$145 of SnapOn vs Tekton vs Icon vs Capri Tools Who Will Flex the Most?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 19 июн 2024
- My Snap-on THLX72G started to slip in the “on” tightening position so it was time for a rebuild. I had no intention of testing this ratchet, but since one pawl was on its way out I figured we would put it up against Tekton and Icon and Capri Tools.
While you would typically never take a 1/4” drive past 40-50 ft-lbs we were able to see that these ratchets all performed well. I was surprised to see the ICON ratchet perform so well. In the end, even the Capri Tools and Tekton again performed better than the Snap-On ratchet as far as pure strength. Today there are so many options for getting value compared to buying what is often considered the best. Hopefully, you can purchase or already have what you feel is the best option for you.
If you break tektons stuff you take a pic and they mail you a new one. for the price you cant beat it, plus usa made on some of their stuff. I like tekton im buying all their sockets slowly
I just ordered their big 3/8 set this morning. Also, you get 10% of your previous purchase price off of your next purchase, so my $125 dollar set gives me 12.50 off the next purchase I make.
yep, i purchased a 3/8 tekton socket set a couple of years ago and it's become my go to set.. i'm very impressed with tekton,, and like you said, for the money, u can't beat it.
I have their impact sockets and I love them!
Its the same warranty process with capri
All4 brands are lifetime warranty.
Yeah for the price of that snap on ratchet you get a whole tekton set with all the extras. Not to mention you also got 14$ in rewards with their 10% rebate on everything. Tekton the clear winner
I inherited a bunch of old mismatched Craftsman and off-brand tools for my dad. About 2 years ago decided to upgrade my sockets and wrenches with cases for better organization. After doing some research I went exclusively with TEKTON and I absolutely love them. I work on all of my own vehicles, lawn mower, tractor, appliances etc but I'm certainly no mechanic so I was not going after professional quality shop tools however I feel like my TEKTON tools are in fact professional quality.
I’m a lube tech and they are definitely professional quality. I use and abuse their sockets and ratchets every day and the only thing I’ve had fail is a set of mini end cutting pliers where the little spring flew out. Took a picture and 4 days later (it was over Labor Day weekend) I have a new set in my mailbox.
Gearwrench is my baby
I have the Tekton 1/4”, 3/8” and 1/2” sets (90 tooth) as well as the SATA 1/4”, 3/8” and 1/2” sets (72 tooth - owned by Apex like Gearwrench and Crescent) ... really happy with them all ... my ratchet wrenches are Gearwrench !!!
Snap-on has been getting away with their BS price-gouging for far too long now.
The reason they are high price is because they have a lifetime warranty bud. They also are amazing tools
Luke tons of companies have lifetime warranty! Lmfao they're not so amazing they should be overpriced. Stupid people buy snap on
You're paying for the tool, the tool truck, the guy driving the truck and his fuel when you buy snap on. They are great tools but not good enough for me to justify that massive middle man expense. Bud.
Luke Snavely dude every tool company now makes lifetime warranty. Nothing special!
Stephen Pena poor people complain about Snap On
i've seen a ton of test videos like this and one thing that always amazes me is the fact people still buy snap on, ICON is pretty much the exact same tool (minor differences) and i've seen way to many videos of them beating out snap on to ever think of buying that price gouged junk
I keep hearing "very impressive !" In project farms voice
That man in a national hero.
We're going to test that!
I have the exact same tekton 1/4" drive set and I love it. The tests that you did is a great example why I always break loose tight bolts using a breaker bar first before using a ratchet. After breaking a few ratchets in my younger years, I started using a breaker bar to bust those tight bolts free first before reaching for my ratchets. The right tool for the right job. Great video.
The Tekton ratchets are typically rated for the same load as their same size breaker bars. I think it is only their 3/4 in breaker bars that exceed the ratchet. All ratchets in this test exceeded the ANSI and ASME standards for 1/4 in ratchets.
