Lyrics: How can I repay you, brother mine? How can I expect you to forgive? Clinging to the past, I shed our blood And shattered your chance to live Though I knew the laws, I paid no heed How can I return your wasted breath? What I didn't know has cost you dear; For there is no cure for death Beautiful mother, soft and sweet Once you were gone we were not complete Back through the years we reached for you Alas, it was not to be And how can I make amends For all that I took from you? I led you with hopeless dreams My brother, I was a fool Don't cry for the past now, brother mine Neither you nor I are free of blame Nothing can erase the things we did For the path we took was the same How could I expect to call you wrong? How could you be blamed for what we've done? Both of us were fools in our desires As we flew too close to the sun Beautiful mother, soft and sweet Once you were gone we were not complete Back through the years we reached for you Alas, it was not to be My dreams made me blind and mute I longed to return to that time I followed without a word My brother, the fault is mine So where do we go from here? And how to forget and forgive? What's gone is forever lost Now all we can do is live...
So why does Vic leave this one verse out in his version? I still don't really get that. How could I expect to call you wrong? How could you be blamed for what we've done? Both of us were fools in our desires As we flew too close to the sun
I still go back to this cover from time to time. Your voice is so soft and gentle and it suits the song so well.. translation is also great Marvelous cover
At first I thought this was real until I realized it was all done by you! I’m so shocked by the fact that it’s so perfect and that it fits so well! This deserves more love and likes because THIS is talent here.
Fullmetal Alchemist are probably the saddest anime I've ever seen the brother's backstory is just too perfect and I felt a connection to these characters more resonant than any before.
Just found this version, and it's by far my favorite version! Unfortunately it's not on Spotify/Soundcloud, so i can't add it to my favorite songs. But all in all i really love this cover and keep singing in the future, because it would be a wasted talent if you didn't.
Charmie Sweets On the part that goes: How can I expect to call you wrong? How can you be blamed for what we've done? Both of us were fools in our desires As we flew too close to the sun Why doesn't Vic sing that part in his version? Was it just cut out of the song or something? I'm confused. You have a great voice though, btw. :)
I think since Brothers is meant to be a duet between both Ed and Al maybe Vic thought the song would sound strange in the absense of Aaron Dismuke (the voice of Al) because he didn't want to sing for this song. So maybe Vic thought Ed singing Al's part wouldn't sound right so maybe that's why it was cut.
+Jason Yang i think the "just Fullmetal Alchemist" is much better than the Brotherhood :D (sorry for my horrible english, im dont speak english so much :) )
As native speaker of russan and a bit speaking english, can say two things: voice are good, but translation (adaptation) of lyrics very weak. Depth of original missing. But thanks, that was good.
(OOC) Alas is an expression of grief, pity, or concern. So, in the context of the song, “But alas ‘twas not to be”, is basically an expression that signifies Ed grieving about his mistake and his mothers death. I hope this answers your question.
![Noob To Max With DRAGON REWORK In Blox Fruits [FULL MOVIE]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/LnBMOinoOvA/mqdefault.jpg)
Lyrics:
How can I repay you, brother mine?
How can I expect you to forgive?
Clinging to the past, I shed our blood
And shattered your chance to live
Though I knew the laws, I paid no heed
How can I return your wasted breath?
What I didn't know has cost you dear;
For there is no cure for death
Beautiful mother, soft and sweet
Once you were gone we were not complete
Back through the years we reached for you
Alas, it was not to be
And how can I make amends
For all that I took from you?
I led you with hopeless dreams
My brother, I was a fool
Don't cry for the past now, brother mine
Neither you nor I are free of blame
Nothing can erase the things we did
For the path we took was the same
How could I expect to call you wrong?
How could you be blamed for what we've done?
Both of us were fools in our desires
As we flew too close to the sun
Beautiful mother, soft and sweet
Once you were gone we were not complete
Back through the years we reached for you
Alas, it was not to be
My dreams made me blind and mute
I longed to return to that time
I followed without a word
My brother, the fault is mine
So where do we go from here?
And how to forget and forgive?
What's gone is forever lost
Now all we can do is live...
So why does Vic leave this one verse out in his version? I still don't really get that.
How could I expect to call you wrong?
How could you be blamed for what we've done?
Both of us were fools in our desires
As we flew too close to the sun
@@SuperBloodredmoon I was asking myself the same question. Maybe he didn't get satisfied with the final result and cropped the part out.
@@_lefabb Oh. That would have been cool if he had included it though.
Thanks
@@SuperBloodredmoon swore, I heard him say it.
Every note came so naturally and I heard no struggle for any of the low or high notes which made it so beautiful. Good job, really!
I still go back to this cover from time to time. Your voice is so soft and gentle and it suits the song so well.. translation is also great
Marvelous cover
i love this cover. your voice is so soothing, i promise i've listened to this at least 100 times in the last week, haha.
This is My Voice Goals, I swear. How can you sing like that? You're amazing
aawwwww omigosh thank you very much!!
I love singing! I hope you achieve all ur singing goals!!! it's so much fun :)
The perfect cover doesn't exi-
how can this only have barely 30k views ? its the best cover i heared so far from this song
At first I thought this was real until I realized it was all done by you! I’m so shocked by the fact that it’s so perfect and that it fits so well! This deserves more love and likes because THIS is talent here.
