Carnivore DEBUNKS Latest Netflix Vegan Film
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 18 янв 2024
- The new vegan Netflix series “You Are What You Eat” has gained a lot of popularity, and a lot of people are questioning the validity of the film. In this video - Ste reacts to controversial clips from the film, and comments why some of the data and results shown in the film, are false vegan propaganda.
Comment below your thoughts!
Shop: www.heartandsoil.co
Follow us on social media!
Instagram: / heartandsoilsupplements
Facebook: / heartandsoilsupplements
Website: heartandsoil.co/
#carnivore #youarewhatyoueat #veganfilm
I would say that about 80% of the women I see in clinic who have menstural/fertility problems are vegan or vegetarian. And I'm seeing a lot of peri-menopausal/menopausal problems in vegan/vegetarian people too.
I'm sure some people are fine with a plant based diet, but it's terrible for some.
I had no idea it contributed to my fertility struggles and miscarriages for so many years. I wish I worked with a provider that helped educate me on what my body needed to sustain life . I am grateful for my journey as I now have two beautiful children by adoption BUT women need to have a practitioner that is guiding them thru this journey in a non judgmental way but that will show them the real data and what eating from sustainable and ethical sources can provide them
Sure.
Vegan nearly killed me. It’s documentaries like this that certainly pushed me into that lifestyle - desire to support the environment, love animals, live longer, etc. but it was by far the most problematic time in my life from a health standpoint.
Multiple miscarriages, ovarian cysts, autoimmune diagnosis, immune system issues, significant gut issues, depression, anxiety . I had no idea I was soooo nutrient depleted and was consuming nearly 75% grains and soy products laden with gmos and toxins. Anyways , I’m not carnivore but I 1000% appreciate eating meat again and that was a huge turning point 5 years ago when I regained my health. I hope people do their due diligence as this documentary bypasses so much in the name of personal belief and agenda.
Too bad they didn't compare teeth...
When they show the results the don’t even show the numbers for the meat eater. The twins that are super fit … never even compared the two. It’s a crock of bullsht.
I'd like to hear how, exactly, we're going to feed the world a vegan diet in a sustainable way -- because thousands of acres of GMO monoculture drenched in pesticides is not my idea of "saving the earth." Not to mention the sheer quantity of plant food humans need to consume to get their nutritional needs met. If we were meant to thrive on plant matter, we'd have two stomachs.
Not to mention all the animals and insects that have to die to maintain those thousands of acres of gmo monoculture fields.
It’s already been shown in a number of studies that far less land would be used.
Let's do a study with twins who were vegan and shifted back to eating meat. To the vegans, yes there are those who go back to normal because they felt not well and fatige in the long-term. Then lets show them regenerative farms, where the meat comes from and how this animals live, let them have raw milk products, eggs from pasture raised chickens, and honey from local bees. I am very confident they will feel well after 30 days and even more in the long-term. Will have a good feeling about the animals they eat, a good relationship to local farmers, and will learn in this process that it is also better for the environment. Those vegans should go to their locations the food gets produced and they will figuer out how much land has to be a mono culture plant farm to get them their organic vegetables where thousands of small animals cant live because of the way the land gets shaped and constantly worked on with heavy equipment. These farms raise micro dust which goes into the same caregory of health issues than living around industrial smog. Also organic farming requires to work on the land more often with heavy equioment, instaed of pesticides, but that leads to an enourmkuse increase in diesel usage and again, disrupts thousands of small animals live. Regenerative farming on the other hand can turn a desert into a green lanscape where thousands of those anned or killed animals from vegetable farming can live a wonderful life. With that the farm goes into negative CO2 in just a few years.
🤣🤣🤣
We need a carnivore Netflix series!
My husband and I would watch this! 😮
meat eater, watch it
I watched this series think how cool a twin study. You can literally get away with watching episodes 1 & 4 that’s still laced with vegan propaganda, but it’s less than the other two. I literally was fast forwarding thru the bullshit until I found the participants on screen. I felt bad for how gullible they were. No one wanted to be vegan at first but then in the end they all were so suggestible that they pretty much said they’d go vegan. The best thing you can do for your self is learn physiology. Know how the body works. When you have this foundation, you don’t get tricked as easily. I think OSU has a free physiology course on RUclips.
Also when she was talking about your microbes eating you when you don’t eat carb, it has a kernel of truth, but it’s not the whole story (surprise, surprise, right?!)
Basically, your mucus degraders (akkermansia, fecalibacterium pruznitzii, and rosburia) love polyphenols (from red fruits raspberries, cherries etc) when they don’t have food (such as during a fast or fasted sleep or even keto people) they break down the mucus to create short chain fatty acids (fuel for a healthy colon). It is only a problem if your cells of your colon are not differentiated (don’t have different cell types with different functions) goblet cells get the signal that the mucus is being degraded when they sense short chain fatty acid production and they produce new fresh mucus. It’s healthy to do so. So she was saying a bold statement without giving any context of the physiology happening.
