YR S no it’s not a time problem it’s a bad planning a production problem so they make the author fill in all the plot holes. If you need a book to understand a movie the movie is bad at being a movie
Anakin: I will be the most powerful Jedi ever! I will even stop people from dying! Kylo Ren: I will finish what you have started...Grandfather. Ben Solo *saves Rey from death but not himself* Sidious: Ironic
I remember being a small child playing some revenge of the sith game on my Nintendo, and in said game Obi-Wan had the power force heal. I then was extremely confused when he didnt use it in the movies. Then I learned video games do not equal canon.
I thinked more at a thing like "maybe they can force heal only little damages and can't heal cutted limbs or death itselfe" wich they could actually put in the canon,but not this broken thing
Yeah, force healing can heal small wounds not large ones as that would require more focus and medical knowledge to repair so a bacta tank would be more ideal for that.
Even in the games, they were only ever able to heal themselves. A jedi healing someone else with force heal is completely unheard of and, to my knowledge, makes TROS a first in that regard.
She can force heal because she got a hold of element115 from ze doctor richtofen. She actually packapunched her lightsaber at the end, that’s why it turned yellow: CANNON
"I know there are things about the Force that they're not telling me" Pretty sure that explains it perfectly. The late PT Jedi probably viewed it as some form of attachment.
I seriously LOVE this channel. I always want to dive into Star Wars lore but don’t really have the time or energy to read all the books and stuff. This channel is perfect for me. Thank you for everything you do
Hey man, can you do more Star Wars Explained type videos? I miss the epic background music playing over the visuals while you went into depth about the different fights and events that transpired throughout the SW Universe
Personally, I think that in Obi-Wan and Qui-Gon’s and Anakin and Shmi’s cases, both Obi-Wan and Anakin did not know about Force healing. I also think that the Jedi May have adopted the “rejoice in those who return to the Force” philosophy(like what Yoda described in ROTS) and abandoned the Force healing technique at some point. This would explain why Anakin in ROTS wanted to become a master and discover the secret of Force healing from ancient Jedi texts that only Masters could access.
That's actually a really neat idea. It's too bad that this wasn't what they said in the movie to explain it. I would've accepted that. At this point, everything is just coping and speculation until the book tries to cover it up.
@@Unknown-hb3id it was mentioned, Anakin said I know there are things about the force they aren't telling me. And the novel explains about the restricted section that only Masters could access
@@MrKyletheawesome This was not brought up in Rise of Skywalker at all. The restrictions of Force knowledge in the old Jedi temple were strongly implied to be dark side based. All they had to do is have a throw-away line in Rise of Skywalker or have Rey training more by reading the book.
In Legends at least Obi-wan knew Force Healing but wasnt proficent enough to heal mortal wounds or terminal illness (and was a padawan himself in Phantom Menace). Anakin on the other hand had no skill in it at all and couldnt heal even the simplest of wounds.
I have a theory on Force Heal: time and the severity of the wound. Time: "It's too late." Qui Gon's first words to Obi Wan immediately after Obi Wan defeated Maul on Naboo. Maybe Obi Wan knows Force heal but the time he took to defeat Maul was far too long. This also explains why Obi Wan, who shows patience even as an apprentice, was trying his fastest to defeat Maul when Qui Gon was stabbed. On the battle of Geonosis Arena, Obi Wan was seen putting his hands on a fallen Jedi. My theory, he was trying to use Force heal but it was too late. Severity of the wound: The serpent's wound was not severe enough to take its life, thus it could be healed. Kylo Ren was healed by Rey because Rey immediately healed him after she stabbed him. Ben Solo was able to heal Rey because it was immediately after she was taken out. Qui Gon's wound was fatal. Shmi's wounds were fatal and she was barely hanging on by when Anakin arrived, maybe Anakin doesn't know the ancient texts. Luke couldn't save Anakin because Anakin just wanted to die.
good theory and it does check out, but I feel like no matter how you explain it, it's gonna be so much of a game changer that the "explanations" just feel like excuses
The transferring life from one to another makes it less OP, and also links it back to another earlier instance. Anakin transferred life from The Daughter to revive Ahsoka in The Clone Wars. This new description pretty much matches that scene, but with Anakin as an intermediary since the other participants were both dying.
Jagrofes Also very reminiscent of the Force Healing technique learned by the “Barsen’thor” in Legends aka the first act of the Jedi Consular class story in SWTOR
The ones are more powerful beings than anything else so I would say is because of that. Anakin could not have done it like Rey cause Ahsoka was legit dead at that point
Just want to point out that KOTOR is Legends, and that means that Force Heal was canon since then, stopped being canon when it turned to Legends and now it's back
@@MrRafaeltrainer kinda strange how people are pissed when this stuff is made non-canon, but then when disney makes it canon again, people are even more pissed
I’ve really enjoyed your content recently and I just wanted to say a big thank you for helping me get better Star Wars knowledge and also making my day every time you upload ❤️❤️
i wish you would do video/audio books of the star wars books, and have moments where you stop and talk about what was read kind of like discussing meanings or what not.How you make sense of what is truly happening a lot of times when you are talking. i like the voice changes you do and it would probably be a cool idea for people who dont like to read but love the star wars novels. Another great video man #ThisIsTheWay
"To cheat death is an ability only one has achieved. But if we work together we might be able to find the secret" Palpatine to Darth Vader episode 3. This line alone it's what JJ Abrams used to explain why Ray and Emperor Palpatine were able to use the force to cheat death but no one has beforehand. It's a talent very few has been able to master. Also, the Jedi don't look to stop death. They see death as a transition into becoming part of the force. I quote Yoda's advice to Anakin regarding death "mourn them do not, miss them do not. Rejoice in their transformation into the force".
Why is it easy to accept that only some force users can do specific things (ex. Quinlan Vos and Cal Kestis) but not accept this force heal ability is also something only few can do? That's why I never questioned why Anikan or Obi Wan couldn't. Just sayin 🤷🏿♂️
I would say because Rey can do so much force powers and we don't see her learning to do any of them in the movies and all explanation is in some books. They should have shown us how she learned the force heal imo cause Kylo got a faital wound and she was able to fix it with out any sweat. Note this is my opinion on the subject
Another great episode. As always I find myself yelling at the screen, "No Ani!". Even though I know where he's headed I don't want him to go there lol. I can only assume Cody is still healing since that was his unit with Mace right? And thank goodness for Obi Wan's smarta$$ humor..he cracks me up.
Hot take: as it was something she gained out of the Jedi texts that weren't even digital, it's quite possible that the method of Force healing she uses just wasn't known by the Jedi Order of the Galactic Republic Era. This can preserve any canon they keep from Old Republic about Force healing (since the games use it a lot, especially SWTOR) while taking a different spin on it again.
