The Edge | Broken Record (Hosted by Rick Rubin)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 21 ноя 2024
- U2’s The Edge is one of only a handful of guitarists who's as recognizable as his band’s wildly successful frontman. U2 has been playing together since 1976, when they were all teenagers in Dublin. Nearing their 50-year anniversary as a band, U2 just released their latest album, Songs of Surrender-a 40-track collection of reimagined and stripped down songs that span the entirety of their catalog.
On today’s episode Rick Rubin talks to The Edge about his theory behind the band’s longevity. The Edge also shares stories about writing U2 classics like “New Year’s Day” and “Where The Streets Have No Name.” And he explains why Bono singing at the top of his range can be a bit much.
Subscribe 🎧 bit.ly/3EamIjM
#podcast #rickrubin #music #u2 #theedge #musicpodcast
ABOUT BROKEN RECORD
For generations of music lovers, the liner notes on albums were a central part of the way music was heard. You bought an album and it came with an accompanying narrative: a digression, an aside, a backstory-maybe even an invented history. We intuitively understood that great music required not just listening but conversation between the artist and the audience and the audience and the rest of the world.
Broken Record is a podcast that restarts those conversations-in a world without liner notes-for a new audience of music lovers.
Broken Record is hosted by Justin Richmond with interviews by producer Rick Rubin, writer Malcolm Gladwell, and former New York Times editor Bruce Headlam.
STAY CONNECTED
Instagram: / thebrokenrecordpod
Twitter: / brokenrecord
Facebook: / thebrokenrecordpod
Website: www.pushkin.fm...
![Chris Langan - The Interview THEY Didn't Want You To See - CTMU [Full Version; Timestamps]](/img/1.gif)
To be able to have; the money, the label support, fantastic producers, 40+ years of experience, positive energy from their fans, and the time to dive deep into music is every professional musicians wish. U2 was able to swim in that pond for many many years. I'm a bit jealous. Love The Edge and his dedication to his art!
I really appreciate and Love The Edge. He is historic and my hero
The coolest grandpa around :)
Thank you Rick. Thank you the Edge. Both of you together is absolutely epic. What a beautiful conversation. ONE
🫵 ❤️💫🌟
The Joshua Tree is still its own genre of music.
Rock n Roll
Even if U2 never creates or plays any new songs ever again, you can’t take away the brilliance of their expansive song catalog and illustrious career, though they seem to be doing just that on this new album retrospective.
The public must hate it since it's gone to #1 in the UK and top 10 in America.
Will this release add anything significant to U2's legacy? No. But there's also nothing wrong with a band in their 5th (!) decade looking back at their career. As Edge said in this interview, very few bands ever get this far and have the opportunity to do this.
They were good in the 80's.
Agree!
Excellent interview. A nice mix of poignant biographical detail of Edge’s early musical explorations end insights about his personal process and the way the band works collectively.
U2 GOAT!
Until the end of the world!
U2 is the reason why our band even exist . that simple
Hopefully one day U2 and Rick can go back and finish that album... Window in the skies was a great song...
Their earlier transition albums are for me their most interesting work. That started with October (emerging from the success with Boy) and then The Unforgettable Fire (transitioning from War) and finally Achtung Baby (moving from the colossus success of The Joshua Tree). Those albums are nestled between more sound defining moments in their creative journey, at least for what first put them on the map.
I'm really enjoying some of the new versions of the old songs!
Love Broken Record; thank you! Am biased bc was a massive U2 fan in the 80s, but gotta say, listening to this I can’t think of another Rick interview where the interviewee matches Rick’s energy so well. They are both very much themselves.
Love from MTL.
I'm an atheist myself and the names like Brian Cox and my personal hero Carl Sagan always hit home. Hearing The Edge talking about them with Brian being his close friend left me speechless! What are the odds! I have always admired The Edge since I was a teenager, but now, man, I wish I could just talk to him over a cup of coffee. Such a balanced, interesting and multidimensional human being. Thanks for this fantastic interview.
