Yeah he might of but Zizzy and Pony were the only reasons why you stood still long enough for Foxy to sneak up in the first place, Foxy would probably just end up following you
@@angangep no chapter 1 wouldent even exist because George wouldn’t have gone missing since mr p would just acept the death and not try to make an antidote
It probably won’t be a paradise, some investigation conducted by the good folks over on Discord has shown that there was possibly a war going on regarding oil prices with Europe and the Middle East attacking each other before Ms.P even got sick, I will let ya guys do some investigations regarding the topic but think we managed to piece up some things leading to this theory, won’t say what lead us to it tho, will let y’all find out for yourselves.
I mean the story would prob go the same way. Actually, Zizzy and Pony would have came with us inside the Plant since Georgie wouldn't have gathered the soldiers. And maybe Mr. P would still be alive since Zizzy and Pony would be much helpful
Actually, Doggy said “I hope you’re right about her being here.” So without us Willow wouldn’t have ever gotten arrested and formed TSP. Well she still might’ve formed it but in the flashback she seemed nicer so maybe since she wouldn’t have anyone in her way she could dedicate TSP to finder her brother. In that case Pony would’ve stayed in TSP
@@furret1855 Maybe Do Something With Carnival And House Bc Gurty Is Piggy And A Joke Bc Carnivals Prob Has Jokes And There Is A Head Of Gurty In Foxys Cage And Body At The Houses Lasers And Arm On A Clown Ball And The Other Arm Is Being Held By Piggy On Her Back And That One Is Tricky You Have To Shoot Piggy And Take The Arm And It Has To Be Bot And The Leg Is On The Roller Coaster And ZombPiggy Has The Last Leg In His Hand And Same Story As Piggy You Have To Shoot Em And Grab It (Has To Be The Tombstone Trap On Carnival)
WHAT IF:Mr.stitchy was an imaginary monster that player had created to suppress their trauma about doggy becoming infected,btw I came up with this when Mr.stitchy was new character with less information about I LOVE YOUR VIDEOS AND PLS MAKE THIS A SERIES
If tigry threw the sword but didnt steal the boat someone would just commit ded And we would have not met captain budgey , we would have gotten different chapters 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 and 12 possibly adding a different ending , we don't know anything about chapter 9 , 10 , 11 and 12 meaning: NOBODY KnOWS WHAT COULD BE NEXT . If we met Willow first in the infection ... I think we would be having to work together , willow would act similarly as in the second part of book 2 , we rather wouldn't meet mr.P and maybe tsp would never be a thing as player and willow would be deciding where they will go together , simply : the story would be very different .
Suggestion: What if: George never went missing? What if: The Piggy Family was never infected, but Mr. P was? What if: Willow's parents were not arrested, William didn't go missing, we didn't arrest Willow, Daisy was with Willow and William and Willow and her family were not criminals? (Shorter version: What if Willow was not mad?) What if: We were in T.S.P.? Edit: *OH MAN JUST LIKE 3 MINUTES AND ALREADY 9 LIKES!?*
Doggy is and always will be my favorite character Mr. P is a close second so, thank you, for doing this. I also kinda forgot that the player was a police officer along with Doggy in the story so they aren't really removable since they would be always be one of the first on the scene
i got some ''what if'' questions what if the player died at the plant? what if mr.p came along with the group? what if pony stayed and did not leave T.S.P that was it i hope you consider doing more of these whatif video's have a good day!
I Love this idea. I'll try to make my own alt history's out of those ideas. Alt history 1: Doggy doesn't drink the potion. The player probably doesn't leave the forest sense doggy can handle infected with his axe. Eventually, they run out of supplies and are forced to leave about 2½ months after arriving. Aside from the player and Doggy, Bunny is infected with no one to save her. Mr. P gets mad with guilt probably later. Depends on how long Bunny survives. Pony, Zizzy, Mimi, and Girrafey meet Georgie later, but they still go to the outpost. They face Mr. P themselves. They are probably killed by Mr. P because they think he is just a survivor that went mad. Girrafey, Mimi, and Zizzy's sisters probably won't survive longer, because they will go out looking for Zizzy and Pony. Sense Tigery took her boat, Willow kills him because she doesn't realize she is bad. Back to Doggy and the player, they go to the city. They find refuge in the abandoned Safe Place. They get batteries and hear about a cure. They hear the military is working on a cure, with a group called "The Silver Paw" up north where infected can not survive. Scavenging let's the player and Doggy survive while the build a bout to ho up north. 15 months after this started, they set sail. They use a river, which had to have been nearby or else they wouldn't have been able to survive in the forest in the actual game, to get to the ocean. They sail across the North sea. Willow is Furios that we survived. Doggy and the player attempt to make Willow less mad, but it's in vain. It fuels her madness and infront of the military, she shoots Doggy. With the military's medical stuff he survives and the military arrests willow.
