Interesting questions people now a days only ask him questions on politics. This was absolute treat to listen to. Chomsky also gives interviews to even small channels that is so generous of him.
شكرا هادي على المقابلة الجيدة مفرح جدا أن نرى من أبناء البلد يدخل في حوار مع أحد أكبر العقول في زماننا. هكذا يجب أن نكون أن نتعلم من الشرق والغرب وهكذا سنطور عقولنا. ما شاء الله تشومسكي في العقد التسعين ولكن لا يزال عقله نشط جدا. أعتقد أن هذه من كرامات القراءة. جميل أيضا طريقة الحوار أنك تتيح للمحاور الحرية في التعبير عن رأيه بدون مقاطعة. بارك الله فيكم واستمروا في المحتوى الجيد. نتمنى لكم كل التوفيق.
@Kyle Stewart Hi, i will answering your questions step by step. The first question, no there are no modern countries follow Mohammed rules in war. The second question , yes there are rules against transgressions and targeting the civilians. The third question, yes Muhammed say word for word not to harm non combatants and innocent civilians and also he say that about the tree, women and children. Yes the wahhabism is some thing different to 9/11. Yes The Saudi Arabia follow the Quran also at tawheed is a word means follow the one god so the lessons it is there in Quran so there are no different between them. My friend attwaheed book is not political books so after that information you will recognize your questions. Syrians fighter doesn’t follow the Quran, on the opposite the political Syrians is Socialism not islamic country. And I as a Muslim against what happens in Russia, I am from Kuwait not Saudi to make you sure that I answering questions with love and honestly
"There are terrible problems all over the world, but they all have solutions." We together can make it happen. Let's make it so ... Excellent interview. Thanks
Try to be a bit more humble. Vijay holds Chomsky in high regards, so even Vijay would disagree about Chomsky being “nothing” how naive. Here’s the video m.ruclips.net/video/d6B-M0_XSGM/видео.html
The world isn't out there, you are the world. The crisis is within. Pointing out that the world (out there) has many problems implies that you know how to solve them.
I want to congratulate you for conducting one of the most intelligent and thought-provoking interviews that Professor Chomsky has been given in recent years.
To me monsieur Chomsky is the most important man and intellectual of our time, and to me he has reached the level of the greatest men in human history, thanks Noam and hopefully there are ears that can listen! شكرا للأخ العمانى على المجهود الي بذله و اتمنى له التوفيق !!!
This is probably the best answers that Noam Chomsky can give to Hira. It is the truth that encompasses every human being that has ever lived. Only our creative instincts can provide some understanding. I wish that every human being would be able to understand this point of view because I believe that it would make a better world.
@@smkxodnwbwkdns8369 "Avram Noam Chomsky[a] (born December 7, 1928) is an American linguist, philosopher, cognitive scientist, historical essayist, social critic, and political activist."
@@5driedgrams You think Wikipedia is an accurate source of information? I used to edit Wiki when I was 13 years old, more than a decade later every edit is still there. I’ve tried making a few edits years ago on an author I had avidly read and three timed my efforts failed and were reversed by people that literally hadn’t read a page of said author who were anarchist activists trying to appropriate respected writers. Chomsky has published on linguistics and studied the topic. He has been apart of many political activism activities. Again, Chomsky has never, I repeat, Chomsky has NEVER PUBLISHED on philosophy and once admitted to never really reading any philosophy besides Descartes, Aristotle, and Plato. I myself have read over 100 philosophers and still wouldn’t call myself a philosopher because I never published. How can someone who hasn’t read more than five philosophers and never published be considered a philosopher? Many people misunderstand what philosophy is, which is where the error comes from.
Thank you for yet another opportunity to listen to this wonderful, wise man. He is an inspiration. I first learned of him in undergraduate in anthropology. Be well my friend. Thank you for teaching me.
الاسئلة معدة سابقا وكأنها ستوجه إلى حاسوب او انسان آلي استاذي المضيف امامك انسان مميز، عبقري يفتقد اللقاء الى التفاعل والاندماج وفهم اجابة الضيف والرد او التعليق عليها بحرفية وانسيابية.
You asked Chomsky (roughly paraphrasing) what spiritual practices he engages in to make himself feel calm and content. It could be that the question never came up for him, because he was blessed with an intellect so powerful that his mind is like a perpetual motion machine, always working productively, always yielding insights, thus furnishing him with a continuous source of intellectual gratification and inner contentment. In sum, God (or nature) gifted him with every possible advantage to pursue the contemplative life, devoted to rational understanding of the world, which no less an authority than Aristotle said is the happiest kind of life possible for a human being.
To add to this point, Chomsky has lead a very contemplative life, - one different from most other people in society. He has spent decades in universities engaging with thought-provoking questions, surrounded by curious professors and students. He is one of the last real philosophers left.
