To be fair, when he's telling the pregnant woman she'll be fine, he's probably more concerned about her panicking than he is with accurately diagnosing her.
@@letmeramble People always assume the good in people. It's scumbag like this person who are constantly teaching people to not trust others. Because of People like him I don't trust a lot of people. Such people are really a curse on humanity
I can't believe they cut out the part when Jack gets pissed and just punches Charlie's chest and he just magically starts breathing. Gosh, I miss Lost.
It’s called a precordial thump, and actually can product around 3-5 joules of electrical activity to correct an irregular rhythm, almost like a mini defibrillator. Although the chances of it working are extremely low, and the person has to actually have a correctable rhythm, it does have the small possibility of working 👍🏻
I feel like you could still do Correct-looking compressions and maybe use camera angles to your advantage so you don’t actually break anyone. They could put a layer of padding on the patient’s chest so it looked like the chest was going down further, just pretend you’re pressing hard without putting your full weight on them, etc. they could definitely do better than they do in these shows.
To be fair to the mouth-to-mouth scene, this show originally aired in 2004, and in my research (I could be wrong) mouth-to-mouth was still used until 2009-2011. Also, gunpowder doesn't explode, it burns hot and fast. It is actually pretty effective for cauterizing a wound.
could be. But cauterizing a wound is still some last resort until you can give proper help. Granted - it's a dire situation, but you don't do this until you have to.
Sayid told Charlie to go back to the camp because of his injury. Charlie didn't want to because he wanted to keep chasing the person who took Claire's baby. So what is the quickest way to stop the bleeding? I think what Sayid did with the gun powder was pretty smart.
*Doctor is forced to do a surgery in a man who kidnapped people of his camp including children and is only doing it because his girlfriend asked, so he cuts Ben's kidney and starts punching everyone around to have a chance to get away* Dr. Mike: this is unethical.
lol yeah, he said he didn't see the show, probably just watching individual scenes without context; plus, there's the hippocratic oath which applies to everyone, even people you hate.
That's why it's sometimes frustrating watching these real vs tv things, where you know why some things are that way and person reviewing doesn't and just shits all over it.
I like the way Doctor Mike critiques the chest compressions for not being deep enough as if they’re going to do full chest compressions on an actor whose heart is beating lol
Yeah what were they thinking! If you don't do rEaL chest compressions as an actor on a show, maybe bust some ribs Dr Mike will give you a bad grade and you will not like it! 🙃
Yeah true but idk maybe the producers didn't want to use the dummies because they would have to make a lot of expensive and time consuming lookalike dummies and especially then they still look derp.
Mike is always so surprised that the baby isn't actually new born as if casting directors should just be waiting around maternity wards to snatch babies as they are born for scenes like this. XD
One trick they used on "Call the Midwife" is to use a premature baby at the age where it should have born. That way it's about the right size. Then they put cream cheese and strawberry jelly on it to look like the goop newborns are always covered in.
Can't use newborn baby's because I think of labor laws but some of these shows use an 8 month old baby that can hold their head up and that always makes me laugh. It's just easier though.
Just wanna make the point “you’re gunna be okay” is more about treating the victim psychologically than being honest with them. I have my combat life saver certification in the army and we are suppose to comfort the victims, tell them we are going to help them and that everything will be okay. The last thing you want is someone with an arm and leg blown off panicking further cause you are like “holy sh*t, I don’t think you’re gunna make it, you look pretty bad.”
Thank you for your service, for what must have been extremely traumatic for you while you helped others stay calm. Thank you is small ...what I want to say is bigger than the words I have.
@@dbopdbop Thank you for your support, but I should mention I have (fortunately) never seen combat. I have trained for it, but I have been lucky enough to not see the traumas of combat.
"Call out to him, oh yeah cuz he's gonna be able to save everybody?" Little does Dr Mike know that's Jacks WHOLE character is trying to save everybody 😂
Just fyi, Jack's overconfidence and need to save everyone is a thing with his character and not necessarily a TV show contrivance. Not that Lost is immune to those.
What I learned about Dr Mike from this video is that he will tell a frantic and worried pregnant lady that she probably won't be okay and then let her continue sitting amongst the fumes of burning plane segments
Let’s be honest: Jack having X-Ray Vision and a clairvoyant capacity to diagnose patients would still be far from the most inexplicable thing to show up in Lost.
I recently tried to rewatch it as I used to watch in while it was airing, but idk I couldn't keep up... same thing happened this time around, I just casually stopped watching because so much weird and non-logical stuff kept happening and I was constantly losing track of it all... and that is coming from me who loves shows with 10+ seasons... but yeah I got lost within season 3 or 4... which is not pun intended....
@@KrisHe1 Yeah, the first season-and-a-half, /two seasons are good, they did tension really well, but the moment they started elaborating on any of it they just kept digging the rabbit hole deeper.
@@TheDakkaman exactlyyyyy... like I was so confused as to who was who, and who were bad and what was the ACTUAL plot and I still don't know how it ends and tbh I'm not even curious enough to google it... which says a lot...
@@KrisHe1 that was the point also they had a lot of mysteries that was meant to get you LOST.... they still explained most of them in season 5 and 6 just that there were still few issues nonetheless one of the greatest drama.
@@KrisHe1 that’s the point of Lost. it’s a mystery box show, and if that’s not your style and you don’t enjoy it- then that’s fine. Because personally for ME, the later season were more enjoyable for me
Doctor Mike: "I, as a family medicine doctor board certified and all, have no idea what's about to happen" Me: As a professional movie watcher, i know exactly what's about to happen xD
@@alicepbg2042 yeah but most of the time they don't use a doll probably bc of the cost and effort. I'm not criticizing or anything I just find it funny him pointing it out every time 😄
They did the same in Grey's. In the episode when Mer fall into the water there were a lot of chest compressions. They had to to that as well so they don't break her ribs or stop her heart
Yeah it can be difficult to do realistic chest compressions, since you don't want to hurt the performer, but so many of them are just so bad. Like I can forgive them clearly not pushing too hard so as not to hurt the person, but sometimes they're barely moving at all, their hands are in totally the wrong place, or they're not even (or barely) touching the person. But I think part of the reason Dr. Mike points it out each time is I think the average by-stander probably is going to be a bit worried about hurting the person, so it's one of those things where you do kind of want to frequently emphasize the proper way to do it in case you ever are in that situation.
My dad was in the military (around 1970s) where he befriended a medic in his squad and they still occasionally hang out and tell some "war stories". He once told me that they actually trained to do this kind of "direct" blood transfusions in emergency situations. Every soldier wore their identification, blood type, chronic illnesses, allergies, etc. on dog tags around their neck and in a situation where someone's life depended on a blood transfusion (which I'd imagine would be fairly common when there's bombs and bullets flying around) and they could not do an immediate evac or didn't have blood supply on hand, they would find someone with a compatible blood type and use a special kind of tube that allowed a direct blood transfusion from a donor's vein to the recipient. As he told me he hasn't actually needed to do it himself, since they always had sufficient medical supplies at hand or some kind of medical vehicle close-by which was fully kitted out, but he does know of a different medic who trained with him and had to use this method in a hostile environment on someone who lost a leg to a landmine going off in close proximity and it saved the guy's life. It bought them enough time to move him to a safe evacuation point and allow them to transport the soldier to hospital by helicopter, almost like a action movie. Maybe this would be an interesting guest to get for a video one day. An actual army medic to tell us of some of the stuff they have to do in combat situations to save patients from explosion or gunshot wounds.