If the player never existed then doggy and the other police officers wouldn’t even be able to arrest willow because they only found willow because of the player’s detective skills
For the first one. Nothing would change. Mall would just be cut. We would just put a pin in the case, classify him as dead and then move on. Georgie makes no impact on the story at all
Suggestion: What if Mr. P got infected instead of the piggy family? Edit: Many people are contradicting this idea and saying it doesn’t make sense so I might delete this comment son
Yeah Pretty Good Idea But Mr.P Was The One Giving Potions In The First Place And probably it would be easier to find the cure Like Take down a Potato look Very easy and I Don't know if That Stick arm Can Scratch anyone But...Pretty cool Idea 👍
Chapter 1 wouldn't happen because Georgie got missing because he was scared of his parents but in this timeline Mr. P is infected instead of his parents
I think we might’ve still met Zizzy and Pony in the “Mr. P not being crazy” run, because there’s something you forgot; we still have to find Georgie. After searching all over Lucella, we’d most likely have one of these outcomes come up. - The Mall was right next to the Safe Place, so after finding Georgie, we’d exit the Mall and see a sign for a “safe place” and although it might be a trap, we go and see if there’s any survivors. - On the way to the Mall, we walk past the Safe Place and happen to spot survivors outside, such as Mimi or others. - When we’re in the Mall, we bump into one of the Safe Place members and partner together. All of these outcomes would pretty much include Mimi, Giraffy, Zizzy, Zee, Zuzy and Pony coming with us back to the Plant. This is just speculation though so idk :)
Honestly, I think the Mr. P situation and him being crazy is due to his wife getting more and more fatigued and progressively sick. I can understand why he picked the risk of using an unstable substance for his cure. Its more of a "If it can work, I'll definitely do it" situation (but in reality you may just want to pick the safer option). I also think I know why Mr. P goes crazy in chapter 7-11. First of all, Mrs. P gets infected, and you probably would go crazy if that happened aswell. Second of all, Bunny gets infected aswell, his best friend. Third of all, he thinks the Player gets infected aswell., cuz he saw signs of infection in the Player. This makes him spiral out of control. I also think I know how the doggy story would go. I agree with everything you said would happen until chapter 6. At the end of chapter 6, and doggy happens to die someway somehow at the end, the player would be extremely enraged, due to the fact that they've already lost zizzy, pony, and now doggy. The Player may not want to help Willow whatsoever at this state, but Willow probably wouldn't care that much because "we're even now (because willow lost 3 members of his family, the player lost 3 of their friends)" The player and willow go of to their seperate ways, while willow (maybe by himself, because you saved all the tsp members, or maybe with only some of the tsp members, because I think Tigry and Kitty may go off with The Safe Place members.) goes back to the factory, and the player and their group goes back to the safe place, maybe to repair it somewhat. The player may put revenge over everything else in their mental state. Every way you think about it, the piggy story if doggy was alive (aside from the cure) all ends at chapter 6, book 6
He would become super power full imagine just imagine if you had super powers and a infected was chasing you so you can grab something to make you have your super power charge and then you can use it to kill the infected but they wake up
Heres my timeline if the player didnt exist: Chapter 1 wouldn't exist, since Doggy is on his vacation. Instead lets make Doggy sort of our protagonist. Doggy is in Chapter 2 and decides to look for the fuel himself and goes to gallery for a safe place. It goes on pretty much the same until forest, Doggy doesn't get Infected and encounters Sheepy instead. He gets out and hears Mr. P This is where it goes a bit different, I'd say Doggy is pretty rational and smart so maybe Doggy decides he doesn't go to the school. You may ask, why? Well bunny could've been a trap. In a zombie apocalypse scenario, supplies are very important, Bunny could've been a trap to beat us up and get our supplies (if we had any). So there's a chance Doggy doesn't go and decides to look for a safe place,. maybe meeting the safe place or T.S.P. But for the sake of our timeline lets say Doggy goes to the school and rescues Bunny, there's another possible scenario that Doggy doesn't pass out. So then Mr. P, Bunny and Doggy decide to go to the Plant and the story goes on from there. Let's say Doggy does pass out and Mr. P leaves us, we go to the Metro and leave bunny. I think Metro would've been the last Chapter since Chapter 8 only existed for revenge, so Doggy would've left behind Bunny and went to look for a safe place. Maybe he'll meet Giraffy and Mimi, not Zizzy and Pony since they're in the Carnival for supplies. Maybe he'll meet T.S.P or maybe even George in mall or other places. If Doggy did infact go to the carnival, then the story would've been the same for Book 1
For the "Player never existed" ( 11:10 ) we still don't know what pony did. Maybe him leaving was such a atrocity that willow would still infect zizzy just to make pony feel pain.
I have a suggestion for Devoun for this cool series. WHAT IF the metro train didnt take us to the carnival. WHAT IF we didnt faint in the school WHAT IF we didnt arrest willow
What If #1: We would’ve never met Zizzy and Pony, and the rest of The Safe Place. We would’ve never found Georgie. We probably would’ve never found Mr. P. Even if we did, we wouldn’t succeed in discovering the truth. What if #2: Bunny would’ve never been infected. Mr. P’s research team wouldn’t have gotten infected. We would’ve never met Zizzy and Pony, same thing with Georgie. It’s pretty similar to “What if Mr. P wasn’t crazy?” What If #3: Doggy and the player would’ve been fired from their jobs, Willow wouldn’t have been angry at us. So, House, Station and Gallery wouldn’t have happened.