@@_KITE a contemplative live is a well lived life. I would argue that academia is not the only place for philosophy. In fact after the neoliberal turn and learning institutions adopted more and more practices from the for profit sector it becomes less and less of a space for philosophy. But there will always be a lot of philosophy happening outside of institutions as well. Just takes a group of people wanting to dialogue about meaning.
Delightful interviewer and very interesting topics and angles in this conversation. As a materialist through and through, Chomsky has no real inclination to dive deep into spiritual ideas and topics, but he nevertheless answers openly. I can related to him in this.
اهنيييييييك من اعماق قلبي على هذا الاختيار الموفق. انتم بالفعل استطعتم استقطاب حوت من حيتان الثقافه والعلم والسياسه والاقتصاد. ارجوكم استمرو في هذا الابداع والف شكر لكم جميعا❤.
Никак не ожидала, что на меня обрушится невообразимое счастье- жить одновременно с гением мира. Хомский - идёт впереди всей науки, всех учёных. Невероятное чувство, видеть и слышать человеческого бога. Спасибо великий человек ! ( Москва, Россия)
بس اتمنى ان ينظر الخليجي بعين واقعيه و لا يترك ولاؤه لوطنه الجميل ليتبع اوهام بلاد يعاني اهلها الامرين من الجوع والهوان...انتم ابناء بلدان كرمتكم و اغنتكم لا تتبعون دول تعذب اهلها و تشردهم بحثا عن ملاذ
@Kyle Stewart Hi dear, That’s a lot of questions and I don’t have the absolute truth to be honest. Even me I have such questions and I couldn’t understand what’s happening regarding war’s in our Arabic countries. What I know for sure that in each religion there is good and bad. There’s some people that change the meaning of words to reach their own evil goals. Otherwise, there’s light, love, freedom in Islam and other religions for those who can open up their heart and seek for truth. It’s just a different directions but the destination is same. 💛
Thank you for producing this interview with Dr. Chomsky. The topics, questions and answers were thoughtful and appreciated but what I found most inspiring is the underlying concern and interest in improving our human experience is equal to conversations happening everyday in my part of the world, in Northern California. It is good to have opportunity to see under the veil of mass media.
@@hichem2837 ليس بذلك الحجم، فهما يشتركان في النظال والخير للشعوب المظلومة، حتى أن نعوم محتفظ بعبارة رسل المشهورة في مكتبه"هنالك ثلاثة أمور بسيطة لكنها مؤثرة غيرت مسار حياتي؛ :التوق للحب والشغف للمعرفة، وشفقة لا تنتهي أمام عتبات وآلام البشر" أو كما قال.
Great initiative from the channel, shukran djazilan. But I wish the interviewer has left Dr Chomsky sky finished his idea and sentences. He stopped him many times in mid analysis. Apart from that I enjoyed listening to Dr Chomsky.
Hi Hira, this was a good interview, you have talent as an interviewer and listening to Noam Chomsky is always a pleasure and a privilege. I hope that in the future you will also interview some women and include them in the discourse. (Not a criticism, just a suggestion) Best regards and keep up the good work
Salam Wa Alaykum wa Rahmat Allah Im Maliki Sunni from Algeria my father was a writer and he met Chomsky in Swansea University he is a wise man. This was a very interesting angle to interview him from. Maybe the most valuable interview he has done for a long while. Awesome channel! Barak Allahu fikum
@ناصر I also despise the "Syrian" AKA ZIONIST coup. Most of the 'fighters' were foreign Dawaesh financed and aided by Israel. Again I'm Maliki you know how highly we defend Sahaba but we took Algeria from Fatimids through debate, proof, not through genociding other sects like the Dawaesh wanted in Syria. You looked at a map and saw Daesh take 80% of Syria being aided by Israel and you thought it was a good thing? I know you're a Najdi and you people don't represent Sunnis at all you represent Saudi and Israelis. Syrian people did protest but the ones who brought guns were not the Syrian people. You probably support the Dawaesh in Algeria too. Any "revolution" aided by Americans and Zionist is fake
@ناصر But I don't think that highly of Chomsky I just thought this was a very original way to interview him.. I heard him say he was basically a Zionist before and he's a neoliberal basically. I don't think he's some great genius
@ناصر I get you people think of him like the Sheikh of geopolitics or something which can be dangerous cause of the influence. But you just said you supported that Fitna in Syria.. Which killed much more women and kids than anything Chomsky has done. You should have another look about the facts on Syria. Why do you think the Zionists wrote articles saying AQ is their ally in Syria? It was literally under Daesh but you want to talk about Assad lol. I can't find anything about Assad killing any civillians until after the war already started and obviously people die in wars. Also those gas attacks were a Hoax by British intelligence... That was not a revolution
@@XeLRUclips He has only done western ones and this is better than most. If you weren't trying to be a snide comtrarian imbecile trying to score ego points on this page you wouldn't ask this question, there's nothing difficult to follow in what i wrote
I’m genuinly happy you got to ask the questions a lot of us thought about asking Chomsky, but I also feel that having the opportunity to interview Chomsky without reading him and ask him such questions that you can get answers to through a google search, made me really frustrated especially as an Arab. There are SO many questions you could have asked 😢
Interesting interview with more existential and philosophical-religious questions. Interesting also Chomsky's answers to them. If I had to place him in some philosophical current of the Hellenistic period, a time also of chaos and conflict, I would say that Chomsky is a supporter of Pyrrhonian skepticism with just a touch of epicureanism and stoicism. Congratulations for the interview.
