Rorke's Drift - The Anglo-Zulu War - Sabaton History 038 [Official]

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 3 дек 2024

Комментарии • 974

  • @SabatonHistory
    @SabatonHistory  5 лет назад +915

    One nations heroic history is anothers national tragedy. In academia, the horrors of imperialism get more and more attention each year. In this episode, besides covering the events that unfolded during the Battle of Rorke's Drift, we try to capture the ambiguous nature of colonial history. Yes, the Last Stand of the British soldiers against an overwhelming Zulu force is impressive, but wether or not it should be celebrated is open for debate. We would like to have this conversation in the comments down below, but keep it civil. *Any racist, apologist or revisionist comments can lead to a ban.*
    Cheers, The Sabaton History Team.
    If you would like to gain early access to our Sabaton History episodes and actively support this awesome project that we are so passionate about, you can do so by joining our Patreon community. There are some pretty cool perks when you become part of the Patreon family.
    Find out more and join here 👉 www.patreon.com/sabatonhistory

    • @mysticnovelbro
      @mysticnovelbro 5 лет назад +30

      Your only justification is,"But the Belgian Congo..."
      Indy, Indy, Indy.......

    • @xclonejager6959
      @xclonejager6959 5 лет назад +72

      While I do agree not all colonial history is great and colourful but it was definitely not black and white in this case with the Zulus,
      Remember the Zulus where highly aggressive themselves offen killing prisoners and caught in constant wars that did nothing but expand there own borders,
      At least Britain brought technology, medicine, law, infrastructure and civil liberties.
      Yes the British invaded but you cannot no matter what you think of British colonialism say it didn’t benefit the natives in the long term

    • @mysticnovelbro
      @mysticnovelbro 5 лет назад +4

      @@xclonejager6959 exactly

    • @USSChicago-pl2fq
      @USSChicago-pl2fq 5 лет назад +34

      Sabaton History they need to write a song about the Battle of Adwa now about the decisive Italian defeat in Ethiopia

    • @mysticnovelbro
      @mysticnovelbro 5 лет назад +14

      Did you just seriously delete a user's innocuous comment, SH? Poor show, poor show indeed.

  • @SirStalingrad
    @SirStalingrad 5 лет назад +1598

    “Bother” said Pooh, as he chambered another round

    • @Tadicuslegion78
      @Tadicuslegion78 5 лет назад +99

      Someone makes a RUclips movie of Zulu only it’s Disney characters....

    • @talknight2
      @talknight2 5 лет назад +41

      That is just way too funny

    • @jonbaxter2254
      @jonbaxter2254 5 лет назад +119

      I didn't know the leader of China fought at Rourke's Drift?

    • @Tadicuslegion78
      @Tadicuslegion78 5 лет назад +78

      @@jonbaxter2254 shush The Chinese don't want the people to know the president served in the British Army

    • @SirStalingrad
      @SirStalingrad 5 лет назад +3

      Tadicuslegion78 we can only hope

  • @kingdraconias
    @kingdraconias 5 лет назад +659

    British CO: "The Zulus are coming, we must barricade our wall with everything we got!"
    British Soldier: "What about the rum sir?"
    British CO: "That, we save."

    • @outrageddeer2101
      @outrageddeer2101 5 лет назад +61

      British soldier: why sir?
      British CO: We need something to celebrate with.

    • @rashkavar
      @rashkavar 4 года назад +41

      Honestly, it's probably because of how strong the rum ration was. There was a concept, primarily used in the Royal Navy, but I'm sure they used the same rum for all branches of the service, called proving the rum - it's where we get the idea of measuring the strength of alcohol in "proof." To prove the rum, you would soak a pellet of gunpowder in rum, and then try to light it up. If it burned, the rum was proven to not be watered down. That works out to be 57% alcohol by volume, or 100 degrees proof. (The modern proof system got simplified down to just 0.5% per unit proof rather than 0.57% for the sake of simplicity, since we no longer have a situation where we need to do the gunpowder test)
      Alcohol will never be the kind of fire weapon that napalm is, or even the kind of flame you'll get off butane or acetylene, but at that proof, and at the kind of temperatures it would be unrefrigerated and outside in the South African sun, it's definitely capable of producing a decent flame. You don't give the enemy a liquid that burns when you're taking shelter in a building with a thatched roof. The Zulu might not have recognized the opportunity that would have offered (I have no idea what the Zulu did for food and drink of any kind, or how much contact they'd had with products of the European world), but the British soldiers would certainly know about it, and would not take the risk that they might find a way to use it.

    • @cerebli
      @cerebli 4 года назад +15

      they probably chugged the shit out of it in the morning

    • @georgelee5786
      @georgelee5786 3 года назад +5

      But why is the rum gone?

    • @cleverduck3921
      @cleverduck3921 3 года назад +7

      Rum was used to sanitize the water ration. That is, the alcohol in the rum would kill off any bacteria in the local water supply that the troops wouldn't have grown-up with an immunity to. This had been done with naval water rations for hundreds of years. Of course, they didn't have the modern understanding of germ theory that we have today, but they did observe the simple fact that men who had their water mixed with a bit of alcohol; grog; didn't come down with dysentery.

  • @starsword-c2534
    @starsword-c2534 5 лет назад +1571

    LOL at Joakim's comment about learning more about the colonization of Africa in two minutes listening to Indy than in nine years of school. I've learned more European history listening to Sabaton than in my entire 12+ years of school.

    • @darkjackl999
      @darkjackl999 5 лет назад +51

      its because of how school is really bad for learning due it being forced
      i've learned so much since graduating high school just via hearing about something or listening to songs like sabatons making me curious about an event and then looking up what i could about it

    • @USSAnimeNCC-
      @USSAnimeNCC- 5 лет назад +12

      Stay in school kid more like keep watching RUclips video kid XD

    • @AshleyBlackwater
      @AshleyBlackwater 5 лет назад +17

      @@darkjackl999 Here in the UK you aren't taught about the second world war unless you take it as an elective, and don't learn much about the first one either.

