
    @eyeheartsushi2212 22 дня назад

    Great video and yeah I can see why you’re letting go of the Monochrome. It can’t hold a candle to your black SMP 300.

  • @marcgirard7551
    @marcgirard7551 Месяц назад +3

    Great video as always. Really can’t blame you for blowing the Tudor away with the arrival of that stunning black dial Seamaster. Kinda hard to beat that Omega!

    • @SIZZO76
      @SIZZO76 29 дней назад +1

      I AGREE! SEAMASTER IS GORGEOUS 🔥🔥🔥🔥

  • @Think890
    @Think890 29 дней назад

    Still want a monochrome but after seeing the seamaster...love it too

  • @Mountain-Hiker
    @Mountain-Hiker 27 дней назад +2

    I require a date on my watches.

  • @momoz283
    @momoz283 Месяц назад +8

    I'm saving up for the monochrome 41mm 😁 already a BB owner of 54 and 36mm (Anthracite).
    Need something big in my collection and the BB monochrome 41mm seems the perfect tudor sub for me!

    • @iamjzr
      @iamjzr 23 дня назад

      Would u go 3 or 5 links bracelet?

    • @momoz283
      @momoz283 22 дня назад

      @iamjzr 5 link 100% that's a sexy bracelet and I also got 3 links on my 54 so don't want none on my monochrome 41mm. I have tried the watch in person at an AD it was nice man but I couldn't buy the display one have to wait...

  • @franco2739
    @franco2739 Месяц назад +3

    I don't think your back pack would magnetize your Willard. ISO standard will definitely with stand that level of magnetism

    • @hubertuswolfthaler
      @hubertuswolfthaler Месяц назад +3

      I had an SPB143 (which has the same movement), and that thing got magnetized all the time.

    • @KC-bv9kf
      @KC-bv9kf Месяц назад

      Nope, ISO but more importantly, what are the specs?
      Bare minimum and outdated considering the number of powerful magnets that are ubiquitous today.
      The mag chargers are about 2x ISO, laptop speakers, desk top speakers…
      Just get a basic compass and test your watches, and that might explain if they are running off of specs.
      Fortunately, demagnetizing and/or demagnetizers are relatively easy and cheap.
      But annoying.

    • @thewatchidiot
      @thewatchidiot  29 дней назад +1

      Yeah unfortunately magnets are getting stronger especially magsafe magnets. I have a peak design back pack and the main latch is a fairly strong magnet and there are multiple other magnets around the back pack. When i was traveling i tried to keep the willard as far from the magnets as possible but over the course of the day it got magnetized. Thankfully demagnetizing it afterwards was very quick!

  • @KalElKent1501
    @KalElKent1501 5 дней назад

    For someone who lives in Switzerland and have been owning watches for a very long time I can tell you that Tudor is currently the best built watches out there...even surpases some Rolex

  • @derrickiwanenko3898
    @derrickiwanenko3898 Месяц назад +2

    Have the monochrome on three link and have been wanting the five link…

    • @jaredmatthews9403
      @jaredmatthews9403 Месяц назад

      Forstner!

    • @thewatchidiot
      @thewatchidiot  29 дней назад

      Forstner is awesome but unfortunately they havent released bracelets for these new 21mm lug width BB41s. Hopefully they release them soon, although it would make be reconsider selling mine lol

    • @jaredmatthews9403
      @jaredmatthews9403 29 дней назад

      @@thewatchidiot oh that is interesting and unfortunate. New tfit bracelets I was quoted at like 980 usd.

  • @dissident_mantis7
    @dissident_mantis7 Месяц назад +5

    I sold my BB58 after purchasing the Seamaster. It’s a better dressy diver IMHO, and I actually like the bracelet better.

    • @SIZZO76
      @SIZZO76 29 дней назад +2

      I agree. SEAMASTER IS GORGEOUS 🔥🔥🔥

    • @csarcpab
      @csarcpab 28 дней назад

      Always Omega >>> Tudor Seamaster is a great diver though I think the the 39mm PO is their Ultimate diver watch.

  • @JosalynBonaventure
    @JosalynBonaventure 28 дней назад

    I believe no man can say no to AMZWATCH's watches

  • @witkidone
    @witkidone 29 дней назад

    Did you sell this one already? If not how much you trying to get?