Ok Kevin, I have to follow you wherever you publish. I have been reading books and listening to podcasts for two years now from some brilliant minds, devouring the science on nutrition (picking up where I left off in my passion for the academic side of it in my 20s--that's decades ago) but I have not yet heard or read what you just explained about the gut. I can tell you I went cross-eyed when I heard that "will eat you" come out of her mouth. What does she think about autophagy?
I watched most of this Netflix show and honestly I knew they would push the vegan diet. All I can say is when I was 18 I tried vegan for 8 months and wound up with a world of health problems. Since eating mostly meat, light carbs, and healthy fats... I've felt my best and have had a lot of energy.
i have yet 2CA logically con sistent argue ment against veganism thanks 4 this bum dass ram dass ja mai can ging her i hardly even know her❣
After listening to years and years of restrictive answers, I finally figured it out. DIVERSITY. REAL FOOD. Pay attention and listen to your body for your personal needs. Powders and pills are marketing. And if someone makes a sacrifice for humane reasons, support them because it is valid. Occam’s razor.
If you put asparagus in front of me, I will probably wonder if you don’t like me. It makes pee and semen smell bad.
I think you made a couple good points, but I feel you overstepped in some areas.
I think you could have presented the points without adding a couple of things:
1) telomere length you could have probably left alone.
2) tackle of visceral fat in a separate way.
However it was fun looking at a rebuttal. I usually ignore single studies as its a low yield of data compared to other study analysis reports.
Whatever propaganda Netflix is pushing makes me automatically go to the extreme opposite. We d'ced out subscription over 2 years ago and haven't missed it at all.
poor twins, often experimented upon 😮
You think like I do. I am a new subscriber.
I eat a ribeye steak every night for dinner. I have eggs every day for breakfast. Just so tired of the lies about "you need carbs", my IBS is corrected by dropping the plants.
Let them fools eat the crap! I eat steaks! I see my abs again! Yeaaahh buddy. Feel better than 20 years ago. Go my lionssssss woaaaa🎉
Everything is bad for you now...even breathing.
I do feel confused though….
i understand being nourished by healthy animal glands, but what if a person has weak kidneys?
Doesn’t protein put a unique strain on kidneys?
Protein only puts strain on STRAINED kidneys. Strains kidneys on a CBC blood panel is found by your eGFR. If you are below 50, your kidneys are strained and you need to be on a low protein diet decide you go into the stages of kidney disease. Prior to that eating MORE protein is protective. Protein in Greek means “of first importance” because it is one of the most important macronutrients. Your body is made of protein, your immune system is made of protein, your receptors on your cells are made of protein, your enzymes to digest food are made of protein. Your DNA has instructions called RNA and that goes to the ribosomes in the cells to basically manufacture proteins for literally everything. Don’t get caught up in the vegan lie that you don’t need “that much protein”
@@KevinDaniArnold I appreciate your generous reply. I’m going to try to wrap my mind around this. I think most people probably have weak kidneys and what if so much protein is truly creating a problem for the near future? What does a day look like in your food life?
@@user-kk6ov4pd2s granola for breakfast (and beef based vitamin supplements) , 1/2 lb slab of beef for lunch, and what ever i can grab for dinner (usually meat) clearly i don't have weak kidneys, if i did i'd be dead already.
My vegan mother-in-law is bedridden. Still waiting for it to work. It has been 8 years.
That's sad; I am sorry you are both going through that. It really is hard to listen to your innate wisdom and buy into the agendas of the powerful around us. It is right up there with all the fraud committed by TV evangelists. It is really, really sad.
Millions of non-vegans die every year. Guess carnism is debunked!
@@ohsnapples5220Carnism doesn’t exist
give her a dang steak. if she freaks it is a prank. if she gets better you be her favorite in-law
I'd recommend listening to different health related podcast even if you disagree with differences of opinions. It's more nuanced that way. Anti meat Netflix documentaries debunk themselves.
🌚🌝
What if conventional farming of the land, i.e. tilling, spraying etc, is causing global warming?
Oh, it is!? Well then 😏 Continue.
Meat!
Fake News, but ignorance is bliss, so smile on.
all vegans should living vegan until the end of their lives and passing this on to their children and grandchildren, who also remain vegan for life. As far as I have researched, there would hardly be a fourth generation and after the fifth generation the discussion would probably be over . Until a few centuries later someone came up with the idea again.
I am not a carnivore and I doubt that it is necessary for humans to eat this way.
Researched🤣🤣🤣
Debunks, this is some rhetoric bullshit.
I have never seen your channel before, so I’m not familiar with your usual take on things. I will say that I agree that the documentary does kind of push the vegan narrative and is definitely more pro vegan. (I watched the whole documentary just the other day). However, I am also a registered dietitian and as someone who has studied nutrition for many years, I believe there are some benefits to the vegan diet. I’m not saying meat is entirely bad. For people who are obese, have cardiovascular disease, or other comorbidities, certain meats being avoided and replaced with options that are much lower in saturated fat and sodium will be more beneficial for these individuals to reduce their health issues. I noticed you didn’t necessarily address the visceral fat statistics in this study and I will say that is definitely a positive indicator for some of those individuals who were on the vegan diet.
