They've duped a FAVORITE high end eyeshadow palette!
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 3 окт 2024
- Hey guys! Today I am testing out the new Alter Ego Harmony eyeshadow palette- a supposed dupe for the Natasha Denona Retro palette. I have LOVED the retro palette since it was released- it is definitely one of the best berry toned palettes I've ever tried! But can this affordable option compare? I hope you enjoy this one! Thanks for stopping by!
o o x x o o X o X X x
Mandy
__________________
On Me:
*some links are affiliates
Alter Ego Harmony palette: shopalterego.com/
Natasha Denona Retro palette: go.magik.ly/ml...
Milani Conceal & Perfect foundation in Vanilla: go.magik.ly/ml...
Milani Conceal & Perfect concealer: go.magik.ly/ml...
LA Girl Intense Wear lip liner in Nonstop Nude: go.magik.ly/ml...
Tower 28 mascara: www.sephora.co...
MAC Glow Play blush in Blush Please: go.magik.ly/ml...
Flower Beauty bronzer: go.magik.ly/ml...
Revlon Skin Lights highlighter in Daybreak: go.magik.ly/ml...
Ulta Beauty Ultra Slim brow pencil: go.magik.ly/ml...
I honestly don’t understand why you don’t have a million subscribers. You are so thorough in your reviews and tutorials and one of the best influencers out there in my opinion. There aren’t many people out there doing true tutorials anymore and they are very helpful. You do so many wearable looks using colors that would typically be very intimidating. You have also introduced me to so many brands I’ve never heard of or tried before, especially K-beauty from YesStyle.
I agree! She will def have a million one day. Reminds me of Emily Noel - kind, drama free with thorough and trustworthy reviews.
KS Corbitt, it's because this channel is only 4 years old in the day and age of Instagram, TikTok and others. Others for you to check out:Jen Phelps is a master of finding dupes of all types of cosmetics. Sounds like you'd really enjoy the following: Shelby Wilson (MUA), Angela Bright (eyes), Smitha Deepak (eyes), Haley Kim (no-makeup makeup), Dominique Sachse (big makeup mistakes-excellent), Glam Gil Gabi (hair expert), You may enjoy these Make Up Artists: Lisa Eldridge, Wayne Goss, Hung Vanngo (the best), Alexandra Anele, Ali Andrea, Allie Glines, Taylor Wynn, Nikki La Rose.
@@violetviolet888 I follow many that you mentioned. Do I have a type??
I looooovvvveee Alter Ego's paletts!
I bought it to celebrate 25 lbs lost! Alter Ego is one of the very best dupe eyeshadow companies 🎉
wow congrats to you? Bought the ND or AE one?
@@amysmithssportsandmakeup1397 AE. I’ll NEVER pay ND prices. 🤷🏻♀️
I don't think you can see a difference but when I bought an ND palette and Alter Ego I think it was the GOLD palette I noticed the biggest difference in wear test. The Alter Ego never stayed on as long as ND and ND was smoother and just looked wonderful at the end of the day. the Alter Ego was indeed beautiful but wore off, smudged etc... so I stopped buying them and just bought the real thing and I am not a makeup snob I don't think but working 2 jobs getting up at 4am and not going to bed until 10pm I need that eyeshadow on all day I never reapply. Thank you for the great review!
Mileva, skin prep, such as primer, mixing with concealer, wetting, and setting spray can also make a huge difference with the dupes. Really setting spray may be all you need.
@@violetviolet888 I do all of the at yes. Still the higher end shadows last longer. I always try the dupe honest lol
Same!! ND eyeshadows last me all day long.
@@amomentwithmileva yes
Yes I have heard the same thing about the alter ego
The Alter Ego is lighter and brighter, especially in the pink tone. I like the ND color better but for the price dif I would still get AE.
Mine should arrive today and I can’t wait!!
Stunning!
I LOVE Alter Ego pallettes. I too ordered the Harmony pallette. It's so nice to have a company that can make dupes for pallettes I just can't afford.
I ordered the Harmony palette the minute it popped up on the site. The Shadow Kiss palette is my all time favorite palette.
I’ve been wanting to try alter ego are they good? I know c color cosmetics is really good but I haven’t tried alter ego. C color duped the jeffree star blue palette and they nailed it. Those deep blues were on point there was just one shade that they didn’t nail and that was the deep blue metalic. I was really pleased. I also loved their clover dupe it even came in a cute “too faced” style tin.
Mandy, I just adore your looks n videos Ty🎉.. still havent grabbed the retro...now i may just grab the harmony OR wait for a big ND sale
Wow, that is amazing. And the price difference incredible. You create the most detailed looks and show me tutorials that are so in depth with and very easy to follow as you go.. The final look was simply stunning and honestly I could not tell the difference. Thanks for sharing your amazing dupe. I 💕 the sweater top you had on as well. 👍❣️🎃🧡🤎💛💚🎃💕❗💯
I LOVE the Retro pallet and use it about once a week.