Dr Mike: "~Call out for him because he's gonna be able to rescue everybody~" It's one of Jack's character traits/flaws that he tries to save literally everyone around him all of the time, no matter how hopeless or dire the situation
Doctor Mike never really understands that these shows are not medical training videos and that they have more important things to do than to spend 15 minutes showing every test being done just so a proper assessment of a tumor can be made.
@@claytoncourtney1309 I don't think you understand what this video is about, he's not there to evaluate the show on its entertainment he's there to evaluate them on their medical accuracy and that's exactly what he's doing
@@johnhostetler2167 however the shows are not trying to be medically accurate. As a watcher of a TV show I know they're not going to be accurate medically so Dr. Mike's efforts here are wasted. He could use these circumstances to show what would actually happen, and sometimes he does, but a lot of the times he just gets mad that they did not spend 5 hours for a scene that is very minor in the overall plot.
FYI, Jack is supposed to be a super surgeon. And that scene where he cut the guy's kidney, well it might be unethical, but they were holding him and a bunch of others prisoner; so... And yes, Jack's thing is that he's heroic, always trying to save everyone. He's effectively their leader.
Lol yes I agree, what they were doing to him and his friends THAT was unethical. I loved Jack's character but in the later seasons he became kinda annoying. Sawyer was always amazing though 😂
@@Jehty_ Im saying there is a recuring trope with Jack... him saying "I can fix it". There is even one or two episode focusing on this. Jack had serious problem with letting go, constantly trying fix everything and everyone around him. So when he says 'Everything will be allright' - there is more to this in his case than usual. Because he is convinced that he can do everything to actually fix the situation and be sure that 'everything be all right'. Even when he shouldn't say that in some situations.
It is such a character trait that they dedicated an entire flashback story to its origin. "Her spine is crushed! I tell her everything is going to be okay, that's false hope, dad!" "Maybe. But it's still hope." Jack then actually makes the promise to fix a broken spine and happens to perform a once-in-a-lifetime miracle surgery... And a conflicted "man of science" is born. 😛
Hahaha, typical doctor, I can't order the right tests and imaging so I can't do anything because I'm so totally clinically adept I can't figure anything out without a 100 tests and images. 🙄
If I were to survive a plane crash on a deserted island and subsequently was injured, I'd want a person like Jack to be there because he's not going to give up. I'm really surprised none of the scenes with the US Marshal were included here.
I would be terrified if I had Dr. Mike as my CPR instructor I can imagine him screaming in my hear "now let's see those chest compressions, they have to be deeper, push with your body" but once passed I would feel like a superhero!
@@maribelmendez9012 It's easy in real life also. The CPR is not the hard part in real life, it's all the rest. Tossing in an IGEL or intubation, reading the 12 lead, figuring out what is wrong and what meds to give, etc. Even that becomes mostly second nature after a bit.
@@ChristineTheHippie Yes, he is a doctor analyzing the TV show from a doctor's perspective. However he is calling things ridiculous when they are 100% obviously being done that way because it is a TV show. THAT is my problem with it. He can simply say "Doctors would not perform this test or that test." Instead he exacerbates how "crazy" it is that they are having the Doctors do all of these tests. The Doctors are the MAIN CHARACTERS ON THE TV SHOW!!!!! He thinks TV shows should be like real life. I just wish that he would take the circumstances present in the TV show as a starting off point to explain how they are done in real life. Instead he does more criticizing of how the writers write the TV show unrealistically. when he does not reaction videos he is VERY good about explaining how things are done and that disappoints me that he does not apply the same process to the reactions.
@@claytoncourtney1309 Thankyou for communicating about the missing context in his reactions and speaking facts🙌❤. I fully agree with you and I am also really surprised that your comment doesn't have more Likes 👍 acknowledgement or even appreciation.
I love that the only medical scene he liked was from Kate, the only one who didn't know what she was doing but still successful helped Claire birth Aaron.
I blame you for this Dr Mike. I’ve never watched lost before and I am now on season two episode 17 and I started watching the show on Sunday last week! 😂
@@SuperPriscilla92 Well the ending was about all of them being connected by the island, that even in their afterlife they were together. They didn't die all at the same time, everyone got there in their own time, the rest just waited for them. And i think that's beautiful.
Dr. Mike, you’re not the only one that hasn’t watched Lost, my fiancé and I haven’t watch that show before either. ☺️ And when are you going to make merch that says “Chest Compressions, Chest Compressions, Chest Compresions?”
1) It's definitely not a good idea for Jack to have "stopped at this point" because of brain damage. Charlie had only been unresponsive for about 5 minutes, there was still some time. 2) I can't believe you didn't comment on the entire reason I clicked: Jack's notorious "smash down on people's chest" technique.
My mum is not even a medical professional, yet she says the same thing whenever she sees a new born on TV. I have to remind her everytime that no one is going to let their new born up to TV people for shoot.
Do you actually think every doctor is a surgeon somehow? Also, even if he was, seeing an open wound and seeing someone being grounded by an engine are two very different situations.
To be fair Lost first aired in 2004. I was a freshman in high school and I'm pretty sure we were taught CPR with the mouth to mouth resuscitation back then. I do believe face guard/shields were available then too.
The thing we have to remember with LOST is that it doesn't really matter how good of a doctor Jack is. *SPOILERS* The island is magic, and it decides if someone's able to survive a terrible injury or if someone's going to die from something otherwise non-serious. :P
I never really thought the island was supposed to fix injuries so make as ailments. Like how Rose’s cancer stops and Locke is no longer paralyzed. But if you get hurt in the island ... you are going to suffer through that
@@TheJadedJames But many of them heal almost instantly and others have very long dragged out recoveries (like Ben after his surgery...they literally call out it is taking too long for him to recover)
@@TheJadedJames Generally, no one was instantly cured (except Richard, I guess), but they allude to the island having a mysterious effect over injuries many times, and events themselves would back that up. When Naomi's lungs get punctured by a tree branch, Mikhail says that injuries heal differently on the island and that she'd be better in a day or two (after being impaled by a branch through her lungs). Locke is shot by Ben and survives with no medical intervention, just Walt telling him he's got things to do. Those are just a couple examples.
Thats the case for most shows and movies. But Lost sucked when they blew the tension and told everyone that only 2 will survive and make it off the island...
Jack is clearly superman. He can see through skin with x-ray vision. He can hear someone call him during a plane crash. He has every specialty of medicine memorized.
it's also a supernatural island that literally manipulates time, space, and reality... The island legitimately de-crippled someone the second they crashed there, so honestly I think its pretty fair that jack is able to do some abnormal things as well (seeing as the island is what is allowing him to do it anyway)
@@TnT_F0X no, they're alive, but the island does what it wants, and the island wanted jack to be a hero at the start, so he could grow as a person and become the new keeper of the island later.
@@Elle... then explain the ending... Jack's dead dad was there at the ending. I havent watched the show in years, but I liked the island before it started getting supernaturally absurd. The weird anomalies that made plane engines fail and government tests was cool enough imo, didn't need a sentient island.
@@TnT_F0X because the last scenes weren’t entirely real, they had died at the end and what we saw as the “flash sideways” was them reuniting to move forward after death.
He really needs to react to all the medical scenes in Outlander. Claire is a nurse and later a doctor, there are SO MANY medical scenes in that show!!!