I'm not going to knock U2 for carrying on longer than I would, but their best music was made when they did the ad-hoc, sit-in-a-room-and-figure-it-out together approach. They were a lot better when they weren't trying to write good songs. They're my favorite band. I just don't really feel their albums since "How to Dismantle an Atomic Bomb". They at least had 2-3 very good songs on every album up to that point. Since then, they have put out 1 or 2 decent songs per album that I never have an urge to go back to. But put on "Surrender" from War, or "A Sort of Homecoming" from The Unforgettable Fire, and I'll play them on loop for an hour and not get bored.
Agree with you! Been a fan since 82-83 saw them many times over the years. For me last classic record they made was Achtung Baby it was and still is f*cking class! Since then studio wise they have got on a downward spiral. Pains me to say it but the are no way as good as they used to be, Live still amazingly good but they have not quite reached the dizzy heights since of the War days to the early 90's since then each album seems unfinished.
agree with both you guys but my last really loved album was POP. some amazing songs on that album.
They suck so bad
I understand people feeling that way. I think part of it is we are much more ‘open’ to being influenced when we are younger. I recommend revisiting the newer albums. They have a way of growing on you after taking a break and coming back.
I feel exactly the same way!!
I met and talked with the Edge in 1984 in San Francisco!
For our generation, new video games were the closest comparison to that excitement he describes around having limited access to brand new records you wanted to hear as a kid but couldn’t buy so you did what you could to beg or borrow. That kind of hunger and appreciation has greatly diminished today with nearly all music being accessible at all times. It’s the hunger and appreciation that actually makes anything in life extraordinary & special.
Could you imagine Rick Rubin producing the new "more rock and roll" record coming after Songs of Ascent!!!??? Amazing interview!
What I wouldn't give to have a conversation with my Hero the Edge. Great chat love it and thank you for doing it.
Rick produced my favorite U2 song Window In The Skies, I hope the band comes back to it one day. Bummed it wasn’t on Songs of Surrender
It's a good song they need to make an album together
@@jamesadcock5235 They made an EP’s worth of material with Rick. I hope it sees the light of day some day
It would have been slaughtered, so just as well it's not.
@@jimbanda Rick slaughtered Billy Gibbons album too. Complete distortion. Unlistenable.
@@subdude1234 True I forgot that, although Edge is credited with producing Songs of Surrender, along with a bunch of random dudes I don't know of.
Didn't Rick take an eternity to do the ZZ's album and then it was like boring.
We cant deny his legacy but we can dislike some of it. He must be a billionaire by now.
Back to HQ, I think this Songs of Surrender turned into a journey of one man's ego and a technical musicians curiosity, it ended badly imo and the critics who have drooled over it are out of step with the majority of fans. Rick calling it radical is just for someone else's ego, it's brutal , but if it was done by a bunch of RUclips kids doing covers I'd probably say good try but let's stick to the originals 👍🎸
….oh, and “Into the Heart” is such a great song. It has a taste of their phenomenal B-sides they released during their Unforgettable Fire and Joshua Tree days. Some of their B-sides (thanks in part to Eno) are other worldly. I really liked listening to the Edge talk about his interest in some scientific theories and his appreciation of how some of them can merge at times with forms of spiritual insight. The Edge has a bit more of “Sgt.Pepper” in him then I knew. I thought he was some what more fixed in place with a traditionally Christian perspective given the influences of his teenage years. That was enjoyable to hear.
Great interview. He’s a well spoken person.
Rick, I’ve really been enjoying your podcasts. Glad to see you expanding your horizons.
Hope the Edge discovers Rick Beato
Hey Alright!
Good seeing this here today
Peace
❤❤❤❤
Very good questions by Rubin and Edge is interesting to listen to. Nice interview indeed.