I have three Alter Ego pallets and love them all. Great formula.
You look beautiful.
I went to use mine today and every color I touched with a brush hard panned!
Thank you for doing this video, it was so helpful!
I love both looks, just my opinion
But I would rather get the ND pallet
Just for pigmentation. It seems easier
To me. Thank you 💞💞
Me too !
Me too! I also seriously cannot support a brand that steals ideas from another brand and everyone seems to legitimise the theft of ND’s original work because she’s a bigger brand.
Weren’t these all the same people that supported an obscure brand that claimed ND stole their primer idea, even though the products looked nothing alike?
I will never support this brand. I’m fine with somewhat similar color stories, but this is actual copycat in my opinion.
I would rather buy ND, who has one of the best formulas in the market than invest in a morally bankrupt brand.
@@mykitm7104 same..I feel they same sentiment...they are just copycats with way cheaper ingredients but understand why people go for alter ego because of costs
@@KaliKali-hv9bt I understand too, I just think it’s horrible brand to support.
Wow! Gorgeous 🤩 I can’t tell the difference. Love the side by side comparison!
Jen Phelps just posted her comparison video; great minds think alike! She too thought the Alter Ego is the way to go! Mandy, you're on the cutting edge again! Thanks for your energy!
I love that they both used the same palette and came up with completely different looks with lots of feedback on the colors in the palette.
Just watched Jen Phelps video about this palette. I am definitely buying it based on both of ur reviews!!
Hi MandyLea. New subscriber here. Enjoying your videos. You are so pretty and I love your curls. My hair is thick and full and I always get compliments, but I've always wanted curly hair. 😀
You and Jen Phelps just posted this at the same time! I just watched hers now I'm watching yours.
I had to have the original ND for this one because of the color story but if they dupe the upcoming green retro I’ll wait for their dupe.
Do yourself a favor and try Goose Creek Candles. They blow b&bw candles out of the water and have great sales all the time! Also, after slipping on ice and shattering my knee 2 yrs ago, my go to boot for winter is now a pair of Merrell winter hiking boots with ice proof soles(I now have ptsd whenever I have to walk over any ice patches) so they really help with that
You just settled something for me. I've been debating between the ND Dream and Huda Empowered for my Christmas list, but I think I am going to patiently instead. I already own the Retro or I would be picking the Alter Ego version up.
So pretty 😍
Excited to see a new video on the Retro plette❤❤ I'm considering buying the Retro but only on discount
I'm just medium neutral-warm tone NC35 and hope it looks good on me like it does you
Great video 💙💛❤💚💜
Hi Mandy! You look just plain beautiful today! I could not tell a dif between the pallets once you had them on. I have never used Alter Ego but that may change soon. 😊
Have a great week!
I have been patiently waiting for this dupe palette from Alter Ego and I ordered it right away! I'm even more excited about it after watching your video Mandy! I actually like that the Alter Ego palettes are not as pigmented because I'm not that great at applying and blending eyeshadow.
I just bought the Alter Ego palette. Love their dupes!
Beautiful look. Thanks for sharing your thoughts and swatches of these two palettes
thank you for confirming that the Alter Ego was duping the retro pallette. I suspected as much, but needed to hear someone confirm it. i loved seeing the comparisons. thanks Mandy!!
Yeah! Your outros are back!
Wow, this was an amazing video, thank you for doing this!!!! I absolutely love ND but gosh the $$$$!!!! Thank you for the dupe!
Absolutely gorgeous!
I knew i could count on you for this video! And you did such a pretty look - thank you! 👍🧡👍🧡
Looks great...I missed which side was which and I cannot tell a difference with end results!
I noticed more differences in this Alter Ego palette and the ND original compared to their other palettes. I own the bronze dupe and the glam dupe as well as the ND palettes, and they are so similar they made me regret spending my money on the ND's!
Ooh I’ve been considering buying the glam, so maybe I should buy the AE version.
@@TheJalebe73it is excellent quality and the shades are pretty much identical. I don't think you'll be disappointed! ❤️
Looks beautiful and it's good to know we can get a palette for cheaper and Looks the same as the expensive one ❤️
Really enjoyed this!😊
Next time would you please include the links for the brushes? Thanks! 😘
I never thought of putting eyeshadow in the under eye unusually just put a pencil ✏️ eye pencil. I will
Try that. Incredible and the price wow impressive
Karrina, eyeliner on the bottom is aging. Softer blended shadow as a liner has been in the last several years.
The top!!! Oh crap I got it wrong
I think the colors in Alter ego palette are not as rich and nuanced as ND's Retro. But its nice that we have more choices, right ? :)
Wow! I’m surprised at the beautiful look you can get from both palettes! Oh m hitting pan on my Retro palette, was thinking I needed to buy another. Maybe I’ll just get the dupe!