This series is a change from normal stuff (meme review) and is creative. You can think of new ways piggy could of happened and can clear up some story as well as changing it. 5/5 series and would love to see more! 👀
What if the uncannon ending in Factory, was cannon? Factory: You and Pony leave the factory without saving any member of T.S.P, and just use the three swords on Willow. Once escaping, there's no member to convince Willow to stop, and just takes aim on the player, before seeing Zee and Zuzy show up. Once the twins arrive, Willow starts to receive a lot of guilt, for not caring about her own people, taking away the twins from their sister, and shooting Giraffy and the Player. Everyone else doesn't trust Willow so quickly now, but still needs her to go north. Port: There's no player to get the lighthouse working, so Willow goes herself. She gets the lighthouse to work. Getting on Budgey's ship, "she needs more fuel" to get the ship running again. Since the player isn't there to go down with Willow, she goes down there by herself once again. Ship: Willow goes down, being outnumbered by all the crewmates. (In a less harsh ending, lets say she makes it down the fuel area). Without Player being able to warn Willow about Kenneth being right behind her, she gets scratched and gets turned into one of them. Pony, Georgie, Zee, and Zuzy go down, to see Willow with a sad look. She tells them, how she has been scratched and needs to leave. They all leave Willow behind, and they're already at Doveport. Without the fuel. The story continues on without the Player, and Willow.
Well, the player got infected by Penny in House since he was hit in the head by her. Bunny would’ve never gotten infected, Mr. P’s research team would’ve never gotten infected, we would’ve never met Zizzy, Pony, the rest of the Safe Place and Georgie. Pretty similar to “What If Mr. P Was Never Crazy?”
what if he was forced to make the potion infected? what if the Inscolence made Mrs p sick and said they would cure her if he makes this potion? what if he just didnt have a choice? this explains the voices in his head part
@@milibao if you think about it, Willow has a bigger impact on the story then us, we would be dead if it wasn’t for Willow in the ship. And her parents being taken away, her parents would still get infected from going outside and getting recourses.
1. Nobody would know of the cure. 2. TSP would never exist. 3. Pony’s parents, and foxy wouldn’t be infected. 4. Zee and Zuzy could possibly be infected
1. What if Pony and Zizzy never met 2. What if the piggy family never got infected 3. What if Willows family never got arrested 4. What if the T.S.P never existed 5. What if Mr.Stichy never existed 6. What if The safe place never existed 7. What if Bunny never got infected 8. What if Doggy and Bunny met each other in stead of Zizzy and Pony meeting each other 9. What if Rash never met Williow 10. What if Piggy and Pokémon made a map together (Ok maybe this might not happen)⬆️ More ideas soon...maybe
If the player didn’t exist, Willow’s parents wouldn’t be taken away. That would lead to a lot, Willow and William would still be with their parents (obviously), Daisy would have no reason to go there, and William wouldn’t leave. They could’ve still be taken away later on for stealing supplies and things, but it wouldn’t be the player or Doggy. It would be someone else that Willow would be mad at, perhaps Poley and Doggy rather then Player and Doggy. So Willow would still be mad at Doggy and now perhaps Poley.
0:55 “Doggy’s infection at the start of piggy book *2* chapter 4,” *Oh, I thought he was infected at the forest, not the safe house! THANKS FOR CLEARING THAT UP DEVOUN.*
Here`s a Better way for What if Doggy was never Infected: In Book 1 Chapter 11 Ending Geroige and Doggy well go the Player and in Book 2 Chapter 2 Ending Willow only just Take Zizzy
WHAT IF: The player was arrested and jailed before Book 2 Ch 1? The player might be in the same prison as Willow and Rash get sent to and they may be allies, as Doggy would be an enemy as the infection starts.
Things i want What if bunny or zizzy didint get infected What if we never met tsp What if mr p didint abandon us in hospital What if tigry didint take willows boat
![KSI - Dirty [Official Visualiser]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/VoDh1h1dPUE/mqdefault.jpg)
Now this is a series I'm gonna have fun watching!
omg real minitoon
Yeah, it will be fun!
oh wow uhh hi minitoon
Wow! Hi MiniToon!
Hi MiniToon!
"And what if,Mr. P. wasn't such a simp for his wife?"
Then Doggy would still be here.
He said piggy book 2 chapter 4 its book 1 forest lol
0:55
aaaaaaaaaAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAaAaAaAaAaAaAAAaAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAWDFASDAWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADADAD
No he wouldn't
@@FearmTheBlueHairGuy r/hadastroke?
What if mr.p wasnt such a simp for his wife
me: WAIT WHAT- WHAT HAVE I MISSED FROM THIS 2-4 MONTHS?
A lot
the thing preserving my sanity
Mr.Simp
Oh you missed a lot
I mean that was a year ago
What if the player was never there? Then we would never see Piggy LOL
HAHA OKAY THATS BIG BRAIN
HUUGE BRAIN RIGHT THERE
@@Devoun What if Zizzy and Pony didn't exist
XD
@@annasigera9158 Then there would be no zizzy x pony ships
"doggy's infection at the start of piggy book 2 chapter 4"
hes a little confused, but hes got the spirit
As soon as I heard that I rushed to the comments lol
@@AdilLovesTowers same
Same
@@cokebo1481 sME
same
I think "What if Zizzy and Pony never went to carnival?" Would be interesting
Then the player would probably be dead. Because foxy might killed the player with a suprise
Foxy would have killed you/the player in the cutscene
Yeah he might of but Zizzy and Pony were the only reasons why you stood still long enough for Foxy to sneak up in the first place, Foxy would probably just end up following you
Totally
What if Mr. P was at the carnival!