U2 was my first concert in 1986.
The idea of U2 re-recording intrigued me. But The Edge settled me on passing on it. I most liked the early U2 albums because I love the intensity. Chilling is not what I'm after. But I know that's just my own tastes and am sure millions will enjoy the album.
37:50 up to 47.20 deeper layers of what we call: existence will be discussed ... I love when people share other deeper insights of life that are beyond mainstream :) ... I noticed they arranged a "break" after 9 minutes and 40 seconds of talking deep philosophy ... and bring the focus back to "normal musicians talk" ... I wonder if there was much more, and they decided to cut it out.
I didn't hear any "deep" philosophy. Just fallacious and nonsensical 101 arguments for a "creator" (i.e., god). Believe in god(s) or not, but Edge's reasoning and knowledge about the basics of science is embarrassingly bad. Good thing he's good with a guitar and a cool guy!
That was truly great. Always knows The Edge to be a wise man.
@@tomalan6519 Yeah, I used to think he possessed some real intellect, but it seems to have been mostly artifice. Most of what comes out of his and Bono's mouths these days strikes me as theatre, bereft of substance or integrity. At this point they're just cannibalizing their past.
I love ❤️ U2 have done since my big brother said to me here you go mate listen to this it’s 91 I’m 10 and I’ve been given Achtung Baby and it blew me away the opening notes of Zoo station so I then got into their albums , for me everything they’ve done from War to All that you can’t leave behind are my favourite U2 Albums and it’s a hell of ride you know 7 albums all in the top five in album charts , but I’ve got to say everything since How to dismantle an atomic bomb, I don’t get it or understand what their trying to do every time I play U2 it’s always war to all that you can’t leave behind !!
This is so good!!!!
Well. It's basiclly one of my guitar teachers. Without the delay pedal (I didn't know). What an interesting way to learn.
Wonderful Interview
I think these reimagined songs would work a lot better if they were recorded live. That's what makes their simplified versions of songs special. I don't think it should have been a studio album. However, when they do these versions of songs live during a regular concert. It will be pretty awesome.
check out their Tiny Desk show, if you haven't seen it.
Agree with some comments here that since ATYCLB or maybe HTDAAB they hadn’t release a great record as they used to through 80’s and 90’s, they’re my fav band but I really can’t stand their late material… BUT… as a live band… they still got it! I just saw some of the sphere… maaaan that’s mindblowing, got to see them on the joshua tree 30th anniversary, it was amazing. To understand U2 you gotta go live, they’re just the best live band!
I think about acoustic U2 songs, and many titles come out: into the heart, the ocean, shadows and tall trees, tomorrow, seconds, drowning man, surrender, sort of homecoming... just the 80s hidden gems in their first 4 albums. For me, songs of surrender mean a surrender to that early inspiration that never will be back. They had enough with a 18-20 songs album. Everything else BORES me.
"In a little while"
And Van Diemems Land. Reach me
Thank you. Enjoyed this immensely.
when is u2 gonna put out a new album? i can't wait! it's been 31 years already, and i'm starting to wonder.
Seriously ?
Albums Pop and Zooropa are very underrated in terms of sonic creativity.
For me, U2s golden age began with Under a Blood Red Sky (1983) -> The Unforgettable Fire (1984) -> The Joshua Tree (1987) -> Rattle and Hum (1989) -> Achtung Baby (1991) -> Zooropa (1993) -> and ended with Pop (1997)
This string of albums over 14 years demonstrated U2s brilliant song writer and ever evolving sound. Zooropa, and especially Pop, are often overlooked by both the band and fans alike. However, both Zooropa and Pop are every bit as good as The Joshua Tree and Achtung Baby and stand head and shoulders above ever album U2 has released since.
Sure, All That You Can’t Leave Behind and How to Dismantle an Atomic Bomb are better than many other bands very best albums. However, both ATYCLB and HtDaAB signalled the end of U2s evolution of, and experimentation with, their sound, with the band retreating to a more traditional rock band sound.