شاب عربي يستضيف نعوم تشومسكي؟😍 أغبطك جدا وأشكرك للجهد الذي بذلته في إعداد هذا اللقاء شعرت بأن الأسئلة في القسم الأول كانت متشابهة إلى حد ما وتمنيت لو أن القسم الأخير كان أطول (القسم المتعلق بنصائحه للشباب)، إذ لم أفهم لماذا قال تشومسكي أن الشرق الأوسط لن يكون قابلا للعيش بعد عدة أجيال . على الهامش: كلمة (conscientiousness) الأفضل أن تترجم إلى (الوعي) أما (الإدراك) فهو ترجمة لكلمة (perception) . شكرا لك مرة أخرى وبوركت جهودك🙌🏻❤️
backward thoughts - When a cup is pulverized, it is no longer a cup; it loses its “cupness” and becomes something other than a cup: it is powder - composed of essentially the same constituent matter that had formerly formed the cup, to be sure, but no longer having the form and physical characteristics of a cup. Therefore, not a cup; and hence, no longer existing as a cup. No?
@@dorianphilotheates3769 nope all parts of the cup become energy and smaller particles. ending/nothing is not newly created. ending/nonexistence of the cup is a part of the initial production of the cup but this requires a little study to get the hang of
backward thoughts - I never claimed any such thing: obviously, you have no training at all in the fundamentals of logic. Here endeth the lesson. Good day.
@@dorianphilotheates3769 'when one is present the other is absent', try to understand your own quotations. this means nonexistence is created upon something no longer existing, which is wrong
Excellent questions and answers, but I wish you would have engaged more in the discussion with him and had more follow-up questions instead of just moving along to the next question you have prepared each time.
Thanks... Yes indeed (follow-up questions) a suggestion that several friends had too... But time was limited and many topics were there to cover. There was a Forth part even. I didnt manage to cover it. It could have been better.
مقابله و حوار رائع و لكن الاسئلة والاجوبه تعطينا اوضح صورة عن المقارنه بين عقولنا و عقل الحكمه الفلسفيه ...همومنا الميتافيزيقيه و العقل الفلسفي ذو المواقف النبيله الاخلاقيه
Such a good person what I like about him is speaking the truth and I hope he finds the true religion one day because I like him I wish for him Janna. may Allah guide him
Well well and the question is this; where will allah guide you. Into the pits of destruction. Have a good look. The flag of lslam cloaks the banner of idolatry. The sickle moon and the sun disc. Allah represents the moon god and is an abomination to the true God. Yahshua Messiah says it is the Spirit that gives life and the flesh profits nothing and furthermore, take heed that no one deceives you. Many false prophets will arise and many false teachers. Satan deceives the whole world including this cult of lslam. Muhammad the pedophile prophet who married a six year old girl is dead in the tomb and will stand before the Yahshua Messiah, the one appointed of God to judge the whole world. And those that live by the sword as did Muhammad will give an account. Come out of Babylon My people is the utterance of God. The true God. Islam is paganism and is cloaked in the doctrine of Babylon. This is the truth and when you know the truth the truth will set you free. HalleluYah.
رحيل المفكر الأممي نعوم تشومسكي خسارة لجميع أحرار العالم ولمناهضي الايديولوجيات المتطرفة وعلى رأسها الحركة الصهيونية، وخسارة وللقيم الانسانية جمعاء. رحم الله كل انسان مناهض للظلم والغطرسة والميز العنصري.
شكرا لكم…مقابلة رائعة رغم أن أراءه الدينية مثيرة للجدل. ولا غرو في ذلك إذ إن معظم طروحاته لا تتعلق بالدين أصلا. يعجبني أسلوبك في المقابلة ومهارتك في اللغة الإنجليزية والفارسية أخي العزيز
@Kyle Stewart Hello dear: I have looked at your confused questions and have made a set of unfair comparisons, and this is due to the angle of your deductive understanding about the course of events and the political reality, which has become complex, but in comparison with Islamic law, you should look at the tolerant Prophet Muhammad’s biography and you will understand the true meaning of Islam.