@@thevenom2731 I know right, when I see someone complain about the extra details from the book I am over here on the otherside thinking which version of movie did these guys see cuz I remember all that stuff.
@@sarimkhan4378Sequel Trilogy Script: "Betray George Lucas and Mark Hamill. Piss off the Star Wars Fans with random nonsense. Create a Mary Sue as the Lead Character. Have Rian Johnson direct the 8th movie and destroy everything that J.J. set up in 7 and have him clean up our mess however he can in 9." It is written on a Coffee-stained McDonalds napkin with Kathleen Kennedy's handwriting.
Also, please do not think that I am only commenting on your videos to bash or two criticize negatively. I honestly enjoy your videos. Even when you cover things that I am not too fond of. One of those things being Disney Canon. But I support your channel as much as I can because I like your content. I just wanted to make sure that is clear. I will never give you a downvote on your Channel.
@@CaptainCoolzCT- You're both acting like children. Who gives a fuck if they did enjoy this shitty movie? Do you have any other dog-whistles you want to parrot (and capitalize??) while you're at it? If you buy "the SJW agenda is what killed star wars" you deny and kill any real thought or explanation to why those movies suck. (while also having a fundamental misunderstanding of social justice, since you don't do your own research.) Disney did butcher star wars, but you are the one bringing up diversity and representation because you saw some bad female actors in your star wars movie. It's really sad to see the hatred, bigotry and vitriol brought into this community by the alt-right. But then again, it shouldn't be surprising.
@@CaptainCoolzCT- no... no they wouldnt have. those texts were from old abandoned jedi temples that luke eventually went to. i dont give a shit about diversity. idk why you would assume that.
@@MrTREEHUNTER22 force healing isnt new. its just new to the movies. The movies have a lot of flaws. but this complaint should be at the bottom of your list
What the fuck are you talking about ? We saw her learning stuff from the book, and she literally said she transfer her Force to the snake to heal it, everything was in the movie but your to lazy to understand it...
Probably because you're too absorbed in your toxicity to not realize she literally had the sacred Jedi texts in her possession so she trained and read for an entire year learning everything from the texts.
This a perfect retcon/ explanation (only if we ignore Kylo) Limits it to people who read the Jedi text/Luke's books/ it being taught by Rey Brings the forces new potential into context Eliminates its necessity in future movies as a crux Explains some of why it wasnt used in the past
thx1085 she loses or draws every single fight against a healthy force user except for the last fight in the entire series, which she wins in the same way that mace windu was able to almost kill prime Sidious in revenge of the sith. How is she overpowered?
Her power in the movies doesn't make sense because they never explain to us about the "dyad in the force." Basically, her and Kylo are one individual in the force, but two seperate physical beings. Thus, as kylo ren's power increased, hers equally did.
I think the first mistake was to make her so powerful right in the beginning, or announce that she is so powerful....What's the difference between Rey & Broom boy? Once we are introduced to broom boy, towards the end of the film we see him use the force effortlessly & at a really young age.....This gives precedence to him being powerful at a later age without any rigorous training since he has shown his abilities at a young age(Anakin Skywalker).....We don't get this with Rey.....Nothing in the movie hints at her being force sensitive until the scene with that stormtrooper because Kylo tells the audience while talking to Snoke that The girl is strong with the force yet untrained??? We as the audience don't see this at all.....I don't count the forceback vision as it is exactly that(A vision).....But after many retcons we now know that she downloaded her powers from Kylo when he entered her mind😂🤣WTF???
I hate the broom boy at the end of the last jedi. It was one of my biggest gripes with that movie, it made people think, oh whos this kid thats powerful at a young age like anakin and you can't have that at the end of part 2 in a trilogy i know theres still force sensitive people in the universe but there's no time to flesh out that story and it just boggles my mind that there was no set plot points or plan for the whole of the sequel trilogy. sorry for my rant but as much as i love ryan johnson he really screwed 8 and left JJ Abrams to pick up the pieces for episode 9.
Movie books shouldn't be explaining a movie, they should be expanding on the background... giving us the inner monologue of characters and the little things that can't fit in the movie arnt essential to the plot but that we fans would maybe have liked to seen thus reading it ENRICHING the movie next time you watch it. Knowing more about what's going on. But they shouldn't be essentially REQUIRED to understand the damned movie.
The Force Drain reminds me of something....Did Palpatine force drained Padme in rots? Like how did he knew that she died? It makes more sense than dying of sadness
Maybe since Palpatine got clone happy, maybe a clone of his grabbed her life force on Mustafar while Anakin was fighting and then when Palpatine came, his clone gave his life force to him, and he gave it to Anakin. I could see Disney making that claim now...
@@marywilcox3102 They have forgotten a lot :/ Dave Filoni wrote it into the canon that the Jedi didn't believe they could be part of the living force after death. There was no known way to live with consciousness after death. But Qui Gon learned it, came back and showed Yoda the way, who then went and taught Obi Wan after Revenge of the Sith, and it made sense. Made sense why only a few Jedi disappeared when they died while the rest didnt. In cloe wars, the jedi council thought Yoda was under a dark side spell believing he could hear Qui Gon from the grave. And yet, in Rise of Skywalker, all the Jedi talk to Rey. especially the ones who died in order 66 and didn't learn how to exist beyond the grave. It's a load of bantha poodoo.
It's been a theory for years and it's pretty believable now. Palpatine transferred Padmé's life force into Anakin, killing her and keeping him alive. That's why the droids said she was healthy but "for reasons we cannot explain, she's dying."
@@kylehill9121 Think about it. She spent years trying to stop the clone wars, watched good people die, lived a secret married life, and then out of the blue, the Republic she fought for became an Empire, Organa and others words of Rebellion becoming more real, the jedi order destroyed, and then hearing that Anakin killed his fellow jedi, including children. Then in her desperation, she confronts him to see if it was not true, only to see that Anakin has become evil. Then that moment when he force choked her. Everything she knew and loved was destroyed in a matter of hours or days.
The Jedi had the ancient texts in their possession. Why wouldn't ALL the other Jedi have used this technique? Selfless giving -- especially from your own life energy -- would be the very essence of the Jedi way. I don't like this answer.
@G Money in real life lots of ancient texts became lost. Ahch-To had been lost and Luke had to seek it out, makes perfect sense that there was lost knowledge there when he found it.