Ever album after Atomic Bomb have been average at best, offering up only the occasional good song amongst albums full of mostly unforgettable, uninspiring, boring tracks.
But U2s run from 1983 to 1997 is U2 at their most creative and represents U2 at their very best. No one can take that supreme run of awesome albums away from the band.
Can someone please write the name of the new podcast there is anounced here please? I really don't understand & don't see it written in the info, thanks from Belgium
Edge is the Erik Satie of guitar.
Edit: Ha, Rick mentions Satie at about six minutes in.
It’s interesting how polarizaing this band is. Guess it’s either love or deep dislike . For me they were a fresh sound in 1980. I appreciate Sunday Bloody Sunday a lot. We’re still struggling over here.
Many are disillusioned fans still looking for a u2 that doesn't exist anymore. Personally, Im glad that u2 doesn't exist. I loved AB, but I don't want another one.
Heh heh, when I was 10 or 11, I saw Tower Records advertising the Grease soundtrack for $5 and I had $5 as a gift from someone. So I went to Tower Records to buy it on cassette but hit a snag. I discovered something called sales tax that day. I came back another day with $5.30 (CA charged 6% at the time).and that was MY first album.
Songs of Surrender is a mixed bag for me. Half of it works imo. I think It would have worked better as a 18 track album, keep all the stuff from Boy though, I thought that worked really well.
Very mixed. A handful of great new interpretations and several things that don't work at all.
The edge talked about a few books during this interview, can I find the list of these books somewhere?
" Unity in diversity "!
Do it with all 4 members? Kind of. There isn’t much of Larry and a Adam to be found despite being 40 songs deep.
B I N G O ! Shame on them. I love U2. But Bono is a narcissist. Shame on The Edge for leaving his mates behind. Come on, where's Larry...? The founder of the band! Shame on them. Ever since Bono got involved in "raising" tons of money through art schemes, I lost a lot of respect for him.
@@leascaart you do realise that Larry has undergone surgery and couldn't play during the sessions. As soon as he makes a full recovery he will return to working with the rest of the band.
@@colinmcdonough4034 Hahah, Larry was very much "have at it, Edge." Those guys are fully committed to each other. Total unity.
U2 needs to go back in the studio with Rick or Danger Mouse. They need to stop making songs for the charts.
Collabolla!!!! 😀 🎸
Man, I still would love for Rick Rubin to produce a U2 album. I know they was trying to sometime ago, but I hope it will still happen.
So…
How about this U2 album produced by Rick Rubin
Why did Bono fall off the stage?
He got to close to The Edge.
FYI...The Edge actually did.
Doing an album of "re-imagined" songs. How original.
Lol
U2 pablum since Pop, agree with many other posters here. Sad really, and the overwrought stage shows.
Rock on, or, "Walk On," or, slither on to Vegas. Fits them now.
Rick Rubin: "Amazing!"
Coke Dealer: "... ... ..."
Rick Rubin: "Amazing!"
❤
Yo Rick, where's The Link to the SOS tracks?
Dear Edge,
My name is Bob Guido and I would like to apply for the Record Producer role with U2. I'm excited about the opportunity to be considered for this role as I believe my character, personality, composition / arranging craft, production and engineering skills would make me a great fit for U2. Please reach out to me if you need any additional information.
Kindest regards,
Bob
Some of U2's best and most underrated stuff in my opinion - is the stuff they did with Rick; Windows in the Skies and The Saints are Coming.
A New U2 single is on the way this month - supposed to be a rocker. With U2 - I have learned to manage my expectations these days. They are capable of making big songs still - cause they still give a s***. No more punk rock attempts. That's like Madonna trying to do hip hop songs. Just doesn't resonate and or translate - to me at least.
What a fabulous interview...Love both of these artists, Rick and Edge.