Icon looks pretty good now at least in their 1/4 ratchet great video brotha keep rollin those cameras and doing what you do
The quick release makes the anvil weaker on the Tekto and Snap-On. I've become a Tekton fan. Warranty, price, and non skipping socket and wrench sets sold me.
Right on! I'm going that direction myself. I have always had craftsman in the past but they can suck it!
I have the Tekton stuff in non quick release, hard to beat for the price.
Yep I have that same Tekton with non quick release and non flex head
I go crazy for those no skips
Also, you get 10% of your previous purchase price off of your next purchase. I just got the 3/8 full set for $125 and that gives me 12.50 off the next purchase I make. I think they're a great company.
Thank you so much I show this video to a snap on Driver he was shocked by amazing results when he 👀 saw icon test.
"All these dang blue-collar tweakers wasting money on expensive tools for the brand names are the backbone of this town"
-almost a Primus lyric
Super Thorough vid! The only thing that seems unfair is everything was brand new aside from the snap-on which was already broken in one direction, It doesn't seem fair to use a previously ABUSED ratchet and compare it to new ones
Facts
Great test! I love how Tekton warranties their tool's.
Great video, very helpful on some lingering questions.
Great video. They are always worth a watch.
Tekton is by far the best tool for your money.
I'd be all over Tekton if the warranty was valid for Australia.
I don't see a reason not to choose Tekton if your in the US though, from everything I have seen they are either up there with the best or beating them and cost less with a better warranty process
Tekton is awesome. Most of my sockets are tekton and I have some misc stuff from them. I work at a dealership so they get used daily and I have yet to break any of their tools yet.
@@ToucanSamich if you work at harbor frieght the icon tools aren't too bad for your buck
Greatest warranty as well for the USA.
Definitely. Warranty process is what sets them above and beyond. No questions asked whatsoever. I absolutely adore my tekton ratchets.
I buy everything ICON now. Can’t wait for them to come out with more tools are they are limited now.
I'm hoping for icon impacts
@@ianthompson2802 theyre out.
@behexen250 that showed them...
ian Thompson
They e been out for a while. I have all the 1/2 deep impacts.
25th anniversary as a full time mechanic last june. Bought my 1st 3/8 drive snap on ratchet in 1999. Retired it for the 80 tooth model last year. Not really retired though because it still gets use and works flawlessly.
Snap-On is really not marketed at the “shade tree” mechanic. For someone like you who depends on his tools for his lively hood, I totally understand paying more for higher quality. Snap-On is just way out my price range and I really can’t justify the price for how much I use them. I have ICON ratchets and sockets and they work wonderfully for me. At some point I may purchase an 80 tooth 3/8th Snap-On ratchet just to say I have one and see what the hoopla is all about.
@@aeromedical6776 if you are getting the job done that's all that matters!
This was a great video . thank you buddy definitely got sumthing outta this
I was impressed with all of them. I don’t think you could go wrong with any of them. Great video!
Tekton doesn't honor their warranty
Pat H I’ve heard nothing but great things about there products and warranties. But I’m sure everyone has different experiences with all tool brands out there.
Where you here that? By paid endorsers on you tube, I'm a broken down retired ass from the Midwest who after 35 years in the trade was basically told to use a faulty tool it will break in, maybe the signals were crossed but a "no hassle warranty" is just that,
Pat H what did you use for those 35yrs in the trade?