    • @morisco56
      @morisco56 5 лет назад +7

      School is useless

    • @mtbguy8365
      @mtbguy8365 5 лет назад +7

      I learn more from this then stupid school sabaton have more history in there songs then stupid schoolbooks

  • @TheSpedy21
    @TheSpedy21 5 лет назад +534

    Damn Indy, that unscripted talking.

    • @old-moose
      @old-moose 5 лет назад +72

      All historians are ticking time bomb lecturers just waiting for a good topic to talk about. Just ask all my friends. ;-)

    • @malachimeeker9480
      @malachimeeker9480 5 лет назад +2

      Mårtin
      Isn’t it great!

    • @Swedishmafia101MemeCorporation
      @Swedishmafia101MemeCorporation 5 лет назад +1

      Nowhere near as bad as me lol

    • @jn4198
      @jn4198 5 лет назад +5

      @@old-moose im not a historian, i love history, but when i talk about history it will be about an hour before i stop.

  • @systymshocked6459
    @systymshocked6459 5 лет назад +697

    Indy- *mentions the Armenians*
    Turkey- " you better delete that "

  • @lutenantsweedpertasa
    @lutenantsweedpertasa 4 года назад +126

    “The army doesn’t like more than one disaster in a day”
    “Looks bad in the newspapers and upsets civilians at their breakfast.”

  • @Jaeger_Bishop
    @Jaeger_Bishop 5 лет назад +370

    "Throw your soldiers into positions where there is escape, and they will prefer death to flight"- The Art of War

  • @exeldofcanadia3461
    @exeldofcanadia3461 5 лет назад +317

    You know you can say what you want in colonialism, and the British Empire, but if you put that all aside and look at Rorke's Drift I think we can all see and respect the absolute astonishing level of marshal bravery and courage shown on both sides. The British for standing their ground in the face of a near never ending hoard of Zulu, whom had just destroyed a force three times the size of themselves. And the Zulu to charge the rifles of those British, in the face of the slaughter they were receiving. Truly a outstanding display on both sides.

    • @5h0rgunn45
      @5h0rgunn45 5 лет назад +46

      I agree. And that's what I like so much about about the movie "Zulu". Although told almost entirely from the British perspective, they managed to make it in a way that shows respect to the men who fought on both sides.

    • @TheSingleTrucker
      @TheSingleTrucker 5 лет назад +4

      Time to dig in and marshall tactics saved the Brits.

    • @mattcarroll8520
      @mattcarroll8520 3 года назад +18

      Well said. All to common these days to toe the politically correct line and trash anything to do with colonialism. It was a different era, with different values, and also there were a lot of positives to come from the British influence. Unfortunately, a lot of the countries as they have gained independence have turned into basketcases rife with corruption and brutality.

    • @pavitashergill8308
      @pavitashergill8308 3 года назад

      @@mattcarroll8520 including Britain I hope??

    • @Henshin0101
      @Henshin0101 3 года назад +10

      @@mattcarroll8520 we can safely talk about the benefits of Roman occupation on Europe and North Africa despite all the war and atrocities committed to gain the empire. One day we will be able to look and talk about the European colonisation of Africa in a similar light.

  • @TheSingleTrucker
    @TheSingleTrucker 5 лет назад +396

    12 years of school: Derp
    15 mins of Sabaton History: informed and educated.

    • @williammitchell2046
      @williammitchell2046 5 лет назад +7

      They should be forced to show the sabaton history videos in schools. I have never seen anything more educational, War-wise

    • @Perkelenaattori
      @Perkelenaattori 5 лет назад +1

      That's because Sabaton isn't glossed over like the history books in school are.

    • @minoreror9961
      @minoreror9961 5 лет назад

      True tho

    • @jamesoakley4570
      @jamesoakley4570 4 года назад

      I learnt more about the world thanks to RUclips more than i did at school. Least i learnt that B+A=22.

    • @Reaper_ginger
      @Reaper_ginger 4 года назад

      My world history teacher in high school taught us literally nothing about WW1 besides how it started and a little of the treaty that ended it. Nothing in between

  • @6th_Army
    @6th_Army 5 лет назад +496

    I love how Indy just went full historian on Joakim during the "Interview". Though my freinds hate me for it, I love it.

    • @5h0rgunn45
      @5h0rgunn45 5 лет назад +12

      I was laughing seeing Joakim keep trying to get a word in edgewise XD

    • @Schattengewaechs99
      @Schattengewaechs99 5 лет назад

      Darkness Nighthingale - What do your friends hate you for?

    • @6th_Army
      @6th_Army 5 лет назад +11

      @@Schattengewaechs99 Going into long "discussions" about history without letting them get a word in.

    • @TheSingleTrucker
      @TheSingleTrucker 5 лет назад +3

      Woe be the rider in my Uber who dares bring up some nugget of history. I fully channel Indy and a 15 min drive just passes like a summer breeze. Rider: 1 star; talk too damn much. LOL!

    • @falangecatolica4692
      @falangecatolica4692 5 лет назад

      Its much more enjoyable

  • @marcomoon6
    @marcomoon6 5 лет назад +349

    From what I heard the Zulu king said not to attack the drift because the first battle could be seen as defending their land but attacking the drift would be seen as them as the the antagonist, history buffs talks about when he goes over the movie Zulu

    • @m0rtez713
      @m0rtez713 5 лет назад +28

      Well he was right.

    • @5h0rgunn45
      @5h0rgunn45 5 лет назад +75

      When the Zulus who'd fought at Rourke's Drift returned, warriors from other regiments made fun of them for attacking men who'd done nothing to them.

    • @elliswatanabe
      @elliswatanabe 5 лет назад +3

      @@5h0rgunn45 source?