@@TheLightSideReactions Yes I had forgotten about that. But, he could have just been talking about Jedi texts in general, or he could have only read these ones after he died :-)
Another thing I’m going to assume.. forgive me if I’m just “making excuses” but.. the abilities that Rey learns in the Ancient Jedi Texts, could possibly be some of the earliest abilities that force wielders could learn, that over time, as the Jedi order evolved and settled on a very specific code, they had banned. I would think that the Jedi within the order we know, Yodas order, would believe that the ability to heal another would go against nature.. since they fear not death, and embrace becoming one with the force. Destiny and all that. So.. you’d think right, if these healing abilities were in an old book, why wouldn’t the order have the knowledge and teach students these abilities? Like, why doesn’t Anakin or obi-wan have this power? They were some of the most powerful Jedi in the order. Because it went against the belief. They wouldn’t teach anyone those abilities. I’m sure Yoda and other masters knew of such power. But it went again their very understanding of the force. So now.. the order has been destroyed.. and the old ways are gone. Rey has no code to live by. So if she decides to go deep within the texts to learn abilities than she will. There is no code to stop her. And this is what makes the sequels more interesting in a way. What would these Jedi do if they had to rebuild the order? And we kind of see that perspective, and powers that we never would know exist if the order survived. Personally I love it. I love it all.
Don't apologise for having common sense, I mean, tlj was kinda forgettable, but her taking the texts was very memorable. i hate fake star wars fans sometimes
Honestly, this concept is interesting and I see how it was needed (IN A WAY) to drive the story forward BUT the fact that it creates way too many inconsistencies just doesn't really sit right; I can understand that Obi-won wasn't able to use it, I can partially overlook Yoda not using it BUT (1) Its in the jedi texts and none of the jedi knew about it? Luke, Obi-Won, Yoda...? (2) so you're telling me Anakin Skywalker... born from the force, didn't possess the ability to do something like this...? I personally think if they wanted to go with this concept then they should have explained it as something to do with Ben and Rey being a dyad... you know energy "like life itself" they even explain the dyad as being just that... so why not avoid plot holes and disgracing Anakins fall even more and just stick to the dyad as an explanation =/ I mean even Palpatine healed himself using their dyad.... so why cant they willingly use it to heal things and people if they wanted to given they are "life itself"... Just a thought.
Of course she can, just as she can force lighting, and mind trick, and everything else, and they had explained it since the force awakens: because. To be honest, if the novel said she got the power by collecting five tokens inside her favourite cereal box and putting them in the mailbox and then waiting for 6-8 weeks to get back a package with force powers to impress her friends and be the coolest girl in the galaxy, well, that wouldn't be better, but i feel at least would be a little more deserving, at least she'd have had to earn the skills somehow, instead of, because.
Darth Plagueis: **spends an entire lifetime leveraging the complete resources of the Sith order to discover the secrets of using the Force to heal wounds and create life** Rey: lol Force goes brrrr
Think about this Anakin's entire fall to the dark side was because of his inability to stop his loved ones from dying. He could do nothing to save his mother in Episode 2. Then he had visions of Padme's death in Episode 3 thus his obsession to save her grew so much that he turned to the dark side to try to learn how to save her The entire Prequels and Anakin's tragic story was because he couldn't save the people he loved from dying. In Rise of Skywalker Rey saves Ben from dying by touching him and then Ben just resurrects Rey from death by lightly touching her stomach for 5 seconds...
Makes Anakins fall even more tragic. Palpatine lied when he said Anakin couldnt learn to save the ones he loved from a Jedi. The power was always there, it just hadnt been discovered yet. Had the Chosen One remained in the Light, who knows, but he chose the quick and easy path, or so he thought.
I thank you for taking the time to read and explain as this opened a big plot hole in Star Wars Kind of like you said, still doesn't make sense how no one uses this throughout the timeline until her so...still a problem The other main issue seems to be, if force users just could continually heal or drain, it would be a continual back and forth of grab, grab, grab, grab
Can someone please explain to me what the hell "life essence" is and why it's a thing in Star Wars now? Star Wars has "the force", "the living force", "the cosmic force" and midiclorians which facilitate a connection and control of the force. What the hell is happening when someone "transfers some life essence"? Are they giving them some of their midiclorians? I had always assumed that some limited force healing could be accomplished by using the force to support and promote someone else's natural healing mechanism. This "life essence" thing just throws its hands up in the air and says "To hell with it. There are no rules. It's just magic." They've completely broken Star Wars and I hate them for it.
I heard a while back a couple of weeks after the movie came out about Palpatine being a clone. I'm not sure if it was one of your videos or somewhere else. I'm pretty sure it was from your channel of the video I watched. It makes a whole lot of sense as to how Palpatine was able to return when Darth Vader killed him. It wasn't explained at all in the film. Same with how Rey was able to force-heal Ben. It made a lot more sense. I should definitely buy the book so I can read it. Although I'll have to wait for the time being until I can read it.
@Tyranus i think the prequels deserve some slack because the time between the 3 movies is about 10 years or so and a lot could happen in 10 years. The sequels is literally a year for all 3. Theres not as much room for exploring the force especially when jedi masters spend their lifetime to learn very little
@@mxkeyxoxo I get where you're coming from, but she still technically stole them from Luke/the island caretakers. Doesn't matter if Luke rejected the Jedi (as dumb as that whole issue is), she still took it without his, and the caretakers', permission.
So Rey just figured it out by reading a book one time? I can't even cook an egg using a recipe. Reason being: I haven't practised enough. Rey is now confirmed to never have healed before this moment and she just does it, without real necessity for the plot.
I’m still trying to get my head around why did they call the film the rise of skywalker? Rey is a Palpatine granddaughter of Palpatine and ben is a solo but grandson of Anakin. So who is the Skywalker that arisen. The whole star wars story is about Anakin Skywalker. Anakin legacy has been ruined by the films and the book.
I like to think that Jedi masters knew how but it was one of their secrets. This would ironically bring about their end as the ability was what anakin desires and turned against the order to obtain. This would go along nicely with the prequel vibe, especially shown in the clone wars, that the Jedi were just as big a part in their fall as the Sith were. Building on this idea, we could see Vader discover this later and reaffirm his place as a Sith through the rage of the Jedi indirectly killing padme and causing his fall. As for how Rey and Ben know how to do this... meh
People are like, why didn't they explain that in the movie... It took me years to learn what the Clone Wars was, who the mother of the Twins were, the roles of the light and the dark sides, how Palpatine took power (even his name lol). Y'all are spoiled from years of development.
Explains why Rey was able to use Force lightning out of now where on that ship that she thought Chewy was on... well I suppose being a Palpatine explains it just as well, but it does put a little more purpose behind that particular scene. Presumably a lot of things Force related come down to the will of the force as well, as if to say you wouldn't know it anyway unless you were open to it. Anakin wouldn't have been able to Force Drain only because he hadn't been taught it as a Sith, but the potential to do it would require him to also know it was even possible which Palpatine would likely have hidden from him if there was even a chance he could have figured it out at all, which would make Palpatine pretty useless to Anakin.
I feel like Force Healing should be a minor ability. Like it can heal simple injuries like scratches or poison (like the Child healing Greef Karga), but not mortal wounds (like Kylo Ren's stab wound) or dead people (Rey).