عندما تسمع له تجد كما أننا كبشر قصرنا مع هذا الفيلسوف العبقري، و بالأحرى هو فلتة زمانه والحمدلله أننا عاصرناه، واستمعنا له، سواء اختلفنا أم اتفقنا إلا أنه في كثير مما يقوله فيه الخير والمحفز للعمل الصالح وللحيرة الأولى للرسول الكريم وما بعدها من أعمال صالحات وأخوة ورحمة وإحسان. كم أشعر بأن هذا البروفسور قد ظلم في زماننا، وأننا لم ندرك قيمته، كم للأسف هي الصرخات والأدلة والبراهين والحجج التي يقدمها لنصرة القضايا العادلة؛ قضية كرامة الإنسان تلو الكرامة. شكرا أخي المبدع صاحب القناة لجهدك، لسعيك، لمحاولتك، لحيرتك التي بداخلها الصدق تلو الصدق تلو المحبة. استوقفتنا الكثير من الكلم والحكم والتجربة المتصالحة لنعوم تشومسكي أطال الله في عمره. شكرا شكرا
Interesting questions people now a days only ask him questions on politics. This was absolute treat to listen to.
Chomsky also gives interviews to even small channels that is so generous of him.
شكرا هادي على المقابلة الجيدة
مفرح جدا أن نرى من أبناء البلد يدخل في حوار مع أحد أكبر العقول في زماننا. هكذا يجب أن نكون أن نتعلم من الشرق والغرب وهكذا سنطور عقولنا.
ما شاء الله تشومسكي في العقد التسعين ولكن لا يزال عقله نشط جدا. أعتقد أن هذه من كرامات القراءة.
جميل أيضا طريقة الحوار أنك تتيح للمحاور الحرية في التعبير عن رأيه بدون مقاطعة.
بارك الله فيكم واستمروا في المحتوى الجيد. نتمنى لكم كل التوفيق.
@Kyle Stewart Hi, i will answering your questions step by step. The first question, no there are no modern countries follow Mohammed rules in war. The second question , yes there are rules against transgressions and targeting the civilians. The third question, yes Muhammed say word for word not to harm non combatants and innocent civilians and also he say that about the tree, women and children. Yes the wahhabism is some thing different to 9/11. Yes The Saudi Arabia follow the Quran also at tawheed is a word means follow the one god so the lessons it is there in Quran so there are no different between them. My friend attwaheed book is not political books so after that information you will recognize your questions. Syrians fighter doesn’t follow the Quran, on the opposite the political Syrians is Socialism not islamic country. And I as a Muslim against what happens in Russia, I am from Kuwait not Saudi to make you sure that I answering questions with love and honestly
"There are terrible problems all over the world, but they all have solutions." We together can make it happen. Let's make it so ... Excellent interview. Thanks
Chomsky is nothing you should listen to Bob avakian, Vijay prashad
Try to be a bit more humble. Vijay holds Chomsky in high regards, so even Vijay would disagree about Chomsky being “nothing” how naive. Here’s the video
m.ruclips.net/video/d6B-M0_XSGM/видео.html
The world isn't out there, you are the world. The crisis is within. Pointing out that the world (out there) has many problems implies that you know how to solve them.
You’re reminding me of the Real Revolution by Jiddu Krishnamurti one of the GOATS
@@r3b3lvegan89The core of Jiddu Krishnamurti's teachIngs never left me.
I am yet again enlightened by this man’s continuous respect for all . He is a blessing.
Thank you Noam Chomsky.
I want to congratulate you for conducting one of the most intelligent and thought-provoking interviews that Professor Chomsky has been given in recent years.
To me monsieur Chomsky is the most important man and intellectual of our time, and to me he has reached the level of the greatest men in human history, thanks Noam and hopefully there are ears that can listen! شكرا للأخ العمانى على المجهود الي بذله و اتمنى له التوفيق !!!
This is probably the best answers that Noam Chomsky can give to Hira. It is the truth that encompasses every human being that has ever lived. Only our creative instincts can provide some understanding. I wish that every human being would be able to understand this point of view because I believe that it would make a better world.
من أكثر فلاسفة العصر المتواضعين والعظماء حقيقة عندما نأتي إلى الفكرة وإلى ما أبدع في مجال اللغة، شكرًا لأنك استضفته، محتواك استثنائي ✨
Chomsky is a such a good guy.
It's rare to see western philosophers on middle-eastern channels.
Chomsky is not a philosopher. He’s a linguist and political scientist.
@@smkxodnwbwkdns8369 "Avram Noam Chomsky[a] (born December 7, 1928) is an American linguist, philosopher, cognitive scientist, historical essayist, social critic, and political activist."
@@5driedgrams You think Wikipedia is an accurate source of information? I used to edit Wiki when I was 13 years old, more than a decade later every edit is still there. I’ve tried making a few edits years ago on an author I had avidly read and three timed my efforts failed and were reversed by people that literally hadn’t read a page of said author who were anarchist activists trying to appropriate respected writers.
