I disagree that Stockton Rush wanted to die and become posthumously famous for his efforts; he had way too much hubris for that. He just thought he was smarter than everyone and saw himself as 10 foot tall and bulletproof.
@@cityman1111 that’s true according to what rush said. that’s even worse - the maximum pressure changing an airplane is less than 15 psi generally, the submersible was over 5000 psi. If it was not good for Boeing at 15 psi, it’s definitely not gonna do very well at pressures over 5000 psi!
@@kenday7942 it seems that he didn't understand the forces involved with the pressure at that depth, it was just numbers and because he'd designed planes that flew a sub would work because he designed it, he had no background or knowledge of the deep sea environment
@@shaunmcclory8117 Exactly! - Two VERY different environments with VERY different parameters- requiring VERY different design solutions. He should have listened to the experts experienced in deep sea exploration. (By-the-way - as far as I know Stockton Rush never actually had any design experience - he just piloted aircraft. He did not even have an engineering degree - he had a Bachelor of Arts degree and an MBA.)
Stockton Mush 100% did dives unrecorded. Hence why this time it imploded, he did well to make it as far as he did in his little trash can. Pure greed from this man build something cheap and rake in the profits if there were any? I’m starting to think he probably owed 10’s of millions to run this suicidal project. There’s a video somewhere that says the polar prince would’ve set Oceangate back $250,000-500,000 per toe to the Titanic area. Not to mention crew costs, this story is fascinating but sad for the crew bar Stockton. He rolled the dice every single time
There's no remains to be consumed. The bodies were liquified and vaporised by the implosion. It was found that there were gelatine-like puddles in the wreckage that was presumed to be the last remnants of the liquified bodies that didin't just wash away.
I think it did. Not like THIS guy is talking about though. Titan wasn't profitable. It lost money. It would have taken so long for them to even begin to break even and Rush knew this from the start. Now, there was likely some greed and want for status. Just not the top priority.
I doubt he wanted to be remembered as a murderer. There was a high level of arrogance, and a disbelief something really bad would happen - especially to him. Once all the hearings are over, he should be only be remembered as a footnote. The victims should be the names that are remembered.
All you have to do is look at the Titanium ring. Its almost perfectly smooth (in the debris field) . There is no glue or epoxy bonding on any of it. The Carbon Fibre hull was compressed and cycled so many times that it torqued the joint until it all failed at once. If you watch the video of them mating the two surfaces you'll see they took no time to abrade or sand blast the ring. It was just heaping the epoxy on like peanut butter and then lowering the titanium onto the CF. Then expecting this to resist the 4 tons of compression per dive. Sure it will work 2 or 3 times.
Sorry, this is preposterous. So, Stockton killed himself so he would be famous??? Thats what this guy is implying. The answer is obvious; Stockton thought he was a genius and smarter than everyone else... and he was out to prove it.
Yeah no big mystery here I think. He was a dumbass megalomaniac that decided to try and "move fast and break things" in an industry where that philosophy doesn't exist for good reason. The moment you disrespect the ocean, it kills you.
If he got to the point where he realized his choices were bankruptcy or death, he may not have cared to face the bankruptcy. I'm with you, though, I'm not sure that was about wanting to be a posthumous hero so much as wanting not to face the inevitable mess. If he had also been a more decent person, he would have gone down alone.
I think it's cool as hell I jus wonder if you scaled the ocean down to its size compared to the real subs size how deep it would dive or if it would imploded.maybe Stockton shoulda tried 3d printing a sub instead of carbon fiber
I think the collapse of the Twin Towers is the closest match to what happened to the remains. It was really a miracle if loved ones actually had remains to bury. I think the same applies here.
Similar yes, but the extreme shock wave of ultrahigh aluminum enriched explosives used not only dustified the concrete flooring but also instantly fragmented bodies.
Has to be. It pronounces the same words and names multiple different ways and randomly goes back and forth between different pronunciations, for example "Ro-has" and "Ro-jas." In one video it pronounced "dives" as "deeves." It's also very low quality sound editing as there are sometimes abrupt skips or cuts mid-sentence that arent even fixed or edited out. It's content mill quality.
I don't think you are quite understanding how much energy is involved in an event like this. You are thinking about the pressure at that depth and what happens to a human under that pressure. But you need to think about the velocity and acceleration forces that happen in the implossion. A huge amount of energy is released (by the water column essentially falling into the space the pressure vessel was taking up). It would have got very hot very quickly, you also have the impact of the water (i.e. the momentum transfer from the water having been accelerated into that space), and like a large amount of shrapnel from the vessel disintegration. Its entierly possible that the people were shredded and momentarily evaporated. Have you ever seen the experiment where we light cotton using a plunger in a cylinder? There is a reason the US navy were the first ones to know about the implossion (IUSS).