Captain Budgey in all of these: *why are we still here? Just to Suffer?*
lol
@@buckositarious9582 what if the player and willow swapped places?
@@Flumby_the_creator_YT interesting
@@Flumby_the_creator_YTyou would be willow and willow would be you
“What if the player never existed”
How would we know? We are the player
True lol
lol thats what I was thinking. We aren't even there to even know who bunny or doggy even were
Ye anything would happen
Piggy wouldn’t be popular
LMAO BAHAHA
"What if Mr. P wasn't a simp for his wife?"
*The world would be a paradise*
what if mr.p accepted the wife’s death or wtv,
**We would be stuck on chapter 1**
@@angangep no chapter 1 wouldent even exist because George wouldn’t have gone missing since mr p would just acept the death and not try to make an antidote
@@hyperionwarrior8398 I think he means like the game would have never happened so none of the chapters would have happened
*The world is hell and always will be - simping potato or not*
It probably won’t be a paradise, some investigation conducted by the good folks over on Discord has shown that there was possibly a war going on regarding oil prices with Europe and the Middle East attacking each other before Ms.P even got sick, I will let ya guys do some investigations regarding the topic but think we managed to piece up some things leading to this theory, won’t say what lead us to it tho, will let y’all find out for yourselves.
"What if Georgie were a voluntary too and get infected with his family?"
I mean the story would prob go the same way.
Actually, Zizzy and Pony would have came with us inside the Plant since Georgie wouldn't have gathered the soldiers. And maybe Mr. P would still be alive since Zizzy and Pony would be much helpful
I don’t know much about that, but we wouldn’t go to the house cos Georgie wouldn’t be missing.
@@MrGamerDoesVids so us and George (even Doggy and Bunny) won't survive or wouldn't be in the story
@@metaiicc yea.
@@MrGamerDoesVids Instead we just skip to some chapters and just.. the story still continues
I LOVE "WHAT IF'S"! YOU SHOULD MAKE THIS A SERIES DEVOUN!
It is.
Agreed
Wait i've seen you before remember that cat guy and you 2 were fighting of which is better among us or fall guys.
@@curtistakai1814, It is already.
Actually, Doggy said “I hope you’re right about her being here.” So without us Willow wouldn’t have ever gotten arrested and formed TSP. Well she still might’ve formed it but in the flashback she seemed nicer so maybe since she wouldn’t have anyone in her way she could dedicate TSP to finder her brother. In that case Pony would’ve stayed in TSP
This was exactly what I thought mate
o m g so smart
its not forever it's just when the infection start
"What if pony went crazy with the insolence earlier in the story?"
what if penny and gurt was a secret skin in all the chapters in piggy and piggy book 2
When that happens,PIGGY LOST BOOK
That’s a good one
@@shamsuzzaman6236 it wouldn't do anything because the skins wouldn't be canon.
@@furret1855 Maybe Do Something With Carnival And House Bc Gurty Is Piggy And A Joke Bc Carnivals Prob Has Jokes And There Is A Head Of Gurty In Foxys Cage And Body At The Houses Lasers And Arm On A Clown Ball And The Other Arm Is Being Held By Piggy On Her Back And That One Is Tricky You Have To Shoot Piggy And Take The Arm And It Has To Be Bot And The Leg Is On The Roller Coaster And ZombPiggy Has The Last Leg In His Hand And Same Story As Piggy You Have To Shoot Em And Grab It (Has To Be The Tombstone Trap On Carnival)
Wow amazing theories!
Question: What's that background music for this video?
IM EARLY
Wow same
Hi
@@nightshade-alt hello
It’s called scary caca land
“What of Doggy was never infected” me: finally, I’m not the only one keeping Doggy alive anymore....
People who keep doggy alive: AM I JOKE TO YOU
@@cocoflute4781 lol
if doggy was never infected
*that axe he carries is gonna be filled with blood*
Oh, I guess I'm the only one keeping tigry alive
@@SparklingLapis tigry is already alive
WHAT IF:Mr.stitchy was an imaginary monster that player had created to suppress their trauma about doggy becoming infected,btw I came up with this when Mr.stitchy was new character with less information about
I LOVE YOUR VIDEOS AND PLS MAKE THIS A SERIES
I actually think this is a pretty creative series and I'd like to see more of the series :)
Yeah me too
I’ve got a good one of these:
“What if Tigry threw the sword but didn’t steal the boat”
Or
“If the player saw Willow first in the infection”
If tigry threw the sword but didnt steal the boat someone would just commit ded And we would have not met captain budgey , we would have gotten different chapters 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 and 12 possibly adding a different ending , we don't know anything about chapter 9 , 10 , 11 and 12 meaning: NOBODY KnOWS WHAT COULD BE NEXT .