Chomsky has published on linguistics and studied the topic. He has been apart of many political activism activities. Again, Chomsky has never, I repeat, Chomsky has NEVER PUBLISHED on philosophy and once admitted to never really reading any philosophy besides Descartes, Aristotle, and Plato. I myself have read over 100 philosophers and still wouldn’t call myself a philosopher because I never published. How can someone who hasn’t read more than five philosophers and never published be considered a philosopher? Many people misunderstand what philosophy is, which is where the error comes from.
Wow Noam Chomsky is interviewed by a lot of people recently
Thank you for yet another opportunity to listen to this wonderful, wise man. He is an inspiration. I first learned of him in undergraduate in anthropology. Be well my friend. Thank you for teaching me.
الاسئلة معدة سابقا وكأنها ستوجه إلى حاسوب او انسان آلي
استاذي المضيف
امامك انسان مميز، عبقري
يفتقد اللقاء الى التفاعل والاندماج وفهم اجابة الضيف والرد او التعليق عليها بحرفية وانسيابية.
Attainable logic from the start. This is why this man is so important.
We LOVE Brother Chomsky🤩
Great you are asking the religious, spiritual, philosophical, personal questions! Thank you
You asked Chomsky (roughly paraphrasing) what spiritual practices he engages in to make himself feel calm and content. It could be that the question never came up for him, because he was blessed with an intellect so powerful that his mind is like a perpetual motion machine, always working productively, always yielding insights, thus furnishing him with a continuous source of intellectual gratification and inner contentment. In sum, God (or nature) gifted him with every possible advantage to pursue the contemplative life, devoted to rational understanding of the world, which no less an authority than Aristotle said is the happiest kind of life possible for a human being.
Mikhail Proudhon - Well said, comrade.
@@dorianphilotheates3769 Thank you.
To add to this point, Chomsky has lead a very contemplative life, - one different from most other people in society. He has spent decades in universities engaging with thought-provoking questions, surrounded by curious professors and students.
He is one of the last real philosophers left.
@@_KITE a contemplative live is a well lived life.
I would argue that academia is not the only place for philosophy. In fact after the neoliberal turn and learning institutions adopted more and more practices from the for profit sector it becomes less and less of a space for philosophy. But there will always be a lot of philosophy happening outside of institutions as well. Just takes a group of people wanting to dialogue about meaning.
@@_KITE He is not even a philosopher. He is neither studied in philosophy nor does he profess to be one.
سبحان الله!يهدي من يشاء ويضل من يشاء!يعلم كثيرا من ظاهر الحياة الدنيا ولا يعرف شيئا عن ربه!ويتساءل عن كل شيء ولا يتساءل عن خالقه؟
Delightful interviewer and very interesting topics and angles in this conversation. As a materialist through and through, Chomsky has no real inclination to dive deep into spiritual ideas and topics, but he nevertheless answers openly. I can related to him in this.
اهنيييييييك من اعماق قلبي على هذا الاختيار الموفق.
انتم بالفعل استطعتم استقطاب حوت من حيتان الثقافه والعلم والسياسه والاقتصاد.
ارجوكم استمرو في هذا الابداع والف شكر لكم جميعا❤.
Никак не ожидала, что на меня обрушится невообразимое счастье- жить одновременно с гением мира. Хомский - идёт впереди всей науки, всех учёных. Невероятное чувство, видеть и слышать человеческого бога. Спасибо великий человек ! ( Москва, Россия)
نصيحته رائعه ...واتصور لعمان الحق بالفخر لشهادة تشومسكي لسياسة عمان الراقيه و قيادتها العبقريه و سياستها المتحضرة و الواعيه....
بس اتمنى ان ينظر الخليجي بعين واقعيه و لا يترك ولاؤه لوطنه الجميل ليتبع اوهام بلاد يعاني اهلها الامرين من الجوع والهوان...انتم ابناء بلدان كرمتكم و اغنتكم لا تتبعون دول تعذب اهلها و تشردهم بحثا عن ملاذ
Great interview! Long live Professor Chomsky! Thank you so much!
اول مرة بشوف شخص عربي مهتم بNoam Chomsky
You gain my full respect ♥️
تفاجأت باللقاء!! 😍🌟
مفكر عظيم..شكرًا أ.هادي المحاور كانت رائعة. كل التقدير لجهودكم في هذا البرنامج 🙏🏼
@Kyle Stewart Hi dear,
That’s a lot of questions and I don’t have the absolute truth to be honest. Even me I have such questions and I couldn’t understand what’s happening regarding war’s in our Arabic countries.
What I know for sure that in each religion there is good and bad. There’s some people that change the meaning of words to reach their own evil goals.
Otherwise, there’s light, love, freedom in Islam and other religions for those who can open up their heart and seek for truth. It’s just a different directions but the destination is same. 💛
شكر على مشاركتنا بهذا اللقاء ، مواضيع قيمة ونقاش شيق.
