Snippet: Did the Dome of the Rock exist in 870 AD?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 24 янв 2025

Комментарии •

  • @MrDrbld
    @MrDrbld 2 года назад +6

    Good analysis and consistency in refering to the availible sources. Much appreciated.

  • @hypnosecoachinghombach7517
    @hypnosecoachinghombach7517 2 года назад +4

    I really like your films and the information you share.
    but...
    please turn the volume of the music down.
    It's really distracting.

    • @TAlexander
      @TAlexander  2 года назад +3

      Yes, when I cut the snippets, I did so without headphones and it felt right at the time, but now that I listened to it myself again, the music is a bit too loud. The last one of these snippets will be released on Saturday which unfortunately will have the same issue.
      Next time I'll do something like it, I will be more careful and either use less music or turn it down more.

  • @sgt.grinch3299
    @sgt.grinch3299 2 года назад +1

    This is very interesting. I enjoy these videos discussing the “Dome of the Mock”.

  • @ishtarlew598
    @ishtarlew598 2 года назад +4

    That's all we ask from Islam, and that is to show historical evidence for their SIN.

  • @simonhengle8316
    @simonhengle8316 2 года назад

    Absolutely superb Thomas, thank you

  • @rockzalt
    @rockzalt 2 года назад +1

    There's one problem that would probably only be unique to a number people like myself. I'm horrible with directions and when they start with a map where the South is to the left rather than the bottom it compounds my issue.

    • @sgt.grinch3299
      @sgt.grinch3299 2 года назад

      Ancient maps were not oriented to the north on top as modern maps are. You need to see the map key or know the matching geography for orientation.

  • @aemiliadelroba4022
    @aemiliadelroba4022 2 года назад +2

    Interesting 🤔

  • @maxschon7709
    @maxschon7709 2 года назад

    Interesting but what was before 870 and who built what?

  • @tommyrotton9468
    @tommyrotton9468 2 года назад

    I believe the only question I have regarding underneath the building due to the current troubles as Muslims are basically banning anyone but them near or inside the place to worship;
    So is there a historical claim by Christian, Jew or both to worship or pay reverence there underground if above ground is all Muslim now?
    I ask this because Jay Smith had someone talk about there being areas underground near the rock that were dedicated to some persons of the Abrahamic traditions. I have no idea who by or when.

    • @TAlexander
      @TAlexander  2 года назад +1

      As far as I know, there are no such claims. We know from stories that the Jews used to come to the Rock once per year to lament the destruction of the temple some time in the 4th century and there are Syrian-Christian beliefs which connect the rock with the Tomb of Adam as well as the crucifixion of Jesus. So to this group, it was a very important place, the centre of the Earth from where God created everything. But there are no surviving reports of it being a place of worship. Neither above nor under ground. Maybe the groups that held those beliefs were actually far away from Jerusalem. The Greek Christians in Jerusalem didn’t seem to have such beliefs. For them it may have been a monument of the old contract with god, but since it had been superseded by the new contract, it wasn’t particularly important anymore.

    • @two_tier_gary_rumain
      @two_tier_gary_rumain 2 года назад

      There are a few underground caves and tunnels. There are a bunch of videos on YT that explore and/or discuss them.
      ruclips.net/user/results?search_query=underground+Jerusalem

  • @JB-jkhb1972
    @JB-jkhb1972 Год назад

    Es wäre super wenn Sie das auf Deutsch auch noch alles mal machen könnten. Wichtiger aber in Deutsch Speichen Raum ist dieses Wissen überhaupt nicht präsent Super Job👏👏👏

  • @gavinjames1145
    @gavinjames1145 2 года назад +2

    This is a good reply to Pfanderfilm's latest video on the Dome 👍
    ruclips.net/video/Jgn0qWVM28Y/видео.html

  • @cindyweatherly4501
    @cindyweatherly4501 2 года назад

    Thomas, CHRIST said that not one stone would remain standing ( the Temple), so I've always wondered about the " wailing wall." I've watched a documentary about the Temple actually being near the city of David. The points that were brought up, especially about the necessity of the spring water, made a lot of sense. Have you heard about this? There is an organization solely focused on what is needed for Temple Worship, even the Red Heifer. Quite awhile back there was an ad about families from the priestly line, being willing to let their sons be trained for the priesthood. A rebuilt Temple is a central part of End Times Prophecies. I, along will millions, believe that we are in that " season. " : 50 Reasons Why We Are Living In The End Times, Dr. David Reagan, CHRIST in Prophecy Ministries ( RUclips)
    Here are two RUclips videos about an interesting connection between Islam and Roman Catholicism: The Convergence of Islam and Roman Catholicism, Mike Gendron, Proclaiming the Gospel ( ministry to Catholics)
    Islam and Roman Catholicism, Dr. Walter Veith, Elias Gospel ( I don't agree with all of his ideas, but I do think the ones about this subject are compelling. )

    • @TAlexander
      @TAlexander  2 года назад

      Hi Cindy. While it is true that we are not 100% sure where the original temple was located, I find it highly likely that it was indeed in the place where the Dome of the Rock now stands, or at least very close to it.
      As for the Wailing Wall, I guess that's also a matter of interpretation. The way I see it, it never was part of the temple proper. It was built as a retaining wall, encasing the natural hill. It allowed Herod the Great to expand the temple complex which would have been built on top. Most of the Herodian wall is below street level now. The part of the wall which is nowadays visible is actually mostly a product of Umayyad times, the upper rungs made of small stones was only built under the Ottomans.
      As for the Cathoilic/Islam connection, I have heard such claims before and never gave it much credence. It goes against everything I know about both Christianity as well as early Islam. After our last chat, I did look up Walther Veith and started to watch a presentation of his on the topic, but I turned it off after a few minutes when I realised that there won't be much of substance. He started out with some claims about the Knights Templar whom he used as a stand-in for the Catholic church, but which were simply wrong and taken from the false charges that were made by the (catholic) French King and which have nothing to do with Catholicism anyway. After all, the Catholic Church condemned the Templars based on those false charges. He then continued to argue not based on tangible evidence but based on his own interpretation of scripture, which means there really isn't much to argue about. If that's what he believes, then that's what he believes, but for me to engage him, there would have to be an argument first.

    • @cindyweatherly4501
      @cindyweatherly4501 2 года назад

      @@TAlexander The symbolism, heresies related to Mary, rote prayers with beads, heresies related to what happens at death ( Catholic/ purgatory - Islam/ Works...you never know), pilgrimages, men evaluated in " Priesthoods", specific clothing....this is what I was talking about, not the " conspiracy stuff. " That's why I said that I did not agree with all of his ideas. Mike Gendron was deeply involved with Roman Catholicism and understands the connection is a " purer" way.

    • @cindyweatherly4501
      @cindyweatherly4501 2 года назад

      @@TAlexander Correction: men elevated...

    • @krzysztofciuba271
      @krzysztofciuba271 2 года назад

      Don't be silly like your authors: All Quran is contra Genesis 1:26: "humans are created on the image of God" which is rejected in all Quran plus Quran just repeats the heresies of Collyirdians, a tiny sect about the relation of Jesus to God, claiming that Jesus is God (contra Mk 10:18) and May is also God (Sura 5:116)

    • @cindyweatherly4501
      @cindyweatherly4501 Год назад

      @@violetsplace524 Roman Catholicism is not Biblical Christianity, at all.

  • @welcometmw
    @welcometmw 2 года назад

    Shit audio...