This is the most beautiful cover of any song I’ve ever heard, you did it perfectly
Fullmetal Alchemist are probably the saddest anime I've ever seen the brother's backstory is just too perfect and I felt a connection to these characters more resonant than any before.
Best. Cover. EVER! Your voice is so great it shows emotion and sadness
@jhechtf I've added one at the end of the description! Please enjoy!! ^___^
You made me cry just how beautiful this is!! Your voice is an angle
which angle?
+razorXgames _Acute angle.-_
+ѕaιтoυ мaѕaнιro (先輩) woah
+ѕaιтoυ мaѕaнιro (先輩) Clever baka.
Your voice is so fucking awesome!!! So perfectly, so beautiful! Is so much forma my!!! I really want to hear you and Vic Mignogna singing this!!
Genuinely this is for me, the only English cover that I adore, and come back to hear. The voice, lyrics, the melody are just beautiful.
Just finished the 2003 anime. Was nice to come back to this song and reflect on everything that happened.
Welp....
Im now subscribing this made me cry your voice is soft and so graceful❤💕
this is without the best cover on this track I have ever heard of in my life! Thanks for making my night much better (:
Oh hello tears '-'
i just start crying.. your song is just.. angelic...
Ur voice is so beautiful!! This cover make me calm! This is the best song I heard of FMA!! Keep up the good work!!
Just found this version, and it's by far my favorite version! Unfortunately it's not on Spotify/Soundcloud, so i can't add it to my favorite songs. But all in all i really love this cover and keep singing in the future, because it would be a wasted talent if you didn't.
Very inspiring. Thank you for such a masterful piece of art
Simplemente hermoso😢😍😍.
Amo tu voz. Esta es mi versión favorita hasta ahora. Bello.
omg this is so beautiful💕💕I love your voice👑✨
Dang this is so good, I keep listening to this and I never get sick of it.
I eventually remembered why I always loved this song T_T oh hello tears been awhile
This is so fucking underrated. Holy shit, why this is not even 100k views is beyond me.
You have an angels voice dear singer
this is phenomenal.... your voice is beautiful. keep it up!
finally, I can hear those few lost lines from Al's part of the song. THANK YOU
It’s very rare for me to cry to a song. This hit hard.
THE BEST COVER IVE HEARD OF THIS SONG
-love it~-
Ed...ward... nii... san...
*I'm* not crying, *you're* crying! 😭😭😭😭
Your voice is beautiful ❤
this was beautiful
U sing this so beautifully!
so beautiful ☺️ my favourite song well sung
Id love to download this version
omg so awsome charmie i loved it
perfect
This deserves more views
Oh my gosh, what instrumental version did you use for this cover?:D It's beautiful! Does it have a link? If so, please put it in the description^^
Love this song
best cover ever
she has a cool voice and I love song
It's nice to relax and experience nostalgia .
Also the comments section was kinda dead so just posting a fresh one lol.
This song always remember my mom
Beautiful cover
3:52 😢😢 Love it
se que no entiendes lo que digo pero cantas precioso es la voz mas hermosa que eh oído en mi vida ^^
Put this on Spotify please, i beg you 🥺😄
Only version of Bratja I can find on Spotify is a violin cover. I mean it's beautiful but I want the lyrical version too, both Russian and English
Charmie Sweets On the part that goes:
How can I expect to call you wrong?
How can you be blamed for what we've done?
Both of us were fools in our desires
As we flew too close to the sun
Why doesn't Vic sing that part in his version? Was it just cut out of the song or something? I'm confused. You have a great voice though, btw. :)
I think since Brothers is meant to be a duet between both Ed and Al maybe Vic thought the song would sound strange in the absense of Aaron Dismuke (the voice of Al) because he didn't want to sing for this song. So maybe Vic thought Ed singing Al's part wouldn't sound right so maybe that's why it was cut.
@@teaffeeblend Oh
Your's voice is sooo awesome
This is really good.
OMG, love it sooooo much :,,-)
Amazing.
Pero que hermoso tema
It's going to rain.
Ого, очень красиво!
Great job.
Angelic
this song makes me cry! i dont even have a brother
:'(
FUKING AMAZING 😍😍
You are amazing
I Love It!!!!! : D
ahhahh... For Vic.. My brother
This reminds meof pelleks you were there cover
lend me your voice please.
From brotherhood or just fullmetal alchemist? Thx ^^ and good cover ;u;
just Fullmetal Alchemist :)
the only one i watched haven't watched brotherhood yet. Thx :D
+Jason Yang i think the "just Fullmetal Alchemist" is much better than the Brotherhood :D (sorry for my horrible english, im dont speak english so much :) )
Nah fam.
Brotherhood is beyond Fma
Brotherhood had a very rushed start which wasn't nearly as good as the original but it had a way better and more satisfying ending.
As native speaker of russan and a bit speaking english, can say two things: voice are good, but translation (adaptation) of lyrics very weak. Depth of original missing.
But thanks, that was good.
it's not her lyrics
@mish098aimer true
I liked the other one too can you please send that to me?
What's "Alas" meaning? Anyone pls
(OOC)
Alas is an expression of grief, pity, or concern. So, in the context of the song, “But alas ‘twas not to be”, is basically an expression that signifies Ed grieving about his mistake and his mothers death. I hope this answers your question.
Lyrics?
MP3. want
x d
ruclips.net/video/C6vRnEO_a1E/видео.html ojala te guste
Not gonna lie, I hate the rhyming scheme. Otherwise a really nice cover!