@Kyle Stewart what makes you think I can answer your questions?
One of the greatest personalities I have ever come to listen to
شكرا استاذ علي الاستضافة لمفكر عظيم و متواضع نتمني المزيد 🌹🌹🌹🇩🇿
شكراً على هذه المقابلة الرائعة مع شخصية متميزة . و قد كانت إدارة الحوار راقية ، بارك الله في جهودكم
Two cultures can and should talk like that. Very good opportunity. Very good interview.
Thank you for producing this interview with Dr. Chomsky. The topics, questions and answers were thoughtful and appreciated but what I found most inspiring is the underlying concern and interest in improving our human experience is equal to conversations happening everyday in my part of the world, in Northern California. It is good to have opportunity to see under the veil of mass media.
Thoroughly enjoyed the questions to Dr Chomsky. Thank you for this interview.
أن هي إلا حياتنا الدنيا نموت ونحيا وما يهلكنا الا الدهر...💔
بوركت الجهود شكرا لك لانك تساهم في تغيير الفكر
Thank you from New Zealand :)
وفقت لكل خير ، بالحقيقه واحد من افضل ما قدمت ولشخصية رائعه ولا اكون بالغت ان قلت انه من اعظم المفكرين في اخر قرنين.
هو متأثر ببرتراند راسل
بالفعل وصدقت
@@hichem2837
ليس بذلك الحجم، فهما يشتركان في النظال والخير للشعوب المظلومة، حتى أن نعوم محتفظ بعبارة رسل المشهورة في مكتبه"هنالك ثلاثة أمور بسيطة لكنها مؤثرة غيرت مسار حياتي؛ :التوق للحب والشغف للمعرفة، وشفقة لا تنتهي أمام عتبات وآلام البشر" أو كما قال.
@@aa7adnan عنده فيديو يصرح بمدى اعجابه وتأثره ببرتراند راسل حتى وان كان مجال الاهتمام العلمي والمعرفي يختلف بينهما.
Great initiative from the channel, shukran djazilan. But I wish the interviewer has left Dr Chomsky sky finished his idea and sentences. He stopped him many times in mid analysis. Apart from that I enjoyed listening to Dr Chomsky.
مقابلة رائعة
شكراً لك
رائع رائع رائع..
إنها مقابلة للتاريخ
Humans have an angelic dimension of their being. Beautiful manners and actions.
then go work in slauhgterhouse with their beautifull manners and angelic dimension
What a wonderful human Noam Chomsky is.
Hi Hira, this was a good interview, you have talent as an interviewer and listening to Noam Chomsky is always a pleasure and a privilege. I hope that in the future you will also interview some women and include them in the discourse. (Not a criticism, just a suggestion) Best regards and keep up the good work
Thanks.
Sure I've already interviewed women in several talks.. Will be posted soon hopefully
نعم ...
جهد عظيم تشكر عليه يا استاذ هادي...هذه مقابلة تاريخية و فريدة جدا من نوعها
Wow . Unique interview with my hero. Ps wish I could wear the clothes and dead gear you wear. Awesome.
شكرا لك على هذا اللقاء الرائع، احترم كثيرا هذا الفيلسوف وارائه رغم اختلافي معه فيما يخص قضية الصحراء المغربية.
لمذا تختلفين مهه
I love his man; may Allah guide him towards islam!
@@JoshLavian u don't know the meaning of what u write; may be ignorance is blessing for ur kind!
الللللللله نعوم تشومسكي مرة وحدة!! ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Noam Chomsky and Billy Meier are two of the wisest men on Earth that I am aware of.
عمل رائع برافو عليك
جزيل الشكر والامتنان استاذ هادي محاضرة قيمة
Salam Wa Alaykum wa Rahmat Allah Im Maliki Sunni from Algeria my father was a writer and he met Chomsky in Swansea University he is a wise man. This was a very interesting angle to interview him from. Maybe the most valuable interview he has done for a long while. Awesome channel! Barak Allahu fikum
نتشرف بكم عزيزي وبأهل الجزائر الأطايب
ونسعد بمتابعتكم واهتمامكم.
وفقتم لكل خير
@ناصر I also despise the "Syrian" AKA ZIONIST coup. Most of the 'fighters' were foreign Dawaesh financed and aided by Israel. Again I'm Maliki you know how highly we defend Sahaba but we took Algeria from Fatimids through debate, proof, not through genociding other sects like the Dawaesh wanted in Syria. You looked at a map and saw Daesh take 80% of Syria being aided by Israel and you thought it was a good thing? I know you're a Najdi and you people don't represent Sunnis at all you represent Saudi and Israelis. Syrian people did protest but the ones who brought guns were not the Syrian people. You probably support the Dawaesh in Algeria too. Any "revolution" aided by Americans and Zionist is fake
@ناصر But I don't think that highly of Chomsky I just thought this was a very original way to interview him.. I heard him say he was basically a Zionist before and he's a neoliberal basically. I don't think he's some great genius
@ناصر I get you people think of him like the Sheikh of geopolitics or something which can be dangerous cause of the influence. But you just said you supported that Fitna in Syria.. Which killed much more women and kids than anything Chomsky has done. You should have another look about the facts on Syria. Why do you think the Zionists wrote articles saying AQ is their ally in Syria? It was literally under Daesh but you want to talk about Assad lol. I can't find anything about Assad killing any civillians until after the war already started and obviously people die in wars. Also those gas attacks were a Hoax by British intelligence... That was not a revolution
ضيف من العيار الثقيل والله تستاهل اقوى لايك واحسن متابعة
Great interview... better than most Western ones he did in recent months!