I was actually thinking the same, mostly because I'm reading the books right now after having watched the 4 first seasons (still waiting for season 5 to be available where I live)
one interesting thing I'd like to point out is that trying to save everyone and fix everything to a detriment is a pretty integral part of his character. He end up almost losing his mind at one point because he tries to control everything
I lost one of my loved ones today evening. I just wanted to say a thank you to Doctor Mike for helping me to cope up. My Parents are depressed, and I'm trying my best to calm them down.
The spinal surgery scene is basically about plot in the show. The guy with the tumor is a bad guy basically and the main guy doing the surgery, he's a good guy and basically is given the opportunity just to kill the bad guy during the spine surgery but makes the threat to the guy he punches who is on the side of the bad guy. Its complicated lol
I watched LOST as a kid, and wow... my parents were obsessed with the show. Zero noise while the show was on or we got in deep trouble. They would spend all week theorizing what was going on in preparation for the next episode.
I feel like you should maybe watch the whole show in some of these cases. Like, Jack cutting Ben's kidney probably looks pretty messed up out of context.
To be fair, I had CPR training in 2019 and we did that, but they gave us these plastic things (like a sheet with a little mouthpiece to breathe through) that we were supposed to put between our mouth and the CPR mannequin thing's mouth, and the one I had didn't even work right, so it kept saying I wasn't doing it right, but my instructor saw that we were actually doing what we were supposed to and the thing just wasn't working correctly, so she passed us anyway.
@@notjustafangirl7313 oh yeah we were shown those things when I learned in 2003, but the school didn't have the money to get enough for everyone, so we just saw the teacher use the plastic separator
@@notjustafangirl7313 I got mine in 2015. They showed us plastic thing, showed us how to use it, and then said you'll only be able to use these in situations where you'll likely have access to better tools anyways, so don't worry about that too much.
Yes. They couldn't correctly do chest compressions because they would injure the actor. Unless there is a mannequin or something over the actor. All chest compressions would be inaccurate.
To be fair Jack could have lied about Ben having an aggressive tumor for the opportunity to operate, pretend he didn't want to and then be able to use the operation as leverage, not really caring about Ben, to free Kate and Sawyer. I actually have seen the entire series of Lost. It's still on Hulu if anyone's interested in watching the show.
I remember watching LOST, it was a favorite of mine :) From what I can remember, I think older shows did the shallow chest compressions to avoid breaking the ribs by accident. Which I know isn't the primary concern when you need to do it in real life. Sure it could happen, but if it happened while saving the persob it's a "ends justify the means" type of thing. Also, glad I'm not the only one with a wheezing laugh xD Thanks Sam!!
Relevant contexts for these scenes: - Charlie (the guy with the head wound that they put gunpowder in) was in a very big hurry, doing something much more important, and they had to avoid an infection. They aren’t worried about his face, nor the “proper” way to do things - Jack is a spinal surgeon - Jack could know if his appendix had ruptured, because he is a doctor and might be able to make an educated guess based on pain levels or something else (idk what, I’m not a doctor.) She obviously wouldn’t have asked anyone else that.. - She’s telling him to lay still not because she expects him to, but because he INSISTED he would be able to.. (Not because he thought it was smart, but because he has a need for control.) They end up drugging him though, because he can’t lay still. - The scene you called “a joke” and unethical practice is not set in a normal hospital situation…. Jack has literally been kidnapped and is being forced to operate on the man who kidnapped him along with several others including children.. He is not that concerned about this man’s life. - In the scene where you think the towels aren’t gonna do much good, I’m honestly curious, what would you do? You just said yourself that they can’t do anything to stop internal bleeding on the island, so do you think he should just give up and not even try to treat the wounds he can, without even knowing for sure yet that there is any internal bleeding? - Jack continues to give blood until someone else forces him to stop because he is getting dizzy etc. - In the birth scene, the person helping the mother is not a doctor in any way.
Critiquing Lost's 'medical' scenes without having watched the show and the scenes in context isn't really productive. Just like you want to know everything surrounding an injury(that hurt ankle), everything surrounding why Jack, Kate, Sayid, etc. do what they do should also be known and taken into consideration. Also, mouth-to-mouth was still accepted practice when this show was made, Jack wasn't a general practice doctor; his specialty was spinal surgery, and actual chest compressions can't be done on actors in a television show without risk of injury. It's enough to show they are being done.
In Kate's defense to the childbirth scene, she legitimately in show states she doesn't know what she's doing but Jack is too busy dealing with Boone to do it.
You have to react to more scenes from Lost. My recommendations: *The whole situation where Jack calls out his father for operating while drunk and the legal procedures *The time jack has to choose between saving Sarah and Shannon's father *When Jack promises Sarah will dance at her wedding and Christian calls him out for making that promise *Claire's amnesia *Claire's night terrors to the point she digs her nails into her palms *Anything to do with Hurley in the mental hospital *Anything from Libby being shot Just anything. I love this show so much.
For the record, part of imprisoned Jack talking to Ben about the spinal tumors, including their "aggression" is because he knows he is the only one capable of operating on the tumor and is just trying to make it seem as urgent as possible so he can get out of the cage. Same with him intentially injuring the patient, he was leveraging the situation to ensure his friends get free.
I was also thinking that when he told Juliet that the X-Ray was of a “40-year-old’s” spine, Jack could have been making a guess to see Juliet’s reaction so he could confirm whether or not it was Ben’s.
I'm always so impressed how much information you retain, and how awesome you are at relaying all the same information to us. It's so helpful! I feel prepared for an emergency situation where Chest Compressions may be needed. Thank you so much Dr. Mike
Thank you so much, Dr. Mike for reacting to LOST! I've been waiting for this one a long time! LOST is my favorite TV show of all time and I think I cried a little when you weren't buying the medical scenes. Don't be trashing my Dr. Jack! Just kidding. I get it. Medical stuff aside, I hope you get a chance to watch the entire show and enjoy the crazy, emotional ride that was LOST!
You skipped some important ones, the ones I was actually hoping for :D (Jack punching Charlie's chest, Jack thinking if amputating Boone's leg can help, Jack's story about his life-defining surgery)
Jack literally just pounded Charlie back to life. IF Charlie ever wanted heroin more in his life, it would for the residual chest pain from Jack's incessant chest pummeling!
![[#2024MAMA] ROSÉ (로제), Bruno Mars - APT. | Mnet 241122 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/dgGqD28J6aQ/mqdefault.jpg)
![[#2024MAMA] BIGBANG (빅뱅) - 뱅뱅뱅 (BANG BANG BANG) + FANTASTIC BABY | Mnet 241123 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EQsYfiPR9uM/mqdefault.jpg)
To be fair, when he's telling the pregnant woman she'll be fine, he's probably more concerned about her panicking than he is with accurately diagnosing her.
this
Exactly 😂
I agree. Labour doesn't sound like a priority issue when there's a plane crash.
Mike was being very salty, relationship problems.
And he’s blissfully unaware of the lethal dangers of falling coconuts
"Don't worry the doctor told me all the bleeding is internal, that's where the blood's supposed to be" [Brooklyn 99]
One of the best lines!
ok hi
i just saw this on r/technicallythetruth lmfao
i came here to comment that hahaha
Literally exactly what I thought of haha
I completely forgot about lost, such a good show "he could be a doctor, he's dressed like one, he looks like one... he's heroic"
@STREAM DYNAMITE & WAY
It’s sad people fall for that
@@letmeramble Yeah
Me too
@@letmeramble People always assume the good in people. It's scumbag like this person who are constantly teaching people to not trust others. Because of People like him I don't trust a lot of people. Such people are really a curse on humanity
I watched LOST all episodes, it was a weird show. The ending was weirdest.