    • @5h0rgunn45
      @5h0rgunn45 5 лет назад +17

      @@elliswatanabe
      ruclips.net/video/VvqQL1F0M2o/видео.html
      The link should be timestamped to the right spot, if not skip to 30:30.

    • @Coramelimane
      @Coramelimane 5 лет назад +40

      Not only that, but when he learned about the attack on the Drift, he was so insulted they did that, he forbade all of the warriors from ever marrying.

  • @mandoschMUh
    @mandoschMUh 5 лет назад +466

    No musical details?! That's unexpected. I really enjoyed Indy getting excited about the topic. Well done, guys!

    • @SabatonHistory
      @SabatonHistory  5 лет назад +124

      Thats what he does;) Thanks!

    • @BigRawb666
      @BigRawb666 5 лет назад +33

      He spent years going over The Great War, which doesn't surprise me about how excited he was about going into the details about WW1 and the effects of the colonization of Africa's effects on WW1

    • @vladadusek8724
      @vladadusek8724 5 лет назад +22

      Indy seemed to try to ask Joakim about musical details, but he somehow transformed it i to 5 minute monologue about British war policy before WWI.

  • @skirk248
    @skirk248 5 лет назад +158

    The Drift wasn't an attack that the Zulus wanted to happen. The attack on it hindered the ability for the Zulus to claim the war was defensive

    • @patchesohoolihan666
      @patchesohoolihan666 4 года назад +23

      In addition it took it took one of their last units of several thousand young bloods, eager for action, and turned it into a demoralised mess. The Zulu won at Isandlwana, but a huge proportion of their army took rather heavy casualties. The Zulu's only realistic chance was to continue repeating Isandlwana like successes of annihilating British forces with charges at the guns. How many survivors of Rorke's drift would be as willing to charge a British line again?

  • @stevehansen5389
    @stevehansen5389 5 лет назад +9

    Almost 50 years ago I was a US Army infantry captain and a student in the Infantry Officer's Advance Course at Ft Benning Georgia. One of the battles we studied was Rorke's Drift. It is a well documented and extensively studied engagement. The consensus is that the British officers did everything right. From there supervision of the effort to fortify the homestead to their leadership in the battle itself. The motion picture ZULU is of course entertainment and not a historical documentary but it dose capture the essence of the battle. If you have an interest in this particular fight you need to watch ZULU.

  • @themightyorange1604
    @themightyorange1604 5 лет назад +157

    South African here: Honestly brilliant coverage of Rorkes Drift. Really cover both sides relativity well. If you guys ever come to South Africa you should go to the battle site. As well was the Battle of Blood-river( Voortrekkers v Zulus). Probably if not the most decisive battles for the opening of the rest of Southern Africa. The battle sites are surprisingly well kept! 🤘🏼

    • @thepiratepenguin4465
      @thepiratepenguin4465 4 года назад +7

      Blood-river & Anglo-Boer war. ✔

    • @Hert42
      @Hert42 Год назад

      Blood river and Anglo Boer War... Please! Remember Amajuba!!!

  • @Puckosar
    @Puckosar 5 лет назад +87

    Indy's historical unscripted rants are something I would love to see more of

  • @rhodritaylor7254
    @rhodritaylor7254 3 года назад +8

    I live a few miles away from the grave of Pvt. Robert Jones VC, one of the 11 who were awarded it at Rorkes Drift. Sadly he never got over his experience there and took his own life a few years later. I visit it now and again.
    I think the film, although it has a few inaccuracies, did quite a good job of showing both sides and what a tragedy it was. The zulu village in the film were all "proper" zulus and King cetshwayo was played by his grandson in the movie.

  • @Legitpenguins99
    @Legitpenguins99 5 лет назад +61

    Indy talking to Joakim at the end reminds me exactly what happens when i listen to Sabaton with my friends. I always get excited explaining to them the history behind every song

  • @bettyblue1465
    @bettyblue1465 3 года назад +15

    Xhosa here: I was listening to the "Last Stand" album and I heard the chorus and had a feeling I knew what they were singing about. Watching this video proved me right. Sabaton never fails to amaze me. Thanks guys, this was a nice surprise.

  • @GambitsEnd
    @GambitsEnd 3 года назад +17

    That after-show "interview" was great. Indy looked genuinely excited to talk about this and Joakim looked genuinely amused at Indy's excitement.

    • @SabatonHistory
      @SabatonHistory  3 года назад +6

      That's the spirit of learning and sharing history, there's endless knoladge and stories to dig in.

  • @TheKrysa40
    @TheKrysa40 5 лет назад +33

    "There are no country songs about British colonisation of Africa"
    *Laughs in John Edmond*

  • @avidficreader5040
    @avidficreader5040 5 лет назад +131

    If I were to speculate, since this song was on Last Stand, and it is a famous last stand with an excellent movie, it attracted the band's attention when they were tossing around ideas for the album. If no one else has written a song on a sensitive topic like this before, well, Sabaton had done controversial topics before anyway.

    • @Indoor_Carrot
      @Indoor_Carrot 5 лет назад +11

      Well, they get shit for the Final Solution and Wehrmacht. Some people are just sad and can't enjoy music for what it is :/

    • @rogmorts1
      @rogmorts1 5 лет назад +1

      They are second on this battle Saxon sung song about it in 1997 The Thin Red Line.
      Though sabaton did a better job of it.

    • @alexandrah9824
      @alexandrah9824 5 лет назад +1

      @@Indoor_Carrot For me as a german metalhead the ,, Final solution “ means much to me.LG Alex🤘

    • @LordVader1094
      @LordVader1094 4 года назад

      @@Indoor_Carrot Also Rise of Evil, for some damn reason.

    • @Indoor_Carrot
      @Indoor_Carrot 2 года назад

      @Kristopher Prime Sadly no. The "regular soldiers" of the Wehrmacht also committed war crimes against civilians (including children). Not just the SS. That was an excuse made by veterans to shift the blame.

