Electric Car vs Petrol Car Financially ఏది కొనడం Better ? | EV vs Petrol

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 6 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 113

  • @familymantelugu
    @familymantelugu  2 месяца назад +2

    If you liked my analysis about buying an Electric Car, You should watch my other video 10 LESSONS LEARNT FROM OWNING MY CAR FOR 10 YEARS - ruclips.net/video/binqW-WEmpQ/видео.html

    • @sethuraj2850
      @sethuraj2850 18 дней назад

      @familymantelugu It would be great if the Petrol price won't change for the next 8 yrs. Also fuel efficiency of ICE engine goes down and fuel price goes up You haven't factored it. Also, MOVING parts....more that double the EV in ICE vehicles. Partial replacement of the battery is not that expensive compared to Transmission replacement in ICE...Also, batteries won't decide to die after 8 yrs. If warranty is the deal you are looking into...8 yrs for battery warranty. How much warranty do you get ICE transmission?

  • @sunilrajpaul1182
    @sunilrajpaul1182 10 часов назад

    Brother! What about insurance costs and cost for accident issues for both types of cars and its benifits ?

  • @Vamsi1988
    @Vamsi1988 Месяц назад +3

    Currently iam using MG ZS EV 2022 bought. Ippati varaku I travelled 38000 kms in 2 years na monthly average min 1800 kms untundi though na car price ekkuva ayna iam enjoying benefit of instant pickup and automatic features. If your daily is usage is more than 50kms u can go with electric cars. And if you want to own secondary car take smaller EV cars within budget of 12 lakhs.

    • @familymantelugu
      @familymantelugu  Месяц назад

      Vamsi garu nice andi, meru ekkuvagane vadtunnaru melanti vallaki electric car is a smart choice.

  • @varaprasadprasad8563
    @varaprasadprasad8563 2 месяца назад +6

    first you have to compare the automatic version with EV not with base model and fuel cost will increase more than the power cost.

    • @familymantelugu
      @familymantelugu  2 месяца назад +1

      Varaprasad garu mee point lo kudaa nyaayam undi, kani dabbulu save cheyyali ani aloochinche vaallu Automatic version konaali anukoru gaa, ee video lo naa focus was mostly around saving money.
      What you mentioned is true, Electric car benefit is lower running costs and also ease of driving.

  • @BRK1961
    @BRK1961 4 дня назад

    I have been using an EV scooter for the last 2 years which proved more comfortable, economical and contributing lower pollution. I recommend you all to go for Electric vehicles.

  • @venkateswararaokodali8671
    @venkateswararaokodali8671 2 месяца назад +1

    If ur driving 50 km per day , in eight years 144000. Then engine repairs or replacement costs ?
    Tata punch Ev warranty is 160000 km. Check and evaluate properly?

    • @familymantelugu
      @familymantelugu  2 месяца назад

      Hi Venkateswara Rao garu, general ga petrol engines15 years / 1.5 lakh kms varaku issues raavu, Still I have added 1 lakh rupees for any repairs after 8 years andi. Battery ki kuda I did not take full cost as replacement.

    • @karthikp9406
      @karthikp9406 Месяц назад

      ​@@familymanteluguwhat about service cost? Engine oil, clutch issues,?

    • @karthikp9406
      @karthikp9406 Месяц назад

      అట్లా అడుగు!! 👍

  • @srinivas1912
    @srinivas1912 2 месяца назад +1

    GOOD ANALYSIS SIR....YOU PROVED MY ASSUMPTIONS

    • @familymantelugu
      @familymantelugu  2 месяца назад

      Hi Srinivas garu, Ohh ayite ippudu meru mee friends tho debate strong gaa cheyyocchu, neenu kuda mee party ee.

  • @jayakumarchoudhury208
    @jayakumarchoudhury208 6 дней назад

    What about resale value?

    • @familymantelugu
      @familymantelugu  3 дня назад

      Resale value gurinchi eppatlo cheppadam kastamey.

  • @sunilpaladugu1489
    @sunilpaladugu1489 2 месяца назад

    Excellent analysis sir ! Thank you very much sir

  • @venkateswararaokodali8671
    @venkateswararaokodali8671 2 месяца назад +2

    After 8 years what will happen to petrol engine? Cost ?