I can't believe they cut out the part when Jack gets pissed and just punches Charlie's chest and he just magically starts breathing. Gosh, I miss Lost.
we have to go back!
Yeah the defibrillator fist was pretty unrealistic but still one hell of an emotional scene.
Could this have been the legendary precordial thump?
@@raivichalves to . The . Island. No thanks I rather stay here
It’s called a precordial thump, and actually can product around 3-5 joules of electrical activity to correct an irregular rhythm, almost like a mini defibrillator. Although the chances of it working are extremely low, and the person has to actually have a correctable rhythm, it does have the small possibility of working 👍🏻
As a huge fan of LOST, I can tell you for sure that Dr. Jack could revive a man who has been pronounced dead for more than 48 hours.
this is my favourite comment
THIS!
LMAO
I mean to be fair, they're all dead anyways lol
I completely agree with you
Doctor Mike every time he reviews chest compressions “why aren’t these actors breaking each others ribs for accuracy?!”
Actually in other medical dramas like New Amsterdam, they do do quite accurate chest compressions, perhaps using a manequinn of some kind
@Sonic Mobian "FOR THE SAKE OF MEDICAL ACCURACY!"
I feel like you could still do Correct-looking compressions and maybe use camera angles to your advantage so you don’t actually break anyone. They could put a layer of padding on the patient’s chest so it looked like the chest was going down further, just pretend you’re pressing hard without putting your full weight on them, etc. they could definitely do better than they do in these shows.
OMG, yeah!
I know these actors aren’t very method
To be fair to the mouth-to-mouth scene, this show originally aired in 2004, and in my research (I could be wrong) mouth-to-mouth was still used until 2009-2011.
Also, gunpowder doesn't explode, it burns hot and fast. It is actually pretty effective for cauterizing a wound.
At least smokeless powder.
could be. But cauterizing a wound is still some last resort until you can give proper help. Granted - it's a dire situation, but you don't do this until you have to.
@@mitchrudolph65 Yes. Or near anything sensible and not replacable...
Sayid told Charlie to go back to the camp because of his injury. Charlie didn't want to because he wanted to keep chasing the person who took Claire's baby. So what is the quickest way to stop the bleeding? I think what Sayid did with the gun powder was pretty smart.
True. I took cpr class and they told us that after 2011 they stopped teaching mouth to mouth in cpr classes.
*Doctor is forced to do a surgery in a man who kidnapped people of his camp including children and is only doing it because his girlfriend asked, so he cuts Ben's kidney and starts punching everyone around to have a chance to get away*
Dr. Mike: this is unethical.
I love this comment🤣
What Dr. Mike didn't know is that Kate and Sawyer are having fish biscuit cage sex outside and Jack's gotta stop that from happening.
Nice summation of S3 Jack!
Yeah, I get the feeling Dr. Mike was missing some important context for that scene. haha :)
lol yeah, he said he didn't see the show, probably just watching individual scenes without context; plus, there's the hippocratic oath which applies to everyone, even people you hate.
The thing is: If the Island doesn't want you to die, you won't - no matter how bad Jack's chest compressions are.
Exactlyyyy
Best Comment Ever 😂
if the director **
That's why it's sometimes frustrating watching these real vs tv things, where you know why some things are that way and person reviewing doesn't and just shits all over it.
i always thought the chest compressions were purposely bad so that the actors don't break ribs >.>
I like the way Doctor Mike critiques the chest compressions for not being deep enough as if they’re going to do full chest compressions on an actor whose heart is beating lol
So true thooo😅
Yeah what were they thinking! If you don't do rEaL chest compressions as an actor on a show, maybe bust some ribs Dr Mike will give you a bad grade and you will not like it! 🙃
Dead body props are a thing, don’t know why they didn’t just use one of those
Yeah true but idk maybe the producers didn't want to use the dummies because they would have to make a lot of expensive and time consuming lookalike dummies and especially then they still look derp.
I was gonna say the same thing. You can't do real compressions, on a real person who is still breathing and heart is still pumping. 😂😂😂
Mike is always so surprised that the baby isn't actually new born as if casting directors should just be waiting around maternity wards to snatch babies as they are born for scenes like this. XD
They should learn fromJohnson's advertisements 😂
To the person who is reading this
You are awesome & hope you are safe🙏
My goal is to hit 30K any help would be awesome🤩
Yeah lol they're child safety/work laws where you can't have infants under a certain age for TV/movies
One trick they used on "Call the Midwife" is to use a premature baby at the age where it should have born. That way it's about the right size. Then they put cream cheese and strawberry jelly on it to look like the goop newborns are always covered in.
Can't use newborn baby's because I think of labor laws but some of these shows use an 8 month old baby that can hold their head up and that always makes me laugh. It's just easier though.
But what if you say "Come on" a forth time? Surely it helps eventually.
LMAO
Lol! You have to say "come on! Don't die on me!"
Let me just say, if I was trying to bring someone back to life, I would probably be screaming at them and using a lot more colorful language 😂
Just wanna make the point “you’re gunna be okay” is more about treating the victim psychologically than being honest with them. I have my combat life saver certification in the army and we are suppose to comfort the victims, tell them we are going to help them and that everything will be okay. The last thing you want is someone with an arm and leg blown off panicking further cause you are like “holy sh*t, I don’t think you’re gunna make it, you look pretty bad.”
Thank you for your service, for what must have been extremely traumatic for you while you helped others stay calm. Thank you is small ...what I want to say is bigger than the words I have.
@@dbopdbop Thank you for your support, but I should mention I have (fortunately) never seen combat. I have trained for it, but I have been lucky enough to not see the traumas of combat.
I think he was just saying that as a joke. It doesn't take a certification to realize that telling someone they're gonna be is so they don't freak out
so its true? doctors heal people, medics make people comfortable while theyre dying (Red Vs Blue reference)
Was thinking the same thing.
"Call out to him, oh yeah cuz he's gonna be able to save everybody?" Little does Dr Mike know that's Jacks WHOLE character is trying to save everybody 😂
Lmao
Do I need to watch this?!
@@cmaize5071 Yes. Watch this show
@@cmaize5071 have you watched it yet?
And, ultimately, he does. (And I mean EVERYBODY.)
Just fyi, Jack's overconfidence and need to save everyone is a thing with his character and not necessarily a TV show contrivance. Not that Lost is immune to those.
Mike: “Why aren’t the actors actually injecting each other with lidocaine? This is so unrealistic.”
What I learned about Dr Mike from this video is that he will tell a frantic and worried pregnant lady that she probably won't be okay and then let her continue sitting amongst the fumes of burning plane segments
😂
But place a little cap on her, so she has some protection against the falling airplane burning pieces. 🤣
I was thinking something similar.
I was thinking the same thing hahaha no he doesnt know shes gonna be okay, but in that situation mitigating panic would be wise
Haha yeah
Let’s be honest: Jack having X-Ray Vision and a clairvoyant capacity to diagnose patients would still be far from the most inexplicable thing to show up in Lost.