As for the muscle loss/gain, it is much more difficult to sustain muscle growth on a vegan diet. You have to eat more food and also make sure that you are getting complementary plant proteins. It is not impossible, but definitely harder since the plant protein is not as bioavailable as protein from animals. These participants may not have been used to eating that much food before and likely had a hard time adhering to the vegan diet.
In my personal opinion, I don’t think meat needs to be cut out entirely to live a healthy/enjoyable life. However, people need to focus on consuming lean meat and reducing the amount of highly processed meat like lunchmeat, bacon, canned meat, hotdogs, etc. I am glad you also acknowledged the issues in the meat industry right now. I think there is much to be fixed with it in order to make it more sustainable and convince those that purchase the products that they are coming from ethical and clean sources.
Interesting take on the documentary overall. I always love to see new perspectives. I wouldn’t say that I entirely agree with you since I know that vegetables are very beneficial for us, but still good to see another side of the story! Best of luck!
The key thing to know about Heart &Soil and other proponents of healthy animal-based eating is that regenerative farming -- the practice of raising animals in a responsible, sustainable, carbon-negative way -- is absolutely key to everything. Factory farming is one thing we can all agree is a problem. But the vegans don't seem to be calling out the factory farming of plants -- the overuse of GMOs, monocultures and pesticides -- as a problem, even as our soil is depleted and our aquifers are poisoned by factory farming of wheat, corn, and soybeans.
Your comment is very thoughtful. I think you might want to investigate books on the cholesterol myth and also read Susan Norton's works on oxylates. There is so much cutting edge science out there that the framework for your perspective on nutrition contradicts. Wishing you the best also!!
I'm sorry to be the A-hole here, but everything you believe about nutrition was fabricated nonsense (blame SDA and greed). You are a tool...a cog in the system...spreading the myth they created to profit on the other end when they sell the solution. Companies like Nestle sell the medication to treat diabetics as well as the food that causes diabetes. I know you have good intentions and my mother did as well when she fed us low-fat produce rich meals. Spend some spare time listening to the prominent voices in the animal based community. They are well educated and think for themselves as well. Jesse Chappus has interviewed some of the best on his channel and Kent Carnivore edits key clips to efficiently highly important concepts. Bless you for trying to do the right thing 🙏
@@tracylunquist836I will agree that there are definitely issues on both sides and neither are a perfect system by any means. Some new things to look for in the future on both sides:
1) pro vegan side - indoor vertical farming
2) pro meat side - lab grown meat
Just some things on both side that could make things more sustainable in the future:)
@@cheriejohnston3062hi! I’m not exactly sure what you mean by the “cholesterol myth”. I tried looking it up, but I’m not sure what it was there that you were specifically speaking on. As for oxalates, I understand that they can be found in some plant foods. These compounds can decrease the absorption of some vitamins and minerals, but the benefits of consuming foods with oxalates highly outweighs the few negative effects. Although, I would be interested to hear more about some of the new nutrition science that you mentioned contradict my earlier points.
The last thing we need is yet another vegan documentary. Great takedown!
It seems like you deleted my longer post since you did not like me saying you did not debunk anything in this video so I will shorten it to the most stupid claim you did in your profil.
Maybe you wanna answer to this :D
Copy paste of deleted post:
Lol. Another weird claim in your info "ur ancestors were physically active in their 70’s! Overall, they were healthier and stronger than we are today. What was their secret? Eating animals nose to tail." LOL? I have no idea if you believe that yourself the life expactancy was about 20-30 years back then??
Triving in their 70's?
Noone even got 50 xDDD
It’s garbled rhetoric.
pre industrial-age life span estimates were heavily skewed to the younger ages due to infant mortality rates and mass death events. usually if you made it by age 5 you would live a full life.
Ok, like always, every time I see someone trying to debunk vegan documentaries, they are the ones being completely bias. And you all lie to your audience like they were children. People who see your video should see this documentary first to see how inaccurate and bias you are being. This is nothing but a meat and dairy propaganda.
It's not a coincidence that the most ethical diet is the healthiest diet and the most environmentally sustainable diet. GO VEGAN!
Nice misinformation cult drone
Just kidding, you're correct. I'm going vegan!
Vegan diet is far from the most environmentally sustainable. As our ancestors knew all too well.
😂 good luck out there
@@8599nissassA imagine being so triggered you make an alt
I have no problem with people occasionally having a little bit of meat or fish in their diet, maybe once a week. But the healthiest diet has been shown again to be largely plant-based. Why this is even discussed and debated as beyond me.
They’re false, cherry picked studies. Lol. And why would you have a problem with anything anyone does? Mind your business
@@Snakey_McSnake every study is false? I bet the earth is flat too right?
And I’m concerned about what other people do because it burdens the healthcare system and it’s not good for them. When you eat meat you promote disease.
Yes but Hunter Biden smokes parmesan cheese 😅