If we met Willow first in the infection ... I think we would be having to work together , willow would act similarly as in the second part of book 2 , we rather wouldn't meet mr.P and maybe tsp would never be a thing as player and willow would be deciding where they will go together , simply : the story would be very different .
I like your theoretical words magic man
@@joshonamous285 this ain't piggy meme review
I gosh dang wish it was
AAA I really want a player and willow dynamic one, or if player never arrested willow
Suggestion:
What if: George never went missing?
What if: The Piggy Family was never infected, but Mr. P was?
What if: Willow's parents were not arrested, William didn't go missing, we didn't arrest Willow, Daisy was with Willow and William and Willow and her family were not criminals? (Shorter version: What if Willow was not mad?)
What if: We were in T.S.P.?
Edit: *OH MAN JUST LIKE 3 MINUTES AND ALREADY 9 LIKES!?*
YES
dude I didn’t know you watch Devon to!!!!!!!
@@tspcpr Xd
the last one tho...
@@PuppyDoggieGirl yeah the last one is my favorite.
Doggy is and always will be my favorite character Mr. P is a close second so, thank you, for doing this. I also kinda forgot that the player was a police officer along with Doggy in the story so they aren't really removable since they would be always be one of the first on the scene
Devoun, you will always have the scoop to keep us in the loop
Roblox drama 🎭
Exactly
Let's get right to the drama!
@@Blu_Macrowave *intro plays*
Aggressively plays recorder
i got some ''what if'' questions
what if the player died at the plant?
what if mr.p came along with the group?
what if pony stayed and did not leave T.S.P
that was it i hope you consider doing more of these whatif video's have
a good day!
I Love this idea. I'll try to make my own alt history's out of those ideas.
Alt history 1:
Doggy doesn't drink the potion. The player probably doesn't leave the forest sense doggy can handle infected with his axe. Eventually, they run out of supplies and are forced to leave about 2½ months after arriving. Aside from the player and Doggy, Bunny is infected with no one to save her. Mr. P gets mad with guilt probably later. Depends on how long Bunny survives. Pony, Zizzy, Mimi, and Girrafey meet Georgie later, but they still go to the outpost. They face Mr. P themselves. They are probably killed by Mr. P because they think he is just a survivor that went mad. Girrafey, Mimi, and Zizzy's sisters probably won't survive longer, because they will go out looking for Zizzy and Pony. Sense Tigery took her boat, Willow kills him because she doesn't realize she is bad. Back to Doggy and the player, they go to the city. They find refuge in the abandoned Safe Place. They get batteries and hear about a cure. They hear the military is working on a cure, with a group called "The Silver Paw" up north where infected can not survive. Scavenging let's the player and Doggy survive while the build a bout to ho up north. 15 months after this started, they set sail. They use a river, which had to have been nearby or else they wouldn't have been able to survive in the forest in the actual game, to get to the ocean. They sail across the North sea. Willow is Furios that we survived. Doggy and the player attempt to make Willow less mad, but it's in vain. It fuels her madness and infront of the military, she shoots Doggy. With the military's medical stuff he survives and the military arrests willow.
If the player never existed then doggy and the other police officers wouldn’t even be able to arrest willow because they only found willow because of the player’s detective skills
MiniToon should make this an actual separate game for alternate endings
Piggy: Branched Realities is a great game
14:16
No way.
You used my video in the background.
Awesome.
“What if Mr. P wasn’t crazy”
Then there would be no story...
true
And that would suck
There would T.S.P and the infected
@@TheSecretMan1898 w d y m
@@kiaansureshkumar5116 Only tsp would exist none of the infected since tsp isn't infected and willow would still be a criminal
If player never existed, doggy wouldn’t have captured willow, because we were the one that told doggy where willow was
What if Georgie Died to his family in the House?
What if Pony was still part of The Silver Paw?
For the first one. Nothing would change. Mall would just be cut. We would just put a pin in the case, classify him as dead and then move on. Georgie makes no impact on the story at all
@@Tandwar that’s true
@@CollidedUniverses its a shame that such a good character went to waste but oh well
@@Tandwar that’s true
@@Tandwar I think Georgie does kinda have an impact so since we first start our journey to find him back at house.
"What if none of our friends got infected?"
Minitoon: ha ha *N O*
Suggestion: What if Mr. P got infected instead of the piggy family?
Edit: Many people are contradicting this idea and saying it doesn’t make sense so I might delete this comment son
amazing idea
Boss Fight!
Yeah Pretty Good Idea But Mr.P Was The One Giving Potions In The First Place And probably it would be easier to find the cure Like Take down a Potato look Very easy and I Don't know if That Stick arm Can Scratch anyone But...Pretty cool Idea 👍
Doggy not infected bunny not infected most of book 1 would not happen some of book 2 would not happen
Chapter 1 wouldn't happen because Georgie got missing because he was scared of his parents but in this timeline Mr. P is infected instead of his parents
I think we might’ve still met Zizzy and Pony in the “Mr. P not being crazy” run, because there’s something you forgot; we still have to find Georgie. After searching all over Lucella, we’d most likely have one of these outcomes come up.
- The Mall was right next to the Safe Place, so after finding Georgie, we’d exit the Mall and see a sign for a “safe place” and although it might be a trap, we go and see if there’s any survivors.