  • @jimmyray7
    @jimmyray7 5 лет назад +34

    Damn. Indy went off on a little tear there. Like Joakim, I learned more about the colonization of Africa in those few minutes than I did in school. Like always, thanks for sharing this gem with us!!

  • @eelvis1674
    @eelvis1674 5 лет назад +180

    I think when it come down to it battles like this should be remembered in the same way as we might remember something like Picket's charge in the US Civil war. Where we can discuss politics separately to the honouring of individual acts of bravery and courage.

    • @jackolaid6179
      @jackolaid6179 5 лет назад +3

      Yeah, while Picket's charge is different I agree that we should be able to honor the bravery of those who fought.

    • @eelvis1674
      @eelvis1674 5 лет назад +16

      @@jackolaid6179 I wasn't meaning that they were similar battles, I was just trying to get at the idea that even though people may have been on the wrong side in a conflict that doesn't mean that they deserve no credit whatsoever.

    • @NeuteredSmurfs
      @NeuteredSmurfs 5 лет назад +16

      Absolutely, bravery should be honored on both sides.

    • @chubbyGrimblr
      @chubbyGrimblr 4 года назад

      Is that so? I definitely disagree: When everybody's reason to be where they are is extremely politically charged (Indiscriminant colonization of a continent), and when they know that they're here to enslave and subjugate, and choose to continue onwards, then how can their actions be honored? Perhaps if they were defending the British Isles in some honorable defense against their homeland, sure, but here these British soldiers and officers were here to put an entire people under them in their own (European) social caste.

    • @randomnerd9088
      @randomnerd9088 4 года назад +21

      @@chubbyGrimblr The British Isles aren't even these people's homeland silly. The Anglo-Saxon people don't originate from the British Isles. The Zulu didn't originate from this region of Africa. You're so incredibly deluded in the mind it's not even funny. When does a land become a people's homeland? These are men following the orders of their country, serving their country, serving their families and their people. The Zulus are no different than the British. The soldiers on both sides are the same. They are motivated by the same things. They desire the same things. They dream of the same things. They fight for their king. They fight for their lives. They fight for their wealth. They fight for their families. They fight for their wives. They fight because they are told to fight, because that's what soldiers do.If you really want to have a nuanced bullshit political theory of morality then you would understand that the Zulus were the antagonistic ones during this specific battle, but you don't. Why don't you? Because you are on a mental crusade against anything which is done by white people, as well as any form of expansion by said white people. You don't grasp that "colonialism" is the very same thing as what has done by the Zulus, by the Romans, the Greeks, the Carthaginians, the Mesopotamians, the Egyptians, Persians, Aztecs, Iroquois, the Kushans, Babylonians, fucking everyone. That's because the emphasis and need for land during the majority of the world's lifetime was absolute. For a nation to succeed it needed to conquer or fulfill a specific niche, and even fulfilling a niche wasn't possible for much of ancient history. It all fucking sucks, I agree, but to somehow insinuate that the British are somehow worse than any other people on the planet is bullshit because they have all been doing the same shit for thousands of years. They fight. They kill. They grow fat and rich and someone else comes along and kills them. That's how it has been for thousands of years. Thankfully due to the advent of such technological wonders much of what was a necessity in the past have been rendered archaic, from the mundane to the wonderous, from what affects individual lives to what affects nations, it has all changed drastically. If you had any sort of critical thinking skills you would not attempt to apply your modern morality to a period in which the foundation for that moralities existence was just beginning to sprout thanks to the fertilization done by the blood of millions upon millions upon millions of people.

  • @Living_Weapon
    @Living_Weapon 4 года назад +7

    South African here. You guys at Sabaton did a brilliant job at creating a song about Rorke's Drift. It would be absolutely amazing if you could maybe do a series of songs about the Anglo-Boer War or one about the battle of Bloodriver (Slag van Bloedrivier).

  • @julianpike2456
    @julianpike2456 5 лет назад +9

    As a South African it's really awesome getting a song about my history. I guess the thing is that horrible things happened in the past but it is still important to learn about them. Often history is overlooked so it's cool learning about my own history along with that of others.

  • @svenw7501
    @svenw7501 5 лет назад +77

    Am I the only one who wants Sabaton to do a song about the Emu War in Australia?

  • @boetata
    @boetata 2 года назад +4

    Awesome to see a representation of Southern African and more particularily the Zulus. My grandparents talked about the aftermath of The anglo Boer war. No winners at the end. Proud that the Zulus were represented as fierce and cunning warriors instead of savages. We are a proud nation with a lot of problems, but we have a rich history of fierce resistance against challenges brought upon us. Love the channel and hope to see more history on the South african front in the future.

  • @abian36
    @abian36 5 лет назад +12

    I met Sabaton with this song almost a year ago and had to watch "Zulu" film after listening to it several time.
    A year later, it still amazes me

  • @sjinnie_boy4988
    @sjinnie_boy4988 5 лет назад +21

    It was so cute seeing Indy get so excited about history!

    • @hellionshark3197
      @hellionshark3197 5 лет назад

      It's really cool to see people talking about things they love.

  • @Unit_Sw4g
    @Unit_Sw4g 5 месяцев назад +1

    Imagine getting an box of ammo in the face thrown by a chaplain

  • @braeddie
    @braeddie 5 лет назад +5

    It's awesome that it got covered, simply for the fact that the history of this continent, is basically unknown in the rest of the world. Good or bad, no topic should be taboo, and art provides us with a tool to depict not only what happened in history, but lends us the ability of emotional expression too. Stories must be told.

  • @blakedurston
    @blakedurston 3 года назад +1

    12:26 Joakim trying to get a word in but getting steam rolled by indie’s train of thought

  • @thenoobgameplays
    @thenoobgameplays 5 лет назад +43

    Please, The Attack of the Dead Men next week. It's one of my favorites songs from the Great War

    • @alexamerling79
      @alexamerling79 5 лет назад +1

      It's a good one.