    • @thewatchidiot
      @thewatchidiot  29 дней назад

      Its still available for $3,950 with free shipping in the continental US! Feel free to send me an email at thewatchidiot@gmail.com

  • @SaSpursFan
    @SaSpursFan 29 дней назад +3

    I would go for the burgundy bezel for some pop of color and uniqueness

  • @craigborrenpohl1233
    @craigborrenpohl1233 29 дней назад +5

    My honeymoon is over and here’s what I’ve learned.
    1. The five link bracelet is amazing but slightly too flashy in my everyday setting. I’m currently seeking the rubber strap for everyday use and will dress it up with the five link when needed.
    2. The snowflake hour hand is just amazing for readability and is now possibly my favorite hour hand for a diver.
    3. The longer power reserve is appreciated when I pick it up after a few days of non-use am surprised to find it still right on time.
    4. T-fit may not be necessary but I find myself adjusting size five or six times a day for that perfect fit.
    Bottom line I’ve found myself adjusting my other watches with flashy straps etc so they will still get wrist time as this one is so versatile I’m wearing it more and more.

    • @craigborrenpohl1233
      @craigborrenpohl1233 29 дней назад +1

      Oh, and the 21 mm lug width is annoying.

    • @jacobschopp3250
      @jacobschopp3250 14 дней назад +1

      I’m kinda in the same spot with my monochrome. I love the 5 link but need a rubber strap to make it a tad more casual. Trying to source a good strap to set it and forget it

  • @HLB2512
    @HLB2512 Месяц назад

    Iv been looking at this and the burgundy both on 3 link and think im slighty more for the red as im worried i may start comparing it to the submariner i used to have. The red is nothing like it tho so i wont be comparing

  • @georgeparaskevopoulos6601
    @georgeparaskevopoulos6601 Месяц назад +1

    Another excellent watch from Tudor!

  • @CaptainCreampie69
    @CaptainCreampie69 10 дней назад +1

    You like black dial white index divers but you don’t have a submariner?! That’s the only one you need. 🤦🏽‍♂️

  • @whodeycinbengals
    @whodeycinbengals 29 дней назад +3

    The monochrome looks phenomenal. Personally, I prefer the BB to the Seamaster, although I do very much like the Seamaster, as well.
    Ever since I started collecting, Tudor has been a top 2-3 brand for me, that is, until I received a bad example of a brand new Pelagos 39, followed by Tudor’s lack of quality customer service.

  • @tomski6811
    @tomski6811 Месяц назад +1

    I was excited when this watch came out. Tried it at my AD and found it boring.

  • @RabbitWatchShop
    @RabbitWatchShop Месяц назад +7

    You have a lot of Tudor haters in your comments 😂 Tough crowd, huh?

    • @hammalamiri12
      @hammalamiri12 29 дней назад +3

      Something I’ve come to know is that is those that hardly own any nice watches or those that only buy Rolex crap on almost every other watch brand

    • @RabbitWatchShop
      @RabbitWatchShop 29 дней назад +2

      @ true lol.

    • @SIZZO76
      @SIZZO76 29 дней назад

      TUDOR is trash 🗑️

    • @SIZZO76
      @SIZZO76 29 дней назад

      @@hammalamiri12TUDOR FANBOY SPOTTED 😂😂😂

    • @RabbitWatchShop
      @RabbitWatchShop 29 дней назад +5

      @@SIZZO76 oh look, it’s the Tudor troll again. Every Tudor video. Every single time. Hope life is treating you well, bud.

  • @bikinglemur7738
    @bikinglemur7738 27 дней назад

    The Black Bay as a line is a submariner homage with vintage flair. Between the gilt / fauxtina and use of colors I think this works really nicely as it isn't too close to the sub, but this watch strips away many of those degrees of difference. I think of this as a modern inspired take on a watch that's just a vintage inspired take on a modern watch, i.e. this doesn't really make sense and comes off as a "poor man's rolex" (something I wouldn't say about most of Tudor's other watches)
    Also, I agree with you it's a bit bland. I think this could appeal to buyers who want a single high quality watch, but as someone who has a decent collection I prefer variety & intrigue over versatility

  • @kp1zza
    @kp1zza 20 дней назад

    Did you find yourself missing the date?

  • @angetassou166
    @angetassou166 29 дней назад

    Je te l'aurai bien acheter mais je suis en France, du coup , c'est mort! Je vais donc acheter Sea Master :) je cherche le meilleur site en Europe , on m'a dit qu'on arrivait à avoir 30% ?

  • @AW-wm9bk
    @AW-wm9bk 9 дней назад

    SAME HAPPENED TO ME, I REALIZED TUDORS ARE JUST FASHION-WATCHES.... 😢

  • @ajh5407
    @ajh5407 Месяц назад +2

    Tudor makes a fantastic watch on par with the seamaster. Though I’d go with the seiko SPB453J1

    • @SIZZO76
      @SIZZO76 29 дней назад

      STOP IT😂😂😂😂 TUDOR IS NOWHERE NEAR THE LEVEL OF A OMEGA SEAMASTER 😂😂😂😂

  • @kevinr206
    @kevinr206 29 дней назад

    The strap options are off. Three link without rivets, or fitted rubber like a seamaster would be better.