The usual snapon Armstrong wright proto craftsman ect. and a bunch of offshore/taiwanese stuff, whatever the company supplied and never got snubbed by a supplier like "Dave" at Tekton did, that douch should be on the soup line, I'm in a local of 8 thousand members in chicago, they should honor their warranty, bad service travels fast
I came here to read all these comments by strap-on users who got screwed with their overpriced, over-hyped garbage....😆
🤣 "strap on" good one
Ebay's a hell of a site
You do realize that the quick release ratchet heads are much weaker than solid anvil ratchets. I have icon and snap on and Mac and craftsman. The icon ratchet is good but using it every day it has started to get binding in the head where the snap on is still strong and smooth over years of use. Everything has its purpose
@@yz85919 Be realistic about "Strength" of any ratchet. If you're going to apply that much torque to any wrenching tool, a ratchet is the wrong tool. If vast amounts of torque is required, use a long handle box wrench or non ratcheting socket drive tool or better yet use a high power impact tool. It is absurd to use a hand ratchet as the default wrenching tool as there are FAR better tools for a given wrenching need.
And... Do NOT be afraid of using the largest square drive for any given wrenching need. There appears to be a chronic and severe allergy within the Moto wrencher folks to avoid at any cost a square drive size larger than 1/2" square. In any application that needs more than 300ft/lb using a 3/4" or 1" square drive tool would be the FAR better choice. Instead, Moto wrencher folks insist on adding a 100 foot long cheater pipe to the tiny (1/2" or less) square drive tool then scream "Cheap Crap" after the square drive tool explodes.
~Why?~
Snap-On's reliability and dealer network notwithstanding; people tout them as "lifetime tools" which...after re-mortgaging your house and starting on a loan that could get you a nice Truck, are quickly sold off wholesale to the first takers to get the loansharks off your back :P
Mid-priced or cheaper $20-40 don't really have any change in value and since you're not dropping your paycheck directly in the tool truck's coffers, you tend to hold onto them longer!
I don't own any Snap-on tools. I've had both had bad experiences with tool men and also don't see the point in paying so much. With that said this proves that a new ratchet will hold a certain amount of torque. But this does not account for the longevity of the tool. As an Automotive Technician I look for what will last. Pushing the ratchet to its failure point doesn't prove that over time the tool will hold up. The way these tools are actually used is very different than a static test.
Uses a broken snap on ratchet against new tools and still was right there with them
It was last dude. Dead last. What do you mean it was "right there with them?"
@@Speed00007 it was broken from the get go😂
My first icon buy was a 3/8 torque wrench and their quality is superb.
It was a good test but honestly its a 1/4" ratchet so really its not made for high torque applications if you have to pull that hard you would up the drive size
I got ratchet mechanisms from various brands, I do notice a wide variance in the overall quality of it and it's not specific to a brand. Snap-on's ratchet mechanism in the torque wrench i have, works OK but lacks smoothness compared to ratchet mechanism from say gearwrench or something. That is something i noticed over time.
@@Enonymouse_ personally I fell that the snap on ratchets are the best ratchets that I've used, the gear wrench to me is much smoother and better feel then a craftsman or matco but my gear wrench 120xp ratchets i dont feel are as good a product or as smooth as my snap on that being said the ratchets are just about the only thing i really use from snap on anymore I've been buying gear wrench products the past couple years because its cheaper and holds up just as well
No shit
No shit... the point of the test is to take it to failure. Obviously they're going to load it more than it's designed for
@@bstceltics4 you gotta try some of the German stuff (e.g. Hazet, Stahlwille, Gedore)!
I'm glad to hear the positive comments on Tekton as I just ordered some and haven't received them yet. The strongest ratchet I've ever owned was a round head Wright 1/2 inch drive. Had rig hands bouncing on it with their feet, and never failed.
Well, I dunno. The smart thing is to never use a ratchet that is too weak for the task at hand. If you want to tighten or release a fastener and know (or suspect) the amount of force needed will cause it to fail, you should upsize the ratchet. Go from 1/4" drive up to a 3/8" drive, and 3/8" drive up to 1/2" drive and save yourself the grief. Better yet, use a long-handled standard wrench or a long breaker bar. Neither of these have a ratcheting mechanism that can fail in use.
I have the flex head 1/4 drive long comfort handle snap on ratchet. It’s about 12 inches long and I regularly put 100 ftlbs. On it. Never had a problem. Have tried several brands of ratchets over the years and can’t complain about snap on hand tools. Air tools and cordless is another story though.