I recently tried to rewatch it as I used to watch in while it was airing, but idk I couldn't keep up... same thing happened this time around, I just casually stopped watching because so much weird and non-logical stuff kept happening and I was constantly losing track of it all... and that is coming from me who loves shows with 10+ seasons... but yeah I got lost within season 3 or 4... which is not pun intended....
@@KrisHe1 Yeah, the first season-and-a-half, /two seasons are good, they did tension really well, but the moment they started elaborating on any of it they just kept digging the rabbit hole deeper.
@@TheDakkaman exactlyyyyy... like I was so confused as to who was who, and who were bad and what was the ACTUAL plot and I still don't know how it ends and tbh I'm not even curious enough to google it... which says a lot...
@@KrisHe1 that was the point also they had a lot of mysteries that was meant to get you LOST.... they still explained most of them in season 5 and 6 just that there were still few issues nonetheless one of the greatest drama.
@@KrisHe1 that’s the point of Lost. it’s a mystery box show, and if that’s not your style and you don’t enjoy it- then that’s fine. Because personally for ME, the later season were more enjoyable for me
Doctor Mike: "I, as a family medicine doctor board certified and all, have no idea what's about to happen"
Me: As a professional movie watcher, i know exactly what's about to happen xD
Same!!
As someone who’s seen lost 5 times, I know what’s about to happen xD
@@tiffanymarieelizabeth 5? Pfft lightweight: D
hahaa lol good one :D
I’m surprised he didn’t know that gunpowder is based on nitroglycerin
Jack trying to micromanage his own appendectomy will always just kill me 😂 classic Jack “I can fix it” Shepherd
Ugh, I had my appendix removed when I was 10 years old, watching that scene with him awake just makes me squirm
In case you couldn't tell, Jack has a hero complex and does think he can save everyone :D
*Actor forgets he is acting and starts doing real chest compressions, resulting in a broken rib*
Dr. Mike: Now that is what I am talking about!
That's what I was just thinking, I mean they can't really do real chest compressions bc they're just acting and the person is actually breathing.....
@@alejandracastillo6327 that's what dolls are for mate.
@@alicepbg2042 yeah but most of the time they don't use a doll probably bc of the cost and effort. I'm not criticizing or anything I just find it funny him pointing it out every time 😄
Hahahaha! Dr. Mike taking a full on acting scene in Grey's Anatomy! 🤣😝
Whenever I've taken CPR Classes I get so caught up during live presentations they have to tell me to just pretend. 😆
The best chest compressions in Breaking Bad, because they actually made a cast for an actress so the don’t break her ribs.
Yesss
Dr. Mike should review it.
Yes, you simply can't do realistic-looking chest compressions on a living actor.
They did the same in Grey's. In the episode when Mer fall into the water there were a lot of chest compressions. They had to to that as well so they don't break her ribs or stop her heart
Yeah it can be difficult to do realistic chest compressions, since you don't want to hurt the performer, but so many of them are just so bad. Like I can forgive them clearly not pushing too hard so as not to hurt the person, but sometimes they're barely moving at all, their hands are in totally the wrong place, or they're not even (or barely) touching the person.
But I think part of the reason Dr. Mike points it out each time is I think the average by-stander probably is going to be a bit worried about hurting the person, so it's one of those things where you do kind of want to frequently emphasize the proper way to do it in case you ever are in that situation.
My dad was in the military (around 1970s) where he befriended a medic in his squad and they still occasionally hang out and tell some "war stories". He once told me that they actually trained to do this kind of "direct" blood transfusions in emergency situations. Every soldier wore their identification, blood type, chronic illnesses, allergies, etc. on dog tags around their neck and in a situation where someone's life depended on a blood transfusion (which I'd imagine would be fairly common when there's bombs and bullets flying around) and they could not do an immediate evac or didn't have blood supply on hand, they would find someone with a compatible blood type and use a special kind of tube that allowed a direct blood transfusion from a donor's vein to the recipient. As he told me he hasn't actually needed to do it himself, since they always had sufficient medical supplies at hand or some kind of medical vehicle close-by which was fully kitted out, but he does know of a different medic who trained with him and had to use this method in a hostile environment on someone who lost a leg to a landmine going off in close proximity and it saved the guy's life. It bought them enough time to move him to a safe evacuation point and allow them to transport the soldier to hospital by helicopter, almost like a action movie.
Maybe this would be an interesting guest to get for a video one day. An actual army medic to tell us of some of the stuff they have to do in combat situations to save patients from explosion or gunshot wounds.
Dr Mike: "~Call out for him because he's gonna be able to rescue everybody~"
It's one of Jack's character traits/flaws that he tries to save literally everyone around him all of the time, no matter how hopeless or dire the situation
Doctor Mike never really understands that these shows are not medical training videos and that they have more important things to do than to spend 15 minutes showing every test being done just so a proper assessment of a tumor can be made.
@@claytoncourtney1309 I don't think you understand what this video is about, he's not there to evaluate the show on its entertainment he's there to evaluate them on their medical accuracy and that's exactly what he's doing
@@johnhostetler2167 however the shows are not trying to be medically accurate. As a watcher of a TV show I know they're not going to be accurate medically so Dr. Mike's efforts here are wasted.
He could use these circumstances to show what would actually happen, and sometimes he does, but a lot of the times he just gets mad that they did not spend 5 hours for a scene that is very minor in the overall plot.
"incompatible with life" my new response when ppl ask why I stay in my room all day 😂
I might be stealing that 🤣
@@geekelly000 same
🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@geekelly000 Same, lemme get in on this lol.
@@geekelly000 sameee
I'm pretty sure the chest compressions are weak looking because they don't want to be to harsh on the actor/actress in question.
Exactly!
They do it good in other shows
@@joshlayes3130 And they may hurt actors this way, what's your point?
Yeah, just like the needles doing nothing.
@@drnanard9605 I doubt new shows hurt actors. Especially in LA w all the labor laws
Dr. Mike watching Ben’s surgery: That’s unethical.
Everyone else: Finally. Someone out maneuvers Ben.
Is it even a Dr. Mike if he doesn't point out chest compressions and doesn't criticize them???
😂😂😂
No, no it is not
To thjs point.. i almost imagine myself giving someone chest compressions in an emergency , when ever he says chest compressions 😂😂
And never mentions the fact that they are actors who aren't actually in cardiac distress.
@@angel102ify They could use dummies and forced perspective if they wanted
FYI, Jack is supposed to be a super surgeon. And that scene where he cut the guy's kidney, well it might be unethical, but they were holding him and a bunch of others prisoner; so... And yes, Jack's thing is that he's heroic, always trying to save everyone. He's effectively their leader.
Lol yes I agree, what they were doing to him and his friends THAT was unethical. I loved Jack's character but in the later seasons he became kinda annoying. Sawyer was always amazing though 😂
so he's like a medical John McClane on that island?
@@AlineBooneMusic , I have to agree with all of that too.
Yeah true. Awesome show
When Jack says "Youre gonna be okay" ... its just his character trait. He always does something like that through the show. :)
How is that a character trait?
Isn't that something everyone would say?
You know basic knowledge - keep the pregnant woman calm?
@@Jehty_ Im saying there is a recuring trope with Jack... him saying "I can fix it". There is even one or two episode focusing on this. Jack had serious problem with letting go, constantly trying fix everything and everyone around him. So when he says 'Everything will be allright' - there is more to this in his case than usual. Because he is convinced that he can do everything to actually fix the situation and be sure that 'everything be all right'. Even when he shouldn't say that in some situations.