    • @ericolsen5592
      @ericolsen5592 5 лет назад

      And it'd be a great song for Halloween, but no, they did Unbreakable.

  • @lastexile6924
    @lastexile6924 5 лет назад +5

    Indy is a walking History bible...such an amazing man

  • @DrippinginSarcasm
    @DrippinginSarcasm 5 лет назад +17

    >Zulu butcher and murder wounded soldiers
    >soldiers return the favor
    Indy: shocked picachu face

  • @Breal2121x
    @Breal2121x 5 лет назад +5

    Great video and great song. Thanks for making both. The Battle of Rorke’s drift was one of my favorite topics in my history of modern Africa class in college. The scramble for Africa is really some of the stuff that helped broaden my world view beyond its “America-centric” view I had for most of my life.

  • @lexingtonbrython1897
    @lexingtonbrython1897 5 лет назад +122

    No shit, I was just thinking about this song last night while playing Civ4!

    • @USSAnimeNCC-
      @USSAnimeNCC- 5 лет назад

      Did something similar happen to you

    • @scipioafricanus6417
      @scipioafricanus6417 5 лет назад

      How do you run civ4 on windows 10?

    • @lexingtonbrython1897
      @lexingtonbrython1897 5 лет назад +1

      @@USSAnimeNCC- Nah, I was in the mopping up stages of my game.

    • @xyz6106
      @xyz6106 5 лет назад

      @@scipioafricanus6417 works fine for me with no extra modifications.

    • @StArShIpEnTeRpRiSe
      @StArShIpEnTeRpRiSe 5 лет назад

      @@scipioafricanus6417 You can run everything on Win10 and even have compatibility modes to older windows even to xp.

  • @Big_E_Soul_Fragment
    @Big_E_Soul_Fragment 5 лет назад +55

    OH GOD *[CIV5 ZULU IMPI RUSH FLASHBACKS]*

    • @stanleyramsrud5204
      @stanleyramsrud5204 3 года назад +1

      I won't even play a game if I see Shaka on the same continent as me

  • @tejesedeny
    @tejesedeny 5 лет назад +41

    'You realize I learnt more about the colonization of Africa in those two minutes talking than I did in nine years in basic school.' That's exactly how I feel anytime I listen to Indy. 😃
    And, this story reminds of a thing Indy told in the Great War several times: one machine gun can replace hundreds of soldiers. I feel in the case of Rorke's drift exactly the same, that superior techniques count much more than numbers.
    And, without going too deep into the colonization topic, just one little thing: however most of the European people thought they're superior to African people, the fact they could actually contact with African people gave birth to a new social science: cultural anthropology. And this new science developed a new way of approach, which didn't consider technically less developed people inferior, but it started to research their culture in its own context and complexity. I know the later history of 20th century doesn't really show the spreading of this approach, but I think I don't have to emphasize too much how important it is in dealing with today's social (which are often also cultural) issues. (Yes, I studied cultural anthropology. 🙂)

    • @SabatonHistory
      @SabatonHistory  5 лет назад +21

      Yes, the birth of Cultural Anthropology as a scientific field could be interpreted as a sign of emancipation/acceptance of other cultures. However, I would argue that it is also a product of a Western Culture which saw itself as superior, and felt the need to study anything that was different (Other). The concept of Orientalism is still very prevalent in modern culture today (look at movies like Aladin or the representation of Arabs/Muslims in mainstream media). Throughout the 19th and 20th century, 'Other' people have been misrepresented by the west, often based on stereotypes like moral corruption, aggressiveness, irrationality, femininity, inferior intellect, resulting in structural prejudices which, again, still thrive today.
      I'm not saying that the field of Cultural Anthropology STILL suffers from this, in the last decades academia has become much more aware of these problems.

    • @tejesedeny
      @tejesedeny 5 лет назад +7

      ​@@SabatonHistory Well, yes, anthropology started its career with an evolutionist approach too, where 'primitive' tribes were considered as earlier stages of human society's ever ongoing development (and this approach inevitably includes the inferior-superior dichotomy). Relativism and studying cultures in their own context came later.
      And yes, the later complex approach of anthropology didn't become mainstream, describing a culture by a few strong stereotypes is still easier than showing its complexity. And the 'our group' - 'their group' thinking is still very much alive, we can't do much about it.
      But at least in those professions which aim to help socially excluded - and often culturally different - groups the approach of understanding and working together with those who need help, and not telling what's good for them from 'above', is more and more present. I hope this approach will spread in mainstream society too with time, however, my realist side doesn't really trust that.

  • @90geekgirl06
    @90geekgirl06 5 лет назад +2

    Ok first I love when Indy just goes off on a historic rant because you can see just how passionate he is about all of this and it's a beautiful thing to see. Second I love this song, it's intense and really gets the blood going. Good episode!!

  • @terrorcop101
    @terrorcop101 5 лет назад +17

    "Very different interview;" there practically wasn't an interview. Still, I've got to agree with Indy: being a historian gets you way more perspective than being a student or casually interested ever will.

  • @iVETAnsolini
    @iVETAnsolini 5 лет назад +4

    This has to be my favorite sabaton history video. The last 4 mins, like he said, I’ve learned more than 9 yrs of school. Thank you guys so
    Much for shedding light on these forgotten and most importantly; overlooked battles!

  • @Nekonymous
    @Nekonymous 5 лет назад +8

    Once again an in depth explanation of the events made a song i haven't really cared about that much before so, so much more interesting!
    Gotta love this channel and Indy's awesome way of explaining stuff. (I do like Indy's own channel too...)

  • @adamsmith4049
    @adamsmith4049 5 лет назад +11

    Best one yet. So interesting; loved Indy's little extra talk at the end!!
    Would have liked to hear about the creation of the song too - but not at the expense of Indy's extra section. Just do a longer video guys!!!