and most Easterns did better?, weird locationism
@@XeLRUclips He has only done western ones and this is better than most. If you weren't trying to be a snide comtrarian imbecile trying to score ego points on this page you wouldn't ask this question, there's nothing difficult to follow in what i wrote
I’m genuinly happy you got to ask the questions a lot of us thought about asking Chomsky, but I also feel that having the opportunity to interview Chomsky without reading him and ask him such questions that you can get answers to through a google search, made me really frustrated especially as an Arab. There are SO many questions you could have asked 😢
Thanks for your comment.
Which kind of questions you had in mind ?
A great Intellectual and thinker Mash'allah
Interesting interview with more existential and philosophical-religious questions. Interesting also Chomsky's answers to them. If I had to place him in some philosophical current of the Hellenistic period, a time also of chaos and conflict, I would say that Chomsky is a supporter of Pyrrhonian skepticism with just a touch of epicureanism and stoicism. Congratulations for the interview.
Brilliant and sagacious words from Dr Chomsky.
what a great man and what a geat life!!!!!
شاب عربي يستضيف نعوم تشومسكي؟😍
أغبطك جدا وأشكرك للجهد الذي بذلته في إعداد هذا اللقاء
شعرت بأن الأسئلة في القسم الأول كانت متشابهة إلى حد ما
وتمنيت لو أن القسم الأخير كان أطول (القسم المتعلق بنصائحه للشباب)، إذ لم أفهم لماذا قال تشومسكي أن الشرق الأوسط لن يكون قابلا للعيش بعد عدة أجيال
.
على الهامش:
كلمة (conscientiousness) الأفضل أن تترجم إلى (الوعي)
أما (الإدراك) فهو ترجمة لكلمة (perception)
.
شكرا لك مرة أخرى وبوركت جهودك🙌🏻❤️
اعتقد أن افضل ترجمة لمصطلح conscientiousness هو حس الضمير
the interviewer did not interrupt until Chomsky started talking about Israel
This man is the greatest wonder of the whole world right now.
“Do not concern yourself with death: when death is, you are not; when you are, death is not. When one is present the other is absent”. - Epicurus
thats like saying when a cup is pulverised then nonexistence is created
even science now understands this is silly
backward thoughts - When a cup is pulverized, it is no longer a cup; it loses its “cupness” and becomes something other than a cup: it is powder - composed of essentially the same constituent matter that had formerly formed the cup, to be sure, but no longer having the form and physical characteristics of a cup. Therefore, not a cup; and hence, no longer existing as a cup. No?
@@dorianphilotheates3769 nope all parts of the cup become energy and smaller particles. ending/nothing is not newly created. ending/nonexistence of the cup is a part of the initial production of the cup but this requires a little study to get the hang of
backward thoughts - I never claimed any such thing: obviously, you have no training at all in the fundamentals of logic. Here endeth the lesson. Good day.
@@dorianphilotheates3769 'when one is present the other is absent', try to understand your own quotations. this means nonexistence is created upon something no longer existing, which is wrong
Noam Chomsky❤
انجاز كبير انكم تجيبو العظيم تشومسكي 👍👍
I enjoyed the meeting so much and write lots of notes
جزاكم الله خيرا
اعتقد انه لو تم تجميع القائيين في شكل مكتوب فسيكون أمر رائع للغاية ..
لقاء جميل شكرا
Great interview, I enjoyed the diversity of questions, especially on literature. Thanks a lot.
Insightful talk. Thanks Naom. Thanks Hira.
Thanks hira,
You made us to see the whole Naom.
Excellent talk.
Excellent!
لا يزال ابداعكم مستمر ولاتزال مفاجئاتكم رائعة .. حفظكم الله وتحياتنا لكم .. ارجوا منكم ان تقابلوا الدكتور عدنان إبراهيم
شكرا شكرا هادي على استضافة الرجل
Excellent questions and answers, but I wish you would have engaged more in the discussion with him and had more follow-up questions instead of just moving along to the next question you have prepared each time.
Thanks... Yes indeed (follow-up questions) a suggestion that several friends had too...
But time was limited and many topics were there to cover. There was a Forth part even. I didnt manage to cover it.