Edge's guitar work has inspired me and I wish I could share that back with him in this track: ruclips.net/video/PwcJL26AEuc/видео.html
I loved u2 when I was 10 , 1981
They just can't seem to get it together since pop record
It makes me sad
agreed. They're been lost since Pop. A few good tunes since then, but not greatness
You poor souls. ATYCLB, Bomb, Innocence & Experience are all incredible.
@@alfie9718 Incredibly mediocre, yes
@@alfie9718 glad you like, to me its crap
@@Daneiladams555 Which helps explain why you're an internet troll instead of a successful musician.
Just so you know, and as a friendly reminder: No matter where you live on earth, what color your skin is, what your religious beliefs are, or what language you speak, we are ALL immortal spiritual beings of light, who love and cherish each other beyond measure.
Most of you, except a very tiny percentage of the population, have forgotten who you REALLY are. Where you’re actually from and that we are spiritual beings, who come from ONE (I AM) collective source of energy in the cosmos. Some believers will call this Heaven or just simply, the other side. It’s all the same, as far as I’m concerned, but some people find comfort with labels and there’s nothing wrong with that. Whatever makes you feel the most comfortable.
Your consciousnesses and your soul are one in the same. Earth is NOT your real and true home. The place your consciousnesses goes when you die, pass away, or cross over, again whatever makes you feel comfortable, is all the same thing and it’s where our spiritual home really is. When you pass, It’s simply a matter of closing your eyes here and immediately reopening your eyes there, It happens instantaneously.
Actually it happens so fast that most people that have NDE’s say that at first they didn’t even realize they were dead for a good while. Even the ones that died on the operating table in the hospital, for example, have said that they were wondering who was on the table in the room because they just felt that there wasn’t anyway that person could be them. Only when they don’t get a response from someone or suddenly walk through a wall is when they realize something happened to them.
I know many people think I’m just making this up for fun, or I’m some kind of religious fanatic but I promise, you will eventually see what I’m saying is absolutely and undeniably 100% true, I have never played silly games with people about fantastical stories and I’m not about to start now.
All I’m hoping to do is give someone hope that needs it or if someone has lost a family member or friend. Plus, with this ridiculous war Putin started would be a good time to give some comfort to those in need, maybe a soldier in the field perhaps.
Everyone on this planet comes from the same realm of existence and has been around since the beginning of time. You have lived many, many lifetimes through reincarnation, hundreds or possibly thousands of times. More than likely, you have been every race, gender and lived from every time period. Again, you are immortal and have died many times throughout history. Every time your soul comes back to earth you pick your life’s blueprint of what you’re going to do and accomplish. Your not meant to just know this or remember this.
You’re meant to discover this throughout life and on your own, learn lessons from it. If everyone was just told what they had to do, or easily remembered, you wouldn’t be able to properly get what you needed out of life. The core learning for each soul, is the ability to love one another and show compassion for each other. Until this is learned by each and every one of us, we will keep having to come back over and over again until it is learned. So please, please start now. For each of us, once you have accomplished this, you will only need to come back if you want to, and if you feel like you lack in some other area of your life.
Please, 🙏 Stop the wars and fighting amongst each other and start to LOVE one another, as it should be. We are spiritual beings having a physical experience, not physical beings having a spiritual experience.
Jesus spoke on the cross: ‘Father, forgive them…. Maybe we will be able to do the same one day. Forgive our enemies. I will get some comments saying some don’t deserve it, but that will be up to and between, you and God.
If you want any other perspective/evidence or guidance on this information, and I suspect you most certainly will, watch the programs/episodes called: (The Ghost inside my Child), and NDE’s, (Near Death Experience) testimonials. Most of these are on RUclips, but you can also find some on the premium’s as well. I watched all three seasons of complete episodes of ‘Ghost’, on my Prime subscription. All the NDE episodes, I watched on RUclips.