  • @hellodetective4862
    @hellodetective4862 Месяц назад

    Bringing back mm300? Hehehee

  • @maitrehg
    @maitrehg 24 дня назад

    Best watch of 2024. By a mile. Flippers are 🤡

  • @splootan
    @splootan 29 дней назад +2

    Do you even dive...

  • @anthonystevens8683
    @anthonystevens8683 Месяц назад

    There are many great watches out there today and the Monochrome is one of the best releases in recent times although I think the lollipop seconds hand doesn't quite work with the hour hand snowflake, it was better before in my humble opinion. If I didn't have a dive watch (or more) in my collection it could be right there on my list but like you I already have watches that occupy this space so a purchase in the near term for me is unlikely. My SMP300M, BB58 along with my Pelagos LHD can sleep well. As always many thanks for sharing.

  • @jaredmatthews9403
    @jaredmatthews9403 Месяц назад

    Great vid as usual. Sell me your 5 link.

  • @KingABVII
    @KingABVII Месяц назад

    Id of bought this if it had a ceramic bezel

  • @gavinwhite9743
    @gavinwhite9743 Месяц назад +3

    The movement hasn’t changed. It’s just been tested. Can’t help but feel you should just buy a submariner.

    • @SIZZO76
      @SIZZO76 29 дней назад +1

      I agree

  • @jaredmatthews9403
    @jaredmatthews9403 Месяц назад

    The deep sea is the best

  • @genclikonboard
    @genclikonboard 29 дней назад

    Wow! What happened to your voice? Seamaster is too big for wrists smaller than 17" imho. And Tudor is too hyped.

  • @facetiousmonkey5322
    @facetiousmonkey5322 29 дней назад +8

    I feel this monochrome BB41 exists solely because the average watch customer cannot just walk into a Rolex dealer and walk out the door with a brand new Submariner. At least the Omega has it’s own identity

    • @drkesrf
      @drkesrf 29 дней назад +1

      You can’t criticize tudor for having identity ties to rolex given they are sister companies. That’s the entire point

    • @Ferien7
      @Ferien7 28 дней назад

      @@drkesrfstill a knockoff

    • @drkesrf
      @drkesrf 28 дней назад

      @@Ferien7 i hope you are a rolex owner and not some broke punk talking smack on a brand that costs thousands of dollars

  • @tomislavm2873
    @tomislavm2873 Месяц назад

    You are the best in busIness.

    • @thewatchidiot
      @thewatchidiot  Месяц назад +1

      You're far too kind!! Glad to hear your enjoying the channel I'll do my best to keep it up😁

  • @lickerishtuna6449
    @lickerishtuna6449 Месяц назад +1

    I think next year we will see a blue dial and blue bezel. That will be the one to get because the blue is associated more strongly with Tudor. You will never see a blue dial blue bezel submariner.

    • @omarion07
      @omarion07 29 дней назад

      Have you heard of the Smurf my man?

    • @lickerishtuna6449
      @lickerishtuna6449 29 дней назад

      White gold though and not stainless steel

  • @csarcpab
    @csarcpab 28 дней назад

    The Pelagos is the only Tudor line worth your money. BB is overrated.

  • @byrontaylor2236
    @byrontaylor2236 Месяц назад

    Yaaawn😂

    • @thewatchidiot
      @thewatchidiot  Месяц назад +2

      Yeah changing the clocks is messing with my sleep schedule too😄

    • @byrontaylor2236
      @byrontaylor2236 Месяц назад +2

      No offense friend, have become exhausted with the tudor hype. Nap time 💤

  • @Ryuu92i
    @Ryuu92i 29 дней назад

    The SMP is very distinct from the submariner and the tudor and thats why its so appealing because its unique
    The tudor is a slimmer submariner with a dress (jubilee like bracelet) as the maxi case of the sub does not allow it to have a jubilee (looking like The Rock wearing high heels)
    If we get the Tudor in the 3 link its basically a less classy submariner which will always leave a taste of frustration
    Imo, the 5 link is the only option for it and if you dont like it, better move to SMP (in rubber) or sub (oyster) that will fit respectively better than the Tudor
    Owner of the 5 link tudor and loving it so far

  • @ronintheamazon1492
    @ronintheamazon1492 Месяц назад

    A date only watch that is 13.5mm thick? No thanks. The new bb58 gmt is under 13mm thick and metas certified + 100m water resistance and has a domed sapphire. No reason the tudor shouldn’t be under 12.5mm thick outside of laziness.

    • @davidiglesiasgomez7616
      @davidiglesiasgomez7616 29 дней назад

      For me a tool watch has to be thick, I want wrist presence. That’s why I sold one of my grials right after got it, the Omega 2264.50.