They test, X-ray, magnaflux, inspect and scrutinize race cars for the Indiana 500 one hundred times more than this deep dive submersible was ever tested.
So - what did (c)Rush do RIGHT? Let's have a looksee at the M.E.L. (Minimum Equipment List) 1- Solid design; signed off by the appropriate experts? - doodled on the back of a cereal packet one morning, 2- The 18 bolts upfront? - at least a dozen, rolling around the deck topsides, 2- Safety/survival equipment? - the best-looking kit ever - on a table back at base, 3- Emergency ballast blow? - some rusty weights, 4- Duly tested? - nope, we're unable to retrieve them, 5- Backup communications? - we all yell; VERY LOUDLY, 6- Ongoing emergency protocol(s) with the U.S. Coast Guard? - NAH! We're MISSION SPECIALISTS! 7- Backup hardware? - someone's wearing a St. Jude medal, 8. Understanding/appreciation of the rudimentary laws of physics which apply? - you kiddin'? 9. C.E.O. arrogance - almost unlimited supply, 10. Ditto hubris? - on each and every dive. Remember the footage of that guy applying the 'glue' - resting his hand on the ring? I seem to recall (from schoolboy chemistry, back in the day), that's an instant point of compromise/failure of the chemical composition (electrolytes on the skin?). Yes/no? Please advise, I'm keen to learn.....
There's video of the chief engineer mixing that epoxy in a bucket with a stick. I CRINGE when I see it! 😖 We're watching him make ICE CREAM with epoxy: FULL of air bubbles. 🤦💔 I'm not even a pro with epoxies, but I KNOW how bad air bubbles are in it! Apparently I KNOW more than their chief engineer.
They could have put it through a pressure chamber to force out the bubbles but that depends on the epoxy and if they're willing to wait a few more mins
Not only that, but they also applied the epoxy to the carbon fibre by hand in a garage! I was surprised because no life-critical carbon fibre parts in the automotive industry are required to be produced by the robots in a clean room to ensure no air bubbles and even distribution of epoxy for optimal performance and durability.
Stocton's explanation/hypothesis about the cause of the "loud bang" is telling in a "say the quiet part out loud" kind of way. If the hull "returning to its original state" caused that violent of a reaction, it means it was deformed enough to do so. Kinda like an earthquake.
The carbon fiber tube hull was wound totally circumfrentially uniaxial. This results in very low compressive strength to resist compressive loading applied by the titanium end caps at depth. Initially this will result in delamination splitting which correlates with the snapping and popping heard inside the hull while descending. With sufficient delamination the tube will lose stability and suddenly crush under pressure. The entire hull should have been made of titanium like some modern submarines.
The way that you're showing that picture of the wreckage next to the picture of the titan, makes me think that you are showing it as the front of the submersible, but it is not the front is the back.
Finally, someone saying 'yeah, if you had access to information about these projects, then you knew this was going to happen' and not 'oh, this is terrible, I can't believe that as the generic executive director that I am that I had no clue this would happen'. Bullshit.
Stockton Rush is just like Ted Faro from the Horizon video games. So obsessed with marking his name in history and maximum profits that he unwittingly crafted the instrument of his own destruction.
It's pretty obvious that the water worked it's way between the ring which started a delamination. Through subsequent dives and rising, the water would've kept squeezing with great force, relief, and more force. It's surprising it lasted as long as it did. I'm guessing Rush was just fixated because of company finances wouldn't bear another prototype.
I don't know why I haven't seen anyone else pick up on this but in the video footage showing the front end cap in the ocean floor, just a few feet to the right I can clearly see a decapitated head with severe cuts to the face, obviously from the debris in the rapidly implosion. You can see it on some of the other videos when you rotate the picture 90° clockwise. If you don't turn the picture 90° clockwise it can be difficult to make out. edit: I wanted to say it looks similar to a mask, if that helps anyone who looks for it.
The facts and testimony will continue to come out, and so will the videos. One intriguing question one could ask is what would some of the survivors of the Titanic tragedy have thought of Stockton Rush and his inevitably, deadly contraption?
If someone could have showed Rush a picture of what the sub would have look like after an implosion his response would have been "get away from me boy yuh bother me" - I cannot find the shred of sympathy in the story
If what your saying or their trying to make him out to be I have nun either .I don't think Stockton was anything like a murder or commitef suicide.i think he was a arrogant prick who thought he new more than what he did I don't think he new it would imploded I think he was a crazed greedy bastard that wanted fame an fortune an he thought he new more than the engineers.i think he made it to the Titanic an he didn't understand about life cycles an delamination he thought I made once good to go anytime you want..he was a smart man but anyone outheir that thinks their to smart to learn anything else in life or their smarter than everybody else is the most ignorant person in the world.id say he owe millions an had to pay that back an thought he could jus use that sub anyway or anytime he wanted an said screw the regulations I made it to the Titanic once I can go as many times as I want .