Some powers are talents for specific Jedi. Remember Corran Horn couldn't use telekinesis, but was great at mind tricks. Psychometry is Rey & Vos's specialty. Perhaps this Force heal is a specialty. Also, Vader hadn't learned Force Drain before confronting Obi-Wan on Mustafar. Hatred kept him alive as it did Maul.
I really like this explanation, a trained jedi or Sith would’ve have been taught that the force is only a one way street and it just depends on how it is used. I know that people are going to hate a lot of the things that come out of the book but I hope that with time it gets more ingrained in canon as time goes on
I find it amazing how much explaining this novelisation has to do in order to attempt to make that farce of a movie make some sense. Disney Star Wars is a joke. How can anyone enjoy this mess? Please explain it to me.
When Rey force healed Kylo Ren, she transferred her life force to Kylo Ren, so whenever anyone force heals somebody gives part of their life force to the other person/living being to heal them. Rey just did it on a severe and extreme scale.
Theory I appreciate so much enthusiastic fans as yourself covering this. However I apologise for not watching any of this particular video. I have zero interest in retroactive books trying explain away the Disney Trilogy fan fiction.
Wow, I love having to read a book to understand serious plot holes from a movie I just watched. Makes sense right? Am I fucked up? Or am I expecting too much haha
Like I keep saying what is everyone about. Rey even said the same thing in the movie as well. Hiw can it be a fix if something that there to begin with
Pretty much every answer we have gotten CONFIRMED so far from the book could already be INFERRED from the movie by the clues that were already there. The book only gives confirmation to things we could already have figured out on our own, for those that indeed want confirmation. We already had the WHO and WHAT. Now we just have a confirmation of the HOW, but it was already possible to figure out from the movie itself.
![Rey Sees Palpatine's ORIGINAL Plan for Anakin [CANON]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ltpKSRoq7nQ/mqdefault.jpg)
To be honest, I’m not a huge fan of the whole “use the book to explain everything the movie didn’t” technique
No one should be. It's unforgivable. Like buying a game but then you need to buy DLC to finish it.
Sometimes there's just not enough time. You can say this for very many movies that people accept no problem.
YR S no it’s not a time problem it’s a bad planning a production problem so they make the author fill in all the plot holes. If you need a book to understand a movie the movie is bad at being a movie
This only makes it where the movie looks more bad because it depends on a book to explain shit.
I agree...at the same time, without it we wouldn't know details. Thanks MISS KENNEDY!!!
Anakin: I will be the most powerful Jedi ever! I will even stop people from dying!
Kylo Ren: I will finish what you have started...Grandfather.
Ben Solo *saves Rey from death but not himself*
Sidious: Ironic
As put by Thor Skywalker:
Anakin: He spent his life trying to save people from death.
Rey and Kylo: Figured it out without even trying.
Damn straight. Sub to Thor. Would be cool to see him in Rule of two podcast alongside EckhartsLadder
Thor is the man
Ouch. A perfect summary of one of many massive issues with this Disney trilogy.
NOW I'm gonna make another video to nit pick in order to stay relevant.
That's dumb, Anakin didn't want to heal Padme, he had all the technology of this galaxy to do that. He wanted to prevent her to die at all...
anakin skywalker: gets legs chopped off
rey: bro wtf just heal the legs back
Force heal can't bring back severed limbs, it can only heal minor wounds
Noah Crawford and people from the dead 🤨🤨🤨
@@ncrawford5673 I guess a hole through the chest, through organs, and through bones with no visible consequences is "minor wounds" now. Yeah, right...
@@Unknown-hb3id yeah but like I said, it can't heal back severed limbs
Rey is the Bestest Evar!!! [Sarcasm]
Rise of Skywalker Novel Explains Everything That We Didn't Get In The Actual Movie: CANON
@Brody Smith You Don't Need To Explain The Shit Out Of A Movie: CANON
I want to like your comment, but it's at 66 likes... The hardest choices require the strongest will... 😔
@@Roockie117 The time has come..... _execute Order 66._
@Brody Smith _At last......._
@Brody Smith grow up ya ballbag
I remember being a small child playing some revenge of the sith game on my Nintendo, and in said game Obi-Wan had the power force heal. I then was extremely confused when he didnt use it in the movies. Then I learned video games do not equal canon.
AceJoker303 they probably didn’t bring it back from legends
I thinked more at a thing like "maybe they can force heal only little damages and can't heal cutted limbs or death itselfe" wich they could actually put in the canon,but not this broken thing
Not only kenobi mqce windu did as well randomly when he fought anakin
Yeah, force healing can heal small wounds not large ones as that would require more focus and medical knowledge to repair so a bacta tank would be more ideal for that.
Even in the games, they were only ever able to heal themselves. A jedi healing someone else with force heal is completely unheard of and, to my knowledge, makes TROS a first in that regard.
That's what Palpatine did to Rey and Ben: Force Drained their essence to bring him to his younger form.
His senate form
@@bobthegodofmemes2249 Pretty much. XD
@Brody Smith Oh well.
@Spectre N7 I meant his Revenge of the Sith form, which is considered young in terms of the time gap.
@Brody Smith I don't care about Palpatine tbh, I'm more confused with the Force Ghost scene at the end.
The numbers, Mason... WHAT DO THEY MEAN?!??!
Ive been looking for this one
Dragovich... Kravchenko... Steiner... ALL MUST DIE!
She can force heal because she got a hold of element115 from ze doctor richtofen. She actually packapunched her lightsaber at the end, that’s why it turned yellow: CANNON
oxrist oooh, that’s what’s UPPPP👍
What this from?
"I know there are things about the Force that they're not telling me"
Pretty sure that explains it perfectly. The late PT Jedi probably viewed it as some form of attachment.
Dude. YES! Thank you!
I seriously LOVE this channel. I always want to dive into Star Wars lore but don’t really have the time or energy to read all the books and stuff. This channel is perfect for me. Thank you for everything you do
Hey man, can you do more Star Wars Explained type videos? I miss the epic background music playing over the visuals while you went into depth about the different fights and events that transpired throughout the SW Universe
The work that has been done on this channel over the past couple weeks, is exceptional. Great, great stuff.
Personally, I think that in Obi-Wan and Qui-Gon’s and Anakin and Shmi’s cases, both Obi-Wan and Anakin did not know about Force healing. I also think that the Jedi May have adopted the “rejoice in those who return to the Force” philosophy(like what Yoda described in ROTS) and abandoned the Force healing technique at some point. This would explain why Anakin in ROTS wanted to become a master and discover the secret of Force healing from ancient Jedi texts that only Masters could access.
Thank you! I like that idea, explains a lot.
That's actually a really neat idea. It's too bad that this wasn't what they said in the movie to explain it. I would've accepted that. At this point, everything is just coping and speculation until the book tries to cover it up.