  • @user-iz9co4qf6z
    @user-iz9co4qf6z 29 дней назад

    How to make the Blandbay monochrome more bland? Put it on a 3 link brushed bracelet

  • @jh-il5sb
    @jh-il5sb Месяц назад +6

    i believe the people who get the tudor monochrome secretly want a sub no-date and eventually loose interest in the tudor

    • @thewatchidiot
      @thewatchidiot  Месяц назад +5

      Or it could be that they secretly want an SMP the way I did😅

    • @jh-il5sb
      @jh-il5sb Месяц назад +1

      @thewatchidiot nice try.......but too dissimilar!! Although as someone who never liked the modern SMP, your latest review has got me intersted in the black dial one.

    • @mickeylickey123
      @mickeylickey123 Месяц назад +1

      I concur. Just save up for the sub. Tudor will never scratch that itch

    • @franco2739
      @franco2739 Месяц назад

      ​The GMT did it for me. Although I actually use my GMT for travel so not sure if I would travel with the Rolex Pepsi. ​@@mickeylickey123

    • @H_tudor
      @H_tudor Месяц назад +2

      For me it was exactly the other way around

  • @CaptChaos1964
    @CaptChaos1964 Месяц назад +1

    Warp factor depreciation on Tudor watches,,I like this one, leave it 2,years and get one for half the price.

  • @CACOPHONIE
    @CACOPHONIE Месяц назад

    On a jubilee it just looks funny.

  • @artemkg2345
    @artemkg2345 25 дней назад

    It's a matter of taste, but apart from the movement, there is nothing attractive about this watch. Longines can offer a level higher quality of workmanship and visual aesthetic, and no less reliable movement for less money.

  • @mickeylickey123
    @mickeylickey123 Месяц назад +2

    Tudor just doesn't do it for me anymore. Had a few and they are missing something. Not sure what but i lose interest fast.

  • @beerkegaard
    @beerkegaard Месяц назад +37

    Not a fan of Tudor. They’re less impressive in person than they are on camera to me.

    • @jaredstephenson6468
      @jaredstephenson6468 Месяц назад +18

      Crazy. I find them so much more appealing than Omega or Rolex designs.

    • @vianouche1
      @vianouche1 Месяц назад

      @@jaredstephenson6468That is because you watch too much youtube videos

    • @hubertuswolfthaler
      @hubertuswolfthaler Месяц назад +8

      True, it's literally the only brand where the watches seemed less impressive to me in person; even Seikos look far nicer in real life than in pictures, but not Tudors.

    • @saneepeopleonly
      @saneepeopleonly Месяц назад +4

      I agree. I still have the BB58 blue from 2020 and don't wear it. I gave my BB58 sliver to my cousin a couple of years ago and don't miss at all. Having said that, one of my treasured watches is my Tudor Sub 75190. Still haven't found a modern Tudor sub that impresses me as much.

    • @RabbitWatchShop
      @RabbitWatchShop Месяц назад +13

      They’re more impressive in person than they are on camera to me 😊

  • @javiercandia3823
    @javiercandia3823 29 дней назад

    I just feel like it's too much of a No date submariner wannabe

  • @weezkidtube
    @weezkidtube 29 дней назад

    You decided the by the watch. It's inanimate. Move on.

  • @drkesrf
    @drkesrf 29 дней назад +1

    The BB54 is essentially the only tudor i like. The rest are too bulbous and bulky even tho are rebust

  • @Beck-Stein
    @Beck-Stein 14 дней назад

    Tudor watches are boring in general. Same looking design

  • @mutawi3i
    @mutawi3i 29 дней назад

    Seiko 5 is a superior watch for the money

  • @derekbrettell8121
    @derekbrettell8121 Месяц назад +2

    Here's a tip...stop buying homage Tudor watches and buy a Rolex Submariner. Then stop buying divers from other brands because you have the best one. You'll be able to move on with your life

    • @saneepeopleonly
      @saneepeopleonly Месяц назад +1

      I kind of agree. Here's a similar but somewhat opposite approach: For me, after I got my 14050M, I felt liberated to buy other watches that I considered more fun, which is also moving on with my life. :)

    • @derekbrettell8121
      @derekbrettell8121 Месяц назад +1

      @saneepeopleonly that's fair. He needs to stop kidding himself on and tick the Submariner box though. Then he can move on and stop messing about with Tudor

    • @MylleZ
      @MylleZ Месяц назад

      Thinking Rolex is the pinnacle of watchmaking 😂
      You’re just scratching the surface…

    • @derekbrettell8121
      @derekbrettell8121 Месяц назад +2

      @MylleZ nobody said that Rolex were the pinnacle of watchmaking. I was merely stating that the Tudor knock off of a Submariner is not going to scratch the itch. Better getting the real thing

    • @SIZZO76
      @SIZZO76 29 дней назад

      I agree 😂

  • @user-iz9co4qf6z
    @user-iz9co4qf6z 29 дней назад

    The Tudor Blandbay 😂