There are many different channels on RUclips with different hosts, so try if you can to eventually watch them all. No two experiences are ever the same and all have different information that others won’t have. The more you watch and learn, the better of an understanding you will have of everything I have mentioned in here.
Again, please watch as many of these videos/episodes as you can, because you will get a broader, more detailed understanding of what it’s all about and what’s to come.
I PROMISE YOU, this will completely change your life for the better and you will NEVER fear death again.
Some of you have said it’s the fear of pain you associate with death, you fear mostly and I get that as well.
It will also give you a complete sense of peace and perspective for all things in your life. You will become exponentially more compassionate towards people and animals. You will learn to love yourself first and foremost and that in return, will help you learn to love others better as well.
I completely understand if you can’t and/or won’t initially except some of what I’m telling you. But I do hope and pray that you will try to expand your mind from what you’ve been taught. Trying to get rid of what you were taught since birth and accept something completely new and what some have called, ‘fantastical’ isn’t the easiest thing to do, especially if you like the way things are in your life and don’t except change that easy. I myself have been accused by my family and friends for being what they have called ‘Pig Headed’. I’m not that way anymore, I have completely changed since learning the truth.
I’ve had some ask me about the situation with babies or young children and cancer or illness, disease and ‘why god takes them at such a young age’. Saying, ‘how’s that fair, they didn’t do anything to deserve that’ or ‘why would they pick a life just to turn around and die’.
I initially had issues with all that as well, but over time and learning, it became clear that sometimes the life blueprint that’s picked, is not always about you, but those you choose to be born unto. A mother or father may need to experience/learn humility or sacrifice and yes, sadly the suffering for the loss of a child, just to name a few. I know it sounds cruel but for whatever reason, it was ultimately necessary and Gods plan. We’re not meant to know or understand everything, that’s essentially in Gods hands.
I was a devout nonbeliever and hardcore sceptic, (as most people are these days) when I first heard about this, but the more knowledge you learn and acquire, the more you will realize it all to be true and not just a ‘nice story’, as one guy responded back to me recently.
Please don’t ignore this, it has everything to do with why you’re here. Some things are true whether you believe them or not. I would like to say though, that I’m not in any way an expert on the subject or claim to know everything, not even close. I encourage you to do your own research and come to your own conclusions.
May God Bless YOU, the people of Ukraine 🇺🇦 and the world.
Rock on! Now back to music.
Bono is a criminal and helps the trafficking of children moving on! he is not of the light.
Get John Frusciante back on again soon pls ✨
He never lost the Irish lilt.
I have been a fan since "Under a blood red sky" and spent countless of thousands of £s on U2 products and concerts but have refused to buy the last 3 albums.
U2 seem to have become their own tribute band, reissuing material every year.
I get the impression Larry is slowly distancing himself from the band.
The time has come to hang up their dream of still being relevant and retire to their mansion's and grow old gracefully
WWG1WGA is the Real U2.
Why did they have to move so fast? Album commitments to the record label? It doesn’t feel authentic. They’ve made an album of new material but set inside for the moment presumably because Larry is having surgery and they can’t tour it. perhaps they had yo release something and that is SOS.
Wonder if The Edge ever gives credit to John Martyn for inspiring his (over) use of the Echoplex guitar sound..
I suspect 'Walk On' was lyrically influenced by the end of Hewson's father's life , the lyrics seemed to fit with that narrative more than I ever thought they were about that over-rated Burmese woman. u2 appear unaware of this, so perhaps it was Hewson's subconscious at work rather than deliberation? u2 should be a little wary of Hewson's tendency to idolize public figures in political causes he favours (as with that Burmese woman), particularly regarding Zelenskyy, it's not fully revealed quite whom or what Z. is yet personally, & I've seen a shadowy aspect of his nature in this regard. Supporting Ukraine's resistance to the tyrant in the Kremlin is a different issue. Pretty heavy interview this.