11:28 I think the orange stuff maybe is blood or it could be rust. The camera is close, so a huge depth underwater really wouldn't make much difference on the color because the camera itself is close to what it's recording. The type of light being used is also a warm toned light with the full spectrum of color (compared to a blue, green, red light). So the perception of the color of the objects it's recording wouldn't be too different than what it really is above the surface. Also, the orange substance is spread out on multiple surfaces
So, to be clear. Said vehicle imploded a year after this 'loud bang' took place. But the fact that they may be related and show that there was stress on the structure and likely shows there were blatant signs that it was failing is just a matter of opinion........
My personal bet is that, if they found anything more than a few pasty smears, it was teeth. Teeth are surprisingly durable, wouldn't be visible on footage, and I don't *know* that the pressure wouldn't have liquefied them, but I think they'd be the more survivable bits as well as contain DNA. Kind of hoping they'll tell us what was found, though.
The remains were compressed into the rear dome with all the carbon fiber debris. There was a pink goo inside the rear dome that contained DNA of all the occupants.
Imho, the safety record of 50 years still stands, Titan wasn't classified and shouldn't tarnish the reputation of the rest of the submersible community.
Y'know of Professor Reason (University of Manchester) & his 'Swiss Cheese' Model - the general cause(s) of aviation accidents? T'was originally applied to the medical arena, now aviation (big time). With Rush & Oceangrave, all the elements lined up to create ONE BIG HOLE, meaning this was not just inevitable but almost totally predictable......
any billionaire not having the state of mind doing their own research before going,has made a choice...only the kid was a real victim,and the dad the only one guilty.....
The body compresses like the styrofoam foam Oceangate used to show the pressure at depth - everything comes out of all the available holes & the skull is crushed like an egg shell!! The air is compressed & heated!! And you’re in the middle - ouch!!
Inquiries look to pin point why a disaster occured. This will be the first time in history the conclusion will be "Take your pick" atop an enormous list of failures.
Stockon was too concerned with 'making history' for the wrong reasons, that being fame. I HATE personalities like that; people who get into hobbies, professions, and other things with the only being the 'face' of said thing without actually contributing towards it or even enjoying it. They often mess up and destroy the groups they get into and leave it when they don't get what they want QUICKLY, leaving those who actually gave an F with the trash to clean up. Rush set back research but in his hubris, he's highlighted why safety is VERY IMPORTANT.
"No strain data is available for dives conducted in 2023..." SR's version of, "If you don't document it (anomalous strain sensor data), it didn't happen." 🤔🙄🤦
A biological paste was found inside the collapsed rear portion of the sub which was found to contain the DNA of the deceased crew. That's what the "presumed human remains" were.
The remains--and they would be remains, not bodies--would be very, very small. What I've heard so far is that they found a "pastelike substance" on some of the wreckage, which, when tested, had DNA from the 5 people on board. They would have been subjected to a water hammer effect over 2 milliseconds with about 400 atmospheres behind it, about like dropping a building on them. Humans are not built of material that stands up to that. I think the xkcd quote was that they stopped being biology and started being physics. One orthopedist has a RUclips video about it. Fortunately, it takes tens of milliseconds for the nervous system to perceive anything, so there was not time to feel or even realize anything once the failure started.
He was as psychopathic as Elizabeth Holmes. They both operated the same way, with desire for a dream to work and as CEO, to keep the company afloat and bills/salaries to pay, by all means possible. They loved limelight, they repeated the same lies of things to cover up/cope with what they were guilty of. In constant denials. They didn’t care if their negligence cost catastrophic outcomes to someone’s life or medical decisions. Cavalier attitude. They came too deep in their own lies that they had to continue them no matter at what cost. That includes avoiding regulation, getting NDA signed by employees (Rush with the waiver forms), more lies and deceptions, firing employees and later sued them, restricting important information to employees or isolating their workplaces to manipulate outcomes, etc. Basically, same behavior pattern exhibited by psychopathic individuals with position of power.
It's so unfortunate Elon not being into submersibles as well.. But now that I think about it he probably wouldn't have the balls to do anything more risky than carrying around sinks - he's the owner of a for once admittedly surprisingly successful space flight company (likely because his role is limited to providing funding and playing it off as an personal achievement of his while qualified people putting in their blood and sweat into making things work behind the scenes) after all - if I was in his position I definitly would have gone up there just as Branson and Bezos did with their respective hobby projects.. Well, I'm actually quite happy to not be because being a billionaire inherently requires a shocking lack of morals and character to begin with - there's no such thing as a "good billionaire", an utter oxymoron.