- On the way to the Mall, we walk past the Safe Place and happen to spot survivors outside, such as Mimi or others.
- When we’re in the Mall, we bump into one of the Safe Place members and partner together.
All of these outcomes would pretty much include Mimi, Giraffy, Zizzy, Zee, Zuzy and Pony coming with us back to the Plant. This is just speculation though so idk :)
The real meaning of S.I.M.P
S stands for : so
I stands for : in love for
M stands for : mrs
P stands for : potato
Hahaha! I love it!
Dude this is amazing lmfao
Right
Your a genius
MR P IS A BIG S I M P
Honestly, I think the Mr. P situation and him being crazy is due to his wife getting more and more fatigued and progressively sick. I can understand why he picked the risk of using an unstable substance for his cure. Its more of a "If it can work, I'll definitely do it" situation (but in reality you may just want to pick the safer option). I also think I know why Mr. P goes crazy in chapter 7-11. First of all, Mrs. P gets infected, and you probably would go crazy if that happened aswell. Second of all, Bunny gets infected aswell, his best friend. Third of all, he thinks the Player gets infected aswell., cuz he saw signs of infection in the Player. This makes him spiral out of control.
I also think I know how the doggy story would go. I agree with everything you said would happen until chapter 6. At the end of chapter 6, and doggy happens to die someway somehow at the end, the player would be extremely enraged, due to the fact that they've already lost zizzy, pony, and now doggy. The Player may not want to help Willow whatsoever at this state, but Willow probably wouldn't care that much because "we're even now (because willow lost 3 members of his family, the player lost 3 of their friends)" The player and willow go of to their seperate ways, while willow (maybe by himself, because you saved all the tsp members, or maybe with only some of the tsp members, because I think Tigry and Kitty may go off with The Safe Place members.) goes back to the factory, and the player and their group goes back to the safe place, maybe to repair it somewhat. The player may put revenge over everything else in their mental state. Every way you think about it, the piggy story if doggy was alive (aside from the cure) all ends at chapter 6, book 6
I need to see “What if player ate a sandwich?”
He would become super power full imagine just imagine if you had super powers and a infected was chasing you so you can grab something to make you have your super power charge and then you can use it to kill the infected but they wake up
He would turn into sandwich sans
😀😀😀😀😀😂😂😂😂😂
@@cecilleracel9589 he would knock out piggy for 20 seconds
If Mr.p wasn't the only one to go crazy then who would also go crazy?
I like this guy LOL
"What if the chapters swapped locations?"
"What if there was no friendly NPCs?"
Then we will be infected
@@chazzywaz except Factory, you need to give 3 swords to pony to knock out Willow to escape.
Suggestion: What if instead of the player it was Sonic, Mario, and Baldy.
Oh that's actually pretty interesti- HEY WAIT
I see what you did there
Oh I get it lol
"She was looking for William or something."
*FNaF flashbacks intensifies*
WE'RE WAITING EVERY NIGHT TO FINALLY ROAM AND INVITE
@@desmeonNEWCOMERS TO PLAY WITH US FOR MANY YEARS WE'VE BEEN ALL ALONE...
@@Goose-wj9wx I posted this comment 3 years ago. Why did you have to remind me of my old self
@@desmeon lol i didnt even realise💀
"what if the player never existed"
me: woah, that sounds deep
then there would be no game
Remember Doge And Bunnnnnnnnnni Zizzzzzzz and PONYyyyy
noo-
All people who played piggy dissappear
We would play as Georgie?
I want to see more of this, I have an idea. What if, we never met the TSP
Then Zizzy wouldn't be infected #Miss Zizzy
Devoun: I’m the only one keeping Mr. P alive Me: I’m the only one keeping Doggy alive
Am I a joke to you
No
Ho ho im keeping him alive to!
Also I kill ships uwu
Heres my timeline if the player didnt exist:
Chapter 1 wouldn't exist, since Doggy is on his vacation. Instead lets make Doggy sort of our protagonist. Doggy is in Chapter 2 and decides to look for the fuel himself and goes to gallery for a safe place. It goes on pretty much the same until forest, Doggy doesn't get Infected and encounters Sheepy instead. He gets out and hears Mr. P
This is where it goes a bit different, I'd say Doggy is pretty rational and smart so maybe Doggy decides he doesn't go to the school. You may ask, why? Well bunny could've been a trap. In a zombie apocalypse scenario, supplies are very important, Bunny could've been a trap to beat us up and get our supplies (if we had any). So there's a chance Doggy doesn't go and decides to look for a safe place,. maybe meeting the safe place or T.S.P.
But for the sake of our timeline lets say Doggy goes to the school and rescues Bunny, there's another possible scenario that Doggy doesn't pass out. So then Mr. P, Bunny and Doggy decide to go to the Plant and the story goes on from there.
Let's say Doggy does pass out and Mr. P leaves us, we go to the Metro and leave bunny. I think Metro would've been the last Chapter since Chapter 8 only existed for revenge, so Doggy would've left behind Bunny and went to look for a safe place. Maybe he'll meet Giraffy and Mimi, not Zizzy and Pony since they're in the Carnival for supplies. Maybe he'll meet T.S.P or maybe even George in mall or other places.