I like seeing all these butt hurt people that still owe thousands to the Snap-On truck
What about those of us that have paid for snap on, icon, and tekton stuff.. and still prefer snap on?
Snap-On fanboys probably drink Budweiser and think it's the best beer in the world. Oh, wait a minute, what am I saying?! Most Snap-On guys probably drink White Claw!
@@scooterpickle8625 Roflmao
@@jamesstephenson2346 Yep, I don't know who 'owes' anything to snap-on. I pay in cash for my tools and have had them for years, the snap-on stuff I do own has been good to me.
I have an impact gun made by snap-on from the 90's that has been rebuilt numerous times, it used to belong to the auto-shop of a telecom formerly known as GTE. They maintained all their own trucks in-house. I own a chicago-pneumatic gun i like better but the old stand-by is always there.
@@jamesstephenson2346 i’d say you’re buying into the needless spending
Id probably go with the tekton, best warranty, performed nearlu as well as the capri and almost as good as the icon but with the flex head being second only to the snapon, plus it had quick release and its the cheapest, best all round
For the 3/8s stuff, I have a Tekton quick release unit. I've REALLY leaned on that ratchet with zero issues, and the tooth engagement vs the Mac and Matco units is near identical. Hell of a deal for the money. The only upgrade I can see worth spending the money on would be the SnapOn (there ratchet mechanisms are just unmatched in my opinion..) or the Matco for the locking Flexhead (I have their 1/2 unit and love it).
I could watch you do this all day lol. Theres something about it , its fascinating lol.. informative tooo... never using alot of those brands , after seeing this , i would absolutely give tekton, icon's, capri ratchets a try..
Digging that 1/4 inch set ,, we have been seeing more and more half sizes on equipment from overseas
A lot of strap on haters disliking this video. Keep making videos like this Chris, its what keeps everyone subbed.
i really love that 1/4in drive set got it on yours and a few other youtubers segestion that said tekton was good i really love it a super nice kit for small engine work its made me a lot of money rebuilding carbs and stuff
That’s awesome, you are the second person that has said that today! I can’t agree more and for the price, complete size the Tekton 1/4 set is fantastic!
@@ClientGraphics i got the 3/8in set after the 1/4 now i am gana get the 1/2in drive set cant beat it for price with how complete it is with rachets and everything super nice when first starting out or trying to build a set of tools. (i say that as i have like 9 sets of hand tools)
Man I love you videos.
Thanks
Although the only issue with the Icon is consistency. They dont all act or feel the same. The first one I bought felt great, but used it once and it locked up. The replacement they gave was much "stiffer" to operate and soynds different. I started checking several on the shelf VERY inconsistent.
Those icon tools feel very awesome in the store.
Super fine teeth. Nice lines. Fit great
So if it wins out I am sold
Really enjoyed the price points up front.
$145!? Snap on can suck it! I’ll stick to $5 ratchets, which I’ve never even had one break.
I agree with you, the warranty is what sells tool. Anyone can have lifetime, but who actually warrants their tools without a headache?
Awesome
Videos man!!
I wanna see this done again with a craftsman ratchet in there also , I’ve put my craftsman ratchets through hell and all my buddys that have snap on ratchets and breaker bars and are always busting them
My favorite flex head budget ratchet is the husky. It's even a locking flex head like the snap on.
I bought the standard icon ratchet and comfort grip finding both were not lubed properly and skipped. Cleaned and re-lubed they work flawless. Left a review and someone contacted me asking proof of purchase and stated my remarks were passed on to the proper channels so they are listening to customersmore than you think!
I'd really like to see the Wright "Double Pawl" ratchets put up against the Snap-On and/or Tekton, Along with Proto, MAC, and Cornwell. A Few mentioned Gedore as well and i know my dad had some of their wrenches so I think that would be a good contest. you could possibly throw in a Boxo ratchet and/or a Titan as I believe these should be fairly similar to the Tekton or Icon.