Beleave me he did not want to die. He just thought he was smarter than every one else. So he did not listen to anyone. And he was a vary smart man.But he had no common sense .There are a lot of people like me that are not sub people at all and we knew that thing was not going to hold up under that kind of pressure. We have common sense. No where close to how smart he was but common sense.
I'll explain the bodies or lack thereof, they are smushed into a combined paste and smeared in the small grooves and around into tiny places, we have found paste in this example too, looks like the failed Krabby patty recipe you see plankton make in SpongeBob in color
Some people are complaining the Titan model is tasteless. Nothing new here. One month after the Titanic disaster, survivor Dorothy Gibson made a movie How I was Saved from the Titanic, wearing the clothes she wore that night for added realism. People complained a Titanic movie was crass and tasteless. Little did they suspect...........
My main issue is time. I'm not sure how much time is needed before it's _less_ tasteless. Humor is tragedy + time, but time is relative. One year is too soon, IMO.
@@LadyhawksLairDotCom Attitude also matters greatly. There have been movies about the Columbine Murders and 9/11, but I am OK with ones that respect the victims as human beings.
To me what he did was murder still may not look like he’s capable of murder but his intentions were arrogant and cheap narcissistic and fired ppl for warning him to me it is baffling me but to drag 4 ppl unsafe submersible sub then it is murder
Your content was good but it doesn't seem right to sell these miniature sub in respect for innocent people who died in the sub. It seems cringy to buy this thinking that it caused people's death.
Yes he is responsible for the deaths of those people, including a 19 year old boy, but suggesting that Rush wanted this to happen is cruel and not correct. He was a person too, and he leaves behind grieving loved ones too. His children and wife could be reading this right now. At least he did something with his life! If all he cared about was making money, he would not have chosen deep sea exploration of all things.
I disagree that Stockton Rush wanted to die and become posthumously famous for his efforts; he had way too much hubris for that. He just thought he was smarter than everyone and saw himself as 10 foot tall and bulletproof.
Bingo.
He bought the material from Boeing who decided that this material was unfit for Boeing's use.
@@cityman1111 that’s true according to what rush said. that’s even worse - the maximum pressure changing an airplane is less than 15 psi generally, the submersible was over 5000 psi. If it was not good for Boeing at 15 psi, it’s definitely not gonna do very well at pressures over 5000 psi!
@@kenday7942 it seems that he didn't understand the forces involved with the pressure at that depth, it was just numbers and because he'd designed planes that flew a sub would work because he designed it, he had no background or knowledge of the deep sea environment
@@shaunmcclory8117 Exactly! - Two VERY different environments with VERY different parameters- requiring VERY different design solutions. He should have listened to the experts experienced in deep sea exploration. (By-the-way - as far as I know Stockton Rush never actually had any design experience - he just piloted aircraft. He did not even have an engineering degree - he had a Bachelor of Arts degree and an MBA.)
This is a debacle that should be taught in school as a cautionary tale on arrogance.
Just like Titanic was taught to us in school...
Schools, specifically public schools, don't even teach stuff that's beneficial.
The odds of them adding something Educational is Slim to None!
Education doesn't help if you deal with a narcissist.
Cause he's always right and everyone else is wrong!
Stockton Mush 100% did dives unrecorded. Hence why this time it imploded, he did well to make it as far as he did in his little trash can. Pure greed from this man build something cheap and rake in the profits if there were any? I’m starting to think he probably owed 10’s of millions to run this suicidal project. There’s a video somewhere that says the polar prince would’ve set Oceangate back $250,000-500,000 per toe to the Titanic area. Not to mention crew costs, this story is fascinating but sad for the crew bar Stockton. He rolled the dice every single time
Stockton Mush 😭😭 diabolical
They all followed him without any critical thinking, they’re all complicit come on now
Oh the wisdom of a poor man…
You know... The story can't "completely" change with every upload. And it doesn't.
There's no remains to be consumed. The bodies were liquified and vaporised by the implosion. It was found that there were gelatine-like puddles in the wreckage that was presumed to be the last remnants of the liquified bodies that didin't just wash away.
I had heard that the gelatin like substance contained the DNA of all five on board.
@@timpmenznot saying you’re wrong. Where did you read this? I’d like to check it out
@@timpmenzyeah can you tell us the source?
Yes and no. Without knowing what happened, you don't know. Just "implosion"
@@Faesharlyn you can rush DNA in certain circumstances.
In such a submersible, I would consider adding a black box that include audio and video recordings.
It had nothing to do with leaving a legacy. It had everything to do with greed and arrogance.
I think it did. Not like THIS guy is talking about though.
Titan wasn't profitable. It lost money. It would have taken so long for them to even begin to break even and Rush knew this from the start.
Now, there was likely some greed and want for status. Just not the top priority.
Why tf would u put the winners private email in the video?