If Doggy did infact go to the carnival, then the story would've been the same for Book 1
Devon:
“Doggy was with us for 2 chapters”
Me:
“Pony was with us for 12 chapters”
But doggy was the first good guy he deserves more respect than a dumb horse.
Pony has been with us for so long, I can’t imagine how sad the piggy community will be if Pony dies.
Oh and Mr_toxic you mean 11 chapters and doggy for 3 chapters so yeah i prefer doggy over pony
@@BlueBagelEnthusiast same, Pony is just so overrated. Team Doggy!
Me
"We, player participated book 1 to book 2"
1.what if,goerge didnt distracked us in the safe place?
2.what if the good ending was the true ending?
3.what if T.S.P capture pony instead?
Doggy getting loved? I haven’t heard that in years..
? But piggy has been around for 1 year and a half.
I know that.
Devoun: doggy died in book 2chapter 4
Me: man has it really been so long since you have played book one?
The infection would have stopped if doggy was alive
The absolute chadnest of Doggy would make everyone cured
What if pony stayed in TSP?
Piggy: haha, pig looking zombie with bat lol
Piggy Lore:
This is a great series also I have some ideas for the series, like what if we never met willow? and what if bunny never existed?
For the "Player never existed" ( 11:10 ) we still don't know what pony did. Maybe him leaving was such a atrocity that willow would still infect zizzy just to make pony feel pain.
He could've abandoned crewmates to die to the infected or caused Arson.
But who knows?
I'm here 10 months later knowing what he actually did
I have a suggestion for Devoun for this cool series.
WHAT IF the metro train didnt take us to the carnival.
WHAT IF we didnt faint in the school
WHAT IF we didnt arrest willow
What If #1: We would’ve never met Zizzy and Pony, and the rest of The Safe Place. We would’ve never found Georgie. We probably would’ve never found Mr. P. Even if we did, we wouldn’t succeed in discovering the truth.
What if #2: Bunny would’ve never been infected. Mr. P’s research team wouldn’t have gotten infected. We would’ve never met Zizzy and Pony, same thing with Georgie. It’s pretty similar to “What if Mr. P wasn’t crazy?”
What If #3: Doggy and the player would’ve been fired from their jobs, Willow wouldn’t have been angry at us. So, House, Station and Gallery wouldn’t have happened.
Devoun: What if the player never existed
Minitoon: Lemme help u with that
*Deletes Piggy*
There u go :)
I have no idea what to say so this is the sentence
Is this supposed to be funny?
Random idea: what if the insolence caused the infection instead of mr p
What if you watched a KreekCraft video and then said this?Crazy,right?
why is everyone saying stuff that Kreek say lol,make an original theory plz
I never seen a piggy what if! Great Video Devoun.
Me neither! There's some really interesting scenarios!
@@Devoun hi DEVOUN MANGO 🏆👑
oh yeah i remember doggy in book 2 chapter 4 when tsp takes him in
This series is a change from normal stuff (meme review) and is creative. You can think of new ways piggy could of happened and can clear up some story as well as changing it. 5/5 series and would love to see more! 👀
Devoun: Add Doggy into the mix an you will get one rager than an Arsenal Player
Me: Oh No! *Remember’s the Soccer Club Arsenal*
What if the Player got taken away by tsp instead of Zizzy?
What if Bunny never got infected?
What if Rash came back?
Awesome job Devoun. Keep this series up please i'm sure it will be enjoyable for everyone
What if Pony didn't change his diaper
Heres some ideas for a what if video
What if william didn't leave willow?
What if Tsp never existed?
What if mr p didn't existed?
Here's a timeline question: Wut if Mr p was simping for bunny
yes devoun needs to make that what if lol
1.What if the piggy family never volunteer?
2.What if mr.p never exist?
3.what if T.S.P never exist
What if: the player got infected instead of doggy.
THAT'S WHAT I WAS THINKING! :O
probably same as chapter 5 and the rest but doggy would still be with us
What if the uncannon ending in Factory, was cannon?
Factory:
You and Pony leave the factory without saving any member of T.S.P, and just use the three swords on Willow. Once escaping, there's no member to convince Willow to stop, and just takes aim on the player, before seeing Zee and Zuzy show up. Once the twins arrive, Willow starts to receive a lot of guilt, for not caring about her own people, taking away the twins from their sister, and shooting Giraffy and the Player. Everyone else doesn't trust Willow so quickly now, but still needs her to go north.
Port:
There's no player to get the lighthouse working, so Willow goes herself. She gets the lighthouse to work. Getting on Budgey's ship, "she needs more fuel" to get the ship running again. Since the player isn't there to go down with Willow, she goes down there by herself once again.
Ship:
Willow goes down, being outnumbered by all the crewmates. (In a less harsh ending, lets say she makes it down the fuel area). Without Player being able to warn Willow about Kenneth being right behind her, she gets scratched and gets turned into one of them. Pony, Georgie, Zee, and Zuzy go down, to see Willow with a sad look. She tells them, how she has been scratched and needs to leave. They all leave Willow behind, and they're already at Doveport. Without the fuel.
The story continues on without the Player, and Willow.
Wait if the player newer existed pony would have never left tsp
Suggestion: what if we never met pony & what if willow never started t.s.p?