It looks the same now - but how does it look after 6-8 hours? That is where quality shows.
I disagree about the colors between the Retro Palette and the Harmony Palette. I think that there is more than just a minor difference. The ND palette is more purple whereas the Harmony is more red based and the intensity and smoothness is nowhere near the ND one even with the layering.
I completely agree.
I've been waiting for this! :)
I noticed you are using Sydney grace brushes more and more. Are they kind of replacing your rephr brushes in many cases?
This was a beautiful look. Love that you show alternative dupes. I feel $69.00 is to much for this size palette. Thank you.
Would it be possible to see more high end pallettes that Alter Ego has duped? I've loved the Sigma pallettes for years, but have never pulled the trigger on buying them due to the price. I've just recently subscribed to your channel and I'll look back on your videos to see if you have more like this. 👍
Mandy has posted the Alter Ego dupes with high end. The last one came out over a year ago July which was Glam palette dupe. Have to look back from there to see other vids 🤗
Ironically Fit, Jen Phelps is a dupe expert if you have anything you've been looking for and want to save money.
ordered the alter ego pallet. also have the shadow kiss
Also where's Alter ego palette made?
Can you link the first shadow brush you used, please?
I'm curious how the Alter Ego formula last throughout a full day's of wear since you described the feeling of their "cream to powder" differently than ND? I always wonder because all of the videos I've seen of these almost dupes from you you've never shown the wear at the end of a video...
What lipstick are you wearing? It is so lovely on you!
I also do wish the comparison swatches were inserted as b roll footage really zoomed in. Could barely see
Agreed 💯 and the lighting is way too bright; washes the color out.
You can definitely see the difference between ND and Alter Ego. I have Retro and she is absolutely stunning.
I also literally hate this brand. It’s literally a brand that copy cats another, it’s plagiarism.
MyKit M, dupes are extremely helpful for those of us putting money in a retirement account.
@@violetviolet888 I said it several times already, I have no issues with dupes, this is not a dupe.
This is not duping the vibe, like colorpop creating a similar palette. This is not like saying pastel palette and BH Lost in LA are dupes.
This is plagiarism. The brand exists only to steal another brand’s ideas and work. That’s it.
Make of it what you will.
@@mykitm7104 I have a degree in design and am a professional designer. I have had my ideas "stolen". If your ideas are in the public realm and they're good, they will be "stolen". In this case they are color stories. There is no way around it unless you spend lots of money to protect it.
@@violetviolet888 Just because people steal, doesn’t mean we should legitimise it, does it?
@@mykitm7104 It's a reality, if you find a way to change the institutionalized systems that enable it, let me know when you've succeeded.
Love the brand I wish they would go back to magnet palette like they had before cause that gave you the versatility of moving it around and making your own color stories especially now that they have such a great formula I would totally wish I could just take them out and put them all in my own little palette
Tonya Sullivan, you can take a hair dryer, warm the glue and pop them out, then put them in a magnetic palette.
I dont understand how you do it. You use a big brush in the outer corner of the eye and move it in circles. Yet the eye shadow forms a V. When I do that it gets blurry and all over the place. Definitely no V here!
My question would be is do they wear the same…?
Earlier this year i purchased an alter ego pallette. No nuance and poor wear time. I definitely don't get the buzz about them.
@@lilcajunqueen888 thank you
❤️❤️❤️
$52 is.not a subtle difference.... it is massive. Especially when they look so much alike.
❤️
Does anyone know if Alter Ego has magnetic pans that can be depotted?
Nd on the top? Wrong! I thought the first pink was too Barbie for ND. Lol!
I love Alter Ego, as a vegan makeup lover, and I was SO excited when this dropped and bought it right away! It didn’t even occur to me to check the ingredients list, since all their other palettes are vegan, so when I did check and found Carmine, I was DEVASTATED! I don’t understand why they would choose to add Carmine when their entire previous line had been vegan! 😩 I’m heart broken and will be returning it once I receive it. A warning to all you fellow vegan makeup lovers out there excited for a vegan retro dupe: this is NOT VEGAN! 💔😥
One last thing can you please say the names? They’re right on the palettes clearly but you say “this shade” instead of saying the name which is more helpful
You need to go back and re-watch the video honey. She said every single shade name 😂
Mandy is saying names of shadows.
Sevyn Calhoun: Re-watch. She does.
I feel like dupe palettes and products are like plagiarism or fake artwork or something. It should not be legal to take someone else's creative ideas and work basically for financial gain. I understand not everyone wants to buy Natasha Denona or can or whatever but idk, it seems shady af. Alter ego should be shut down. Clearly you purchase or get pr from both companies it's not like you're personally choosing alter ego over Natasha Denona or something I just think it's shitty to steal other people's work for financial gain.
Thank you!! Finally someone else saying the same thing that I did.
Too much palette content..I stopped watching..