It's also weird that he's selling a miniature of the submersible that became a coffin.
@@0tt0z can't disagree, however I'm not surprised. There are people that buy morbid shit of all types lol.
@@SmoteMyRuin True. 😆
@@0tt0z Why not? People are buying miniature Titanic models all the times.
@@0tt0zAl least the price dropped by half. Would’ve been pissed if I paid $80 for it a week ago
I doubt he wanted to be remembered as a murderer. There was a high level of arrogance, and a disbelief something really bad would happen - especially to him. Once all the hearings are over, he should be only be remembered as a footnote. The victims should be the names that are remembered.
Remembered as people with more money then common sense.
This sub was a death trap he killed them all and his wife should be questioned by police this is a crime called murder
Maybe hide those email addresses and do a little better obscuring the post addresses? Yikes.
Agreed, that shocked me.
All you have to do is look at the Titanium ring. Its almost perfectly smooth (in the debris field) . There is no glue or epoxy bonding on any of it. The Carbon Fibre hull was compressed and cycled so many times that it torqued the joint until it all failed at once. If you watch the video of them mating the two surfaces you'll see they took no time to abrade or sand blast the ring. It was just heaping the epoxy on like peanut butter and then lowering the titanium onto the CF. Then expecting this to resist the 4 tons of compression per dive. Sure it will work 2 or 3 times.
10:53 oof that AI can't figure that sentence out
Sorry, this is preposterous.
So, Stockton killed himself so he would be famous???
Thats what this guy is implying.
The answer is obvious; Stockton thought he was a genius and smarter than everyone else... and he was out to prove it.
Yeah no big mystery here I think. He was a dumbass megalomaniac that decided to try and "move fast and break things" in an industry where that philosophy doesn't exist for good reason. The moment you disrespect the ocean, it kills you.
If he got to the point where he realized his choices were bankruptcy or death, he may not have cared to face the bankruptcy. I'm with you, though, I'm not sure that was about wanting to be a posthumous hero so much as wanting not to face the inevitable mess. If he had also been a more decent person, he would have gone down alone.
That mini sub model looks pretty sweet!
I think it's cool as hell I jus wonder if you scaled the ocean down to its size compared to the real subs size how deep it would dive or if it would imploded.maybe Stockton shoulda tried 3d printing a sub instead of carbon fiber
I think the collapse of the Twin Towers is the closest match to what happened to the remains. It was really a miracle if loved ones actually had remains to bury. I think the same applies here.
Similar yes, but the extreme shock wave of ultrahigh aluminum enriched explosives used not only dustified the concrete flooring but also instantly fragmented bodies.
My cousin who lived in manhattan said they put each piece of remains in a fridge to dna test, which they’re still doing to this day. 😢
Is this AI generated speech?
Has to be. It pronounces the same words and names multiple different ways and randomly goes back and forth between different pronunciations, for example "Ro-has" and "Ro-jas." In one video it pronounced "dives" as "deeves." It's also very low quality sound editing as there are sometimes abrupt skips or cuts mid-sentence that arent even fixed or edited out. It's content mill quality.
Its sickning how these thumbnails are always the same exact bait
Are there any of those subs left? The NTSB should test those to see just how bad they are.
This might of worked if they kept up maintenance on the sub and actually listened to their engineers.
I don't think you are quite understanding how much energy is involved in an event like this. You are thinking about the pressure at that depth and what happens to a human under that pressure. But you need to think about the velocity and acceleration forces that happen in the implossion.
A huge amount of energy is released (by the water column essentially falling into the space the pressure vessel was taking up). It would have got very hot very quickly, you also have the impact of the water (i.e. the momentum transfer from the water having been accelerated into that space), and like a large amount of shrapnel from the vessel disintegration. Its entierly possible that the people were shredded and momentarily evaporated.
Have you ever seen the experiment where we light cotton using a plunger in a cylinder?
There is a reason the US navy were the first ones to know about the implossion (IUSS).
They test, X-ray, magnaflux, inspect and scrutinize race cars for the Indiana 500 one hundred times more than this deep dive submersible was ever tested.
So - what did (c)Rush do RIGHT? Let's have a looksee at the M.E.L. (Minimum Equipment List)
1- Solid design; signed off by the appropriate experts? - doodled on the back of a cereal packet one morning,
2- The 18 bolts upfront? - at least a dozen, rolling around the deck topsides,
2- Safety/survival equipment? - the best-looking kit ever - on a table back at base,
3- Emergency ballast blow? - some rusty weights,
4- Duly tested? - nope, we're unable to retrieve them,
5- Backup communications? - we all yell; VERY LOUDLY,
6- Ongoing emergency protocol(s) with the U.S. Coast Guard? - NAH! We're MISSION SPECIALISTS!