Larry has been replaced by a metronome.
As a person who discovered U2 in 1982 and thought they were the only band that mattered throughout the 80s and 90s, I am just bored with most things they have come out with since the turn of century. And the energy of their amazing early work as men in their 20s doesn't need to to be "reimagined" by guys in their 60s. Its the most disappointing, un-rock thing ever.
Doing what they want to do despite the reaction of fans is the most rock’n roll thing ever.
@@kpodonnell7924 Right. Kicking out your childhood bandmates must be right up there with "doing the RNR thing." Sounds lovely.
Interesting… I’ve also been on the journey since ‘82 as well and apart from this last album I’ve loved every bit of the journey. I find whatever has been going on the last couple of years with Bono & The Edge a bit weird to be doing stuff without the others, and the gig in Las Vegas itself seems super odd and basically a sellout and a simple money grab for some reason and surely they don’t need it but to be doing it without Larry??? Bugger that!
Hey Marty! Give the last 4 albums another chance! Loved them all.
dave, like me, can't shred
He said edges there is only one 😂
I could see new album as "radical" in the original meaning of the word, "at the root", so it's going back to the root of the past songs. Not sure if the new album succeeds, though would need to listen to all the songs. Afraid they will be kind of Lounge versions of the originals.
Waiting to see Rubin with his usual brown nose routine.
Not an album for me, as a long time fan. With three less than affecting albums and a now a greatest hits residency, it seems like the lads are on the precipice of 'packing it in' and it is OKAY TO DO SO. For me, Actung Baby was their pinnacle.
"High School" ??? Edge?? C'mon, Primary School, Secondary School and 3rd Level tis called in Ireland 😂
It's about as radical as my Cat strutting.
Reimagined for sure , but not much imagination in the rearranging.
There are better "reimagined" U2 covers by kids on here.
I am extremely disappointed, not one rearrangement is attractive..... really it's just Bono strutting without an audience, like my Cat does.
Rick is massaging egos here, how can he possibly think its radical ? It's not!!! It's like watching the tv without turning it on, you can see yourself in it but it's a pale shadow.
What the heck has happened U2 ?? Really, I've been a fan, I've got the T-shirts (a few signed by edge actually😊), I've paid my money and it was well spent but these guys have completely lost their mojo and "Mofo" 🤔.
Just go out and give us your top 20 hits in original versions live and dangerous(?), stop trying to blind us with this garbage Edge, it's not working on any level and if it's just something deeply personal then just keep it for your living room then you don't have to come on trying to justify something that's truly brutal. God help us if it was Bono who was on with Rick and telling us all about it............. Meanwhile, several hours later.... wtf , w...t...a...F Bono & Edge ?.... almost 50yrs telling us that it's a four piece unit or nothing and now it's not. I once heard Bono telling some fans that the sum of all the parts (members) was greater than any individuals.... Well never had it been soo damn obvious.
BTW... I can testify that Edge is a really nice bloke.
But can I launch the MUGA campaign right now.
Make U2 Great Again!!😢😢😢
2 things that are starting to tick me off about U2 after being a lifetime fan since 1983, I have to say playing shows without Larry to me is outrageous that's not really in the spirit of U2 and also doing 40 songs stripped down and lyrics changed to suit whatever arty farty thing that their into now is self indulgent and like so wish they could get back to rock'n'roll. I'm starting to get tired of this. The Edge will always be my guitar hero, but it's like the guitar playing is really starting to runout of gas. Sure there are moments, but like the iconic songs and sounds are starting to really fall off the wagon.
,
That’s what satan is, something that is almost it but turns out to actually not be it.
They are fine until they talk about physics
the incessant graphic gives me a headache and i feel pre stroke....unsubscribe
Lol, do you stare at the radio when listening 😂😂 I have often found me doing it. The graphic is kinda Scalextrics infinity.