@@Unknown-hb3id it was mentioned, Anakin said I know there are things about the force they aren't telling me. And the novel explains about the restricted section that only Masters could access
@@MrKyletheawesome This was not brought up in Rise of Skywalker at all. The restrictions of Force knowledge in the old Jedi temple were strongly implied to be dark side based. All they had to do is have a throw-away line in Rise of Skywalker or have Rey training more by reading the book.
In Legends at least Obi-wan knew Force Healing but wasnt proficent enough to heal mortal wounds or terminal illness (and was a padawan himself in Phantom Menace). Anakin on the other hand had no skill in it at all and couldnt heal even the simplest of wounds.
I saw numbers and thought, “this has to be important!!!”🤔
Same
I thought it was in code
@anakin skywalker same
Spot on.
I have a theory on Force Heal: time and the severity of the wound.
Time:
"It's too late." Qui Gon's first words to Obi Wan immediately after Obi Wan defeated Maul on Naboo.
Maybe Obi Wan knows Force heal but the time he took to defeat Maul was far too long. This also explains why Obi Wan, who shows patience even as an apprentice, was trying his fastest to defeat Maul when Qui Gon was stabbed.
On the battle of Geonosis Arena, Obi Wan was seen putting his hands on a fallen Jedi. My theory, he was trying to use Force heal but it was too late.
Severity of the wound:
The serpent's wound was not severe enough to take its life, thus it could be healed.
Kylo Ren was healed by Rey because Rey immediately healed him after she stabbed him.
Ben Solo was able to heal Rey because it was immediately after she was taken out.
Qui Gon's wound was fatal.
Shmi's wounds were fatal and she was barely hanging on by when Anakin arrived, maybe Anakin doesn't know the ancient texts.
Luke couldn't save Anakin because Anakin just wanted to die.
This is a great theory! Nice one.
good theory and it does check out, but I feel like no matter how you explain it, it's gonna be so much of a game changer that the "explanations" just feel like excuses
The transferring life from one to another makes it less OP, and also links it back to another earlier instance.
Anakin transferred life from The Daughter to revive Ahsoka in The Clone Wars.
This new description pretty much matches that scene, but with Anakin as an intermediary since the other participants were both dying.
Jagrofes Also very reminiscent of the Force Healing technique learned by the “Barsen’thor” in Legends aka the first act of the Jedi Consular class story in SWTOR
It's also similar to what Bastila did to Revan
The ones are more powerful beings than anything else so I would say is because of that. Anakin could not have done it like Rey cause Ahsoka was legit dead at that point
2020 03 12 15 39 44
Dexil12 notification gang
Dexil12 I agree and relate
Exactly
Same
you know you're early when
Love what you’ve been covering lately with the novel! Thank you for fleshing it out for us!
When you’re so early, only numbers showed up for the notification and you thought it was the release date for Vader Ep. 2.
Thank you for sharing these educational videos! The movie is starting to make more sense bit by bit
Oh god. Imagine if Anakin had found these texts when Padme was going to "die." He probably wouldn't have had a need to turn to the dark side.
I'm gonna need 3PO to translate that title
okay but that requires a memory reset. are you sure?
When Rey force healed I remember the many times i used force heal in KOTOR, which made me wonder why game abilities made it into canon star wars
Just want to point out that KOTOR is Legends, and that means that Force Heal was canon since then, stopped being canon when it turned to Legends and now it's back
@@MrRafaeltrainer the pathway to canon and legends is confusing and unatarual
@@iwu-xm3xc Agreed
It's only canon when it's convenient
@@MrRafaeltrainer kinda strange how people are pissed when this stuff is made non-canon, but then when disney makes it canon again, people are even more pissed
I’ve really enjoyed your content recently and I just wanted to say a big thank you for helping me get better Star Wars knowledge and also making my day every time you upload ❤️❤️
Dang, it's like they half-assed the movie but put their heart and soul into the book.
Maybe because the movie should have been 4h20m..? Idk, just a thought.
@@carefreefantasy8522 _nice_
They literally delayed the book to retcon the movie
@@phillyskyguy9535 Seriously.
@ChandSlam They're just lazy, that's all. (Lucasfilm, that is.)
i wish you would do video/audio books of the star wars books, and have moments where you stop and talk about what was read kind of like discussing meanings or what not.How you make sense of what is truly happening a lot of times when you are talking. i like the voice changes you do and it would probably be a cool idea for people who dont like to read but love the star wars novels. Another great video man #ThisIsTheWay
Force heal? The next thing you’ll tell me is all powerful Rey can defeat Palpatine with 2 lightsabers.
This is outrageous... It's unfair.
GAVIN SMITH how can a Jedi be on the council and not be a master?
@@mattflachs6260 Take a seat
@@mattflachs6260 From my point of view the JEDI are evil!
G Lane she had help from the force ghosts you idiot.
Thanks for the videos, good content, good questions and good patience 👀
That title man. Super creative!!!
"To cheat death is an ability only one has achieved. But if we work together we might be able to find the secret" Palpatine to Darth Vader episode 3. This line alone it's what JJ Abrams used to explain why Ray and Emperor Palpatine were able to use the force to cheat death but no one has beforehand. It's a talent very few has been able to master. Also, the Jedi don't look to stop death. They see death as a transition into becoming part of the force. I quote Yoda's advice to Anakin regarding death "mourn them do not, miss them do not. Rejoice in their transformation into the force".
It’s an ability that needs to be learned, you don’t get it handed to you on a silver platter. That is why Darth Plaguies was studying the Force.
Why is it easy to accept that only some force users can do specific things (ex. Quinlan Vos and Cal Kestis) but not accept this force heal ability is also something only few can do? That's why I never questioned why Anikan or Obi Wan couldn't. Just sayin 🤷🏿♂️
I would say because Rey can do so much force powers and we don't see her learning to do any of them in the movies and all explanation is in some books. They should have shown us how she learned the force heal imo cause Kylo got a faital wound and she was able to fix it with out any sweat. Note this is my opinion on the subject
Another great episode. As always I find myself yelling at the screen, "No Ani!". Even though I know where he's headed I don't want him to go there lol.
I can only assume Cody is still healing since that was his unit with Mace right? And thank goodness for Obi Wan's smarta$$ humor..he cracks me up.
Day 437 of me trying to get Star Wars theory to make part 3 of what if I wrote the last Jedi
Like so he can see
Edit: Spelling Errors
Wait he hasn't finished that yet
Thanks for covering all these interesting facts and details
When you’re so early the title is a bunch of numbers
Michael Campbell yep
Literally
Hot take: as it was something she gained out of the Jedi texts that weren't even digital, it's quite possible that the method of Force healing she uses just wasn't known by the Jedi Order of the Galactic Republic Era. This can preserve any canon they keep from Old Republic about Force healing (since the games use it a lot, especially SWTOR) while taking a different spin on it again.
so early, the title isnt even changed from the file yet.