7- Backup hardware? - someone's wearing a St. Jude medal,
8. Understanding/appreciation of the rudimentary laws of physics which apply? - you kiddin'?
9. C.E.O. arrogance - almost unlimited supply,
10. Ditto hubris? - on each and every dive.
Remember the footage of that guy applying the 'glue' - resting his hand on the ring? I seem to recall (from schoolboy chemistry, back in the day), that's an instant point of compromise/failure of the chemical composition (electrolytes on the skin?). Yes/no? Please advise, I'm keen to learn.....
Rush will be remembered for the rules he broke and the murder of 4 individuals! Darwin Award?
Your content is good but the constant peddling of those Titan replicas is really in poor taste.
Agreed. Very ick
How disgusting giving little titan toys … and the indulging of body parts? This is awful
Poor poor taste
Indeed.
They are cute and whimsical ... what's wrong with you people?
I disagree. There are million of replicas Titanics in the world, and nobody is crying that that is poor taste. There's actually one in my house.
I would love to have a Titan model on my desk!
There's video of the chief engineer mixing that epoxy in a bucket with a stick. I CRINGE when I see it! 😖
We're watching him make ICE CREAM with epoxy: FULL of air bubbles. 🤦💔
I'm not even a pro with epoxies, but I KNOW how bad air bubbles are in it! Apparently I KNOW more than their chief engineer.
They could have put it through a pressure chamber to force out the bubbles but that depends on the epoxy and if they're willing to wait a few more mins
Not only that, but they also applied the epoxy to the carbon fibre by hand in a garage! I was surprised because no life-critical carbon fibre parts in the automotive industry are required to be produced by the robots in a clean room to ensure no air bubbles and even distribution of epoxy for optimal performance and durability.
stockton mush is a hero, and a legend, advancing submersible technology to the next level, he will be dearly missed.
He left a real mark on history. A skid mark. Dude is the definition of Dunning-Kruger. Also looks like you just parshly doxxed 3 people...
What's with the AI voice?
Stocton's explanation/hypothesis about the cause of the "loud bang" is telling in a "say the quiet part out loud" kind of way. If the hull "returning to its original state" caused that violent of a reaction, it means it was deformed enough to do so. Kinda like an earthquake.
The carbon fiber tube hull was wound totally circumfrentially uniaxial. This results in very low compressive strength to resist compressive loading applied by the titanium end caps at depth. Initially this will result in delamination splitting which correlates with the snapping and popping heard inside the hull while descending. With sufficient delamination the tube will lose stability and suddenly crush under pressure. The entire hull should have been made of titanium like some modern submarines.
The way that you're showing that picture of the wreckage next to the picture of the titan, makes me think that you are showing it as the front of the submersible, but it is not the front is the back.
Click bait video 11 in less than a week
I really like your videos, however, the fact that your making money off a replica of a tragedy, idk it’s just not sitting right with my soul.
Blame the millionaires that gambled with their lives to make this lil bit of joy and happiness with a shitty plastic submarine possible
Finally, someone saying 'yeah, if you had access to information about these projects, then you knew this was going to happen' and not 'oh, this is terrible, I can't believe that as the generic executive director that I am that I had no clue this would happen'. Bullshit.
Stockton was a better salesman than shipbuilder.
Stockton Rush is just like Ted Faro from the Horizon video games. So obsessed with marking his name in history and maximum profits that he unwittingly crafted the instrument of his own destruction.
Snap, Crackle, Pop would have been a more fitting name for the submersible.
It's pretty obvious that the water worked it's way between the ring which started a delamination. Through subsequent dives and rising, the water would've kept squeezing with great force, relief, and more force. It's surprising it lasted as long as it did. I'm guessing Rush was just fixated because of company finances wouldn't bear another prototype.
Stockton "Rushed" that whole project.
Could you stop using almost the exact same title every day please? Be more direct and explain a bit better rather than the same thing.
I wonder if anybody on the ship could a heard the implosion of they was outside on the ship at the time of implosion
I don't know why I haven't seen anyone else pick up on this but in the video footage showing the front end cap in the ocean floor, just a few feet to the right I can clearly see a decapitated head with severe cuts to the face, obviously from the debris in the rapidly implosion. You can see it on some of the other videos when you rotate the picture 90° clockwise. If you don't turn the picture 90° clockwise it can be difficult to make out.
edit: I wanted to say it looks similar to a mask, if that helps anyone who looks for it.
The facts and testimony will continue to come out, and so will the videos.
One intriguing question one could ask is what would some of the survivors of the Titanic tragedy have thought of Stockton Rush and his inevitably, deadly contraption?