I love all my tekton tools great quality for Harbor Freight prices I don't use mine everyday but I have not had any problems and the finish and fit of the tools excellent
Those are all extremely impressive.
Awesome video thanks for sharing it. What happened to Snap-On Tools? I never see their trucks anymore.
I purchased all of the comfort grip ICON ratchets and got all three ICON torque wrenches. I got one ICON ratchet and used it on a job. I ended up buying the whole set after that job. Love my ratchets.
Why spend triple or more when you don’t have to for the same, if not better, tool. I’m planning on, over time, getting the entire line of ICON Hand tools. Snap-on is good quality (mostly) but they don’t have the advantage anymore.
Why buy snap on when the only persons impressed by snap on are other guys who like tools. Whatever your working on, the customer nor the world at large cares what brand tool u have as long as it works.
So far, I’ve really put some heavy stress on my ICON tools and they perform flawlessly. Plus, if they ever fail, a quick run to the local HF for a new one is all it takes. No shipping, no waiting, no hassle. Theirs just no reason to pay more anymore.
I agree. Only thing I don't like about Icon is their box prices. Boxes are still ridiculously over-priced in general.
Maybe you would think differently if you were slave labor and got fed a cracker and a bowl of soup today. And while your at work slaving away your children can sweep and clean the factory you work at and live at buy AMERICAN don't have to be snapon
As others have mention, if your doing a ft-lb test, they should mechanically function the exact same. Quick release vs not is comparing apples and oranges.
Agreed. Also, if he is going to take the tool to failure it should be done with one constant continuous application of force to the tool/cheater bar instead of repeatedly stressing the tool in a yo-yo fashion and then finally taking it to failure. There is a lot of room for improvement in his testing methods.
Yeah the snap on guy would be screaming abuse!!!!😫😫😫😫😫💯💯💯
Another good video. I would like to see you test gearwrench flex head ratchet. I would like to see how it compares to the ones you've tested. I'm a big fan of gearwrench and I really like my gearwrench ratchets and I haven't had any problems with them.
Best video yet, Information not just you opinion.
Great video. Thank you
Been working on cars and trucks for over 25 year's never needed a flex head or any high end ratchets for anything. I prefer my great neck and craftsman tools because they have lifetime warranty and are easy to get. Although I've only had to replace the 3/8" drive craftsman one time when the handle snapped in half while working on some brakes. I was surprised that the handle broke before the driver especially after the abuse I put it through. I only have a regular 1/4" drive snap on with a short handle and that was actually given to me.
I really like my icon 1/4 flex head. It broke my bell house bolts with a 2 foot cheater. It still works fine.
I went with the Tekton non quick release swivel head ratchets. 1/4",3/8",1/2"drives. I'm really picky about ergonomics and the lowest profile heads with no protruding mechanisms. Having complete control of the socket while in tight spaces is very important. Most inexpensive ratchets are bulky and have alot of resistance when working on finger tight fasteners. This makes them useless in tight spaces when you can't keep the fastener moving in the right direction. You end up using some form of thread sealer to create enough resistance to keep the fastener from spinning back the wrong direction.
I have not picked up the ICON ratchets yet, but I do have the 25" breaker bar. When.. err, if my Kobalt ratchets end up failing, I may pick up the ICON ones. I do have the SAE/Metric deep sockets from ICON, which work as intended. :)
I stick with the icon brand tools just because if they do break I can just walk to the harbor freight next to my house and get it replaced. I have used others and liked them a little more but the convenience of being able to grab a new one if it breaks instead of having to wait to get a new one in the mail is the seller for me.
I like these vids, but (and i make no excuses for snappy if it doesnt win, im not that far) its silly to use an already damaged mechanism. Id love to see you redo that part once you get a new rebuild in. Either way, thank you for doing this. Its entertaining
Have a look at the mechpro ratchets, I bought a set with sockets as I broke my ABW ratchet and I’m really impressed with the quality for the price. I’ve really abused the whole set and it all holds up, apart from the unis which have all broken
I love my tekton tools!