Nice video bro keep up the good work. Looking forward to Vader episode 2
Something that the movie didn't explain again?
JEeeesus, At this point Disney should remake this film following the novel's script.
The only movie where the script is still being written after its release. The ST is just insulting at this point.
It was in the movie as well. Rey even said it out loud same as in the book.
@@AstraFulminous yeah, they even hinted at Palpatine being a clone.
@@thevenom2731 I know right, when I see someone complain about the extra details from the book I am over here on the otherside thinking which version of movie did these guys see cuz I remember all that stuff.
@@sarimkhan4378Sequel Trilogy Script:
"Betray George Lucas and Mark Hamill.
Piss off the Star Wars Fans with random nonsense.
Create a Mary Sue as the Lead Character.
Have Rian Johnson direct the 8th movie and destroy everything that J.J. set up in 7 and have him clean up our mess however he can in 9."
It is written on a Coffee-stained McDonalds napkin with Kathleen Kennedy's handwriting.
Also, please do not think that I am only commenting on your videos to bash or two criticize negatively. I honestly enjoy your videos. Even when you cover things that I am not too fond of. One of those things being Disney Canon. But I support your channel as much as I can because I like your content. I just wanted to make sure that is clear. I will never give you a downvote on your Channel.
I don't like Disney fixes unnessesary Plotholes by slapping Novels onto it. They should have tried to get the essentials right in the first place.
Amazing video @Star Wars Theory!!
I love the hat, Theory, where’d you get it? The dark horse comics were better than the new ones me thinks.
I'd say the newer comics are on the same level as dark horse espcially the Vader ones
Your notification is my favorite part of the day
This is complete BS. That was awful in the movie. It retcons the whole point of the prequels. This trilogy was garbage.
when i saw it I pretty much assumed she learned it from the ancient texts, ya know, instead of crying like a manchild
@@Vexreal_ You can't explain everything with a vague bullshit excuse.
@@CaptainCoolzCT- You're both acting like children. Who gives a fuck if they did enjoy this shitty movie? Do you have any other dog-whistles you want to parrot (and capitalize??) while you're at it? If you buy "the SJW agenda is what killed star wars" you deny and kill any real thought or explanation to why those movies suck. (while also having a fundamental misunderstanding of social justice, since you don't do your own research.) Disney did butcher star wars, but you are the one bringing up diversity and representation because you saw some bad female actors in your star wars movie. It's really sad to see the hatred, bigotry and vitriol brought into this community by the alt-right. But then again, it shouldn't be surprising.
@@CaptainCoolzCT- no... no they wouldnt have. those texts were from old abandoned jedi temples that luke eventually went to. i dont give a shit about diversity. idk why you would assume that.
@@MrTREEHUNTER22 force healing isnt new. its just new to the movies. The movies have a lot of flaws. but this complaint should be at the bottom of your list
Thank you for explaining from The Rise of the Skywalker novel about how rey learn force heal may the force be with you
WHY DIDN'T THEY EXPLAIN IT IN THE STUPID MOVIE
Zorastorm 32 right it’s like stop explaining the movie at this point
you answered your own question. It was a stupid movie thats why.
Why would they need to?
What the fuck are you talking about ? We saw her learning stuff from the book, and she literally said she transfer her Force to the snake to heal it, everything was in the movie but your to lazy to understand it...
Probably because you're too absorbed in your toxicity to not realize she literally had the sacred Jedi texts in her possession so she trained and read for an entire year learning everything from the texts.
I love your videos man, a true king 👑
I may not like the sequel trilogy but Hearing Mr Theory read (In a Yoda voice) "It warms my heart"😂👍
This a perfect retcon/ explanation (only if we ignore Kylo)
Limits it to people who read the Jedi text/Luke's books/ it being taught by Rey
Brings the forces new potential into context
Eliminates its necessity in future movies as a crux
Explains some of why it wasnt used in the past
As much as I love Star Wars and love watching your content...
I still think Rey’s over powered and it was annoying
thx1085 she loses or draws every single fight against a healthy force user except for the last fight in the entire series, which she wins in the same way that mace windu was able to almost kill prime Sidious in revenge of the sith. How is she overpowered?
Her power in the movies doesn't make sense because they never explain to us about the "dyad in the force." Basically, her and Kylo are one individual in the force, but two seperate physical beings. Thus, as kylo ren's power increased, hers equally did.
my local tyme is 00:28 and I had a feeling that a new video was uploaded, and the force brought me here.
Love the title
Love the vidz and cant wait for episode 2 of the vader film 😁
I think the first mistake was to make her so powerful right in the beginning, or announce that she is so powerful....What's the difference between Rey & Broom boy? Once we are introduced to broom boy, towards the end of the film we see him use the force effortlessly & at a really young age.....This gives precedence to him being powerful at a later age without any rigorous training since he has shown his abilities at a young age(Anakin Skywalker).....We don't get this with Rey.....Nothing in the movie hints at her being force sensitive until the scene with that stormtrooper because Kylo tells the audience while talking to Snoke that The girl is strong with the force yet untrained??? We as the audience don't see this at all.....I don't count the forceback vision as it is exactly that(A vision).....But after many retcons we now know that she downloaded her powers from Kylo when he entered her mind😂🤣WTF???
I hate the broom boy at the end of the last jedi. It was one of my biggest gripes with that movie, it made people think, oh whos this kid thats powerful at a young age like anakin and you can't have that at the end of part 2 in a trilogy i know theres still force sensitive people in the universe but there's no time to flesh out that story and it just boggles my mind that there was no set plot points or plan for the whole of the sequel trilogy. sorry for my rant but as much as i love ryan johnson he really screwed 8 and left JJ Abrams to pick up the pieces for episode 9.
Nice video now i know more about rise of skywalker thxxx
Movie books shouldn't be explaining a movie, they should be expanding on the background... giving us the inner monologue of characters and the little things that can't fit in the movie arnt essential to the plot but that we fans would maybe have liked to seen thus reading it ENRICHING the movie next time you watch it. Knowing more about what's going on. But they shouldn't be essentially REQUIRED to understand the damned movie.
I love your videos
Ur the best
Please make more fan fictions
The Force Drain reminds me of something....Did Palpatine force drained Padme in rots? Like how did he knew that she died? It makes more sense than dying of sadness
How could he? He never interacted with her.
Maybe since Palpatine got clone happy, maybe a clone of his grabbed her life force on Mustafar while Anakin was fighting and then when Palpatine came, his clone gave his life force to him, and he gave it to Anakin.
I could see Disney making that claim now...
@@Bacontats I don't doubt that they will make such a claim. They clearly forgot that cloning a Force Sensitive being is a difficult process.