    • @familymantelugu
      @familymantelugu  2 месяца назад

      Hi Venkateswara Rao garu, petrol engine cars manam laread chaala years nunchi vaasutunnaamu, they generally work without any issue till 15 years / 1 lakh kms, even my car is 10 yrs old and I did not have any issues with engine andi.

    • @karthikp9406
      @karthikp9406 Месяц назад

      Engine gets issues after 8years, and battery doesn't deplete total 100%. The range will decrease but not becomes zero.

  • @jkmurthy2421
    @jkmurthy2421 Месяц назад

    Correct analysis sir

  • @anumolulalithmohan79
    @anumolulalithmohan79 13 дней назад +1

    Taxi perpose per day 200 km electric car okay na brother❤🎉

  • @gocharliegaming1041
    @gocharliegaming1041 17 дней назад +1

    sir ur comparing basic punch with long range punch there is features differance in it u need to compare mid level ICE with this EV then u get different figures

    • @familymantelugu
      @familymantelugu  16 дней назад

      Yeah correct ee, may be purchase cost lo 1 lakh difference vastundi, But please note I also did not talk about extra interest paid to bank for that extra 3 3-4 lakhs we pay for an electric car.

  • @GandlagandlaPraveenkumar
    @GandlagandlaPraveenkumar 26 дней назад

    Thank you for the information sir.please give me more information electric cars.🙏🙏🙏

  • @ramakrishnareddyavula9319
    @ramakrishnareddyavula9319 23 дня назад

    Can you give some economic comparison information between MG windsor basic & Maruti basic mild hybrid models? Which one is better?

    • @familymantelugu
      @familymantelugu  23 дня назад

      @@ramakrishnareddyavula9319 Do you have any specific maruti car in mind?

    • @ramakrishnareddyavula9319
      @ramakrishnareddyavula9319 4 дня назад

      @familymantelugu maruti grand vitara mild & strong hybrids

  • @ravikiranhrd
    @ravikiranhrd 2 месяца назад +1

    2 years తరువాత Car అమ్మేసి కొత్త car కొంటే ఏమవుతుంది? Petrol car కి resale value ఉంటుంది, but used Electric car ని ఎవ్వరూ కొనరు

    • @familymantelugu
      @familymantelugu  2 месяца назад

      Hi Ravikiran garu,
      Avunandi, 2 yrs taruvaata petrol car ni ammite resale value untundi. Electric car resale value gurinchi ippatlo cheppadam kastame, anduke neenu calculation 8 years ki vestunnaanu.

  • @akulanarayana5284
    @akulanarayana5284 26 дней назад

    Future fuel prices ???

    • @familymantelugu
      @familymantelugu  25 дней назад

      Hi Narayana garu, Fuel prices konni years ekkuvaga peragavu ani experts cheptunnaaru because of Indian Govt Agreements with crude oil supplying nations. meru observe chesi untaaru last 1.5 years nunchi petrol price pergaleedu.

  • @SuchanSchool
    @SuchanSchool 2 месяца назад

    Hi Sir, in the 2nd scenario (excel sheet) battery replacement or battery maintenance cost not included (after 8 years), am i right?

    • @familymantelugu
      @familymantelugu  2 месяца назад +1

      Avunandi, in that case, I have considered the usage for 8 years only as I can use my 8 year old car for 8 more years. you can download the sheet and use it for yourself.

  • @syedanwarpasha699
    @syedanwarpasha699 2 месяца назад

    Based on your analysis, If I have 12 Lakhs in hand (instead of car loan) I prefer buying a Petrol car for 7+ lakhs, and put 5+ lakhs as Fixed Deposit for 8 years. At the end of 8 years, total petrol car costs me 16+ lakhs. Where as 8 years Fixed Deposit may yield 9+ lakhs. So, my petrol car cost will be 16 lakhs minus 9 lakhs, which is equal to 7 lakhs. The only advantage of Electric car is we save our environment at an extra cost to give better environment for our future generations. Hope you agree 🙂

    • @familymantelugu
      @familymantelugu  2 месяца назад

      Hi Syed garu,
      correct ee from point of investing money, I did not touch this aspect because most of the people go for car loan, Anyhow I have subtly mentioned the extra interest they will pay for Electric car when compared to a petrol car.
      End of the day Electric car is beneficial only for people who travel a lot.