My work is near where all those Auto repair shops, the snap on truck usually came once in 2 weeks. Now, one of the shop owner told me the truck only comes every 2 months.
When it comes to 1/4 ratchets there's no need to buy from snap on there are better options out there for the bucks
TBH you sont really need a snap on on any size. About the only thing I'd buy snap on is their torque wrenches. Everything else is over priced
Tekton doesn't honor their warranty
fourwheelerjock even the torque wrenches are overpriced. Most are rebrands.. like the dual beam torque wrench is a rebranded precision instrument for 5x the cost. That beating said..I will always the their sockets
@@ThadrinC I mainly mean their snap on atech line. Where it has FTLB, unch pounds etc etc all in one, torque to yield. It has all of it in one wrench and some other great features that I havent seen in others yet.
@@path3848 they always have with me. Honestly haven’t used it much though. You’re the 1st person I’ve saw make this claim.
I love my gearwrench 120xp 1/4 flex. I beat on it with stuff I should for sure be using atleast a 3/8 drive and it just keeps going
Tech In the UK here. We have MAC, Snap On and Tool Truck on our tool rounds. I Used to buy snap on. Used to being the operant phrase. Never liked MAC, our rep is a bit of a dick, his van is never stocked and their tools are equally as overpriced as snap on. However, Our Tool truck dealer is an absolute Legend. I only buy from him now and I’m a total Gearwrench junkie now. I bought 9 ratchets for the same price as 4 off snap on with some change. I absolutely reef on them. More so than the Snap on and still not had any problems (had my snap ons rebuilt like 4 times this year)
Morale of the story. These big companies are not your friend and expensive tools don’t make you a better tech.
Gotta take the head size into account.
I have to wonder if an import of the same head size will be as strong as a snapon with new Internals.
'Old' Tekton is going to be sought after if the brand ever goes really mainstream. I have the 3/8 and 1/4 sets. I love them!!!
They are out of stock of most stuff on their website. I hope a price increase isn’t going to come when they re stock
I would say they've hit "mainstream" now!
I was really pulling for the tekton on this one
Love your videos. Is a socket torture test on your radar? Nobody else has done this as far as I know.
I know when i bought my extra long handle 1/4 snap on ratchet it was advertised as withstanding 100ft lbs. I thought to my self. " i could torque log nuts with this baby!" Haha. Its a non quick release. That weakens ratchets because there is a hole and detent ball. Which makes the drive not a solid piece of metal. But end of the day tool truck tools are nice. But generally not worth the cost. Id say certain tools yes. You need snap on or such. Like for instance an o2 sensor socket. Here up north they get very stuck. And cheap ones just flex and round things off. But as a mechanic myself. Id say 1/10 of my tools are truck brands. And i do just fine...
ICON for the win, plus easy to shop for and replace in this case, when necessary.
I love harbor freight but there no reason to buy icon when tekton exists
@@jamfd3s788 why not pittsburgh pro or quinn at that case, I wouldn't recommend the wrenches from pittsburgh, but the sockets and rachets are great
I am a snap on snob however there are many other tool companies offering quality tools at lower prices. I do buy snap on tools when i get a good deal on Ebay. But have been very impressed with some of the ICON tools. A while back wanted 6 point wrenches standard and metric none were made in icon or tekton snap on and sk were to much money for me being on a limited income i ended up buying a set of gearwrench and i will say not bad.
The tekton would have won if it was not quick release
To bad they don't stand behind their product, ask me how I know
@@path3848 Sad.. Tekton swapped out a complete 3/8 quick release ratchet for me just because the quick release button didn't seat properly. I bought a rebuild kit... It's up and running again.