If someone could have showed Rush a picture of what the sub would have look like after an implosion his response would have been "get away from me boy yuh bother me" - I cannot find the shred of sympathy in the story
If what your saying or their trying to make him out to be I have nun either .I don't think Stockton was anything like a murder or commitef suicide.i think he was a arrogant prick who thought he new more than what he did I don't think he new it would imploded I think he was a crazed greedy bastard that wanted fame an fortune an he thought he new more than the engineers.i think he made it to the Titanic an he didn't understand about life cycles an delamination he thought I made once good to go anytime you want..he was a smart man but anyone outheir that thinks their to smart to learn anything else in life or their smarter than everybody else is the most ignorant person in the world.id say he owe millions an had to pay that back an thought he could jus use that sub anyway or anytime he wanted an said screw the regulations I made it to the Titanic once I can go as many times as I want .
I think I said it much better in far fewer words
I think I said it much better in far fewer words
11:28 I think the orange stuff maybe is blood or it could be rust.
The camera is close, so a huge depth underwater really wouldn't make much difference on the color because the camera itself is close to what it's recording. The type of light being used is also a warm toned light with the full spectrum of color (compared to a blue, green, red light). So the perception of the color of the objects it's recording wouldn't be too different than what it really is above the surface. Also, the orange substance is spread out on multiple surfaces
just gonna email some people real quick ,}
So, to be clear. Said vehicle imploded a year after this 'loud bang' took place. But the fact that they may be related and show that there was stress on the structure and likely shows there were blatant signs that it was failing is just a matter of opinion........
My personal bet is that, if they found anything more than a few pasty smears, it was teeth. Teeth are surprisingly durable, wouldn't be visible on footage, and I don't *know* that the pressure wouldn't have liquefied them, but I think they'd be the more survivable bits as well as contain DNA. Kind of hoping they'll tell us what was found, though.
The remains were compressed into the rear dome with all the carbon fiber debris. There was a pink goo inside the rear dome that contained DNA of all the occupants.
Did you hear this from somewhere?
@@bryanutterback4074
ruclips.net/video/CxBtZmyPzVA/видео.htmlsi=zV4uQEcJCp1eKlU6
Yeah!! Yeah " sounds like you got it right ▶️👍 exactly they all ended up squashed or sqeezed with the carbon fiber at the 👉 rear dome"
Your videos are awesome I'm also going to purchase a Titan submersible from you next week
Imho, the safety record of 50 years still stands, Titan wasn't classified and shouldn't tarnish the reputation of the rest of the submersible community.
this could be a change in how tourist subs are operated in the future
01:44 does it implode or explode? Just asking!?
It implodes .exploding blows everything apart imploded swishes it so tight nuthing is left but a couple little puddles look like jelly
Ohhhh he left a mark on history alright.
Did they use an autoclave to suck out the air, it doesn't sound like it or perhaps they didn't use it properly.
He left his mark on history…..and the ocean floor.
Y'know of Professor Reason (University of Manchester) & his 'Swiss Cheese' Model - the general cause(s) of aviation accidents? T'was originally applied to the medical arena, now aviation (big time). With Rush & Oceangrave, all the elements lined up to create ONE BIG HOLE, meaning this was not just inevitable but almost totally predictable......
any billionaire not having the state of mind doing their own research before going,has made a choice...only the kid was a real victim,and the dad the only one guilty.....
The body compresses like the styrofoam foam Oceangate used to show the pressure at depth - everything comes out of all the available holes & the skull is crushed like an egg shell!! The air is compressed & heated!! And you’re in the middle - ouch!!
I've wondered about the presence or absence of human remains. I could swear there are 2 items that look exactly like human teeth.
Nobody was onboard 😊😁
Inquiries look to pin point why a disaster occured. This will be the first time in history the conclusion will be "Take your pick" atop an enormous list of failures.
😮
when you realize Stockton and Father Ted is the same guy it get pretty funny
Stockon was too concerned with 'making history' for the wrong reasons, that being fame.
I HATE personalities like that; people who get into hobbies, professions, and other things with the only being the 'face' of said thing without actually contributing towards it or even enjoying it. They often mess up and destroy the groups they get into and leave it when they don't get what they want QUICKLY, leaving those who actually gave an F with the trash to clean up.
Rush set back research but in his hubris, he's highlighted why safety is VERY IMPORTANT.
Safety recommendations? How about we not allow companys to just make their own subs and sell tickets for it?
"No strain data is available for dives conducted in 2023..."
SR's version of, "If you don't document it (anomalous strain sensor data), it didn't happen."
🤔🙄🤦
A biological paste was found inside the collapsed rear portion of the sub which was found to contain the DNA of the deceased crew.
That's what the "presumed human remains" were.
I wonder those ppl blast into particle size, pieces or chunk?
I'm thinkin they were turned into soup.