    • @karthikp9406
      @karthikp9406 Месяц назад

      Buy a bike and invest 11L into funds!

  • @suryaraju31
    @suryaraju31 17 дней назад

    In fact, the biggest scam in India is EV cars.
    You are not calculating interest paid for that additional premium of 6 lakhs for EV... Every car buyer buys on Loan... so we are paying around Rs.6000 per month for additional EV cost of 6 lakhs .
    1) Using this Rs.6000 interest paid every month for EV, we can compensate petrol car fuel charges.
    2) Again after 7/8 years , we need to buy battery (forget about that module cost and consider full battery) so the same story repeats
    3) You never get your 6 lakhs additional cost back..and when we resell the car, the value for battery cost will be zero.
    3) EV is useful for the people who runs above 2500kms/ month only.
    4) You need to plan your journey properly due to its range is around 300kms. You need to wait in queue at charging stations (mostly at restaurants) and you will make Rs.1000 bill for your food while battery is charging.
    5) Environment: In cities it is good, the battery manufacturing process cause so much pollution in their manufacturing locations.
    5) So EV car is a BIG scam.

    • @familymantelugu
      @familymantelugu  16 дней назад

      Hi Surya garu,
      I agree with you for points 1,3,4 and 5. I respect your insights.
      Correct I did not calculate the interest paid on EMI for the example here,
      Yes that extra 6000 INR can help us drive a petrol car 750 kms / month (considering 8 rs per km)
      But for people who travel 1500 kms/ month - fuel cost will be 6000 INR more.
      For the battery replacement cost, Experts suggest that we dont need a full battery replacement, and also the warranty is for 1.5 lakh kms. But time only will tell the reality.
      Yes I also believe right now EV's are not value for money in most cases, Let us see if they become more affordable in future.

  • @chaitanyafiresafety869
    @chaitanyafiresafety869 2 месяца назад

    TQ sir

  • @aarryarun
    @aarryarun 16 дней назад

    Sir I do agree with some of ur caluclations but u r completely missing out some serious issues
    Of ICU cars
    For petrol car every three months u have to change engine oil
    Filters that will cost u around 5000-6000 per 3 months
    That alone will cost u around 192000
    What about wears tear cost cost of petrol when I bought my car in 2007 it was rs 55 now in 2024 it is 102
    From here on cost of petrol will go high

    • @familymantelugu
      @familymantelugu  16 дней назад

      Hi Arun,
      For petrol car Engine oil change is for every 6 months - 1 year or 5000 kms to 10000 kms based on the type of Engine oil used.
      Air Filters dont cost that much, Service costs for most of the cars like Maruti, Honda, Hyundai and Toyota for year ranges between 10000 inr - 20,000 inr.
      Petrol cost has definitely increased with time like all other costs ( take inflation into consideration), last 1.5 years petrol cost has stayed the same.
      but we dont really know the future and at the sametime if people buy electric cars a lot, electricity charges may also go up, we cannot completely predict.
      I agree that EV's can be really good if you drive more, I am not saying EV is not good, but you cannot say EV is good for everyone.

    • @aarryarun
      @aarryarun 15 дней назад

      @@familymantelugu yes sir
      I appreyur work
      But sir while comparing the prices of car
      U hav taken basic price of punch nd comparing it with midrange punch ev cost
      Nd over the time ev users might go up nd battery cost nd production cost might come down

    • @familymantelugu
      @familymantelugu  15 дней назад

      @@aarryarun Agree with you Arun, thank you for sharing your thoughts which can help everyone who is reading our comments.
      comments from people like you make the channel more valuable.

  • @మానాన్న
    @మానాన్న 8 дней назад

    ఎక్కువగా తిరిగే వాళ్ళకి electic కార్ most usefull.

  • @varunshashank5865
    @varunshashank5865 27 дней назад

    Electric vehicles are best, but govt policy strict undi rates ni control chese board undaali, batteries companies mida govt controling undaali, appudu middle class people kuda kontaaru, people safety priority isthu regulation body correct unte appudu baguntadi

    • @familymantelugu
      @familymantelugu  27 дней назад

      Varun garu avunandi, it will be good if Govt is able to bring down the prices of Electric cars, more people will purchase them.