@@marywilcox3102 They have forgotten a lot :/ Dave Filoni wrote it into the canon that the Jedi didn't believe they could be part of the living force after death. There was no known way to live with consciousness after death. But Qui Gon learned it, came back and showed Yoda the way, who then went and taught Obi Wan after Revenge of the Sith, and it made sense. Made sense why only a few Jedi disappeared when they died while the rest didnt. In cloe wars, the jedi council thought Yoda was under a dark side spell believing he could hear Qui Gon from the grave.
And yet, in Rise of Skywalker, all the Jedi talk to Rey. especially the ones who died in order 66 and didn't learn how to exist beyond the grave.
It's a load of bantha poodoo.
@@Bacontats maybe he was so powerful, he didnt had to be near her to do that..still, how did he knew she died...?
Nice video men, that's cool that you do those video go on and do more, concerning the story, i call bs on that force healing power lol
Actually I saw a theory about palpatine healing Anakin with a little bit of force life from padme and that being the reason why she died!
It's been a theory for years and it's pretty believable now. Palpatine transferred Padmé's life force into Anakin, killing her and keeping him alive. That's why the droids said she was healthy but "for reasons we cannot explain, she's dying."
@@kylehill9121 yeah exactly! :D
I always thought her broken heart killed her. She couldn’t handle Anakin turning into the dark side.
@@jacobcollins8279 That doesn't seem very much like Padmé though. Padmé is a strong leader.
@@kylehill9121 Think about it. She spent years trying to stop the clone wars, watched good people die, lived a secret married life, and then out of the blue, the Republic she fought for became an Empire, Organa and others words of Rebellion becoming more real, the jedi order destroyed, and then hearing that Anakin killed his fellow jedi, including children. Then in her desperation, she confronts him to see if it was not true, only to see that Anakin has become evil. Then that moment when he force choked her. Everything she knew and loved was destroyed in a matter of hours or days.
Very interesting video!
The Jedi had the ancient texts in their possession. Why wouldn't ALL the other Jedi have used this technique? Selfless giving -- especially from your own life energy -- would be the very essence of the Jedi way. I don't like this answer.
I don't thihk Republic Jedi had these texts, Luke found them on Ahch-To.
@G Money in real life lots of ancient texts became lost. Ahch-To had been lost and Luke had to seek it out, makes perfect sense that there was lost knowledge there when he found it.
@@peteface24 - Yoda had access to them. Otherwise, how would he know that they weren't "page-turners?"
@@TheLightSideReactions Yes I had forgotten about that. But, he could have just been talking about Jedi texts in general, or he could have only read these ones after he died :-)
The fact that so much needs to be explained by a book is just another indication that they should have just made 2 movies.
Another thing I’m going to assume.. forgive me if I’m just “making excuses” but.. the abilities that Rey learns in the Ancient Jedi Texts, could possibly be some of the earliest abilities that force wielders could learn, that over time, as the Jedi order evolved and settled on a very specific code, they had banned. I would think that the Jedi within the order we know, Yodas order, would believe that the ability to heal another would go against nature.. since they fear not death, and embrace becoming one with the force. Destiny and all that. So.. you’d think right, if these healing abilities were in an old book, why wouldn’t the order have the knowledge and teach students these abilities? Like, why doesn’t Anakin or obi-wan have this power? They were some of the most powerful Jedi in the order. Because it went against the belief. They wouldn’t teach anyone those abilities. I’m sure Yoda and other masters knew of such power. But it went again their very understanding of the force.
So now.. the order has been destroyed.. and the old ways are gone. Rey has no code to live by. So if she decides to go deep within the texts to learn abilities than she will. There is no code to stop her. And this is what makes the sequels more interesting in a way. What would these Jedi do if they had to rebuild the order? And we kind of see that perspective, and powers that we never would know exist if the order survived.
Personally I love it. I love it all.
You don't have to apologise about using your brain, it's pretty rare in the star wars community...
Don't apologise for having common sense, I mean, tlj was kinda forgettable, but her taking the texts was very memorable. i hate fake star wars fans sometimes
love the insight keep em coming bud subscribe back also
Honestly, this concept is interesting and I see how it was needed (IN A WAY) to drive the story forward BUT the fact that it creates way too many inconsistencies just doesn't really sit right; I can understand that Obi-won wasn't able to use it, I can partially overlook Yoda not using it BUT (1) Its in the jedi texts and none of the jedi knew about it? Luke, Obi-Won, Yoda...? (2) so you're telling me Anakin Skywalker... born from the force, didn't possess the ability to do something like this...? I personally think if they wanted to go with this concept then they should have explained it as something to do with Ben and Rey being a dyad... you know energy "like life itself" they even explain the dyad as being just that... so why not avoid plot holes and disgracing Anakins fall even more and just stick to the dyad as an explanation =/ I mean even Palpatine healed himself using their dyad.... so why cant they willingly use it to heal things and people if they wanted to given they are "life itself"... Just a thought.
100%, they created the greatest retcon in Star Wars history. I saw it as an ability only granted to Rey & Kylo bcuz of the Force Dyad.
Of course she can, just as she can force lighting, and mind trick, and everything else, and they had explained it since the force awakens: because. To be honest, if the novel said she got the power by collecting five tokens inside her favourite cereal box and putting them in the mailbox and then waiting for 6-8 weeks to get back a package with force powers to impress her friends and be the coolest girl in the galaxy, well, that wouldn't be better, but i feel at least would be a little more deserving, at least she'd have had to earn the skills somehow, instead of, because.
357 likes, 154 comments, no views and the title is 2020 03 12 15 39 44?
Sounds about right 😂
Darth Plagueis: **spends an entire lifetime leveraging the complete resources of the Sith order to discover the secrets of using the Force to heal wounds and create life**
Rey: lol Force goes brrrr
Think about this Anakin's entire fall to the dark side was because of his inability to stop his loved ones from dying. He could do nothing to save his mother in Episode 2. Then he had visions of Padme's death in Episode 3 thus his obsession to save her grew so much that he turned to the dark side to try to learn how to save her
The entire Prequels and Anakin's tragic story was because he couldn't save the people he loved from dying. In Rise of Skywalker Rey saves Ben from dying by touching him and then Ben just resurrects Rey from death by lightly touching her stomach for 5 seconds...
Makes Anakins fall even more tragic. Palpatine lied when he said Anakin couldnt learn to save the ones he loved from a Jedi. The power was always there, it just hadnt been discovered yet. Had the Chosen One remained in the Light, who knows, but he chose the quick and easy path, or so he thought.
I thank you for taking the time to read and explain as this opened a big plot hole in Star Wars
Kind of like you said, still doesn't make sense how no one uses this throughout the timeline until her so...still a problem
The other main issue seems to be, if force users just could continually heal or drain, it would be a continual back and forth of grab, grab, grab, grab
Can someone please explain to me what the hell "life essence" is and why it's a thing in Star Wars now? Star Wars has "the force", "the living force", "the cosmic force" and midiclorians which facilitate a connection and control of the force. What the hell is happening when someone "transfers some life essence"? Are they giving them some of their midiclorians? I had always assumed that some limited force healing could be accomplished by using the force to support and promote someone else's natural healing mechanism. This "life essence" thing just throws its hands up in the air and says "To hell with it. There are no rules. It's just magic." They've completely broken Star Wars and I hate them for it.