    • @SabatonHistory
      @SabatonHistory  5 лет назад +5

      Thanks! Unfortunately we have a limited capacity for editing and such, so endless videos are not possible at this point

    • @wborworse
      @wborworse 4 года назад +2

      @@SabatonHistory Just listen 20min of Sabaton songs before and it is enough to edit, etc., for 3 videos of 0-20 mins

  • @ravenlord_xix
    @ravenlord_xix 5 лет назад +9

    This is my favourite song on The Last Stand, every time it comes on I bust the dial of the stereo off at 11. I’ve used a lot of duct tape fixing it

  • @PikkeWouter
    @PikkeWouter 5 лет назад +21

    Please do a song about "The battle of blood river "

  • @MrBlipman
    @MrBlipman 5 лет назад +5

    FOR KING AND COUNTRY

  • @Hiraghm
    @Hiraghm 4 года назад +3

    "...with only a few hundred of their own..."
    Actually it was just over ONE hundred of their own.

  • @cmdrgarbage1895
    @cmdrgarbage1895 5 лет назад +20

    What the hell! I never knew Joakim was a Star Trek fan! Long live the Federation and Starfleet!

  • @10thCompanyCaptain
    @10thCompanyCaptain 5 лет назад +1

    Indy's point of view is wonderful and I'm glad that he spoke as much as he did about how the Zulus saw things.

  • @bran7538
    @bran7538 5 лет назад +57

    I was just listening to this song! What perfect timing!

    • @TrollbaitMage
      @TrollbaitMage 5 лет назад +3

      Same here

    • @SabatonHistory
      @SabatonHistory  5 лет назад +16

      How uncanny!

    • @TrollbaitMage
      @TrollbaitMage 5 лет назад +8

      @@SabatonHistory i listen to Sabaton everyday while at work. I work in a cubical farm / data entry building and all i do is type. So i listen to music and books every day. Been there 7 and half years have listened to a book everyother day to every day and Sabaton everyday and never gotten bored once.

    • @kurtkenehan8017
      @kurtkenehan8017 5 лет назад +2

      same

    • @sovietagent9303
      @sovietagent9303 4 года назад +1

      @@TrollbaitMage same

  • @henrykeyter53
    @henrykeyter53 5 лет назад +1

    Joakim, Indy, if you read this... Guys please make a song about the battle of Blood River. It deserves a lot more attention than it gets. 468 South African farmers (I know most people would just call them Dutch, but they themselves wouldn't) vs 10 000 - 15 000 Zulu Impis. If one compare this battle to the Battle of Isandhlwana or the Battle of Bembezi (Brits vs Ndebele, also worth reading about the atrocities committed there) the Battle of Blood River stands out as the Voortrekkers suffered only three minor injuries....

  • @C4Cole05
    @C4Cole05 5 лет назад +57

    Hi, am South African and have been waiting for this episode, its really weird how Indy got some of the pronunciation right and the commander's name which I dont think I would pronounce right but then gets mielie (short sounds) pronounced like meelee (long ee sound). Also people dont really celebrate the battle and wasnt as big of a thing as the battle of Blood River as the forces here were British which werent as cherished as the Afrikaans and Dutch settlers in Apartheid (there used to be a public holiday to celebrate Blood River but was renamed and now celebrates both sides of the battle).Overall great video.
    Also I live in the Western Cape in the South while Rorke's Drift is in the North eastern side in Kwa-Zulu Natal so closer to Durban and Johannesburg.

    • @stimublu8570
      @stimublu8570 5 лет назад

      Locals did well with great bravery and cunning in Blood River, alas British too proud to learn from the locals.

    • @thesouthafricanviking
      @thesouthafricanviking 4 года назад +2

      Sabaton should do a song about Die Slag van BloedRivier "The Battle of Blood River" and a Sabaton History Episode of it. But with the way thinks are here in South Africa currently that might also be a bit 'controversial' . < side note >. . . .I also live in the Western Cape

    • @henrykeyter53
      @henrykeyter53 4 года назад +2

      Hi C4 Cole
      Jong, the difference between Bloedrivier and Rorke's Drift is... Well there is a lot of differences. Bloedrivier was the first defeat the Zulus had suffered since King Shaka. It was also a "just" battle - as far as battles can be - because it was in direct response to the murders of Piet Retief and the trekkers in their camps. Furthermore Bloedrivier was 41 years before Rorke's Drift, the British were better armed and the odds were more in their favor than the odds the Trekkers had. Also - because Bloedrivier was the first defeat the Zulu had, the Brits had a "better" chance to win because the Zulu realised that they can lose...
      But quite frankly I think the real reason that the Brits don't really celebrate Rorke's is because it is overshadowed by Isandhlwana

  • @skelo9033
    @skelo9033 5 лет назад +4

    Sir we’re surrounded!
    Good,now we can shoot in all directions!

  • @PrimarisBlackTemplaDraven
    @PrimarisBlackTemplaDraven 5 лет назад +26

    I love the movie when I was a kid to be honest I don't know who to side with cause the Zulu's are fighting for freedom while the British are fighting for their lives

    • @xclonejager6959
      @xclonejager6959 5 лет назад +14

      Darryl Draven not really freedom considering they where fighting for a king even more violent with no civil liberties

    • @javanbybee4822
      @javanbybee4822 5 лет назад +5

      Rorkes drift was a un just attack by the zulus, their leaders did not allow them to attack but they did anyway

    • @markrenzella2825
      @markrenzella2825 5 лет назад +6

      It's a little complicated . The Zulu nations rise to power was made by them "imposing " their will on other tribes and subjugating them to Zulu ways. Just like the British

