The biggest reason why Magic Railroad is my favorite Thomas movie, is that the classic feel of Thomas is present here. Lost Treasure might be the better movie, but nothing can beat anything from the Classic Series for me, if that makes sense.
I agree 1000%! Thomas and the Magic Railroad is indeed the BEST movie of the franchise! A lot of people say that Sodor's Legend of the Lost Treasure (Or sometimes The Great Discovery, Blue Mountain Mystery and The Adventure Begins) is the best movie, however I disgree with them. Not only do I think that SLOTLT is overrated, but it seriously needs a lot of fixing (Mainly the Fat Controller). I respect your opinion on The Great Discovery (I love it and consider it the perfect series finale to the Model-Era) and, in fact, I think that it's better than SLOTLT. I respect your opinion on The Adventure Begins too (Though, for my headcanon, I like to mix the RWS, Model and TAB together) and I think that Thomas' arrival in TAB is WAY better than the RWS. While Season 21 is my CGI Series (Because it has some dark moments) and The Great Race, The Adventure Begins and King of the Railway are my favourite CGI Movies, I agree that the CGI Series, as a whole, doesn't have as much charm or magic as the models. In my opinion, the ENTIRE Model-Era (Classic-Era, TATMR, Jack and the Pack and the HiT-Era) triumphs over the CGI. Diesel 10, hands down, is the BEST villian ever!
Adventure Begins is my personal favorite although I do have a massive soft spot for Magic Railroad. I get it’s massive flaws and plot holes but I do like the movie quite a bit. Not the best Thomas movie to me but I enjoy it still and it’s not the worst
Excellent defense, dude! 👍 Personally, while I understand why some people dislike the film, but I think it’s over-hated; and besides, I mostly blame the test audience for the movie’s failure, not Britt Allcroft. In other words, I still like Thomas and the Magic Railroad despite its flaws.
diesel 10 is a extraordinary model
The biggest reason why Magic Railroad is my favorite Thomas movie, is that the classic feel of Thomas is present here. Lost Treasure might be the better movie, but nothing can beat anything from the Classic Series for me, if that makes sense.
Diesel 10 always makes me laugh in this movie
I agree 1000%! Thomas and the Magic Railroad is indeed the BEST movie of the franchise!
A lot of people say that Sodor's Legend of the Lost Treasure (Or sometimes The Great Discovery, Blue Mountain Mystery and The Adventure Begins) is the best movie, however I disgree with them. Not only do I think that SLOTLT is overrated, but it seriously needs a lot of fixing (Mainly the Fat Controller).
I respect your opinion on The Great Discovery (I love it and consider it the perfect series finale to the Model-Era) and, in fact, I think that it's better than SLOTLT.
I respect your opinion on The Adventure Begins too (Though, for my headcanon, I like to mix the RWS, Model and TAB together) and I think that Thomas' arrival in TAB is WAY better than the RWS.
While Season 21 is my CGI Series (Because it has some dark moments) and The Great Race, The Adventure Begins and King of the Railway are my favourite CGI Movies, I agree that the CGI Series, as a whole, doesn't have as much charm or magic as the models. In my opinion, the ENTIRE Model-Era (Classic-Era, TATMR, Jack and the Pack and the HiT-Era) triumphs over the CGI.
Diesel 10, hands down, is the BEST villian ever!
Adventure Begins is my personal favorite although I do have a massive soft spot for Magic Railroad. I get it’s massive flaws and plot holes but I do like the movie quite a bit. Not the best Thomas movie to me but I enjoy it still and it’s not the worst
Diesel 10 has always been a scary diesel.
Finally Someone else who dislikes Sodor’s Legend of the Lost Treasure, but i respect your opinion on The Great Discovery and The Adventure Begins
W opinion blue mountain and this are the best good job!
To be honest i don't have an opinion about this film i never watched maybe il give it a shot just because Diesel 10 is such an amazing villain
Excellent defense, dude! 👍 Personally, while I understand why some people dislike the film, but I think it’s over-hated; and besides, I mostly blame the test audience for the movie’s failure, not Britt Allcroft. In other words, I still like Thomas and the Magic Railroad despite its flaws.
Goonus the skipdi ohiongine