  • @mohanpalisetty793
    @mohanpalisetty793 27 дней назад +1

    History vaddu. Present analysis cheppu bro.

    • @familymantelugu
      @familymantelugu  27 дней назад

      Mohan garu electric cars history gurinchi konchem cheppanu to give you an idea about future, chaala saarlu mana future man history depend ayi untundi ga anduku, meeku bore kottinchaana?

  • @gvrao7832
    @gvrao7832 2 месяца назад

    You have not touched about R & M of Electric Car at all. After all there would be many
    parts like suspension, AC system etc to mention a few which would require maintenance.
    Why R & M only for Petrol / Diesel cars.
    You need to consider R & M expenses fot Electric Cars as well after say Five years of running
    to arrive at saving aspet before the Battery's expected / Guaranteed Life.

    • @familymantelugu
      @familymantelugu  2 месяца назад

      Yes Sir, meeru cheppinattu regular maintenance neenu petrol car ki inka electric car ki untaadi kaabatti, vaati gurinchi discuss cheyyaleedu.
      But like you said, I have added 1 lakh as major repair cost for petrol cars after 8 years and 50k for electric car as a major repair cost after 8 years.
      may be equal amount kuda veyyocchemo.

  • @santhosh-wl1oo
    @santhosh-wl1oo 2 месяца назад

    Sir second hand car or first ha d car better please let me know
    Which one is better below 10lacks.?

    • @familymantelugu
      @familymantelugu  2 месяца назад +1

      Santosh garu,
      Following conditions meet ayite first hand car konandi, lekapotey go for second hand car.
      1. Daily > 30 kms.
      2. You will use your car for long trips regularly.
      Dont buy a Second hand car
      1. which is more than 5 years old.
      2. Get the car thoroughly checked.
      If you want my personal advice you can connect with me on facebook, send me a friend request, we can talk - facebook.com/gowardhandoddi

  • @anilvutukuri
    @anilvutukuri 2 месяца назад

    The major difference comes with the maintenance cost.
    And you have missed the same.
    For EV vehicle it is just Rs 500 for every 10000 kms.
    When coming to petrol or diesel it will be not less than Rs.10,000/-

    • @familymantelugu
      @familymantelugu  2 месяца назад

      Electric cars braking fluid needs to be changed more often, so I dont personally think 500 rs / 10,000 km is enough, anyway like you said maintenance cost of electric car is much lesser than a petrol car for sure.

  • @princekiranu3186
    @princekiranu3186 Месяц назад +1

    Tax Purpose use cheyyocha sir...

    • @familymantelugu
      @familymantelugu  Месяц назад

      ledu andi tinhaku mundu tax exemption undedi ippudu tesesaaru.

  • @ramaraju9706
    @ramaraju9706 Месяц назад

    Good 👍

  • @rajanikanthreddy9823
    @rajanikanthreddy9823 18 дней назад

    Na tata nexon ev -380 milege vastundi, ev 45

    • @familymantelugu
      @familymantelugu  18 дней назад

      Hi Rajnikanth garu, thank you for sharing the Rnage of Tata Nexon EV.

  • @maheshmahe5877
    @maheshmahe5877 19 дней назад

    Tata Nano gurinchi cheppandi sir new model.

    • @familymantelugu
      @familymantelugu  19 дней назад

      @@maheshmahe5877 Mahesh garu Tata Company Nano Car electric version India lo launch cheestunattu official announcement eemi ivvaleedu.
      So Tata nano EV ippatlo expect cheyyaleemu?

  • @bhanumurthysirmathsvediocl720
    @bhanumurthysirmathsvediocl720 Месяц назад +3

    ఎలక్ట్రికల్ బెస్ట్ అన్నిటికంటే ఏడో పిచ్చోడు మాటలు వినకండి

  • @Pavankumar-pc6lb
    @Pavankumar-pc6lb 2 месяца назад

    Instead of mentioning as repairs mention as service cost like engine oil costs. Because repair is common in both cars

    • @familymantelugu
      @familymantelugu  2 месяца назад

      Hi Pavan garu, avunandi you are right I did not cover that apsect in detail.

    • @karthikp9406
      @karthikp9406 Месяц назад

      What replies does EV gets?