I'm glad you got taken care of, I didn't, as of now, we will see and then I will definitely recant my statement until then, they sold a defective product and did the old brush off technique, I seen it a time or two in the 35 years in the trade, Armstrong did it when gearwrench took over, never again with them, guaranteed I give them more than the 30 dollars in bad press, and yes I'm a sour old prick😂 snappy always did me right though
@@path3848 I feel your pain with the Apex group. I had issues with a wrench and since then I'm switching from Gearwrench to Tekton. I hope Tekton treats you right. Good luck.
Majority of Tekton made in Twain lol
At 4:54 what is the set propped up the the background? It's a red foam base and black top layer. I like the foam organizer!
I prefer being able to go into Harbor Freight where I buy iCon and occasionally Pittsburgh Pro tools. I also own Tekton open/box end combo wrenches, but like to be able to shop, and if need be, exchange in person so iCon my tool of choice.
I own mostly snap on but I picked up a set of icon sockets and a wrench. Icon wrench was pretty good but I returned the sockets. Wrench was worth the money but sockets were junk. Very soft metal and chrome was damaged after just a few uses.
I've had that same Snap On ratchet for many years, and it's never been rebuilt. They have the best locking mechanism compared to the others. As far as actually fixing cars for a living, it helps when the tool stays in the position you set it in. The other ratchets don't work as well. Plus why did you start off with the Snap On ratchet already damaged when the others were brand new.
danc2581 I really do like the locking mechanism on that Snap-On the best. They have a patent on that so you won’t see another just like it for quite a while. The only ratchet that was slightly less used was the Capri Tools. The Snap-On had one pawl with damage under regular use the other pawl inspected and used for this test was fine. They all hit over 37.5 lb-ft which is the only real mark needed to hit to be within spec for ANSI/ASME👍🏻
I don't understand the one sided reviews on these icon ratchets... I am a heavy equipment mechanic and after seeing tons of reviews about these I decided to give one a try. I got the 3/8 stubby I put a socket on it and spun it by hand and the thing locked up and would not switch directions. I took it apart greased it and tried it again got two ratchets on a hose clamp and it stopped.
GARBAGE!!!!!
Every other ratchet I have are snap on's and they work day in and day out. Thanks for another one sided review towards the people giving you free stuff.
Kevin the 3/8 ratchets got recalled just to let you know. I’m not saying those ratchets are better or as good as snap on but they did recall the 3/8.
@@toddosterhout9866 Hey Todd thanks for the heads up! I will take this one back
@@kevhouse55 I bought a 1/4 inch that did the exact same thing. They may have a great warranty system but I really don't want to trade one junk out of the box ratchet for another.
Ive picked up snap on stuff here and there at yard sales and ive found they will break like the rest pretty easy.
Try the Wera Zyklop Ratchet. Would be interested to see how strong that is
I like the duralast ratchets the best, i have the tekton metric socket sets and i like them because there one of the only complete sets i could find at a reasonable price but the shallow sockets are 1/4 inch longer than most others and the deeps are 1/4 inch shorter.
That could be an advantage in certain situations where a standard socket or deep socket wouldn't normally fit. Thanks for letting me know. I may pick up the set now.
The really interesting thing with these sort of tests is how far Asian made and particularly Taiwanese tools have come. Even a modest ratchet will take more than you can give it by hand.
The fact is I'm more afraid of braking a bolt in my car than I am breaking a cheap ratchet like the Pittsburgh brand from harbor freight. I have broken more than just a couple of bolts already thankfully I ve been able to pull them out with vise grips or easy out. So there is no need to overspend on ratchets lol.
My 88 tooth 3/8 drive Snap on cost me 138.
But it's worth it. Nice smooth action. A rachet is used to remove nut or bolt.
Use a pull handle to break shit loose.
I'd like to see SK's X-Frame ratcheting wrench tested to it's claim of 100-150 ft lbs torque.