TheJoeMan the force was always just magic until the prequels changed it to biology lol
I heard a while back a couple of weeks after the movie came out about Palpatine being a clone. I'm not sure if it was one of your videos or somewhere else. I'm pretty sure it was from your channel of the video I watched. It makes a whole lot of sense as to how Palpatine was able to return when Darth Vader killed him. It wasn't explained at all in the film. Same with how Rey was able to force-heal Ben. It made a lot more sense. I should definitely buy the book so I can read it. Although I'll have to wait for the time being until I can read it.
When you need 15 novels to explain plot holes in your trilogy, you made a bad trilogy, screw Disney-Wars.
@Tyranus Oh yeah definitely, we give them slack because of the memes but the prequels (especially 1 and 2) were absolutely terrible in that regard.
@Tyranus i think the prequels deserve some slack because the time between the 3 movies is about 10 years or so and a lot could happen in 10 years. The sequels is literally a year for all 3. Theres not as much room for exploring the force especially when jedi masters spend their lifetime to learn very little
You are a fucking idiot
it's not surprising that Rey can use force heal since she, unlike Anakin is a Mary Sue who could literally do anything if the plot requires it.
I mean, she 'stole' the ancient sacred Jedi texts.
DjTruchas well...yeah
🙄🙄🙄 they belonged to her just as much as any other Jedi, especially considering there were no other living Jedi to study those texts besides her.
MICHALIS true enough
@@mxkeyxoxo I get where you're coming from, but she still technically stole them from Luke/the island caretakers. Doesn't matter if Luke rejected the Jedi (as dumb as that whole issue is), she still took it without his, and the caretakers', permission.
Love these book excerpt reviews.
Book explains how Rey can Force Heal:
Something...something...Mary Sue.
It's impressive that another one of Rey's powers was a new asspull, even with the explanation
Hold up, something ain't right with the title
So Rey just figured it out by reading a book one time? I can't even cook an egg using a recipe. Reason being: I haven't practised enough. Rey is now confirmed to never have healed before this moment and she just does it, without real necessity for the plot.
I’m still trying to get my head around why did they call the film the rise of skywalker? Rey is a Palpatine granddaughter of Palpatine and ben is a solo but grandson of Anakin. So who is the Skywalker that arisen. The whole star wars story is about Anakin Skywalker. Anakin legacy has been ruined by the films and the book.
Marketing.
Skywalker in a figurative sense...
I like to think that Jedi masters knew how but it was one of their secrets. This would ironically bring about their end as the ability was what anakin desires and turned against the order to obtain. This would go along nicely with the prequel vibe, especially shown in the clone wars, that the Jedi were just as big a part in their fall as the Sith were. Building on this idea, we could see Vader discover this later and reaffirm his place as a Sith through the rage of the Jedi indirectly killing padme and causing his fall. As for how Rey and Ben know how to do this... meh
People are like, why didn't they explain that in the movie...
It took me years to learn what the Clone Wars was, who the mother of the Twins were, the roles of the light and the dark sides, how Palpatine took power (even his name lol).
Y'all are spoiled from years of development.
Exactly!
WOOOOOOOORD!!!!
Explains why Rey was able to use Force lightning out of now where on that ship that she thought Chewy was on... well I suppose being a Palpatine explains it just as well, but it does put a little more purpose behind that particular scene. Presumably a lot of things Force related come down to the will of the force as well, as if to say you wouldn't know it anyway unless you were open to it. Anakin wouldn't have been able to Force Drain only because he hadn't been taught it as a Sith, but the potential to do it would require him to also know it was even possible which Palpatine would likely have hidden from him if there was even a chance he could have figured it out at all, which would make Palpatine pretty useless to Anakin.
"She was acting on pure instinct now." ..."now"? NOW?? It's comical how bad this all is, lol.
I feel like Force Healing should be a minor ability. Like it can heal simple injuries like scratches or poison (like the Child healing Greef Karga), but not mortal wounds (like Kylo Ren's stab wound) or dead people (Rey).
Can we stop talking about Rise of Skywalker?
Exactly. Now he's an active member of the Rise of Skywalker Defense Force, and it's getting really boring and annoying.
Some powers are talents for specific Jedi. Remember Corran Horn couldn't use telekinesis, but was great at mind tricks. Psychometry is Rey & Vos's specialty. Perhaps this Force heal is a specialty. Also, Vader hadn't learned Force Drain before confronting Obi-Wan on Mustafar. Hatred kept him alive as it did Maul.
short answer: she's a mary sue
Short answer: you are an Idiot who doesn't know what a mary sue is
@@deadshot5007 okay, tell me why she isn't
I really like this explanation, a trained jedi or Sith would’ve have been taught that the force is only a one way street and it just depends on how it is used. I know that people are going to hate a lot of the things that come out of the book but I hope that with time it gets more ingrained in canon as time goes on
I find it amazing how much explaining this novelisation has to do in order to attempt to make that farce of a movie make some sense.
Disney Star Wars is a joke. How can anyone enjoy this mess? Please explain it to me.
"I've been looking forward to this!"
When Rey force healed Kylo Ren, she transferred her life force to Kylo Ren, so whenever anyone force heals somebody gives part of their life force to the other person/living being to heal them. Rey just did it on a severe and extreme scale.
Is there a rule with that? Like 30 seconds of force healing takes away two years? Can’t wait for that book to come out
Which she learned from herself
When you so early the title is a literal sequence of numbers
More “after the fact” explanation of weak points that weren’t thought of ahead of production. Classic JarJar Abrams garbage.
You inspire me to be happy
Theory I appreciate so much enthusiastic fans as yourself covering this. However I apologise for not watching any of this particular video. I have zero interest in retroactive books trying explain away the Disney Trilogy fan fiction.
AMEN!!!!!!!!
Watch "Why Jedi Couldn’t use Force Healing to Save Others in Every Situation! (Legends)" on RUclips
ruclips.net/video/CJwy8jwt-mw/видео.html
Wow, I love having to read a book to understand serious plot holes from a movie I just watched. Makes sense right? Am I fucked up? Or am I expecting too much haha
Like I keep saying what is everyone about. Rey even said the same thing in the movie as well. Hiw can it be a fix if something that there to begin with
Pretty much every answer we have gotten CONFIRMED so far from the book could already be INFERRED from the movie by the clues that were already there. The book only gives confirmation to things we could already have figured out on our own, for those that indeed want confirmation. We already had the WHO and WHAT. Now we just have a confirmation of the HOW, but it was already possible to figure out from the movie itself.