Idea: What if willow and the TSP never existed..?
What if willow and the tsp never existed
It would be said like
What if willow and the the silver paw never existed
@@snow799 works but I made it shorter
Well, the first half of Book 2 would never happen, and we would have never met Pony. Captain Budgey would starve to death. Other stuff.
@@adreamofspring_wastaken yea
Video Ideas: What if the safe place wasn't a thing?
What if the player got infected?
What if T.S.P didn't exist?
*What if the player was in the military and not the police?*
What if Mimi found the "Don't... Doveport" radio message instead of the Silver Paw message?
0:54 Ah yes, book 2 chapter 4 was definitely the chapter and book that Doggy got infected in.
Ah yes, we’ll just forget book 1
If we, the player just never existed everyone would just be screwed because we do all the work and escaping.
“What if the player never existed”
The game wouldn’t exist
Dang... never thought of it that way
Ok, but the story would still exist sort of...
@@EliTheGingerCat the story would but the game No
If the player was still sleeping
A new other player (that is not us) will try joining
and it will probably change the story a bit
devoun actually knew what happens in the distraction chapter
What if CuteJemma96 and LittleTimmy123 never vent camped
then society will be perfect
What if the infection never happened but we still met TSP?
I missed that *theory* music.
Same
It's been months, same
0:56
"Doggy got infected in a Safe Place"
~Devoun, 2021
"What if zizzy and pony got married lol?"
What if the Player is the leader of T.S.P?
What if we never find the cure?
What if Mr.P was lying?
Here’s an idea for one. What if: the player got infected in the hospital?
I mean some say the player did.
Mr.P said that we found some of the infected inside you but the player wasn’t infected
Well, the player got infected by Penny in House since he was hit in the head by her.
Bunny would’ve never gotten infected, Mr. P’s research team would’ve never gotten infected, we would’ve never met Zizzy, Pony, the rest of the Safe Place and Georgie. Pretty similar to “What If Mr. P Was Never Crazy?”
@@adreamofspring_wastaken same with if the player never existed
what if he was forced to make the potion infected? what if the Inscolence made Mrs p sick and said they would cure her if he makes this potion? what if he just didnt have a choice? this explains the voices in his head part
What If: Willow Died
What If: Willow’s parents were never taken away
What If: Zizzy never existed
@@milibao if you think about it, Willow has a bigger impact on the story then us, we would be dead if it wasn’t for Willow in the ship. And her parents being taken away, her parents would still get infected from going outside and getting recourses.
@@milibao and willam (willow brother) (i think that his name)
If willow didn't exist Doggy zizzy would not be infected
1. Nobody would know of the cure.
2. TSP would never exist.
3. Pony’s parents, and foxy wouldn’t be infected.
4. Zee and Zuzy could possibly be infected
@@allgamesrespecter4880 Willow and Zizzy are basically the main characters, but more Willow xD
1. What if Pony and Zizzy never met
2. What if the piggy family never got infected
3. What if Willows family never got arrested
4. What if the T.S.P never existed
5. What if Mr.Stichy never existed
6. What if The safe place never existed
7. What if Bunny never got infected
8. What if Doggy and Bunny met each other in stead of Zizzy and Pony meeting each other
9. What if Rash never met Williow
10. What if Piggy and Pokémon made a map together (Ok maybe this might not happen)⬆️
More ideas soon...maybe
Please do these ideas Devoun
.
Your first
A
.
.
.
Devoun be looking like matpat now
If the player didn’t exist, Willow’s parents wouldn’t be taken away. That would lead to a lot, Willow and William would still be with their parents (obviously), Daisy would have no reason to go there, and William wouldn’t leave. They could’ve still be taken away later on for stealing supplies and things, but it wouldn’t be the player or Doggy. It would be someone else that Willow would be mad at, perhaps Poley and Doggy rather then Player and Doggy. So Willow would still be mad at Doggy and now perhaps Poley.
What if the Player was part of The Insolence??
What if Mr.P hadn't been the one to make the cure, but The Insolence was?
0:55 “Doggy’s infection at the start of piggy book *2* chapter 4,”
*Oh, I thought he was infected at the forest, not the safe house! THANKS FOR CLEARING THAT UP DEVOUN.*
i feel like if the player didn't exist, doggy would be the new player.
What if devoun had a star code.
Y E S
Here`s a Better way for What if Doggy was never Infected: In Book 1 Chapter 11 Ending Geroige and Doggy well go the Player and in Book 2 Chapter 2 Ending Willow only just Take Zizzy
WHAT IF: The player was arrested and jailed before Book 2 Ch 1? The player might be in the same prison as Willow and Rash get sent to and they may be allies, as Doggy would be an enemy as the infection starts.
Erm actually doggy didn’t drink the potion pony before he left. The TSP was forced by Willow to make doggy drink it ☝️🤓1:57
Things i want
What if bunny or zizzy didint get infected
What if we never met tsp
What if mr p didint abandon us in hospital
What if tigry didint take willows boat
Zizzy stans when they realize that they were the reason zizzy got infected : Umm I...I can expla...explaain
If the player never existed, piggy wouldn't even exist.
Fr
Idea for this series: What if Zizzy was never caught by T.S.P?