Vietnam's Catholic Regime
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 2 окт 2024
- Miller, Edward. “Religious Revival and the Politics of Nation Building: Reinterpreting the 1963 ‘Buddhist Crisis’ in South Vietnam.” Modern Asian Studies, vol. 49, no. 6, 2015, pp. 1903-62:
www.jstor.org/...
Miller, Edward. “Vision, Power and Agency: The Ascent of Ngô Ðl̀nh Diệm, 1945-54.” Journal of Southeast Asian Studies, vol. 35, no. 3, 2004, pp. 433-58:
www.jstor.org/...
Nguyen, Phi Vân. “Fighting the First Indochina War Again? Catholic Refugees in South Vietnam, 1954-59.” Sojourn: Journal of Social Issues in Southeast Asia, vol. 31, no. 1, 2016, pp. 207-46:
www.jstor.org/...
If you enjoyed this video, please like and leave a comment. It helps the channel a lot. Many thanks.
45:05 "The attempts at demographic change in the name of unity only caused inter-ethnic strife".
Who could have guessed?
Diem certainly looks like an underappreciated historical figure.
¡Viva Cristo Rey!
Nixon the nominal Quaker would have been better for Catholicism in Vietnam than Kennedy.
Certainly! Kennedy beating Nixon in the election hurt Christendom, and helped communism.
Certainly! Kennedy beating Nixon in the 1960 election hurt Christendom, and helped communism.
Thank you for this Apostolic Majesty. If anyone's interested in Catholic Tradition as well as French history and warfare I warmly recommend Schwerpunkt's channel. The greatest dream would be a coop with AM
I don't typically watch history RUclipsrs, but I tried watching Schwerpunkt. Until he streamlines his content, and works on the concision of his individual videos - he's inaccessible to me.
I must say as a Vietnamese Catholic born in Canada, Ngo Dinh Diem is, among many things, a figure not unlike how Louis XVI is a major figure for French Catholic monarchists, who also is often given requiem masses every year on the anniversary of his death.
My family who was Buddhists admire President Ngo. I myself attribute my convertion to Catholicism to him too.
@quando1208 wow. I thought that most Viet Buddhists wouldn't have liked him
As much as I admire Diệm as a Catholic president of Vietnam, as a monarchist, I'm not so favourable to his ousting of Emperor Bao Dai in the referendum that established South Vietnam as a republic.
@@michaeljcdo335 The correct take.
@incompetent_3424 Diem was a real monarch. Bao Dai was stooge. It's something I didn't quite emphasise here, but Bao Dai had already surrendered his Imperial status when committing Vietnam to the French Union. Diem conceived of his own rise as a transfer of the mandate of heaven. Had this occurred in an earlier age, the Ngo Dinh may have simply supplanted the Nguyen as Vietnam's Emperors.
I know I keep saying this but AM just doesn't let up!
Second and only 7 minutes late, when did Vietnam have a Catholic regime? WoW am I ignorant. Lovely work as always.
Love the Catholic Vietnamese. There’s a lot of them in the State of Oklahoma. I grew up with Vietnamese neighbors next door and carpooled with them. We still keep in touch today. I’ve been writing a post-apocalypse novel set in the American southwest, and at one point the main characters enter an isolated Vietnamese Catholic settlement.
By comparison, there are also a lot of Burmese in Oklahoma, who came to the country by different circumstances, and much more recently than the Vietnamese. Both are Southeast Asians, but the Burmese are generally much less pleasant to deal with, and are less industrious. I like Vietnam, and may Americans and the Vietnamese always remain friends!
In Houston and Austin, there is a very strong South Vietnamese Catholic presence from people who migrated here during that era. My former priest is a South Vietnamese Catholic himself, and he told me about how his family escaped to America as Vietnam fell under communist rule. It's such a vibrant and unique cultural identity that often gets overlooked, and that makes it a treasure.
Something I learned a little about a few months ago, but this is orders of magnitude more detailed.
Great podcast again. Well, it is often overlooked, due to cold war propanda of course, that almost all east Asian communist movements actually were as much as nationalist as they were communist. They didnt have to study nationalism which was the same thing as anti-colonialism but some of the leading figures studied communism in Paris at French universities, like Ho.
@lowersaxon From Ho's point of view he only took up communism because it's anti Europeanism was convenient for his Vietnamese nationalism
This is going to be great.
Very fascinating. Keep up the great work. 👍
As a Buddhist practitioner with Vietnamese children of expat friends who are Catholic, it was quite surprising to me when I talked to them about this particular period in their motherlands history, and they were totally ignorant of the subject. Quite the overshadowed piece of important history.
What was the name of the version of the march of the valkyries you were using before?
Vietnam catholic who fled to Soviet union, Russia were sent to Kazan. The families descendants we see in catholic church services here
It sounds like you are a bit far back from your microphone. Even with my volume up to the last I struggle to hear everything. I like to listen while driving and its a pity to have given up on this episode. I don’t know if I was the only one experiencing it but it was disappointing. Thank you for the videos they are great.
Upwards of million South Vietnamese died mostly by indiscriminate SVN artillery ("A Bright Shining Lie", Sheehan, others). How much did sectarianism play a role in that military strategy?
Trad Catholic Third Positionism?
Fascinating, thank you for this.
From my view Diem had much in common with other great Statesman such as Franco, Patin, Musillini, Salazar , and Adolfus, ....anti Communistic militants and Nationalistic Catholics. They all represented a "third way" with an eventual return to Monarchy but knew Facsicm under an Integralist society was the only segway to the re-establishment of a King.
Indeed. Even Ho Chi Minh, Diem’s enemy, respected him. While Diem was right to view the communists as enemies, ultimately, it was the CIA that did him in, which he was not expecting.
I'd heard the quote of Kissinger many times - sometimes the "Fatal" is reworked as "Deadly." Now I realize it's specifically about a one time best pal of the American Empire.
Another hole in my knowledge filled, thank you
Hugely helpful, and very informative. I hear so much slander about him, but it seems he was great
Very good, a gem of a channel
Hello AM, another fantastic video
Thank you
If you want to do a video on Bishop Thuc and Sedevacantism then a RUclipsr named Serp Kerp is a good guest. He has videos on Sedevacantism where he mentions that Thuc was distraught at the time due to his old age, exile, and death of his family.