It could have been better.
Got all shakened…once again
مقابله و حوار رائع و لكن الاسئلة والاجوبه تعطينا اوضح صورة عن المقارنه بين عقولنا و عقل الحكمه الفلسفيه ...همومنا الميتافيزيقيه و العقل الفلسفي ذو المواقف النبيله الاخلاقيه
If there were a contest right now for the the most knowledgeable person in the world, would anyone else even come close?
مقابلة مثرية. مشكور على الجهد واستمر.
Such a good person what I like about him is speaking the truth and I hope he finds the true religion one day because I like him I wish for him Janna. may Allah guide him
Well well and the question is this; where will allah guide you. Into the pits of destruction. Have a good look. The flag of lslam cloaks the banner of idolatry. The sickle moon and the sun disc. Allah represents the moon god and is an abomination to the true God. Yahshua Messiah says it is the Spirit that gives life and the flesh profits nothing and furthermore, take heed that no one deceives you. Many false prophets will arise and many false teachers. Satan deceives the whole world including this cult of lslam. Muhammad the pedophile prophet who married a six year old girl is dead in the tomb and will stand before the Yahshua Messiah, the one appointed of God to judge the whole world. And those that live by the sword as did Muhammad will give an account. Come out of Babylon My people is the utterance of God. The true God. Islam is paganism and is cloaked in the doctrine of Babylon. This is the truth and when you know the truth the truth will set you free. HalleluYah.
Learned so muchh about US policies
املنا كبير۔ للسلام بين اليهود والعرب،الشرق والغرب، بين النساء والرجال، بين كل خلوق الله التي والذين يحبهم۔
رحيل المفكر الأممي نعوم تشومسكي خسارة لجميع أحرار العالم ولمناهضي الايديولوجيات المتطرفة وعلى رأسها الحركة الصهيونية، وخسارة وللقيم الانسانية جمعاء.
رحم الله كل انسان مناهض للظلم والغطرسة والميز العنصري.
نعم، ولكنه لم يرحل بعد .
شكرا لكم…مقابلة رائعة رغم أن أراءه الدينية مثيرة للجدل. ولا غرو في ذلك إذ إن معظم طروحاته لا تتعلق بالدين أصلا.
يعجبني أسلوبك في المقابلة ومهارتك في اللغة الإنجليزية والفارسية أخي العزيز
الظاهر انت لا تعرف تشومسكي و لا اراؤه الدينيه ...و اللواتي فارسيته احسن من انكليزيته
جهود تشكر عليها 🌷
الله عليك استمر عزيزي أنت ملهم
حفظك الرحمن يابن بلادي🇴🇲💪
@Kyle Stewart Hello dear:
I have looked at your confused questions and have made a set of unfair comparisons, and this is due to the angle of your deductive understanding about the course of events and the political reality, which has become complex, but in comparison with Islamic law, you should look at the tolerant Prophet Muhammad’s biography and you will understand the true meaning of Islam.
ثقافة عابرة للقارات
شكرا أخي هادي .. استمتعت كثيرا بالمشاهدة .. فخور بأن أحد منا لديه قناة رائعة كقناتك .. أتمنى لك التوفيق والأستمرار
شكرا عزيزي، أتشرف باهتمامك ومتابعتك
Beautiful gift 🙂
Thanks.
noam dgaf hunnid thousand years old will go on any podcast
Awesome
أسئلة ومطارحات ذكية من المحاور الكريم
چمبس الله انفاسك
شكرا لك على تلك الحوارات الهادئة والهادفة والرصينة
Really great interview.
What a great interview! thank you for giving us this privilege.
عندما تسمع له تجد كما أننا كبشر قصرنا مع هذا الفيلسوف العبقري، و بالأحرى هو فلتة زمانه والحمدلله أننا عاصرناه، واستمعنا له، سواء اختلفنا أم اتفقنا إلا أنه في كثير مما يقوله فيه الخير والمحفز للعمل الصالح وللحيرة الأولى للرسول الكريم وما بعدها من أعمال صالحات وأخوة ورحمة وإحسان.
كم أشعر بأن هذا البروفسور قد ظلم في زماننا، وأننا لم ندرك قيمته، كم للأسف هي الصرخات والأدلة والبراهين والحجج التي يقدمها لنصرة القضايا العادلة؛ قضية كرامة الإنسان تلو الكرامة.
شكرا أخي المبدع صاحب القناة لجهدك، لسعيك، لمحاولتك، لحيرتك التي بداخلها الصدق تلو الصدق تلو المحبة.
استوقفتنا الكثير من الكلم والحكم والتجربة المتصالحة لنعوم تشومسكي أطال الله في عمره.
شكرا شكرا
Very good interview, thank you.
You cannot be loved by people who hate you because of who you are, no matter how hard you try.
Point of life is to get it.
Great person 🎉🎉❤❤❤❤