    • @theposhdinosaur7276
      @theposhdinosaur7276 4 года назад +2

      I can't quite call myself a historian yet, but I have written a 30 page assignment on the war and its two famous movies. With that out of the way, this is how I see it.
      The Zulus were a brutal people. They had made themselves into a regional super-power through acts of brutality that was at least no better than the British. But the justification of the British of bringing civilization was a shallow excuse for getting to the diamond filled lands of the Zulu. It was as such no surprise that at the flimsiest of excuses (I believe it was a murder) the colonial government gave a ridiculous ultimatum to the Zulu that all but made them a vassal state. The Zulu king even agreed to most terms, but asked to ratify some things, but since peace was never the objective, war was declared.
      Now the important thing to note here, is that the British crown had not sanctioned this war, neither did they really want it. As such, when they finally heard of it, they initially wanted to find an excuse to end it. Only with the humiliating defeat at Islandiwana and move on "British" soil at Rorke's Drift, the British now had no other choice than to see the war through, if they wanted to save face.
      The worst thing about this war, is that the man most responsible for the war, and the incompetent command that led to unnecessary deaths of British soldiers (and thus the continuation of the war) suffered no consequences as he was favored by the queen, that is other than being relieved of his duties.

  • @robintenfelde6105
    @robintenfelde6105 5 лет назад +1

    Seeing Indy getting enraptured by his own monologue was beautiful to watch

  • @CK-530
    @CK-530 5 лет назад +14

    When you are about to write a paper on the movie Zulu and sabaton history puts out the vid on Rorke's Drift... nice

  • @TheonlyStebates
    @TheonlyStebates 4 года назад +2

    Not one mention of Lt JRM Chard VC Royal Engineers who took command from Bromhead due to seniority and organised the defences and redoubt leading to victory

  • @jankeroodman1633
    @jankeroodman1633 5 лет назад +11

    South African here! Awesome song, and good to see that perspectives from both sides are covered. You guys should really look into the Anglo-Boer war. There are a lot of heroic stories and war heroes from that war.

  • @JuanMartinez-ju6vp
    @JuanMartinez-ju6vp 5 лет назад +1

    Despite a sensitive topic, for me this is the most powerful song of Sabaton, LOL. You can feel the adrenaline breaks out your brain. Awesome. Rorke’s Drift ROCKS!

  • @donnergrober179
    @donnergrober179 5 лет назад +3

    I can't resist not watching a new episode, yet it's 9:50 PM here!

  • @ericolsen5592
    @ericolsen5592 5 лет назад +2

    Rorke's Drift was like a beta release version of the siege of Jadotville

  • @scipioafricanus6417
    @scipioafricanus6417 5 лет назад +12

    "elsewhere" nice analogy for Elssas-Lothringen

    • @EarthForces
      @EarthForces 4 года назад +1

      Alsace-Lorraine (correction)

  • @crazypenguine9391
    @crazypenguine9391 4 года назад +1

    Hey I like what you have been doing with this, I know this is highlighting your music but your giving something back to the community and educating people which is something not many people do nowadays.
    Keep up the good work!

  • @gewehr36c89
    @gewehr36c89 5 лет назад +23

    They need to make a song on the american civilwar

    • @Eveline_420
      @Eveline_420 5 лет назад +2

      Adam Miltrion that would be awesome

    • @dude34150
      @dude34150 3 года назад +1

      They are a sweedish band it would be cool but unlikely

  • @Carpathice
    @Carpathice 4 года назад +2

    There is a movie about Rorke's Drift. Zulu (1964)

  • @understand6970
    @understand6970 5 лет назад +19

    Respect for both the Zulu attacker and the British defender in this battle.

    • @__DwiPurna
      @__DwiPurna Год назад

      Ok sir now do you prefer gigachad or team fortress 2 sniper? 😅

  • @_aullik
    @_aullik 5 лет назад +2

    Thank you soo much for the history lesson at the end Indy!

  • @natestathes
    @natestathes 4 года назад +3

    Lesson learned: warriors good
    Politicians bad. ....good lesson.

  • @Oakley902
    @Oakley902 5 лет назад +2

    Indy should be a history teacher! The way he talks and tells the stories keep you so interested and invested in it!

    • @talknight2
      @talknight2 5 лет назад +2

      He is a history teacher. On RUclips. Where history is fun.

    • @Oakley902
      @Oakley902 5 лет назад

      This is very true ,we can learn more here then we ever could in school

  • @tamaslapsanszki8744
    @tamaslapsanszki8744 5 лет назад +7

    Notification squad reporting as ordered to FIGHT BACK TO BACK

  • @ukaszkowalczuk9456
    @ukaszkowalczuk9456 5 лет назад +1

    "Come tell us (...) How you bravely faced each one with your 16-pounder gun,"

  • @sebastiantiainen2749
    @sebastiantiainen2749 5 лет назад +10

    Nice, I decided to write a history essay on the Zulus and more specifically The Anglo-Zulu War because of this song. Great stuff as always, tack

  • @hermitcard4494
    @hermitcard4494 5 лет назад +3

    - What fo you know about zulus?
    - Aren't they just savages, is it?
    🎶🎶🎶🎶🎶

  • @Patris-corde
    @Patris-corde 5 лет назад +7

    Great episode.

    • @TheBigOne0305
      @TheBigOne0305 5 лет назад +2

      Yes, but I kind of feel like we missed out on the Sabaton aspect of the interview. Why did they decide to make a song about this specific topic? What has been their experience with playing this live? Especially comparing Britain and other countries (I don't know if they've ever played in former British colonies, but I guess the song would be received quite different there).
      Indy's part was great, I just think they could have added on another 3-5 minutes giving the other perspective, as they usually do.

    • @alexandrah9824
      @alexandrah9824 5 лет назад

      Ja,da habt ihr Recht🤘LG Alex

  • @gunjirox7485
    @gunjirox7485 5 лет назад

    Indy talking about Rorke's Drift,... my life a is bit better now. You are so awsome dude!!!!