I have all 3 of tekton quick release ratchets. I like them but find myself using my Gearwrench 90Ts or the icons because the comfort grip. If Tekton had a comfort grip Option I’d be all over them.
Make your own comfort grip
i have been watching the ICON brand and so far I like what I see. What I wish you would add is the warranty of them. They are warrantied to the original owner only? What about snap-on? Also how much trouble to return the ICON? Do they have replacements in stock at HB or is it warrantied through ICON. If you needed the tool to finish the job, could you get it replaced immediately? The Tekton seems easy enough to replace immediately through their website without a receipt?
The thing I absolutely LOVE about TEKTON tools is their sets don't skip any sizes! Not sure about ICON but most of the Pittsburgh sets at HFT skip sizes so you have to buy the SAE & Metric sets.
They do skip size I had to buy the missing ones from tekton lol
I'm going with HF ICON.
On close inspection they drip quality. With HF warranty of no receipt needed and walk in any store for a replacement, it's a win win.
The icon logos on the ratchet look like they were scratched in by hand. You cheap assholes support communism
Try out there warranty.
I had a Snap on 3/8 hand ratchet years ago that the reversing lever kept falling off. I would give it to the tool truck guy to fix and he would just tighten the screw down holding it on. In other words did nothing to fix it because it would keep doing it, one day even falling off without me noticing it. Luckily I found it on the floor. It isn't the best ratchet, there are better ones out there. I won't even get going on the test light I bought from him that lasted less than a year before the clamp end kept coming apart.
I love how this vid has been executed. Now I know for a fact where failure points are, way beyond what your hand can exert given regular laws of physics
Anyone know whether you can still get that Carlyle socket organizer at 3:21?
There is a company called Mechanics Time savers - it appears to be the same and maybe it is.
As a professional I much rather have my tools fixed or replaced asap when the tool truck comes around. Mac. Matco. Snap on. Cornwell visit weekly and that's the difference for me
All you have to do with icon is drive over to your local harbor freight and get a new one. If the tool truck comes on Monday and you break a ratchet in Tuesday you’ll be out a week. Icon you’ll be up and running after a lunch run.
And a lot of companys you just send a picture and they ship it too you usually only takes a couple days less then a week thats for sure
@@Mjc103 driving to HF isn't really feasible because it's 30 min away in a different direction than I live, so the whole trip would be over an hour plus gas after working a 10 hour day. I'd rather text my truck guy and he will bring it to me.
@@mmholling87 that makes no sense at all. You’d rather pay double than spend an hour of your time and gas??? Then you’d rather be out of the tool for 6 days rather than be up in running in a couple hours. Bro listen to yourself. Get off the tool truck koolaid.
@@Mjc103 my time is valuable to me. It's much easier to get more money than it is to get more time. A $140 ratchet isn't a crazy amount of money in the grand scheme of things. Most techs spend more money on tobacco, energy drinks and fast food than their tools.
That tekton flex head with the detent is a steal at $20. Tekton should put a nice grip on that handle, I'd pay extra for that. Who actually manufacturers tekton?
Have you ever done that aluminum handle Titan ratchets with blue accents at autozone?
Thank you !!
For $140 I would expect a lot more. Sounds like paying for the name is a waste of $.
I know, because u are not profesional Doug Lmao
There are torque ratings for each ratchet if you need a lot of torque you would up the drive size 1/4" is not made to be used that way thats like trying to take off tractor lug nuts with a 1/2" ratchet. I buy snap-on for the fine teeth and smooth application but i also have from 1/4" up to 1"
I'd also like to see the comparison of head thickness and reset degrees that's what I look for in a1/4 ratchet this is more a 3/8 or 1/2 test for me
Interesting results between the 4 of them
Hey I have had my snap on for 15 years and use it every day and have only had to have it rebuilt 1 once
Isn't Bahco socket sets availiable in the US? They are some of the most popular tools in Europe most companies i worked uses them, would b interesting to see how it compares, same sort of price tag as harbour freight and Tekton.