  • @dynacom5384
    @dynacom5384 2 месяца назад +3

    తప్పు పెట్రోల్ రేట్ 8 ఇయర్స్ లో ఎంత పెరిగుతుంది

    • @familymantelugu
      @familymantelugu  2 месяца назад +1

      Hi andi, perugutaado ,taggutaado cheppaleemu, meru observe chesi vuntaaru last 1 year nunchi ade rate undi, inka petrol cheap avve avakasm kuda undi. at the same time current charges perigey avakasam kuda vundi EV'S perigitey

  • @dwaramsri
    @dwaramsri Месяц назад +2

    city lo cab nadipae variki use avvudi electric

    • @familymantelugu
      @familymantelugu  Месяц назад

      vallaki baaga useful, dabbulu baaga save chestaaru electric car use cheyyadam valla.

  • @kondalpandhiri
    @kondalpandhiri Месяц назад +7

    Ev cars అనేది ఒక పెద్ద ఆటోమొబైల్ మాఫియా, పెట్రోల్ డీజిల్ car ల కన్నా ఎక్కువ పొల్యూషన్ ప్రొడ్యూస్ చేస్తాయి బ్యాటరీ ద్వారా కూడా పొల్యూషన్ వస్తుంది వాటర్ ద్వారా నడిచే కారును ప్రోత్సహిస్తే బాగుంటుంది

    • @familymantelugu
      @familymantelugu  Месяц назад +3

      Avunandi, electric car valla pollution undadu kani environment friendly kadu endukantey battery tayyaru chese process lo chaala problems vastaayi.

  • @prasadnvk
    @prasadnvk 13 дней назад

    Petrol car Periodical maintenance మర్చిపోయారు మీరు. అలాగే on road price తీసుకోవాలి మీరు.

    • @familymantelugu
      @familymantelugu  3 дня назад

      Hi Prasad garu, Yes maintenance petrol car ki konchem ekkuva avutundi, at the same time we should note EV is not a zero maintenance car. You are right on road price valla variation inkonchem ekkuva perugutaadi and EV will have some advantage.

  • @ramanadavaluri4486
    @ramanadavaluri4486 Месяц назад

    CNG IS BEST

    • @familymantelugu
      @familymantelugu  Месяц назад +1

      CNG gurinchi nenu study cheyyaledu Ramana Garu.

  • @badrinarayana8227
    @badrinarayana8227 28 дней назад +1

    పెట్రోల్ బండీ కిలోమీటర్ కీ 9 rupes అయినప్పుడు ఎలక్ట్రానిక్ బండీ 1.5 rupes అయితే చాలా డిఫరెంట్ వుంటుంది కాదా మీ calculations తప్పు అనిపిస్తోంది

    • @familymantelugu
      @familymantelugu  28 дней назад +1

      @@badrinarayana8227 Hi Badri garu, Kani Electric car battery 🔋 8 years taruvaata maarchali daaniki 4 lakhs varaku Karchu avutundi inka electric car cost 3-4 lakhs ekkuva vuntundi gaa.

  • @mava885
    @mava885 2 месяца назад +1

    You missed oil maintenance, coolent , engine repairs and serviceing etc..

    • @familymantelugu
      @familymantelugu  2 месяца назад +1

      @@mava885 Hi andi, rendu cars ki common ga maintenance cost untundi gaa, anduke vaati gurinchi discuss cheyyaleedu.

    • @anilvutukuri
      @anilvutukuri 2 месяца назад

      No you are mistaken brother.
      EV maintenance cost is very cheaper than petrol or diesel.
      You need to change the filters engine oil etc.
      But in EV it will not be there

    • @familymantelugu
      @familymantelugu  2 месяца назад

      @@anilvutukuri correct ee gani, 1 year ki entha difference untundi? 10,000 inr?

  • @prabhakar0076
    @prabhakar0076 Месяц назад

    Maintenance kosam kontaru ELECTRIC car

    • @familymantelugu
      @familymantelugu  Месяц назад

      Hi Prabhakar garu, You mean Electric Car Maintenance is less?