  • @Merf_Gaming
    @Merf_Gaming 5 лет назад +6

    fun fact Bromhead was actually from the town I'm from and also went to school to the same school as me in year 7

  • @Jasza676
    @Jasza676 5 лет назад +2

    7:06
    "Facing, awaiting...
    ...5 o'clock"

  • @Merf_Gaming
    @Merf_Gaming 5 лет назад +3

    well if I recall correctly not only was Rorke's Drift actually outside the accepted Zululand but prior to the war's starting I believe that zulu warriors were actually raiding Boer and British settlements and kidnapping women and all sorts

  • @edwinwilliamson5913
    @edwinwilliamson5913 5 лет назад

    There's a local musician whose name was Johnny Clegg, he did a song about the Battle of Isandlwana called Impi, riveting listen, much like a prequel to Rorke's Drift.

  • @JayKayKay7
    @JayKayKay7 5 лет назад +3

    You must do The Alamo!!

  • @scouttroopermerc1506
    @scouttroopermerc1506 5 лет назад +1

    YAY!!! Finally! My favourite Sabaton Song. Love this song, love this channel Keep up the good work guys.

  • @Snowmunkee
    @Snowmunkee 5 лет назад +17

    Wait, who is presenting this video? they didnt tell me!

  • @JorgenD-original
    @JorgenD-original 5 лет назад +1

    You really make it good

  • @lennardlee4483
    @lennardlee4483 5 лет назад +31

    Sabaton History Channel: *posts new video*
    Me: I have arrived

  • @fazole
    @fazole 3 года назад +2

    I read an account of the British fighting warlords in China in early 20th century. They found that allowing the Chinese peasants to escape avoided many battles, because warlords usually killed the other Chinese they captured.

  • @mirzarustemov7700
    @mirzarustemov7700 5 лет назад +4

    Indy dressing up for this one

  • @theoutlook55
    @theoutlook55 5 лет назад

    Thanks for reminding us of the bloody reprisals that occur after a battle, 11:11. Also, wise words at 11:25.

  • @somebloke13
    @somebloke13 4 года назад +10

    Britain was colonised by the Romans. We don't curse the Italians, we thank them for their contribution to British culture. The same goes for the Angles, the Saxons, the Jutes, the Vikings, and the Normans.
    Goes round, comes round...

  • @peppermintfalcon3904
    @peppermintfalcon3904 5 лет назад +1

    Best interview thus far!

  • @GooseMasterful
    @GooseMasterful 5 лет назад +3

    Could y'all do a history video on The Last Stand

  • @bigbrojo
    @bigbrojo 5 лет назад +1

    I love the tangents they make me happy. And are informative. Love you guys

  • @Tadicuslegion78
    @Tadicuslegion78 5 лет назад +23

    From the movie Zulu
    In the hundred years since the Victoria Cross was created for valour and extreme courage beyond that normally expected of the British soldier in face of the enemy only 1344 have been awarded. Eleven of these were won by the defenders of the mission station at Rorke's Drift, Natal, January 22nd to the 23rd 1879.
    Fredrick Schiess, Corporal, Natal Native Contingent.
    William Allen, Corporal, B Company, 2nd Battalion, 24th Foot.
    Fred Hitch, Private B Company, 2nd Battalion, 24th Foot.
    James Langley Dalton, Acting Assistant Commissary, Army Commissariat Department.
    612 John Williams, Private, B Company, 2nd Battalion, 24th Foot.
    726 Robert Jones, 593 William Jones, Privates, B Company, 2nd Battalion, 24th Foot.
    Henry Hook, Private, B Company, 2nd Battalion, 24th Foot.
    James Henry Reynolds, Surgeon Major, Army Hospital Corps.
    Gonville Bromhead, Lieutenant, B Company, 2nd Battalion of the 24th Regiment of Foot, South Wales Borderers.
    John Rouse Merriott Chard, Lieutenant, Royal Engineers, Officer Commanding - Rorke's Drift.

  • @RhettPerry88
    @RhettPerry88 3 года назад

    You guys are awesome!!!
    I use your songs to help teach my 7 yr son history!!!
    He loves it

  • @MDMetal
    @MDMetal 5 лет назад +6

    Joakim wearing a Starfleet Academy shirt. Right on, man! 🖖😎🍺

    • @MercenaryPen
      @MercenaryPen 5 лет назад +2

      who knows what space wars he's planning to write songs about... maybe the Dominion war, or the Vulcan-Romulan war, the battle of Wolf 359, the list goes on

  • @AceHardy
    @AceHardy 5 лет назад

    👑

  • @dredlord47
    @dredlord47 5 лет назад +169

    I want a song about the Rhodesian Bush war.

    • @PrimarisBlackTemplaDraven
      @PrimarisBlackTemplaDraven 5 лет назад +45

      Yes cause Rhodesians never die

    • @ghazghkullthraka4237
      @ghazghkullthraka4237 5 лет назад +3

      Sweet banana

    • @xclonejager6959
      @xclonejager6959 5 лет назад +40

      Shhh you can’t talk about the green shorts boys,
      there really racist, don’t ya know, they didn’t give control of the bread basket of Africa to the natives that weren’t ready at all to take over and thus saved them from the famine that would happen the second the communist took over,
      Seriously tho it’s a massive shame what happened to the Rhodesians

    • @jacobfarley434
      @jacobfarley434 5 лет назад +3

      Green Leader raid

    • @thomasrogers5514
      @thomasrogers5514 5 лет назад +19

      Salute to the brave and mostly forgotten Rhodesians.

  • @gusbuehler9524
    @gusbuehler9524 Год назад +2

    I just watched this in 2023 in the middle of the night eating mac and cheese with my leopard gecko on my shoulder. What is my life😂

    • @SabatonHistory
      @SabatonHistory  Год назад +1

      Sounds like an awesome life to us! 🤘

    • @gusbuehler9524
      @gusbuehler9524 Год назад

      @@SabatonHistory I never thought that a comment from years after the video would get a response, but I am so glad I got one.