You’re gonna be okay...in the afterlife.
@@Thorongil83 yeah it was tragic man. Everyone of their stories were tragedies
It is such a character trait that they dedicated an entire flashback story to its origin.
"Her spine is crushed! I tell her everything is going to be okay, that's false hope, dad!"
"Maybe. But it's still hope."
Jack then actually makes the promise to fix a broken spine and happens to perform a once-in-a-lifetime miracle surgery... And a conflicted "man of science" is born. 😛
A good breakdown of this entire show:
"Where is Jack?! Someone get Jack!"
What I learned: If we crash on an island with Dr. Mike... he'll let us die all
+-
Lol
If I see him waiting in line to board an aeroplane I’m out of there posthaste! 😳 😱🏃🏻♀️🤸🏻♀️🏃🏻♀️🤸🏻♀️🏃🏻♀️🗣”It’s Dr Mike! Flee!!!!”🤪
Hahaha, typical doctor, I can't order the right tests and imaging so I can't do anything because I'm so totally clinically adept I can't figure anything out without a 100 tests and images. 🙄
true
I was thinking the same thing 😂
Dr.Mike explaining why saying “come on” 3 times doesn’t work, made me laugh so hard
I was really hoping he would say: but saying come on 3 times does indeed help.
dude same
SAME
If I were to survive a plane crash on a deserted island and subsequently was injured, I'd want a person like Jack to be there because he's not going to give up. I'm really surprised none of the scenes with the US Marshal were included here.
@Ciera Geary girl lol
yeah jack never gonna give you up,never gonna let you and never gonna turn around and desert you
god this makes me wish I could watch lost for the first time again this show was so good
Be patient. There will come a day and you reach an age when it will FEEL like you're watching it for the first time, lol.
Exactly dude. I watched it with my family when I was 10 which was such a fun experience.
It was reallll good up until the 5th season when it got all pseudo and loopy
I would be terrified if I had Dr. Mike as my CPR instructor I can imagine him screaming in my hear "now let's see those chest compressions, they have to be deeper, push with your body" but once passed I would feel like a superhero!
Ikr it's like having chef Ramsey as your cooking instructor
Just do them correctly... it's not that hard. Any instructor would be like that.
@@websterri you are right it's not hard doing it on the dummies. The one time I assisted someone in real life I was scared!
@@maribelmendez9012 It's easy in real life also. The CPR is not the hard part in real life, it's all the rest. Tossing in an IGEL or intubation, reading the 12 lead, figuring out what is wrong and what meds to give, etc.
Even that becomes mostly second nature after a bit.
hahaha! I was just thinking about it! He would be soo scary !!
Doctor Mike: if someone is not breathing what do we do?
All of us in front of our screens: CHEST COMPRESSIONS, CHEST COMPRESSIONS, CHEST COMPRESSIONS!
Use the paddles after put Nutella on them
"Just call for me, I'll definitely be able to hear you over the screaming and explosions. I don't need to tell you my name or anything either."
He did tell his name, but yeah on the screaming part.
LOL 😂
The very next bit is him screaming "what's your name?" "Jack!"
Man I love when Mike misses the fact that this show was created during the early 2000s where we were taught we needed to breathe into peoples mouths.
Mike misses most everything in TV show reactions. They are not training videos!!!!
@@claytoncourtney1309 he's a doctor analyzing a TV show he was asked to review. You're the one missing the point
@@ChristineTheHippie Yes, he is a doctor analyzing the TV show from a doctor's perspective. However he is calling things ridiculous when they are 100% obviously being done that way because it is a TV show. THAT is my problem with it.
He can simply say "Doctors would not perform this test or that test." Instead he exacerbates how "crazy" it is that they are having the Doctors do all of these tests. The Doctors are the MAIN CHARACTERS ON THE TV SHOW!!!!!
He thinks TV shows should be like real life.
I just wish that he would take the circumstances present in the TV show as a starting off point to explain how they are done in real life. Instead he does more criticizing of how the writers write the TV show unrealistically.
when he does not reaction videos he is VERY good about explaining how things are done and that disappoints me that he does not apply the same process to the reactions.
@@claytoncourtney1309 Thankyou for communicating about the missing context in his reactions and speaking facts🙌❤. I fully agree with you and I am also really surprised that your comment doesn't have more Likes 👍 acknowledgement or even appreciation.
I love that the only medical scene he liked was from Kate, the only one who didn't know what she was doing but still successful helped Claire birth Aaron.
Lost is literally one of my favorite TV shows of all time. I love it so much.
Was eager to see Dr. Mike's reaction to the scene of Jack reviving a person by punching him in the chest until he magically regains consciousness.
mans took the idea of chest compressiosn too far
That's what I came here to see
It was on The Island, who can say why it worked?
It’s called a precordial thump. It’s used to try to interrupt a faulty heart rhythm, like fibrillation or certain tachycardias.
I laughed out loud when that happened
I blame you for this Dr Mike. I’ve never watched lost before and I am now on season two episode 17 and I started watching the show on Sunday last week! 😂
You finish?? Did you like it!!
Did you finish the show?
@@Tavernum @CrownedGamer oh I finished it and it was gooood! But the ending... a bit disappointing!
@@SuperPriscilla92 Well the ending was about all of them being connected by the island, that even in their afterlife they were together. They didn't die all at the same time, everyone got there in their own time, the rest just waited for them. And i think that's beautiful.
@@wannaput10shots so they weren’t in purgatory the whole time?
dr mike getting angry over an inaccurate scene is my fav thing
*especially his sarcasm lol 😅*
It's hilarious🤣
Whenever he said "not deep enough" I was thinking: "yeah, because the victim's actor doesn't need chest compressions!" xD
Dr. Mike, you’re not the only one that hasn’t watched Lost, my fiancé and I haven’t watch that show before either. ☺️ And when are you going to make merch that says “Chest Compressions, Chest Compressions, Chest Compresions?”
Me: YOU TELL THEM DR. MIKE!!✊🤣
Dr.Mike: *Talking like this situation is easy*
Also Dr.Mike: Crashing his car because there was a spider in his car.
Wait what??? I did that once
@@blobster91 Really?
😂
@@rosepetal4524 of course it's funny...
@@rosepetal4524 its mad jokes
Btw it's not like he can say "Everything is not okay and you're going to die" to a pregnant woman panicking 🤦
1) It's definitely not a good idea for Jack to have "stopped at this point" because of brain damage. Charlie had only been unresponsive for about 5 minutes, there was still some time.
2) I can't believe you didn't comment on the entire reason I clicked: Jack's notorious "smash down on people's chest" technique.
My mum, who was a nurse, used to always do the same comment “that is not a newborn” when they in tv series and films have birth scenes 😂
my mom is not a nurse, but she is a mom :D :D she is making the very same comment about "that is too big, that is not newborn" everytime
I have no medical background but I have 3 kids and I’m the same way 😂 “Oh come ON...that baby is 6 months old at least!”
My mum is not even a medical professional, yet she says the same thing whenever she sees a new born on TV. I have to remind her everytime that no one is going to let their new born up to TV people for shoot.
When kids are born weighing 10 lbs and having more hair than their father
That’s one of my biggest pet peeves. Call the Midwife is one of the best shows I’ve seen depicting birth and newborns.