    • @prabhakar0076
      @prabhakar0076 Месяц назад

      @@familymantelugu yes less complicated, less parts and less maintenance. Only costly part is BATTERY.
      After battery recycling plants starts, even the battery cost or compatible will be available

  • @prasadbvkg1069
    @prasadbvkg1069 2 месяца назад

    Ev comet per month 600 rupees only

    • @familymantelugu
      @familymantelugu  2 месяца назад

      Hi Prasad garu,
      meru enni kms ki lekkapettaru?
      Are you using Comet?
      I have also considered charges while going outstation trips. anduke km ki 1.5 rs vesaanu, meku inka thakkkuva cost padtundaa?

  • @TWorldCup-ez2wt
    @TWorldCup-ez2wt 11 дней назад

    So petrol cost remains same for 8 years???? LoL😂😂😂😂😂
    What if petrol cost raises 50% in 8 years,
    EVERYONE is best go for it

    • @familymantelugu
      @familymantelugu  11 дней назад

      Hi andi,
      Petrol cost tagocchu kuda in near future as predicted by Experts like Tony Seba who said that petrol prices may decrease by 50% in the coming 5 years. But we never know the future exactly.
      But you are right buying an EV right now is still a good choice for people who drive more than 50 kms / day because right now govt is charging only 5% GST on EVs where as it charges 28% GST on petrol cars.
      That means for 6 Lakh Rs Car, The GST for petrol car is 1,68,000 INR.
      But for an Electric car GST amount will be 30,000, but in near future if more people buy Electric Car Government may increase GST.
      So right now some conditions are favorable for Electric cars.

  • @karthikp9406
    @karthikp9406 Месяц назад +1

    రేయ్ యెడ్డి ఫెలోస్!! ఒక ఐడియా చెప్తా విని సావండి!!
    ఒక లచ్చ పెట్టి యూజ్డ్ ఆల్టో కొనండి, మిగిలిన 10-12 లచ్చెలు మిత్తీలు ఇచ్చుకోండి!! మీ యెడ్డి లాగిక్ కి ఇలాంటి సమాధానమే సరియైనది.
    EVs about comfort, reliable and luxury. Buy either BYD ooe MG for more reliable than indian sub-standard EVs. Dont mislead the people by fake propoganda! Furure is EV.
    By 2030 diesel production will end, and by 2040 petrol production will be ended.
    These guys having half baked brains shelling wrong stories!!

  • @sandeep8manchikant
    @sandeep8manchikant 2 месяца назад

    Service cost add cheyaledu

    • @familymantelugu
      @familymantelugu  2 месяца назад

      Avunu Sandeep garu, adi common ga rendu cars ki undede kada ani add cheyyaleedu.

    • @sandeep8manchikant
      @sandeep8manchikant 2 месяца назад

      Srvice cost lo chala diifrence untadi

    • @familymantelugu
      @familymantelugu  2 месяца назад

      @@sandeep8manchikant yes, I guess you are right.

  • @mkc5260
    @mkc5260 Месяц назад +1

    పెట్రోలు rate ప్రతి year పెరుగుతుంది, అలాగే ఎలక్ట్రిసిటీ కూడా మీరు వాటిని కూడా predict చేసి actual data estimate చేయాలి అని నా అభిప్రాయం

    • @familymantelugu
      @familymantelugu  Месяц назад

      @@mkc5260 correct ee sir, Kani petrol ⛽️ actual ga tagge avakasam kuda vundi,, because of fall in crude oil prices, and electricity kuda peragocchu.. konchem estimate cheyyadam kastame.

  • @ravirajkumarchebrolu1034
    @ravirajkumarchebrolu1034 2 месяца назад

    Mee name family man hai viewers my name .......Ani cheppandi sir 🙏

    • @familymantelugu
      @familymantelugu  2 месяца назад +1

      @@ravirajkumarchebrolu1034 Hi Ravi garu, naa Peru Gowardhan. Family man is my identity so naa laanti family man relate avutaaru inka gurtu pettukovadam easy ga untundani Ala cheptunnaanu.

    • @ravirajkumarchebrolu1034
      @ravirajkumarchebrolu1034 2 месяца назад

      @@familymantelugu
      Good car videos posted sir 🙏👏

    • @familymantelugu
      @familymantelugu  2 месяца назад

      Thanks Ravi garu.

  • @basineni_manohar
    @basineni_manohar 2 месяца назад

    Next comparison tata nexon vs bmw x1 😂😂😂

    • @familymantelugu
      @familymantelugu  2 месяца назад

      I dont even know Bro, are they even comparable?