Umpire is correct with Jeremy Cameron one. He must start on his line because Cameron’s line is outside the field of play. If he was inside field of play then he can just simply get to his line and then go wherever but since he is outside boundary line he can’t go past his line until he get on his line.
20.3.2 Moving in One Direction (a) A Player who is awarded a Mark or Free Kick may bring the football back into play from outside the Playing Surface beyond the Boundary Line provided that the Player starts on his line of The Mark in the process of re-entering the Playing Surface. (b) If a Player breaches Law 20.3.2(a), the football shall be deemed Out of Bounds and a boundary throw-in shall result.
@@asheronwindspear552 still wasn’t up right and Joel Selwood lifts his arm up to make the opponents arm go high it’s a different technique, still not in the Spirit of the game though
@@asheronwindspear552 you need to watch it carefully it gets done in my league as well when an opponent grabs you you lift your arm up and it makes there are go high
@@francydancy24 umpire is right coz Jeremy Cameron is starting outside the field of play. If he was starting inside the field of play then he can start off his line but that would be play on. Since he is starting outside field of play he must start on his line because u can’t play on if ur outside boundary line
Well, probably because they have new players who strengthen their team... And maybe some free kicks that are erm lol 😭 Anyways, they are pretty good compared to their last year game.
Shouldn’t the first one have been a free kick / deliberate, to Brisbane? Although it was a mistake by Sam, surely that would have been free kick to Brisbane? But then again, I guess it is kind of like the “lack of common sense” with the Tigers vs Swans game and the non-50 Warner nearly gave away.
They should video all AFL games and put all the games in this video. All AFL games you have no idea what’s going on with all the new stupid rules they have.
The only time the ump was wrong was with the holding the ball one. Jeremy Cameron MUST start on his line coz his line is outside field of play and Rioli ducked into his tackle. Holding the ball he must’ve thought he handballed it or something coz that was pretty regulation
@@sarcasticdragon8673 theres a pretty general consensus that umpires have been known to perform pretty poorly over the past few years. All I said was this video further solidifies my opinion. Thats all! Thanks!
Umpire is correct with Jeremy Cameron one. He must start on his line because Cameron’s line is outside the field of play. If he was inside field of play then he can just simply get to his line and then go wherever but since he is outside boundary line he can’t go past his line until he get on his line.
I think the commentator is correct on this one mate
@@lwb0920 In fact the umpire is correct
@@qtrmagicshot6919 Who would you rather trust a random person on the internet or a commentator who knows the game
@@lwb0920 You should go to to the law book
20.3.2 Moving in One Direction
(a) A Player who is awarded a Mark or Free Kick may bring the football back into play
from outside the Playing Surface beyond the Boundary Line provided that the
Player starts on his line of The Mark in the process of re-entering
the Playing Surface.
(b) If a Player breaches Law 20.3.2(a), the football shall be deemed Out of Bounds
and a boundary throw-in shall result.
I recall many years ago (1999) when former AFL umpire Peter Carey marked the ball in play in a Freo vs St Kilda game. That was amusing & confusing!
That last one was a genuine good decision from the umpire we need to stamp that out of the game
Agreed wish the umpires called play on there more often
He stayed more upright than Joel Selwood though.
@@asheronwindspear552 still wasn’t up right and Joel Selwood lifts his arm up to make the opponents arm go high it’s a different technique, still not in the Spirit of the game though
@@wheelson7895 I literally quack out loud every time Selwood gets the ball.
@@asheronwindspear552 you need to watch it carefully it gets done in my league as well when an opponent grabs you you lift your arm up and it makes there are go high
Bloody good Aussie content, keep it up!
Now that’s confusing
Umpire is right in the Cameron one
Umpire was right, you can only go off your line if siren has gone
No he's not
@@twd_9983 Thats ligit the opposite of the rules
@@francydancy24 couldn’t agree more!!!!
@@francydancy24 umpire is right coz Jeremy Cameron is starting outside the field of play. If he was starting inside the field of play then he can start off his line but that would be play on. Since he is starting outside field of play he must start on his line because u can’t play on if ur outside boundary line
Love the videos keep it up! ❤️
Your a great content maker. Keep it up
Love the idea! Keep it up! Love these vids!
Great video
What about that God-awful Anzac day where the umps just called play on... that game was insanely dumb.
The last one was fair, but definitely confusing
Keep up the good work
You left out the most confusing moment, Carlton being 3-0
Well, probably because they have new players who strengthen their team... And maybe some free kicks that are erm lol 😭
Anyways, they are pretty good compared to their last year game.
Not confusing anymore
oi third!
Fucking love this channel
Second
Shouldn’t the first one have been a free kick / deliberate, to Brisbane? Although it was a mistake by Sam, surely that would have been free kick to Brisbane? But then again, I guess it is kind of like the “lack of common sense” with the Tigers vs Swans game and the non-50 Warner nearly gave away.
They should video all AFL games and put all the games in this video. All AFL games you have no idea what’s going on with all the new stupid rules they have.
You should have a gaming channel
yaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
FIRST
Surely esava shitgolia punching a goal back into play has to be up there
haha stopped his own team from scoring. That was possibly one of the dumbest things ive seen a player do hahaha
hi
I don’t get it, the whole sport is confusing😂
You get eventually
The only thing this video proves more than ever is how shit the umps are
The only time the ump was wrong was with the holding the ball one. Jeremy Cameron MUST start on his line coz his line is outside field of play and Rioli ducked into his tackle. Holding the ball he must’ve thought he handballed it or something coz that was pretty regulation
@@archiesinfield9333 i mean if you want to look into it that much then sure thing! But i still think they're shit its pretty obvious haha
@@pinkmonkey444 "if you want to look into it that much" you called them shit and he showed you that the umps weren't
@@sarcasticdragon8673 theres a pretty general consensus that umpires have been known to perform pretty poorly over the past few years. All I said was this video further solidifies my opinion. Thats all! Thanks!
First