No show has ever made me feel as excited and intrigued as Lost.
I love how he's a doctor who seen injurys and wounds but still gets squirmy when seeing them 😂😂😂
Well guess he went to family medicine for a reason
He's not ER
Do you actually think every doctor is a surgeon somehow? Also, even if he was, seeing an open wound and seeing someone being grounded by an engine are two very different situations.
@@drnanard9605 True true it's more like the surgeon doctors who see that kind of stuff
@@vibrantgleam No it's not. It's the ER doctors and really paramedics.
To be fair Lost first aired in 2004. I was a freshman in high school and I'm pretty sure we were taught CPR with the mouth to mouth resuscitation back then. I do believe face guard/shields were available then too.
The thing we have to remember with LOST is that it doesn't really matter how good of a doctor Jack is. *SPOILERS* The island is magic, and it decides if someone's able to survive a terrible injury or if someone's going to die from something otherwise non-serious. :P
Poor Jack 🥲
I never really thought the island was supposed to fix injuries so make as ailments. Like how Rose’s cancer stops and Locke is no longer paralyzed. But if you get hurt in the island ... you are going to suffer through that
@@TheJadedJames But many of them heal almost instantly and others have very long dragged out recoveries (like Ben after his surgery...they literally call out it is taking too long for him to recover)
@@TheJadedJames Generally, no one was instantly cured (except Richard, I guess), but they allude to the island having a mysterious effect over injuries many times, and events themselves would back that up. When Naomi's lungs get punctured by a tree branch, Mikhail says that injuries heal differently on the island and that she'd be better in a day or two (after being impaled by a branch through her lungs). Locke is shot by Ben and survives with no medical intervention, just Walt telling him he's got things to do. Those are just a couple examples.
Thats the case for most shows and movies. But Lost sucked when they blew the tension and told everyone that only 2 will survive and make it off the island...
99% sure that Mike was traumatized from the Final Destination review. I think he needs a happy review next to reset.
to be fair, he's probably not the only one XD
2:00 I think this guy was performing the age-old technique of "lying to someone so that they'll be calm in the moment".
Certified* as well, by my grandma 😂
I still remember the first time I saw LOST as a kiddo.
I saw a man with an open break in his leg in the bottom of the well.
OH BOY did I get sick.
Did Dr. Mike have a bad day? 😂 Somebody tell Bear to give him kisses, he seems so agitated 😂😂
Omg yes I noticed that too!
@@areeshashaikh2155 Maybe it was because the chest compressions were poor lol
Doctor Mike had it up to here when the doctor said his lungs just collapsed😂😂😂😂😂😂
Haha..that was the best reaction
I was reading this as I watched that part 😭
It was Lost. What did he expect?
I'm only 5 seconds into this and I know we need a part two.
Uh yeah. Gonna have agree here....
ABSOLUTELY YES
YESSSS
Studio C has made a skit about the “Breathe Charlie, breathe!” Part of Lost. When I heard that part in this video I smiled
"Call out for him like hes gonna be able to save everybody" he clearly doesn't know Jack 🙄🤚
😂❤️😂❤️😂
lol right
Considering they are all dead. He didn't save anyone lol
@@Twitch380 omg omg ur right
@@Twitch380 bruh they weren’t all dead
Jack is clearly superman.
He can see through skin with x-ray vision.
He can hear someone call him during a plane crash.
He has every specialty of medicine memorized.
it's also a supernatural island that literally manipulates time, space, and reality... The island legitimately de-crippled someone the second they crashed there, so honestly I think its pretty fair that jack is able to do some abnormal things as well (seeing as the island is what is allowing him to do it anyway)
@@Elle... yeah yeah and they're all dead in limbo blah blah blah.
But still, superman!
@@TnT_F0X no, they're alive, but the island does what it wants, and the island wanted jack to be a hero at the start, so he could grow as a person and become the new keeper of the island later.
@@Elle... then explain the ending... Jack's dead dad was there at the ending.
I havent watched the show in years, but I liked the island before it started getting supernaturally absurd.
The weird anomalies that made plane engines fail and government tests was cool enough imo, didn't need a sentient island.
@@TnT_F0X because the last scenes weren’t entirely real, they had died at the end and what we saw as the “flash sideways” was them reuniting to move forward after death.
He really needs to react to all the medical scenes in Outlander. Claire is a nurse and later a doctor, there are SO MANY medical scenes in that show!!!
Yes! I would click so fast
I was actually thinking the same, mostly because I'm reading the books right now after having watched the 4 first seasons (still waiting for season 5 to be available where I live)
THIS!!!!
Oh yes please
@@queenofnevers6990 this!
one interesting thing I'd like to point out is that trying to save everyone and fix everything to a detriment is a pretty integral part of his character. He end up almost losing his mind at one point because he tries to control everything
I lost one of my loved ones today evening. I just wanted to say a thank you to Doctor Mike for helping me to cope up. My Parents are depressed, and I'm trying my best to calm them down.
The spinal surgery scene is basically about plot in the show. The guy with the tumor is a bad guy basically and the main guy doing the surgery, he's a good guy and basically is given the opportunity just to kill the bad guy during the spine surgery but makes the threat to the guy he punches who is on the side of the bad guy. Its complicated lol
LOST is such a great series! I was in labor and waited until the episode was over before going to the hospital. It was the last season. 😂
Does your kid know? What a funny story ahha
I'd do the same! that's a birth story to tell 😂
@@TTHBLOX_ I think I mentioned it once but she's like, "Okay Mom..." 🙄 😆
@@SherriLyle80s one day she'll get the funny view. That her mom waited to give birth because the show was gud
Lol I had my first during season 1. I also finished the episode before going to the hospital. 🤣
I watched LOST as a kid, and wow... my parents were obsessed with the show. Zero noise while the show was on or we got in deep trouble. They would spend all week theorizing what was going on in preparation for the next episode.
I feel like you should maybe watch the whole show in some of these cases. Like, Jack cutting Ben's kidney probably looks pretty messed up out of context.
yeah, considering what unethical things they had to endure...
Can I get the context please? :)
@@horse14t Ben is ab evil jerk, and Jack was kinda kidnapped to do the surgery
@@FrantheMJfan Aaahhh, thank you :)
This episode came out in 2004, so wasn't breathing into the mouth still a thing?
I’m pretty sure it was.
yup, I learned CPR in 2003 and we were taught to do rescue breathing
To be fair, I had CPR training in 2019 and we did that, but they gave us these plastic things (like a sheet with a little mouthpiece to breathe through) that we were supposed to put between our mouth and the CPR mannequin thing's mouth, and the one I had didn't even work right, so it kept saying I wasn't doing it right, but my instructor saw that we were actually doing what we were supposed to and the thing just wasn't working correctly, so she passed us anyway.
@@notjustafangirl7313 oh yeah we were shown those things when I learned in 2003, but the school didn't have the money to get enough for everyone, so we just saw the teacher use the plastic separator
@@notjustafangirl7313 I got mine in 2015. They showed us plastic thing, showed us how to use it, and then said you'll only be able to use these in situations where you'll likely have access to better tools anyways, so don't worry about that too much.
Actor: *doesn’t want to crush the other person’s ribs*
Dr. Mike: D-!
Yes. They couldn't correctly do chest compressions because they would injure the actor. Unless there is a mannequin or something over the actor. All chest compressions would be inaccurate.