Strangely more satisfying than the reimagined offering though 😢
The Edge getting his nose brown with these fake carnivorous guru
What is the point of "reimagining" stuff already recorded? It is not "radical," it is boring and uninspired.
What’s the point of continuing to play songs you recorded decades ago the same way over and over again? Those original versions are still out there people can listen to them anytime they want. Why not offer people something different?
I agree. I am a huge u2 fan, but when band's do these type of things it usually means they're out of ideas. Im disappointed. If you're out of ideas, just stay home and take the time to work it out instead of regurgitating more of the same. Less is more at this time in your career.
Bla bla bla
The Edge has mangled all the songs. The problem is when the Edge thinks he's found out who he is and what he does. Starting to believe the hype. It's an appalling collection where the purpose of the songs has aside from about 3 or 4 been vampirically drawn away from them. It's been creeping up for a long time, but somebody needs to seriously take back control of the situation. The new versions are in danger of revealing that U2 are a production deal.
He really seems to have tried to do a Sufijan Stevens, it's really not the point of their back catalog !!! Sure you can do Some days are better than others, but this is just terrible...!!!!!
U2 need to do a humdrum album about like furniture catalogs, dirt on a windscreen, coffee filters, and stuff like that. Miami, laid back precise reflections.
It's terrible to the point of making me into a critic. Probably that one where he was on with Jimmy Page and the nation army dude, was the beginning of the end !!!
I’m from Dublin Ireland and I have listed to this record and it’s terrible. It’s boring, zero musical intelligence. Being from Ireland U2 are big hero’s and have recorded some classic albums but this is crap. ☘️
I don't think the problem is that U2 are a "production deal", but rather that Bono & Edge have this naive and erroneous idea that they need to prove that their songs can be reduced to just chords strummed on an acoustic guitar and a melody sung by Bono. As if arrangements don't matter. But that's not how a lot of U2's music works. It's like taking a symphonic piece and arranging it for piano and leaving out all the orchestral colors and all the intricacies found in the accompaniment. It won't have the same impact.
Radical ??
Some of these re-arrangements absolutely are radical compared to the originals.
God, he's so boring. Edge sits between Neil Peart and Robert Fripp.
Terrible album. Complete copout. Release new material or step down.
They should retire now .
The Edge should talk to Bono about changing his ways. Donating less than 2 % of all proceeds from Bono's charity is dishonest, and absolutely repugnant. I refuse to listen to their music for that reason.
Rumour, me thinks. Sources?
It's a known fact
@@advancingtruth9096 hmmmm…. unless there is credible evidence it’s likely a rumour.
@@advancingtruth9096 hmmm… unless there is credible evidence it’s likely just a rumour.
I can't post links. But if you want, you can search: Bono's ONE foundation under fire for giving tiny percentage of funds to charity
Yep, U2 achieved extreme pretentiousness in a new and refreshing way.
Give Sting a try for pretentiousness some time.
I get such a kick out of the U2 jealousy. lol. Just admit they are better than you are- as musicians, as people... in every way imaginable.
@@AbbeyRoadkill1 I think SOS is a terrible idea. For one of the most creative bands of the last 40 years to rewrite some of their biggest hits with basically two members of the band not involved is just lazy.
They could have released some rarities. I’m sure some of the songs they did with Rick are interesting.
@@DrPhil-pw2to You're seriously gonna begrudge a band that's made it into their 5th decade for looking back at their career? As Edge said in this interview, very few bands are ever in this position, with an opportunity to look back on 40 years of songs. I'm not in love with every re-arrangement. Some of their big hits sound weird to me re-arranged. But there are some deep cuts here that are as good or better than the originals, such as "Invisible" and "Dirty Day."
@@AbbeyRoadkill1 Problem is it sounds like a opportunity missed. Bland.
Radical? It's plain awful, like a sad friend's party.
I'm from the 80s. U2 is without a doubt the most over rated band I. Rock ever.