This guy welded his own stuff. Machined his own stuff. Developed his own stuff. Hes no engineer
The remains--and they would be remains, not bodies--would be very, very small. What I've heard so far is that they found a "pastelike substance" on some of the wreckage, which, when tested, had DNA from the 5 people on board. They would have been subjected to a water hammer effect over 2 milliseconds with about 400 atmospheres behind it, about like dropping a building on them. Humans are not built of material that stands up to that. I think the xkcd quote was that they stopped being biology and started being physics. One orthopedist has a RUclips video about it.
Fortunately, it takes tens of milliseconds for the nervous system to perceive anything, so there was not time to feel or even realize anything once the failure started.
Famous? or infamous?
Oh, he got famous in some way, just more like in-famous.
Can somebody please stop them completely changing their story.
Wait... that's a reddit comment !!! I read it one minute before ! You stealing contents ?
If the collectible doesn't implode then what's the point of buying it?
Your obsession with human remains more than borders on the macabre.. leave it alone.
He was as psychopathic as Elizabeth Holmes. They both operated the same way, with desire for a dream to work and as CEO, to keep the company afloat and bills/salaries to pay, by all means possible. They loved limelight, they repeated the same lies of things to cover up/cope with what they were guilty of. In constant denials.
They didn’t care if their negligence cost catastrophic outcomes to someone’s life or medical decisions. Cavalier attitude.
They came too deep in their own lies that they had to continue them no matter at what cost. That includes avoiding regulation, getting NDA signed by employees (Rush with the waiver forms), more lies and deceptions, firing employees and later sued them, restricting important information to employees or isolating their workplaces to manipulate outcomes, etc.
Basically, same behavior pattern exhibited by psychopathic individuals with position of power.
Law suit!!
11:25 At this time stamp, look to the right and look up. What is that brownish-orange thing? :/
Now I think we have seen enough of these videos. There is nothing new beside throwing a dead man under the bus again.
Voice is AI? Sounds similar to other channels
MarineLife Better Choice Than WildLife🤔
2 Titanic depth dives? There were many more than 2
It's so unfortunate Elon not being into submersibles as well..
But now that I think about it he probably wouldn't have the balls to do anything more risky than carrying around sinks - he's the owner of a for once admittedly surprisingly successful space flight company (likely because his role is limited to providing funding and playing it off as an personal achievement of his while qualified people putting in their blood and sweat into making things work behind the scenes) after all - if I was in his position I definitly would have gone up there just as Branson and Bezos did with their respective hobby projects..
Well, I'm actually quite happy to not be because being a billionaire inherently requires a shocking lack of morals and character to begin with - there's no such thing as a "good billionaire", an utter oxymoron.
THIS (shows the logitech controller)
i see what you did there.
Loathsome c...
Five are dead!! Zero accountability
Perhaps he just wanted to feed the fish.
Beleave me he did not want to die. He just thought he was smarter than every one else. So he did not listen to anyone. And he was a vary smart man.But he had no common sense .There are a lot of people like me that are not sub people at all and we knew that thing was not going to hold up under that kind of pressure. We have common sense. No where close to how smart he was but common sense.
All that hype and you gave away a measly three ?? Your content is fantastic but I have to say you overly sold it with the promotion
I'll explain the bodies or lack thereof, they are smushed into a combined paste and smeared in the small grooves and around into tiny places, we have found paste in this example too, looks like the failed Krabby patty recipe you see plankton make in SpongeBob in color
👂🏻10:53 🤔wtf was that? 😆
Some people are complaining the Titan model is tasteless. Nothing new here. One month after the Titanic disaster, survivor Dorothy Gibson made a movie How I was Saved from the Titanic, wearing the clothes she wore that night for added realism. People complained a Titanic movie was crass and tasteless. Little did they suspect...........
My main issue is time. I'm not sure how much time is needed before it's _less_ tasteless. Humor is tragedy + time, but time is relative. One year is too soon, IMO.
@@LadyhawksLairDotCom Attitude also matters greatly. There have been movies about the Columbine Murders and 9/11, but I am OK with ones that respect the victims as human beings.
@@LadyhawksLairDotComThat is not what humor is. Lol
To me what he did was murder still may not look like he’s capable of murder but his intentions were arrogant and cheap narcissistic and fired ppl for warning him to me it is baffling me but to drag 4 ppl unsafe submersible sub then it is murder
I'm sure there's teeth
Your content was good but it doesn't seem right to sell these miniature sub in respect for innocent people who died in the sub.
It seems cringy to buy this thinking that it caused people's death.
Yes he is responsible for the deaths of those people, including a 19 year old boy, but suggesting that Rush wanted this to happen is cruel and not correct. He was a person too, and he leaves behind grieving loved ones too. His children and wife could be reading this right now. At least he did something with his life! If all he cared about was making money, he would not have chosen deep sea exploration of all things.
This AI voiced? because it sounds AI voiced. 🤦🏻♂️