To be fair Jack could have lied about Ben having an aggressive tumor for the opportunity to operate, pretend he didn't want to and then be able to use the operation as leverage, not really caring about Ben, to free Kate and Sawyer. I actually have seen the entire series of Lost. It's still on Hulu if anyone's interested in watching the show.
also let’s not forget he was a spinal surgeon
He waited until he was in the middle of the surgery, it wouldn’t be leverage when Kate and sawyer were still imprisoned
Yeah, he might have seen 2 X-rays too and been able to tell that its growing fast.
Okay I get like 60% of his grades on chest compressions, but he does realize they would break the actors ribs right?
That's what I thought
Yep 😑
My thoughts each time he says that. lol
Two of my favorites: Dr. Mike and my favorite show, "Lost" 🙌 can this video get any better?
I have such a crush on kate
Same
Bruh
Did my comment get deleted
I just don’t understand why you watch her
I remember watching LOST, it was a favorite of mine :)
From what I can remember, I think older shows did the shallow chest compressions to avoid breaking the ribs by accident. Which I know isn't the primary concern when you need to do it in real life. Sure it could happen, but if it happened while saving the persob it's a "ends justify the means" type of thing.
Also, glad I'm not the only one with a wheezing laugh xD Thanks Sam!!
The way mike doesnt care abt the fact that they are acting so the guy is still alive and cant actually do a CPR and says the CPR isnt deep enough😂😂😂
Right? Lol he knows you can’t go deep on someone not dead!
Its Hollywood, they could have faked it.
Im a fan but yes I agree with you.
Dr. Mike saying “my guy” is the best thing I’ve heard today I love the way he says it
"You're going to be fine." Wouldn't that just be trying to calm the patient so they don't go into shock and cause more issues? Genuinely asking.
Relevant contexts for these scenes:
- Charlie (the guy with the head wound that they put gunpowder in) was in a very big hurry, doing something much more important, and they had to avoid an infection. They aren’t worried about his face, nor the “proper” way to do things
- Jack is a spinal surgeon
- Jack could know if his appendix had ruptured, because he is a doctor and might be able to make an educated guess based on pain levels or something else (idk what, I’m not a doctor.) She obviously wouldn’t have asked anyone else that..
- She’s telling him to lay still not because she expects him to, but because he INSISTED he would be able to.. (Not because he thought it was smart, but because he has a need for control.) They end up drugging him though, because he can’t lay still.
- The scene you called “a joke” and unethical practice is not set in a normal hospital situation…. Jack has literally been kidnapped and is being forced to operate on the man who kidnapped him along with several others including children.. He is not that concerned about this man’s life.
- In the scene where you think the towels aren’t gonna do much good, I’m honestly curious, what would you do? You just said yourself that they can’t do anything to stop internal bleeding on the island, so do you think he should just give up and not even try to treat the wounds he can, without even knowing for sure yet that there is any internal bleeding?
- Jack continues to give blood until someone else forces him to stop because he is getting dizzy etc.
- In the birth scene, the person helping the mother is not a doctor in any way.
dr. mike's sarcasm has got to be my favorite thing ever
Dr. Mike went so hard on this, lol. But we all know he'd be Jack in this scenario too.
He WAS hard on this show. It kind of bummed me out. 🙂
@@marylane3181 Me too.
i like how he says “incompatible with life” that’s what i’m gonna start telling people when i’m angry
Critiquing Lost's 'medical' scenes without having watched the show and the scenes in context isn't really productive. Just like you want to know everything surrounding an injury(that hurt ankle), everything surrounding why Jack, Kate, Sayid, etc. do what they do should also be known and taken into consideration. Also, mouth-to-mouth was still accepted practice when this show was made, Jack wasn't a general practice doctor; his specialty was spinal surgery, and actual chest compressions can't be done on actors in a television show without risk of injury. It's enough to show they are being done.
Kids these days will never understand the pain of having to wait weekly to find out what happens next
WHY DOES THE STATUE ONLY HAVE FOUR TOES?!?
Yeah, well we need to wait a decade for the next season.
I had conversations with friends just to dissect every episode every week
YES. THIS.
… and to finally realise that the writers didn't know, either. :-/
“And if you say come on, It actually doesn’t help” 😂😂😂😂😂
And if you say come on twice, it also doesn't help
That cracked me up good
And if you say it three times, it also doesn't help 😂
Okay, yeah . . . but, did you say it four times? I didn't think so. Fourth time is the charm!
In Kate's defense to the childbirth scene, she legitimately in show states she doesn't know what she's doing but Jack is too busy dealing with Boone to do it.
And she still handled it like a pro 👏
I love Dr. Mike’s sarcastic frustration! I can empathize as a scientist, some shows/movies drive you round the bend. You can’t unlearn some things. 😂
You have to react to more scenes from Lost. My recommendations:
*The whole situation where Jack calls out his father for operating while drunk and the legal procedures
*The time jack has to choose between saving Sarah and Shannon's father
*When Jack promises Sarah will dance at her wedding and Christian calls him out for making that promise
*Claire's amnesia
*Claire's night terrors to the point she digs her nails into her palms
*Anything to do with Hurley in the mental hospital
*Anything from Libby being shot
Just anything. I love this show so much.
I need to know what was up with Hurley and "Dave"
For the record, part of imprisoned Jack talking to Ben about the spinal tumors, including their "aggression" is because he knows he is the only one capable of operating on the tumor and is just trying to make it seem as urgent as possible so he can get out of the cage. Same with him intentially injuring the patient, he was leveraging the situation to ensure his friends get free.
Yes this! It’s just part of the story.
I was also thinking that when he told Juliet that the X-Ray was of a “40-year-old’s” spine, Jack could have been making a guess to see Juliet’s reaction so he could confirm whether or not it was Ben’s.
I love how Doctor Mike refers to the doctor/person performing medical care as “my guy” whenever they’re doing something horribly wrong
So I've got to ask- how are you going to do a real chest compression on a real person for a television show without cracking every rib?
I wonder if this is the reason why they avoid it completely.
you put a cast on their chest like breaking bad did
Gosh, Dr. Mike why so savage today, huh???
😂😂
He’s very passionate about medical inaccuracy!
I'm always so impressed how much information you retain, and how awesome you are at relaying all the same information to us. It's so helpful! I feel prepared for an emergency situation where Chest Compressions may be needed. Thank you so much Dr. Mike
I love when mike gets frustrated and starts calling him “my guy” 😂
Thank you so much, Dr. Mike for reacting to LOST! I've been waiting for this one a long time! LOST is my favorite TV show of all time and I think I cried a little when you weren't buying the medical scenes. Don't be trashing my Dr. Jack! Just kidding. I get it. Medical stuff aside, I hope you get a chance to watch the entire show and enjoy the crazy, emotional ride that was LOST!
"That's not...good teamwork." That line killed me lmao
Dr. Mike getting angry over inaccurate scenes (gun powder/How does he know his lung collapsed?!?) is a whole mood 🤣🤣
Doctor Mike talks as if he’s never smacked in the face a colleague while he performed surgery on his patient
You skipped some important ones, the ones I was actually hoping for :D (Jack punching Charlie's chest, Jack thinking if amputating Boone's leg can help, Jack's story about his life-defining surgery)
Jack literally just pounded Charlie back to life. IF Charlie ever wanted heroin more in his life, it would for the residual chest pain from Jack's incessant chest pummeling!
Sam wheezing in the background is my favorite part 😂